You are on page 1of 115

Förband

Förband är ofta
dimensionerande i
träkonstruktioner

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Fuktegenskaper
Träets fuktkvot strävar efter att stå i jämvikt med omgivningens relativa ånghalt
och temperatur.
Fuktkvotens förändringar sker i allmänhet långsamt och kan ytterligare bromsas
genom lämplig ytbehandling.

Exempel:
-Inomhustemperatur T=20o
-Inomhus rel. ånghalt: RH=50%

~8%
Jämviktsfuktkvot: u = ~ 8%

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Fuktegenskaper
Förändring i fuktkvoten kan vara:
- 2-4% för trä inomhus
- 8-10% för trä utomhus.

Krympning/svällning
− βt ≈ 0,2% (dvs. 0,002) i tvärriktning
− βL ≈ 0,01% (dvs. 0,0001) i längdriktning

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Fuktegenskaper
Exempel 1:
- balk 140 x 1000 x 10000
-Fuktkvot vid leverans: ui = 12%
∆ω = (uf-ui)·100 = 5
-Fuktkvot efter , t.ex. 10 mån: uf = 17%

Rörelser i
1000+∆h

tvärriktning
∆b = β ·∆ω·b= 0,002 x 5 x 140 = 1,4 mm
1000

∆h = βt·∆ω·h= 0,002 x 5 x 1000 = 10 mm

140 140+∆b

Rörelser i längdriktning
∆L = βL·∆ω·L= 0,0001 x 5 x 10000 = 5 mm

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Gör inte så här:

Tjock stålplåt och relativt stort avstånd mellan skruvarna. När träet krymper,
rörelsen förhindras av beslaget. Balken spricker!!

Lösning: Använd ovala (i vertikalled!) hål

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Type of joints

• Traditional or carpentry joints

• Modern connections

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Traditional or carpentry joints

Half-lap

Framed

Tenon

After
Leijten

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


CNC machines

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


”Dove tail joint”

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Advanced jointing technique

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Common problems with
carpentry joints

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Let us take a look to some
modern joints

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Hinged (pinned) connection between beams

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Hinged (pinned) connection between beams

After H. J. Blaß

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Hinged (pinned) connection between beams

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Hinged (pinned) connection between beams

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Hinged connection at the base of a column

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Gerber hinge

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Moment resistant connection, beam-to-beam

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Idrottshall i Livorno
D max= 109 m
H max= 33,3 m
R60
Jordbävning

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Momentstyva skarvar

Momentstyv skarv
i ståltryckringen
vid nocken
Momentstyv skarv
Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/
Moment resistant connection, at the base of a
column

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Moment resistant connection, beam-to-column

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Connections in a three-hinge portal frame

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Node in a truss

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


”Real hinges” (adequate for large structures)

Crown

abutment

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


”Real hinges” (suitable for large structures)

Abutment

Crown

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Undvik förband som kan ge upphov till
krafter vinkelrätt fiberriktningen

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Hög risk för fläkning

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Rainier Beach Library, Seattle,
Washington
• fackverk
• limträ, genomgående över-
och underram, diagonaler och
vertikaler dimensionerades
som ledad infästa
• förband med bultar (1 in) och
utanpåliggande stålplåtar
(tvärsnitt 3 in x ¼ in)

• spricka längs
bultarna

orsak?

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Rainier Beach Library, Seattle,
Washington
• styva långa stålplåtar med
många bultar ger inte ledad
infästning utan delvis inspänd
infästning
rotationen hindrades när
fackverket deformerades
under last

kraft vinkelrätt fiberriktningen


brott

diagonal byts ut, nytt förband


som förstärks med skruvar
vinkelrätt fiberriktningen

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Different types of joints and
connectors
• Glued connections
• Ring, toothed-plate and shear connections
• Punched metal plate connections
• Dowel-type connections
• Screwed connections
• Glued-in rods

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Behaviour of fastners: typical
load-slip curves
F/ Fmax Glue Nail plate Bolt with pressed metal plate

Nail 3 nails in a line

0.5
Bolt with inlaid metal plate

Wooden screw, dowel

Bolt

Slip [mm]
0 2 4 6 8

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Glued Joints

• Scarf joints

• Finger Joints

• Glued-in rods

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


• Advantages:
- High stiffness and high strength
- Very automated process
- Very economic for applications such as: finger joints, glulam,
etc
• Disadvantages:
- Very sensitive to unskilled manufacture
- Requires manufacture control
- Should not be performed on-site
- Brittle failure
- Very sensitive to shrinkage and swelling of the wood

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Bond between members

What is the
adhesive for?
-Fills the voids
between wooden
members
-Produces
adhesive bonds to
each members
Wood
cells
After S. Aicher

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Stiffness

The stiffness of the joint depends upon


the thickness of the bond line. For
common adhesives
Thickness (mm) Shear modulus (MPa)
0,1 1300-1800

0,4 700-850

0,8 600

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Types of adhesives
According to EN 301

• Type I: outdoors exposure, T>50 oC


• Type II: indoor or outdoor but protected from the weather

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Common adhesives: Phenol-resorcinol-
formaldehyde (PRF)

- Adhesive type: I, according to EN 301;

- Curing: room temperature or at elevated


temperature (high-frequency curing, for faster
curing);

- Properties: dark, thickness up to 2 mm


(“gapfilling”)

- Use: glulam, finger joints, overlap joints, nail


and screw-gluing, etc
Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/
Common adhesives: Melamine-Urea-
formaldehyde (MUF)

- Adhesive type: I, according to EN 301;

- Curing: room temperature or at elevated


temperature (high-frequency curing, for faster
curing);

- Properties: light, thickness about 0,1mm

- Use: glulam, finger joints,

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Common adhesives: Polyuretheans (PUR)

- Adhesive type: II, according to EN 301;

- Curing: room temperature

- Properties: Ductile behaviour, lower shear


strength than PRF and MUF

- Use: finger joints, glued-in rods, etc


Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/
Common adhesives: Epoxy resins (EP)

- Adhesive type: I, according to EN 301;

- Curing: room temperature

- Properties: Ductile or brittle behaviour,


depending on the type

- Use: glued-in rods, metal-to-wood connections,


repairing of wood with decay (casting)

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Some applications of glued
joints– overlap joints

Normally plywood or Kerto-Q plates are nail-glued to the


truss members
Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/
An example

After S. Aicher

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Scarf joints

• From the purely technical point of view, it is the jointing


method delivering the highest strength
• (It is the forerunner of the finger joint)
• Still today, it can be used for some specific application, for
example for jointing two large glulam elements

• Uneconomic due to high loss of timber


• Expensive cramping arrangement (but could be probably
performed by means of screw-gluing – in combination with
gapfilling adhesives)

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Equilibrium
y
ξ
η
σ
t
α x
σ xt
L t α
ση ⋅ t
sin α τ⋅
sin α
  t   t 
 Σ ( F ) = 0 ⇒  σ ⋅  sin α +  τ ⋅  cos α = σ ⋅ t cos α
Σ(F ) y = 0 ⇒ τ = σ η ⋅
η
x
 sin α   sin α 

 Σ(F ) y = 0 ⇒  σ η ⋅ t  cos α + τ ⋅ t  ⋅ sin α = 0 sin α
  sin α   sin α 

 cos 2 α   cos 2 α   1 
Σ(F ) x = 0 ⇒ σ η + σ η ⋅   = σ ⇒ σ = σ η ⋅ 1 + 
 = σ ⋅
η   ⇒ σ η = σ ⋅ sin α
2

 sin α   sin α   sin α 


2 2 2

cos α
(
Σ(F ) y = 0 ⇒ τ = σ ⋅ sin 2 α ⋅ ) sin α
⇒ τ = σ ⋅ sin α ⋅ cos α

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Peel stress and shear stress
t

L/t After S. Aicher

-The peel stress ση drops rapidly with decreasing slope. It is


negligible for l/t>10
-FE analyses show that shear stress is almost uniformly distributed
along the bond line (no stress peaks at the overlap ends)

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Optimum slope
• To obtain a “good joint” the shear strength of the joint
should be larger than the tensile strength of the timber.
Disregarding the peel stresses ση :
σ 1
τ = σ ⋅ sin α ⋅ cos α ⇒ =
τ sin α ⋅ cos α

• With τ = fv and σ =ft,0 (for small slopes fv0 ~ fv,a ) and


keeping in mind that for softwood ft,0 / fv ~ 6

1 l
≈ 6 ⇒ α ≈ 10 ⇒ ≈ 6
0

sin α ⋅ cos α t

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


• However, for such a slope the peeling
stresses may still be too large. Therefore,
it is recommended to use the following
slope:
t α

L
α ≈ 5 −6 ⇒ 0
≈ 10
0

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Finger joints
l

τ
γ σ p

τ
The joint should be stronger than the base
material. Therefore (disregarding the peel
stresses):
 l  σ 2⋅l
σ ⋅ p ≤  2 ⋅τ ⋅  ⋅ cos γ = 0 ⇒ ≤
 cos γ  τ p
The ratio of tensile strength to shear strength is approx. ft / fv≈6
2⋅l l
≥ 6 ⇒ ≥ 3,0
p p

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


l
p
3,9
3,2
4
5,2
After S. Aicher

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Spannbandbrücke över „Main-Donau“ kanal vid Essing

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Finger visible on the flat or on the
narrow side
f m , flatwise
Define: kf =
f m ,edgewise

Kf ~ 1 Kf ~ 1,1-1,3

The reason for fm,flat > fm,edge are related to


defects/deficiencies:
- Outer fingers less glued and cramped than inner finger

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Dowel type Connections

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Dowel type fasteners

- Bolt

After H. J. Blaß

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Dowel type fasteners

- Dowel

After H. J. Blaß

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Dowel type fasteners

-Threaded rod

After H. J. Blaß

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Dowel type fasteners

Nails

Brad (dyckert), round nail, grooved wire nail (räfflad trådspik),


annular ring shanked nail (kamspik) or anchor nail (ankarspik)

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Dowel type fasteners
Nails are often inserted
by means of a
pneumatic nailer

After H. J. Blaß

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Dowel type fasteners
- Screw Self-tapping screws

Coach screws

After H. J. Blaß

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Dowel type fasteners
-Special dowels

(d=5-7mm, can perforate


up to 3 plates, t=5mm)

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Some applications of self-drilling dowels

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Some preliminary observations

Plastic
deformation
Crashed timber

Nail pulled out

Relative After H. J.
displacement Blaß

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Parameters influencing the load-carrying
behaviour
• The bending capacity of the dowel (mainly depends on “d”
and “fy”)

• Embedding capacity of the timber (primarily depends upon


“ρ”)

• The withdrawal capacity of the fastener (threaded


connectors or connectors with washer and screw head/nut
provide higher capacity than smooth fasteners)

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Johansen’s yield theory

• Rigid-plastic behaviour of the fastener in bending


• Rigid-plastic behaviour of the timber in embedding

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Behaviour of the fastener (Johansen)

After H. J. Blaß

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Bending capacity
Dowel Elastic Plastic
fy fy For a half circle:
2⋅d
pg e=
3⋅π
d e pg π ⋅d2
M A=
8
fy fy

Two limit cases for the yield


moment 3
π ⋅d
1. M el = f y ⋅W = f y ⋅
32
 π ⋅d2 2⋅d  d3
2. M pl = f y ⋅ Z = f y ⋅ ( A ⋅ 2 ⋅ e) = f y ⋅  ⋅ 2⋅  = f y ⋅
 8 3⋅π  6

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


⌠sin2α= ⌠1/2[1-cos(2α)]=a/2 - sin(2α)/4

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Plastic bending capacity

• A full yielding of the cross section requires:

- Large strains large bending angle (up to 450)

• However, in general, when the connection fails, the bending


angle is considerably less than 450. Therefore, Blaß proposes
the following formula:

M pl = 0,3 ⋅ f u ⋅ d 2, 6 (Nmm)

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Plastic bending capacity
1,600

Plastic bending capacity (kNm)


1,400

1,200
1,000
theory
0,800
EC5
0,600

0,400
0,200
0,000
8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30
Diameter (mm)

Assumption: fy=355 MPa fu= 510 MPa

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Yield moment for smooth nails
(with fu,min= 600 MPa)

0,3 f u d 2, 6 Round
M pl =
0,45 f u d 2, 6
Square

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Brittle failure is not allowed!

After H. J. Blaß

High strength steels (e.g. 8.8 or 10.9) have a more brittle


behaviour than mild steels (e.g. S235, S275 or S355)

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Behaviour of the timber
“real” stress
distribution

“assumed”
stress
distribution

Embedding strength
The embedding strength is
Fu influenced by:
f hk =
d ⋅t d: diameter of the fastener
ρ: density of the wood
α: direction of the grain

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Influence of the diameter of the
fastener

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Vinkel mellan last och fiberriktning
f 0 ⋅ f 90
fα =
f0 f 0 sin 2 α + f 90 cos 2 α

f90
α
0° 90°

F
Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/
Behaviour of the Timber (Johansen)

// grain
⊥ grain

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/
Possible failure modes
a b c d e f

1
1 shear plane

2
2 shear planes

g h i j

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Let us take a closer look to some possible
failure modes:
we start with connections with one shear
plane

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Failure modes a & b
Fy

Failure in timber, either


in the first or the second
piece
F = f h1 ⋅ t1 ⋅ d
Fy F = f h2 ⋅ t2 ⋅ d
Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/
t1 t2 Definition

fh1 (fh2) - Embedment strength


1
in timber 1 (timber 2)
2

d
β = fh2/fh1

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Failure mode c

The dowel is stiff


and change the
t1 t2
angle in relation to
fh,1 fh,2 timber. Embedding
fh,1 fh,2
a1 a1 b1 b2 a2 a2
failure in one or
both pieces of
F timber

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Failure
modes
d&e

Mf
One plastic hinge
occurs
t1 t2

fh,1
fh,1 fh,2
a1 a1 b1 b2

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/ F


Failure mode
e

F
Mf Mf

Mf Mf

t1 t2 fh,1
fh,2

fh,1 b1 b2
fh,2

b1 b2 Two plastic hinges occur in


both timber pieces
F
Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/
What is behind EC5 formulas?

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Fy

Johansen’s equations for one shear


plane

Fy
a) b) c) d) e) f)

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Johansen’s equations for two shear
planes

g h j k

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


From brittle to plastic failure
t1 t2 t3
d
d d d I

R1 R2 R3

II

Mode III
Mode Mode
I II III

λ = t/d

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Steel-to timber connections

Steel plates acts as a simple Steel plates provide a


support clamped support

 t ≤ d ⇒ thin plate

t > d ⇒ thick plate

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Steel-to timber connections
- one shear plane

a b c d e

0,4 f h ,k t1 d (a)
 Thin plates
Fv , Rk = min  Fax , Rk
1,15 ⋅ 2 M y , Rk f h ,k d + (b)
 4

 f h ,´k t1 d (c)

  4 M y , Rk  Fax , Rk Thick plates
Fv , Rk = min  f h ,k t1 d  2 + − 1 + (d)
 
2
 f h ,k dt1 4

2,3 ⋅ M Fax , Rk
 f
y , Rk h , k d + (e)
4

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Steel-to timber connections
- slotted-in plate

f g h


 f h ,´k t1 d (f)

  4M y , Rk  Fax , Rk Thin and thick
Fv , Rk = min  f h ,1,k t1 d  2 + − 1 + (g)
 
2
 f h ,1,k dt1 4 plates

2,3 ⋅ M Fax , Rk
 f
y , Rk h ,1, k d + (h)
4

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Steel-to timber connections
- two shear plane

j/l k m

0,5 f h , 2,k t 2 d (j) Thick plates



Fv , Rk = min  Fax , Rk
1,15 ⋅ 2 M f d + (k) Thin plates

y , Rk h , 2 , k
4

0,5 f h , 2,k t 2 d (l)


Thick plates

Fv , Rk = min  Fax , Rk
2,3 ⋅ 2 M y , Rk f h , 2,k d + (m) Thin plates
 4

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


The mysterious factors (1,05
and 1,15)??

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Factor 1,15

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


What is this term??

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Rope effect

R
Ftens α
∆R
Fcomp

-R is the resistance calculated according to “classic Johansen´s theory”

-In the inclined part of the fastener, tensile forces Ftens develop due to the
angle of rotation α . This give rise to a component // the joint line (∆R)

-Moreover, the compression force Ftens also increases the strength of the
connection, due to the friction between the timber parts

(∆R )Tot = ∆R + µ ⋅ Fcomp


Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/
is the characteristic axial
withdrawal capacity of the
fastener divided by 4

It is the contribution from


the rope effect should be
limited to the following %
of the Johansen part:

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


My suggestion is to be very careful with the increase in
strength due to the “rope effect”, especially for nails. The
reason is that there are not many test results showing the
long term behaviour of such connections

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Group effects in joints with dowel type
fasteners
• When several dowels in a row - along the
direction of the load - are present,
sometimes brittle failure may occur, even
though the distance prescribed by the
building code are adopted.

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Group effects in joints with dowel type
fasteners
When there are several fasteners in a row, especially in

the case of rows parallel to the grain, the loads taken by

each fastener are generally different. The reason are:

-Variation in yield moment among the fasteners

-Variation in timber density or moisture content

-etc

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Connection with only one dowel

The failure occurs when the


P
embedding strength of the
timber is reached. If there is
only one dowel in line, the final
failure occurs after rather large
plastic deformations

δ splitting

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


But, what happens if we have several
connectors in a row, in the load direction?

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Several connectors in a row (// grain):
effect of the spacing

“Wedge effect”

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Connection with more than one dowel in line

If there are more than one


P dowel in line, the failure
occurs by splitting of the
2R1k timber or by shear plug.
Fk

R1k
Fk < 2 R1k
δ

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/
Influence of several fasteners in a row
Nominell bärförmåga, förband

25

20

15 Spikavstånd 14d
Spikavstånd 7d
10 Spikavstånd 4d

5
Nail
0
0 5 10 15 20 25
Antal spik i rad (förborrning) 25

Nominell bärförmåga, förband


20

15 14d
7d
10 4d
Dowels 5

0
0 5 10 15 20 25
Antal dymlingar i rad

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


…Sometimes failure due to Plug-
shear

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


…Sometimes failure due to Splitting

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


How can we reduce the group
effect?

• Use larger distances between connector and


larger end distance

• Use more slender connectors

• Reinforce the connection

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Reinforcement of the connection
(H.J. Blaß)

Reinforced: failure due to


embedding. No group
effect

Non-reinforced: failure due


to splitting. Group effect

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/


Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/
Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/
Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/
Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/
The following failure modes are not contempled in the Johansen´s
theory!! In particular:
Failure type a) and b): is avoided by using adequate distances
Failure type c) and d) need to be checked separately

Lund University / Roberto Crocetti/

You might also like