Professional Documents
Culture Documents
JOHNNY
9 Edgar Winter Feat. Doyle Bramhall II– When You Got A Good Friend
Lead Vocals, Guitar [All Guitars] – Doyle Bramhall II
Written-By – Robert Johnson
…After Johnny Winter’s 2014 death, multi‐instrumentalist brother Edgar, who had recorded and played with him
often, felt that organizing a musical homage so close to his passing didn’t feel appropriate. But after a few years, the
younger Winter was encouraged by others, including his wife, to move forward with it. The result is this heartfelt 17
track set, years in the making, which finds Edgar calling on a diverse group of high‐profile stars to assist a core band
that he helms.
It’s an impressive lineup. Musicians who were either influenced by Johnny (Joe Bonamassa, Derek Trucks, Kenny
Wayne Shepherd, Doyle Bramhall ll, Warren Haynes), wanted to contribute — like fellow Texans Billy Gibbons, David
Grissom — or peers like Bobby Rush and Joe Walsh, take turns on a batch of Winter classics, many of them covers that
the guitarist crafted in his own style.
Not surprisingly, Edgar plays on everything, takes lead vocals on about half the selections, and helped match songs
with artists. He also wrote two new compositions. The acoustic Delta “Lone Star Blues” where he shares lead vocals
with Keb’ Mo’ (who lays down multiple guitars), speaks in the first‐person voice of Johnny recounting his life story
from obscurity to an uncomfortable relationship with superstardom. The closing “End of the Line” is an earnest if
somewhat sappy, string accompanied ballad about death that leaves the generally high voltage album off on a
meditative moment.
The bulk of the generous hour and a quarter collection is packed with rugged, mostly rocking, and energized
performances, clearly emotionally motivated, displaying the contributors’ love of the songs, vocals, and playing that
made Winter’s blues based attack so iconic.
Bonamassa smokes on slide for the opening “Mean Town Blues” that explodes with the same passion and intensity
Johnny exuded in his prime. Shepherd lays down a sizzling solo on “Still Alive and Well” and Gibbons blasts off while
dueling with Derek Trucks on a fiery “I’m Yours and I’m Hers,” an album highlight.
Walsh shares lead vocals (but leaves the guitar to David Grissom) with Edgar for “Johnny B. Goode” as the latter adds
piano and alto sax. Haynes brings his A‐game to a tough “Memory Pain” with a soaring guitar solo and his growling
voice which mirrors Johnny’s.
Selected quieter moments provide a respite from the sonic fireworks with Michael McDonald holding firm on Winter’s
bittersweet “Stranger” and Bramhall ll going solo unplugged on a faithful version of Robert Johnson’s “When You Got a
Good Friend,” which Winter included in his high profile 1969 Columbia debut. The late Taylor Hawkins makes a
surprise appearance as a singer on a scorching “Guess I’ll Go Away.” Shepherd revs up on a drive down “Highway 61
Revisited” and Steve Lukather pounds out a credible “Rock N’ Roll Hoochie Koo” staying true to the original.
Oddly, material from Winter’s later albums for Alligator is MIA as is anything after 1977. That’s a major omission since
some of Johnny’s finest work was during those decades and deserves the attention. Surely a rather rote reading of the
already over‐recorded “Stormy Monday Blues,” even with a punchy solo from Robben Ford, could have been
jettisoned in lieu of additional Winter penned tunes.
That doesn’t detract from the overall excellence of this tribute and it may leave the door open for a volume two. At
the very least, Brother Johnny should send blues fans, or those new to his catalog, back to the initial recordings to
appreciate the legendary guitarist’s talents at their most inspired. — AmericanSongwriter