Therapy: A Bisexual Surrogate Partner Relates Her Experiences from the Field
LINDA POELZL San Francisco, California, USA
A surrogate partner is a trained professional who works with clients
in sex therapy as part of a three-way therapeutic team, consisting of a psychotherapist, surrogate partner and client. This article looks at surrogate partner therapy and its relevance to bisexuals in therapy. The author approaches the subject from a personal and a pro- fessional perspective by using anecdotes, presenting case studies, background information about surrogate partner therapy as well as including elements from her own personal journal as a bisexual woman.
KEYWORDS surrogate partner, bisexual, sex therapy, therapeu-
tic team, premature ejaculation, erectile dysfunction, sexual ori- entation, homosexuality, biphobia, heterophobia, virgin, alterna- tive relationship, masturbation, orgasm, fantasy, nonmonogamy, polyamory, “coming out,” Kinsey scale, Klein Sexual Orientation Grid
The original article was published in the Journal of Bisexuality,
Volume 1, Number 1, 2001.
When I wrote my article on “Bisexual Issues in Sex Therapy” in the 2001
premier edition of the Journal of Bisexuality, I had been practicing as a surrogate partner for about 5 12 years. At that time I had had the opportunity to work with a number of clients who were questioning their sexuality and exploring the idea of a bisexual identity. The majority of these clients were relatively short term (20 sessions or fewer). Some of them concluded their therapy with me before they had come to any solid sense of their bisexuality, heterosexuality or homosexuality.
Address correspondence to Linda Poelzl. E-mail: poelzl@earthlink.net
385 386 Journal of Bisexuality
In the intervening years, although I’ve actually had fewer bisexually
identified or questioning clients, I did have the opportunity to work with a woman for an extended amount of time, 2 12 years to be exact. The referring female therapist, Dr. F, had worked with Sally (not her real name) for at least a year when she contacted me about the case. Sally was a 58-year-old woman in the process of divorcing her husband to whom she’d been married about 20 years. She had a 16-year-old son who was gay, and she and her husband had been aware and accepting of his sexual orientation from an early age. Sally worked full-time as a health-care professional. Although she was attracted to men, she knew she had a strong at- traction to women throughout her adult life and during her marriage. Even her husband was aware of her passionate and consuming friendships with straight women, who usually did not know that Sally was so emotionally and sexually attracted to them. When I began seeing Sally, she had an intense emotional relationship with a woman she worked with. This woman, Alice, was aware of Sally’s romantic and sexual feelings for her and even passively encouraged them. It gave Alice a sense of power, and she enjoyed being the object of such intense desire—even though she was married herself and claimed to have no sexual or romantic feelings for Sally (or women in general). When Sally began working with me, she was desperate to clarify her sexual identity and find a way to meet and relate to women who would return her feelings fully. She had mixed feelings all the way around. She was attracted to men, but not her husband, and it was clear that they needed to divorce. She knew she was attracted to women emotionally and sexually, and she often lubricated profusely when she spent time with Alice: there was often affectionate touch involved, primarily hugging and holding hands during their intimate emotional exchanges. She tended to prefer more femi- nine women (“soccer moms,” she called them, who were often straight) and had avoided venturing into the lesbian community because she was terrified of butch, “manly” women. She also never thought about women’s genitals as particularly sexually interesting. It was the face-to-face and eye contact that she craved. Sally’s issues were related to her relationship with her mother who had been critical and distant emotionally, and she had been exploring the family of origin material with her therapist for some time. Sally was deeply sensitive and emotionally fragile and frequently obsessed about her relationship with Alice. She was also being treated for depression with several medications. However, Dr. F. said Sally had made a lot of progress from the nearly infantile state of emotional development in which she had started therapy. The surrogate therapy process proceeded slowly, and we spent many sessions talking, doing relaxation techniques and touching with clothes on. Sally liked to be held and often wept. We gave Sally plenty of space for L. Poelzl 387
her feelings to emerge in a nurturing environment with no pressure about
nudity or sexuality. Eventually we began confronting body image issues and exploring sensual and sexual touch. It was a pleasure to see the lover in her emerge now that she could express herself freely. I thought about other ways I could support her in expressing her newfound queer identity. Sally lived in a small, rural community with no visible lesbian, gay, or bi community, and she was definitely in the closet at work and while participating in local community activities. Because she travelled such a distance for our sessions (a 3–4 hour drive) and often stayed overnight at a hotel, we began to “think outside the box” regarding Sally’s therapy. My office is near the Castro District in San Francisco. I brought up the idea with Dr. F. of including some field trips into the community, especially since it was literally a 15-minute walk or 5-minute drive away. When Dr. F. discussed the field trip idea with Sally, she was eager to try it, although nervous. We usually did at a least a 3- to 4-hour session in my office, during which we had privacy, space and time for intimate conversations, affectionate touch and sexual activities. We negotiated a much-lower hourly rate for field trips and often spent 5 to 6 hours out in the community after our private sessions. We started with simply holding hands in the Castro. That was a big step for her, and she would glance around cautiously, convinced everyone was staring at us. Of course, she found that no one noticed. It was simply acceptable and mundane behavior for same-sex partners to hold hands in public in that neighborhood. After dinner we often went to a lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender (LGBT) bookstore. She started reading women’s erotica and enjoying it. Sally was a member of Toastmasters in her rural community and loved public speaking. I located a queer Toastmasters group at the LGBT Center. It was educational and fun going to meetings at Rainbow Toastmasters and par- ticipating in the group. The women toastmasters were especially delighted at our arrival, because most of the participants were gay (or bi) men. Ironically, this was where Sally’s bisexuality came out a bit more as she found herself attracted to some of the gay men. She had a great time flirting with all the genders at Toastmasters’ meetings. Our explorations got a little more adventurous. I took Sally to a women’s introductory tantra class in Sebastopol. Again, she was overwhelmed yet in- trigued and excited to explore her sexuality in a group setting with women of all sexual orientations who were open to being sensual and erotic with other women. I also accompanied her one weekend to a Women’s Cele- brating the Body Erotic workshop presented by The Body Electric School in Oakland. Although these experiences challenged her on many levels (group nu- dity, “yoni showing,” massage, orgasmic breath work, dancing, ritual), my presence and support helped Sally push her edges. She was ready to do it and integrated these experiences surprisingly easily. 388 Journal of Bisexuality
When we were ready to conclude our intimate work, she continued to
see Dr. F. She also enrolled in a 6-month women’s tantra intensive where she went to Sebastopol one weekend a month for 6 months. After each weekend, she would call me for a phone session to process the events of the weekend. Dr. F. encouraged her to consult with me as needed because I had far more experience in “alternative sexuality” communities like these. Eventually, we concluded our work together. Sally continued attending the women’s tantra group and met a woman at a workshop with whom she developed a loving sexual and romantic relationship. We spoke recently on the phone as Sally was preparing to move to another state with her lover. She continued to be amazed at how compatible they were and how “easy” the relationship was. I was delighted she had found a lover, especially through one of these alternative communities. Sally made an amazing transition in her life. She was able to do this through the combination of talk therapy with Dr. F, appropriate medications for her depression and surrogate therapy with me. The fact that she had the commitment and resources to stick with the process for as long as it took her to find her identity as a bisexual/lesbian woman contributed to the success of her therapy and the happiness she is currently experiencing. I am proud of the work we did together and honored by the amazing trust Sally placed in me as her surrogate partner and guide. When Sally and I completed our work, Dr. F and I did our own clo- sure, as is customary in surrogate partner therapy. We agreed that the extra time spent in a community where Sally could express herself socially as a bisexual woman, and/or simply as a woman with a female partner, was ex- tremely beneficial therapeutically. It enabled Sally to have a wide variety of social, sensual and sexual experiences in a completely safe and supportive situation with me by her side, literally holding her hand at times. I recom- mend including some form of practical and supported activities such as the types described above when socializing a person questioning their sexual orientation.
Linda Poelzl is a self-identified bisexual woman and has been working in
the field of human sexuality since 1990 as a sex educator, public speaker, writer, coach and sexological bodyworker. She was trained as a professional surrogate partner and has been working with clients in sex therapy for 16 years. Linda’s clientele includes women, men, transgender and intersex people. She is currently writing a book about her career in sexual health and well-being. She can be reached through her website: www.waterdragonwoman.com. Copyright of Journal of Bisexuality is the property of Taylor & Francis Ltd and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.