You are on page 1of 6

GUILD INVESTMENT

M A N A G E M E N T February 24, 2022

GLOBAL MARKET COMMENTARY

Lithium: Lifeblood For a Wired World


Hydrocarbon energy sources, even though Hydrocarbons and fossil fuel energy should not
they’ve been sidelined by investors during the be considered down for the count. In spite of
ESG craze, still power the world, and are still lower levels of investment in growing produc-
essential for industry’s functioning and consum- tion, legacy energy producers can continue to
ers’ wellbeing. Overhasty calls for a total de- generate ample cash flow, even if their valua-
carbonization are coming up against the hard tions remain challenged. We’ll write about this
limits of reality, as ideology usually does. Be- topic in future letters.
sides the potential fallout from war between
Russia and Ukraine, which is putting Europe’s Decarbonization and Lithium
dependence on Russian energy in stark outline,
investment in U.S. hydrocarbon production ca- But still, it is apparent that decarboniza-
pacity has been falling off a cliff for almost a tion is going to proceed inexorably, even
decade. if not at the pace desired and anticipated

© Guild Investment Management Inc.

Source: Bloomberg, LLP and Crescat Capital, LLC


GUILD INVESTMENT 2
M A N A G E M E N T February 24, 2022

EDITORS by its more extreme advocates. from homes to cars to smart


This transformation will involve devices. That demand curve is
several new forms of industrial “life headed “up and to the right,” and
blood,” of which perhaps the fore- battery manufacturers are making
most is lithium -- the most critical use of whatever form of lithium
ingredient in the currently domi- they can secure. Even though lith-
nant lithium-ion battery technology. ium itself may be plentiful, produc-
(The Department of Defense agrees ing battery-grade lithium at
that these minerals are critical -- so the quality levels required for
it is boosting its strategic stockpile large-scale battery production
MONTY GUILD of lithium, cobalt, and rare earths.) is proving not to be trivial.
Founder

Other battery technologies are in Companies capable of doing so,


development, and we follow them; such as Albemarle [ALB] have in
but so far, there is nothing apparent recent years commanded a valua-
in the near- or mid-term that will tion premium to other more pro-
displace the lithium-ion batteries saic commodity producers both for
being churned out (mostly by Chi- this reason (the technical demands
nese factories). of processing) and because of the
significance of the global move to-
Lithium is abundant in the Unit- wards decarbonization.
ANTHONY ed States, although the world’s
DANAHER largest reserves are in Austra- Still, ALB disappointed some
President lia, Chile, and China. (The situa- traders and investors at its re-
tion is thus not dissimilar from that cent earnings conference call.
of the “rare earths,” critical techno- Some people were hoping ALB
logical materials which are not re- was raking in the dough based
ally rare, but whose production is on spiking spot lithium prices.
centered in China and Africa.) It’s
abundant, but production in the U.S. Some traders might take the stocks
is undeveloped. Globally, it is still a of lithium producers as proxies for
young supply chain, and the chem- the mineral itself, and expects them
istry underlying different kinds of to trade in line with these recently
RUDI
© Guild Investment Management Inc.
battery production (for example, spiking spot lithium prices, but this
VON ABELE lithium iron phosphate versus nick- is a long term trend that will require
Senior Research
Analyst el cobalt manganese) is in flux and and understanding of the nuance
can cause short term disruption in and complexity.
12400 Wilshire Blvd the market for different processed
Suite 820 forms of lithium. Only 10% of ALB’s production is sold
Los Angeles, CA 90025
at spot, the rest being tied to vari-
310-826-8600
The big picture is simply expo- ous longer-term contracts. (Also,
guild@guildinvestment.com nentially ramping demand for high spot prices mostly reflect the
Mon–Fri 06:30–16:30 batteries to power everything mainland Chinese market.) That ca-
GUILD INVESTMENT 3
M A N A G E M E N T February 24, 2022

Battery-Grade Lithium Carbonate Price in China

Source: Bloomberg, LLP

veat applies to lithium producers as a whole: spear; where that goes, the indices follow
they should be bought out of conviction for globally. Those global indices are about half in
their valuation in the context of the long-term some cases of current China prices. So there’s
process of decarbonization and projections for probably room to go in those indices, but…
multi-year growth in battery demand -- as well with prices where they are in China, one could
as their runway for capacity expansion, which only speculate where they would go and could
will allow them to gradually realize rising spot they go down, we don’t know.”
prices in their future contracts.
The company’s full-year guidance was for
Discussing pricing of battery-grade lithium 20–30% growth in lithium volumes -- and a
during the call, the management of ALB said 65–85% growth in lithium EBITDA. And we’re
that China “is the lead, sort of the tip of the still early in the lithium demand cycle.

Investment implications: Like rare [LIT]. Investors with access to Canadi- © Guild Investment Management Inc.

earths, lithium is a long-term theme. As an securities could look at the Horizons


usual, we would prefer to enter a posi- Global Lithium Producers ETF [Cana-
tion in this theme after a correction and da: HLIT]. However, investors should
not at the peak of speculative fervor, note that there is likely to be a wide dis-
and some lithium producers have al- persion in the performance of the secu-
ready obliged with a significant correc- rities underlying these ETFs -- and that
tion from the pandemic liquidity highs like cybersecurity ETFs, this may be an
of 2021. One available catch-all is the area where due diligence on individual
Global X Lithium & Battery Tech ETF companies can produce superior results.
GUILD INVESTMENT 4
M A N A G E M E N T February 24, 2022

The Markets This Week


Vladimir Putin pulled the trigger and has be- that “there is no alternative” to stocks.
gun an apparently full-scale attempt to occupy
Ukraine -- or at least enough of it to create a On the edges, with investors believing that
permanent instability that will forestall its ac- both stock and bond markets are highly valued,
cession to NATO. We have long identified this some will increase their allocations to com-
issue as the lynchpin of Russia’s policy in its modities, and particularly to precious metals,
“near abroad.” Markets are reacting in a pre- as well as to digital assets. But most investors
dictable way, considering Russia’s geostrategic will likely see great pain ahead for bond portfo-
significance in hydrocarbons and many import- lios, and conclude that most of their realloca-
ant minerals. The prospect of a large-scale Eu- tion will have to go to stocks -- where at least
ropean land war is an uncomfortable one and there is the possibility of growth.
adds a new twist to the evolving macroeco-
nomic landscape. Allianz analyst Mohamed El That process will be automated in the case of
Erian has referred to the possibility of a “stag- the vast pool of assets held in “Target Date”
flationary shock” arising from this eventuality. retirement-fund ETFs, which will automatically
Time will tell how the markets, and critically rebalance into more stocks as interest rates
the Fed, respond. rise and the value of bonds falls. These funds
will also be mathematically regular and predict-
We believe that markets -- whether cynically able buyers of the broad indexes every two
or realistically, the reader may judge -- have al- weeks as automatic payroll contributions oc-
ready concluded that Ukraine belongs to Rus- cur -- in a strong employment market.
sia. The question is how long hostilities last,
whether other actors become engaged, and Price-insensitive passive flows and 401K
how disruptive the sanctions are. While these allocation models do not care who con-
uncertainties remain, and they may remain for trols Donetsk and Lugansk. And many
some time, many market participants will be non-machines (discretionary human investors,
on tenterhooks. both individuals and institutions) have been sit-
ting on cash, waiting to buy.
The broad U.S. market is now down about
12% from its early December highs, and Ukraine
the NASDAQ is near or in bear-market © Guild Investment Management Inc.
territory. There are, as always, many reasons The news in Ukraine is sad, particularly for
to be bearish. A reason to be bullish: the first those Ukrainians with a genuine desire to in-
seven weeks of the year saw investors pull tegrate into liberal Europe. However, we be-
$160 billion from money-market funds and lieve that Russia’s determination to prevent
$17.5 billion from bond mutual funds and ETFs, Ukraine’s accession to NATO is an existential
funnelling $50 billion of that back into stocks. matter for Russia, even prescinding from spec-
ulation about any broader ambitions to reas-
To us, the message from this is not unrelated semble the former Soviet Union. The markets
to TINA -- the old trope of the bull market have likely priced in local tensions, but have not
GUILD INVESTMENT 5
M A N A G E M E N T February 24, 2022

priced in a wider conflict, particularly one in down “Freedom Convoy” bank accounts, but
which NATO becomes directly involved. We the crypto message is continuing to resonate
also note that with an 18% debt-to-GDP ra- widely in spite of the HODLers’ portfolio
tio, stringently managed while much of the pain.
rest of the world splurged on covid-era fiscal
and monetary excess, Russia has been pre- As we said last week, we like innovation,
paring a financial fortress for this occasion visible growth, strong balance sheets,
for a long time. It is a despicable regime in and inflation-defense assets, particu-
many ways, but not a foolish one. larly some precious metals and miners;
tech-adjacent commodities and com-
Crypto modity producers (such as lithium, as
discussed above); and brands and com-
This week, one brief observation about panies with pricing power who can turn
crypto. Previous crypto crashes (or crypto inflation into accelerating earnings.
“winters,” as some call them) have seen an The market may be nearing a bottom in a
evaporation of mainstream and institutional few weeks or possibly months, so we are also
interest in digital assets. Exactly the oppo- holding cash to be able to buy opportunisti-
site seems to be happening now, with regula- cally. Consumer stocks do not look good, but
tory developments, technical developments, some other sectors will be buys on dips as
institutional adoption, and public interest all monetary and geopolitical tensions resolve.
remaining at elevated levels. Perhaps it’s the
specter of inflation, or the news of regula- Thanks for listening; we welcome your calls
tory overreach by Canadian officials shutting and questions.

© Guild Investment Management Inc.


GUILD INVESTMENT 6
M A N A G E M E N T February 24, 2022
GEneralDisclosures
General Disclosures about
Aboutthis This
Newsletter
Newsletter
The publisher of this newsletter is Guild Investment Management, Inc. (GIM or Guild), an investment advisor registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission.
GIM manages the accounts of high net worth individuals, investment partnerships, trusts and estates, pension and profit sharing plans, and corporations, among other
clients.

Your receipt of this newsletter does not create a personal investment advisory relationship with GIM although some recipients may also be advisory clients of GIM. GIM
has written investment advisory agreements with all its personal advisory clients, which sets forth the nature of that relationship.

The newsletter makes general observations about markets and business and financial trends and may provide advice about specific companies and specific investments. It
does not give personal investment advice tailored to the needs, objectives, and circumstances of individual readers. Whether investment ideas and recommendations are
suitable for individual readers depends substantially on the personal and financial situation of that reader, which GIM, as the publisher of the newsletter, makes no effort
to investigate.

GIM attempts to provide accurate content in its newsletters to the extent such content is factual rather than analysis and opinion, but GIM relies primarily on informa-
tion compiled or reported by third parties and does not generally attempt to independently verify or investigate such information. Moreover, some content and some of
the assumptions, formulas, algorithms and other data that affect the content may be inaccurate, outdated, or otherwise flawed. GIM does not guarantee or take responsi-
bility for the accuracy of such information.

Please note that investing in stocks, other securities, and commodities is inherently risky, and you should rely on your personal financial advisors and conduct your own
due diligence in connection with any investment decision.
A Special Comment for Guild’s Clients
If you are an investment advisory client of GIM who is receiving this newsletter, please note that the fact that a general recommendation is made of a particular security,
commodity, or investment area to its newsletter subscribers does not mean that investment is suitable for you or should be purchased by you. For example, GIM may
already have purchased such securities on your behalf or purchased securities in the same industry (and an increase in the position for you may represent too much
concentration in one security or industry), or GIM may believe the investment is not suitable for you based on your risk tolerance or other factors. If you have questions
about the recommendations in this newsletter in relation to your account at GIM, please contact Monty Guild or Tony Danaher.
Conflicts of Interest
As of the date of this newsletter, GIM’s investment advisory clients or GIM’s principals owned positions in areas that are the subject of current recommendations, com-
mentary, analysis, opinions, or advice, contained in this newsletter. GIM’s advisory clients or principals are currently long U.S. and foreign equities.

GIM and its principals have certain conflicts of interest in its relations with its investment advisory clients and its newsletter subscribers resulting from GIM or its
principals holding positions for its clients or themselves which are also recommended to its clients. GIM may change the positions of its clients or GIM’s principals may
change their positions (increasing, decreasing, and eliminating them) based on GIM’s best judgment at any given time, including the time of publication of the newslet-
ter. Factors that lead GIM to change or eliminate its positions may include general market developments, factors specific to the issuer, or the needs of GIM or its advisory
clients. From time to time GIM’s investing goals on behalf of its investment advisory clients or the personal investing goals of GIM’s principals and their risk tolerance
may be different from those discussed in the newsletter, and the investment decisions made by GIM for its advisory clients or the investment decisions of its principals
may vary from (and may even be contrary to) the advice and recommendations in the newsletter.

In addition, GIM or its principals may reduce or eliminate their positions in an investment that is recommended in the newsletter prior to notifying the newsletter sub-
scribers of such a reduction or elimination. The publication by GIM of a “target price” or “stop loss” for a particular security or other asset does not necessarily represent
the price at which GIM intends to sell or will sell any such assets for its advisory clients or the price at which GIM’s principals intend to sell any such assets.

As a consequence of the conflict of interest, GIM’s clients or principals may benefit if newsletter subscribers purchase assets recommended by GIM since it could increase
the value of the assets already held by GIM’s investment advisory clients or GIM’s principals. On the other hand, GIM’s principals and clients may suffer a detriment
if they seek to acquire additional shares in securities that have been recommended and the price of the securities has increased as a result of purchases by newsletter
subscribers.

To help mitigate these conflicts, GIM seeks to avoid recommending the securities of individual companies where GIM or its principals have an ownership position and
where the issuer is small or its securities are thinly traded−that way sales by GIM in advance of possible sales by newsletter subscribers would not be likely to cause any
significant decrease in the sale price to newsletter subscribers. GIM has a fiduciary relationship with its investment advisory clients and cannot agree on behalf of such
clients to refrain from purchases or sales of a security mentioned in the newsletter for a period of time before or after recommendations for purchases or sales are made
to its newsletter subscribers.

GIM encourages you to do independent research on the securities or other assets discussed or recommended in the newsletter prior to making any investment decisions
and to be especially cautious of investments in small, thinly-traded companies, which are usually the most risky investments that you can make.
Disclaimer of Liability
© Guild Investment Management Inc.

GIM disclaims any liability for investment decisions based upon recommendations, information, or opinions in its newsletters. GIM is not soliciting you to execute any
trade. Nothing contained in GIM’s newsletters is intended to be, nor shall it be construed as an offer to buy or sell securities or to give individual investment advice. The
information in the newsletter is not intended for distribution to, or use by, any person or entity in any jurisdiction or country where such distribution or use would be
contrary to law or regulation, or which would subject GIM to any registration requirement within such jurisdiction or country.
COPYRIGHT NOTICE: PRINT ONCE----DO NOT FORWARD----DO NOT COPY
Guild’s current and past market commentaries are protected by U.S. and International copyright laws. All rights reserved. You must not copy, frame, modify, transmit,
further distribute, or use the market commentaries, without the prior written consent of Guild.

NOTICE TO RECIPIENT: This email or any download from a secure website is meant for only the intended recipient of the transmission, and may be a communication
privileged by law. If you received this email in error, any use, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this email is similarly prohibited. Please notify us immediately of
the error by return email and please delete this message from your system. Although this email and any attachments are believed to be free of any virus or other defect
that might affect any computer system into which it is received and opened it is the responsibility of the recipient to ensure that it is virus free and no responsibility is
accepted by Guild Investment Management for any loss or damage arising in any way from its use.

You might also like