Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Major: Literature
Semester: 06
Option: Literature
Submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of
Bachelor in English Studies
DEDICATION
This study is dedicated to future English students, who will carry on and be the change we
To my beloved parents, who have been my source of strength when I doubted myself, who
To my mentor, relatives, and classmates who shared their words of advice and encouragement
I'd also want to sincerely thank Dr. Benlemlih Bouchra for not only allowing me to do the
research I wanted to do but also for her encouragement and support for my effort. Her faith in
And lastly, I dedicate this paper to the almighty God, thank you for the guidance, strength,
power of the mind, protection, and skills and for giving me healthy life. Always remember
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
I would first like to thank my supervisor, Professor Bouchra Benlemlih, whose expertise was
essential in formulating the research questions and methodology. I was inspired to think more
clearly by your insightful criticism, which improved the quality of the project.
encouragement during the preparation of this paper. I would particularly like to single out my
dearest friend Lahoucine Bouhouche. Lahoucine, I want to thank you for your patience with
I would also like to thank my tutors, Dr. Brahim Houban and Professor Ali Oublal, for their
valuable guidance and support throughout my studies. You provided me with the tools that I
In addition, I want to express my gratitude to my parents for their sound advice and
understanding heart. You are always there for me. Last but not least, Brahim Anjjar and
Jawad Taouili. I was able to successfully finish this project thanks to the help of two of my
best friends, who provided me with a humorous escape and interesting conversations to
Table of Contents
DEDICATION .......................................................................................................................... 2
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ....................................................................................................... 3
INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................... 5
CHARACTER. ..................................................................................................................... 16
CONCLUSION ........................................................................................................................ 18
BIBLIOGRAPHY .................................................................................................................... 20
Abidar 5
INTRODUCTION
Using the case of Danny Boyle's film "Slumdog Millionaire", this paper examines the
misrepresentation and stereotypes that the Indians suffer from in the foreign filmmaking
industry. The film tells the story of two brothers from boyhood to manhood, the position of
Islam and Muslims in India, and the nature of evil. By using Stuart hall's theory of
representation and stereotypes to identify and investigate the portrayal of Indians in Foreign
films. Despite the fact that Stuart Hall was not a formal film theorist, his theories have had a
considerable impact on media studies. Hall's influence on films and cinema studies can be
seen on many different levels and in many different ways, but it is most obvious in how
people approach and perceive modern filmmaking. To narrow the scope of the study, attention
will be paid to watching and evaluating Danny Boyle's 2008 hit film "Slumdog Millionaire."
This film embarks on a variety of issues confronting the world today, ranging from
projects developed by foreigners, particularly the British, and their perspective on Indians'
post-colonial lives. The postcolonial approach in addition to hall's theories provides a clear
Danny Boyle’s film Slumdog Millionaire is a film that shows how destiny works. At
the outset of the film, there is a question on how the hero, Jamal Malik reached that level in a
popular game show in India. This allows him to win the grand prize. However, based on his
background and state the host of the show suspected that there might be some sort of cheating
with the answers. Text pops up on the screen, and we see four possible answers which are: A)
The right answer is D) It's Written, which is revealed at the end of the film. Jamal is either
going to win or is meant to win. The story depicts the fate of the two main characters (Jamal
and Latika), who face several difficulties from childhood through maturity, ultimately leading
to their separation. But the narrative doesn't end there; Jamal, who loves Latika, will do
anything and everything to find her. He decided to participate in the game program "Who
Wants to Be a Millionaire" since he knew Latika will be watching. The two still found each
Danny Boyle is a British filmmaker and screenwriter who was born on October 20,
1956, in Manchester, England. His films were recognized for their stunning visual vision and
joyful energy. Danny is one of the most interesting filmmakers working today. Since the early
1990s, he has gradually produced a body of work that crosses genres and defies easy
categorization, ranging from black comedy (Shallow Grave), gritty realism (Trainspotting),
screwball comedy (A Life Less Ordinary), cult adaptations (The Beach), and horror (28 Days
Abidar 7
Later), to science fiction (Sunshine), children’s drama (Millions), love stories (Slumdog
Unlike many of his peers, Boyle appears to be most comfortable when working with
little budget, depending on acting skills rather than special effects. Danny also relies on his
trusty crew of writers, cinematographers, and production designers. The exuberant tone of his
works - their passion for life – reflects his restless energy, passion, and drive.
This study aims to investigate the portrayal of Indians in Foreign cinemas. This will be
done by applying both the postcolonial approach and the representation theory by Stuart Hall.
To limit the investigation, the focus will be on observing and analyzing the 2008 hit film
'Slumdog Millionaire' by Danny Boyle. Various challenges confronting the globe today are
addressed in this film, ranging from misrepresentation to social class issues. The material was
narrowed to comprise projects that are made by foreigners especially the British and their
REPRESENTATION
Stuart Hall was a Jamaican-British academic, writer, and cultural studies pioneer, who
was born in Kingston, Jamaica in 1932 and died in London aged 82 in February 2014. Hall is
several television programs including the BBC series Redemption Songs and many broadcasts
certain group of people over another. Representation in media often uses stereotypes.
Stereotypes are misrepresentations of individuals and groups that are widely circulated. A
stereotype is a preconceived notion about what a person is like, depending on several criteria.
Culture, religion, race, sexual orientation, age, gender, and physical appearance are some of
these criteria.
powerful, and confident. For example, James bond's character during the last decades.
Another example of a stereotype created by the media is the portrayal of ethnic minority
groups in a negative light, frequently as dangerous or criminals. For example, the portrayal of
Abidar 9
Arabs in various films, documentaries, and series as aggressive, abusers, and wealthy
characters. This can be seen clearly in the 2010 Indian Film "My Name is Khan" by Karan
Johar. Which tells the story of a Muslim Indian in the United States of America. Moreover,
the 1992 "Aladdin" movie shows the position of Arabs in Hollywood. The film opens up with
a song that shows a pure stereotypical view of the foreigners over the Arabs, the song begins
"Where they cut off your ear If they don’t like your face, It’s barbaric, but hey, it’s home".
These false representations affected the overall image of Arabs in today's world. Both Indians
and Arabs suffer greatly from these media representations. As a result of these media
portrayals, Hall came up with the representation theory as a way to show the malevolent
The cliché "the Indians are coming" no longer holds true in Hollywood since the
Indians have already landed and are busy establishing their influence on the industry.
Nevertheless, their journey to get there was not easy, it took them years to establish a path that
gives them the advantage to spread wide. During the late 1920s till the early 1930s, The
Indians were seen as primitive people, savages, and animal-like. They were also seen as the
people who serve only the British Raj which is a territory established by the monarch of Great
Britain. In the early, to the mid-1900s the world views India as the land of tigers and
elephants. There is a British film Elephant Boy 1936 by Robert Flaherty and Zoltan Kodra
which reflected the stereotypes and misrepresentations of the Indians. This film featured a
young Indian boy who went by the name Sabu. Sabu, who began his career in the United
Kingdom, was quickly enticed by Hollywood and the first Indian actor to earn international
recognition. This recognition provides him a chance to work with the Anglo-Indian actress
Merle Oberon who has mixed Indian and British ancestry. Merle Oberon is best known for
Abidar 10
her role in the film The Dark Angel 1935, her role in this film gives her the chance to win her
Indians were still misrepresentation on movie screens; they were cast as extras or in
minor roles, and they were forced to speak in thick Indian accents that made them seem
almost ridiculous to the western ear. A few more Anglo-Indians made a minor impact in
Hollywood in the early 1960s. Leela Naidu, whose mother was French and father Indian, was
named one of the most beautiful women in the world for several years. Leela was an active
actress from the 1960s till the early 1990s. Leela was loyal to her mother's home, India even
though she got several tempting offers from studios in foreign cinema, especially Universal
Television and others, she decided to grow and develop her career in India.
During the same period in the late 50s and the early 60s, another beautiful and
charming actress by the name of Kamala Devi appeared to surprise the audience with
incredible talent yet disappeared quickly. Kamala was half English and alongside the great
Tony Randall and Burl Ives in the motion picture Brass Bottle 1964 a fantasy comedy about a
magical genie who’s determined to fulfill his master’s wishes. She also did some television
work. There was also, another actress by the name of Anna Kashif an English actress with
Indian blood, she also goes by the name Joanna O'Callaghan. Joanna is the former wife of the
miracle of Hollywood Marlon Brando who was once considered to be the greatest actor alive
in the late 50s to the early 70s. Joanna is best known for her association with Paramount in the
1956 film Mourning Snow alongside Spencer Tracy and Robert Wagner.
Abidar 11
During the eighties, we witness proper roles for the Indians on TV. The best example
of that is the 1982 St. Elsewhere Hospital comedy-drama series starring Kavi Raz an Indian-
born actor who played one of the major characters in the series. By playing the role of the
doctor in the series, he became the first Indian to have a TV series. Also, Persis Khambatta
was one of the first to be cast in the movie Star Trek in 1979. She also appeared in other
projects like Megaforce 1982, My Beautiful Laundrette 1985, and The Knight of the Lost
World 1983.
All this great success that the Indians achieved didn’t come overnight, it took them
years and years to establish a foundation that allows the current generations of actors and
actresses to be where they are now. Indians manage to conduct success not only in the
filmmaking industry but in the technological and digital world from the end of the 80s to the
early 90s. Moreover, People like Aziz Ansari, Mindy Kaling, and Asif Mandvi rose from
stand-up comedians to full-time TV and movie stars and eventually ended up becoming
According to Fanon in his book The Wretched of The Earth, Colonization is not satisfied with
holding a people in its grip and emptying the native's brain of all form and content. By a kind
of perverted logic, it turns to the past of the oppressed people and distorts, disfigures, and
destroys it. This reflects the British colonialism of India and its long-term repercussions.
Nevertheless, the media represents a meaning which is already been presented before, also
media uses stereotypes. These stereotypes are reinforced by the media. Furthermore, the
media tends to create these new stereotypes about the groups through the way they report
about them. These misleading opinions that the media corporation creates are based on the
hegemonic groups of the society. These groups seek to control those who are less powerful
than them. The bulk of media firms is controlled by white, upper-class, straight wealthy
Abidar 12
males. Media representations aren't reflections of things that already have meaning, they are
the meaning makers of things that happen in reality. This shows the significance of the notion
of representation and stereotyping for both cultural studies and media studies.
Yes, India has one of Asia’s biggest slums in Mumbai formerly known as Bombay.
This does not mean that all Indians have the same lifestyle. Danny's film "Slumdog
Millionaire" sells the idea that the majority of Indians live in slums and poverty. The story of
the main character Jamal malik an 18 years old orphan takes place in Mumbai. The film
represents Mumbai as a poor, corrupted, and undeveloped city. All these stereotypes that the
film promotes are wrong and misleading. This goes to say that India's true identity is ruined
In "Slumdog Millionaire", Danny employs the yellow filter as a way of showing the
miserable condition the life in India. This shows the misrepresentation that foreigners apply to
both Indians in cinemas. The yellow filter shows the degradation and dehumanization of these
groups compared to countries like Europe and the United States of America. The Global
media brand Matador Network says the American/ Britain filmmakers use this filter to
represent nations that are stereotyped as the poorest of the poor, dirty, and living in areas of
conflict. This representation allows the Americans to maintain their dominance over these
Another example is the 2007 film by Wes Anderson, an American filmmaker, his film
"The Darjeeling Limited" had the same filter. The yellow shade in cinema indicates either
Abidar 13
Indians, Arabs, Asians, or Mexico. This yellow filter is intended to show a warm, tropical
atmosphere, but it also makes the environment look uglier and unhealthy. Danny portrayed
the city of Mumbai as poor which is wrong. India's economy is the fifth-largest in the world.
According to the Global media brand Matador Network American filmmakers use this filter to
represent nations that are stereotyped as the poorest of the poor, dirty, and areas of conflict.
This representation allows the Americans to maintain their dominance over these groups.
This concern is far larger than India. In countless Hollywood films, countries like
Pakistan, Bangladesh, Mexico, and Southeast Asia have been subjected to the yellow filter
effect. Arab countries also suffer from the same representation. In the 2020 Netflix film
"Extraction" and the 2022 sequel of the same film, the use of the yellow filter is dominant.
For example, in this film scenes that were shot in Australia seem to be normal and beautiful,
the rest of the film which takes place in Dhaka, Bangladesh came in a yellow shade that was
highly saturated.
Abidar 14
MILLIONAIRE”
Jamal and Salim are Muslims from a Muslim family. The movie tackles the condition
of Muslim minorities in India. The two brothers lost their family and community to a Muslim
massacre by a group of terrorists. This tragic incident took place in the first 20 minutes of the
movie. It prevented the two brothers from living a normal childhood. Both names 'Jamal' and
'Salim' are Muslim names. Salim in one of his scenes said the word "Allah Akbar" which
means that God is great. Danny Boyle portrayed crucial, horrible, and violent images that
mirror the miserable condition of Muslims in India. However, Boyle didn't give an
explanation for this incident, perhaps it was intended. The film gives some sense that these
things just happened and are somehow normal. Boyle made a movie that tackles morality,
ethics, and the nature of evil. Boyle didn't insist much on Islam references in his movie which
Jamal's journey from boyhood to manhood seems to affect his faith. Throughout the
film, Jamal's love for Latika distracted him and caused him to neglect his religion. His brother
Salim, however, maintained that side of his character. Salim's praying scene in 01:12:52
shows the character's strong bonding with God. He was asking for forgiveness. This means
that despite the horrific journey that Salim had had, he maintained his trust and belief in God.
Latika's character was also one of the victims of the Anti-Muslim riot. However, she doesn't
Abidar 15
seem like a Muslim girl. She didn't wear a headscarf that covers all of her hair like all the
other Muslim women. The director left her religious belonging unknown to create some sense
of diversity and acceptance from the audience. In addition, the name 'Latika' is used by both
Muslims and Hindus. Latika's journey throughout the events of the film was either homeless
or house arrest. This draws a clear image that she never had a chance to decide which religion
These attacks are known as communal riots between the majority Hindu and minority Muslim
communities. The rise in Islamophobia throughout the 20th century mainly means fear,
hatred, and prejudice against the religion of Islam or Muslims. Some scholars have described
these incidents of anti-Muslim violence as an act of genocide. A few of the biggest massacres
took place in Bihar also known as the 1989 Bhagalpur riots with over 1000 deaths and 50000
displaced. Another is the Gujarat massacre between 1969-1989 which caused over 3100
deaths. A recent incident happened in Delhi, India also known as the 2020 Delhi riots, this
During The Hindu-against-Muslim massacre, both Salim and Jamal flee away from the
scene towards a police vehicle on the side of the road asking for help. However, the police
were playing cards, smoking, and having fun in the back of the vehicle which shows the
carelessness of the powers of law regarding the safety of Muslim minorities. The police did
a result, huge numbers of children are thrown into the streets, fighting to survive. These
orphans become easy targets for human trafficking, beggers, and prostitution. the three
musketeers Jamal, Salim, and Latika suffered badly from the Hindu-against-Muslim
massacre. The three orphans live for a while in dumpsters, later taken to an orphanage by
Maman's gang, a group of children kidnappers. Kids who can sing beautifully suffer the most.
Maman's men crucially and intentionally blinded the kids for good. Eventually using them as
begging puppets to earn cash in the slums of Mumbai. Danny portrayed this incident in the
The hadeeth by the prophet Muhammed peace be upon him summarizes the position
and destiny of Muslims in this life "Islam began as something strange and will go back to
CHARACTER.
Jamal is one of the two brothers who are orphaned when their mother is killed during
an anti-Muslim riot. Jamal is the main character of the story. The sad tragedy of his boyhood,
The Hindu-against-Muslim massacre served as a trigger and fueled his desire to survive.
Jamal is the opposite of his brother, he is more of an optimistic type of person. While his
brother, Salim used violence as a defense mechanism against his environment, Jamal
employed his mind and intellect to survive. Also, Jamal was driven by love, love at first sight.
Their love flourished after the massacre. Latika and the two brothers are the Three Musketeers
Abidar 17
of this story, they suffer from vicious abuse and mistreatment. Nevertheless, The love
Mumbai was a fortune and misfortune to the Three Musketeers. Jamal's tragic
boyhood drove him from living in the slums of Mumbai to becoming a millionaire. This goes
to say that Jamal refuses to allow anything to stand in his way and decided to seize his
destiny. However, Salim chooses the life of the street and crime rather than Jamal's path.
Eventually ended up dead at the hands of the crime lord's men. Jamal and Latika are finally
reunited after a series of unfortunate events. To "Jai Ho," they kiss, dance, and sing.
Abidar 18
CONCLUSION
The whole film was criticizing child poverty in India, from the point of view of a
western filmmaker, Danny Boyle. The film chronicles poverty and social inequality in India
filmmaker uses British actors to cosplay people in poverty in India and cast judgment on them
from outside. While there have been countless more realistic movies made in Bollywood
about poverty that have been completely ignored. This goes to say that this depiction is
"Slumdog Millionaire" is a movie that breaks the circle of the typical Indian movie.
This film connected with people, especially foreigners from all over the world. An Indian
audience may not feel the same way as the others do while watching. Watching movies is
subjective, but it does not imply the film's meaning will shift or change. Having a reference
point about what real India is actually like prevents the audience from accepting Danny's
point of view.
The film "Slumdog Millionaire" presents the story of a young man who succeeds
despite enormous obstacles, which is much needed in these days of economic gloom. If Jamal
Malik can overcome such terrible birth and circumstance handicaps, then despair is
unjustified, according to the film. "Slumdog Millionaire" mirrors the greatest and ugliest
sights that can be found in India. Yet, Indians manage to overcome the effects of the
colonizer, the British empire. India in both "Slumdog Millionaire" and the public's eyes is a
poor, weak, and vulnerable place. Regardless, in the last two decades, the nation had achieved
Abidar 19
tremendous development economically and socially. India turned itself from a country that
The film illustrates how, regardless of how intelligent or hardworking they are, all
people who are born poor tend to stay that way. Jamal Malik achieves success through a
mixture of skills, hard effort, and pure luck. Nevertheless, those with whom he grew up, are
condemned to have less fortunate lives, with some turning to crime, in this case, his older
The lack of Muslim influencers and leaders in India prevents Muslim minorities from
promoting their true Islamic values. This means that their current position feeds and
exacerbates religious bigotry toward them. According to Fanon in his book The Wretched of
The Earth, "Individuals without an anchor, without horizon, colorless, stateless, a race of
angels." Fanon's violence theory might end the discrimination against Muslim Indians. By
employing violence Muslims will be able to reclaim their identity, position, and respect.
understand the reason behind this, one must have read the Al Furqan or Quran. Other names
of the Quran are Tanzil, Mubin, and al Qawl. Unfortunately, it's easy to misrepresent Islam
because only fewer people have read the Quran. People who haven't read the Quran see terror
attacks like 9/11 as an Islamic event. Lack of branding prevents Islam from becoming a
desirable religion to the young generations. The big question is how can you say that the
Islamic State is a false construct if you don't understand what true Islam is?
Abidar 20
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Akomfrah, John, director. The Stuart Hall Project. Smoking Dogs Films. 13 June 2013.
Boyle, Danny, and Loveleen Tandan. Slumdog Millionaire. Fox Searchlight Pictures, 2008.
Brussat, Frederic, and Mary Ann Brussat. “Slumdog Millionaire: Film Review: Spirituality &
www.spiritualityandpractice.com/films/reviews/view/18548/slumdog-millionaire.
De Souza, Noël. “Indians in Hollywood, Part 1.” Golden Globes, 5 July 2018,
www.goldenglobes.com/articles/indians-hollywood-part-1.
De Souza, Noël. “Indians in Hollywood, Part 2.” Golden Globes, 8 July 2018,
www.goldenglobes.com/articles/indians-hollywood-part-2.
Fanon, Frantz, and Charles L. Markmann. Black Skin, White Masks. , 1967.
Fanon, Frantz. The Wretched of the Earth. New York: Grove Press, 1963.
2020, biosidmartin.com/what-is-representation-according-to-stuart-hall/.
Hall, Stuart. Representation: Cultural Representations and Signifying Practices. London: Sage
www.screendaily.com/features/slumdog-millionaire-/4040676.article.
Jhally, Sut, Jeremy Earp, Andrew Killoy, Mary Patierno, Simon Shaheen, and Jack G. Shaheen.
Reel Bad Arabs: How Hollywood Vilifies a People. Northampton, MA: Media Education
Foundation, 2006.
today.duke.edu/2009/03/krishna_oped.html.
“Media Studies - Stuart Hall's Representation Theory - Simple Guide For Students & Teachers."
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HxK5CXfKSCI.
“Quentin Tarantino, Ridley Scott, Danny Boyle, & More Directors on THR's Roundtables I
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SQ7qKKQrSBY.
“Representation, As Seen by Stuart Hall." YouTube, uploaded by kcnova24, Jun 14, 2010,
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EKkSi8PTP4U.
“Representation & the Media: Featuring Stuart Hall." YouTube, uploaded by ChallengingMedia,
“Representation and the Media by Stuart Hall." YouTube, uploaded by Keith Bishop, Nov 30,
2021, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84depWskwu0.
Shaheen, Jack G. “Hollywood's Bad Arabs.” The Cairo Review of Global Affairs, The Cairo
arabs/.
“Stuart Hall - Race, Gender, Class in the Media." YouTube, uploaded by Al Jazeera English, Mar
2, 2017, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FWP_N_FoW-I.
“Stuart Hall’s Representation Theory Made Simple." YouTube, uploaded by Media/Pool, Jan 31,
2022, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Up3v8ZH6s7c.
“Stuart Hall's representation analysis." YouTube, uploaded by Moana Luri, Feb 29, 2020,
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yGML4v_vmjM.
“Stuart Hall's Representation Theory Explained! Media Studies revision." YouTube, uploaded by
“Top 10 Danny Boyle Movies." YouTube, uploaded by communiTV, Nov 19, 2020,
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A1iMJGNAe14.
Abidar 22
www.britannica.com/biography/Danny-Boyle.
“3 filmmakers ‘Trainspotting’ director Danny Boyle thinks you should be following now."
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ct7KTJ_bsiw.