Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Rubric Defense
Rubric Defense
Total
Aspect Exemplary Accomplished Poor Score
Points
The content is clear and concise and deals The content is vague in conveying the
The content provides persuasive
with important issue in the field of study. point of view and does create a strong 20
Content information and is accurate.
Information is accurate sense of purpose.
Presents information in logical, interesting Presents information in logical sequence Audience has difficulty following the
15
Organization sequence which audience can follow. which audience can follow. presentation because students jump around.
Maintains eye contact with audience, Occasionally uses eye contact, but still
Reads all of report with no eye contact 10
Eye Contact seldom returning to notes. reads most of the report.
Uses a clear voice and correct, precise Voice is clear. Pronounces most word Mumbles. Incorrectly pronounces terms
pronunciation of terms so that all audience correctly. Most audience can hear the and speaks too quietly for audience in the 15
Elocution
members can hear presentation. presentation back of class to hear.
PowerPoint Graphics explain and reinforce screen text. Graphics relate to text and are readable Uses graphics that rarely support text and 20
Slides Graphics are clear and easy to follow. No with minor misspellings and grammatical presentation. Texts are difficult to read and
misspellings or grammatical errors. Texts
errors. Texts are readable. understand.
are readable.
REMARKS:
_________________________________________________
Panel Member
Total
Aspect Exemplary Accomplished Poor Score
Points
The content is clear and concise and deals The content is vague in conveying the
The content provides persuasive
with important issue in the field of study. point of view and does create a strong 20
Content information and is accurate.
Information is accurate sense of purpose.
Presents information in logical, interesting Presents information in logical sequence Audience has difficulty following the
15
Organization sequence which audience can follow. which audience can follow. presentation because students jump around.
Maintains eye contact with audience, Occasionally uses eye contact, but still
Reads all of report with no eye contact 10
Eye Contact seldom returning to notes. reads most of the report.
Uses a clear voice and correct, precise Voice is clear. Pronounces most word Mumbles. Incorrectly pronounces terms
pronunciation of terms so that all audience correctly. Most audience can hear the and speaks too quietly for audience in the 15
Elocution
members can hear presentation. presentation back of class to hear.
Graphics explain and reinforce screen text.
Graphics relate to text and are readable Uses graphics that rarely support text and
Graphics are clear and easy to follow. No
PowerPoint with minor misspellings and grammatical presentation. Texts are difficult to read and 20
misspellings or grammatical errors. Texts
Slides errors. Texts are readable. understand.
are readable.
REMARKS:
_________________________________________________
Panel Member
Total
Aspect Exemplary Accomplished Poor Score
Points
The content is clear and concise and deals The content is vague in conveying the
The content provides persuasive
with important issue in the field of study. point of view and does create a strong 20
Content information and is accurate.
Information is accurate sense of purpose.
Presents information in logical, interesting Presents information in logical sequence Audience has difficulty following the
15
Organization sequence which audience can follow. which audience can follow. presentation because students jump around.
Maintains eye contact with audience, Occasionally uses eye contact, but still
Reads all of report with no eye contact 10
Eye Contact seldom returning to notes. reads most of the report.
Uses a clear voice and correct, precise Voice is clear. Pronounces most word Mumbles. Incorrectly pronounces terms
pronunciation of terms so that all audience correctly. Most audience can hear the and speaks too quietly for audience in the 15
Elocution
members can hear presentation. presentation back of class to hear.
PowerPoint Graphics explain and reinforce screen text. Graphics relate to text and are readable Uses graphics that rarely support text and 20
Slides Graphics are clear and easy to follow. No with minor misspellings and grammatical presentation. Texts are difficult to read and
misspellings or grammatical errors. Texts
errors. Texts are readable. understand.
are readable.
REMARKS:
_________________________________________________
Panel Member
Total
Aspect Exemplary Accomplished Poor Score
Points
The content is clear and concise and deals The content is vague in conveying the
The content provides persuasive
with important issue in the field of study. point of view and does create a strong 20
Content information and is accurate.
Information is accurate sense of purpose.
Presents information in logical, interesting Presents information in logical sequence Audience has difficulty following the
15
Organization sequence which audience can follow. which audience can follow. presentation because students jump around.
Maintains eye contact with audience, Occasionally uses eye contact, but still
Reads all of report with no eye contact 10
Eye Contact seldom returning to notes. reads most of the report.
Uses a clear voice and correct, precise Voice is clear. Pronounces most word Mumbles. Incorrectly pronounces terms
pronunciation of terms so that all audience correctly. Most audience can hear the and speaks too quietly for audience in the 15
Elocution
members can hear presentation. presentation back of class to hear.
Graphics explain and reinforce screen text.
Graphics relate to text and are readable Uses graphics that rarely support text and
Graphics are clear and easy to follow. No
PowerPoint with minor misspellings and grammatical presentation. Texts are difficult to read and 20
misspellings or grammatical errors. Texts
Slides errors. Texts are readable. understand.
are readable.
REMARKS:
IN EFFICIENCY
_________________________________________________
Panel Member
Total
Aspect Exemplary Accomplished Poor Score
Points
The content is clear and concise and deals The content is vague in conveying the
The content provides persuasive
with important issue in the field of study. point of view and does create a strong 20
Content information and is accurate.
Information is accurate sense of purpose.
Presents information in logical, interesting Presents information in logical sequence Audience has difficulty following the
15
Organization sequence which audience can follow. which audience can follow. presentation because students jump around.
Maintains eye contact with audience, Occasionally uses eye contact, but still
Reads all of report with no eye contact 10
Eye Contact seldom returning to notes. reads most of the report.
Uses a clear voice and correct, precise Voice is clear. Pronounces most word Mumbles. Incorrectly pronounces terms
pronunciation of terms so that all audience correctly. Most audience can hear the and speaks too quietly for audience in the 15
Elocution
members can hear presentation. presentation back of class to hear.
PowerPoint Graphics explain and reinforce screen text. Graphics relate to text and are readable Uses graphics that rarely support text and 20
Slides Graphics are clear and easy to follow. No with minor misspellings and grammatical presentation. Texts are difficult to read and
misspellings or grammatical errors. Texts
errors. Texts are readable. understand.
are readable.
REMARKS:
_________________________________________________
Panel Member
Total
Aspect Exemplary Accomplished Poor Score
Points
The content is clear and concise and deals The content is vague in conveying the
The content provides persuasive
with important issue in the field of study. point of view and does create a strong 20
Content information and is accurate.
Information is accurate sense of purpose.
Presents information in logical, interesting Presents information in logical sequence Audience has difficulty following the
15
Organization sequence which audience can follow. which audience can follow. presentation because students jump around.
Maintains eye contact with audience, Occasionally uses eye contact, but still
Reads all of report with no eye contact 10
Eye Contact seldom returning to notes. reads most of the report.
Uses a clear voice and correct, precise Voice is clear. Pronounces most word Mumbles. Incorrectly pronounces terms
pronunciation of terms so that all audience correctly. Most audience can hear the and speaks too quietly for audience in the 15
Elocution
members can hear presentation. presentation back of class to hear.
Graphics explain and reinforce screen text.
Graphics relate to text and are readable Uses graphics that rarely support text and
Graphics are clear and easy to follow. No
PowerPoint with minor misspellings and grammatical presentation. Texts are difficult to read and 20
misspellings or grammatical errors. Texts
Slides errors. Texts are readable. understand.
are readable.
REMARKS:
_________________________________________________
Panel Member
Total
Aspect Exemplary Accomplished Poor Score
Points
The content is clear and concise and deals The content is vague in conveying the
The content provides persuasive
with important issue in the field of study. point of view and does create a strong 20
Content information and is accurate.
Information is accurate sense of purpose.
Presents information in logical, interesting Presents information in logical sequence Audience has difficulty following the
15
Organization sequence which audience can follow. which audience can follow. presentation because students jump around.
Maintains eye contact with audience, Occasionally uses eye contact, but still
Reads all of report with no eye contact 10
Eye Contact seldom returning to notes. reads most of the report.
Uses a clear voice and correct, precise Voice is clear. Pronounces most word Mumbles. Incorrectly pronounces terms
pronunciation of terms so that all audience correctly. Most audience can hear the and speaks too quietly for audience in the 15
Elocution
members can hear presentation. presentation back of class to hear.
PowerPoint Graphics explain and reinforce screen text. Graphics relate to text and are readable Uses graphics that rarely support text and 20
Slides Graphics are clear and easy to follow. No with minor misspellings and grammatical presentation. Texts are difficult to read and
misspellings or grammatical errors. Texts
errors. Texts are readable. understand.
are readable.
REMARKS:
_________________________________________________
Panel Member
Total
Aspect Exemplary Accomplished Poor Score
Points
The content is clear and concise and deals The content is vague in conveying the
The content provides persuasive
with important issue in the field of study. point of view and does create a strong 20
Content information and is accurate.
Information is accurate sense of purpose.
Presents information in logical, interesting Presents information in logical sequence Audience has difficulty following the
15
Organization sequence which audience can follow. which audience can follow. presentation because students jump around.
Maintains eye contact with audience, Occasionally uses eye contact, but still
Reads all of report with no eye contact 10
Eye Contact seldom returning to notes. reads most of the report.
Uses a clear voice and correct, precise Voice is clear. Pronounces most word Mumbles. Incorrectly pronounces terms
pronunciation of terms so that all audience correctly. Most audience can hear the and speaks too quietly for audience in the 15
Elocution
members can hear presentation. presentation back of class to hear.
Graphics explain and reinforce screen text.
Graphics relate to text and are readable Uses graphics that rarely support text and
Graphics are clear and easy to follow. No
PowerPoint with minor misspellings and grammatical presentation. Texts are difficult to read and 20
misspellings or grammatical errors. Texts
Slides errors. Texts are readable. understand.
are readable.
REMARKS:
_________________________________________________
Panel Member