Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Introduction tamination from either gas-fired ovens each batch was divided equally by weight
© 2002 Institute of Food Technologists Vol. 67, Nr. 3, 2001—JOURNAL OF FOOD SCIENCE 1011
bin patties, respectively. Reflectance ra- Table 1—Least square means for pork patties differing in quality and cooked
tios at 610nm/525nm (indictive of oxy- to 5 endpoint temperatures
myoglobin) were 2.50 and 2.96 for the Endpoint temperature, °C
deoxymyoglobin and oxymyoglobin pat-
Trait Quality 62.8 65.6 71.1 76.7 82.2 SEf
ties respectively. These values are typical
for the specific pigments. Frozen and Visual colorgNormal x2.2a x2.7b x3.6 c x4.5d x4.9e 0.1
PSE y3.8a y4.1b y4.7 c y4.9cd x5.0d
thawed patties were cooked in an electric
SEf 0.2
skillet (Model 72024; The West Bend Co., a* value Normal x7.4 c x6.6b x6.2b x5.4a x5.2a 0.2
West Bend, Wis., U.S.A.) to 1 of 5 endpoint PSE y5.2ab x5.4b x5.0ab x4.7a x4.8a
ment was met for the specified tempera- PSE x62.8ab x62.2a x62.9ab x63.7b x63.3b
Table 2—Least square means for pork patties differing in myoglobin form when found that oxygenated samples had a
cooked to 5 endpoint temperatures more tannish color than deoxygenated
Endpoint temperature, °C samples. No differences in b* values were
detected from 62.8 °C to 76.7 °C; however,
Trait Myoglobin form f 62.8 65.6 71.1 76.7 82.2 SEg
at 82.2 °C values were higher for those pat-
Visual scoreh Dmb x2.5a x2.9b x3.8 c x4.5d x4.9e 0.1 ties. These b* trends are similar to those
Omb y3.5a y3.9b y4.5 c y4.9d x5.0d
Table 3—Least square means for pork patties cooked to 5 endpoint tempera- come less pink as internal temperatures
tures from either the frozen or thawed state increase. Patties made from PSE meat are
Endpoint temperature, °C prone to premature browning and will ap-
pear more well done than patties from
Trait Precook State f 62.8 65.6 71.1 76.7 82.2 SEf
normal quality pork at endpoint tempera-
a* value Frozen x2.8b x2.6ab x2.4ab x2.2a x2.4ab 0.2
y9.7 c y9.4 c y8.9b y8.0a y7.6a
tures from 62.8 °C to 82.2 °C. Patties
Thawed
cooked when they contain highly oxygen-
SEf 0.9
Saturation indexg Frozen x15.3b x14.9b x14.5a x14.2a x14.3a 0.2 ated pigment appear prematurely brown
Thawed x14.2d x13.9cd x13.5 c x12.6b y12.1a and will be less pink than patties contain-
SEf 0.8 ing deoxygenated myoglobin. Patties
Hue angleg Frozen x79.5a x79.9ab x80.6bc x81.1 c x80.2ab 0.5 cooked from the frozen state will be less
Thawed y42.1a y42.4ab y43.3b y45.3 c y46.1 c
pink internally than patties cooked after
SEf 5.1
Myoglobin Frozen x67.1a x72.6b x79.7 c x85.6d x87.5d 1.6 thawing and could appear more well done
Food Chemistry and Toxicology
denaturation, % Thawed y73.4a y76.4a x80.3b x85.4 c x88.0 c than they really are. Myoglobin denatur-
SEf 1.8 ation increases as endpoint temperatures
a-e Means in a row for each trait with a different superscript letter differ (P < 0.05) increase in patties of both normal and PSE
f Standard errors fro endpoint (right column) and precook form (precook column)
gSaturation index = (a* 2 + b* 2 ) 1/2 ; hue angle = (b*/a*) tan-1 quality.
x-y Means in a column for each trait with a different superscript letter differ (P < 0.05)
References
Antonini E, Brunori M. 1971. Hemoglobin and myo-
globin in their reactions with ligands. Amsterdam:
North-Holland Publ Co 9p.
Berry BW. 1998. Cooked color in high pH beef patties
as related to fat content and cooking from the fro-
65.6 °C were higher (P < 0.05) than for the have been reported for beef patties zen or thawed state. J Food Sci 63(5):797-800.
Berry BW, Bigner-George ME. 1999. Properties of
higher endpoint temperatures. cooked from the frozen state ( Van Laack
beef patties cooked to elevated internal tempera-
Overall, the tendency for hue angles and others 1996ª; Bigner-George and Ber- tures as a means of reducing pink color. J Muscle
was to increase as temperatures in- ry 2000). These differences might be due Foods 10(3):215-230.
Bigner-George ME, Berry BW. 2000. Thawing prior
creased. Thawed patties had lower hue to the presence of ice in the frozen patties. to cooking affects sensory, shear force, and cook-
angle values at every endpoint tempera- When frozen patties are cooked, there ing properties of beef patties. J Food Sci 65(1): 2-8.
Briskey EJ. 1964. Etiological status and associated
ture (P < 0.05) than cooked-from-frozen must be a phase change as the ice is con- studies of pale, soft, exudative porcine muscula-
patties. Hue angles for cooked-from-fro- verted into water without a change in tem- ture. Food Res. 13:89.
Cornforth DP, Vahabzadeh F, Carpenter CE, Bartho-
zen patties ranged from 79.5 to 81.1. Larg- perature, and 80 cal/g would be absorbed lomew DT. 1986. Role of reduced hemochromes in
er hue angles indicate a more yellowish- (latent heat of fusion). Even though the pink color defect of cooked turkey rolls. J Food Sci
51(5):1132-1136.
tan sample. Although the range was thawed patties also underwent the FDA (US Food and Drug Administration). 1999. Food
narrow, some differences were found change from ice to water, it occured as a Code. Washington D.C.: US Public Health Service,
among endpoint temperatures. At 62.8 separate event (thawing) and the energy Food and Drug Administration.
Froning GW. 1983. Color of processed turkey. IFT
and 65.6 °C, hue angles of frozen patties absorbed by the product was not cumula- Muscle Foods Division Newsletter 9: 2-5.
did not differ (P > 0.05). At 76.7 °C, frozen tive as it was in the frozen patties (Mohse- Froning GW, Daddario J, Hartung TE. 1968. Colour
and myoglobin concentration in turkey meat as
patties had a larger hue angle than all oth- nin 1980). When energy is transferred be- affected by age, sex and strain. Poultry Sci
er endpoint temperatures except 71.1 °C. tween 2 bodies of mass, a large part of that 47(6):1827-1830.
Hague MA, Warren KE, Hunt MC, Kropf DH, Kastner
Values for cooked-from-frozen patties energy is converted into heat, which rep- CL, Stroda SE, Johnson DE. 1994. Endpoint temper-
were much larger (P < 0.05) than hue an- resents a change in enthalpy. However, ature, internal cooked color, and expressible juice
color relationships in ground beef patties. J Food
gles from those thawed before cooking. the other part of the energy does not re- Sci 59(3):465-470.
flect as heat and it only causes a change in Hunt MC, Warren KE, Kropf DH, Hague MA, Waldner
Myoglobin denaturation CL, Stroda SL, Kastner CL. 1994. Factors affecting
the order of the molecules, that is, a premature browning in cooked ground beef. Pro-
No differences in myoglobin denatur- change in entropy. This means that not all ceedings 40 th International Congress Meat Sci-
ation (P > 0.05) were observed between types of energy will change the actual ence and Technology, The Hague, The Netherlands.
S-VIB.24.
frozen and thawed patties cooked above temperature of the product. Differential Hunt MC, Sørheim O, Slinde E. 1999. Color and heat
65.6 °C, but values at 62.8 °C and 65.6 °C energy absorbed by the frozen patties denaturation of myoglobin forms. J Food Sci
64(5):847-851.
were lower (P < 0.05) for the frozen patties could denature the pigment earlier than Lavelle CL, Hunt MC, Kropf DH. 1995. Display life
versus the thawed patties. Trout (1989) in thawed patties, which could explain the and internal cooked color of ground beef from vi-
tamin E-supplemented steers. J Food Sci 60(6):1175-
found increasing percent myoglobin de- more well-done appearance of patties 1178, 1196.
naturation from 55 ° to 83 °C. cooked from frozen. Furthermore, the Lien R, Hunt MC, Anderson S, Kropf DH, Loughin TM,
Dikeman ME, Velazco J. 2001. Effects of endpoint
thermal conductivity is 2 or 3 times greater temperature on the internal color of pork loin
Consideration of the thermal for frozen meat than for thawed meat. chops of different quality. J Food Sci. Forthcoming.
properties of meat and color Thus, at a common final endpoint temper- Machlik SM. 1965. The effect of heat on bovine myo-
globin derivatives in model systems and in beef
It is clear that patties cooked from fro- ature, the frozen patties would have ab- semitendinosus muscle. PhD dissertation, Purdue
zen had less red color and had greater sorbed more energy than the thawed Univ, West Lafayette, IN.
Marksberry CL. 1990. The effect of fat level, pH, car-
myoglobin denaturation at the lower end- meat. cass maturity and compaction on the cooked inter-
point temperatures relative to cooked nal color of ground beef patties at five end-point
temperatures. (MSc thesis) Manhattan, KS: Kansas
from thawed patties. This indicates that Conclusions State University. 70p.
frozen patties become more tan early in
the cooking process similar to premature
browning in ground beef. Similar results
P ATTIES MADE FROM NORMAL QUALITY
pork will develop cooked internal color
in a normal, predictable pattern and be-
Mendenhall VT. 1989. Effect of pH and total pigment
concentration on the internal color of cooked
ground beef patties. J Food Sci 54(1):1-2.
Mohsenin NM. 1980. Thermal properties of foods and
agricultural materials. New York: Gordon and State University. 50 p. Van Laack RLJM, Berry BW, Solomon MB. 1996b. Vari-
Breach Science Publishers 178 p Trautman JC. 1966. Effect of temperature and pH on ations in internal color of cooked beef patties. J
NAMP. (North American Meat Processors Associa- the soluble proteins of ham. J Food Sci 31(3):409- Food Sci 61(2):410-414.
tion). 1997. The Meat Buyers Guide. North Amer- 418. Warriss PD. 1979. The extraction of haem pigments
ican Meat Processors Association. Reston, VA. p. Trout GR. 1989. Variation in myoglobin denaturation from fresh meat. J Food Technol. 14:75-80.
124. and color of cooked beef, pork, and turkey meat as MS20010218 Submitted 5/4/01, Accepted 11/28/01,
NPPC. (National Pork Producers Council). 1991. Pro- influenced by pH, sodium chloride, sodium tripoly- Received 11/28/01
cedure to evaluate market hogs. 3rd Ed. National phosphate, and cooking temperature. J Food Sci
Pork Producers Council. Des Moines, IA. p. 8. 54(3):536-540. Contribution No. 01-340-J from the Kansas Agr. Exp. Sta-
Pool MF. 1956. Why does some turkey turn pink?. Tur- USDA (United States Department of Agriculture). tion, Manhattan.
key World Jan 68-74. 1997. USDA advises consumers to use a thermom-
SAS. 1998. SAS User´s Guide: Basic Statistical Anal- eter when cooking hamburger. Washington, D.C.:
The authors are with Kansas State Univ., Animal
ysis, Cary, N.C.: SAS Institute Inc. USDA, Food Safety and Inspection Service. Sciences and Industry, 232 Weber Hall, Manhat-
Schoenbeck MK. 1998. The effect of pH, myoglobin Van Laack RLJM, Berry BW, Solomon MB. 1996a. Ef- tan, KS 66506-0201. Direct inquiries to author
form and endpoint temperature on cooked ground fect of precooking conditions on color of cooked Hunt (E-mail: hhunt@oznet.ksu).
beef color (MSc thesis). Manhattan, Kans.: Kansas beef patties. J Food Protection 59(9):976-983.