Professional Documents
Culture Documents
E3 (2lr1704)
ENROLLED BILL
— Judiciary/Judicial Proceedings —
Introduced by Delegate Clippinger
_______________________________________________
Proofreader.
_______________________________________________
Proofreader.
Sealed with the Great Seal and presented to the Governor, for his approval this
______________________________________________
Speaker.
CHAPTER ______
1 AN ACT concerning
3 FOR the purpose of altering provisions of law relating to the jurisdiction of the juvenile
4 court, the juvenile intake process, and the placement of a certain child in detention
5 or community detention; altering provisions of law relating to the authority of the
6 juvenile court in making a disposition on a certain petition; specifying the authority
7 of the juvenile court to place a child on probation under certain circumstances;
8 requiring the Governor’s Office of Crime Prevention, Youth, and Victim Services to
9 request and analyze certain data, develop a model policy for diversion of juveniles
10 from the juvenile and criminal justice systems, and submit certain reports;
11 establishing the Commission on Juvenile Justice Reform and Emerging and Best
12 Practices; requiring the Department of Juvenile Services to provide a certain report
13 to the General Assembly; and generally relating to juvenile justice.
*hb0459*
2 HOUSE BILL 459
6 BY adding to
7 Article – Courts and Judicial Proceedings
8 Section 3–8A–10(n), 3–8A–15(l), 3–8A–19.6, and 3–8A–19.7
9 Annotated Code of Maryland
10 (2020 Replacement Volume and 2021 Supplement)
11 BY repealing
12 Article – Courts and Judicial Proceedings
13 Section 3–8A–15(e)
14 Annotated Code of Maryland
15 (2020 Replacement Volume and 2021 Supplement)
26 BY adding to
27 Article – Public Safety
28 Section 3–530
29 Annotated Code of Maryland
30 (2018 Replacement Volume and 2021 Supplement)
31 BY adding to
32 Article – State Government
33 Section 9–3501 and 9–3502 to be under the new subtitle “Subtitle 35. Commission
34 on Juvenile Justice Reform and Emerging and Best Practices”
35 Annotated Code of Maryland
36 (2021 Replacement Volume)
1 3–8A–03.
7 (B) In addition to the jurisdiction specified in Subtitle 8 of this title, the court has
8 exclusive original jurisdiction over:
1 8.
THIRD DEGREE SEXUAL OFFENSE UNDER § 3–307 OF
2 THE CRIMINAL LAW ARTICLE; OR
8 [(b)] (C) The court has concurrent jurisdiction over proceedings against an adult
9 for the violation of § 3–8A–30 of this subtitle. However, the court may waive its jurisdiction
10 under this subsection upon its own motion or upon the motion of any party to the
11 proceeding, if charges against the adult arising from the same incident are pending in the
12 criminal court. Upon motion by either the State’s Attorney or the adult charged under §
13 3–8A–30 of this subtitle, the court shall waive its jurisdiction, and the adult shall be tried
14 in the criminal court according to the usual criminal procedure.
15 [(c)] (D) The jurisdiction of the court is concurrent with that of the District Court
16 in any criminal case arising under the compulsory public school attendance laws of this
17 State.
19 (1) A child at least 14 years old alleged to have done an act that, if
20 committed by an adult, would be a crime punishable by life imprisonment, as well as all
21 other charges against the child arising out of the same incident, unless an order removing
22 the proceeding to the court has been filed under § 4–202 of the Criminal Procedure Article;
23 (2) A child at least 16 years old alleged to have done an act in violation of
24 any provision of the Transportation Article or other traffic law or ordinance, except an act
25 that prescribes a penalty of incarceration;
26 (3) A child at least 16 years old alleged to have done an act in violation of
27 any provision of law, rule, or regulation governing the use or operation of a boat, except an
28 act that prescribes a penalty of incarceration;
29 (4) A child at least 16 years old alleged to have committed any of the
30 following crimes, as well as all other charges against the child arising out of the same
31 incident, unless an order removing the proceeding to the court has been filed under §
32 4–202 of the Criminal Procedure Article:
33 (i) Abduction;
34 (ii) Kidnapping;
HOUSE BILL 459 5
14 (xii) Assault in the first degree under § 3–202 of the Criminal Law
15 Article;
23 (5) A child who previously has been convicted as an adult of a felony and is
24 subsequently alleged to have committed an act that would be a felony if committed by an
25 adult, unless an order removing the proceeding to the court has been filed under § 4–202 of
26 the Criminal Procedure Article; or
1 [(e)] (F) If the child is charged with two or more violations of the Maryland
2 Vehicle Law, another traffic law or ordinance, or the State Boat Act, allegedly arising out
3 of the same incident and which would result in the child being brought before both the court
4 and a court exercising criminal jurisdiction, the court has exclusive jurisdiction over all of
5 the charges.
6 (a) In addition to the jurisdiction specified in Subtitle 8 of this title, the court has
7 exclusive original jurisdiction over:
27 H.
THIRD DEGREE SEXUAL OFFENSE UNDER § 3–307 OF
28 THE CRIMINAL LAW ARTICLE; OR A CRIME OF VIOLENCE, AS DEFINED IN § 14–101
29 OF THE CRIMINAL LAW ARTICLE; OR
30 2.
ARISING OUT OF THE SAME INCIDENT AS AN ACT
31 LISTED IN ITEM 1 OF THIS ITEM;
HOUSE BILL 459 7
6 (b) The court has concurrent jurisdiction over proceedings against an adult for
7 the violation of § 3–8A–30 of this subtitle. However, the court may waive its jurisdiction
8 under this subsection upon its own motion or upon the motion of any party to the
9 proceeding, if charges against the adult arising from the same incident are pending in the
10 criminal court. Upon motion by either the State’s Attorney or the adult charged under §
11 3–8A–30 of this subtitle, the court shall waive its jurisdiction, and the adult shall be tried
12 in the criminal court according to the usual criminal procedure.
13 (c) The jurisdiction of the court is concurrent with that of the District Court in
14 any criminal case arising under the compulsory public school attendance laws of this State.
16 (1) A child at least 14 years old alleged to have done an act that, if
17 committed by an adult, would be a crime punishable by life imprisonment, as well as all
18 other charges against the child arising out of the same incident, unless an order removing
19 the proceeding to the court has been filed under § 4–202 of the Criminal Procedure Article;
20 (2) A child at least 16 years old alleged to have done an act in violation of
21 any provision of the Transportation Article or other traffic law or ordinance, except an act
22 that prescribes a penalty of incarceration;
23 (3) A child at least 16 years old alleged to have done an act in violation of
24 any provision of law, rule, or regulation governing the use or operation of a boat, except an
25 act that prescribes a penalty of incarceration;
26 (4) A child at least 16 years old alleged to have committed any of the
27 following crimes, as well as all other charges against the child arising out of the same
28 incident, unless an order removing the proceeding to the court has been filed under §
29 4–202 of the Criminal Procedure Article:
30 (i) Abduction;
31 (ii) Kidnapping;
13 (xii) Assault in the first degree under § 3–202 of the Criminal Law
14 Article;
22 (5) A child who previously has been convicted as an adult of a felony and is
23 subsequently alleged to have committed an act that would be a felony if committed by an
24 adult, unless an order removing the proceeding to the court has been filed under § 4–202 of
25 the Criminal Procedure Article; [or]
1 (7)
EXCEPT AS PROVIDED IN SUBSECTION (A)(1)(II) OF THIS SECTION,
2 A DELINQUENCY PROCEEDING AGAINST A CHILD WHO IS UNDER THE AGE OF 13
3 YEARS.
4 (e) If the child is charged with two or more violations of the Maryland Vehicle
5 Law, another traffic law or ordinance, or the State Boat Act, allegedly arising out of the
6 same incident and which would result in the child being brought before both the court and
7 a court exercising criminal jurisdiction, the court has exclusive jurisdiction over all of the
8 charges.
9 (F) A CHILD UNDER THE AGE OF 13 YEARS MAY NOT BE CHARGED WITH A
10 CRIME.
11 3–8A–10.
12 (c) (4) 1.
(i) [If] EXCEPT AS PROVIDED IN SUBSUBPARAGRAPH 2
13 OF THIS SUBPARAGRAPH, IF a complaint is filed that alleges the commission of an act
14 which would be a felony if committed by an adult or alleges a violation of § 4–203 or §
15 4–204 of the Criminal Law Article, and if the intake officer denies authorization to file a
16 petition or proposes an informal adjustment, the intake officer shall immediately:
26 B.
THE ACT DID NOT INVOLVE THE INTENTIONAL
27 CAUSING OF, OR ATTEMPT TO CAUSE, THE DEATH OF OR PHYSICAL INJURY TO
28 ANOTHER; AND
1 interest. After the preliminary review the State’s Attorney shall, within 30 days of the
2 receipt of the complaint by the State’s Attorney, unless the court extends the time:
16 (II)
THE INTAKE OFFICER SHALL PROPOSE AN INFORMAL
17 ADJUSTMENT OF THE MATTER IF:
20 A. ADJUDICATED DELINQUENT; OR
22 2. A.
THE COMPLAINT ALLEGES THAT THE CHILD
23 COMMITTED AN ACT THAT WOULD BE A MISDEMEANOR IF COMMITTED BY AN ADULT;
24 OR
12 (3) The intake officer may not proceed with an informal adjustment unless
13 [the victim,] the child[,] and the child’s parent or guardian consent to the informal
14 adjustment procedure.
15 (N) (1)
SUBJECT TO PARAGRAPH (2) OF THIS SUBSECTION, AT ANY TIME
16 BEFORE AN ADJUDICATORY HEARING, THE COURT MAY HOLD THE PROCEEDINGS IN
17 ABEYANCE FOR INFORMAL ADJUSTMENT IF CONSENTED TO BY:
19 (II) THE CHILD WHO IS THE SUBJECT OF THE PETITION AND THE
20 CHILD’S COUNSEL; AND
24 (II)
IF THE CHILD DOES NOT SUCCESSFULLY COMPLETE THE
25 INFORMAL ADJUSTMENT, THE COURT SHALL RESUME PROCEEDINGS UNDER THIS
26 SUBTITLE AGAINST THE CHILD.
27 3–8A–15.
28 (b) (1) [If] SUBJECT TO PARAGRAPHS (2) AND (3) OF THIS SUBSECTION,
29 IF a child is taken into custody under this subtitle, the child may be placed in detention or
30 community detention prior to a hearing if:
32 [(2)] (II) The child is likely to leave the jurisdiction of the court.
12 HOUSE BILL 459
1 (2)
(I) IN THIS PARAGRAPH, “RISK SCORING INSTRUMENT” MEANS
2 A TOOL, A METRIC, AN ALGORITHM, OR SOFTWARE THAT:
3 1.
IS USED TO ASSIST IN DETERMINING THE ELIGIBILITY
4 OF A CHILD FOR RELEASE BEFORE A HEARING; AND
5 2.
HAS BEEN INDEPENDENTLY VALIDATED AT LEAST
6 ONCE IN THE PRECEDING 5 YEARS.
13 (I)
THE ACT INVOLVED A HANDGUN AND WOULD BE A
14 VIOLATION UNDER THE CRIMINAL LAW ARTICLE OR THE PUBLIC SAFETY ARTICLE
15 IF COMMITTED BY AN ADULT; OR
16 (II)
THE CHILD HAS BEEN ADJUDICATED DELINQUENT AT
17 LEAST TWICE IN THE PRECEDING 12 MONTHS.
18 [(e) Notwithstanding any other provision of this section, detention may not be
19 continued beyond emergency detention for a child under the age of 12 years unless:
24 [(f)] (E) (1) Detention or community detention may not be continued beyond
25 emergency detention or community detention unless, upon an order of court after a hearing,
26 the court has found that one or more of the circumstances stated in subsection (b) of this
27 section exist.
1 (3) (i) If the court has not specifically prohibited community detention,
2 the Department of Juvenile Services may release the child from detention into community
3 detention and place the child in:
4 1. Shelter care; or
27 [(g)] (F) (1) Shelter care may only be continued beyond emergency shelter
28 care if the court has found that:
3 (2) (i) If the court continues shelter care on the basis of an alleged
4 emergency, the court shall assess whether the absence of efforts to prevent removal was
5 reasonable.
6 (ii) If the court finds that the absence of efforts to prevent removal
7 was not reasonable, the court shall make a written determination so stating.
11 [(h)] (G) A child alleged to be delinquent may not be detained in a jail or other
12 facility for the detention of adults.
13 [(i)] (H) (1) A child alleged to be in need of supervision may not be placed in:
4 (ii) The plan to be submitted to all parties to the petition and their
5 counsel.
6 [(j)] (I) The intake officer or the official who authorized detention, community
7 detention, or shelter care under this subtitle shall immediately give written notice of the
8 authorization for detention, community detention, or shelter care to the child’s parent,
9 guardian, or custodian and to the court. The notice shall be accompanied by a statement of
10 the reasons for taking the child into custody and placing him in detention, community
11 detention, or shelter care. This notice may be combined with the notice required under
12 subsection (d) of this section.
13 [(k)] (J) (1) If a child is alleged to have committed a delinquent act, the court
14 or a juvenile intake officer shall consider including, as a condition of releasing the child
15 pending an adjudicatory or disposition hearing, reasonable protections for the safety of the
16 alleged victim.
17 (2) If a victim has requested reasonable protections for safety, the court or
18 juvenile intake officer shall consider including, as a condition of releasing the child pending
19 an adjudicatory or disposition hearing, provisions regarding no contact with the alleged
20 victim or the alleged victim’s premises or place of employment.
21 [(l)] (K) If a child remains in a facility used for detention [for the specific act for
22 which the child has been adjudicated delinquent for more than 25 days after the court has
23 made a disposition on a petition under § 3–8A–19 of this subtitle], the Department of
24 Juvenile Services shall:
25 (1) [On the first available court date after the 25th day that the child
26 remains in a facility used for detention,] WITHIN 14 DAYS AFTER THE CHILD’S INITIAL
27 DETENTION, appear at a hearing before the court with the child to explain the reasons for
28 continued detention; and
29 (2) Every [25] 14 days thereafter, appear at another hearing before the
30 court with the child to explain the reasons for continued detention.
35 3–8A–19.
16 HOUSE BILL 459
1 (d) (1) In making a disposition on a petition under this subtitle, the court may:
27 B.
THE CHILD HAS BEEN ADJUDICATED DELINQUENT ON
28 A PRIOR OCCASION FOR AN OFFENSE INVOLVING A FIREARM; OR THE OFFENSE
29 INVOLVES A FIREARM; OR
16 [(iv)] (II) This paragraph may not be construed to prohibit the court
17 from committing the child to another appropriate agency.
18 3–8A–19.6.
21 (1)
AN ARREST OR A SUMMONS ISSUED BY A COMMISSIONER ON A
22 STATEMENT OF CHARGES FILED BY A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER;
23 (2)
A VIOLATION OF A CRIMINAL PROHIBITION, OR AN ACT THAT
24 WOULD BE A VIOLATION OF A CRIMINAL PROHIBITION IF COMMITTED BY AN ADULT,
25 OTHER THAN A MINOR TRAFFIC OFFENSE;
27 (4) ABSCONDING.
31 (A) (C) THE COURT MAY NOT PLACE A CHILD ON PROBATION FOR A TERM
32 EXCEEDING THAT PROVIDED IN THIS SECTION.
18 HOUSE BILL 459
27 (II)
EXCEPT AS PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH (3) OF THIS
28 SUBSECTION, IF THE PROBATION IS EXTENDED UNDER THIS PARAGRAPH, THE
29 TOTAL PERIOD OF THE PROBATION MAY NOT EXCEED 2 YEARS.
1 SUBSECTION IF, AFTER A HEARING, THE COURT FINDS BY CLEAR AND CONVINCING
2 EVIDENCE THAT:
7 (II)
IF THE PROBATION IS EXTENDED UNDER THIS PARAGRAPH,
8 THE TOTAL PERIOD OF PROBATION, INCLUDING EXTENSIONS UNDER PARAGRAPH
9 (2) OF THIS SUBSECTION, MAY NOT EXCEED 3 YEARS.
10 (D) (1)
EXCEPT AS PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH (2) OF THIS SUBSECTION, IF
11 THE MOST SERIOUS OFFENSE COMMITTED BY A CHILD WOULD BE A CRIME THAT, IF
12 COMMITTED BY AN ADULT, WOULD BE PUNISHABLE BY LIFE IMPRISONMENT, THE
13 COURT MAY PLACE THE CHILD ON PROBATION FOR A PERIOD NOT EXCEEDING 2
14 YEARS.
15 (2)
THE COURT MAY, AFTER A HEARING, EXTEND THE PROBATION BY
16 PERIODS NOT EXCEEDING 3 MONTHS IF THE COURT FINDS THAT:
27 3–8A–19.7.
30 (1)
AN ARREST OR A SUMMONS ISSUED BY A COMMISSIONER ON A
31 STATEMENT OF CHARGES FILED BY A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER;
20 HOUSE BILL 459
1 (2)
A VIOLATION OF A CRIMINAL PROHIBITION, OR AN ACT THAT
2 WOULD BE A VIOLATION OF A CRIMINAL PROHIBITION IF COMMITTED BY AN ADULT,
3 OTHER THAN A MINOR TRAFFIC OFFENSE;
7 (B)A CHILD MAY NOT BE PLACED IN A FACILITY USED FOR DETENTION FOR
8 A TECHNICAL VIOLATION.
9 3–8A–27.
25 A. Arrest; or
28 4–202.
HOUSE BILL 459 21
1 (b) Except as provided in subsection (c) of this section, a court exercising criminal
2 jurisdiction in a case involving a child may transfer the case to the juvenile court before
3 trial or before a plea is entered under Maryland Rule 4–242 if:
4 (1) the accused child was at least 14 but not 18 years of age when the
5 alleged crime was committed;
6 (2) the alleged crime is excluded from the jurisdiction of the juvenile court
7 under [§ 3–8A–03(d)(1), (4), or (5)] § 3–8A–03(E)(1), (4), OR (5) of the Courts Article; and
10 (c) The court may not transfer a case to the juvenile court under subsection (b) of
11 this section if:
12 (1) the child was convicted in an unrelated case excluded from the
13 jurisdiction of the juvenile court under [§ 3–8A–03(d)(1) or (4)] § 3–8A–03(E)(1) OR (4) of
14 the Courts Article; or
15 (2) the alleged crime is murder in the first degree and the accused child
16 was 16 or 17 years of age when the alleged crime was committed.
21 (i) the time for filing of a motion to transfer to juvenile court under
22 the Maryland Rules has expired and no such motion has been filed; or
24 4–202.2.
27 (1) as a result of trial or a plea entered under Maryland Rule 4–242, all
28 charges that excluded jurisdiction from the juvenile court under [§ 3–8A–03(d)(1) or (4)] §
29 3–8A–03(E)(1) OR (4) of the Courts Article do not result in a finding of guilty; and
1 (ii) the court did not transfer jurisdiction after a hearing under §
2 4–202(b) of this subtitle.
3 10–215.
4 (a) The following events are reportable events under this subtitle that must be
5 reported to the Central Repository in accordance with § 10–214 of this subtitle:
11 10–216.
17 Article – Education
18 7–303.
23 3–530.
13 (3)
THE NUMBER OF JUVENILES HOUSED IN EACH STATE
14 CORRECTIONAL FACILITY AND LOCAL CORRECTIONAL FACILITY; AND
25 9–3501.
28 9–3502.
24 HOUSE BILL 459
6 (2)
EVALUATE THE COST–EFFECTIVENESS OF PRACTICES
7 RESEARCHED BY THE COMMISSION;
8 (3)
IDENTIFY MEANS OF EVALUATING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF
9 PRACTICES RESEARCHED BY THE COMMISSION; AND
10 (4)
GIVING SPECIAL ATTENTION TO ORGANIZATIONS LOCATED IN OR
11 SERVING HISTORICALLY UNDERSERVED COMMUNITIES, IDENTIFY STRATEGIES TO
12 ENABLE COMMUNITY–BASED ORGANIZATIONS THAT PROVIDE SERVICES FOR
13 JUVENILES TO EVALUATE AND VALIDATE SERVICES AND PROGRAMMING PROVIDED
14 BY THOSE ORGANIZATIONS.
26 (2) plans for the inclusion of information and data relating to use of a risk
27 assessment tool in the Department of Juvenile Services’ Data Resource Guide;
28 (3) the use of community detention for juveniles in the care and custody of
29 the Department of Juvenile Services;
4 (6) access to mental health services for all juveniles served by the
5 Department of Juvenile Services;
6 (7) the feasibility of and any plans for providing quality, evidence–based
7 programming for juveniles detained in secure juvenile facilities, including educational
8 programming, structured weekend activities, and activities involving family members of
9 detained juveniles;
14 (10) plans to track and report data on the number of days juveniles ordered
15 to shelter care placements remain in secure juvenile facilities;
23 (14) standards for attorneys to access their clients within all juvenile
24 facilities in the State;
27 (16) plans to transition from the current slate of secure juvenile facilities to
28 ensure access to both nonresidential and residential facilities that use culturally
29 competent, evidence–based programming in all jurisdictions of the State.
32 (1) (i) develop a model policy for diversion of juveniles from the juvenile
33 justice system and criminal justice system;
HOUSE BILL 459 27
7 SECTION 4. AND BE IT FURTHER ENACTED, That this Act shall take effect June
8 1, 2022.
Approved:
________________________________________________________________________________
Governor.
________________________________________________________________________________
Speaker of the House of Delegates.
________________________________________________________________________________
President of the Senate.