Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Artikel 5 - Covid19
Artikel 5 - Covid19
https://www.emerald.com/insight/1750-6123.htm
Intention to
The role of information quality, buy food
trust and anxiety on intention to supplements
Farah Fahma
Department of Agroindustrial Technology, IPB University, Bogor, Indonesia
Dwi Suhartanto
Department of Business Administration, Politeknik Negeri Bandung,
Bandung, Indonesia
Retno Santi Sumardi
School of Business and Economics, Universiti Putra Malaysia,
Serdang, Malaysia, and
Mohamad Fazli Sabri
Faculty of Human Ecology, Universiti Putra Malaysia, Serdang, Malaysia
Abstract
Purpose – The purpose of this study is to analyze the factors affecting consumer`s intention to buy
food supplements during COVID-19 pandemic using the expanding theory of planned behavior model.
The variables of perceived information quality, trust and anxiety are integrated in the model of this
study.
Design/methodology/approach – A total of 553 valid questionnaire responses were collected via an
online survey in the epicenter of the pandemic in Indonesia, such as Jakarta and surrounding cities. To
evaluate the causal links between latent variables, structural equation modeling was adopted using LISREL
software. Before the research hypothesis had been tested, validity and reliability analysis was carried out to
make sure the measurement can be used.
Findings – The findings indicate that perceived information quality influences trust and anxiety, and then
both of them influence attitude toward food supplements. Moreover, the intentions to buy food supplements
are determined by the consumer`s attitude.
Research limitations/implications – This study assumes all consumers have similar access to
information because they are living in the greater Jakarta. Nevertheless, in fact, the access of information is
not similar between age groups and locations. Future research may wish to differentiate evaluations of a full-
information group from those of the limited-information groups.
Originality/value – This study provides a model of consumers` buying intentions toward food
supplement products in the time of a health crisis such as the COVID-19 pandemic as a novelty. The
International Journal of
implications of this study provide meaningful direction for marketing decisions and policy interventions in Pharmaceutical and Healthcare
developing food supplement industries. Marketing
Vol. 16 No. 3, 2022
pp. 429-447
Keywords Attitude, Indonesia, Pandemic, Structural equation model, Theory of planned behavior © Emerald Publishing Limited
1750-6123
Paper type Research paper DOI 10.1108/IJPHM-01-2021-0007
IJPHM 1. Introduction
16,3 The World Health Organization (WHO) declared the COVID-19 outbreak as a global
pandemic (World Health Organization, 2020). Within a short time, it had spread to countries
on all continents, disrupting people’s daily lives and having a severe impact on the world
economy (Foddai et al., 2020). Haines and Berney (2020) called this period of COVID-19
outbreak as an unusual time that is able to encourage stress that may lead to sadness,
430 anxiety and/or depression.
To respond to this unusual situation, consumers seem to change their consumption
behavior. Jung et al. (2016) conducted a study on the impact of an epidemic outbreak on
consumer expenditures in Korea. They found that an epidemic outbreak caused a
substantial disruption of consumer expenditures, especially in health-related products. In
Indonesia, after the government announced the first confirmed COVID-19 case, the purchase
amount of food supplements increased. As defined by the Food and Drug Supervisory
Agency of the Republic of Indonesia (2004), a food supplement is a product intended to
complete the nutritional needs of food. It contains one or more ingredients in the form of
vitamins, minerals, amino acids or other ingredients (derived from plants or non-plants) that
have nutritional value and or physiological effects in concentrated amounts. Within two
weeks since the COVID-19 outbreak was officially announced by the government, the level
of consumption of vitamin drinks increased by 37%, traditional herbals increased by 37%
and health products increased by 44% (Nielsen, 2020).
Before the pandemic, the habit of consuming food supplements was only carried out by a
part of the middle class, especially for those who are on a diet or educated middle-class
consumers who have a high awareness of healthy life. However, during a pandemic, such as
COVID-19, perceived health risk could significantly impact a person’s behavior (Jang et al.,
2020; Long and Kho, 2020). As this pandemic alters consumer behavior (Bonfanti et al.,
2021), the findings of past studies related to food consumption cannot be generalized into
current consumption behavior. Along with the incessant appeals from the government and
health experts to the public to increase their immunity by consuming more nutritious foods,
consumers who had never previously taken food supplements began to change their
behavior and start taking food supplements. The consumer’s behavioral change is
hypothesized because of the massive amount of information related to COVID-19 and
healthy life promotion by the government and other stakeholders to prevent consumers
from contracting COVID-19.
Several studies explained that during the COVID-19 outbreak pandemic, stress responses
by consumers increase help-seeking behaviors that may be disproportionate, overburdening
health-care facilities and diverting critical resources (Garfin et al., 2020; Gao et al., 2020). For
example, panic buying of essential consumer items such as masks, hand sanitizers and
vitamins in response to COVID-19 has led to global shortages. Proactive communication
encourages people to adopt protective behaviors, facilitates surveillance of the spread of
outbreaks, reduces people’s confusion and enables better use of resources, all of which are
necessary for effective response during a pandemic (World Health Organization, 2008). A
previous study reported that trust with formal information (from government and media)
about influenza was related to a greater reported understanding of A/H1N1 cause (Liao et al.,
2010).
During pandemic, the public depends on the media to convey accurate and up-to-date
information to make informed decisions regarding health protective behaviors. Some people
try to maintain their health by consuming food supplements recommended by health
experts or a professional doctor. However, previous research has demonstrated that some
other people place value on information obtained from personal connections rather than
advice obtained from health experts (Dobele and Lindgreen, 2011). Following such evidence, Intention to
it is imperative to further study the factors affecting consumer’s intentions toward food buy food
supplements and the role of information. Because of the changing market environment, it is
important to understand the behavior of consumers during a crisis as a foundation to
supplements
develop a marketing strategy in the food supplement industry.
The theory of planned behavior (TPB) proposed by Ajzen (1991) is one of the popular
theories for predicting consumer intention. However, the findings regarding the impact of
the antecedents from the TPB have been inconsistent and dependent on the specific research 431
context (Nguyen et al., 2019). Besides inconsistent results, the limited predictive validity of
the TPB became the main focus of criticism by researchers. For example, a study conducted
by McEachan et al. (2011) found that the ability of TPB to predict behavioral intention in the
context of health was only 19.3%. Meanwhile, Chen (2020) found that TPB could only
explain 47% of variation on the variable of consumer`s intention in the context of eco-
friendly food. Several studies have successfully combined new variables with the TPB to
investigate consumer intentions, such as Nystrand and Olsen (2020) who used TPB to
examine consumers` attitudes and intention in Norway. Meanwhile, Nguyen et al. (2019)
added the variable of self-perceptions to improve the TPB to predict consumer’s intentions.
However, no studies were found that examined the influences of perceived information
quality, trust and anxiety to advance the TPB model. Meanwhile, during a disaster, crisis or
unusual times, such variables seem to appear in individual buying decision-making.
In times of crisis, consumers will look for complete and accurate information that can be
used as a basis for developing attitude. In this case, the quality of information becomes
important because it is directly related to consumer trust in the information (Chesney et al.,
2017). On the other hand, information about outbreaks can also be a source of anxiety and
drive consumer panic (Haines and Berney, 2020). Unclear news often causes consumer
anxiety and this anxiety will in turn affect consumer attitudes (Kugbey et al., 2019).
Variations in information quality, trust and anxiety often appear in crisis situations. These
variables have been scantily analyzed in relation to intention. On the other hand, TPB
models that are considered well-established have limitations in predicting intention in the
times of crisis such as pandemics. Therefore, in the present study, it is important to examine
additional influential factors on consumers’ intention toward food supplements.
Accordingly, adding the variable of trust, anxiety and perceive information quality to the
TPB model should have a better prediction power in the context of a pandemic.
The purpose of this study is to analyze the factors affecting consumers’ intentions
toward food supplements during the COVID-19 pandemic using a modified TPB model by
inserting the variables of perceived information quality, trust and anxiety. Despite the
existence of massive research related to consumer’s intentions, its specific model related to
consumption at the time of a virus outbreak has not been extensively studied. Behavioral
patterns of consumer’s consumption during the outbreak are of course different from normal
conditions; thus, this study that explored the influential factors affecting consumer intention
toward food supplements during COVID-19 outbreak has novelty. Additionally, there is no
robust model to predict consumer behavior during unusual conditions such as pandemics.
Therefore, this study makes a specific contribution in modeling consumer intentions in
pandemic situations.
2. Literature review
2.1 Theory of planned behavior
TPB developed by Ajzen (1991) explains the determinants factors which influence an
individual’s conscious decision to perform a certain behavior. In this theory, behavioral
IJPHM intention at a particular time and place is hypothesized to be a function of attitudes,
16,3 subjective norms and perceived behavioral control. Ajzen (1991) defines intention as a
condition in which a person is consciously motivated to perform an action after
carefully considering the consequences of that action based on available information.
Meanwhile, attitude can be defined as the extent to which a person has a positive or
negative assessment of a particular behavior. Moreover, subjective norms can be
432 defined as a perceived social pressure to display certain behaviors (Ajzen, 1991;
McEachan et al., 2011). Regarding perceived behavioral control, researchers criticize the
conceptual clarity of perceived behavioral control (Raats et al., 1995; Terry and
O’Leary, 1995). Recent empirical research also noted that perceived behavioral control
has no substantial influence on intention (Liu et al., 2018; Nystrand and Olsen, 2020).
Perceived behavioral control measures how easy or difficult it is for consumers to take
specific actions. In the context of food supplements in Indonesia, this is not an issue
because consumers easily obtain food supplements in various forms. Therefore, in this
study, we do not put perceived behavioral control into the model.
TPB is one of the most prevalent behavioral theories in the study of consumer
behavior, and has been widely used in research related to consumer intentions toward
food- and health-related behavior (Nuttavuthisit and Thøgersen, 2017; Sniehotta et al.,
2014). However, past studies, such as Chen (2020), have criticized the TPB because it
fails to effectively consider other important variables. For instance, the theory has been
criticized for its limited focus on rational reasoning, excluding unconscious effects on
behavior (Sheeran et al., 2013) and the role of emotions beyond anticipated affective
outcomes (Conner et al., 2013). In a time of crisis, some scarce information on previous
epidemic outbreaks causes public anxiety. According to Hwang et al. (2020), perceived
information is linked to social anxiety. Meanwhile, anxiety will encourage people to
protect themselves. In this case, the anxiety factor, together with consumers’ trust, can
be considered as predictors of attitude to improve the predictive power of the TPB
model in a pandemic.
H4. Consumer’s anxiety to their health condition has a positive influence on attitudes
toward food supplement.
H5. Consumer’s attitude toward food supplement has a positive influence on intention
to buy food supplements.
435
Figure 1.
Extended TPB model
in the time of
pandemic
3. Research methods
3.1 Data collection
The empirical study was carried out on the basis of a questionnaire during March to April
2020. The questionnaire was distributed online to respondents who stay in Greater Jakarta.
The location was chosen because Jakarta is the epicenter of the COVID-19 outbreak in
Indonesia. The sample in this research has been chosen based on purposive sampling
techniques because of the impossibility of implementing random sampling during lockdown
in the locus of study. The random sampling technique could not be applied in this study
because we do not have a sampling frame accurately. We also have a technical problem
using random sampling because of lockdown in Jakarta as an epicenter of the COVID-19
pandemic in Indonesia. In addition, purposive sampling was chosen because this study
requires specific criteria so that the samples taken follow the research objectives, namely,
being able to solve research problems and provide a representative sample. Many studies
(Suhartanto et al., 2021; Nguyen et al., 2019; Pandey et al., 2019) also use purposive sampling
to analyze consumer’s purchasing intentions. Therefore, in this context, the use of purposive
sampling is the most appropriate. The respondent criteria in this study were those who had
bought food supplements in the past two weeks. The reason is that in the past two weeks, it
was still possible for respondents to remember their experience in buying food supplements.
We collected 590 questionnaires from Greater Jakarta consumers. After eliminating the
invalid questionnaires because of incomplete responses, 553 valid data were finally used to
test the hypothesis.
3.2 Measurement
To measure latent variables, this study used a number of observed variables. Questionnaire
items proposed in previous research and theories have been adopted and adapted to the
research context of the present study. Five domain experts from the university are involved
in determining the content validity. Consultation to develop the measurement of each
construct involved five participants, namely, two experts from the field of consumer
behavior, one expert from the field of human ecology, one public health expert and an expert
from communication and society development studies. Regarding construct validity, we did
convergent validity analysis. To test the reliability of the instrument, we calculated
IJPHM Cronbach’s alpha. The questionnaire includes two parts. The first part contains indicator
16,3 items from each construct, and the second part contains several questions related to
respondents’ demographic information. Respondents scored items using a five-point Likert
scale ranging from 1 (strongly disagree) to 5 (strongly agree). Table 1 explains each
construct and measurement item used in this study compared to previous literature.
Perceived Always receive information related to COVID-19 Boon-itt (2019), Joe ilsever (2007);
information outbreak from mainstream media Sukrat et al. (2015)
Well informed how government handles this
health crisis from government media releases
Following health information related to COVID-19
outbreak prevention from doctors and health
experts
Trust to health Trust to healthy tips advised by doctors and Boon-itt (2019), Hall et al. (2001);
information health experts in the media Sukrat et al. (2015)
Believe that COVID-19 can be prevented by a
healthy body as informed by government, doctors
and health experts
Believe the benefits of healthy food advised by
doctors and health experts
Consumer anxiety Worry about my health as the COVID-19 issue Chiou and Wan (2006); Özhan
develops et al. (2019)
News of the spread of COVID-19 made me feel
uneasy
The number of sick and dying because of COVID-
19 makes me worry
Subjective norm My family and friends think I should take food Ashraf et al. (2019); Nguyen et al.
supplements (2019), Pandey et al. (2019); Rezai
Doctors and health experts think I should et al. (2017)
consume food supplement
The media that I follow makes me conclude
consuming food supplements is important
Attitude to food Believe that taking food supplements will Rezai et al. (2017); Tudoran et al.
supplement maintain stamina (2009); Nystrand and Olsen (2020)
Believe that consuming food supplements is a
good preventive action
Believe that taking food supplements will reduce
the risk of contracting the disease
Intention to buy I want to buy food supplements to increase Jahn et al. (2019); Nystrand and
food supplement stamina Olsen (2020)
I will make an effort to buy food supplement in
Table 1. the near future
Construct and I intend to buy food supplements because of
measurement believing with its benefits
SEM analysis is appropriate. Hair et al. (2017) calculated the average variance extracted Intention to
(AVE) and composite reliability (CR) of latent variables to test the links between observable buy food
and latent variables. The good values of AVE and CR are 0.5 and 0.7 above, individually. R2
is called the coefficient of determination which describes the proportion of total variation
supplements
revealed by the research model. The R2 values for each endogenous construct in the models
show that the antecedent constructs explain the percent variance in that endogenous
construct (Kartika et al., 2020; Nurlaela et al., 2019). This research implemented the
assessment measures in terms of R2 to discover whether the extended TPB model 437
demonstrates better predictive power to explain the variation in the consumer’s intention to
buy food supplements than the original TPB models.
4. Results
4.1 Respondent profile
The characteristics of the sample are as follows from the 553 respondents. The number of
female consumers is 336 (60.8%), and male consumers are 217(39.2%). The respondents’ age
and education demographics are as follows: 112 (20.3%) participants are less than 30 years
old, 187 (33.8%) participants are between 30s and 40s; a total of 174 (31.5%) participants are
between 41s and 50s. A total of 84 (14.4%) participants are over 50s. In terms of education
level, 41 (7.6%) respondents have senior high school certificates, and 263 (47.6%)
respondents hold bachelor degrees and 248 (44.8%) respondents have postgraduate degrees.
Regarding the monthly income, 133 (24.1%) respondents earn less than IDR 5m monthly,
138 (24.9%) respondents receive between IDR 5m and IDR 10m monthly and 92 (16.6%)
respondents have over IDR 20m rupiah monthly. Regarding the consumption pattern of
food supplements, a majority of respondents (41.4%) consume food supplements every day
during the COVID-19 pandemic. Meanwhile, as many as 32.2% of respondents consume
food supplements when they feel unhealthy. To keep their body healthy, 75.8% of
respondents consumed multivitamins, and 20.2% of respondents prefer to consume herbals.
Based on interviews conducted with consumer representatives, food supplement
marketing practitioners and marketing experts, information was obtained that before the
COVID-19 pandemic, consumers considered food supplements to provide hope for a healthy
lifestyle. However, consumers also do not fully believe in the benefits of food supplements.
Further, most people do not really care about food supplements because they think of food
supplements only as other food that is not necessarily needed by the body. Thus, before the
pandemic, the marketing of food supplement products was still constrained by the
controversial perception of the benefits of these food supplements. While the price of food
supplements is considered quite expensive by some consumers, it is not a priority to be
consumed.
During the COVID-19 outbreak, health experts and the government appealed to the
public to increase their immunity by consuming nutritious food. Health experts and the
government provide information regularly regarding the spread of COVID-19 and provide
direction to the public on what should people do during the pandemic. One effort to prevent
the infection of COVID-19 suggested by health experts is to increase and maintain body
immunity. There have been various efforts to ward off this virus, one of which was taking
food supplements to enhance immunity (Rahayu et al., 2020).
According to Kim et al. (2016), in the context of a pandemic, the information provided by
health experts could create people trust. Meanwhile, lessons from the SARS epidemic
showed that knowledge toward infectious diseases was significantly related to a level of
anxiety (Chan et al., 2007). Information, trust and anxiety toward COVID-19 play major roles
in assessing the willingness of a public to adopt behavioral change during the pandemic.
IJPHM This is why COVID-19 pandemic has led to an increased demand for food supplements
16,3 because people trust the information that suggests consuming more vitamins than ever to
improve their body immunity.
Path
Hypotheses coefficient t-values p-value Decision
Corresponding author
Mukhamad Najib can be contacted at: najib@apps.ipb.ac.id
For instructions on how to order reprints of this article, please visit our website:
www.emeraldgrouppublishing.com/licensing/reprints.htm
Or contact us for further details: permissions@emeraldinsight.com