AN IN VITRO CULTURE PROTOCOL, ANALYSIS OF SAPONIN AND
BIOASSAY OF BIOLOGICAL ACTIVITY OF VERBASCUM THAPSUS L.,
A MEDICINAL PLANT
” 123492
ARZU UCAR TURKER
THESIS SUBMITTED TO
THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF NATURAL AND APPLIED SCIENCES
OF
THE ABANT IZZET BAYSAL UNIVERSITY
IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF
THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF
DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY
IN
THE DEPARTMENT OF BIOLOGY
voxsexOcRerion KOROLY %
Ce NARDSYON werkt a!
JUNE 2002Approval of the Graduate School of Natural Sciences
Prof. Dr. Nihat CELEBI
Director
| certify that this dissertation satisfies all the requirements for the degree
of Doctor of Philosophy.
Prof. Dr. M.Tekin BABAG >
Head of Department
This is to certify that we have read this dissertation and that in our
opinion it is fully adequate, in scope and quality, as a dissertation for the degree
of Doctor of Philosophy.
= Cuan Wo
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Ekrem GUREL
Supervisor
Examining Committee Members
4. Prof. Dr. Ismail TURKAN
2. Prof. Dr. M.Tekin BABAG
3. Assoc. Prof. Dr. Sebahattin OZCAN
4. Assoc. Prof. Dr. Ekrem GUREL
5. Assist. Prof. Emel USLUABSTRACT
AN IN VITRO CULTURE PROTOCOL, ANALYSIS OF SAPONIN AND
BIOASSAY OF BIOLOGICAL ACTIVITY OF VERBASCUM THAPSUS L.,
A MEDICINAL PLANT
Turker Ucar, Arzu
Ph.D., Department of Biology
Supervisor: Assoc. Prof. Dr. Ekrem Garel
June 2002, 127 pages
Verbascum thapsus L. (common mullein) is a medicinal plant that has
been used to treat pulmonary problems, inflammatory diseases, asthma,
spasmodic coughs, diarrhea and migraine headaches. A reliable in vitro
culture protocol for common mullein was established. Explants (leaf discs,
petioles and roots) were cultured on Murashige and Skoog minimal organics
(MSMO) medium with benzyladenine (BA) or kinetin (KIN). Best shoot
proliferation was obtained from leaf discs and petiole explants with 3 mg/l
BA. Leaf discs were cultured on MSMO medium with 3 mg/ BA in
combination with naphthalene acetic acid ~(NAA) or 2,4-
dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D). More shoot development was obtained
with 3 mg/l BA and 1 mg/l NAA. Shoots were transferred to rooting media
containing different levels of NAA or 2,4-D. Majority of shoots rooted on
medium with 1 mg/l NAA.
2c. VUMSEROCHETIN KORY
‘DOKUMANTASYONAn extraction and analytical protocol for saponins was established for
Verbascum thapsus L. Four different kinds of plant sample were analyzed
Commercially obtained leaves had a higher concentration of saponin (0.215
mg/g tissue) than jin vitro cultured and field-grown leaves (0.081 and 0.198
mg/g tissue, respectively) or the capsule samples (0.016 mg/g tissue)
Biological activities of mullein extracts and commercial mullein
products were assessed using selected bench-top bioassays. Bioassays
included antibacterial, antitumor, and two toxicity assays (i.e., brine shrimp
and radish seed bioassay). In general, aqueous extracts were the most
effective and showed antibacterial activity against K. pneumoniae and S.
aureus. Commercial products and purified saponins showed little or no
antibacterial activity. Agrobacterium tumefaciens-induced tumors in potato
tissue were inhibited by all mullein extracts, commercial products and
purified saponins. Methanolic extracts of in vitro-grown leaves and
commercially obtained leaves inhibited tumor formation better than the other
extracts. Results of brine shrimp bioassay showed that extracts of mullein
were toxic at higher doses (around 1,000 mg/l). Among aqueous extractions,
decoctions had more toxicity (LCso < 1,000 mg/l) than the infusion extracts
In radish seed bioassay, at high doses (10,000 mg/l, all extracts reduced the
root length. However, at 1,000 mg/l, extracts did not affect the root length as
much. Seed germination was also inhibited by mullein extracts at 7,500
mg/l. Low doses (1,000 mg/l) affected germination, but not as much ashigher doses. Ethanolic extracts inhibited seed germination more than other
types of extracts
Keywords: Verbascum thapsus L., common mullein, in vitro culture, HPLC,
saponin, bioassay, antibacterial, antitumor, toxic, brine shrimp bioassay,
radish seed bioassay.OZET
TIBBI BIR BITKi OLAN VERBASCUM THAPSUS L.’UN iN VITRO KULTUR
PROTOKOLU, SAPONIN ANALIiZi VE BIYOLOJIK AKTIVITESININ
DEGERLENDIRILMESi
Turker Ugar, Arzu
Ph.D., Biyoloji Bélima
Tez Danismant: Dog. Dr. Ekrem Girrel
Haziran 2002, 127 Sayfa
Verbascum thapsus L. (sigir kuyrugu) akciger problemleri, iitihablr
hastaliklar, astim, oksiruk, ishal ve migren agnilarinda kullanilan tibbi bir bitkidir.
V. thapsus L. igin givenilir bir in vitro cogaltim protokold _gelistirilmistir
Eksplantlar (yaprak diskleri, petiyoller ve kékler) benziladenin (BA) veya
kinetinin (KIN) bulundugu Murashige ve Skoog minimal organik (MSMO) ortami
igerisinde kulture alinmisiardir. Yaprak diskleri ve petiyollerden en iyi govde
olusumu 3 mg/l BA igeren ortamlarda elde edilmistir. Ayrica yaprak diskleri 3
mg/l BA’nin naftelen asetik asit (NAA) veya 2,4-diklorofenoksi asetik asit (2,4-D)
ile kombinasyonunu igeren ortamlarda kiltire alinmig ve en fazla govde
olusumu 3 mg/l BA ve 1 mg/l NAA kombinasyonunda elde edilmistir. Govdeler
vifarkli duzeylerde NAA veya 2,4-D igeren kéklendirme ortamlarina gecirilmistir.
En fazla kok olugumu 1 mg/l NAA igeren ortamda gézlenmistir.
V. thapsus L. bitkisinde bulunan saponinler igin bir ekstraksiyon ve analiz
metodu gelistiriimistir. Dért gesit bitki Srnegi analiz edilmistir. Sifal bitki olarak
satilan yapraklardan tespit edilen saponin miktari (0.215 mg/g doku) in vitro
kultura yapilmig ve arazide yetismig bitkinin yapraklarindan (0.081 ve 0.198
mg/g doku) veya kapsiillerde (0.016 mg/g doku) bulunan miktardan daha fazla
olmustur.
Laboratuvarda elde edilen sigir kuyrugu ekstraktinin ve ticari olarak
satilan bu bitkinin drinlerinin biyolojik aktiviteleri_gesitli_biyolojik testler
kullanilarak degerlendirilmistir.Antibakteriyal, antitumor ve iki farkli toksisite
testi (brine shrimp ve turp tohumu biyolojik testleri). Genel olarak su ile
hazirlanmis ekstraklar daha etkili olmug ve K. pneumoniae and S. aureus’a
karsi_ antibakteriyal etki géstermislerdir. Bitkinin ticari Urunleri ve diger test
edilen saponinler bu bakterilere kari cok az antibakteriyal etki gostermisler
veya hig géstermemislerdir. Butan sigir kuyrugu ekstraklan, ticari Urinleri ve
test edilen saponinler patates dokusunda Agrobacterium tumefaciens tarafindan
olusturulan timérleri inhibe etmistir. In vitro yetistirilmig ve satin alinmis
yapraklarin metanol ile yapilan ekstraksiyonu tumdr olugumunu diger metanolik,
etanolik ve suyla yapilan ekstraklardan daha fazia inhibe etmistir. Brine shrimp
vilbiyolojik testinin sonuglan sigir kuyrugu ekstraklarinin yuksek doziarda (1,000
mg/l civarinda) toksik oldugunu géstermistir. Su ile yapilan ekstraklar arasinda,
kaynatilarak hazirlanan ekstrakin (LCso < 1,000 mg/l) kaynamig suya batinip
demlenme ile hazirlanan ekstrakta oranla cok daha fazla toksik oldugu
gézlenmistir. Turp tohumu biyolojik testinde yuksek dozlarda (10,000 mgjl)
botiin ekstraklar turp kok uzunlugunu azaltmasina ragmen, dsik dozlarda
(1,000 mg/l) ekstraklar kdk olusumunu ok fazla etkilememistir. 7,500 mg/l
dozunda turp tohumu gimlenmesi bittun ekstraklar tarafindan inhibe edilmistir.
Disk dozlar (1,000 mg/l) cimlenmeyi azaltmistir fakat bu yUksek doziardaki
kadar degildir. Etanolik ekstraklar tohum gimlenmesini diger ekstraklardan daha
fazla inhibe etmistir.
Anahtar Kelimeler: Verbascum thapsus L., sigir kuyrugu, in vitro kultir, HPLC,
saponin, biyolojik test, antibakteriyal, antitlimér, toksik, brine shrimp biyolojik
testi, turp tohumu biyolojik testi
viiiDEDICATION
| dedicate this dissertation to my husband, Hakan Turker; my
daughter, Damla Nur Tirker; my mother and father, Nurhayat and Necati
Ucar; and my mother-in-law, Arife Tirker for their love and encouragement.ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
| wish to acknowledge the indispensable assistance afforded me by so
many people throughout my life and this experience. | would like to express my
appreciation and gratitude to my supervisor Dr. Ekrem Gurel for his guidance,
support, patience and encouragement. | would like to thank to Dr. N. Dwight
Camper, with my deepest appreciation, for giving me the opportunity to work as.
a visitor scientist under his guidance and his help and support during my time at
Clemson University in USA. | would like to thank my committee members Dr.
ismail Turkan of Ege University, Dr. Sebahattin Ozcan of Ankara University and,
Dr. M. Tekin Babag and Dr. Emel Uslu of Abant Izzet Baysal University for their
__ advice and review of this manuscript. Thanks are due to Dr. Melissa B. Riley for
her valuable advice during the course of this work. | am grateful to Dr. Ihsan
Gali, Faculty of Pharmacy, Hacettepe University, Turkey for his kind gift of
ilwensisaponin A and other saponins used as standard. | would like to express
my gratitude to the entire Plant Pathology and Physiology faculty, staff, and
student body for making my work at Clemson University very enjoyable and
beneficial. Appreciation is due to all members of Department of Biology, Abant
izzet Baysal University in Turkey.
This research would not be completed without reference to my fellow
grad students in Dr. Camper's lab. | am grateful to my lab-mate, Dr. TharathornBoonkaew without whose assistance and conversation in the lab would have
made this work unbearable. She has contributed so much work and time to this
research. She was a great friend, thank you very much for making me smile.
Thanks goes for the assistance | have received from my other lab-mates; Karen
Carlson Hall, Dr. Aranya T. Pimmongkol, Joe-Ann Helen McCoy, David Hooper
and Pamela Cooker. How nice to be in a place where ideas and frustrations
could be shared. My special thanks go to my wonderful husband, Hakan
Turker. His love, patience, support, and help enabled me to achieve this goal. |
also thank to my daughter, Damla Nur for giving me a good mood with her
existence during this work. My appreciation is extended to my mother, my
father and my mother-in-law for their love, patience, encouragement and help
for the completion of this research. | would also like to thank my friend Selma
Merdun and Filiz Dik for sharing the stressful moments with me and for helping
me whenever I needed. Finally, | apologize to those not mentioned-they are,
however, not forgotten
xiTABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
TITLE PAGE ..... i
ABSTRACT ii
OzET vi
DEDICATION... ix
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS .........0..000000000+ x
TABLE OF CONTENTS....scscssssaisieininctittttiiineneienenenenen Xl
LIST OF TABLES... xv
LIST OF FIGURES. ........... xviii
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS .....cccssssstsinstssntntintintinssieieetentea xxi
CHAPTERS,
4, INTRODUCTION AND LITERATURE REVIEW... 1
1.1. Introduction 41
1.2. Literature Review 6
1.21. BOtany wscssssnieiniatntenentetetnieeenes 6
1.2.2. Habitat...... seeeneteneeeeneneee 9
1.2.3. Biology and ecology... seitititatnenenenene 10
1.2.4. Medicinal or historical use... oscteneunene 14
1.2.5. In vitro culture of V. thapsus L. and of related
species . 18
xiiTable of Contents (Continued)
Page
1.2.6. Active ingredients of V. thapsus L. 20
1.2.7. Saponins of Verbascum species, extraction and
analysis........... 24
1.2.8. BIOASSAYS... ecccecccteeseeseenstene ceceeeteeeineee 24
2. IN VITRO CULTURE OF COMMON MULLEIN
(VERBASCUM THAPSUS L.) . 27
2.1. Introduction .....-.e-eesseeseee . - cose a 27
2.2. Materials and Methods .. fn... a... sone 29
2.3. Results and Discussion 33
3. HIGH-PERFORMANCE LIQUID
CHROMATOGRAPHIC DETERMINATION OF A.
SAPONIN FROM VERBASCUM THAPSUS L. ee a 43
3.1. IMtrOdUCtiOn .....ccceeesssesstesereneseeetene sevens 43
3.2. Materials and Methods 45
3.2.1. Plant material . see wee 45
3.2.2. Sample preparation . . 46
3.2.3. HPLC analysis . see ceceeeeneeseeeee see 49
3.3, Results and Discussion sestennstusetesssteenstinstenseeisseesnssens 52
4, BIOLOGICAL ACTIVITY OF COMMON MULLEIN 58
4.1. Introduction ... 58
4.2. Materials and Methods........... - 62
4.2.1, Plant material and extraction ........cccceeseenseenetee 62
4.2.2. Antibacterial assay.......--cesccseeeee sess 64
xiii
‘tc YOKSEKOCRETIM KUROLU
DOKUMANTASYONTable of Contents (Continued)
Page
4.2.3. ANtiMUMOF ASSAY... .cacscsssctesstestnsteeentee . 65
4.2.4. Brine shrimp bioassay.......... secs 67
4.2.5. Radish seed bioassay.......... seseeteee 70
4.3. Results and Discussion . 71
5. CONCLUSIONS ....... oes essessseeeeeeeee 97
REFERENCES...
APPENDICES ....c.:sccsssesssestensecsenes 119
A. Zone diameter interpretive chart used in antimicrobial
assay — aa . 120
B. Bacteria used in antibacterial assay and their representative
diseases a. aa oe . 124
C. Antibacterial activity against Agrobacterium tumefaciens... 124
CURRICULUM VITAE .....
xivTable
24
2.2
2.3
3.4
3.2
3.3
44
LIST OF TABLES
Page
Shoot formation from leaf discs, petiole and root segment explants
from in vitro grown seedlings of common MUIlEIN.....-sccseweeenenn 34
Shoot development from leaf discs from greenhouse-grown plants
incubated on media containing combinations of BA with NAA or
2,4 Du...
Effects of NAA and 2,4-D on root formation from shoots after 5
WeeKS INCUBATION... cesses eesseecseeeseseseesseesneenseeenecenee see 441
HPLC gradient solvent system. Composition: A, acetonitrile with
0.1% orthophosphoric acid; B, water with 0.1% orthophosphoric
acid .... 49
Retention times of digitoxin, ilwensisaponin A and saponin-1 in
leaves (field-grown, in vitro cultured and commercially obtained)
and capsules (from field-grown plants) of V. thapsus L. 55
Content of saponin-1 in leaves (field-grown, in vitro cultured and
commercially obtained) and capsules (from field-grown plants) of
V. thapsUs L. .eecsesessecsesee 55
Designation of extracts and different saponins used in bioassays
and their extraction procedures econectinistitistisietetsieee 62List of Tables (Continued)
Table
4.2
4.3
44
45
46
47
48
Page
Antibacterial activity of mullein extracts, selected saponins and
reference antibiotics. Data presented as zone of inhibition of
bacterial growth in mm. ....... 71
Mean number of tumors observed with mullein extracts, selected
saponins, and controls (water and camptothecin) ....... 76
LCs0 (lethal concentration for 50% mortality after 24 hr exposure)
values for mullein extracts, different saponins and MS-222 (a
Positive COMMON) .....sscssrstcsesteststetse 80
Effects of water (control), various Mullein extracts and commercial
products on radish seediing root elongation (at 10,000 mg/l)... 83
Effects of water (control), various mullein extracts, commercial
products and different saponins on radish seedling root elongation
(at 1,000 mg/l)
Effects of different saponins on radish seedling root elongation at
100 MgM..sscrecessessteseersessese 87
Effects of mullein extracts, commercial products and control
(water) on radish seed germination (at 7,500 mg/l). 89List of Tables (Continued)
Table Page
4.9 Effects of mullein extracts, commercial products, control (water)
and different saponins on radish seed germination (at 1,000 mg/l) 90
4.10 Effects of different saponins on radish seed germination at 100
mgfl.. 93
A.1___ Interpretation of inhibition zones of antibiotics used in antimicrobial
assay for Kirby-Bauer antibiotic susceptibility testing (Atlas, 1988)...... 120
B.1 Bacteria used in antibacterial assay and their representative
GiSCASES 0... esseseeseen 121
xviiFigure
11
12
13
21
2.2a
2.2b
2.2¢
2.2d
2.2e
2.2f
3.1
3.2
3.3
3.4
LIST OF FIGURES.
Common mullein plants ....:cieucusen
Leaf and flower morphology of V. thapSUs L s.r:
Commercial mullein products
Protocol for in vitro culture of Verbascum thapsus L. (common
mullein)
Shoot formation from petiole explant with 3 mg/l BA
Shoot formation from root segment explant with 3 mg/l BA ........
Shoot formation from leaf disc with 3 mg/l BA + 1 mg/l NAA.............2.
Root formation from shoots after 5 weeks with 1 mg/l NAA.
Regenerated plants after 3 weeks in Magenta containers ......
Regenerated plants transferred to pots 3 weeks later.
Chemical structure of digitoxin used as an internal standard ......
Chemical structure of ilwensisaponin A used as an external
standard (Calis et al., 1991)
Standard curve of external standard ilwensisaponin A.
Standard curve of internal standard digitoxin ...........
xviii
32
37
37
38
38
39
39
47
48
51
51List of Figures (Continued)
Figure
3.5
41
42
43
44
45
HPLC profiles: (1) of digitoxin and ilwensisaponin A; (2) of field-
grown leaves; (3) of in vitro cultured leaves; (4) of commercially
obtained leaves; (5) of capsules from field-grown plants.......
Brine shrimp egg (right) and mature nauplii (left) used in the
experiment
Antibacterial activity of mullein extracts, commercial products,
different saponins and controls [water, carbenicillin (CB-100)
and erithromycin (E-15)] against K. pneumonia...
Antibacterial activity of mullein extracts, commercial products,
different saponins and controls [water, chloramphenicol (C-30)
and erithromycin (E-15)] against S. aUreUS «ees
Inoculated petri dishes with K. pneumonia shows an inhibition
zone with CL-Dec water extraction (decoction) from commercial
leaves (right) and quality control, erithromycin (E-15) (left)...
Inoculated petri dishes with S. aureus shows an inhibition zone
with FL-Dec (below right), IL-Dec and CL-Dec (below left)
[water extraction (decoction) from field, in vitro cultured and
commercial leaves] and quality controls, chloramphenicol (C-
30) (above left) and erithromycin (E-15) (above right) .......:sceeee.
Page
xix
53
69
73
74
75
75List of Figures (Continued)
Figure Page
4.6 Mean number of tumors observed with mullein extracts,
commercial products, different saponins, and controls (water
and camptothecin)... 78
4.7 Tumors produced by Agrobacterium tumefaciens with distilled
water (above) and with IL-MeOH (methanolic extract from in
vitro cultured leaves) (below). 79
4.8 LCs0 (lethal concentration for 50% mortality after 24 hr
exposure) values for mullein extracts, commercial products,
different saponins and MS-222 (a positive COntPOl) accesses BZ
4.9 Effects of mullein extracts (10,000 mg/l - above; 1,000 mg/l -
below) on radish seediing root length.. 86
4.10 Radish seedling root elongation with CL-EtOH (ethanolic
extraction from commercial leaves) (left) and water (right) at
10,000 mg/l after 3 days...
4.11. Effects of mullein extracts (7,500 mg/l — above;1,000 mg/l -
below) and control (water) on radish seed germination as a
function of incubation time (days) 92
4.12 Radish seed germination with water (left) and CL-EtOH
(ethanolic extraction from commercial leaves) (right) at 7,500
mgfl after 1 day... ccc 95
xxAbbreviations
2,4-D
AE-Com
ANOVA
BA
Cre
c-30
CB-100
CF-30
CHCls
CL-Dec
CL-EtOH
CL-MeOH
Dccc.
E15
EtOH
FC-MeOH
FDA
FL-Dec
FL-EtOH
FL-Inf
FL-MeOH
FO-Com
G25
GA3
6c
Gly
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
Full Name
2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid
Commercial mullein extract in alcohol
Analysis of variance
Benzyladenine
Octadecyl
Chloramphenicol (30 4g)
Carbenicillin (100 ug)
Cephalothin (30 yg)
Chloroform
Water extract-decoction from commercially obtained leaves
Ethanolic extract from commercially obtained leaves
Methanolic extract from commercially obtained leaves
Droplet counter current chromatography
Erythromycin (15 yg)
Ethanol
Methanolic extract from field capsules
Food and Drug Administration
Water extract-decoction from field leaves
Ethanolic extract from field leaves
Water extract-infusion from field leaves
Methanolic extract from field leaves
Commercial mullein flower oil
Sulfisoxazole (2.0 mg)
Giberellic acid
Gas chromatography
Glycyrrhizic acid (Glycyrrhizin)
xxi
Teri Ruut
YON RnAbbreviations
HPLC
IL-Dec
IL-EtOH
IL-MeOH
LCs0
MeOH
MS-222
MSMO
M-H
NAA
NCCLS.
PBS
Sap IL
Sap P
Sap Q
SC-Com
SPE
TB-Com
TLC
TSA
TSB
UV-Vis
YEM
Full Name
High pressure liquid chromatography
Water extract-decoction from in vitro cultured leaves
Ethanolic extract from in vitro cultured leaves
Methanolic extract from in vitro cultured leaves
Lethal concentration for 50% mortality after 24 hr exposure
Methanol
Tricaine methane sulfonate
Murashige and Skoog Minimal Organic
Mueller-Hinton
Naphthalene acetic acid
National Committee for Clinical Laboratory Standards
Phosphate buffered saline
llwensisaponin A from Scrophularia ilwensi C. Koch
Pure saponin
Saponin from Ouillaja bark
Commercial mullein swallow capsule
Solid phase extraction
Commercial mullein tea bag
Thin layer chromatography
Tryptic soy agar
Tryptic soy broth
Ultraviolet visible
Yeast extract media
xxiiCHAPTER ONE
Introduction and Literature Review
4.1. Introduction
Verbascum thapsus L. (common mullein), a biennial plant of
Scrophulariaceae family, produces a low vegetative rosette in the first year
which flowers with a stout stem (0.3-2.0 m tall) in the next growing season
(Gross and Werner, 1978) (Figure 1.1 and 1.2). Common mullein is native to
Europe and Asia (Semenza et al., 1978) and was probably introduced into North
America several times as a medicinal herb. Mullein leaves and flowers have
expectorant and demulcent properties which are used to treat respiratory
problems such as bronchitis, dry coughs, whooping cough, tuberculosis,
asthma, and hoarseness (Grieve, 1981; Mabey, 1988; Tyler, 1993; 1994). The
plant is mildly diuretic and has a soothing and anti-inflammatory effect on the
urinary tract, and also acts as a mild sedative (Mabey, 1988). Mucilaginous
constituents are primarily responsible for the soothing actions on mucous
membranes, and the saponins are responsible for the expectorant actions’ of
mullein (Tyler, 1993). Saponins also have anti-inflammatory, analgesic and
cytotoxic/anti-tumour activities (Marston and Hostettmann, 1991).
Although common mullein has been used medicinally since ancient
times, the popularity of this medicinal plant has been increasing commercially
for the last few years. Today, dried leaves and flowers, swallow capsules,Figure 1.1 Common mullein plants.Figure 1.2 Leaf and flower morphology of V. thapsus L.alcoholic extracts, and flower oil of this plant can easily be found in health stores
in United States (Figure 1.3). Native populations of common mullein are easily
found in pastures, abandoned fields and along roadsides, but they are
threatened by chemical (herbicides) and biological (insects and pathogens)
controls. Sustainable organic agriculture allows for conscientious and chemical-
free planting, cultivating and processing. Organic products are grown in
harmony with nature, protecting our air and water, and nurturing the soil
Organic products also benefit the health and well being of human and animal
life. Common mullein is easily out competed in areas with a densely vegetated
ground cover, but readily grows in disturbed sites. Because of its low dispersal
rate, the establishment of V. thapsus L. in a particular site depends primarily on
the presence of dormant seeds in the soils. It is an ephemeral plant, which is
eventually displaced by other plants in undisturbed sites (Gross and Werner,
1978). Manual removal of plants before flowering, the establishment of a dense
vegetative cover, and minimizing the availability of bare soil are probably
adequate to destroy mullein populations. For medicinal purposes, it is worthy of
propagation to compensate for the steady demand by sufferers of pulmonary
diseases.
The overall goal of this research was to obtain in vitro cultured plants that
are free of any pesticide residues or disease infestation and bulk material for
future physiological and biochemical studies, and to support the biological
activity of this medicinal plant with scientific data. The specific objectives weresjonpoid uje|inus jeroseWW0D €") esnB Lyto i) establish an experimental protocol for in vitro culture of Verbascum thapsus
L., ii) develop extraction and analysis procedure for the biologically active
ingredient saponin and iii) assess biological activity using specific bioassays
(anti-bacterial, anti-tumor and toxicity assessments)
1.2. Literature Review
1.2.1. Botany
The Scrophulariaceae family is an important family of plants comprising
over 200 genera and about 2500 species. They occur mostly in temperate and
sub-tropical regions, and many of them produce flowers of great beauty in either
a garden setting or as roadside ‘weeds’. The family includes Mimulus,
Penstemon, Digitalis, Veronica and Verbascum (Grieve, 1981). A number of the
Scrophulariaceae are, or have been, valued for their curative properties and are
widely employed both in domestic and regular medicine. At least 250 species of
Verbascum are known. Of the species formerly used in medicine, the most
important is Verbascum thapsus L. Common names include mullein, common
mullein, great mullein, wooly mullein, candlewick plant, velvet plant, blanket leaf,
white mans footsteps, Aaron's rod, Jacob's staff, hedge taper, high taper, old
man’s flannel, lady's foxglove and sigir kuyrugu (in Turkish) (Strange, 1977). *
The generic name of this plant, Verbascum, is believed to be a corruption
of barbascum, from the Latin barba, meaning a beard, referring to the shaggy
appearance of the genus, while thapsus, its specific name, may refer to the
Greek island of that name, where the species originally thrived. The word
“mullein” comes from the Middle English moleyne and the Old French moleine,and originally from the Latin mollis, meaning ‘soft’ and referring to the leaves
(Strange, 1977)
Verbascum thapsus L. is a biennial, or rarely an annual plant, with a deep
tap root. In its first year, it produces a low vegetative rosette up to 60 cm in
diameter, which over winters and is followed in the succeeding growing season
by a stout flowering stem 0.3-2.0 m tall. The basal leaves are oblong-obovate to
obovate-lanceolate and 10-40 cm long including the petiole (Figure 1.2). The
flower stem is longitudinally ridged by the bases of decurrent leaves and is
densely woolly with branched hairs. Cauline leaves are elliptic-lanceolate,
decurrent, and gradually reduced up the stem (Milspaugh, 1974). The leaf
system is so arranged that the smaller leaves above drop the rain upon the
larger ones below, which direct the water to the roots. This is a necessary
arrangement since the mullein grows mostly on dry soils. The stellately
branched hairs, which cover the leaves so thickly, act as a protective coat, thus
reducing moisture loss, and also providing a defense. They prevent attacks of
creeping insects and set up an intense irritation in the mucous membrane of any
grazing animals that may attempt to browse upon them. The hairs are not
confined to the leaves alone, but are also on every part of the stem, on the
calyces and on the outside of the corollas, so that the whole plant appears
whitish or gray (Gross and Werner, 1978; Whitson et al., 1992). Muzik (1970)
reported that these epidermal hairs protect the species from aqueous solution. of
2,4-D because the droplets are held away from the leaf surface. Ice crystals are
held away in the same manner. The homely but valuable “mullein tea’, aremedy of the greatest antiquity for coughs and colds, must always be strained
through fine muslin to remove any hairs that may be floating in the hot water,
which was poured over the flowers or leaves. They can cause intolerable
itching in the mouth (Grieve, 1981)
The inflorescence is a spike-like raceme 20-50 cm long and
approximately 3 cm in diameter. It is usually very dense; rare axillary racemes
may arise from the upper leaves. The sessile flowers are usually one per axil
with pedicels less than 2 mm and slightly irregular with rotate corollas (Whitson
et al., 1992). Individual flowers of mullein are ephemeral, opening before dawn
and closing before midaftemoon of the same day. They are protogynous, the
style maturing first and then bending downward once the anthers appear.
Flowers are also autogamous, selt-pollination occurring at the end of the day if
cross-pollination has not occurred. The style retums to its original position and
the corolla closes, pushing the still receptive stigma against the anthers. The
calyx consists of five lanceolate or ovate sepals, 7-9 mm long with caudate tips.
The corolla is 20-25 mm broad consisting of five yellow (rarely white) petals.
Stamens are irregular and attached to corolla, three upper filaments are shorter
and densely white-villous, lower two are longer and glabrous. Anthers are
larger and colored. The ovary is superior and two-celled. The fruit is an ovoid,
stellate-pubescent, capsule 3-6 mm long, longer than calyx and splits into two
valves at maturity. There are numerous brown seeds, 0.5-1.0 mm long which
are six-sided and have angular lateral surfaces with rows of pits (Abrams, 1951;
Davis, 1965-1985; Munz and Keck, 1973; Gross and Werner 1978; Radford et
BC. YORSEKOGRETIM KURDLUS
DOKUMANTASYON MEREal., 1968). Chromosome counts from plants collected in Ottawa and British
Colombia gave 2n=36 (Packer, 1964; Mulligan, 1961). Other counts from
European material have given 2n=34 and 2n=36 (Darlington and Wylie, 1955;
Love and Love, 1961) and n= 9, 11, 17 (Love and Love, 1961).
1.2.2. Habitat
V. thapsus L. is found growing in neglected meadows and pasture lands,
along fence rows and roadsides, on waste ground, more especially on gravel,
sand or chalk and in industrial areas throughout North America (Semenza et al.,
1978). It occurs in areas where the mean annual precipitation is 50-150 cm and
the growing season is at least 140 days. Dry sandy soils are preferred, but it is
common in the chalk and limestone districts of England. In Canada, it grows
abundantly in, but is not restricted to, pastures with well-drained soils and a pH
of 6.5-7.8 (Gross and Werner, 1978). In Turkey, common mullein is distributed
in Black Sea region (Kastamonu, Ordu, Trabzon, Rize, Coruh) and commonly
found in riversides, forests, Corylus and Quercus scrub and volcanic tuff (Davis,
1965-1985).
V. thapsus L. is native to Europe and Asia. It was probably introduced
into North America several times as a medicinal herb. It was introduced in the
mid-1700 to Virginia as a piscicide (fish poison) and spread rapidly (Semenza et
al., 1978). It quickly became so well established that an 1818 flora of the East
Coast described it as a native. By 1939 it had spread as far as Michigan andbecame widely naturalized on the Pacific Coast by 1876 (Gross and Werner,
1978)
Although extracts from mullein can inhibit growth of wheat seedlings, it is
not a serious agricultural weed, since it can be controlled by cultivation. In
overgrazed or poor pastures, the presence of common mullein represents a
further degradation of the pasture because grazing animals avoid eating
mullein. This species is not allelopathic, allergenic or poisonous to humans
(Gross and Werner, 1978).
1.2.3. Biology and ecology
Williams and Kemp (1976) have shown that seedlings of V. thapsus L.
collected from a range of cold to warm temperature habitats (based on altitude
and latitude) exhibit similar rates of photosynthesis within a temperature range
of 20-35 °C. Only at the highest temperature tested, 40 °C, the seedlings from
the warmest habitat (low altitude and latitude) exhibit higher photosynthetic
rates than those from the coolest habitat. They concluded that the ability of an
individual plant to photosynthesize over a broad range of temperature has
contributed to mullein's success across a diversity of habitats.
Williams et al. (1975) reported a CO, compensation point of 58 vpm CO2
for V. thapsus L. and on this basis concluded that the species had a Cs
photosynthetic pathway. Wuenscher (1970) shaved the dense trichomes of the
leaves of V. thapsus L. and found that the unshaved half of the leaf was
consistently warmer than the shaved half. The hairs must, then, affect leaf
energy exchange, since two halves of the same leaf, differing only in thepresence of hairs, reached different equilibrium temperatures. Convection and
the latent heat loss are reduced by the hairs although the hairs have little effect
on radiation absorption. Transpiration rate is reduced in hairy leaves. All of
these effects are explained by an increase in boundary layer thickness caused
by the hairs. The boundary layer forms above the surface of the hair coating
rather than directly over the leaf surface. This thickens the boundary layer by
the distance to which the hairs extend from the leaf surface. Increased
transpiration resistance has obvious ecological significance for V. thapsus L.,
which grows on dry, exposed sites. The dense hair coating is an efficient water-
conserving mechanism. Parkhurst (1976), evaluating the work of Wuenscher
(1970), showed by calculation that the main effect of the trichomes was to
increase stomatal resistance with only a slight increase in boundary layer
resistance.
Lortie and Aarssen (1997) demonstrated that clipping the shoot apex of
V. thapsus L. resulted in significantly more branches and branching intensity
could not be increased by greater resource levels in mullein when the apical
meristem was intact. Branching was stimulated by the addition of nutrients only
when the shoot apex was damaged. These results indicated that nutritional
status does not solely determine the degree of branching expressed in mullein.
Glier and Caruso (1973) demonstrated that decreasing temperatures
were observed to induce starch degradation in roots of mullein. Virtually no
starch remains in the roots when the acclimation period of decreasing
temperature was followed by an extended period of exposure to 4 °C. Thebreakdown of starch which was presumed to occur in late autumn under field
conditions may provide cryoprotective chemicals for the over wintering rosette.
‘Such chemicals might also serve as an energy source for the bolting process,
which occurs during the following spring or early summer. Later, they showed
that starch content in roots of V. thapsus L. was reduced when rosettes were
exposed to low temperatures because of the increased activities of starch
degradative enzymes (Glier and Caruso, 1974). They also (Glier and Caruso,
1977b) reported that two nonspecific enzymes, namely, acid and alkaline
phosphatase increased their activities in Verbascum roots exposed to
decreasing temperatures; alkaline phosphatase was of more importance than
acid phosphatase in over wintering rosettes. It was known that mullein had a
cold-requirement for bolting and that applied gibberellin substituted for this
requirement (Caruso and Glier, 1970). Glier and Caruso (1977a) also described
the influence of gibberellin on activities of starch degradative enzymes and
phosphatase. There was a sharp decrease in starch in the roots of Verbascum
as a result of treating rosettes with GAs and all three starch degradative
enzymes revealed increases in their activities. Also, application of GAs resulted
in an increase in the activity of alkaline phosphatase in roots and rosettes
showed an early response to applied gibberellin.
Gross (1981) showed that the rosette sizes of V. thapsus L. gives a
reliable estimate of an individual's fate the following year. A minimum size must
be reached before a plant is capable of flowering and the probability of flowering
increases steadily with rosette size. For mullein, all rosettes with a diameter
12greater than 41 cm flower the subsequent year and rosettes less than 9 cm in
diameter do not flower. Conversely, the probability of death decreases with
increasing rosette size
Seeds of V. thapsus L. are contained in a capsule with two cells.
Salisbury (1942) reported the mean number of capsules per explant as 226442
(SD; n=37), with an average of 596430 (SD; n=16) seeds per capsule. This
gives an approximate average of 100,00-180,000 seeds per individual plant,
each seed averaging 0.067 mg (Gross, 1980; Gross and Werner, 1982). The
seeds posses no specialized morphological adaptations for dispersal by wind or
animals. The capsules split open along its longitudinal axis when mature, and
movement of the stalk by wind or a large animal is required to release the seeds
from the parent. Seeds are dispersed as far as 11 m, although 93% of them fall
within 5 m and 75% of them fall within 1 m of the parent plant. Seeds may
remain viable for over 100 years and viable seeds have been found in soil
samples archaeologically dated from A.D. 1300 (Gross and Werner, 1978).
Mullein seeds may germinate under a wide variety of environmental
conditions. Germination is completely inhibited below 10 °C and at constant
temperatures above 40 °C (Semenza et al., 1978). Chilling during the winter
lowers the temperature requirement for germination; thus, seeds brought to the
surface in the autumn by soil disturbance are able to germinate early the next
spring (Baskin and Baskin, 1981). Sernenza et al. (1978) found that only 35%
of seeds germinated in the dark, compared to 93% germination in the light. This
light sensitivity varies seasonally, but on the whole, only those seeds, which lie
43at, or near the soil surface (0.5 cm or less) will be able to germinate. If seed
burial occurs due to subsequent disturbance or heavy rains rapidly sifting the
seeds below the soil surface, germination may be reduced or prevented through
light deprivation (Gross, 1980) .
There are some natural enemies (insects and pathogens) of common
mullein such as curculionid weevil (Gymnaetron tetrum Fab.) which is specific to
V. thapsus L. and was introduced to North America from Europe (Burcham,
1937). The larvae mature in the capsules (Sleeper, 1954) and destroy up to
50% of the seeds. The other insect, the mullein moth (Cucullia verbasci) feeds
and develops on mullein species. There are some pathogens, which cause
disease in common mullein such as Erysiphe cichoracearum (powdery mildew)
and Phymatotrichum omnivorum (root rot) (Gross and Wermer, 1978).
1.2.4, Medicinal or historical uses
Historically, mullein has been used as a remedy for the respiratory tract,
particularly in cases of irritating coughs with bronchial congestion (Hoffman,
1988). Some herbal texts extend the therapeutic use to pneumonia and asthma
(Grieve, 1981).
The leaves, roots and the flowers are anodyne, anti-inflammatory,
antiseptic, antispasmodic, astringent, demulcent, diuretic, _ emollient,
expectorant, nervine and vulnerary. Some of the uses like analgesic,
antihistaminic, anti-inflammatory, anticancer, antioxidant, antiviral, bacteristat,cardiodepressant, estrogenic, fungicide, hypnotic, sedative and pesticide are
also valid (Lucas, 1969; Harris, 1972; Null and Null, 1972; Grieve, 1981)
Demulcent and emollient properties come from the polysaccharide
mucilage and gums that soothe the irritated tissue. The expectorant property is
the result of saponins that stimulate fluid production. The anti-inflammatory
property is due to of iridoid glycosides and flavonoids that decrease
inflammation (Grieve, 1981). The mullein combines the expectorant action of its
saponins with the soothing effect of its mucilage, making this a most useful herb
for the treatment of hoarseness, tight coughs, bronchitis, asthma and whooping
cough (Mabey, 1988). The whole plant seems to possess slightly sedative and
narcotic properties. The dried leaves are sometimes smoked in an ordinary
tobacco pipe to relieve the irritation of the respiratory mucus membrane, and will
completely control the hacking cough of consumption. The leaves are
employed with equal benefit when made into cigarettes, for asthma and
spasmodic coughs. It is also diuretic, helping to reduce inflammation of the
urinary system and counter the irritating effect of acid urine (Ambasta, 1986;
Tyler, 1993; 1994). The flowers placed in a bottle and set in the sunshine are
said to yield a fatty matter valuable as a cure for haemorrhoids. Fomentations
and poultices of the leaves have been found serviceable in haemorthoidal
complaints. Mullein is said to be of much value in diarrhoea, from its
combination of demulcent with astringent properties, by this combination
strengthening the bowels at the same time (Grieve, 1981; Mabey, 1988). In
Europe, a sweetened infusion of the flowers strained in order to separate therough hairs is used as a domestic remedy in mild catarrhs and colic. A
conserve of the flowers has also been employed on the Continent against
ringworm, and a distilled water of the flowers was long reputed a cure for burns
and erysipelas (Millspaugh, 1974; Grieve, 1981). Decoction of leaves was used
as a hearth stimulant. Roots febrifuge; their decoction is used to alleviate
toothache and also relieve cramps, convulsions and migraines. The juice of the
plant and powder made from the dried roots is said to quickly remove rough
warts when rubbed on them (Tyler 1993; 1994). An oil produced by macerating
mullein flowers in olive oil, stored in a corked bottle during prolonged exposure
to the sun, or by keeping it near the fire for several days, is used as a local
application in country districts in Germany for piles and other mucus membrane
inflammations, and also for frost bites and bruises. Mullein oil is recommended
for earache and discharge from the ear, and for any eczema of the external ear
and its canal (Mabey, 1988; Yarnell, 1997). Mullein oil is a valuable destroyer of
disease germs (Chopra et al., 1956; Milspaugh, 1974). The fresh flowers,
steeped for 21 days in olive oil, are said to make an admirable bactericide. An
alcoholic tincture is prepared by homoeopathic chemists, from the fresh herb
with spirits of wine, which has proved beneficial for migraines or sick headaches
of long standing, with oppression of the ear (Bianchini and Corbetta, 1977;
Lewis and Elvin-Lewis, 1977). The seeds of mullein are said to be toxic and
should not be used in any of these preparations (Berk, 1996). The seeds when
thrown into the water are said to intoxicate fish, and are used by poachers for
that purpose, being slightly narcotic. To be effective, a piscicide plant must bereadily available for use, must have great solubility and rapid diffusion in water,
and must have such an effect that the fish do not have a toxic quality when they
are eaten by humans. The common mullein satisfies these piscicide
requirements. Major toxic elements found in fish poisons include saponin,
rotenone and glycoside. These substances affect the circulatory, respiratory
and central nervous systems of the fish. The common mullein causes fish to
have difficulty in breathing (Wilhelm, 1974).
Sweetish settlers called it wild tobacco and tied the leaves around their
feet and arms when they had the ague. Some prepared a tea from the leaves
for dysentery. A decoction of the roots was injected into the wounds of cattle
when afflicted with worms, which caused them to die and fall out. Also some
American Indian tribes (Mohegans, Penobscots, Catawbas, Chochtaws, Creeks,
Forest Potawatomis and Menominees) used common mullein as a medicinal
herb. The Mohegans smoked them to relieve asthma and sore throat, and the
Penobscots smoked the dried and powdered leaves for asthma. The Catawbas
boiled the root and sweetened it to make syrup for croup in children. The leaves
were mashed and applied as a poultice for pain and swelling, sprains, bruises
and wounds. The Chochtaws put the leaves on the head as a headache
poultice. The Creeks boiled the roots with those of Button Willow for a drink
used for coughs. The leaves were also boiled and the patient bathed in the
infusion while it was hot. The Forest Potawatomis smoked the dried leaves for
asthma, but it is not certain whether they learned the practice from the whites or
vice versa. A smoke smudge was made of the leaves and the fumes inhaled forcatarth and to revive an unconscious patient. The Menominees smoked the
root for pulmonary diseases. Whites smoked the leaves for asthma and
bronchitis and that the flowers were believed to be diuretic and had been used
for tuberculosis (Moerman, 1986; Vogel, 1990)
The flowering stem was used dried by Greeks and Romans as taper
dipped in tallow for light. Mullein torches were said to repel witches. There is
evidence that at one time it was a ‘magical plant” of the ancients. Agrippa, a
general and minister under Caesar Augustus, claimed that the scent from the
leaves had an overpowering effect on demons. Mullein was thought to be an
ingredient in brews and love potions, and mentioned in incantations used by
witches during the Middle Ages. The women of Rome also infused the flowers
and mixed the resulting liquid with lye, using it as a wash to turn their hair
golden yellow (Strange, 197)
1.2.5. In vitro culture of V. thapsus L. and of related species
There is no indication of previous attempts to initiate tissue cultures of V.
thapsus L. Caruso (1971) showed that excised internodal segments of
flowering specimens of V. thapsus L. with vascular tissues grew and formed
numerous buds on a simple nutrient medium which lacked added growth
regulator. Pith explants without vascular tissues became brown in a matter of 2
to 3 weeks with no visible sign of growth. Endogenous growth regulators
supplied by vascular tissues were believed to be major factors in bud formation
in excised internodal segments of this species.
18Several species of Scrophulariaceae have been regenerated. Torenia
fournieri has been studied extensively (Bajaj, 1972). Shoots were initiated in
numerous hormone treatments for both leaf (Bajaj, 1972) and internode
(Kamada and Harada, 1979) explants. Five different cytokinins were used to
initiate shoot formation in T. fournieri. In most cases 4.4 uM (1 mg/l) 6-BA, 4.6
LM (1 mg/l) zeatin, or 7.3 UM (1 mg/l) 4-phenylurea was sufficient to initiate
shoot formation (Kamada and Harada, 1979), whereas numerous combinations
of cytokinin and auxin also have been successful (Bajaj, 1972). Shoot formation
was induced from internode segments when cultured in 0.5 UM (0.1 mg/l) NAA
with either 3.35 uM (1 mg/l) SD8339, a cytokinin that has been used with
Nicotiana tabacum (Nitsch et al., 1967), or 4.7 pM (1 mg/l) kinetin.
Organogenesis of Torenia also could be regulated by application of amino
acids; shoot formation was observed in cultures with glutamic acid and aspartic
acid added to the medium (Kamada and Harada, 1979). Sangwan et al. (1976)
demonstrated the action of exogenously applied hormones in the induction of
morphogenesis in Limnophila chinensis (Osb.) Mert. tissue culture. Various
levels of kinetin, gibberellic acid and indole-3-acetic acid were tested on stem
explants. The formation of normal shoots and roots was stimulated by
treatment with kinetin. GA 3 treatment stimulated bud differentiation, but
inhibited the root initiation.
Arrebola et al. (1997) showed the optimal micropropagation procedure for
Isoplexis canariensis (L.) G. Don, using nodal segments with two axillary buds
as explants. A concentration of 0.5 uM (0.1 mg/l) kinetin in MS (Murashige and
19‘Skoog, 1962) liquid basal medium was found to be optimal for micropropagation
and rooting in vitro was unnecessary for ex vitro survival
Raste and Ganapathy (1970) cultured the internodal segments of the
inflorescence of Mazus pumilus on Murashige and Skoog's revised medium
(Murashige and Skoog, 1962). Indole-acetic acid, kinetin, gibberellic acid and
adenine sulphate were used as growth regulators. The inflorescence segments
produced calli, which differentiated into either roots or leafy shoots, which
subsequently flowered, or only flower buds.
Dietrich et al. (1990) established the optimum conditions for the
tegeneration of Digitalis Janata from shoot tips, for daughter shoot formation and
rooting as well as for the adaptation of the regenerated plants to the open
ground. Gene banks of valuable clones were built by keeping shoots at 4 °C on
media with high sucrose concentration or by growing juvenile clone plants in the
greenhouse at temperatures preventing the induction of flowering
1.2.6. Active ingredients of V. thapsus L.
The constituents of V. thapsus L. include polysaccharides; iridoid
glycosides including harpagoside; harpagide and aucubin (especially in the
leaf); flavonoids, including 3'-methylguercitin, hesperedin and verbascoside;
saponins and volatile oils (Pascual Teresa et al., 1978a; 1978b; 1980; Hattori
and Hatanaka 1958; Khuroo et al., 1988; Mehrotra et al., 1989; Warashina et
al., 1991; 1992)
Pascual Teresa et al. (1978a) isolated veratric acid and a-spinasterol
20from the benzene extract of capsules of V. thapsus L. From the hydrolyzed
ethanol extract, the triterpene A, saikogenin A, benzyl alcohol and methylfurfural
were isolated. They also showed that the oil from mullein seed (benzene
extract) had the following components: Fatty acids: palmitic, steriac, oleic,
linoleic, linolenic, arachic and behenic. Unsaponifiable matter: B-sitosterol and
ergosta-7-en-3-f-ol (Pascual Teresa et al., 1978b). Phenylethanoid and lignan
glycosides (Warashina et al., 1992), sterones, iridoid glycosides and
sesquiterpene acid (Khuroo et al., 1988; Warashina et al. 1991) and
verbacoside, a new luteolin glycoside (Mehrotra et al., 1989) were obtained from
whole plants of V. thapsus L. Bourquelot and Bridel (1910) discovered the
verbascose, an oligosaccharide in the root of the mullein. Hattori and Hatanaka
(1958) demonstrated the oligosaccharides in V. thapsus L. and distribution of
mono- and oligosacharides in various organs of the plant in various stages was
studied.
Saponins of Verbascum species, extraction and analysis
Hartleb and Seifert (1994; 1995) isolated songarosaponin D, E, F and
buddlejasaponin | from the aerial parts of V. songaricum Schrenk. A
combination of chromatographic separation on silica gel (CC and TLC) and RP-
8 (HPLC) of the methanolic extract of the 160 g dried and powdered aerial parts
resulted in 3 mg songarosaponin E, 2 mg songarosaponin F, 1 mg
buddlejasaponin | and 14 mg songarosaponin D.
Klimek et al. (1992) isolated two triterpene saponins from the methanol
21extract of the inflorescences of V. nigrum L. From 400 g dried powdered plant
material, crude saponin (240 mg) was obtained as a brown amorphous powder
which was chromatographed on alumina. The crystalline mixture of saponin 1
and 2 was finally resolved by chromatography on silica gel; yields were 19 mg of
saponin 1 and 14 mg of saponin 2. Anil (1980) also isolated two triterpenoid
saponins from the leaves of V. nigrum L. Fresh 18 kg leaves were extracted
with methanol three times. After chromatographic separation on silica gel, 3.7 g
saponin | and 2.1 g saponin Il were obtained.
Klimek (1996) obtained a new saponin in addition to two known ones,
and identified as desrhamnosylverbascosaponin from the flowers of V.
phlomoides. Air-dried and powdered petals (170 g) were extracted with ethanol,
and it was fractionated between diethyl ether, n-butanol and water. The n-
butanol-soluble fraction was subjected to repeated column chromatography on
polyamide, followed by silica gel and sephadex to obtain 12 mg of
verbascosaponin, 30 mg of verbascosaponin A and 5 mg of
desrhamnosylverbascosaponin
Pascual Teresa et al. (1980) isolated four saponins from the capsules of
V. thapsus L, thapsuine A, thapsuine B, hydroxythapsuine A and
hydroxythapsuine B with a chromatographic separation on silica gel (TLC)
Crushed capsules (5 kg) were extracted with benzene and ethanol and
subjected to chromatography on silica gel and sephadex. They obtained 300
mg thapsuine A and 460 mg thapsuine B.
A range of methods has been employed for the qualitative and
22quantitative analysis of saponins: haemolysis, piscicidal activity, gravimetry,
spectrophotometry, TLC (thin layer chromatography), GC (gas
chromatography), HPLC (high pressure liquid chromatography), DCCC (droplet
counter current chromatography), etc. (Price et al., 1987). For TLC analysis of
crude saponin extracts, either silica gel plates with a CHCLIs-MeOH-H:0
solvent systems (65:35:10, lower phase or 58:35:, for example), or reversed
phase (octyl-or octadecylsilica) plates with MeOH-H20 or CHsCN-H20 solvent
systems can be used. The saponins may be detected by means of the Godin
reagent (vanillin-sulphuric acid) (Marston and Hostettmann, 1991).
HPLC analysis of crude extracts of Phytolacca dodecandra has been
achieved by Domon et al. (1984). Reversed-phase (RP-8) and polar-bonded
supports (Diol), with eluents containing methanol-water or acetonitrile-water
mixtures were employed. Detection was affected at 206 nm. The use of elution
gradients was possible with acetonitrile as it has a relatively weak absorbent at
this wavelength. Under these conditions mono- and bidesmosidic saponins
could be separated. The problem with the HPLC analysis of saponins is the
lack of a suitable chromophore in many of the gylcosides. One of the methods,
however, of overcoming this disadvantage is to derivatize the saponin with a
chromophoric reagent, which allows suitable UV detection. Attaching a 4-
bromophenacyl group at position Czs of the aglycone is one method of achieving
this aim (Slacanin et al., 1988; Marston and Hostettmann, 1991).
Many papers concerning the separation of saponins by HPLC have been
published. The reversed phase method is the most often described and the
23solvent generally used is a mixture of water and acetonitrile either in the
isocratic mode or with an elution gradient (Domon et al., 1984; Slacanin et al.,
1988; Kazanawa et al., 1990; Crespin et al., 1993). Acids (orthophosphoric acid
and trifluoroacetic acid) have been added to the mobile phase to improve the
separation of monodesmosidic saponins or saponin including glucuronic acid
(Burnouf-Radosevich and Delfel, 1986). Saponins were detected at 210 nm
(Crespin et al., 1993; Reznicek et al., 1996). Reznicek et al. (1996) also showed
that digitoxin turned out to be a good intemal standard for the determination of
the saponins. Using the HPLC on RP-8, the standard was eluted between the
saponins at ta=39.6 min.
1.2.8. Bioassays
Generally, the disc diffusion assay has been used to screen for antibiotic
activity (Barry and Thornsberry, 1985). McCutcheon et al. (1992) used the disc
diffusion method to show the antibiotic activity of common mullein leaves and
demonstrated that methanolic extract of leaves had antibacterial activity against
Escherichia coli {inhibition zone (iz); 8.0-10.0 mm], Mycobacter phlei (iz; 8.0-
10.0 mm) and Staphylococcus aureus methicillin-resistant (iz; 10.1-15.0 mm).”
Methanolic extract of common mullein leaves was found to partially inhibit
the cytopathic effects of bovine herpesvirus type 1, two double-stranded DNA
viruses, which causes respiratory, genital, conjunctival or encephalitic infections
which become latent in the trigeminal ganglion (McCutcheon et al., 1995).
‘TC. YOKSEKOGRETIM KURULD
DOKDMANTASYON MERKEREMoreover, this extract had antifungal activity against Microsporum cookeril (iz;
8.0-10.0 mm) and M. gypseum (iz; 8.0-10.0 mm) (McCutcheon et al., 1994)
Ferrigini et al. (1982) modified and evaluated the potato disc assay for its
potential use as a prescreen and fractionation monitor of plant extracts for 3PS.
(in vivo, mouse leukemia) activity. The modified assay was performed on a
series of natural compounds and plant extracts (known to have 3PS activity)
and on extracts of 41 Euphorbiaceae species and results showed that the
potato disc assay was a safe, simple, rapid, in-house, low cost, prescreen for
3PS antitumor activity. No potato disc assay was performed on common
mullein extracts.
A procedure for general toxicity screening that does not require much
specialization is essential as a preliminary stage in the study of bioactive
compounds. A simple animal that has been used for this purpose is the brine
shrimp, Artemia salina Leach (Sam, 1993). The first report of the use of the
brine shrimp as a test organism appeared in 1956 (Michael et al., 1956). Since
then there have been many reports on the use of this animal for environmental
studies, screening for natural toxins, and as a general screening for bioactive
substances in plant extracts (Sam, 1993). Meyer et al. (1982) performed the
brine shrimp bioassay on seed extracts of 41 species of Euphorbiaceae and
compared the results with 9KB and 9PS cytotoxicities and concluded that the
method was rapid, reliable, inexpensive, and convenient as an in-house general
bioassay tool for natural product research. Brine shrimp bioassay has not been
used on common mullein extracts.
25Radish seed bioassay has been used in various assessment of toxicity
and was established by Einhellig and Ramussen (1978). They showed the
effects of vanillic and p-hydroxybenzoic acids on radish and grain sorghum
germination. Since then there have been many studies using allelochemics or
plant extracts to examine the effects on germination of seeds of any weeds and
cfops (Williams and Hoagland, 1982)
Pardo et al. (1998) isolated iridoid glycosides lateroside 1, harpagoside 2,
ajugol 3, and aucubin 4 from an ethanolic extract of the roots of mullein that
exhibits antigermination activity on seeds of barley (Hordeum vulgare).
Bioassays indicated that at 3 mM concentration, compounds 1, 2, and 4 showed
moderate inhibition of seed germination. Aucubin 4 was the most active against
root elongation and ajugol 3 showed no activity in the bioassays on barley seed
germination and growth
26CHAPTER TWO
In Vitro Culture of Common Mullein (Verbascum thapsus L.)
2.4. Introduction
All normal living cells within the plant body possess the potential capacity
to regenerate an entire plant. This potentiality has been exploited through the
culture of protoplasts, cells, tissues and organs in vitro. Cells and tissues, which
are mitotically quiescent or already committed to some function or pathway of
development, can be (re) directed into organ or embryo formation.
Organogenesis is the process by which cells and tissues are forced to undergo
changes which lead to the production of a unipolar structure, namely a shoot or
root primordium, whose vascular system is often connected to the parent
tissues (Thorpe, 1994). The earliest report of controlled shoot formation in vitro
was by White (1939). In the same year, the first observation of root formation
from callus was reported by Nobecourt (1939), using carrot callus. White's
observation was confirmed and extended by Skoog (1944), who showed that
auxins could stimulate root formation and inhibit shoot formation. A similar
conclusion on the role of auxin in rooting also was made by Gautheret (1945).
In addition, Skoog (1944) found that the inhibitory effect of auxin on shoot
formation could be partially overcome by increasing the concentration of
sucrose and inorganic phosphate in the medium. Skoog and Tsui (1948)
demonstrated that adenine sulfate was active in promoting shoot formation and
27counteracted the inhibitory action of auxin. They further reported (Skoog and
Tsui, 1951) that the extent of organ formation was dependent on both the
concentration and proportion of these additives. The discovery of kinetin (Miller
et al., 1956) led to the classic finding of Skoog and Miller (1957) that a basic
regulatory mechanism underlying organogenesis involved a balance between
auxin and cytokinin. Both of these substances are required for cell division and
enlargement in tobacco callus, but a relatively high level of auxin to cytokinin
favored root formation and the reverse favored shoot formation. These
observations led them to suggest that quantitative interactions between diverse
growth factors rather than specific morphogenetic substances provided a
common mechanism for the regulation of all types of morphogenetic
phenomena in plants that is basic concept on the regulation of organogenesis in
vitro (Thorpe, 1980)
Christianson and Wamick (1988) determined that there are three phases
of organogenesis: dedifferentiation, induction and —_ differentiation.
Dedifferentiation involves callus production and ends when cells become
competent. During the induction phase, cells become determined and in the
differentiation phase, cells form roots or shoots.
There has been a significant increase in popularity of common mullein as
a medicinal plant and because of the market demand for this herb, in vitro
culture protocol providing multiple regenerants per explant would be very useful
for mass propagation of common mullein. Although this plant can easily be
28found in the wild, it is generally subjected to some herbicides and attacked by
some insects and pathogens. In vitro micropropagation of common mullein
provides pesticide or disease-free plants and produces large numbers of
vegetative planting stock. In addition, with an in vitro propagation method,
unlimited plant material can consistently be obtained throughout the whole year
and uniform plant materials (less genetic diversity) can be produced that will be
higher with seed germination
Caruso (1971) showed that excised internodal segments of flowering
specimens of V. thapsus L. with vascular tissues grew and formed numerous
buds on a simple nutrient medium which lacked added growth regulators.
However, a defined protocol for in vitro culture of common mullein has not been
reported, Therefore, the objective of this study was to establish an in vitro
culture protocol for Verbascum thapsus L. to provide a source of plant material
for the extraction and analysis of biologically active ingredients. The results
given in this chapter were already published (Turker et al., 2001).
2.2. Materials and Methods
Seeds were collected from South Carolina Botanical Garden, Clemson,
SC, in July and August of 1998. They were washed with anti-bacterial soap,
rinsed with distiled water and surface disinfested by shaking for 20 min in 95%
E1OH, for 20 min in 20% clorox® (1.05% sodium hypochloride) with tween 20
(three drops per 100 ml), and then rinsed with sterile water three times. Seeds
29were placed in sterile, disposable petri dishes (60 x 15 mm) containing 15 ml of
Murashige and Skoog Minimal Organics medium (4.43 g/l, MSMO, Sigma
Chemical Co., St. Louis, MO; Murashige and Skoog, 1962) with 30 g/l sucrose,
8.0 g/l Difco Bacto-agar (pH 5.7, autoclaved for 20 min at 121 °C and 105 kPa).
Twenty-day-old seedlings were transferred to Magenta containers (GA-7
Vessel, Sigma Chemical Co., St. Louis, MO) containing liquid MSMO. Explants
excised from 20- to 30-day-old plants (3 om in height) were leaf discs (7 mm in
diameter), petioles (7-8 mm) and roots (2 om). Explants were placed in 96 x 25
mm shell vials containing 10 ml MSMO. Either BA (1,2,3,4 or 5 mgjl) or kinetin
(1,2,3,4 or 5 mg/l) was added to the medium. Alll cultures were incubated at 25
°C under a 16-h photoperiod (cool-white fluorescent lights, 22-28 ymol m?s”).
Shoot number and % explants producing shoots were recorded after 6 weeks
for leaf discs and petioles, and after 8 weeks for root segments. Tests had 10
replications for each explant and the experiment was repeated three times
Leaves (youngest three to four leaves of first-year rosette) were obtained
from plants grown under greenhouse conditions in commercial potting soil.
Leaves were washed with anti-bacterial soap, rinsed with distilled water, surface
disinfested by agitating in 70% EtOH for 2 min, 20% clorox® with tween 20
(three drops per 100 mi) for 15 min, and subsequently rinsed with sterile distilled
water three times. Leaf discs (9 mm, four per dish) were placed onto MSMO
medium (15 mi per 60 x 15 mm sterile disposable petri dishes). After 1 week,
single non-contaminated leaf discs were placed into 95 x 25 mm shell vials
30containing MSMO medium with combinations of auxin and cytokinin: BA (3 mg/l)
and 2,4-D (0.1, 0.5 or 1 mg/l); BA (3 mg/l) and NAA (1, 3 or 5 mg/l). Shoot
number and percent explants producing shoots were recorded after 6 weeks.
There were 10 replications and the experiment was repeated twice.
Well-developed shoots were excised from the various explants and
subcultured for 15 days on the same initiation medium. Shoots were then
separated individually and placed on rooting medium containing MSMO and
various levels of either 2,4-D (0.1, 0.5 or 1 mg/l) or NAA (1, 3 or 5 mg/l). Shoots
were subcultured onto medium containing the same auxin used to induce root
formation. After 5 weeks, the number of roots and % of explants producing
roots were recorded. There were 20 replications and the experiment was
repeated three times. Rooted explants were transferred to vermiculate
(Patterson Vermiculate Co., Enoree, SC) in Magenta containers and after 3
weeks transferred to 4.5 inch-plastic pots containing potting soil (Garden Magic®
Potting Soil containing peat moss).
Flow chart of the experiments is given in Figure 2.1. Data was subjected
to ANOVA and Duncan's Multiple Range Test (SAS, 1996).
31PLANT SOURCE
‘Seedlings from sterilized seeds) (Plants grown under greenhouse condition)
EXPLANTS
(Leaf Discs, Petioles, Roots) (Leaf Discs)
SHOOT FORMATION
1
ROOTING
!
PLANTLETS
Figure 2.1. Protocol for in vitro culture of Verbascum thapsus L. (common
mullein).
322.3. Results and Discussion
Verbascum thapsus L. is a widely-used medicinal herb, but there has
been almost no interest in the in vitro propagation of this species. We, therefore,
aimed at developing a reliable protocol for in vitro regeneration of V. thapsus L.
and thus examined the effects of several combinations of plant growth
regulators using different explants.
Our initial attempts to sterilize explants taken from field-grown plants
were unsuccessful due to significant contamination on the leaves, mostly
located among dense and woolly hairs. We then had to germinate seeds under
aseptic conditions to obtain a sterile source of explant.
When leaf disc, petiole and root explants were cultured on MSMO
medium containing 1-5 mg/l BA or kinetin, all explants tested formed shoots with
either BA or kinetin (Table 2.1). The greatest number of shoots per explant and
percentage of leaf and petiole explants forming shoots was observed on media
with 3.0 mg/l BA (Table 2.1; Figure 2.2a,b). It was clear that the BA induced
more shoot formation than kinetin at all concentrations regardless of the explant
type. Root segment explants formed fewer shoots than leaf and petiole
explants. In addition, root explants were considerably slower in shoot induction
since the majority of the leaf and petiole explants had already formed shoots by
6 weeks while it took 8 weeks to see root explants formed shoots. Although we
33UIUYIM su9y9] Bes a4} YIM SUea\y
“squawuedxe sad sayeoyjdei 0} YUM sjueuiadxe sary) Jo URAL ay)
“GO'00.05.
Sample Saponin-1 content (mg/g)
Mean + SE
Leaves from field-grown plant 0.198 + 0.024%
Leaves from in vitro cultured plant 0.081 + 0.012"
Commercially obtained leaves 0.215 + 0.0147
Capsules from field-grown plants 0.016 + 0.001°
55level detected (0.016 mg/g tissue). The higher levels in the commercial product
may be related to the method of harvest and product preparation.
In vitro cultured leaf material was obtained from micropropagated plants
in our laboratory (Turker et al, 2001). For HPLC experiments, leaves of
micropropagated plants developed from leaf disc with 3 mg/l BA + 1 mg/l NAA
were used. Secondary product synthesis by disorganized callus or cell
suspension is typically low in un-manipulated cultures. In contrast to
disorganized cultures the behavior of differentiated cultures is much more
predictable (Parr, 1989). Shoot cultures often produce higher product levels
and more conventional product profiles than their corresponding callus or
suspension cultures (Stafford, 1991). But, sometimes the level of the detected
secondary products in shoot cultures is lower than donor plants. For example,
in Catharanthus roseus shoot cultures, the dimeric alkaloids have been
detected, although at lower levels than those found in the leaves of the plant,
while cell suspension cultures contained no trace of these complex structures
Although tropane alkoloids were obtained from multiple shoot cultures of shoot
tip, lateral bud or leaf discs of Atropa belladonna, detected level was about 7%
of donor plant (Benjamin et al., 1987). Also, production of steroids obtained
from shoot tip cultures of Digitalis species was much lower than those found in
the donor plant (Seidel and Reinhard, 1987). If the secondary product synthesis
is low, there are some procedures for enhancing productivity. Optimization of
hormone regime is often effective. The type and concentration of
56phytohormones available to cultured cells is probably the most important factor
influencing their potential for secondary product synthesis. For example 2,4-D
can stimulate both cell division and cell expansion in many systems. However,
it can also bring about a dramatic suppression of secondary product synthesis in
cell cultures. Alterations in other environmental factors such as nutrient levels,
light regime and temperature may also be effective in increasing productivity
and reduced phosphate levels often stimulate product accumulation (Parr,
14989).
Future studies will focus on isolation of saponins from V. thapsus L. with
subsequent elucidation of their structures. Perhaps this information can assist
in standardization of commercial samples and elucidation of active ingredients
and their mode of action.
57CHAPTER FOUR
Biological Activity of Common Mullein
4.1. Introduction
As an antimicrobial susceptibility testing, the most widely used procedure
is the disk diffusion method. Bacterial susceptibility to antimicrobial agents may
be measured in vitro by utilizing the principles of agar diffusion. At the end of the
1950's, antimicrobial susceptibility testing was marked by lack of an acceptable
standardized procedure, which led to variable results depending on which
laboratory was used (Atlas, 1988). The disc diffusion procedure (Kirby-Bauer
method) (Barry and Thornsberry, 1985) has been accepted by the Food and
Drug Administration (FDA) and as a standard by the National Committee for
Clinical Laboratory Standards (NCCLS). Reasonably accurate and precise
results can be obtained with Kirby-Bauer procedure, which all-procedural details
are carefully standardized and controlled (Barry and Thornsberry, 1985).
The qualitative susceptibility of microorganisms to antimicrobial agents
can be determined on agar plates by using filter paper disks impregnated with
antimicrobial agents. The Kirby-Bauer test system is a standardized
antimicrobial susceptibility procedure in which a culture is inoculated onto the
surface of Muller-Hinton agar, followed by the addition of antibiotic impregnated
disks to the agar surface. In such agar diffusion methods the antibiotics diffuse
into the agar, establishing a concentration gradient. A clear area (zone of
inhibition) indicates inhibition of microbial growth around the antibiotic disk. The
diameter of the zone of inhibition reflects the solubility properties of the
58particular antibiotic; that is, the concentration gradient established by diffusion of
the antibiotic into the agar, and the sensitivity of the given microorganism to the
specific antibiotic. Standardized zones for each antibiotic disk have been
established to determine whether the microorganism is sensitive (S),
intermediately sensitive (|), or resistant (R) to the particular antibiotic (Appendix
A). Kirby-Bauer agar diffusion test procedure is designated for use with rapidly
growing bacteria. It is not directly applicable to filamentous fungi, anaerobes, or
slow-growing bacteria (Atlas, 1988). The disk diffusion method has been
employed by using plant extracts in antibacterial susceptibility testing (Caceres
et al., 1991; McCutcheon et al., 1992; Mousa, 1994; Mongelli, 1995; Essawi and
Srour, 2000; Kelmanson, 2000; Samy and Ignacimuthu, 2000).
For antibacterial assay in our study, bacteria were chosen according to
medicinal properties of common mullein (Appendix B)..
Crown gall is a neoplastic disease of plants induced by specific strains of
Agrobacterium tumefaciens, a Gram-negative bacterium. The bacterium
contains a large Ti (tumor-inducing) plasmid, which carties genetic information
(T-DNA) that transforms normal, wounded, plant cells into autonomous tumor
cells (McLaughlin, 1991). In 1980, Galsky et al. (1980; 1981) demonstrated that
inhibition of crown gall tumors on discs of potato tubers showed an apparent
correlation with compounds and plant extracts known to be active in the 3PS (in
vivo, murine leukemia) antitumor assay (McLaughlin et al., 1998). Later,
Ferrigini et al. (1982) modified the Galsky potato disc method (Galsky et al.,
1980; 1981) and tested the effectiveness, with appropriate statistical evaluation,
59of the modified assay as a prescreen for 3PS activity in crude plant extracts
(McLaughiin et al., 1991; McLaughlin et al., 1993). Finally, Ferrigini et al. (1982)
concluded that crown gall tumors on potato discs could routinely be employed
as a comparatively rapid, inexpensive, safe, animal-sparing, and statistically
reliable prescreen for in vivo 3PS antitumor activity.
Bioactive compounds are almost always toxic in high doses
Pharmacology is simply toxicology at a lower dose, or toxicology is simply
pharmacology at a higher dose. Thus, in vivo lethality in a simple zoologic
organism can be used as a convenient monitor for screening and fractionation
in the discovery of new bioactive natural products. The eggs of brine shrimp,
Artemia salina (Leach) are readily available in pet shops at low cost and remain
viable for years in the dry state. Upon being placed in seawater, the eggs hatch
within 48 hours to provide large numbers of larvae (nauplii) for experimental
use. A positive correlation was found between brine shrimp toxicity and 9KB
(human nasopharyngeal carcinoma) cytotoxicity, and now the brine shrimp test
has been used as a prescreen for a panel of six human solid tumor cell lines, at
the Cell Culture Laboratory of Purdue Cancer Center (McLaughlin et al., 1998).
It is possible to detect and then monitor the fractionation of cytotoxic, as well as
3PS (in vivo murine leukemia) active extracts using the brine shrimp lethality
bioassay rather than more tedious and expensive in vitro and in vivo antitumor
assays. The brine shrimp assay has the advantages of being rapid (24 hours),
inexpensive, and simple. It easily utilizes a large number of organisms for
statistical validation and requires no special equipment and a relatively small
60amount of sample (50 mg for crude extracts). Active compounds thus obtained
could then be subjected to more elaborate bioassays for specific pharmacologic
activities (Meyer et al., 1982). Furthermore, it does not require animal serum as
is needed for cytotoxicities. Animal rights advocates have not yet objected to
the use of these invertebrates in experimental work (McLaughlin et al., 1991).
Allelopathy is an anti-competition mechanism in plants and described as
inhibition of the germination, growth or reproduction of an organism affected by
chemical substances released from another organism. Weed species are
frequently considered to be competitive because they show vigorous growth in
crops and reduce crop yield. An ideal weed should show strong interspecific
competition via special mechanisms such as allelopathic processes
Allelopathic chemicals may play an important role in determining the persistence
and abundance of weed species in mixtures of plants (Pardo et al., 1998)
Radish seed bioassay is suggested in order to demonstrate the effects of
allelochemics on seed germination and to evaluate the allelopathic potential of
V. thapsus L. (Patterson, 1986)
In spite of the use of mullein in folk medicine, many of the medicinal
activities of mullein are not supported by scientific studies. The objective of this
study was to assess the biological activity of common mullein extracts using
selected bioassays including antibacterial, antitumor and toxicity (brine shrimp
and radish seed bioassays). The results of these bioassays were already
submitted for publication (Tuirker and Camper, 2002).
614.2. Materials and Methods
4.2.1, Plant material and extraction
Plant materials were extracted with different solvents (MeOH, EtOH and
water) and their biological activities assessed. For extractions, three different
sources of leaves (field-grown, in vitro cultured and commercially obtained) and
capsules (from field-grown plants) were used. Leaves and capsules from field-
grown plants were collected from native mullein plants between August and
September of 2000. Leaves of in vitro cultured plants were collected from
mullein plants that were previously micropropagated in our laboratory (Turker et
al., 2001). In addition, mullein leaves were purchased from a health food store.
Commercially obtained leaves were dried and pulverized by Frontier Herbal
Company, but field-grown leaves, capsules and in vitro cultured leaves were
dried in oven at 60 °C and then ground into a powder. In addition, commercial
products of common mullein (tea bags, swallow capsules, an alcoholic extract
and flower oil) were purchased from health food stores. Purified saponins were
also included in the bioassays for comparison. Treatments, plant materials and
extraction procedures are summarized in Table 4.1.
62“y uluodesisuem||
UISIINW :O4 eNKe
plaly :O4 ‘sereaj paureygo AI
| deg ‘uuodes oing :d deg Syeq elfen wioy uluodeg :D deg ‘pioe oz1yUhofIO :AID
joyooiy “av ‘aInsdeo moljemg :9¢ ‘sjonpoud pauleyqo
JOLIN :19 ‘seAea| painyno ay/A Uj °7] {UOYOONEG :9a ‘uOIsNyU| {Jul ‘seAee| Piel 14 «
(SIOMOY,
OIBUILUOD :WOD ‘Beg eal 'a ‘sainsdeo
TUTE TT TOS OG) SIEM HORN UI UOHAIOS OOS WON D SUBHT EuEIMITONS WOH Y UVOEESSURNT Tees
‘(qeuibig) uNDdeS sing aes
(juy6u |) 203m ur uoanios 01g nuodes odes
2 MOA, Aig__suuodes snouen
18 BAIS SINT PDEINS SOROS SPE RUSH", JOHVOIS) HO 765 Uk WOS-O4
WoRRIORT SATOH TTT) UCSTE TEAS-GP UI PEISEINS SANES| USAT BUT SqRH BRO) TOUODTE U EAN Ur wosa¥
TU G6 10) PUETS Pue JeIeM pajoq Jo W Og Uy SayNSdeS USSU Tq FeIE|OS) SINSTED MOTENS UF Wog-0S
“TN 10} pUETS PUR TayeM aja jo TU OB UI paoeId seq ea) SOIL TaeaIED BAL GSH Hoyas) Beg Goh uk WOI-GL.sjonpord fe1eusw09
(weduiOg TequoIg) (B OF) Senee] jeRVAUILOD BeG-10
unnoea sepun ju! 08 0} paonpas JO}EMA "UW OF
40} pojog pue Jejem partisip 1 QOOL Ul paveid-uoH}I0O3q
(6 oy) saneay paimyno oxy uy
(6 oy) sonea) piel
TUNROBA TOpUN TU OB OF PETNS! TIEN
ue uly OF JO} 49}2m pa}OG jw DOL Ul PaDeId-UOISTYUL (6 op) soneat pies eI JOT
HueaTOD FaWaI (OFT 56K
-JaJeM |W 08 UI PEAIOSSIp enpiseu pue wNnoeA JepUN (6 op) saneay
payelodena HOI (Xe) 0, 0S 1 HOIS %OS WM Pees (6 oy) soneay pias ea HOI
“JVEM |W OB Ul PaAjOssip eNpises TE OF) seinsdes pisiz HOSW-O4
pue wnnoea Jepun payesodens HOS “S14 > (Auedwo9 senuois) (6 Oy) sanzay jenseuw0D HOeW-19
40} (Xe) HOBW Wim peyDeNK UO ‘papleOsIp pue Sy E (6 op) senza, paimro ona Uy Ho=W-
20} (XE) Wi0jo10140 YAP PEYDELND YOHOS (6 or) seneei piel HoAN-14 72243 HOON
‘unpadoig WORSEN qweunees, ui steuaIeW _.uoneUBISeG TEHOIeW 3891
‘senpaooid uoqoenxe s18u) pue sKesseoig ul pasn suluodes jualayip pue s}oes}xe Jo uoneUbISEG Jy 81GeL
634.2.2. Antibacterial assay
The disc diffusion assay (Kirby-Bauer method) was used to screen for
antibiotic activity (Prescott et al., 1990). Six bacterial strains were used in the
screening: Escherichia coli (ATCC®25922), Pseudomonas aeruginosa
(ATCC®27853), and Klebsiella pneumoniae (ATCC®13883) which are Gram-
Negative bacteria and Streptococcus pyogenes (ATCC°19615), Staphylococcus
aureus (ATCC®25923), Staphylococcus epidermidis (ATCC®12228) which are
Gram-Positive bacteria. Bactrol™
disks (Difco Laboratories) containing different
bacterial strains were transferred to test tubes containing 2 mi of Tryptic Soy
Broth (TSB) and incubated for 3 hours at 37 °C. After 3 hours, one
bacteriological loop from each broth was streaked on Tryptic Soy Agar (TSA)
plates and incubated for 2 days at 37 °C. After 2 days, a single colony was
removed and streaked on a new TSA plate and incubated 37 °C for 2 additional
days. After 2 days, 4-5 loops of pure culture were transferred to 20 ml of TSB in
a test tube for each bacterial strain and incubated overnight at 37 °C; then stock
bacterial suspensions (100-200 jl) were transferred to test tubes containing 2
ml of TSB and turbidity was measured at 625 nm. For Gram (-) bacteria,
suspensions were adjusted to absorbance values of 0.08+0.02 and for Gram
(+), 0.140.02. These absorbance values correspond to a 0.5 Mac Farland
standard. This turbidity standard is used in hospitals for antimicrobial
susceptibility testing and endorsed by the National Committee for Clinical
Laboratory Standards (NCCLS) (Coker, 1999).
64A sterile cotton swab was dipped into the standardized bacterial
suspension and used to evenly streak the entire surface of a (60 X 15 mm)
Mueller-Hinton (M-H) agar plate (one test tube was used for each agar plate).
Agar plates were streaked three times, each time tuming the plate at a 60°
angle and finally rubbing the swab through the edge of the plate. All extracts
were sterilized by filtering through a 0.22 um filter (Pal-Gelman Laboratory).
Filter paper discs (Glass microfibre filters, Whatman®; 7 mm in diameter) were
soaked in the extract and then blotted on a sterile paper towel and placed on
the inoculated plates. There were four replicates in each plate and two plates
for each extract tested for each bacterium. Positive controls consisted of five
different BBL™ Sensi-Disc™ antimicrobial susceptibility test discs (Becton
Dickinson Microbiology Systems): erythromycin (15 1g) (E-15), cephalothin (30
1g) (CF-30), carbenicillin (100 1g) (CB-100), sulfisoxazole (2.0 mg) (G-25) and
chloramphenicol (30 1g) (C-30) (Appendix A). Four antibiotic discs were used
for each plate and run in duplicate. Negative controls consisted of water,
MeOH, 50% MeOH and 50% EtOH. Inoculated plates with disks were placed in
a 37 °C incubator. After 16 to 18 hrs of incubation, inhibition zone diameter
(mm) was measured. All experiments were repeated three times.
4.2.3. Anti-tumor assay
Antitumor activity of mullein extracts was assessed with the potato disc
method as modified by McLaughlin's group (Fertigini et al., 1982).
Agrobacterium tumefaciens (strain B6) was cultured on Yeast Extract Media
un nORod ge
A yMANTASHON(YEM) for 2-3 days at 28 °C. Camptothecin (Sigma) (tumor suppressant)
served as a positive control. All extracts were aqueous; therefore, water was
used as a negative control. As a second negative control, 50% MeOH was also
used for ilwensisaponin A and commercial products. Six to seven loops of A.
tumefaciens were added to 10 ml phosphate buffered saline (PBS) (pH=7.2).
Suspensions of A. tumefaciens in PBS were standardized to 1.0 X 10° colony
forming units (CFU) as determined by an absorbance value of 0.96+0.02 at 600
nm. Inoculum: All extracts, controls and solutions were filter sterilized (sterile
0.22 ym filter, Pal-Gelman Laboratory). The following design was followed:
Positive control: 600 yl camptothecin stock + 150 ul sterile distilled water + 750
ul A.tumefaciens in PBS; Solvent control |: 600 11! control (water, 50% MeOH or
50% EtOH) + 150 ul sterile distilled water + 750 pl A. tumefaciens in PBS;
Solvent control Il: 600 ul control (water, 50% MeOH or 50% EtOH) + 150 yl
sterile distilled water + 750 jl PBS; Test extracts: 600 pl test extract + 150 ul
sterile distilled water + 750 jl A.tumefaciens in PBS.
Red-skinned potatoes (Solanum tuberosum L. var. Red Russett) were
scrubbed with a brush under running water and surface sterilized by immersion
in 10% clorox for 20 min. Tubers were then placed on sterile petri dishes and
cut along either side revealing the largest flat surface area available; tubers
were immersed in 20% clorox for 15 min and then placed on sterile petri dishes.
Cylinders (10 mm diameter) were cut from the center of potato tissue (skin
portion was eliminated) and placed in sterile distilled water. Cylinders were
66rinsed twice more. Each cylinder was cut into 0.5 cm discs after excluding 1 cm
end pieces. These discs were transferred to 24-well culture plates containing
water-agar (15 g/l). One well plate (24 cell wells) was used for each
experiment; each experiment had 24 replicates. Each disc was overlaid with 50
ul of appropriate inoculum. No more than 30 min elapsed between cutting the
potato discs and inoculation (McLaughlin, 1991). Plates were incubated at
room temperature (25 °C) in the dark for 2 weeks. After 2 weeks, disks were
stained with Lugol's reagent (I2KlI; 5% lp plus 10% KI in distilled water) and
tumors on each disc were counted. Lugol's reagent stains the starch in potato
tissue to dark blue to dark brown color, but the tumors do not take up the stain
and appear creamy to orange. Experiments were repeated three times.
Percent inhibition of tumors was calculated (McLaughlin, 1991; McLaughlin et
al., 1993; McLaughlin and Rogers, 1998)
Significant activity was indicated when two or more independent assays
gave consistently negative values of approximately 20% or greater inhibition.
4.2.4, Brine shrimp bioassay
Brine shrimp (Artemia salina Leach) eggs (San Francisco Bay Brand,
Inc.) were purchased from a pet store. Seawater was prepared by dissolving 36
g sea salt (Instant Ocean Salt Mix, Aquatic Eco-Systems, Inc. Florida) in 1 liter
of distilled water and put in V-shaped, Plexiglas hatching container. Oxygen
was supplied and 60-watt lamp was positioned near the container to provide
direct light and heat (~ 27-28 °C). One-teaspoon brine shrimp eggs were
67placed in 1 liter of seawater. After 10 to 12 hr, cysts began hatching, Two days
was allowed for the shrimp to hatch and mature as nauplii (Figure 4.1) (shrimp
can be used 48-72 hrs after the initiation of hatching). After 72 hr they should
be discarded (Mclaughlin et al., 1991), Nauplii were harvested by turning off the
aeration and letting the culture settle for about 10 min, Hatched, empty shells
floated on the surface and unhatched cysts sank to the bottom. Newly hatched
nauplii concentrated just above the unhatched cysts on the bottom. Since the
nauplii are positively phototropic (attracted to light), shining a light at the middle
of the container and shading the container at the bottom helped direct them’ to
an area where they can be easily harvested by siphoning or draining (Hoff and
Snell, 1987). Stock solutions of extracts and other commercial products (Table
4.1) were prepared by suspending dried extract in saltwater to prepare a 10,000
mg/ml solution. The suspension was mixed for 5 min; then, 1000, 100 and 10
mg/l solutions were prepared by dilution. Twenty-four-well culture plates were
used. A suspension of nauplii was removed and 10 nauplii were placed into
each well and 2.5 ml of appropriate concentration of extract+salt mixture was
added. Uncovered plates were incubated for 24 hr at room temperature under
illumination. There were three replicates for each concentration (10,000, 1000,
100, 10 mg/l) and experiments were repeated three times. The same saline
solution used to prepare the stock test sample solution was used as a negative
control. As a positive control, MS-222 (tricaine methane sulfonate, Aquatic Eco-
Systems, Inc. Florida), a common fish anesthesizer, was used at concentrations
of 1, 10, 100, 1000 mg/l.
68