Professional Documents
Culture Documents
http://ajc.sagepub.com/
Published by:
http://www.sagepublications.com
Additional services and information for Asian Journal of Management Cases can be found at:
Subscriptions: http://ajc.sagepub.com/subscriptions
Reprints: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.nav
Permissions: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav
This case details the decision facing Cool King Limited, one of the leading businesses
in India dealing with the installation of central air conditioning. So far it has had only
a token presence in the window air conditioning business, but is now looking to expand
into it as explosive growth in the industry is predicted in the near future. However,
this change of focus from central air conditioning to window air conditioning is likely
to affect the sales of central air conditioners, which is already on the decline, and may
prevent Cool King from venturing into other related businesses such as sales of
refrigerators.
Keywords: Indian air conditioner industry, competition, competitive strategy, business
portfolio
On 12 March 2002, Rahul Chandra, Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of Cool King Ltd
(CKL), was in his office in Bangalore, India, going over the company’s annual progress
report. He was concerned about Cool King’s diminishing central air conditioning sales.
He wondered whether the time was right to expand the company’s window air condition-
ing business to compensate for the decline in sales of the central air conditioners (ACs).
COMPANY BACKGROUND
CKL was established in 1943 and became a public limited company in 1969. The company
was initially engaged in reconditioning refrigerators and ACs. In 2002, Cool King was
India’s largest central air conditioning company with an annual turnover of Rs 51 million.
It had a network of offices in twenty-nine cities and three modern manufacturing facilities.
Cool King manufactured and marketed a wide range of air conditioning and refrigeration
systems and products. These included large central air conditioning plants, packaged air
conditioning systems, split and window ACs, commercial refrigeration equipment such
as water coolers, bottled water dispensers, ice cube machines, deep freezers, walk-in
cold rooms and commercial kitchens, and laundry equipment. Cool King’s other
INDUSTRY BACKGROUND
The Indian AC market in 2002 was estimated to be Rs 330 million, growing at 20–25 per
cent annually. Of these, central air conditioning, including packaged and ducted AC
systems, was approximately Rs 120 million and the window and split AC market was
approximately Rs 200 million.
The industry consisted of three kinds of companies: multinational companies (MNCs),
Indian companies and unit assemblers. The MNCs included Carrier Aircon, Hitachi (with
Amtrex) and Fedder Lloyd. The leading Indian companies were Voltas, Amtrex, Shriram,
Godrej, Blue Star and Videocon. While the MNCs sold on brand and premium image, the
Indian companies sold on established credibility. The assemblers (usually regional players)
competed on price with adequate quality. The assemblers accounted for more than 50 per
cent of the market share.
ACs were considered a luxury product and therefore subjected to high duty structure.
The rate of excise duty (as of 2002) was 32 per cent compared to 16 per cent for all other
consumer durables and white goods such as televisions, refrigerators and washing
machines.
The domestic demand for ACs was largely met by window ACs. The demand for room
ACs came mainly from the corporate sector, accounting for 80 per cent. The government,
Dealer Network
Sales and service dealers: They had powerful technical orientation, usually a strong
service team and fully equipped workshops. Usually they did not have a front office. AC
projects that required a great deal of engineering knowledge were handled very well by
them. They were comfortable handling projects worth Rs 500,000 or more. Their revenue
depended heavily on annual maintenance contracts (AMCs) that they entered into with
the customers whose AC plants they supported.
Air conditioner dealers: Many sales and service dealers graduated into AC dealers.
They had shop and display facilities and a strong service orientation. They were best
suited to service the residential segment customers.
White goods dealers: They owned a showroom and stocked and sold ACs with other
white goods. They had no service orientation or service facilities. They executed a sale
and typically had nothing more to do with the appliance.
Sales and service dealers serviced 5 per cent of the residential segment. AC dealers
serviced 20 per cent of the segment and the remaining 75 per cent was serviced by ap-
pliance dealers. These percentages were reversed for the corporate segment. Appliance
dealers rarely catered to corporate segments (5–10 per cent only).
The senior management team of CKL had deliberated on the issue of the company’s
response to the emerging opportunities in the window AC business. The central issue
was, should Cool King reorganize itself to face the challenges in the window AC business
or should it vacate this market segment and concentrate on the project business? Several
conflicting factors, some of them internal and others external, were complicating the
Opportunity Assessment
The window AC business in India was likely to experience explosive growth. There would
be three distinct market segments—residential, commercial and corporate. The residential
segment would require standardized products, the commercial and corporate segments
would require standard products with low customization. The market growth opportunity
assessments were based on (a) expected availability of quality power as a consequence
of government investment on infrastructure and implementation of economic reforms,
and (b) growth in the need for comfortable work and commercial environments as a
consequence of economic liberalization and enhanced industrialization. These reasons
were expected to boost the commercial demand for window ACs. The increase in dis-
posable income was also expected to translate into higher demand growth for window
ACs.
The cost of ACs in China was one-and-a-half times the average monthly salary. In
India as of 2002, the cost of a window AC was five times the average monthly salary.
Since growth in volume was a reality, prices were expected to fall dramatically. Revenue
growth would be driven by volume and gross margins would be thin.
ALTERNATIVES
Should CKL decide to concentrate on project business and maintain only a token presence
in the window AC business, several financial and operational implications followed. The
growth and profitability in the Cooling Product Division could be severely affected by
aggressive competition; commercial and corporate segments of the window AC business,
which was being supported by the technology and solution platform, would be more
vulnerable to competition; CKL had to work with a limited product portfolio characterized
by technological complexity and higher project implementation skills; and size and profit-
ability would be slow, leading to stagnation. Therefore, long-term sustainability in the
business could be threatened.
CKL was characterized by a wide product range in the AC business, a strong presence
enabled by excellent project execution skills and a carefully built reputation in the relevant
market segments. Revenue and profitability were enhanced by project execution skills,
retrofit business and after sales service revenue. CKL was accustomed to treating distri-
butors as their business partners. However, while the products were sold at a premium
price, the efforts on brand building had been relatively low. Project execution time had
been appropriate rather than rapid. The common manufacturing facilities of the company
were used to make a small presence in the window AC market. Technological understand-
ing of the AC business and application engineering skills had been adequate.
Some senior management members within CKL were of the view that the company
would be able to change the rules of the game against Korean competition. They cited a
recent experience with the ICICI bank as an example. ICICI Bank wanted ACs in their
automated teller machines (ATMs) across the country. This bid was won by CKL against
Please address all correspondence to Dr N. Ravichandran and Dr P.K. Sinha, Indian Institute of
Management, WIN h 3, Vastrapur, Ahmedabad 380 015, India. E-mail address: nravi@iimahd.
ernet.in, pksinha@iimahd.ernet.in
Exhibit 2
Segment-wise Sales (in percentage)
Product Window Split
Segment/Year 2000–01 2001–02 2002–03 2000–01 2001–02 2002–03
Banks 7 6 12 9 11 18
Educational Inst. 6 2 4 4 6 9
Software 6 3 4 24 12 14
Government 21 15 20 4 4 4
Hospitals 2 2 5 3 3 3
Office 33 24 33 32 35 34
Residence 17 38 17 8 22 12
Showrooms 8 4 4
Others 8 10 5 8 3 2
Total 100 100 100 100 100 100
Source: Published industry reports.
Group Electronics
Line of ACs and engineering ACs, refrigeration ACs ACs, consumer ACs, consumer
business and other consumer durables and durables and
durables electronic electronic
products products
Range of AC Package and ductable Window, split and Room AC, Windows, split Windows, split,
product(s) split unit, packaged multi-split and handling units multi-split, floor
chillers, screw coolers and chillers standing
chillers
Market Package ductable split Net sales for Unitary product N.A. Sales turnover
performance units grew by 14 per 1997–98 was segment with a of 500 by March
cent, packaged Rs 897.2 million on 30 per cent 2001 and a
chillers by 50 per which it earned a share in the growth of 20 per
cent, vapour absorp- profit after tax of window AC and cent over the
tion machines by Rs 31.2 million mini-splits corresponding
100 per cent, screw markets period
chillers by 28 per cent
Financial Equity capital 330.5, N.A. Equity capital N.A. Cumulative
figures (in profit 59.23, capital 234.2, profit 82.21, turnover of
Rs millions) employed 2,895.4 capital employed Rs 5,000 by
in January 2001 1,316.4 in January June 2001
2001
Source: Published industry reports and company website.
Exhibit 4
Financial Highlights for Cool King Limited
Year 2000–01 1999–2000* 1999–2000 1998–99 1997–98 1996–97 1995–96 1994–95 1993–94 1992–93 1991–92
Operating results (in Rs million)
Total Income 5,098.2 4,438.1 4,809.4 4,764.9 4,527.7 4,408.5 4,089.1 318.82 2,475.4 2,227.7 2,157.8
Profit before Tax 255.7 171 252 181.2 180.4 232.1 354.8 221 92.9 45.2 41.9
Tax 20.3 19.6 19.6 18.5 25.3 84.3 103 57.2 32.5 4 5
Profit after Tax 235.4 151.4 232.4 162.7 155.1 147.8 251.8 163.8 60.4 41.2 37
Downloaded from ajc.sagepub.com by chandrasekhar natarajan on September 28, 2010
Dividend 111.8 101.6 101.6 94.8 94.8 94.8 81.2 35.1 24.9 16.4 12.9
Retained profit 112.2 37.5 118.5 57.5 50.8 43.5 170.6 128.7 31.9 24.8 24.1
Financial Position (in Rs million, excluding ratios)
Paid up Capital 203.2 203.2 271 271 271 271 271 100.5 99.5 72 72
Reserves 897.2 858.1 976.7 859.5 803.7 754.7 712.7 515.6 394.7 296.1 273.3
Shareholders’
funds 1,100.4 1,061.3 1,247.7 1,130.5 1,074.7 1,025.7 983.7 616.1 494.2 368.1 345.3
Borrowings 573.5 640.4 640.4 824.9 604.3 329.6 101.8 156.5 174.4 308.7 303.6
Total funds
employed 1,673.9 1,701.7 1,888.1 1,955.4 1,679 1,355.3 1,085.5 772.6 668.6 676.8 648.9
Net fixed
assets and
investments 941.1 1,001 1,052.5 999.3 970.5 736 460 378.1 266.9 257.8 259.2
Net Working
Capital 674.3 651.9 786.8 881.8 674.4 618.8 624.5 389.3 390 506 367.5
Debt equity ratio 5.2 6 5.1 7.3 5.6 3.2 1 2.6 3.6 8.7 9.4
Book value
per equity
share (Rs) 512.7 498.3 442.4 389.8 384 378.4 362.6 607.9 485.1 499.2 453.4
Other information
Number of share-
holders 260,940 273,990 273,990 239,630 233,180 205,780 180,040 156,970 146,920 125,340 107,700
Number of
employees 20,840 21,250 24,890 25,040 26,190 27,990 29,820 26,610 26,080 26,830 27,070
Downloaded from ajc.sagepub.com by chandrasekhar natarajan on September 28, 2010
Year 2000–01 1999–2000* 1999–2000 1998–99 1997–98 1996–97 1995–96 1994–95 1993–94 1992–93 1991–92
Performance indicators
Earnings per
share (Rs) 115.8 74.5 85.8 60 57.2 54.5 108.5 163 60.7 57.9 51.9
Dividend per
share (Rs)# 55 50 50 35 35 35 35 35 25 23 18
Return on share-
holders’ funds1 213.9 153.2 197.9 154.1 155.3 155.9 278 305.2 146.5 150.7 148.7
Return on capital
employed2 204.7 162.1 191.4 148.8 147.2 220.3 391.5 391.7 256.8 183.1 177.5
Source: Annual reports and published information.
Notes: # Proposed dividend
* Excluding software business
1
Excluding revaluation reserve in %
2
Excluding revaluation reserve in %
Exhibit 5
Cool King in the Window Air Conditioning Business
Cooling Products
CKL offers a wide range of contemporary window and split ACs, apart from manufacturing and
marketing a wide range of commercial refrigeration products and services that cater to the indus-
trial and commercial sectors.
Commercial Refrigeration
This segment includes a wide range of products such as cold storages, water coolers, bottled
water dispensers, deep freezers, visi coolers and ice cubers. In the storage-type water cooler
market, CKL is the leader with a market share of 45 per cent.