You are on page 1of 16

THE EFFECT OF b-ALANINE SUPPLEMENTATION ON

POWER PERFORMANCE DURING REPEATED


SPRINT ACTIVITY
KAITLIN M. SWEENEY,1 GLENN A. WRIGHT,1 A. GLENN BRICE,2 AND SCOTT T. DOBERSTEIN1
1
Exercise and Sport Science Department; and 2Biology Department, University of Wisconsin–La Crosse, La Crosse, Wisconsin

ABSTRACT INTRODUCTION

T
Sweeney, KM, Wright, GA, Brice, AG, and Doberstein, ST. The
consists of intermittent
he activity pattern of bouts
many offield-based
maximal or
effect of b-alanine supplementation on power performance near-
during repeated sprint activity. J Strength Cond Res 24(1): 79–
87, 2010—The dipeptide carnosine has been shown to contribute
light-intensity recovery periods. The ability to
maintain this pattern of activity throughout an entire game or
to the buffer capacity of hydrogen ions (H+) during intense match requires the rapid resynthesis of adenosine triphos-
exercise. Increasing skeletal muscle carnosine levels through b- phate (ATP). Rapid ATP resynthesis is primarily accom-
alanine (BA) supplementation has been shown to maintain acid-base plished by the limited stores of phosphocreatine (PCr) and
balance, delay fatigue, and improve exercise performance. We fast glycolysis (27). Gaitanos et al. (11) suggested that com-
designed this study to examine the effect of 5 weeks of BA plete PCr resynthesis cannot occur within short recovery
supplementation on repeat high-intensity sprint performance. periods, resulting in a progressive depletion of PCr and an
increased reliance on fast glycolysis during repeat sprint
Nineteen, physically active, college men were divided into 2 groups
exercise. The increased dependence on fast glycolysis also
(control [C], n = 10 or BA, n = 9). We performed double-blind
implies an increase in hydrogen ion (H+) concentration
placebo-controlled study where sub- jects ingested 4 g per day
within the muscle, which decreases pH, slows ATP pro-
during the first week and 6 g per day over the next 4 weeks of a duction, and inevitably causes fatigue. In addition, increased
placebo (rice flour) or a BA supple- ment. Subjects completed 2 H+ may interfere with muscle contraction and may poten-
sets of 5 5-second sprints with 45-second recovery separated by 2 tially decrease power production (20). As a result, field-based
minutes of active recovery. All tests were conducted on a non- athletes in sports such as American football, soccer, and
motorized treadmill against a resistance of 15% of the field hockey may look for nutritional supplements to aid in
participant’s body weight. We recorded horizontal power (HP) of improving muscle buffer capacity to improve performance
the running sprint. Post- exercise capillary blood samples were during competition.
analyzed for lactate to determine the metabolic demands. There were The intramuscular dipeptide carnosine is thought to
no significant between-group differences (p . 0.05) in HPpeak or contribute between 7 and 10% to the total buffering capacity
HPmean for the repeat sprint protocol. No significant between- in skeletal muscle of untrained subjects (18,23). Carnosine is
group differences were found for performance decrement (% made up of 2 amino acids, b-alanine (BA), and histidine.
Histidine is found in plentiful amounts in muscle, which leads
fatigue) for HPpeak or HPmean. In addition, no significant
many to suggest that the BA may be the rate-limiting sub-
interactions were observed. Post-exercise blood lactate values were
strate for carnosine production in muscle (2). Studies where
similar pre and post supplementation in both groups. The results of
subjects supplemented with doses of 3–6 g BA per day for
this study clearly indicate that 5 weeks of BA supplementation
at least 4 weeks have shown to be an effective means of
provides no benefit for repeat sprint performance. increasing skeletal muscle carnosine levels (9,16,18). In-
creasing skeletal muscle carnosine levels through BA supple-
KEY WORDS carnosine, high-intensity exercise, buffer capacity, mentation delays fatigue and increases anaerobic exercise
fatigue performance (9,15,17,29), presumably by improving buffer
capacity.
Human Performance Laboratory, University of Wisconsin–La Crosse. Previous investigators observed that BA supplementation
Address correspondence to Kaitlin M. Sweeney,
improved anaerobic exercise performance (15,17,28); how-
kaitlin.sweeney@gmail.com.
ever, not all anaerobic exercises are limited by the same
24(1)/79–87
metabolic factors. For example, it is suggested that fatigue
Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research during repeat sprint exercise is caused by the rapid depletion
© 2010 National Strength and Conditioning Association

VOLUME 24 | NUMBER 1 | JANUARY 2010 | 79


Effect of b-Alanine Supplementation on Power Performance

of PCr stores in the muscle (12). At the same time, repeat 3–4 days of resistance training and 2 days of sprint training.
sprint exercise is known to produce moderate to high muscle The remaining 8 subjects were involved with a recreational
and blood lactate levels and a resulting decrease in muscle strength training program where the focus was on muscle
pH (4,8,11), indicating the heavy use of fast glycolysis to hypertrophy and were regularly trained 3–4 days per week
resynthesize ATP. Bishop et al. (5) found that there was for at least 6 months before beginning the study. One subject
a strong relationship between power decrement and change in the BA group dropped out of the study during the week of
in plasma [H+] during a repeat sprint protocol consisting of post-testing because of illness unrelated to the study.
5 3 6-second sprints with a 24-second recovery. As a result of Therefore, pre- and post-supplementation data for
this finding and the relationship between blood and muscle this subject were not included in data analysis, leaving the
pH (1), Bishop et al. (5) suggested that the ability for the BA group with only 9 subjects. The research protocol was
muscle to buffer H+ may be important for maintaining repeat approved by the university’s Institutional Review Board
sprint performance. It is possible that repeat sprint exercise before its implementation. Subjects were informed of the
performance may be improved by BA supplementation experimental risks and signed an informed consent
because muscle buffer capacity seems to be important for document before participation in the study. The subjects
such performance (3); however, no studies have been per- were not permitted to use any additional nutritional or
formed to investigate this hypothesis. Therefore, the purpose performance enhancement supplementation in the previous
of this study was to determine the efficacy of 5 weeks of 8 weeks. We asked our subjects to maintain their normal
BA supplementation on repeated brief sprint performance. diet and eat a normal meal within 2–3 hours before each
exercise testing session. No other nutritional guidelines
METHODS
were given.
Experimental Approach to the Problem
This study was conducted over a 6-week period using a 2-
Procedures
group, matched, double-blind design that was placebo
controlled. After 2 familiarization sessions of the repeated Supplementation. After pretesting, subjects ingested 2 capsules
sprint protocol used in the study, the participants were of the BA supplement (Intra X cell; Athletics Edge
assigned to 1 of 2 groups of 10 subjects: BA or placebo (C) Nutrition, Miami, FL, USA) or placebo (rice flour) 3 times
matched to their mean power performance during the per day during the first week. Daily intake of the
second familiarization of the sprint protocol. The C group experimental supplement at this dosage supplied 4 g of
was used rather than a crossover design because the BA, 402 mg pro- prietary blend of N-acetylcysteine/g-lipoic
washout time for BA is not at present known. Subjects acid, and 15 mg of vitamin E. During the following 4
performed a repeated sprint protocol before and after 5 weeks, participants increased the dose to 6 g of BA or
weeks of supplementation with either a BA or a placebo placebo per day by ingesting 3 capsules, 3 times per day.
similar in appearance, taste, and texture. It was Subjects were asked to take the capsules with meals and
hypothesized that BA supplementation would allow sprint record the exact day and time of dose in a dosing journal.
performance (horizontal power produc- tion, HP; power Supplements were disbursed at the beginning of weeks 1
decrement, % fatigue) to be maintained through a greater and 3.
number of sprints than without BA. Sprint Treadmill Testing. The testing protocol consisted of
Subjects 2 familiarization sessions performed on nonconsecutive days.
Twenty, physically active, college-aged men were recruited The second of these sessions was performed 1 week before
as subjects in this investigation (descriptive characteristics the first of 2 experimental sessions. Experimental sessions
found in Table 1). Twelve subjects were National Collegiate were separated by the 5-week supplementation period. The
Athletic Association Division III football players involved in 2 experimental sessions consisted of a standardized warm-up
the early phases of their off-season training program, which of 5 minutes on a motorized treadmill at a self-selected fast
included walk or slow jog followed by 3 short 2- to 3-second bursts
on a non-motorized treadmill (Force Treadmill; Woodway
USA, Waukesha, WI, USA) against a resistance load equal
to 15% of the subject’s body weight. This resistance was
established through pilot work to find the highest load that
TABLE 1. Participant characteristics (mean 6 SD).* would ensure reaching peak power within the first 3 seconds
Height Body of a 5-second sprint. After the warm-up, subjects rested for
Group nAge (y) (cm) mass (kg) 5 minutes before starting the sprint protocol.
The non-motorized treadmill consisted of a hard rubber
BA9 22.5 6 1.7 71.8 6 3.3 90.4 6 20.2 belt that was user driven. The load was produced by an
C10 22.7 6 1.3 70.9 6 2.6 87.9 6 8.7
electromagnetic braking system that provided up to 68 kg of
resistance to the treadmill belt. The subject was attached to
*BA = b-alanine; C = control.
a vertical strut by a belted tether system that contained a
load cell to measure horizontal force. Information from the
load
80 Journal
the
of Strength and Conditioning Research
Journal
the of Strength and Conditioning Research | www.nsca-jscr.org

Figure 1. Peak and mean HP output per sprint for the BA group (A) and C group (B) pre and post supplementation (mean values only, SD not shown for clarity). HP = horizontal power; BA = b-al

cell and the velocity of the treadmill belt were interfaced were instructed to achieve maximal effort and maintain that
with a computer and software that determined horizontal effort for the entire 5 seconds of every sprint. Strong verbal
force, velocity, power, work, and distance of each sprint at encouragement was given to each participant. The test-retest
50 Hz. These data were accumulated on a Microsoft Excel reliabilities (intraclass correlation, ICC) of this repeat sprint
spread- sheet and averaged to 0.5-second intervals. protocol were r = 0.998 and r = 0.918 for mean power and
Performance decrement (% fatigue) during the repeat sprint peak power performance, respectively.
protocol was calculated using recommendations made by
Glaister et al. Blood Lactate. Fingertip capillary blood samples were taken
(13) and the performance decrement score devised by before warm-up and 5 minutes after the last sprint. After
Fitzsimons et al. (10): % fatigue = 100 2 ([total power puncturing the skin of the fingertip, the first drop of blood
output/ideal power output] 3 100), where total power was wiped from the skin. The succeeding blood flow was
output = the sum of the power output values for all collected in a heparinized capillary tube. Twenty-five
sprints and ideal power output = the number of sprints 3 microliters of blood was immediately removed from the
highest power output of all sprints. capillary tube and mixed with 50 ml of NaF Triton buffer,
The repeat sprint protocol consisted of 2 sets of five 5- which is used for red blood cell lyses and to prevent an
second sprints with 45 seconds of passive recovery. A 2- increase in lactate after the whole blood sample was added
minute walking recovery at 1.5 mph on an adjacent to the buffer. Samples were immediately analyzed for
motorized treadmill separated the 2 sets of sprints. Subjects lactate using a Yellow Springs

Group Time HPpeak (W) Effect size HPmean (W) Effect size
B Pre 1,089.1 6 168.4 0.15 885.3 6 139.0 0.06
A
Post 1,114.8 6 194.5 876.3 6 136.9
C Pre 1,101.1 6 153.2 0.14 888.3 6 116.2 0.07
Post 1,121.9 6 140.8 880.2 6 115.7

TABLE 2. HP for the BA and C groups pre and post supplementation (mean 6 SD).*
Time p = 0.644 p = 0.000†
Group p = 0.849 p = 0.952
Time 3 group p = 0.962 p = 0.824

*HP = horizontal power; BA = b-alanine; C = control.


†p , 0.05.

VOLUME 24 | NUMBER 1 | JANUARY 2010 | 81


Effect of b-Alanine Supplementation on Power Performance

Figure 2. Individual response (lines) and group mean (bars) for average HPpeak and HPmean per sprint for the BA group (A, C) and control group (B, D) pre and post supplementation (mean values only

Instruments 1500 Sport lactate analyzer (Yellow Springs, OH, a statistical power of 0.80 for peak power performance and
USA). The test-retest reliability (ICC) of this method in our 8 subjects would be necessary to achieve this level for mean
laboratory has been shown to be r $ 0.953. power performance (21). Because mean power is a more
representative measure of sprint performance, we decided
Statistical Analyses to recruit 10 subjects per group in this study.
Based on a similar repeat sprint study design (31), we Analysis of variance (2 3 2) with repeated measures on
determined that 12 subjects would be necessary to achieve one factor (time: pre vs. post) was performed to determine if
any

Group Time HPpeak (%) Effect size HPmean (%) Effect size
B Pre 10.0 6 3.7 0.05 8.8 6 3.8 0.03
A
Post 10.2 6 2.5 8.9 6 2.5
C Pre 10.1 6 3.4 0.12
8.4 6 8.6 0.43
Post 10.5 6 3.2 12.1 6 4.9
Time p = 0.613 p = 0.080
Group p = 0.858 p = 0.367
T ABLE 3. Performance decrement (% fatigue) for HP and velocity (V) for the BA and C groups pre and post
Time 3 group p = 0.887 p = 0.094
supplementation (mean 6 SD).*†
*HP = horizontal power; BA = b-alanine; C = control.
†p # 0.05. No differences were identified.

82 Journal
the of Strength and Conditioning Research
th e TM

Jo u rnal of Strength and Conditioning Research | www.nsca-


jscr.org

Figure 3. Individual response (lines) and group mean (bars) for power decrement (% fatigue) during the sprint protocol for the BA group (A, C) and C group (B, D) pre and post supplementation for

significant main effects or interactions were present between No significant differences were identified for HPpeak by time,
time and between groups (BA and C) for analysis of HP, % group, or interaction of time 3 group (Table 2). We observed
fatigue (performance decrement), and blood lactate. All data a significant main effect in HPmean by time such that
are reported as mean 6 SD unless otherwise indicated. The there was a decrease in HPmean in both groups from pre- to
level of statistical significance was set at p # 0.05, with post- testing; however, there was no significant difference
meaningfulness of differences determined by the use of between groups or time 3 group interaction (Table 2). Effect
effect sizes. Effect sizes were calculated by determining the sizes for HP in both groups were trivial, ranging from 0.06
differ- ence between pretest and posttest means, divided by to 0.15. Figure 2 shows that there was a fairly consistent
the pretest SD, and interpreted according to a scale individual subject response to both the BA and C
previously proposed by Rhea (24). supplementation.
Fatigue
RESULTS
The performance decrements (% fatigue) seen in the BA
Review of supplement dosing journals indicated that all group and C group pre and post supplementation are shown
subjects met the required supplement dosage and demon- in Table 3. No significant differences were seen in the
strated no side effects other than a mild prickling sensation performance decrement for HPpeak or HPmean. Effect sizes
in their neck and limbs due to the neural sensitivity from the for HP in both groups were trivial to small, ranging from 0.03
supplement. This side effect is considered to be normal and to 0.43. Figure 3 shows a large variation in both HPpeak
typical of BA supplementation and dissipates with time. and HPmean for the individual subject response in
Horizontal Power performance decrement for both groups of subjects.
Figure 1 shows the power output for peak (HPpeak) and Lactate
mean (HPmean) horizontal power for each sprint by Blood lactate response to the repeat sprint protocol is shown
group. in Figure 4. There were no significant differences observed by
VOLUME 24 | NUMBER 1 | JANUARY 2010 | 83
Effect of b-Alanine Supplementation on Power Performance

individual pre- to post-supple-


mentation % fatigue responses
for both BA and C groups are
quite variable. Although the
method used to determine
performance decrement in this
study has been evaluated and
compared with other methods
for reliability and validity and
determined to be the most
reliable and valid method, it
has also been shown to have
a test-retest variability in fatigue
of about 30% (13).
The absence of an ergogenic
effect may be related to the
inability to increase muscle
carnosine levels by the dosing
strategy used in this study.
Beta- alanine is likely the rate-
limiting substrate and essential
supple- ment required to
increase car- nosine levels
group (p = 0.562) or time (p = 0.809). There was also no within the muscle
significant group 3 time interaction (p = 0.585). tissue (2). Previous research has demonstrated that BA
supplementation can increase muscle carnosine levels and
DISCUSSION contribute to the acid-base buffering capacity of the muscle
The aim of this study was to determine the effect of 5 weeks (8,12,14,15,18). For example, Harris et al. (16) found a 42%
of BA supplementation on performance during repeated increase in carnosine levels after supplementing with 3.2 g
brief all-out sprints. Results indicate that 6 g per day of BA per day of BA and a 64% increase with 6.4 g per day after
Figure 4. Lactate response to repeat sprint protocol pre and post supplementation. BA = b-alanine; C = control (mean 6 SD).
supplementation had no effect on HP or performance 4 weeks of supplementation.
decrement (% fatigue) during repeated sprints. The decrease Active subjects show higher resting levels of carnosine in
in HPmean from pre to posttesting in both groups may be their muscles than untrained individuals, especially if they
attributed to a change in pacing strategy during the sprint. have a history of anaerobic training (30). Muscle carnosine
We observed that both groups produced a nonsignificant levels have been determined to be twice as high in com-
increase in HPpeak after supplementation, which may petitive bodybuilders as untrained individuals, possibly due
have led to earlier fatigue within each sprint, resulting in to changes associated with prolonged repetitive exposure to
a lower HPmean. The BA group increased HPpeak 2.4%, low muscle pH, diet, or supplementation (30). The subjects
whereas HPmean decreased 1.0%. Similarly, the C group in our study would be classified as highly active with the
increased HPpeak 1.9%, which was accompanied by a 0.9% majority of their activity in anaerobic activities (strength
decrease in HPmean. Although the small decrease in training), although none would be considered elite athletes.
HPmean produced a significant main effect by time, it is Recently, Derave et al. (9) found that trained sprinters were
unlikely that this decrease is practically significant for most able to increase intramuscular carnosine 47% in the
field sport athletes. The lack of a group 3 time interaction and 37% in the gastrocnemius after 4 weeks of 2.4–4.8 g per
indicates there was no difference in the improvement in day of BA supplementation. Although an important limita-
HPmean due to BA supplementation. One of the key tion of this study was our inability to measure carnosine
outcomes of a repeat sprint protocol is the measure of levels, the dosage and supplement periods used in our study
performance decrement over the number of sprints. In (6 g per day, 5 weeks) are equal to or in excess of previous
this study, we looked at the power decrease over ten 5- studies that have shown a significant increase in muscle
second sprints with a 45-second recovery. To be able to carnosine levels in both trained and untrained subjects.
conclude that BA provides some positive ergogenic Therefore, the lack of ergogenic benefits observed in the
proper- ties, supplementation with BA should improve present study is not likely attributed to an inappropriate
the perfor- mance decrement (smaller decrease in BA supplementation protocol.
power) for both HPpeak and HPmean. Our results An increase in carnosine levels and muscle buffer capacity
show that BA did not improve the performance from BA would likely increase the ability to withstand and
decrement; however, the results should be interpreted with maintain performance during high-intensity activity where
caution. As shown in Figure 3, the
84 Journal
the
of Strength and Conditioning Research
th e TM

Jo u rnal of Strength and Conditioning Research | www.nsca-


jscr.org

fast glycolysis is an important energy system. An increased used four to five 2-minute stages after BA supplementation of
reliance on fast glycolysis means a greater concentration of 1.6 g per day for 28 days. Although many previous studies
H+ ions and drop in pH. In the present study, we did not support the use of BA supplementation as a performance-
measure blood or muscle pH. However, sprint-type activity is enhancing ergogenic aid for some types of anaerobic exer-
known to recruit high-threshold motor units during high cise, this is the first study to investigate the effects of BA
force production in muscles required in sprinting (25). The supplementation on repeat sprint exercise performance.
fast-twitch fibers that make up the high-threshold motor Our findings of the inability of BA supplementation to
units are characterized by greater intramuscular acidosis maintain HP during repeat sprint exercise in the present
during their activation than slow-twitch fibers (32). There- study are consistent with other studies using all-out efforts
fore, during repeated all-out sprint exercise, the involvement for less than 1 minute (9,19). For example, Hoffman et al.
of fast glycolysis in fast-twitch fibers, as evidenced in our (19) found no additional benefit of supplementing with BA
study by moderately high blood lactate levels, indicates along with creatine compared with creatine alone when
a likelihood that the muscle is in a state of acidosis during performing two 30-second Wingate tests separated by 3
this repeat sprint protocol. As the pH of the muscle drops, minutes of active recovery. In the same study (19), the
power output may be impaired due to muscular fatigue (9). supplementation of BA did not improve the maintenance of
It is known that the fatiguing effects attributed to a jumping power during a 20 consecutive jump test. In
decreasing pH during intense exercise include inhibition of addition, after 4 weeks of 4.8 g per day of BA (which
rate-limiting enzymes involved with fast glycolysis significantly increased intramuscular carnosine), Derave et al.
(phosphofructokinase and phosphorylase), decreased release (9) found no change in performance time (average ;52
of Ca++ from the sarcoplasmic reticulum, and a decrease in seconds) in a single 400-m sprint in trained sprinters.
cross-bridge inter- actions in the muscle (22,26), leading to These findings, along with the results of our study, suggest
a drop in HP. that factors other than changes in pH may be more
The presumed increase in muscle carnosine levels asso- important than the accumulation of H+ ions for producing
ciated with BA supplementation used in this study should fatigue during repeated brief sprints with short recovery
have increased the ability to buffer H+ ions and maintain periods. During a single bout (6 seconds) of high-intensity
muscle pH and sprint performance. However, it is possible exercise, use of PCr and fast glycolysis each account for
that the H+ produced may have exceeded the capacity of approximately half of the total energy needed; however,
carnosine to be an effective intramuscular buffer because during repeated sprints, a greater depletion of PCr is
estimated that during intense exercise, muscle pH will drop observed than during a single maximal effort (9). The rate
from 7.2 at rest to 6.5 or lower at fatigue (16). However, the of PCr resynthesis is influenced by the metabolic
suggestion of exceeding the capacity of carnosine may be environment of the muscle, H+ ion concentrations of the
somewhat controversial because there is disagreement to muscle and blood, and ATP concentration within the
the extent of the buffering capacity of carnosine. According muscle (27). It has been demon- strated that short recovery
to Mannion et al. (23) carnosine may be of little importance periods (30–180 seconds) may not provide adequate time to
to pH maintenance by only contributing approximately restore PCr values to resting levels, thus leading to an
7% to the total muscle buffer capacity. However, findings by increased need for additional energy from fast glycolysis
Davey (7) suggest that carnosine can contribute as much as (2,9). Indeed, Bogdanis et al. (6) reported that the halftime
40% to buffering capacity when the physiological pH is for PCr resynthesis was 57 seconds, considerably longer than
between 6.5 and 7.5. the recovery period (45 seconds) used in the present
Although previous research has shown an improvement in study. The incomplete resynthesis of PCr may explain the
performance after BA supplementation (9,17,18,29), it might relatively high levels of blood lactate observed in our study
be concluded from those studies that the ergogenic benefit but also suggest that changes in pH may not be the sole
may be more related to the dominant energy system used explanation for muscle fatigue during our sprint protocol.
during the performance and as a result depend on the The availability of PCr may be the limiting factor in multiple
duration of the maximal effort. For example, Hill et al. (18) sprint performance (4,5,9). During repeated sprints, PCr may
demonstrated a 16% increase in total work performed at only be partially restored if the recovery bouts are less
110% of maximum cycling power to exhaustion than 1–2 minutes long and may take more than 6 minutes to
(;150 seconds) after BA supplementation for 4 weeks. In fully recover (4,9). It is likely that the 45-second recovery
addition, Derave et al. (9) demonstrated that BA improved periods used in our study did not allow for sufficient PCr
perfor- mance of intermittent exercise bouts of isokinetic leg resynthesis to maintain a considerable contribution to power
exten- sions (5 bouts of 30 maximal repetitions with 1- output beyond the first couple of sprints. Therefore, BA
minute rest between bouts) where each bout lasted supplementation may not have a large effect on repeated
approximately sprint performance because the lack of PCr resynthesis may
45 seconds. The ergogenic benefits however were not have a greater effect on fatigue and decrease in performance
noticed until the last 2 sets of the intermittent protocol. than the accumulation of H+. In support of this notion,
Stout et al. (29) demonstrated an increase in neuromuscular Bishop et al. (3) found that the physiochemical buffering
fatigue threshold using an incremental cycling challenge that
VOLUME 24 | NUMBER 1 | JANUARY 2010 | 85
Effect of b-Alanine Supplementation on Power Performance

in the muscle during a 5 3 6-second sprint protocol with 6. Bogdanis, G, Nevill, M, Boobis, L, and Lakomy, H. Contribution of
24-second recovery had no relationship to repeated sprint phosphocreatine and aerobic metabolism to energy supply during
ability. They suggest that the contribution from the repeated sprint exercise. J Appl Physiol 80: 876–884, 1996.
metabolic reactions that consume H+, the sarcolemmal 7. Davey, C. The significance of carnosine and anserine in striated
skeletal muscle. Arch Biochem Biophys 89: 303–308, 1960.
lactate/H+, and Na+/H+ exchange mechanisms;
8. Dawson, B, Goodman, C, Lawrence, S, Preen, D, Polglaze, T,
capillarization; muscle blood flow; and changes in the Fitzsimons, M, and Fournier, P. Muscle phosphocreatine repletion
intracellular strong ion differ- ence may be a greater following single and repeated short sprint efforts. Scan J Med Sci
influence than the physiochemical buffering in the muscle. Sports 7: 206–213, 2007.
They also suggest that the individuals with the best repeated 9. Derave, W, Ozdemir, M, Harris, R, Pottier, A, Reyngoudt, H,
Koppo, K, Wise, J, and Achten, E. Beta alanine supplementation
sprint ability are likely the ones who produce fewer H+, augments muscle carnosine content and attenuates fatigue during
especially in the first few sprints (3). repeated isokinetic contraction bouts in trained sprinters. J Appl
In conclusion, it was determined that BA supplementation Physiol 103: 1736–1743, 2007.
does not have an ergogenic effect on repeated brief sprints. 10. Fitzsimmons, M, Dawson, B, Ware, D, and Wilkinson, A. Cycling
The lack of PCr resynthesis associated with short recovery and running tests of repeated sprint ability. Aust J Sci Med Sport
25: 82–87, 2003.
periods may more likely explain the limiting factors for
11. Gaitanos, G, Williams, L, Boobis, L, and Brooks, S. Human muscle
performance. metabolism during intermittent maximal exercise. J Appl Physiol
75: 712–719, 1993.
PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS 12. Glaister, M. Multiple sprint work: Methodological, physiological,
and experimental issues. Int J Sports Physiol Perform 3: 107–112,
The ability to produce and maintain bouts of high-power 2008.
output during periods of multiple sprint work is important to 13. Glaister, M, Howatson, G, Pattison, J, and Mcinnes, G. The reliability
many field-based sports. Previous research using repeat high- and validity of fatigue measures during multiple-sprint work: An
issue revisited. J Strength Cond Res 22: 1597–1601, 2008.
intensity sprint performance has attributed fatigue to the
14. Glaister, M, Lockey, R, Abraham, C, Staerck, A, Goodwin, J, and
availability and resynthesis of PCr. Phosphocreatine Mcinnes, G. Creatine supplementation and multiple sprint running
depletion may be a greater cause of fatigue in this protocol than performance. J Strength Cond Res 20: 273–277, 2004.
acidosis, and as a result, any effects of BA were not 15. Harris, R, Hill, C, and Wise, J. Effect of beta alanine and creatine
noticeable. Although this area requires more investigation, monohydrate supplementation on exercise performance. Med Sci
Sports Exerc 35: S218, 2003.
the results of this study suggest that sports such as football,
16. Harris, R, Tallon, M, Dunnett, M, Boobis, L, Coakley, J, Kim, H,
soccer, lacrosse, and others with repeated sprint efforts Fallowfield, J, Hill, C, Sale, C, and Wise, J. The absorption of orally
should probably not rely on BA supplementation for supplied beta-alanine and its effect on muscle carnosine synthesis in
performance enhancement. human vastus lateralis. Amino Acids 30: 279–289, 2006.
17. Hill, C, Harris, R, Kim, H, Boobis, L, Sale, C, and Wise, J. The effect
of beta-alanine and creatine monohydrate supplementation on
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS muscle composition and exercise performance. Med Sci Sports Exerc 37:
S348, 2005.
The authors would like to thank the University of Wisconsin–
18. Hill, C, Harris, R, Kim, H, Harris, B, Boobis, L, Sale, C, and Wise, J.
La Crosse Graduate Research Grant Program for assisting Influence of beta-alanine supplementation on skeletal muscle
with funding for this project. The authors would also like to carnosine concentration and high intensity cycling capacity. Amino
acknowledge Athletes Edge Nutrition, Miami, FL, for their Acids 32: 225–233, 2007.
help in providing supplementation. The results of the 19. Hoffman, J, Ratamess, N, Kang, J, Mangine, G, Faigenbaum, A, and
Stout, J. Effect of creatine and beta-alanine supplementation on
present study do not constitute endorsement of the product
performance and endocrine responses in strength/power athletes.
by the authors or the National Strength and Conditioning Int J Sport Nutr Exerc Metabol 16: 430–446, 2006.
Association. 20. Lamb, G, Recupero, E, and Stephenson, D. Effect of myoplasmic
pH on excitation-contraction coupling in skeletal muscle fibers of
the toad. J Physiol 448: 211–224, 1992.
REFERENCES
21. Lenth, R. Java applets for power and sample size [Computer
1. Alsop, P, Cheetham, M, Brooks, S, Hal, G, and Williams, C. Software]. Available at: http://www.stat.uiowa.edu/;rlenth/
Continuous intramuscular pH measurement during the recovery Power. Accessed April 6, 2009.
from brief, maximal exercise in man. Eur J Appl Physiol 59: 465–470,
1990. 22. Linderman, J and Fahey, T. Sodium bicarbonate ingestion and
exercise performance: An update. Sports Med 11: 71–77, 1991.
2. Asatoor, A, Bandoh, J, Lant, A, Milne, A, and Navah, F. Intestinal
absorption of carnosine and its constituent amino acids in man. 23. Mannion, A, Jakeman, P, Dunnett, M, Harris, R, and William, P.
Gut 11: 250–254, 1970. Carnosine and anserine concentrations in the quadriceps femoris
muscle of healthy humans. Eur J Appl Occup Physiol 64: 47–50, 1992.
3. Bishop, D, Edge, J, Davis, C, and Goodman, C. Muscle buffer
capacity and aerobic fitness are associated with repeated sprint 24. Rhea, M. Determining the magnitude of treatment effects in
ability in women. Eur J Appl Physiol 92: 540–547, 2004. strength training research through the use of the effect size. J
Strength Cond Res 18: 918–920, 2004.
4. Bishop, D, Edge, J, Davis, C, and Goodman, C. Induced metabolic
alkalosis affects muscle metabolism and repeated-sprint ability. 25. Ross, A, Leveritt, M, and Riek, S. Neural influences on sprint
Med Sci Sports Exerc 36: 807–813, 2004. running: Training adaptations and acute responses. Sports Med 31:
409–425, 2001.
5. Bishop, D, Lawrence, S, and Spencer, M. Predictors of repeated-
sprint ability in elite female hockey players. J Sci Med Sport 6: 199–
209, 2003.
86 Journal
the of Strength and Conditioning Research
th e TM

Jo u rnal of Strength and Conditioning Research | www.nsca-


jscr.org

26. Roth, D and Brooks, G. Lactate and pyruvate transport is dominated


30. Tallon, M, Harris, R, Boobis, L, Fallowfield, J, and Wise, J. The
by a pH gradient-sensitive carrier in rat skeletal muscle sarcolemmal
carnosine content of vastus lateralis is elevated in resistance
vesicles. Arch Biochem Biophys 279: 386–394, 1990.
trained bodybuilders. J Strength Cond Res 19: 725–729,
27. Silverthorn, D. Human Physiology: An Intergrated 2005.
Approach. San Francisco, CA: Pearson Education, 2004.
31. Wright, G, Grandjean, P, and Pascoe, D. The effects of creatine
28. Stout, J. Beta-alanine: The new kid on the block. Strength Cond J loading on thermoregulation and intermittent sprint exercise
27: 90–91, 2005. performance in a hot-humid environment. J Strength Cond Res
29. Stout, J, Cramer, J, Mielke, M, O’kroy, J, Torok, D, and Zoeller, R. 21: 655–660, 2007.
Effects of twenty eight days of beta-alanine and creatine mono- 32. Zhen-He, H, Botinelli, R, Pellegrino, M, Fereczi, M, and Reggani, C.
hydrate supplementation on the physical working capacity at ATP consumption and efficiency of human single muscle fibers
neuromuscular fatigue threshold. J Strength Cond Res 20: 928–931, with different myosin isoform composition. Biophys J 79: 945–961,
2006.
2000.

VOLUME 24 | NUMBER 1 | JANUARY 2010 | 87

You might also like