Professional Documents
Culture Documents
http://dx.doi.org/10.14336/AD.2021.0423
Review
ABSTRACT: Mild cognitive impairment (MCI) impacts approximately 20% of older adults, with many also
experiencing sleep disorders, such as insomnia. Given the relationship between sleep and dementia, addressing
sleep issues may offer an opportunity to treat reversible causes. There are two primary treatments for insomnia:
behavioral-based (cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia, CBT-I) and pharmacological interventions.
Although CBT-I is recommended as first-line treatment for insomnia in older adults, sedative-hypnotics are more
likely to be recommended than non-pharmacological treatments given their convenience and accessibility.
However, there are significant concerns in prescribing medications to patients with MCI. To explore this
disconnect, we reviewed insomnia treatments in older adults with MCI studies and current guidelines of
pharmacological therapy. First, we reviewed studies presenting non-pharmacological treatment of insomnia in
older adults with MCI. Although the search yielded over 4,000 non-duplicate titles, only one article presented
data on non-pharmacological treatment of insomnia in MCI. The literature covering comorbid insomnia, CBT-
I, and MCI is sparse. In contrast to review of non-pharmacological studies, studies on the pharmacological
treatment of insomnia in older adults were ample. Finally, we reviewed international guidelines for
pharmacological treatment of insomnia in cognitive disorders. More widely used pharmacological interventions
show short-term effectiveness with problems of recurrence, ineffectiveness in inadvertent or purposeful chronic
use, and adverse side effects. Despite evidence regarding adverse consequences, pharmacological treatment of
insomnia remains the most common treatment for insomnia. Reflecting on age-related changes in older adults,
particularly those with MCI, inappropriate or mismanagement of medication can lead to unnecessary
complications. Further research examining effective behavioral-based sleep management options in older adults
with cognitive impairment is needed with exploration of improved sleep on cognitive function.
Key words: sleep, sleep initiation and maintenance disorders, cognitive dysfunction, and cognitive behavioral
therapy
Mild cognitive impairment (MCI, formerly “pre- Sleep is an important factor in AD pathogenesis, where
dementia”) is an important transitional state between sleep disturbances and deprivation can increase levels of
normal cognition and dementias, such as Alzheimer’s beta-amyloid and phosphorylated tau [5], a known
disease (AD) [1, 2]. MCI affects up to 20% of older adults cardinal pathophysiological feature of AD [6, 7], and lead
and has an annual conversion to dementia of 8-15% [3, 4]. to worse global cognition [8]. Individuals with AD
*Correspondence should be addressed to: Dr. Meghan K. Mattos, University of Virginia, School of Nursing, Charlottesville, VA 22903,
USA Email: ms2bv@virginia.edu.
Copyright: © 2021 Mattos MK et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution
License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
ISSN: 2152-5250 1036
Mattos MK., et al Insomnia Treatment in Mild Cognitive Impairment
pathology also have an increased inflammatory response, The burdens of insomnia are clear. Comorbid
which increases beta-amyloid production [6, 9, 10]. conditions may also be worsened by insomnia or through
Studies have shown that a lack of sleep likely contributes other bidirectional relationship(s) with comorbidities.
to the progression of AD [11] and may prevent interstitial Ninety-three percent of adults over 65 have at least one
fluid drainage through cerebrospinal fluid into interstitial comorbid condition [28], which may help explain the
space to clear beta-amyloid and phosphorylated tau from higher rates of insomnia in this population [29]. The
the brain [12, 13]. This increased beta-amyloid production frequency and number of comorbidities may also
is even more concerning as insomnia symptoms are contribute to inaccurate diagnosis, particularly when
known to negatively impact the brain’s ability to clear trying to differentiate between primary or comorbid
these beta-amyloid plaques [6, 7]. Although exact insomnia. Common comorbid conditions in insomnia
mechanisms are not yet known and may be bidirectional include depression, suicidal tendencies, heart disease,
or interrelated [14, 15], sleep may mediate progression to hypertension, myocardial infarction, diabetes, and
AD, wherein sleep improvements could promote metabolic syndrome [29]. Chronic insomnia affects
cognitive functioning. physical, social, and emotional health [30]. Individuals
Because insomnia is common in individuals with with insomnia have decreased work productivity, more
MCI, the evaluation and treatment of insomnia present an accidents, more hospitalizations, and overall greater
opportunity to intervene in the early stages of cognitive healthcare costs than their healthy counterparts [31, 32].
decline in disorders that generally present with no known For example, the cost of human capital loss due to
cure. Current guidelines [16–20] recommend non- insomnia is estimated to cost roughly $63 billion each
pharmacological cognitive-behavioral therapy for year [33]. There are also significantly more direct costs
insomnia (CBT-I) as the first step in insomnia treatment for patients with insomnia compared to matched non-
with pharmacological intervention only offered if the insomnia controls, including higher all-cause healthcare
CBT-I was not effective or available [20]. Based on the costs [34] and an estimated additional six-month direct
current guidelines and complications of polypharmacy in medical expenditure of $1,143 [27]. Insomnia symptoms
older adults with cognitive concerns, our original can also affect significant others and caregivers.
intention was to review current non-pharmacologic Specifically, nighttime activities can disrupt partners’
therapies in older adults with MCI, namely CBT-I. We sleep, which may impact their ability to function normally
found that these studies, quite simply, do not yet exist in and provide care [35, 36].
a quantity that makes sense for a review. Therefore, we
present a summary of selected studies and guidelines for Insomnia and cognition
this patient group’s prevalent pharmacological therapies.
We argue that clinical trials of CBT-I in this at-risk elderly This review focuses on the comorbidities of cognition and
population are critically needed. insomnia in older adults [37–40]. Insomnia prevalence in
patients with MCI or other cognitive disorders is as high
Definitions, Incidence, and Comorbidities of Insomnia as 50% (7). A recent systematic review found that
insomnia was significantly associated with a 27% higher
Insomnia is a sleep disorder characterized by difficulty risk of cognitive disorders [41]. Another found a 2.14-fold
falling and/or staying asleep with impaired functioning increase in dementia risk in adults with primary insomnia
resulting in daytime impairment [21]. Insomnia [42]. Insomnia and cognition in the elderly may not only
classification differs among the Diagnostic and Statistical be co-associated; decreased attention and impaired
Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-V), the International memory of insomnia and sleep deprivation may present as
Classification of Sleep Disorders (ICSD-2), and the dementia in older adults [35, 36, 43]. Whether
International Classification of Disease (ICD-10, 2). These confounding or comorbid to cognitive assessments,
differences result in varying prevalence estimates, insomnia may have its own independent course, making
ranging from 5-50% across different definitions and treatment decisions in this population even more critical.
populations [21, 23, 24]. Using the DSM-V, insomnia can Limited options are available for individuals with MCI to
be short-term (acute), where insomnia symptoms with promote cognitive maintenance and prevent further
impairment last one night to a few weeks, or chronic, cognitive decline. Intervention with effective insomnia
where insomnia symptoms with impairment occur at least treatments may provide an opportunity to intervene early
three times a week for at least three months [25]. Up to and not only prevent, but potentially reverse, cognitive
50% of older adults report symptoms of insomnia that decline.
may or may not impact daytime functioning [21, 23];
however, chronic insomnia occurs in closer to 10-15% of Insomnia Treatments in Patients with MCI: A
the population [26, 27]. Disconnect between Recommendations and Evidence
Insomnia treatment is recommended in two forms: of Parkinson’s disease, traumatic brain injury, rapid eye
behavioral and pharmacological. The American Academy movement sleep behavior disorder, spindle density, or
of Sleep Medicine [16], the British Association for multiple sclerosis. The outcome was cognitive status, as
Psychopharmacology [17], the American College of measured by at least one or more neuropsychological
Physicians [18, 19], and the European Sleep Research assessment(s). Most of the papers that did not meet
Society [20] recommend CBT-I in the treatment of inclusion or exclusion criteria evaluated a broad swath of
insomnia. Only when CBT-I is not effective or available sleep disturbances rather than insomnia specifically.
should a pharmacological intervention be offered [20]. The qualifying article presented cognitive outcomes
Traditional CBT-I targets maladaptive behaviors and of an RCT of CBT-I in individuals with MCI [45, 46].
dysfunctional thoughts that perpetuate sleep problems. Patients (N=28) lived in two residential facilities.
Most clinicians conduct six to eight in-person, hour-long Participants were randomly assigned to CBT-I (n =14) or
sessions and measure patient outcomes with subjective an active control group (n=14) that received a class on
reports and daily sleep diaries. Across these sessions, nutrition. The study intervention included four group
there are typically five tenets presented as part of CBT-I: sessions of CBT-I over eight weeks. Primary sleep
sleep restriction, stimulus control, cognitive restructuring, outcomes were sleep latency (SL), wake after sleep onset
sleep hygiene, and relapse prevention. The focus of (WASO), sleep efficiency (SE), and total sleep time
therapy is on establishing healthy sleep behaviors and (TST) measured by sleep diaries supplemented with
reducing negative thoughts behaviors associated with actigraphy. The insomnia severity index (ISI), a highly
sleep. Success is operationalized through demonstrated validated subjective marker of insomnia, was also
sustained symptom improvements, including SE, SOL, evaluated [47]. Secondary outcomes were measures of
WASO, and TST [44]. This multi-modal approach allows neuropsychological functioning including memory,
for tailored, patient-centered treatment and promotes verbal learning, attention, processing speed, executive
sustained symptom improvement. functioning, task shift, and inhibition. All outcomes were
The potential advantages of behavioral therapy assessed at three time points: baseline, post-intervention,
include avoiding medication polypharmacy, medication and 4-month follow-up.
dependence, and a focus on the underlying predisposing, The CBT-I intervention group, compared with the
precipitating, and/or perpetuating factors of chronic control group, experienced improved SL, WASO, SE, and
insomnia. Although non-pharmacological treatment is ISI at post-intervention and 4-month follow-ups [46].
recommended as first-line treatment for insomnia in older Neuropsychological functioning findings demonstrated a
adults, pharmacological interventions are widespread. We statistically significant improvement in executive
reviewed insomnia treatments in older adults with MCI functioning based on the Delis Kaplan Executive
studies and current guidelines of pharmacological therapy Function System assessing inhibition (p<.05); however,
to explore this disconnect. there were no changes in the other neuropsychological
domains, such as memory [45]. The authors concluded
Review of Non-Pharmacological Insomnia Treatment that in-person CBT-I for individuals with MCI is feasible,
in Older Adults with MCI improves sleep outcomes, and may have long-term effects
on cognition [46].
A review was performed on non-pharmacological sleep
interventions in older adults with MCI by searching Other Non-Pharmacological Treatments
PubMed, PyscInfo, and Web of Science through
November 1, 2020. Search terms used were sleep, sleep- Our review uncovered some non-pharmacological
wake, circadian, insomnia, sleep initiation and insomnia treatments that did not meet criteria, but, given
maintenance disorders, sleep disturbance, mild cognitive the paucity of rigorous evidence for non-pharmacological
impairment, cognitive dysfunction, and neuropsychiatric therapies, bear mentioning. For example, one study of an
symptoms. Inclusion criteria included MCI diagnosis, alternative pharmacological therapy examined the use of
intervention studies, human participants, and sleep a nutrient supplement comprised of omega-3 and omega-
disturbance with pre- and post-measurement. An MCI 6 fatty acids plus pure γ-tocopherol [48] in an RCT of 46
diagnosis required that participants undergo a older adults with probable MCI. We note that insomnia
neuropsychological assessment that included more than was not an entry criterion and that sleep was a secondary
one assessment. For example, studies in which only the outcome. Significant improvements across memory,
Mini-Mental Status Examination were administered as the fluency, language, and the visuospatial cognitive domains
neuropsychological assessment were excluded from this were noted at 3- and 6-month follow-ups. Sleep
review. Exclusion criteria included subjective complaints subjectively improved in the treatment group. Light or
of cognitive impairment for MCI diagnosis or diagnosis acoustic therapies to improve cognition and sleep
disorders in adults with dementia (rather than the present pathways are important in light of the proposed
review’s criteria of MCI) have demonstrated mixed pathophysiology of Alzheimer’s dementia that state,
effectiveness in some measures of cognitive impairment overall, that sleep provides an important custodial
and sleep physiology [49, 50]. For example, a recent pilot function in brain health, and that disruptions of sleep lead
randomized crossover study presented the effect of a one- to dementia [57, 58]. In this light, studies of sleep
night acoustic versus sham stimulation on next-morning disorders of the at-risk population of patients with MCI to
memory recall in patients with amnestic MCI and modify conversion to dementia appear critical. Our
unknown insomnia status. Increasing slow-wave activity review findings that robust trials of improving insomnia –
was associated with improved word recall, but larger and hopefully preserving cognition – in patients with MCI
efficacy studies are needed. are lacking.
Our review of CBT-I in MCI highlights this scarcity.
Pharmacological Treatments for Insomnia in Patients We note that criteria for the diagnosis of MCI were
With MCI inconsistent or insufficient across studies. Many studies
required only one neuropsychological measure (e.g.,
Our review’s striking finding is that only one therapy to memory) or a brief assessment tool, such as Mini Mental
improve insomnia symptoms individuals with MCI cohort Status Examination (MMSE), for MCI diagnosis. These
qualified for discussion. This one reason is that inclusion criteria do not measure up to clinical standards
pharmacological use remains so prevalent. We reiterate required to diagnosis MCI. Criteria for MCI, as defined
concerns over the use of sedative-hypnotic agents in by Petersen et al. (2001, 25), are regarded as the gold
elderly patients. Aging physiology heightens the risk of standard, and future studies including individuals with
untoward side effects, drug interactions, and MCI should consider the use of comprehensive testing to
polypharmacy interactions. [51-53]. Age-related issues promote generalizability of results.
are especially concerning when using traditional One factor that may have limited studies is that non-
benzodiazepines and non-benzodiazepine receptor pharmacological treatments for insomnia in MCI may be
agonist sleep aids such as zolpidem, eszopiclone, and challenging to implement in those with later-stage
zaleplon. The use of traditional sleep aids in older adults dementia. Similar limitations applied to criteria to identify
has been associated with serious adverse events, including insomnia. Across sleep outcome studies, data collection
cognitive impairment and falls [54, 55]. methods ranged from self-report to lab-reported
Industry-sponsored sedative-hypnotic trials in older polysomnography. Sleep outcomes varied across studies,
adults, however, unexpectedly do not confirm these risks. such that some emphasized sleep study measurements
Additionally, studies on the target population of MCI and (sleep efficiency, wake after sleep onset, and sleep onset
insomnia are lacking. For example, a systematic review of latency), and others focused on ISI. Another major
pharmacotherapies for sleep disturbances (including but limitation was that few studies specifically evaluated
not limited to insomnia) in dementia found nine insomnia; many included sleep disturbances as a catch-all,
randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of medications less specific inclusion. The high prevalence of insomnia
including melatonin, trazodone, ramelteon, suvorexant, in patients with MCI and improved sleep’s potential effect
and lemborexant [56]. RCTs demonstrated significant but on cognition warrants population-specific intervention
low- to moderate-effectiveness on sleep outcomes (such studies.
as sleep-diary measured sleep onset latency and Even though there are effective treatments for
actigraphy-measured sleep efficiency). RCTs insomnia, less than 15% of adults with chronic insomnia
demonstrated no higher serious adverse effects between are estimated to get treatment [60]. If a patient is
intervention versus placebo arms. However, none interested in CBT-I and a provider recommends this first-
examined the effects of improved sleep on cognition, and line treatment, there are access barriers, including the
none included MCI as a cohort [56]. limited number of clinicians trained in behavioral
insomnia treatment [61]. However, one important
Discussion development is the growth in the use of telemedicine and
other online techniques, an aspect of medical care that has
CBT-I is recommended as the first-line treatment for been emphasized by the medical system’s response to the
insomnia in older adults; however, in our review of non- novel coronavirus pandemic. Older adults have
pharmacological treatment of insomnia in MCI, we found historically had limited Internet access, but this is
studies are lacking. Most studies feature the use of changing dramatically. through government-funded
sedative-hypnotics in the elderly or demented populations broadband expansion [62] and the dramatic change in
and focus on sleep effects rather than cognitive effects. need for technological connections during the pandemic.
The shortcomings in the literature in both treatment Receiving therapy over the Internet may also allow
Analysis. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry, 91:236–244. [53] Maher RL, Hanlon J, Hajjar ER (2014). Clinical
[42] Hung CM, Li YC, Chen HJ, Lu K, Liang CL, Liliang consequences of polypharmacy in elderly. Expert Opin
PC, et al. (2018). Risk of dementia in patients with Drug Saf, 13:57–65.
primary insomnia: A nationwide population-based [54] Fick D, Selma T, Beizer J, Brandt N, Dombrowski R,
case-control study. BMC Psychiatry, 18:38. DuBeau C, Eisenberg W, Epplin J, Flanagan N,
[43] Ancoli-Israel S (2000). Insomnia in the elderly: A Giovannetti E, Hanlon J, Hollmann P, Laird R,
review for the primary care practitioner. Sleep, 23:S23– Linnebur S, Sandhu S SM (2015). American Geriatrics
S30. Society 2015 Updated Beers Criteria for Potentially
[44] Trauer JM, Qian MY, Doyle JS, Rajaratnam SMW, Inappropriate Medication Use in Older Adults. J Am
Cunnington D (2015). Cognitive behavioral therapy for Geriatr Soc, 63:2227–2246.
chronic insomnia: A systematic review and meta- [55] Fick DM, Cooper JW, Wade WE, Waller JL, Maclean
analysis. Ann Intern Med, 163:191–204. JR, Beers MH (2003). Updating the Beers Criteria for
[45] Cassidy-Eagle E, Siebern A, Unti L, Glassman J, Hara Potentially Inappropriate Medication Use in Older
RO, Siebern A, et al. (2018). Neuropsychological Adults: results of a US consensus panel of experts. Arch
Functioning in Older Adults with Mild Cognitive Intern Med, 163:2716–2724.
Impairment and Insomnia Randomized to CBT-I or [56] Mccleery J, Cohen DA, Sharpley AL (2016).
Control Group Neuropsychological Functioning in Pharmacotherapies for sleep disturbances in dementia.
Older Adults with Mild Cognitive Impairment and Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 11:CD009178.
Insomnia Randomized to CBT-I or Control Group. Clin [57] Shi L, Chen SJ, Ma MY, Bao YP, Han Y, Wang YM,
Gerontol, 41:136–144. et al. (2018). Sleep disturbances increase the risk of
[46] Cassidy-Eagle E, Siebern A, Unti L, Glassman J, dementia: A systematic review and meta-analysis.
O’Hara R (2018). Cognitive Behavioral Treatment for Sleep Med Rev, 40:4–16.
Insomnia in Older Adults with Mild Cognitive [58] Liguori C, Spanetta M, Izzi F, Franchini F, Nuccetelli
Impairment in Independent Living Facilities: A Pilot M, Sancesario GM, et al. (2020). Sleep-Wake Cycle in
Study. J Sleep Disord Med Care, 1:1-6. Alzheimer’s Disease Is Associated with Tau Pathology
[47] Morin CM, Belleville G, Bélanger L, Ivers H (2011). and Orexin Dysregulation. J Alzheimers Dis, 74:501–
The insomnia severity index: Psychometric indicators 508.
to detect insomnia cases and evaluate treatment [59] Petersen R, Doody R, Kurz A, Mohs R, Morris J,
response. Sleep, 34:601–608. Rabins P, et al. (2001). Current Concepts in Mild
[48] Stavrinou PS, Andreou E, Aphamis G, Pantzaris M, Cognitive Impairment. Arch Neurol, 58:1985–1992.
Ioannou M, Patrikios IS, et al. (2020). The Effects of a [60] Mellinger G, Balter M, Uhlenhuth E (1985). Insomnia
6-Month High Dose Omega-3 and Omega-6 and its treatment: Prevalence and correlates. Arch Gen
Polyunsaturated Fatty Acids and Antioxidant Vitamins Psychiatry, 42:225–232.
Supplementation on Cognitive Function and Functional [61] Perlis ML, Smith MT (2008). How can we make CBT-
Capacity in Older Adults with Mild Cognitive I and other BSM services widely available? J Clin Sleep
Impairment. Nutrients, 12:325. Med, 4:11–13.
[49] Cibeira N, Maseda A, Lorenzo-López L, Rodrí guez- [62] Pew Research Center (2017). Internet/ Broadband Fact
Villamil JL, López-López R, Millán-Calenti JC (2020). Sheet. http://www.pewinternet.org/fact-sheet/internet-
Application of light therapy in older adults with broadband/. Accessed 15 Dec 2017.
cognitive impairment: A systematic review. Geriatr [63] Pigeon W (2010). Treatment of Adult Insomnia With
Nurs (Minneap), 41:970–983. Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy. J Clin Psychol,
[50] Papalambros NA, Weintraub S, Chen T, Grimaldi D, 66:1148–1160.
Santostasi G, Paller KA, et al. (2019). Acoustic [64] Ritterband LM, Thorndike FP, Ingersoll KS, Lord HR,
enhancement of sleep slow oscillations in mild Gonder-Frederick L, Frederick C, et al. (2017). Effect
cognitive impairment. Ann Clin Transl Neurol, 6:1191– of a web-based cognitive behavior therapy for insomnia
1201. intervention with 1-year follow-up: A randomized
[51] Mangoni AA, Jackson SHD (2004). Age-related clinical trial. JAMA Psychiatry, 74:68–75.
changes in pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics: [65] Mattos MK, Barnes L, Davis EM, Manning CA,
basic principles and practical applications. Br J Clin Mostafavi M, Quigg MS, et al. (2020). Preliminary
Pharmacol, 57:6–14. feasibility of technology use in an Internet-delivered
[52] Spinewine A, Schmader KE, Barber N, Hughes C, intervention: Improving sleep in older adults with mild
Lapane KL, Swine C, et al. (2007). Appropriate cognitive impairment. 2020 Alzheimer’s Assoc. Int.
prescribing in elderly people: how well can it be Conf.
measured and optimised? Lancet, 370:173–184.