There are many possibilities for improving train punctuality. For example, after a disastrous year in 2002 with 7% of trains canceled, a 17 million euro project was initiated to improve punctuality. However, cost-benefit analyses are scarce despite large investments in punctuality projects. Decisions should be based on a quantitative trade-off between investments and improvements in punctuality, services, and travel characteristics. The research also led to a better understanding of timetabling norms, which when applied, will lead to more robust timetables or provide a scientific basis for the current norms.
There are many possibilities for improving train punctuality. For example, after a disastrous year in 2002 with 7% of trains canceled, a 17 million euro project was initiated to improve punctuality. However, cost-benefit analyses are scarce despite large investments in punctuality projects. Decisions should be based on a quantitative trade-off between investments and improvements in punctuality, services, and travel characteristics. The research also led to a better understanding of timetabling norms, which when applied, will lead to more robust timetables or provide a scientific basis for the current norms.
There are many possibilities for improving train punctuality. For example, after a disastrous year in 2002 with 7% of trains canceled, a 17 million euro project was initiated to improve punctuality. However, cost-benefit analyses are scarce despite large investments in punctuality projects. Decisions should be based on a quantitative trade-off between investments and improvements in punctuality, services, and travel characteristics. The research also led to a better understanding of timetabling norms, which when applied, will lead to more robust timetables or provide a scientific basis for the current norms.
There are many possibilities for the improvement of punctuality.
For example, after the
disastrous fall of 2002, when 7% of all trains had to be canceled, a 17 million euro project was initiated to improve the punctuality. However, well-founded cost-benefit analyses are scarce, despite the enormous investments that are involved in some projects aimed at improving the punctuality. Decisions should be based on a quantitatively supported trade-off between the investments and the improvements in punctuality, other services and travel-characteristics. Furthermore, our research has led to a better understanding of timetabling norms. Applying these insights will lead to more robust timetables, or give the current norms a scientific foundation. 1.5 Outline of the Thesis Chapter 2 introduces the railway planning process to the reader, and more specifically the Dutch situation. It then also describes disturbances and delay propagation, and how planning can help to improve reliability. Furthermore, performance measures and perception are discussed. Finally a literature review is given. In Chapter 3, existing timetabling models and timetable evaluation models are discussed. The first part focuses on timetabling models. More specifically, the timetabling tool DONS is discussed. Later, two types of timetable evaluation models are discussed. First, the focus is on models based on max-plus algebra. After that, simulation is addressed as a way to evaluate timetables. In particular, the simulation tool SIMONE is discussed. In the following chapters several timetabling characteristics are investigated. Chapter 4 focuses on the distribution of running time supplements. This problem is researched by an analytical model, a numerical approach and simulation. All these methods show that the proportional supplement allocation used in practice is not optimal with regard to average arrival delays. This is followed in Chapter 5 by a closer look at the influences of heterogeneity of railway traffic on the reliability. First, new heterogeneity measures are developed. Then both a theoretical and a practical simulation case are worked out. These cases both analyze the influence of the heterogeneity on reliability, and the appropriateness of the new heterogeneity measures. In Chapter 6, an innovative stochastic optimization model is introduced. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first optimization model that takes the delay propagation explicitly into account. The model is able to decrease the average delay of existing timetables considerably within the model settings. The model can be used in different settings, of which the standard version can handle a large subnetwork. 18 Chapter 1. Introduction Chapter 7 is the concluding chapter. First the results from the earlier chapters are discussed. Then we relate these results to the research questions, that are described in Section 1.3. Finally, some recommendations for further research are given.