Professional Documents
Culture Documents
3. What constitutes prima facie evidence 8. The liabilities of the partner who has
of a continuation of the partnership undertaken to contribute a sum of
after the expiration of its fixed term? money and fails to do so
A continuation of the business by the (1) To contribute on the date due the
partners or such of them as habitually amount he has undertaken to
acted therein during the term, without any contribute to the partnership;
settlement or liquidation of the (2) To reimburse any amount he may
partnership affairs, is prima facie have taken from the partnership
evidence of a continuation of the coffers and converted to his own use;
partnership (3) To pay the agreed or legal
interest, if he fails to pay his
4. In the preceding question, is there any contribution on time or in case he
change in rights and duties of the takes any amount from the common
partners? fund and converts it to his own use;
The rights and duties of the partners and
remain the same as they were at such (4) To indemnify the partnership for
termination but only insofar as is the damages caused to it by the delay
consistent with a partnership at will. in the contribution or the conversion
of any sum for his personal benefit
5. When is a partner considered a debtor
of the partnership? 9. Rule in the event a partner converts
He is considered a debtor when he partnership money to his personal
promises to contribute into the use
partnership. Art. 1786 provides that ARTICLE 1788. A partner who has
“every partner is a debtor of the undertaken to contribute a sum of money
partnership for whatever he may have and fails to do so becomes a debtor for
promised to contribute thereto.” the interest and damages from the time
he should have complied with his
6. Obligations of a partner with respect
obligation.
to his promise to contribute property
(1) To contribute at the beginning of the The same rule applies to any amount he
partnership or at the stipulated time the may have taken from the partnership
money, property, or industry which he coffers (fund), and his liability shall begin
may have promised to contribute;
from the time he converted the amount to
(2) To answer for eviction in case the
his own use. (1682) He becomes a
partnership is deprived of the
determinate property contributed; and debtor of the partnership for whatever he
(3) To answer to the partnership for the may have promised to contribute and for
fruits of the property the contribution of interests and damages from the time he
which he delayed, from the date they should have complied with his obligation.
should have been contributed up to the
time of actual delivery. In addition, the 10. May industrial partner engage in
partner has the obligation: business for himself?
(4) To preserve said property with the No, An industrial partner cannot engage
diligence of a good father of a family in business for himself
pending delivery to the partnership (Art.
1163.); and 11. Does this prohibition apply to a
(5) To indemnify the partnership for any business the same as the business of
damage caused to it by the retention of the partnership?
the same or by the delay in its Yes, unless the partnership expressly
contribution. (Arts. 1788, 1170.) permits him to do so. The prohibition is
absolute and applies whether the
7. If the capital or part thereof which a industrial partner is to engage in the
partner is bound to contribute same business in which the partnership
consists of goods, how shall said is engaged or in any kind of business. It
good be appraised? is clear that the reason for the prohibition
Manner of Appraisal: exists in both cases, which is to prevent
any conflict of interest between the
industrial partner and the partnership and 16. Which partner is not bound to
to insure faithful compliance by said contribute additional fund despite
partner with his prestation. imminent loss of the business of the
partnership?
12. The remedies available to the It is to be noted that the industrial partner is
partnership if an industrial partner exempted from the requirement to contribute
engages in business for himself an additional share. Having contributed his
without the express permission of the entire industry, he can do nothing further.
partnership.
Remedied of capitalist partner against an 17. A and B are partners in A and
industrial partner engaged in business for Company. A is the managing partner.
himself X owes A and Company P50,000.00
• The capitalist partner may exclude and A, in his personal capacity,
the industrial partner from the another sum of P50,000.00. Both
partnership plus damages; or debts are due and demandable. If A
• The capitalist partner may avail collects the amount of P50,000.00
themselves of the benefits which the from X, how shall such payment be
industrial partner may have obtained applied?
plus damages. A and A and Company will share if A issued
the receipt for his own credit, then the 50,000
13. If A, B and C form a partnership should be applied proportionately that is
stipulating that the capital shall be 25,000 will be applied to his own credit and
P150,000.00 without specifying the the balance of 25,000 will be applied to the
share of each partner, how much shall credit of the partnership.
each partner contribute? If A issued a receipt for the credit of the
Unless there is a stipulation to the partnership, then the entire 50,000 will be
contrary, partners shall contribute equal applied to the credit of the partnership.
shares to the capital of the partnership.
The case did not mention the separate 18. The obligation of a partner who has
contribution of partners A, B, and C received in whole or in part, his share
hence, using the disputable presumption, of a partnership credit when the other
each partner shall contribute P50,000. partners have not collected their
share and the partnership debtor
14. In case of imminent loss of the thereafter becomes insolvent
business of the partnership, which to bring to the partnership capital what he
partners are required to contribute received even though he may have given
additional capital to save the business receipt for his share only.
of the partnership?
As a general rule, a capitalist partner is 19. If the partnership suffers loss or
not bound to contribute to the partnership damage due to the fault or negligence
more than what he agreed to contribute of a partner, who shall be
but in case of an imminent loss of the responsible?
business, and there is no agreement to Every partner is responsible to the
the contrary, he is under obligation to partnership for damages suffered by it
contribute an additional share to save the through his fault, and he cannot compensate
venture. If he refuses to contribute, he them with the profits and benefits which he
shall be obliged to sell his interest to the may have earned for the partnership by his
other partners. industry.
15. The remedy in case a capitalist 20. Can the partner who is responsible for
partner refuses to contribute the damage compensate them with
additional fund when he is bound to the profits and benefits which he may
do so have earned for the partnership by his
The law provides a remedy which, industry?
incidentally, is just to both parties since the As a general rule, the damages caused by a
partner who refuses to contribute is paid the partner to the partnership cannot be offset by
value of his interest while the other partners the profits or benefits which he may have
earned for the partnership by his industry
are thereby relieved from the burden of
continuing their association with him in the
21. Who shall bear the risk of loss of
business things contributed to the partnership?
If the things contributed are fungible, or 26. The 2 distinct ways of appointing a
cannot be kept without deteriorating, or if partner as managing partner.
they were contributed to be sold, the risk • Appointment in the articles of
shall be borne by the partnership. In the partnership; or
absence of stipulation, the risks of things • In an instrument other than the
brought and appraised in the inventory, shall articles of partnership
also be borne by the partnership, and in such
case the claim shall be limited to the value at 27. What are the rights and obligations of
which they were appraised. a managing partner whose
appointment is contained in the
22. Who shall be answerable for the articles of co-partnership?
amounts disbursed and for the • If he acts in good faith, he may do all
obligations a partner may have the acts of administration despite the
contracted in good faith in the interest opposition of his partners
of the partnership business and for • If he acts in bad faith, he cannot do
risks in consequence of its any act of administration. It must be
management? noted that the presumption in law is
ART. 1796. The partnership shall be in favor of good faith.
responsible to every partner for the amounts
he may have disbursed on behalf of the 28. What are the powers of 2 or more
partnership and for the corresponding managing partners whose respective
interest, from the time the expenses are duties are not specified?
made; it shall also answer to each partner for Each one may separately execute all acts of
the obligations he may have contracted in administration, but if any of them should
good faith in the interest of the partnership oppose the acts of the others, the decision of
business, and for risks in consequence of its the majority shall prevail. In case of tie, the
management. matter shall be decided by the partners
owning the controlling interest.
23. How shall be the profits and losses be
distributed among the partners? 29. How shall management be exercised
Distribution of profits: in case it is stipulated that none of the
• According to the agreement managing partners shall act without
• If there is no agreement: the consent of the others?
o Capitalist Partner- shall be in The concurrence of all shall be necessary for
proportion to his capital validity of the acts, and the absence or
contribution. This rule is based on disability of any one of them cannot be
the presumed will of the partners alleged, unless there is imminent danger of
o Industrial Partner- just and grave or irreparable injury to the partnership.
equitable under the General Rule: Unanimous consent of all the
circumstances managing partners (even if one is absent or
Distribution of losses: incapacitated) shall be necessary for the
• According to the agreement validity of the acts.
• If there is no agreement: Exception: When there is imminent danger of
o Capitalist Partner- shall be in grave or irreparable injury to the partnership
proportion to his capital
contribution. 30. Who shall manage the partnership
o Industrial Partner- not liable for incase no manner of management has
losses been agreed upon?
ARTICLE 1803. When the manner of
24. Can the designation of the share of the management has not been agreed upon,
partners in profits and losses be the following rules shall be observed:
entrusted to a third person? (1) All the partners shall be considered
Yes, the designation of the share in the agents and whatever any one of them
profits and losses may be delegated to a third may do alone shall bind the partnership,
person by common consent. without prejudice to the provisions of
article 1801.
25. If the decision of the third person is to (2) None of the partners may, without the
be impugned, within what time shall it consent of the others, make any
be brought? important alteration in the immovable
only when it is manifestly inequitable. property of the partnership, even if it may
be useful to the partnership. But if the
refusal of consent by the other partners
is manifestly prejudicial to the interest of
the partnership, the court’s intervention 38. Can a capitalist partner engage in
may be sought. (1695a) business for his own account without
the consent of the other partners?
31. Can a partner associate another ARTICLE 1808. The capitalist partners
person with him in his share in the cannot engage for their own account in
partnership without the consent of the any operation which is of the kind of
other partners? business in which the partnership is
ARTICLE 1804. No. Every partner may engaged, unless there is a stipulation to
associate another person with him in his the contrary.
share, but the associate shall not be
admitted into the partnership without the 39. What is the liability of a capitalist
consent of all the other partners, even if partner who engages in the same
the partner having an associate should business that of the partnership
be a manager. (1696) without the const of the other
partners?
32. Can the associate take part in Any capitalist partner violating this
management? prohibition shall bring to the common
No, unless there is a consent of all the funds any profits accruing to him from his
other partners. transactions, and shall personally bear all
the losses.
33. What will the associate share with the
partner? 40. Under what circumstances shall any
partner demand a formal account as
34. Where shall be partnership books be to partnership affairs?
kept? ARTICLE 1809. Any partner shall have
at the principal place of business of the the right to a formal account as to
partnership. partnership affairs:
(1) If he is wrongfully excluded from the
35. What are the rights of the partners partnership business or possession of its
with respect to the books of the property by his co-partners;
partnership? (2) If the right exists under the terms of
Every partner shall at any reasonable any agreement;
hour have access to and may inspect and (3) As provided by article 1807;
copy any of them. A partner is given by (4) Whenever other circumstances
law the right to have access to, inspect render it just and reasonable. (n)
and copy the partnership books for the
purpose of enabling that partner to obtain PROPERTY RIGHTS OF A PARTNER
true and full information of all things 1. What are the property rights of a
affecting the partnership. Partnership partner?
books is an example of partnership ARTICLE 1810. The property rights of a
property and every partner is a co-owner partner are:
of specific partnership property. (1) His rights in specific partnership
property;
36. To whom shall partners be obligated (2) His interest in the partnership; and
to render information of all things (3) His right to participate in the
affecting the partnership? management.
to any partner or the legal representative
of any deceased partner or of any partner 2. As regards specific partnership
under legal disability. property, what relationship exists
between and among the partners?
37. When are partners accountable to the A partner is co-owner with his partners of
partnership and are considered as specific partnership property.
trustees for the partnership?
ARTICLE 1807. Every partner must 3. What are the incidents of this co-
account to the partnership for any ownership?
benefit, and hold as trustee for it any (1) A partner, subject to the provisions of this
profits derived by him without the consent Title and to any agreement between the
of the other partners from any transaction partners, has an equal right with his partners
connected with the formation, conduct, or to possess specific partnership property for
liquidation of the partnership or from any partnership purposes; but he has no right to
use by him of its property.
possess such property for any other purpose If a partner conveys (assigns, sells, donates)
without the consent of his partners; his whole interest in partnership, it may still
(2) A partner’s right in specific partnership subsist (this is the general rule) or it may
property is not assignable except in dissolved (this is an exception, for example,
connection with the assignment of rights of if the remaining partner not want to continue
all the partners in the same property; the operation of the business of the
(3) A partner’s right in specific partnership partnership)
property is not subject to attachment or
execution, except on a claim against the 8. What are the rights of an assignee of
partnership. When partnership property is a partner’s interest?
attached for a partnership debt the partners, • To receive the profits to which the
or any of them, or the representatives of a assigning partner would otherwise be
deceased partner, cannot claim any right entitled;
under the homestead or exemption laws; • In case of fraud in the management
(4) A partner’s right in specific partnership of the partnership, the assignee me
property is not subject to legal support under avail himself of the usual remedies
article 291. (n) provided by law;
• In case of dissolution, to receive the
4. What is the nature of a partner’s assignor's interest; and
interest in the partnership? • In case of dissolution, the assignee
A partner’s interest in the partnership is his may require an account from t date
share of the profits and surplus. only of the last account agreed to by
A partner’s right in specific partnership all the partners.
property belonging to the fi rm to be used for
business purposes (supra.) is to be 9. What rights cannot be exercised by an
distinguished from a partner’s right to share assignee?
in the fi rm’s earned profits. • Cannot interfere in the management
of the partnership business;
5. Can a partner assign his whole • Cannot require information or
interest in the partnership to another accounting of partners transactions;
without the consent of the other and
partners? • Cannot inspect partnership books.
A partner’s right in specific partnership
property is not assignable (Art. 1811[2].) but 10. Is a partner’s interest in the
he may assign his interest in the partnership partnership subject to attachment or
(Art. 1812.) to any of his co-partners or to a execution for his personal debts?
third person without the consent of the other No. - (3) A partner’s right in specific
partners, in the absence of agreement to the partnership property is not subject to
contrary. attachment or execution, except on a
claim against the partnership. When
6. Will the assignee become a partner? partnership property is attached for a
No, because a conveyance by a partner of partnership debt the partners, or any of
his whole interest in the partnership does not them, or the representatives of a
of itself dissolve the partnership, or, against deceased partner, cannot claim any right
the other partners in the absence of under the homestead or exemption laws;
agreement, entitle the assignee, during the
continuance of the partnership, to interfere in 11. May the interest so charged be
the management or administration of the redeemed and with what property
partnership business or affairs, or to require shall it be redeemed?
any information or account of partnership The interest charged may be redeemed
transactions, or to inspect the partnership at any time before foreclosure, or in case
books; but it merely entitles the assignee to of a sale being directed by the court, may
receive in accordance with his contract the be purchased without thereby causing a
profits to which the assigning partner would dissolution:
otherwise be entitled. However, in case of (1) With separate property, by any one or
fraud in the management of the partnership, more of the partners; or
the assignee may avail himself of the usual (2) With partnership property, by any one
remedies. or more of the partners with the consent
of all the partners whose interests are not
7. Will the conveyance of a partner of his so charged or sold.
whole interest in the partnership
dissolve the partnership?
12. What other right may a partner whose 5. What is meant by subsidiary liability
interest has been so charged avail of? of the partners?
Redemption, which means the Subsidiary liability means that the
extinguishment of the charge or attachment partners’ separate property may be held
of the partner's interest in the profits. liable only after the partnership creditors’
Or exhausted the assets of the partnership.
A partner shall not be deprived of his right
under the exemption laws, as regards his
interest in the partnership. However, a 6. What is meant by the partner’s pro-
partner, cannot avail himself of the rata liability?
exemption laws insofar as his right in specific Pro-rata liability means equally or joint.
partnership property is concerned.
7. How do you reconcile the exception of
OBLIGATIONS OF THE PARTNERS WITH an industrial partner from loss and his
REGARD TO THIRD PERSONS pro-rata liability for partnership
contractual obligations?
1. Under what name shall every The industrial partner would have to pay
partnership operate? but he can recover the amount he has
ARTICLE 1815. Every partnership shall paid from the capitalist partners unless
operate under a firm name, which may or there is an agreement to the contrary
may not include the name of one or more
of the partners. 8. When is a partnership contractual
obligation incurred?
2. Is there any limitation as to the firm ART 1816 – It is incurred when the
name a partnership may adopt? contractual obligation is entered into in
The partners may use any firm name the name and for the account of the
desired and this will be the name of that partnership, under its signature and by a
juridical person. The partnership cannot person authorized to act for the
use an identical or deceptively partnership.
confusingly similar to that of any existing
partnership or corporation or to any other 9. What is the effect of a stipulation
name already protected by law or is among the partners contrary to the
patently deceptive or contrary to existing pro-rata and subsidiary liability of the
laws. partners?
ART 1817 – A stipulation among the
3. What is the liability of a person, who partners contrary to the pro rata and
not being a partner includes his name subsidiary liability is void and of no effect
in the partnership’s name? insofar as it affects the rights of third
Those who, not being members of the persons. It is valid and enforceable only
partnership, include their names in the among the partners.
firm name, shall be subject to the liability
of a partner. 10. In the absence of any agreement to the
contrary, who shall act as agent of the
4. How are partners including industrial partnership?
ones be liable for contractual ART 1803 – In the absence of any
obligations of the partnership? agreement to the contrary, all partner
ARTICLE 1816. All partners, including have equal rights in the management
industrial ones, shall be liable pro rata and conduct of the partnership
with all their property and after all the business.
partnership assets have been exhausted,
for the contracts which may be entered 11. Classify the acts of a partner in the
into in the name and for the account of partnership.
the partnership, under its signature and a. Acts apparently for carrying on in the
by a person authorized to act for the usual way the business of the partnership
partnership. However, any partner may b. Acts not apparently for carrying on in
enter into a separate obligation to the usual way the business of the
perform a partnership contract. partnership
c. Acts of strict dominion or Ownership
d. Acts in contravention of a restriction on Under the provisions of the Civil Code,
authority any partner may convey title to such
property involving title to real property.
12. If a partner who has no authority
performs an act for apparently 17. One title is conveyed may the
carrying on in the usual member partnership recover such property?
manner the business of the
partnership, will such act be binding The partnership may recover such
upon the partnership? property if the partner’s act does not bind
the partnership under the provisions of
Every partner is an agent and may
the first paragraph of Article 1818, or
execute such acts with binding effect on unless such property has been conveyed
the partnership even if he has in fact no by the grantee.
authority unless the third person has
knowledge of such lack of authority 18. Where title to real property is in the
name of the partnership, and a
13. Give examples for acts of strict conveyance is executed by a partner
dominion. in his own name, will title pass to the
1) Assign the partnership property in trust grantee?
for creditors or on the assignee’s promise
to pay the debts of the partnership; Where title to real property is in the name
(2) Dispose of the good-will of the of the partnership, a conveyance is
business; executed by a partner in his own name,
(3) Do any other act which would make it passes the equitable interest of the
impossible to carry on the ordinary partnership, provided the act is one
within the authority of the partner under
business of a partnership;
the provisions of the first paragraph of
(4) Confess a judgment;
Article 1818.
(5) Enter into a compromise concerning
a partnership claim or liability; No, the title of the real property remains
(6) Submit a partnership claim or liability in the partnership. It is only the equitable
to arbitration; interest which will be transferred to the
(7) Renounce a claim of the partnership. grantee though he/she can ask for the
No act of a partner in contravention of a reformation of their contract of sale.
restriction on authority shall bind the
partnership to persons having knowledge 19. Define equitable interest.
of the restriction. (n)
According to the provisions of the Civil
14. When shall the partnership be bound Code, equitable interest is an interest
by any act of strict dominion? held by virtue of an equitable title or
Authorized by the other partners or claimed on equitable grounds, such as
unless they have abandoned the the interest held by a trustee beneficiary.
business
Equitable interest or Title is one not
recognized by law but in equity alone; it
15. Under whose name may real property
is a right or interest in property which is
owned by the partnership be
imperfect and unenforceable at law but
registered? which under well-recognized equitable
a. Partnership principles should and is convertible into a
b. One or more but not all the legal right or title.
partners
c. One or more all the partners, or in Equitable Interest means all the
a third person in trust for the beneficial interests in the property like the
partnership use thereof and its fruits, but not the title
d. All the partners
20. When may conveyance of real
16. Where title to real property is in the property of the partnership by a
partnership name, who may convey partner in his own name pass title to
title to such property? the grantee?
Conveyance of real property of the 25. How is a partnership tort committed?
partnership by a partner in his own name
pass title to the grantee if the latter had - Art.1822 - Where, by any wrongful act or
no knowledge of the fact that the partner omission of any partner acting in the ordinary
had no authority even though the course of the business of the partnership or
conveyance was made in the usual way with the authority of his co-partners, loss or
of business injury caused to any person, not being a
partner in the partnership, or any penalty is
21. Where title to real property is in the incurred, the partnership is liable therefor to
name of one or more or all the the same extent as the partner so acting or
partners, or in a third person in trust omitting to act.
for the partnership and is conveyed by
a partner in his own name or in the 26. Who shall be charged liable for
partnership name, will title pass to the partnership tort?
property?
- ART 1822 – The partnership is liable to the
- Art. 1819 (par. 4) - Yes, a conveyance same extent as the partner acting or omitting
executed by a partner in the partnership to act
name, or in his name, passes the equitable
interest of the partnership, (with the partner - ART 1823 – Any partner may pay for the
being a mere trustee of the partnership), obligation when:
provided the act is one within the authority of
the partner under the provisions of the first a. When an unlawful act or omission, loss or
paragraph of Art. 1818 injury is caused to a 3rd person
22. If real property is registered in the b. A partner, within the scope of his authority,
names of all the partners and is receives money or property from a 3rd
conveyed by all the partners, what person and misapplies it
passes to the grantee?
c. The partnership, in its ordinary course of
- Art. 1819 (par. 5) - A conveyance executed business, receives money or property from a
by all the partners passes all their rights in 3rd person and a partner misapplies it while
such property. in the custody of the partnership
23. When may admission or ART 1824 – All partners are liable solidarily
representation made by a partner be with the partnership for everything
considered evidence against the chargeable to
partnership?
27. How does a person not a partner
- Art. 1820 - An admission or representation become a partner by estoppel?
made by any partner concerning partnership
affairs within the scope of his authority is - In Article 1825, he will be liable to third
evidence against the partnership. persons as if he were a partner, when by
words or by conduct he:
24. Under what cases may notice or
acknowledge of any partner of any
a. Directly represent himself to anyone as a
matter relating to partnership affairs partner in an existing partnership or in a non-
operate as notice to or knowledge of existing partnership.
the partnership?
b. Indirectly represent himself by consenting
- Art.1821 by consenting to another representing him as
partner in an existing partnership or in a non-
a. Knowledge of the partner acting in the existing partnership.
particular matter acquired while a partner.
28. If a person is admitted as a partner
b. Knowledge of the partner acting in the into an existing partnership, shall he
particular matter then present in his mind. be liable for all the obligations of the
partnership incurred by the
c. Knowledge of any other partner who partnership before his admission?
reasonably could and should have
communicated it to the acting partner
- Yes, he is liable for all the obligations of the
partnership arising before his admission as
though he had been a partner when such
obligations were incurred.