9/20/22, 1:28 AM Industrial Capitalism Protects Us from Climate-Related Risks

 

SCIENCE & PROGRESS

Industrial Capitalism Protects Us from Climate-Related

Risks
Keith Lockitch  March 17, 2021  5 min read

We must not ignore capitalism’s stellar record of reducing climate-related threats.

Share this article:

Joe Biden won the presidency on a Democratic platform that calls climate
change a “global emergency” confronting America with “an existential crisis as
a result of sea level rise and stronger storms.” Biden’s own climate plan states:
“From coastal towns to rural farms to urban centers, climate change poses an
existential threat — not just to our environment, but to our health, our
communities, our national security, and our economic well-being.” As the
Biden administration ramps up what’s sure to be a massive environmentalist
legislative agenda, debate will center on our vulnerability to climate-related
disasters. In that context, my journal article on the subject has continuing
relevance. The term “climate denial” is used to smear those who rationally
reject alarmist claims of climate apocalypse. But perhaps it has a valid usage, to
describe the all-too-common tendency to ignore the benefits of industrial
capitalism in reducing exposure to climate-related risks.
Climate Vulnerability and the Indispensable Value of Industrial Capitalism

By Keith Lockitch

https://newideal.aynrand.org/industrial-capitalism-protects-us-from-climate-related-risks/ 1/7
9/20/22, 1:28 AM Industrial Capitalism Protects Us from Climate-Related Risks

Energy & Environment

Vol. 20, No. 5 (2009)

 

ABSTRACT

It is widely believed that man-made greenhouse gas emissions are increasing

overall vulnerability to climate-related disasters, and that, consequently,
policies aimed at cutting off these emissions are urgently needed. But a broader
perspective on climate vulnerability suggests that the most important factors
influencing susceptibility to climate-related threats are not climatologic, but
political and economic. The dramatic degree to which industrial development
under capitalism has reduced the risk of harm from severe climate events in the
industrialized world is significantly underappreciated in the climate debate.
Consequently, so too is the degree to which green climate and energy policies
would undermine the protection that industrial capitalism affords — by
interfering with individual freedoms, distorting market forces, and impeding
continued industrial development and economic growth. The effect of such
policies would, ironically, be a worsening of overall vulnerability to climate.

1. INTRODUCTION

Severe climate events have become a weapon in the rhetorical arsenal of green
politics. Hurricane Katrina became the literal poster child for global warming
when the movie placard for Al Gore’s An Inconvenient Truth depicted a
satellite image of the storm blowing out of a set of industrial smokestacks. No
climate-related disaster occurs today without being seized upon as a cautionary
tale against the purported threat of anthropogenic climate change.

The claim that man-made greenhouse gas emissions are causing large-scale
changes to the earth’s climate systems — dramatically increasing the risk of
climate catastrophe—is omnipresent and trumpeted daily with ever-increasing
alarm. Climate-related tragedies past and present are routinely used to
underscore the theme of man’s vulnerability to the climate. Consider the
following from Spencer Weart’s book The Discovery of Global Warming:

In 1972 a drought ravaged crops in the Soviet Union, disrupting world grain
markets, and the Indian monsoon failed. In the United States the Midwest was
struck by droughts severe enough to show up repeatedly on the front pages of

newspapers and on television news programs. Most dramatic of all, years of

drought in the African Sahel reached an appalling peak, starving millions,
killing hundreds of thousands, and bringing on mass migrations. Television and
https://newideal.aynrand.org/industrial-capitalism-protects-us-from-climate-related-risks/ 2/7
 g
9/20/22, 1:28 AM
, g g g
Industrial Capitalism Protects Us from Climate-Related Risks

magazine pictures of sun-blasted fields and emaciated refugees brought home  

just what climate change could signify for all of us.

READ ALSO:  After Omicron, Should We Be Aiming at ‘Zero Covid’?

The intended implications are clear: all of us are dangerously susceptible to the
ravages of climate; to protect ourselves we must immediately adopt drastic
policies aimed at cutting off greenhouse gas emissions.

And such policies are not merely being pondered, but are steadily moving
toward political reality. International negotiators will meet in Copenhagen in
December 2009 to hammer out a much stronger successor to 1997’s Kyoto
Protocol, which imposed on its signatories binding emissions cuts. Also, as of
this writing (April 2009), a draft bill before the U.S. Congress would impose
energy rationing in a variety of guises: a cap-and-trade system rationing U.S.
carbon emissions, a renewable energy mandate, forced energy efficiency
programs, and more. Should the bill fail, regulation of greenhouse gases might
still go forward in the United States since the EPA — following the Supreme
Court — has “found” them to be air pollutants under the Clean Air Act.

The lurid examples of climate-related tragedy fuel this political agenda by

imparting a sense of panicked urgency. They convey the impression that
something is happening that is unprecedented in human history — that where
mankind once flourished in a world with a stable, benign climate, we are now
facing an apocalyptic hell beyond all capacity to manage.

But vulnerability to the climate has been a feature of human existence for all of
human history; there have always been droughts and floods and hurricanes and
heat waves — and there always will be, regardless of what happens to
atmospheric greenhouse gas concentrations. Moreover, the history of industrial
development has been one of an ever-increasing ability to cope with natural
disasters — an ever-increasing resilience against them.

Read the remainder of this article here.

SUPPORT ARI
If you value the ideas presented here, please become an ARI Member
toda
https://newideal.aynrand.org/industrial-capitalism-protects-us-from-climate-related-risks/ 3/7
9/20/22, 1:28 AM Industrial Capitalism Protects Us from Climate-Related Risks
today.
 
Membership

Readers seeking a superior print result may wish to download the free Just Read
app.

Share this article:

Keith Lockitch
Keith Lockitch, PhD in physics, is a senior fellow and vice president of
education at the Ayn Rand Institute. He focuses primarily on the intersection of
science with current events and policy issues. He is a senior editor of New Ideal.

VIEW ALL ARTICLES

Amesh Adalja on the Pandemic in the Environmentalism’s ‘Anti-Industrial

 
U.S. and Around the World Revolution’

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

https://newideal.aynrand.org/industrial-capitalism-protects-us-from-climate-related-risks/ 4/7
9/20/22, 1:28 AM Industrial Capitalism Protects Us from Climate-Related Risks

 
Agustina Vergara Cid  August 5, 2022 67 min watch/listen

New ARU Course: Foundations of Physical Science



Sam Weaver  June 5, 2022 65 min watch/listen

Alex Epstein’s Powerful Case for More Fossil Fuel Energy

Updates from New Ideal

New Ideal offers a distinct, rational

perspective on today’s cultural and political
issues. Subscribe today.

email address
 
SUBSCRIBE

Listen to New Ideal Live!

New Ideal Live is the podcast that explores

pressing cultural issues from the perspective
of Ayn Rand’s philosophy, Objectivism,
which upholds the ideals of reason,
individualism, and capitalism.

S b ib h
https://newideal.aynrand.org/industrial-capitalism-protects-us-from-climate-related-risks/ 5/7
9/20/22, 1:28 AM Industrial Capitalism Protects Us from Climate-Related Risks
Subscribe here.
 

Ayn Rand University App

Explore unique philosophical content that

challenges conventional views — in courses
you can take on the go.

Available on Google Play and

the App Store.

Media Inquiries

Contact Us

Privacy Policy

Terms & Conditions

Updates from New Ideal

Updates from New Ideal

email address
 
https://newideal.aynrand.org/industrial-capitalism-protects-us-from-climate-related-risks/ 6/7
9/20/22, 1:28 AM Industrial Capitalism Protects Us from Climate-Related Risks
SUBSCRIBE
 

STAY IN TOUCH







Copyright © 1985 – 2022 The Ayn Rand® Institute (ARI).

Reproduction of content and images in whole or in part is prohibited.
All rights reserved. Ayn Rand® is a registered trademark and is used
by permission. ARI is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization.
Contributions to ARI in the United States are tax-exempt to the
extent provided by law. Objectivist Conferences (OCON),
AynRandCon (ARC), Objectivist Academic Center (OAC), and the Ayn
Rand Institute eStore are operated by ARI. Payments to OCON, OAC,
OAC or the Ayn Rand Institute eStore do not qualify as tax-
deductible contributions to the Ayn Rand Institute.

https://newideal.aynrand.org/industrial-capitalism-protects-us-from-climate-related-risks/ 7/7