Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
Keywords Background: It is well established that extra virgin olive oil (EVOO), applied to the skin, has
extra virgin olive oil healing and anti-inflammatory properties.
(EVOO), Aim: To evaluate the effectiveness of EVOO in the prevention of nipple cracking in lactating
nipple cracking, women.
lactating women Methods: Experimental, prospective, randomized study of 300 lactating women, admitted to the
postpartum unit of the city’s general hospital (Cienfuegos, Cuba). The study was carried out in
2012. Eligible patients were randomized into two groups of 150 women. In Group 1, EVOO was
applied on the nipple after feeding, and in Group 2, drops of breast milk were applied to the
nipple after feeding. Clinical evaluations were made during the first week of treatment and after
the first month. All women who initiated breastfeeding were considered eligible to be included
in this study; breastfeeding was characterized as the moment of mother–child interaction with
suction on the nipple. Efficacy was evaluated quantitatively, as the absence of cracks in the nipple
during the first 2 weeks of lactation using as the proportion of women with or without nipple
cracks, and if present, whether they were moderate or slight.
Results: The quantitative efficacy was 97.3% and no adverse effects occurred in mothers and
newborns during the administration of EVOO.
Discussion and Conclusions: EVOO helps prevent nipple cracking in lactating women. It has
been shown to have protective effects when breastfeeding presents technical difficulties. This
conclusion is borne out by the frequency distribution results obtained, which reflect a significantly
higher proportion of nipple cracking in the population that was not treated with EVOO.
Linking Evidence to Action: Use EVOO to prevent nipple cracking during breastfeeding by
administering 3 drops on each nipple after each feeding. Decreased nipple cracking will reduce
pain and enhance breastfeedinging by administering 3 drops on each nipple after each feeding,
improving the health of mothers and infants.
Correction made after online publication November 17, 2015: Author names have been updated.
364 Worldviews on Evidence-Based Nursing, 2015; 12:6, 364–369.
C 2015 Sigma Theta Tau International
Original Article
Table 1. Treatment With and Without Extra Virgin Olive Oil (EVOO)
Quality of
Treatment/ Skin Toxic Studying/ feeding Type of Type of Nipple
variables color habits working posture feeding birth cracking
No EVOO % White Tobacco Not working Good Breast Natural delivery Present
68.7, 5.3, 41.3, 11.4, 59.3, 50.7, 44.0,
Black 31.3 coffee 30.0, working 42.7, moderate 51.7, mixed 40.7 vaginal operative delivery or not present 56.0
neither 64.7 studying 16.0 poor 36.9 cesarean 49.3
EVOO % White Tobacco Not working Good Breast Natural delivery Present
82.7, 6.0, 27.3, 26.7, 70.0, 50.7, 2.7,
Black 17.3 coffee 14.7, working 47.3, moderate 54.7, mixed 30.0 vaginal operative delivery or not present 97.3
neither 79.3 studying 25.3 poor 18.7 cesarean 49.3
Table 2. Presence of Nipple Cracking and its Rela- are reflected in the inhibition of the generation of various re-
tionship With the Other Study Variables active oxygen species, and thus the suppression of phenomena
of lipid peroxidation, which are ultimately responsible for sys-
temic tissue damage (Villarrubia et al., 2007).
Variables Score Significance The undoubted immunological and anti-inflammatory ef-
fects of EVOO give rise to a potent antioxidant action that
Quality of feeding 12.166 .000 has been shown in various experimental models (Abdulrhman
posture evaluated:
et al., 2012; Cortés Castell et al., 2014; and Gungor et al., 2013)
moderate
and is apparent in various pathological processes in humans.
Quality of feeding 53.577 .000 It reduces tissue aggression and preserves anti-infective and
posture evaluated: anti-tumor mechanisms. Given the systemic nature of these
poor
actions, it seems reasonable to suggest there may be a cuta-
Exclusive 49.495 .000 neous outcome of the systemic effects of EVOO.
breastfeeding Current scientific opinion is that, among oil products, only
EVOO/no EVOO (1) 69.246 .000 EVOO is biologically functional in humans, presenting specific
trophic, anti-inflammatory and antioxidant actions (Villarrubia,
2000). The heating of olive oil, and its refining, both cause
the loss of many of its functional activities. Moreover, they
can generate toxic and clearly pro-inflammatory substances
(Villarrubia, 2000).
like ibuprofen and aspirin, can inhibit the activity of cyclooxy-
The skin is rich in fats, of different compositions and struc-
genase COX-1 and COX-2 enzymes, which is the basis for the
tures, and in this organ, in addition to the functions described
action of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs and analgesics
above, skin lipids play an important mechanical role. The bar-
(Whitehead & Rice, 2006). Fifty grams of EVOO contains up
rier responsible for skin permeability is located in the stra-
to 200 µg of oleocanthal, equivalent to 10% of the recom-
tum corneum and is composed primarily of ceramides, free
mended adult dose of ibuprofen for pain relief (Whitehead &
fatty acids, and cholesterol. The intercellular arrangement of
Rice, 2006).
In vivo experimental studies have demonstrated the anti- these lipids plays an important role in the regulation of water
inflammatory capacity of EVOO, as reflected in the in- exchange and storage processes in the skin and in the trans-
creased survival of animals lethally challenged with bacterial dermal permeation of oil-soluble agents (Bonilla Polo, Murillo
lipopolysaccharide. This outcome is related to the systemic Ramos, González Bonillo, & Sanz Pérez, 1997).
suppression of the production of tumor necrosis factor alpha, There is scientific evidence to recommend the oral adminis-
which is associated with many inflammatory processes of the tration of EVOO to prevent oxidative stress in skin, analogously
skin. In both cases, these anti-inflammatory effects of EVOO to its use for the prevention or treatment of systemic oxidative
This research was conducted in Cuba, a Caribbean coun- ministration of the product. EVOO continues to protect against
try with a tropical climate, which is seasonally humid with a nipple cracking even when the feeding posture adopted is in-
temperate, maritime influence, and high levels of solar radia- adequate. WVN
tion throughout the year. The results obtained showed that the
application of small drops of EVOO directly on the nipple af-
ter breastfeeding provided considerable protection against the
LINKING EVIDENCE TO ACTION
appearance of cracks in the nipple. Furthermore, the climate
conditions do not appear to reduce the beneficial effects of the r Use EVOO to prevent sore nipples during breast-
oil.
feeding by administering 3 drops on each nipple
The logistic regression analysis (Table 2) shows there is
after each feeding.
a relationship between the dependent variable appearance of
nipple cracking and the independent variables posture, type r EVOO did not produce adverse effects in mothers
of feeding and EVOO treatment. We highlight the preventive and newborns.
value of this natural product, which is greater than that of oil r Seventy percent of the women treated with EVOO
lacking the “extra virgin” denomination (i.e., refined olive oil).
breastfed exclusively during the first 6-month
EVOO contains large quantities of antioxidants and vitamin A,
period.
which are responsible for its healing and restorative qualities.
One of the relationships observed was that between the vari- r There is a direct relationship between the decrease
able appearance of nipple cracking and the quality of the breast- of nipple cracking and the quality of feeding (pos-
feeding posture. A highly significant finding was the presence ture) and the type of feeding.
of nipple cracking in women whose breastfeeding technique
was suboptimum. It has been reported elsewhere that when
the posture is not correct, the child’s mouth fails to cover the
entire nipple; in consequence, the vacuum created is incom- Author information
plete and the milk is extracted poorly. Therefore, the early de- Marı́a José Aguilar Cordero, Research Group CTS 367, Andalu-
tection of problems in applying the correct suction technique is sia, Spain, and Nursing Department, University of Granada,
very important, in order to avoid nipple cracks, mastitis and hy- Spain; Norma Mur Villar, Research Group CTS 367, Andalu-
pogalactia, which are the main causes of mothers’ abandoning sia, Spain, and University of Medical Sciences, Cienfuegos,
breastfeeding (Aguilar Cordero et al, 2012; Aguilar Cordero, Cuba; Rafael Guisado Barrilao, Nursing Department, Univer-
2010). sity of Granada, Spain; Manuel Eduardo Cortés Cortés, Math-
ematical Sciences, University of Technical Sciences, Cienfue-
LIMITATIONS gos, Cuba; Antonio Manuel Sánchez López, Research Group
The main limitation of this study was the difficulty of telephone CTS 367, Andalusia, Spain, and Nursing Department, Univer-
communication with women after childbirth to check if they sity of Granada, Spain
had sore nipples. Another limitation was the difficulty in mov- Address correspondence to Dr. Marı́a José Aguilar Cordero,
ing the EVOO from Granada, Spain, to the city of Cienfuegos, Departamento de Enfermerı́a, Facultad de Ciencias de la Salud,
Cuba. Universidad de Granada, Avda/de la Ilustración s/n, 18071
Granada, Spain; mariajaguilar@telefonica.net
CONCLUSIONS
Our literature search found no references to previous stud- Accepted 25 April 2015
Copyright
C 2015, Sigma Theta Tau International
ies of the effect of EVOO on the variables examined here.
However, research comparing the use of lanolin and breast
milk after feeding concluded that breast milk is preferable for References
treating sore and cracked nipples, although lanolin produced Abdulrhman, M., El Barbary, N.S., Ahmed Amin, D., & Saeid
a longer lasting healing effect (Ledoux, Hingle, & Baranowski, Ebrahim, R. (2012). Honey and a mixture of honey, beeswax, and
2011; Mohammadzadeh, Farhat, & Esmaeily, 2005). The re- olive oil-propolis extract in treatment of chemotherapy-induced
oral mucositis: A randomized controlled pilot study. Pediatric
sults of large-scale prospective studies based on clinical events Hematology-Oncology, 29, 285–292.
such as incident cases of cardiovascular disease, cancer or dia-
Aguilar Cordero, M.J. (2005). Lactancia Materna. Madrid, Spain:
betes mellitus corroborate the benefits of using EVOO. These Ed Elsevier.
studies provide sufficient scientific evidence that EVOO can
Aguilar Cordero, M.J. (2012). Tratado de enfermerı́a del niño y el
prevent cardiovascular and degenerative diseases (Aros & Es- adolescente. Cuidados pediátricos. [Treaty nursing the child and
truch, 2013; Arumugam et al., 2011; De Lorenzo, 2012). adolescent. Pediatric care]. Madrid, Spain: Ed Elsevier.
The results of this study reflect the importance of using Alba, J., Izquierdo, J.R., Gutiérrez, F., & Vossen, P. (2008). Aceite de
EVOO to prevent sore nipples during breastfeeding and no ad- Oliva Virgen Extra. Análisis sensorial [Extra Virgin Olive Oil. Sen-
verse effects occurred in mothers or newborns during the ad- sory analysis.] (2nd ed.). Madrid, Spain: ED Agrı́cola española.