Professional Documents
Culture Documents
3, NOVEMBER 2002
ABSTRACT. The aim of this paper is to present an approach, applied, generalizing the meaning of the studied examples,
able to deal with all possible connections of voltage and instead of a theoretically obtained approach. So, some
current sources and impedances, combining conductors in common winding connections were studied─one-phase circuit
which the skin effect is taken into account and conductors in and three-phase circuits with star and delta connections─,
which skin effect is neglected. This approach is obtained being presented here the three-phase star connection handling
using a bottom-up methodology. In this way, the meaning of unbalanced load and voltage conditions. In this paper, the
terms in the generalized approach is naturally inherited from model is applied to the study of a power transformer, although
some specific problems. This model is presented in a compact it has been applied to other non-static machines as induction
form, preserving sparse, symmetric and positive-definiteness motors, [10].
matrices. The vectors and matrices, computed during the
solution stage, are employed in engineering calculations as 2 BASIC EQUATIONS
current and inductance computations providing compact
expressions suitable for efficient algorithms. Finally, the Assuming that the displacement currents are neglected,
proposed approach, implemented in a FEM software package Maxwell’s equations using a magnetic vector potential
developed by the authors, is applied to the study of a three- formulation can be written in 2D as:
phase transformer, supplied with a balanced three-phase
voltage (sinusoidal and nonsinusoidal) and loaded with an ¶ æ ¶A(x, y) ö ¶ æ ¶A(x, y) ö
çn ( B ) ÷ + n (B) = - J(x, y) (1)
unbalanced three-phase RL impedance. The agreement ¶x è ¶x ø ¶y çè ¶y ÷ø
between the computed and experimental results shows the
validity of the proposed model and its implementation. Where A(x,y) is the magnetic vector potential, J(x,y) the
current density (z component) and n the reluctivity that
1 INTRODUCTION depends on the magnetic flux density vector (B). In
anisotropic materials, reluctivity depends on |B| and the angle
The natural excitation for the Finite Element Method (FEM) (q) between B and the rolling direction of the material
in electromagnetism is current (current density). This current n=n(A,q).
is supplied by an external electric circuit; and, usually, the
value of this current is unknown, as the circuits consist of The expression of current density depends on how the
passive elements and voltage sources. Therefore, FEM and conductors are defined. So, the conductors can be modelled as
electrical equations are coupled by these unknown currents. solid conductors, in which case the skin effect is taken into
There are two different approaches to couple these equations. account, or stranded conductors, in which case the skin effect
In the first approach, called direct coupling, the equations is neglected. Stranded conductors are particularly useful to
obtained from FEM and the electrical circuits are integrated in model windings in which an individual mesh considering their
a single system of equations having the magnetic vector relations would exceed in many cases the requirements of
potential as its solution. In the second one, called indirect actual computers without providing a significantly greater
coupling, two different systems of equations are obtained; one accuracy. If all the conductors in the problem are solid
of them takes into account the FEM equations, and the other conductors, the following equation is employed, [8] [9]:
one, the circuit equations. In this paper, a method, based on ¶A
the direct coupling of FEM and circuit equations is presented. Ñ ´nÑ ´ A = s Eext - s -sn e ´ Ñ ´ A (2)
¶t
Many approaches on coupled 2D Finite Element models and
circuit equations have been proposed [1]-[7]. Most of them, The first term on the right side in (2), Eext being the external
take into account the skin effect for all the conductors or, they electric field and s the electrical conductivity, represents the
neglect its influence, without evaluating its magnitude over current density due to the voltage source. The second term
each conductor. In this paper, a bottom-up methodology is takes into account the current density due to the temporal
uF l N dA æ di ö æ di ö (11)
VTR = eT - eR + ç RT iT + LT T ÷ - ç RRiR + LR R ÷
if = -
RF RF S òòS dt dS (6)
è dt ø è dt ø
òò b ( x, y ) {j ( x, y )}
3 EXAMPLE. THE WINDINGS ARE STAR T
j dW
CONNECTED
= W
{ A ( t )} = {w} { A ( t )}
T
Being {w}T the phase vector, which provides information Using (20), (21) and the definition of Am in (14) the following
about the topology of each winding, j(x,y) the shape or equation is obtained:
interpolation functions, whose formulas are well-known for
classical elements, and W the entire domain where the integral { J } = Dt [W ][ N ][G ]{u
t+Dt
} a
( t +Dt ) + t
ext
is extended by using the phase functions b j:
-l [W ][ N ][G ][ N ][W ] ({ A } - { A })
T t+Dt t (22)
b
ì 1 If ( x, y ) Î S +
ï
j
- [W ][ N ][G ][G ]{i } a c
t
b j ( x , y ) = í -1 If ( x, y ) Î S - (15)
j
ï 0 Otherwise Where the term [W] is called the phase matrix defined as the
î
matrix containing the phase vectors presented in the problem
Using the Crank-Nicholson time stepping method, the (three in this case).
following equations are obtained:
Using (1) and (22):
t +Dt t
( éë S ){ A
t +Dt
æ 1 ö æ di ö i - i
t
1 æ di ö
ç ÷ + ç1 - ÷ ç ÷ = (16) t +Dt
ùû + l [W ][ N ][Gb ][ N ][W ]
T t+Dt
}=
2 è dt ø è 2 ø è dt ø Dt
Dt [W ][ N ][Ga ]{uext } + l [W ][ N ][Gb ][ N ][W ] (23)
( t +Dt ) + t T
{A }
t
t +Dt t +Dt t
æ 1 ö æ dA ö A - Am
t
1 æ dAm ö
+ ç1 - ÷ ç m ÷ = m (17) - [W ][ N ][Ga ][Gc ]{i t }
ç ÷
2 è dt ø è 2 ø è dt ø Dt
where [St+Dt] is the stiffness matrix. Therefore, equation (23)
Using (9), (10), (11), (12), (13), (16) and (17): models 2D magnetic circuits with a three star connected
ì i t+ü - M S ù ì V t+
windings of stranded conductors, the magnetic vector
RS + V RS ü
Dt Dt
é MT 0 t
ê ú ê ú ï t+Dt ï
M R ú ê 0 N S 0 ú í Am, S - Am, S
t
ê MT MT+M R ý 4 THE GENERALIZED SYSTEM OF
ï ï
ëê M S M S + M R ûú ëê 0 0 N T ûú î Am,T - Atm,T
t+Dt
MR þ EQUATIONS
é M 'R( M S + M T ) M 'S M T - M 'T M S ù ì iR ü
t
ëê M 'R M S M 'S M R M 'T ( M S + M R )ûú ï it ï types of connections and conductors (solid and stranded) [11].
î Tþ
æ é t +Dt ù 2s
where:
ç ëS û + [T ] + l [W ][ N ][Gb ][ N ][W ]T ö÷ { At+Dt}=
è D t ø
M j = R j Dt + 2L j j = R, S , T
æ é t ù 2s T ö
meaning and dimensions of the terms in (24) can be expressed Current in windings made of conductors considered as
as: stranded ones can be calculated using (1), (5) and the
definition of phase vector:
· [S]nxn is the stiffness matrix.
· [T]nxn is called the mass matrix, containing information m
5.1 Current Calculations In the same way mutual inductance can be computed using the
flux linkage definition:
The winding currents can be calculated using:
l N i{w i} { A }
t +Dt T t +Dt
N f
t +Dt
= i t +Di t =
i f (t)= ò J (t) dW (25) M ij
ij {w j} éë S t +Dt ùû {At +Dt }
T
Wf
(30)
N j {w j} {w j}
T
æ u ¶A ö
I c = òò ç s s - s dS (26)
¶t ÷ø
As the current is computed in (28), self and mutual
Sc è
l inductances are calculated using the phase vectors and the
stiffness matrix, that can be dependent on time. Stiffness
229 ACES JOURNAL, VOL. 17, NO. 3, NOVEMBER 2002
matrix is affected by the B-H curve when it exhibits a nonsinusoidal three-phase voltage (figure 3), generated with a
nonlinear behaviour. programmable AC power source. These waveforms are
applied to the software package using files obtained from an
In [13] the inductance computation in case of solid conductors oscilloscope. The secondary is loaded with an unbalanced
is stated. three-phase RL impedance. Figure 4 shows the simulated
currents in steady state, and figure 5 shows the computed and
6 EXAMPLES measured currents.
Current (A)
i3
over transformers, considering several balanced and 0
Current (A)
0 i6
6.1 Steady-state
-2
The model is applied to a 3 kVA three-phase DY transformer 0 0.005 0.01 0.015 0.02 0.025 0.03 0.035 0.04
(figure 2). The transformer is supplied with a balanced Primary line currents -Time (s)
1 i7
I6 I3 I9
i8
Current (A)
C i9
0
I5 I2 I8
B -1
I4 I1 I7
0 0.005 0.01 0.015 0.02 0.025 0.03 0.035 0.04
A Secondary phase currents -Time (s)
Load
Figure 4. Primary and secondary computed currents.
Figure 2. The transformer is delta-star connected.
I4 I5 I6
500
2
U
AB 2
Voltage (V)
2
1
0 1
Current (A)
Current (A)
Current (A)
0 0 0
-500
0 0.005 0.01 0.015 0.02 0.025 0.03 -1
-1
Time (s) -2
500 -2
U -2
BC
Voltage (V)
-500 1 1
0 0.005 0.01 0.015 0.02 0.025 0.03 0.5
Time (s) 0.5 0.5
500
Current (A)
Current (A)
Current (A)
U
CA 0 0 0
Voltage (V)
0 -0.5 -0.5
-0.5
-1 -1
-500
0 0.005 0.01 0.015 0.02 0.025 0.03 0 0.01 0.02 0 0.01 0.02 0 0.01 0.02
Time (s) Time (s) Time (s) Time (s)
Figure 3. Line-to-line supplied voltages. Figure 5. Computed (solid) and measured (dashed) currents.
GOMEZ, ROGER-FOLCH, GABALDON, MOLINA: COUPLING 2D FE MODELS AND CIRCUIT EQUATIONS 230
20
8 REFERENCES
10
[1] A. Y. Hannalla and D. C. Macdonald, “Numerical
analysis of transient field problems in electrical
Current (A)
Emilio Gómez Lázaro was born in José Roger-Folch obtained his MSc. in
Albacete, Spain. He received his MSc. Electrical Engineering in 1970 from the
and Ph.D. degrees, from Universidad Universidad Politécnica de Cataluña
Politécnica de Valencia, respectively in and his Ph.D. in 1980 from the
1995 and 2000; both in Electrical Universidad Politécnica de Valencia,
Engineering. He has held teaching and Spain. From 1971 to 1978 he worked in
research positions at Universidad the Electrical Industry as Project
Politécnica de Valencia and Univer- Engineer. Since 1978, he joined the
sidad Jaume I, Spain. Currently, he is Universidad Politécnica de Valencia
an Associate Professor of Electrical Engineering at and he is currently Professor of
Universidad Politécnica de Cartagena in Murcia, Spain. His Electrical Installations and Machines. His main research areas
current research interests include numerical methods for are the Numerical Methods (F.E.M. and others) applied to the
electromagnetism, large-scale parallel computing and, more Design and Maintenance of Electrical Machines and
generally, scientific computing and engineering. Equipments.
Antonio Gabaldón Marín was born in Angel Molina García was born in
Murcia, Spain. He received his MSc. in Murcia, Spain. He received his MSc. in
Electrical Engineering from Electrical Engineering from Univer-
Universidad Politécnica de Valencia, sidad Politécnica de Valencia, Spain, in
Spain, in 1988, and his Ph.D. degree 1998. Currently, he is working towards
from the same University in 1991. his Ph.D. at Department of Electrical
Currently, he is working at Department Engineering of Universidad Politécnica
of Electrical Engineering of de Cartagena, Spain. His research
Universidad Politécnica de Cartagena, interests include Demand-Side
Spain. His research interests include Demand-Side Management, Demand-Side Bidding, residential load
Management, End-Use Efficiency, Modelling and Distribution modelling, large-scale parallel computing and scientific
Automation, and numerical methods for electromagnetism. computing and engineering.