You are on page 1of 9

http:// ijp.mums.ac.

ir
Review Article (Pages: 6713-6721)

Intergenerational Learning Program: A Bridge between


Generations
Seyedeh Zahra Aemmi1, 2,* Hossein Karimi Moonaghi3

1
PhD Candidate in Nursing, Department of Nursing, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Ahvaz Jundishapur
University of Medical Sciences, Ahvaz, Iran. 2Psychiatry and Behavioral Science Research Center, Ibn-e-Sina
Hospital, School of Medicine, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran.
3
Associate Professor, Evidence- Based Caring Research Center, Department of Medical Surgical Nursing,
School of Nursing and Midwifery and Department of Medical Education, School of Medicine, Mashhad
University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran.

Abstract
One of the goals of education can be considered the transfer of knowledge, skills, competencies,
wisdom, norms and values between generations. Intergenerational learning program provide this goal
and opportunities for lifelong learning and sharing knowledge and experience between generations.
This review aimed to investigate the benefits of this program for the children and older adult and its
application in health care systems.
An extensive literature search was conducted in some online databases such as Magiran, SID, Scopus,
EMBASE, and Medline via PubMed until July 2016 and Persian and English language publications
studied that met inclusion criteria. The review concluded that this program can be provided wonderful
resources for the social and emotional growth of the children and older adults and can be used for
caring, education and follow-up in health care systems especially by nurses. Also, this review
highlighted the need for research about this form of learning in Iran.

Key Words: Aged, Child, Education, Intergenerational learning.

*Please cite this article as: Aemmi SZ, Karimi Moonaghi H. Intergenerational Learning Program: A Bridge
between Generations. Int J Pediatr 2017; 5(12): 6713-21. DOI: 10.22038/ijp.2017.28072.2430

*
Corresponding Author:
Dr. Hossein Karimi Moonaghi, Associate Professor, Evidence- Based Caring Research Center, Department of
Medical Surgical Nursing, School of Nursing and Midwifery & Department of Medical Education, School of
Medicine, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran.
Email: karimih@mums.ac.ir
Received date: Feb.20, 2017; Accepted date: Sep. 22, 2017

Int J Pediatr, Vol.5, N.12, Serial No.48, Dec.2017 6713


Intergenerational Learning

1- INTRODUCTION Cultural Organization (UNESCO) as


"social vehicles that create purposeful and
Education is one of the most important
ongoing exchanges of resources and
necessities for the human that without it,
learning among older and younger
human is certainly would be incomplete.
generations" (7-9). Intergenerational
Having beneficial education is a
learning opportunities recommended
fundamental right for all children (1-2). In
should be provided for all children.
all societies, schools are places to educate
Societies need a re-creation and value to
children in a similar age. Today, due to
intergenerational relationships in order to
demographic changes, aging and
creating purposeful life, sharing
consequently a longer life span for human,
knowledge and experience between past
as well as changes in the family structure
and present and empathy and acceptance
has been created the deficit in
between generations. Also, the use of
intergenerational harmony and
reciprocal learning and share knowledge
cooperation. The covering this gap
and experience through intergenerational
between generations and the important role
learning in sociocultural theory has
of older people in children's education
benefits for culture and society. The theory
should not be forgotten (2-4).
of people like Dewey, Vygotsky and
The separation and limited contact Erikson support of intergenerational
between generations has disadvantages learning and this learning program is a
including lees support for meaningful form of service based learning and its
relationships and social and emotional origins go back the Foster Grandparent
growth, fewer opportunities for learning, Program in 1963 (5, 6, 9-12).
understanding, acquisition of values,
Intergenerational learning has been proved
wisdom and skills for children and youth
as an effective strategy for various groups;
and lose the opportunity to vitality, love,
provides financial, emotional and social
support, and acquisition of the new
support to various generations and has a
technological skills for older people (5).
global application. Children and older
Erik Erikson defined "generatively" as a
persons can engage and reflect the
criterion for successful aging and a
meaningful and socially relevant learning
fundamental and inherent need of human
opportunities together (2, 5, 6, 9).
(adult) to expand their attention from self
Opportunities for contact and
to others, transfer knowledge and wisdom
communication between generations
and care for younger generations. This
enable older adults to help other by
transfer of knowledge from one generation
listening, reflecting and offering advice
to the next generation may be done
and cause a sense of identity, and relieving
randomly or purposeful (3-4).
loneliness ,depression or anxiety,
On the other hand, lifelong learning improved well-being, self-esteem and
creates the opportunities for all generations cognitive ability and an increased social
to in-depth rethinking, education, learning contact for them (7, 10).
and work (not necessarily jobs) that cause
In this program, purposefully multi-
to enhance the quality of life. Systematic
generational participation and
transfer and interactions of knowledge,
collaboration provide benefits for all and
skills, competencies, wisdom, norms and
create the hope for mutual growth and
values between generations named
personal connection between generations.
intergenerational learning (5, 6).
In fact, in this program participant
Intergenerational learning programs define
complement each other and the goal is that
by the International Consortium and the
they have interaction, stimulation,
United Nations Educational, Scientific and

Int J Pediatr, Vol.5, N.12, Serial No.48, Dec.2017 6714


Aemmi and Karimi Moonaghi et al.

education, support, and provide caring for were original or review articles, and access
one another. This program has the to the full text of the articles was available.
possibility of holding in different places
such as schools, community organizations, 3- RESULTS
hospitals, kindergarten, nursing home and This program has immediate or long-
worship places (mosque) (6, 11-13). In this term and complementary or shared
program, older people can be provide benefits for both the older and younger
service for children and youth as tutor and learners. Among its advantages for both
mentor and children and young people can generations can be noted to the creation of
help in matters related to health and care, a meaningful relationship and the feeling
and teaching of new technologies such as of being valued, accepted and respected
computers or use of device to measuring and enhanced knowledge and skills (5). In
sugar and blood pressure to older people our study, the search strategy identified 63
(11). In many countries including Ohio articles that after an initial screening of
and the United States runs the titles and abstracts, 20 articles were
intergenerational school (TIS) as a model included in this review (Figure.1). The
of intergenerational programs and older effect of the intergenerational learning
adults as a mentor teach the reading and program for children and/or older adult
mathematics to children (7). This program and its application in health care systems is
is compatible with empowerment theory presented in three themes labeled ‘Benefits
and seeks to goals such as the mutual for older people,’ ‘Benefits for children’
respect, critical reflection, caring and and the ‘Application in health care
group participation between generations system’.
(5). According to the importance, necessity
and application of the intergenerational 3-1. Benefits for older people
learning program for children, older adult
and health care systems especially by The 7-year follow-up about long-term
nurses, this review aimed to explore the effects of an intergenerational program
benefits of the this program for the on functional capacity of older adults
children and older adult and its application showed that the intellectual activity and
in health care systems. active intergenerational lifestyles (interact
with children) of the older adults that
2- MATERIALS AND METHODS participated in group activities such as
playing a hand game and reading
An extensive literature search was picture books to children at
conducted in some online databases such kindergartens, elementary schools, and
as Magiran, SID, Scopus, EMBASE, and public childcare centers, were
Medline via PubMed, using the search significantly maintained/improved than
terms: "intergenerational learning", control group (4-5). Create a meaningful
"intergenerational programs", "older intergenerational relationship, serving as
adults", "intergenerational relations", and role models or mentors for student, a
"children". Searches were restricted to change in perspective about their own life
English and Persian language journals up and memoir development mentioned as a
July 1st, 2016. To ensure of search results, result of participation and positive
also was conducted a manual search of experiences of intergenerational service-
article references. Studies were included learning program for healthy older adults
and eligible if the papers surveyed the with college students (12, 14). Finding of a
effect of the intergenerational learning another study in Japan demonstrated senior
program for children and/or older adult that participated voluntarily in an
and its application in health care systems,

Int J Pediatr, Vol.5, N.12, Serial No.48, Dec.2017 6715


Intergenerational Learning

intergenerational health promotion elderly positively participated in the


program and engaged in reading picture program), and intergenerational
books to children were more improved in conversation were significantly higher in
self-rated to their health condition, social older adults that participated in the
support for other, social networks (contact intergenerational programs with preschool
with grandchildren and others around the children and these led to reinforce the
neighborhood) and physical performance interpersonal acceptance as a basic human
(e.g., hand-grip strength) (10). Older adults need in older adults (10). Promotion
that participate in teach of children in productive aging with emphasis on
public elementary schools in USA showed physical and mental health and activity
the lower rates of disability in mobility, level of senior, having meaningful
more effort to maintenance of activities, improve self-esteem and
independence, decrease in frailty, falls, and memory function, a sense of responsibility
memory decline and increased social and and morale, higher social behavior and less
psychological engagement in follow up 4, solitary behavior, decrease of depressive
8, 12, 16, 20, and 24 months later (15). symptoms and mortality rate, enhanced
problem solving skills and physical
In another study that was done in London,
mobility, change attitudes toward children,
young children and their grandparents
youth and toward self and life, increase
participate in intergenerational learning
quality of life for older adults, stimulate
program that ranging from storytelling to
lifelong learning, emotional support,
computer activities. The exchange of
increase the life expectancy and life
knowledge, enhances learning for both
satisfaction, more willingness to perform
generations, children offering new
daily activities, self-care and independence
knowledge as computer to the older
and prevent of feel the need for the use of
generation, shared understandings and new
long-term care institutions were listed as
forms of linguistic and cultural learning by
the some achievements of
using their different capabilities and
intergenerational learning program for
mature relationship formed between
older adults (11, 20-23).
grandchild/grandparent mentioned as
results of this study (16, 17).
3-2. Benefits for children
In Pennsylvania, older adults that provide The results of a study in USA showed that
internet-based tutoring for 5th-grade intergenerational learning program was
students, reported positive experience effective in improving academic
about their self-efficacy, comfort in using performance and behavior of children in
computers and awareness of the public elementary schools. Improve in
complexities that involved in using reading achievement and attention,
computers for instruction (18). Positive motivation to learn, concentration,
changes in mood and affection, enhanced decreases in disruptive classroom
quality of life and enjoyment from the behavior, improvements in school climate,
interactions with the children was report as
reduced utilization of special services in
a results of an exploratory school, self-respect, concern for others,
intergenerational program that where in propensity towards lifelong learning and
participated the older adults with mild importance for the adult health status, as
dementia and neurocognitive deficits and well as future educational and
school aged children with language or occupational achievement were the
reading concerns (19). The results of a outcomes of intergenerational learning
study in day care center in Tokyo showed program for these children (15). In a study
that the smiles, constructive behavior (the in USA, students in the second grade visit

Int J Pediatr, Vol.5, N.12, Serial No.48, Dec.2017 6716


Aemmi and Karimi Moonaghi et al.

with elderly residents at two retirement create more positive attitudes toward older
facilities as grand friends monthly and they persons and the aging process and most
work together on a craft, draw pictures, or importantly, provide emotional support
simply talk. Understanding of the needs of and empathy were reported as outcomes of
others and learn to interact with those of intergenerational learning programs for
differing abilities, influences positively on children and youth (9, 11, 21-23).
the student’s impressions of older adults,
3-3. Application in health care system
experience of giving and receiving
assistance during activities for children, Ageing is as an important stage in human
understanding and valuing for their role to life that require special attention (24).
create happiness in others were the results According to statistics of World Health
of this study for the children. All of the Organization (WHO), ageing is a growing
students said having a positive experience global phenomenon and problem (Figures
with their grand friend and recommend to 2, 3). WHO recommended for preparing
other students for having interactions with and planning to active aging and enacting
older adults to learn from them and also policies and programs that promote active
helping the older adults to be happy (16). ageing via increased participation and
reduced costs in health care system.
Children who participated in an Intergenerational learning program
intergenerational internet tutoring program introduce as one of these programs and
with older adult in Pennsylvania showed services that it can be considered as a
the improved recall, more important bridge for age differences, enhances the
information remembered from their transmission of cultural values and
reading and increased the self-efficacy of promotes the worth among all ages. This
the children (18). During an exploratory program provides intergenerational
intergenerational program, the perception activities in schools and communities and
of school-aged children with language or encourages older people to become role
reading concerns changed and became
models for active ageing and to mentor the
more positive about older adults with mild young people and provide for them this
dementia and/or cognitive deficits. Also, opportunity that assist to contribute the
changes in reading behaviors and mutual society (7, 25).
enjoyment were reported as results of this
program (19). Synergy of interaction and The intergenerational programs provide an
time and guidance that given by the opportunity of social engagement activities
grandparents caused that child to do things for older adults that it can help them to
that previously were not able to do it alone maintain mental and physical functioning
(16, 17). A transfer of traditions, values, levels and meaningful and impactful roles
culture and life-time skills were of the post-retirement (4, 17). The empowerment
benefits of reciprocity learning as a result of the elderly in care of yourself and
the intergenerational learning program for decrease of feel the need for the use of
the young learner (5-8). Significant long-term care institutions, reduce
improvements in children's academic economic costs related to the need for care,
performance and self-management skills at health and disease issues of this group of
school including reading, writing and people, create a meaningful life and
increase social skills such as cooperation, increase the quality of life, attention to the
communication, tolerance, concern and elderly as social capital that all of these are
respect for the limitations of others, a part of the benefits of this program (8,
decrease negative behavior, prevention 11, 24).
program for at-risk high school students,

Int J Pediatr, Vol.5, N.12, Serial No.48, Dec.2017 6717


Intergenerational Learning

Fig.1: Flowchart search strategy.

Fig.2: The number of people over age 60 in less and more developed regions, in 1970, 2000 and 2025
(25).

Int J Pediatr, Vol.5, N.12, Serial No.48, Dec.2017 6718


Aemmi and Karimi Moonaghi et al.

Fig.3: Distribution of world population over age 60 by regions in 2002 and 2025 (25).

4- DISCUSSION health and the affect (happier, calmer, and


more valued) of older adults (29, 30). Of
The main objective of this review
course, the benefits of this enjoyable
was to investigate the benefits of the
program not be limited to improve the
intergenerational learning program for the
mental performance and it demonstrated
children and older adults and its
some positive outcomes regarding the
application in health care systems. In all
physical activity such as to reach target
studies that above mentioned,
heart rate and levels of perceived exertion
intergenerational learning and program had
for older adults and children, as a
a positive effect for children, older adults
promising obesity prevention program for
and in the healthcare system. The need of
older adult and children to the caring, children and improve the health habits of
children (physical activity, health
attention and learning can be provided in
education and nutrition behavior practices)
the intergenerational communication and
(31, 32). Intergenerational learning as one
interaction (7, 9, 26). According to
of the lifelong learning methods can be
personal communication importance in
used in differently places, cultural and
health and wellbeing, create the
historical context such as schools, family
opportunities for a close and positive
life, social life and adult education (8).
intergenerational interactions between
children and older adults can be reduce the Using of this learning and training method
gap between the generations (7, 27). can be reduced costs of caring and
education for children and older adults (5,
Also, this program can be respond to the
10, 33). However the intergenerational
elderly need to more connected with the
program can be provide wonderful
society according to theory of aging (28).
resources for the social and emotional
This social engagement can be decrease
growth of the older adults and children and
the risk of cognitive impairment and
to reintegrate older adults into society but
incident dementia and has a positive and
for its success needs attention to how
protective effect on cognitive performance
programs planned, activities selection,
(age‐related hippocampal atrophy), mental
facilitation strategies, create appropriate

Int J Pediatr, Vol.5, N.12, Serial No.48, Dec.2017 6719


Intergenerational Learning

opportunities for learning, mutually 4. Chamberlain VM, Fetterman E, Maher M.


beneficial interactions, given meaningful Ninovation in elder and child care: an
roles to older adults, provide opportunities intergenerational experience. Educational
to reflect, close interaction and repeated Gerontology: An International Quarterly.
contact and finally evaluation of this 1994; 20(2):193-204.
program (7, 11). 5. Newman S, Hatton-Yeo A.
Intergenerational learning and the
4-1. Limitations of the study contributions of older people. Ageing
horizons. 2008; 8(10):31-9.
This literature review was limited by the
number and types of databases used. There 6. Hassanian ZM, Ahanchian MR, Ahmadi S,
was many articles published on Hossein Gholizadeh R, Karimi-Moonaghi H.
Knowledge creation in nursing education.
intergenerational studies may include
Glob J Health Sci. 2014;7(2):44-55.
useful information, but did not inclusion
criteria for the review in this study. 7. Morita K, Kobayashi M. Interactive
programs with preschool children bring smiles
5- CONCLUSION and conversation to older adults: time-
sampling study. BMC Geriatr. 2013;13(1):1-8.
The intergenerational learning program
has the interesting benefits for children, 8. Karimi Moonaghi H, Namdar Areshtanab
H, Jouybari L, Arshadi Bostanabad M,
older adults and in the healthcare system
McDonald H. Facilitators and barriers of
by providing a good opportunity for adaptation to diabetes: experiences of Iranian
generation interaction and it can be patients. J Diabetes Metab Disord.
considered as one of easy and convenient 2014;13(1):17.
ways of life skills training to children.
9. Marcia SM, Alicia RP, Parpura-Gill A,
Since education is one of the important
Cohen-Mansfield J. Direct observations of
roles of nurses, they can get assist of this children at risk for academic failure: benefits
form of learning for caring, education and of an intergenerational visiting program.
follow-up in these two age groups. Also Educational Gerontology. 2004;30(8):663-75.
this review highlighted the need for
research about this form of learning in 10. Fujiwara Y, Sakuma N, Ohba H, Nishi M,
Lee S, Watanabe N, et al. Reprints: effects of
Iran.
an intergenerational health promotion program
for older adults in Japan. Journal of
6- CONFLICT OF INTEREST: None. Intergenerational relationships. 2009;7(1):17-
39.
7- REFERENCES
11. Kaplan MS. School-based
1. Reyhani T, Aemmi SZ, Emami Zeydi A. intergenerational programs: Citeseer; 2001.
The effect of teacher's presence at children's
bedside on the anxiety of mothers with 12. Zucchero RA. Share your experience and
hospitalized children: A randomized clinical I'll lend you my ear: older adult outcomes of
trial. Iran J Nurs Midwifery Res. an intergenerational service-learning
2016;21(4):436-40. experience. Gerontology and Geriatrics
Education. 2010;31(4):383-402.
2. Karimi Moonaghi H, Emami Zeydi A,
Mirhaghi A. Patient education among nurses: 13. Fair CD, Delaplane E. It is good to spend
bringing evidence into clinical applicability in time with older adults. you can teach them,
Iran. Invest Educ Enferm. 2016;34(1):137- they can teach you: second grade students
151. reflect on intergenerational service learning.
Early Childhood Education Journal.
3. Park A-L. The effects of intergenerational 2015;43(1):19-26.
programmes on children and young people. Int
J Sch Cog Psychol. 2015; 2(1):1-5. 14. Mirhaghi A, Karimi Moonaghi H, Sharafi
S, Emami Zeydi A. Role Modeling: A

Int J Pediatr, Vol.5, N.12, Serial No.48, Dec.2017 6720


Aemmi and Karimi Moonaghi et al.

Precious Heritage in Medical Education. Acta 24. Kerka S. Intergenerational learning and
Facultatis Medicae Naissensis 2015;32(1):31- social capital: ERIC Clearinghouse on Adult
42. Career and Vocational Education; 2003.
15. Fried LP, Carlson MC, McGill S, Seeman 25. Active ageing: a policy framework:
T, Xue Q-L, Frick K, et al. Experience corps: a WHO; 2002. Available at:
dual trial to promote the health of older adults http://www.who.int/ageing/publications/active
and children's academic success. Contemp _ageing/en/.
Clin Trials. 2013;36(1):1-13.
26. Karasik RJ, Wallingford MS. Finding
16. Kenner C, Ruby M, Jessel J, Gregory E, community: developing and maintaining
Arju T. Intergenerational learning between effective intergenerational service-learning
children and grandparents in East London. partnerships. Educational Gerontology.
Journal of Early Childhood Research. 2007;33(9):775-93.
2007;5(3):219-43. 27. S. Bales SJE, Catherine F. Siffin,
17. Kenner C, Ruby M, Jessel J, Gregory E, Stephanie. Children's perceptions of elders
Arju T. Intergenerational learning events before and after a school-based
around the computer: a site for linguistic and intergenerational program. Educational
cultural exchange. Language and Education. Gerontology. 2000; 26(7): 677-89.
2008; 22(4): 298-319. 28. Loewen J. Intergenerational learning: what
18. Meyer BJ, Middlemiss W, Theodorou E, if schools were places where adults and
Brezinski KL, McDougall J, Bartlett BJ. children learned together? New York;1996.
Effects of structure strategy instruction 29. Sakurai R, Ishii K, Sakuma N, Yasunaga
delivered to fifth-grade children using the M, Suzuki H, Murayama Y, et al. Preventive
internet with and without the aid of older adult effects of an intergenerational program on age‐
tutors. Journal of Educational Psychology. related hippocampal atrophy in older adults:
2002;94(3):486-519. The REPRINTS study. Int J Geriatr
Psychiatry. 2017; 1–9.
19. Isaki E, Harmon MT. Children and adults
reading interactively the social benefits of an 30. Baker JR, Webster L, Lynn N, Rogers J,
exploratory intergenerational program. Belcher J. Intergenerational programs may be
Communication Disorders Quarterly. especially engaging for aged care residents
2014:1525740114529154. with cognitive impairment: findings from the
avondale intergenerational design challenge.
20. Fair CD, Davis A, Fischer V. “It makes Am J Alzheimers Dis Other Demen. 2017;
them so happy”: 4th-graders' reflections on 32(4):213-221.
intergenerational service learning. Childhood
Education. 2011; 87(3): 177-84. 31. Schroeder K, Ratcliffe SJ, Perez A, Earley
D, Bowman C, Lipman TH. Dance for health:
21. Holmes CL. An intergenerational program an intergenerational program to increase
with benefits. Early Childhood Education access to physical activity. J Pediatr Nurs.
Journal. 2009;37(2):113-9. 2017; 37: 29-34.
22. Knight T, Skouteris H, Townsend M, 32. Werner D, Teufel J, Holtgrave PL, Brown
Hooley M. The act of giving: A systematic SL. Active generations: an intergenerational
review of nonfamilial intergenerational approach to preventing childhood obesity. J
interaction. Journal of Intergenerational Sch Health. 2012; 82(8):380-6.
Relationships. 2014; 12(3): 257-78. 33. Jafari J, Karimi Moonaghi H, Zary N,
23. Roodin P, Brown LH, Shedlock D. Masiello I. Exploring educational needs and
Intergenerational service-learning: a review of design aspects of internet-enabled patient
recent literature and directions for the future. education for persons with diabetes: a
Gerontol Geriatr Educ. 2013; 34(1): 3-25. qualitative interview study. BMJ Open. 2016;
6(10): e013282.

Int J Pediatr, Vol.5, N.12, Serial No.48, Dec.2017 6721

You might also like