Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/344496340
CITATIONS READS
0 6,738
1 author:
Michael Philippou
University of Birmingham
3 PUBLICATIONS 0 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Michael Philippou on 06 October 2020.
The purpose of this template is to ensure you receive targeted feedback that will
support your learning. It is a requirement to complete to complete all 3 sections, and to
include this completed template as the first page of every assignment that is submitted
for marking (your School will advise on exceptions).
Section One: Reflecting on the feedback that I have received on previous assessments,
the following issues/topics have been identified as areas for improvement: (add 3 bullet
points). NB – for first year students/PGTs in the first term, this refers to assessments in
your previous institution
•
Section Two: In this assignment, I have attempted to act on previous feedback in the
following ways (3 bullet points)
Please ensure that you complete and attach this template to the front of all work that is submitted.
By submitting your work online you are confirming that your work is your own and that you understand and
have read the University’s rules regarding plagiarism and the consequences that will arise should you submit
plagiarised work.
In a period of economic and global political volatility, it is essential to critically
analyse the contemporary issues that multinational organisations must face and the
extent to which they do so effectively. This report will focus on the American,
multinational, retail corporation ‘Walmart’. Walmart was a suitable company to focus
on within this report as they are somewhat representative of many large
transnational firms which have to face many issues in order to maintain a competitive
advantage within today's interconnected and globalised economy. One of the driving
motivations behind conducting an exhaustive critical reflective analysis of Walmart
and the method in which they respond to key contemporary issues is that Walmart is
an enormous corporation fixated with profit maximisation and world supremacy and
is arguably one of the earth's most prevailing company (Useem, Schlosser & Kim,
2003). This report will focus on issues regarding cultural differences and the effect
this has had on Walmart when operating in other countries and assuming mergers
and acquisitions, this issue seemed of great relevance due to the vast sources of
academic literature regarding the success and failures of Walmart when operating in
other countries in order for this report to compare and contrast these findings to
provide the reader with in-depth, quality business research and sound analytical
conclusions. Walmart has recently been under scrutiny for the pay gap between
executives and full-time hourly associates and this report will focus on this issue and
make recommendations on how Walmart should cope with this global issue. Walmart
operates within the UK under the organisation ASDA, this report will focus on the
economic impact of Brexit, its disruption on the UK economy and how Walmart will
cope with the economic fluctuations in order to remain competitive in the UK market
(Jones, Hillier & Comfort, 2014).
The first global issue that will be critically analysed are the challenges Walmart must
face during mergers and acquisitions (M&A), more specifically concentrating on the
cultural challenges that occur through post-acquisition integration within M&A. M&A
is an effective strategy for countless organisations to continue their growth trajectory,
create incremental value and compete in an internationalised market. And this is
supported by studies such as the graph in Figure 1 showing the number of M&A type
deals from the end of the 19th century to recent times; concluding that there is a
positive correlation and as the years go by more and more M&A deals have taken
place. However, while organisations have promising projections for the success of
M&A deals it must be recognised that mergers and acquisitions recurrently fail, and
this is partially due to the cultural challenges that occur through post-acquisition
integration and a neglection of human resource issues such as cultural sensitivity
and appreciation (Cartwright & Schoenberg, 2006). Recent literature in the field of
M&A shows that organisations overanalyse financial considerations and frequently
show disregard for human resource issues; thus fail to address cultural challenges,
this has proven to be a key issue in today’s increasingly interconnected and
globalised business environment (Ahern, Daminelli & Fracassi, 2015). However
other literature mentions that although sociocultural factors are critical factors
influencing mergers and acquisitions through knowledge transfer, the role of cultural
differences within M&A performance requires further clarification through research to
be held responsible for the failure of M&A in today's communicated commercial
domain (Sarala et al., 2016).
How are commentators (media and other stakeholders) interpreting and evaluating
Walmart’s response to this issue?
Walmart continues to employ its aggressive strategy of foreign acquisitions. And the
degree to which this aggressive strategy is successful is a controversial topic in the
light of the media and the opinions of Walmart’s stakeholders. In some cases, the
media believe that Walmart lacks the capabilities to achieve their goal of being the
all-around shopping destination in whichever foreign country they are operating in.
Landler and Barbaro (2006) from the New York times use Walmart’s unsuccessful
M&A venture in Germany as an example of how their formula is incapable of
effectively harmonising every culture even with necessary adaptations. Although
stakeholder’s mentioned that Walmart was able to effectively make necessary
adaptations to its organisation's work processes and HR issues in order to fit with
Latin American culture and be successful (Matusitz, 2016). Walmart also received a
lot of scrutiny from activist groups and the media in Mexico when Walmart was
accused of paying bribes in order to open a store less than two miles away from a
historical archaeological site and the “Pyramid of the moon” dated back to 200 AD.
Walmart replaced a small clay altar and other artefacts with its parking lot; proving
them to be inconsiderate of ancient Mesoamerican culture when conducting M&A’s
within Latin America (Barstow, 2012). Recent literature states that any stakeholders
come to the conclusion that in order for Walmart to combat this issue effectively it
must implement international strategic human resource management within the
workplace more effectively (Goggin, 2018).
The Brexit referendum is a popular and controversial topic of discussion among
economists and the severity of the impact of Britain leaving the European Union is
debatable. Some pro-Brexit economists believe that the impact of the Brexit
referendum is not as detrimental to the UK economy as first demonstrated by the fall
in the strength of currency and rise in inflation (Van Reenen, 2016). Although Menon
and Fowler (2016) believe that the effect of the Brexit deal is largely dependent on
whether the UK follows a hard or soft Brexit the degree of uncertainty within the UK
economy is a deterrent for large firms such as Walmart when operating within the UK
(Dhingra et al., 2016). Walmart operates within the UK under the name ASDA which
started its own brand before it was acquired by Walmart in 1999. ASDA is now the
third largest supermarket chain within Britain; thus the economic impacts of Brexit
are likely to disrupt revenue and Walmart’s international competitiveness whilst
operating within such a dynamic and unpredictable UK economy. The unstable and
capricious nature of the climate of the UK economy is likely to increase inflation
making it hard for ASDA to provide UK consumers with its low pricing strategy. The
Brexit deal is likely to translate to ASDA being forced to increase their prices, reduce
its range of products and provide poorer quality of goods to its consumers (Merrick,
2018). This could lead to immense changes within the supermarket industry inside
the UK, however, it is argued that large retail chains such as ASDA are more at risk
of losing market share due to entrants within the market that offer lower prices such
as ALDI and LIDL (Clarke, 2000). The Brexit referendums impact of the UK economy
is likely to impact the confidence of Walmart whilst operating in an unstable UK
market especially when Walmart’s goals is to become the largest retailer in the world
and has to compete with the likes of Amazon and Costco. Furthermore, Walmart
could experience detrimental effects due to the currency market as a stronger USD$
will almost definitely lead to a reduction in the value of Walmart’s international
revenues.
A number of sources conclude that Walmart has undoubtedly been attentive to the
unpredictable and volatile climate of the UK economy after it was voted to leave the
European Union. However, the impact of Brexit is still uncertain at this moment in
time and the UK doesn’t formally leave the EU till March 2019 and even if the UK
follows a hard Brexit this will not be fully implemented till the end of 2020 (Menon
and Fowler, 2016). Furthermore, Walmart is still precautious in the fact that Brexit
has raised a lot of economic uncertainty which will influence consumers to limit their
consumption due to job insecurity and inevitable price increases from supermarket
chains due to inflation and other shock factors. Walmart needs to be sure to keep
prices as low as possible in the midst of Brexit In order to remain competitive within a
volatile UK economy. However, if ASDA is to lower their prices they will start a price
war with the other large supermarket chains within the UK such as Tesco,
Sainsburys and Morrisons (Harvey, 2000). ASDA responded to the issues caused by
the Brexit referendum by imposing tougher payment terms on its clothing suppliers
for the brand “George”. Walmart’s ASDA was one of the first supermarket chains to
respond to the Brexit referendum and this is because Walmart use USD$ to buy its
fashion lines and the fall in the power of sterling due to Brexit shock means that the
money taken from tills at ASDA can comparatively purchase less USD$ (Steiner,
2017). There have been recent announcements made that say Walmart’s ASDA’s
method of staying competitive and combatting the volatile Brexit economy is to
merge with rival Sainsbury’s. By gaining market share and becoming market leader
ASDA will be at lesser risk to the economic impacts of Brexit. Sainsbury’s and
Walmart’s ASDA are the second and third largest supermarket chains in the UK and
if approved by regulators and they are able to merge they would be the market
leader; bettering Tesco (Amaro, 2018).
How are commentators (media and other stakeholders) interpreting and evaluating
Walmart’s response to this issue?
Most recent findings from the fiscal year of 2018 show that the pay gaps between
shop floor workers and executives within Walmart are worsening. Walmart’s CEO
salary is recorded at an astounding $22.8 million which works out to 1,188.1 times as
much as a median employee within Walmart this is a 2% rise from last year and
evidence that Walmart isn’t taking noticeable action to tackle this issue (Heller,
2018). Walmart has shown attention to this issue and made statements to
aggravated shareholders saying they would cut cash bonuses of executives by up to
25 per cent, however, this did not occur (Ritcey, Zhao & Boyle, 2018). This can be
shown from a section on the Walmart (2018) equity report for its shareholders as
shown in figure 7. However, it can be argued that this behaviour is to be expected of
Walmart as they are the biggest employer within the US and focus on keeping its
costs to a very minimum therefore focus on providing their skilled workers with pay
that they deserve and keeping its typical store workers wage to a minimum.
How are commentators (media and other stakeholders) interpreting and evaluating
Walmart’s response to this issue?
Aguilera, R.V. and Dencker, J.C.(2004). The role of human resource management in
cross-border mergers and acquisitions. The International Journal of Human
Resource Management, 15(8), pp.1355-1370.
Ahern, K.R., Daminelli, D. and Fracassi, C., (2015). Lost in translation? The effect of
cultural values on mergers around the world. Journal of Financial Economics, 117(1),
pp.165-189.
Barstow, D., (2012). Wal-Mart Hushed Up a Vast Mexican Bribery Case. New York
Times, 22.
Bruner, R. (2005). Deals from hell: M&A lessons that rise above the ashes, pp.1-18.
Cartwright, S., & Schoenberg, R. (2006). Thirty years of mergers and acquisitions
research: Recent advances and future opportunities. British journal of management,
17(S1), S1-S5.
Clarke, I., (2000). Retail power, competition and local consumer choice in the UK
grocery sector. European Journal of Marketing, 34(8), pp.975-1002.
Dhingra, S., Ottaviano, G., Sampson, T., & Van Reenen, J. (2016). The impact of
Brexit on foreign investment in the UK. BREXIT 2016, 24.
Dines, T. (2017). Binding shareholder votes put executive pay under the spotlight.
[online] Available at: https://www.investorschronicle.co.uk/2017/05/11/shares/news-
and-analysis/binding-shareholder-votes-put-executive-pay-under-the-spotlight-
uIscQ0B5DvgihkCbbm88zH/article.html [Accessed 3 Jan. 2019].
Foster, D. and Bowman, S. (2017). Debate: Are executives paid too much?. Sky
News.
Froese, F.J., Pak, Y.S. and Chong, L.C.,(2008) Managing the human side of cross-
border acquisitions in South Korea. Journal of World Business, 43(1), pp.97-108.
Gabbatt, A. (2018). Bernie Sanders targets Walmart and takes aim at low wages and
CEO pay. [online] Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/us-
news/2018/nov/17/bernie-sanders-stop-walmart-act-ceo-pay-low-wages [Accessed 4
Jan. 2019].
Goggin, N. (2018). Worried About M&A Culture Clashes? First, Take a Hard Look at
Acquisition Drivers. [online] Available at: https://www.aptos.com/worried-about-ma-
culture-clashes/ [Accessed 19 Dec. 2018].
Grobart, S. (2013). How Samsung became the world’s no. 1 smartphone maker.
Bloomberg Businessweek.
Hamza, S. and Nizam, I. (2016). Why Walmart Fails in Germany? An Analysis in the
Perspective of Organizational Behaviour. International Journal of Accounting &
Business Management, [online] 4(2), pp.206-211.
Heller, M. (2018). Walmart CEO’s Pay Rises 2% to $22.8 Million. [online] Available
at: http://ww2.cfo.com/compensation/2018/04/walmart-ceos-pay-rises-2-to-22-8-
million/ [Accessed 3 Jan. 2019].
Jones, P., Hillier, D., & Comfort, D. (2014). Assurance of the leading UK food
retailers' corporate social responsibility/sustainability reports. Corporate Governance,
14(1), pp.130-138.
Kiatpongsan, S. and Norton, M.I., (2014). How much (more) should CEOs make? A
universal desire for more equal pay. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 9(6),
pp.587-593.
Landler, M. and Barbaro, M. (2006). Wal-Mart Finds That Its Formula Doesn’t Fit
Every Culture. [online] Available at:
https://www.nytimes.com/2006/08/02/business/worldbusiness/02walmart.html
[Accessed 19 Dec. 2018].
Li, W. and Young, S. (2016). An Analysis of CEO Pay Arrangements and Value
Creation for FTSE-350 Companies. CFA Society of the United Kingdom (CFA UK),
2, pp.1-4.
Lichtenstein, N., (2005). Wal-Mart: Template for 21st century capitalism. In New
Labor Forum (Vol. 14, No. 1, pp. 21-30).
Lin, Y.F., Yeh, Y.M.C. and Shih, Y.T., (2013). Tournament theory's perspective of
executive pay gaps. Journal of Business Research, 66(5), pp.585-592.
Lunden, I. (2018). Walmart retreats from its UK Asda business to hone its focus on
competing with Amazon. [online] Available at:
https://techcrunch.com/2018/04/30/walmart-retreats-from-its-uk-asda-business-to-
hone-its-focus-on-competing-with-amazon/ [Accessed 4 Jan. 2019].
Merrick, R. (2018). Brexit certain to see food prices rise unless Theresa May gets EU
trade deal, warn peers. [online] Available at:
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/brexit-food-price-rise-theresa-may-
eu-trade-deal-lords-grocery-customs-barriers-tariffs-a8344351.html [Accessed 2 Jan.
2019].
Reardon, T., & Berdegué, J. A. (2002). The rapid rise of supermarkets in Latin
America: challenges and opportunities for development. Development policy review,
20(4), 371-388.
Ritcey, A., Zhao, J. and Boyle, M. (2018). Walmart Said It Would Cut the CEO's
Bonus Last Year. It Didn't. [online] Available at:
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-04-25/walmart-said-it-would-cut-ceo-
s-bonus-last-year-and-then-didn-t [Accessed 3 Jan. 2019].
Rushe, D. (2018). US bosses now earn 312 times the average worker's wage,
figures show. [online] Available at:
https://www.theguardian.com/business/2018/aug/16/ceo-versus-worker-wage-
american-companies-pay-gap-study-2018 [Accessed 3 Jan. 2019].
Sarala, R.M., Junni, P., Cooper, C.L. and Tarba, S.Y., (2016). A sociocultural
perspective on knowledge transfer in mergers and acquisitions. Journal of
Management, 42(5), pp.1230-1249.
Steiner, R. (2017). Asda imposes harsher terms on suppliers after pound's Brexit
slide. [online] Available at:
https://www.theguardian.com/business/2017/mar/02/asda-suppliers-pound-brexit-
george-clothing [Accessed 2 Jan. 2019].
Useem, J., Schlosser, J., & Kim, H. (2003). One nation under wal-mart. Fortune,
147(4), 65.
Van Reenen, J., (2016). Brexit’s Long-Run Effects on the UK Economy. Brookings
papers on economic activity, pp.367-38.