Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Worldwide
S. Bauer and B. J. Hoye
Science 344, (2014);
DOI: 10.1126/science.1242552
If you wish to distribute this article to others, you can order high-quality copies for your
colleagues, clients, or customers by clicking here.
Permission to republish or repurpose articles or portions of articles can be obtained by
following the guidelines here.
Science (print ISSN 0036-8075; online ISSN 1095-9203) is published weekly, except the last week in December, by the
American Association for the Advancement of Science, 1200 New York Avenue NW, Washington, DC 20005. Copyright
2014 by the American Association for the Advancement of Science; all rights reserved. The title Science is a
registered trademark of AAAS.
REVIEW SUMMARY
Migratory animals link resident communities
READ THE FULL ARTICLE ONLINE
across the globe.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1126/science.1242552
CREDIT IN ORDER OF APPEARANCE: J. B. ARMSTRONG, B. J. HOYE, A. K. GLOVER, M. D. TUTTLE (BAT CONSERVATION INTERNATIONAL), J. WALDENSTRÖM, B. J. HOYE, BIKERIDERLONDON (SHUTTERSTOCK.COM),
Background: Every year, billions of migratory animals cross the planet in interactions between plant species, and ultimately, the composition and
pursuit of increased foraging opportunities, improved safety, and higher long-term persistence of the entire plant community. The most striking
reproductive output. In so doing, these migrants transport nutrients, difference between migrant and resident consumers is, however, the
energy, and other organisms (including seeds, mollusks, parasites, and pulsed nature of migrant utilization and the timing of their interactions.
pathogens) between disparate locations. Migrants also forage and are Together, these fundamentally define the relationship between migrant
preyed upon throughout their journeys, thereby establishing transport abundance and primary production (in the case of migrant herbivores) or
and trophic interactions with resident communities. Migratory animals the stability of food webs (in the case of migratory predators).
thus couple ecological communities across the globe and may mediate
their diversity and stability. However, as yet, the influence of migrants and Outlook: Our Review demonstrates that the highly predictable, season-
their services on these communities is often overlooked, and as a conse- ally pulsed nature of animal migration, together with the spatial scales
quence of global changes, migrations are threatened worldwide. at which it operates and the immense number of individuals involved, not
only set migration apart from other types of movement, but render it a
Advances: We review several examples in which interactions between uniquely potent, yet underappreciated, dimension of biodiversity that is
migratory animals and resident communities have been quantified, illus- intimately embedded within resident communities. Given the potential
trating the processes by which migrants may uniquely alter energy flow, for migration to influence ecological networks worldwide, we suggest
food-web topology and stability, trophic cascades, and the structure and integrative network approaches, through which studies of community
dynamics of (meta-)communities. For example, the inputs of nutrients and dynamics and ecosystem functioning may explicitly consider animal
energy originating from distant localities by migrants can dramatically migrations, understand the ramifications of their declines, and assist in
increase resource availability, with rippling consequences for productiv- developing effective conservation measures.
ity at various trophic levels and
the potential to drive the tran-
sition between alternative sta-
ble states. Migrant-mediated
transport of propagules of
other organisms can lead to the
establishment of new or lost
species, as well as influencing
gene flow and genetic mixing
among resident populations.
TROPHIC
digestive tract (26) and through deposition, ger-
mination, and competition in the resident com-
munity must also be assessed in order to quantify
TRANSPORT
Northern fulmar
(Fulmarus glacialus) Fertilize otherwise nutrient-poor terrestrial systems
Breed along Arctic coastlines in large colonies; (breeding sites) with vast quantities of marine-derived
migrate to more southerly waters outside nutrients (18,19)
breeding season
TRANSPORT EFFECTS
Mallard
Transport freshwater molluscs & plant seeds,
(Anas platyrhynchos)
internally & externally, over potentially considerable
Partial migrants - northernmost breeding
Propagules
Old-world songbirds
Migrants harbor haemosporidian parasites from
(Passeriformes)
breeding & wintering ranges, suggesting transmission
Many species breed in northern Europe & with residents across migratory range (32)
Parasites
Bewick’s swan
(Cygnus columbianus bewickii) Avian influenza virus infection linked to foraging
during autumn mighration; potentially increase
Breed on tundra in Arctic Russia, return to
terrestrial transmission in winter (37)
western Europe in autumn
Desert locust
(Schistocerca gregaria) Consumes its own mass daily; when gregarious grazing
Migrate 100s of km in search of food may devastate agricultural crops (40,41)
Herbivores
Wildebeest spp.
(Connochaetes spp.) Migrants increase primary productivity, with the timing
of grazing decoupled from the timing of
TROPHIC EFFECTS
Army cutworm
(Euxoa auxiliaris)
Important food source of Grizzly bears (Ursus arctos)
Adults summer in Rocky Mountains; mate
occupying talus slopes during summer (51)
& lay eggs on Great Plains in autumn
Prey
Fig. 2. Key examples of migrant-induced changes to the dynamics of resident community processes. [Photo credits in order of appearance: J. B. Armstrong,
B. J. Hoye, A. K. Glover, M. D. Tuttle (Bat Conservation International), J. Waldenström, B. J. Hoye, bikeriderlondon (shutterstock.com), S. Uryadnikov (shutterstock.com),
J. Brodersen, D. White Jr., and J. Bêty].
Ecosystem
Transport of Input can alter
Baseline nutrient levels, ratios, Soil, topography, precipitation,
Nutrients Nutrient levels & turnover
productivity, transition to temperature; stochasticity &
Energy alternative stable state Resistance, resilience, stability seasonality of these
Transport effects
Community
Community attributes
(Propagules Establishment of new or Germination, establishment,
competition, niche availability Species identity, pool, richness
of) other lost species, genetic & composition, phenology
organisms mixing of populations Gene exchange (mating, mate choice)
Presence of potential host &
Transmission to other Contact rates, prevalence, vector species
Parasites hosts, disease outbreaks susceptibility of potential hosts
Fig. 3. The transport and trophic effects that migratory animals exert on resident communities critically depend on the attributes of communities
and ecosystems.
Fig. 4. Migratory herbivores furnish a smorgasbord for resident lions at both ends of their migratory range in the Serengeti. [©www.iStockphoto.
com/GlobalP]