BENCHMARKING STUDY

OF
3.0 HP MONOBLOC PUMP

22-Jul-20 This is a proprietary document of Kirloskar Brothers Limited 1

 3.0 HP KBL MODELS
40
KS-316+ KSMB 324
35 KSMB 328 KBL-KOS-314+*
KBL-KOS-318+** KBL-KOS-325+*
KBL-KOS-335+* KBL JOS-326”
30 KBL JOS-330“” KBL JOS-335
KDS-312 (KBL) KDS-314 + (KBL)
KDS-318+ + (KBL) KDS-325+ + (KBL)
25 KDS-335+ + (KBL) KDI 318++(KBL)
Head , m

KDI 325++(KBL) KDI 335++(KBL)

20

15

10

0
0 5 10 15 20
Discharge, LPS
22-Jul-20 This is a proprietary document of Kirloskar Brothers Limited 2
 3.0 HP ALL COMPETITOR + KBL MODELS
70
SM 300 / S 300 (SALFLO) KS-316+

KSMB 324 KSMB 328

60
SL 32-160 B(SALFLO) CHM 300 / CH 300 (SALFLO)

PMHS-03 (POINTPUMP) PMSS-03 (POINTPUMP)

50
PCE90/6550 (POINTPUMP) PCE75/7565 (POINTPUMP)

40 DAB-KE 36/200 T MCE30/P DAB-K 11/500 T

Head , m

DAB-K 36/200 M DAB-K 11/500 M

30

20

10

0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
Discharge, LPS
22-Jul-20 This is a proprietary document of Kirloskar Brothers Limited 3
MODEL SEGREGATION AS PER BELOW CRITERIA

1) HIGH HEAD & LOW DISCHARGE

2) MEDIUM HEAD & MEDIUM DISCHARGE

3) LOW HEAD & HIGH DISCHARGE

22-Jul-20 This is a proprietary document of Kirloskar Brothers Limited 4

 HIGH HEAD & LOW DISCHARGE MODELS

22-Jul-20 This is a proprietary document of Kirloskar Brothers Limited 5

 HIGH HEAD & LOW DISCHARGE ALL COMPETITOR MODELS
70 SM 300 / S 300 (SALFLO)

CP 200 PEDROLLO
60
NM 3/A/B (CALPEDA)

NMD 25/190C/B (CALPEDA)

50
WCH-2205S/T (MITSUBISHI)

40 DAB-KE 36/200 T MCE30/P

Head , m

30

20

10

0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Discharge, LPS
22-Jul-20 This is a proprietary document of Kirloskar Brothers Limited 6
 HIGH HEAD & LOW DISCHARGE ALL COMPETITOR BEST MODELS
70
SM 300 / S 300 (SALFLO)
CP 200 PEDROLLO
60 NMD 25/190C/B (CALPEDA)
WCH-2205S/T (MITSUBISHI)
DAB-KE 36/200 T MCE30/P
VARUNA-VNA 37B
50 KBL-KOS-335+*
MBKS32 CROMPTON
CPm 210C/CP 210C PEDROLLO
40
Head , m

HF 70A PEDROLLO
NM 32/16A/B (CALPEDA)

30

20

10

0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Discharge, LPS
22-Jul-20 This is a proprietary document of Kirloskar Brothers Limited 7
 HIGH HEAD & LOW DISCHARGE - FINAL MODELS
70
NMD 25/190C/B (CALPEDA)

60 KBL-KOS-335+*
CPm 210C/CP 210C PEDROLLO

50 KDS-335+ + (KBL)
KDI 335++(KBL)
KBL JOS-335
40
Head , m

30

20

10

0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Discharge, LPS
Conclusion:-
For high head & low discharge, Need to developed 2 pumps.
1) Need to developed pump having performance of NMD 25/190C/B (Calpeda).
2)Need to developed pump having performance of CPm 210C/CP 210C (Pedrollo) with increased discharge like JOS 335 (KBL)
22-Jul-20
which will replace This is. a proprietary document of Kirloskar Brothers Limited
KDS/KDI/KOS 335 (KBL) 8
MEDIUM HEAD & MEDIUM DISCHARGE MODELS

22-Jul-20 This is a proprietary document of Kirloskar Brothers Limited 9

 MEDIUM HEAD & MEDIUM DISCHARGE ALL COMPETITOR MODELS
40
PCE90/6550 (POINTPUMP)

35 DAB-KE 36/200 T MCE30/P

DAB-K 36/200 M
30
VARUNA-VNA 36B

VARUNA-VNA 37B
25
Head , m

VARUNA-VNA K33

20 VARUNA-VCS 2265 (A)

KBL-KOS-325+*
15

10

0
0 5 10 15 20 25
Discharge, LPS
22-Jul-20 This is a proprietary document of Kirloskar Brothers Limited 10
 MEDIUM HEAD & MID DISCHARGE ALL COMPETITOR BEST MODELS
40 PCE90/6550 (POINTPUMP)
DAB-KE 36/200 T MCE30/P
VARUNA-VNA K33
35 KBL-KOS-325+*
KBL JOS-335
NM 32/16A/B (CALPEDA)
30 NM 32L/16C (CALPEDA)
KDS-325+ + (KBL)
ACM 45 (CRI)
25 WCM-2205S/T (MITSUBISHI)
Head , m

CAPRARI
MDH-47(LUBI)
20 KDI 325++(KBL)

15

10

0
0 5 10 15 20 25
Discharge, LPS
22-Jul-20 This is a proprietary document of Kirloskar Brothers Limited 11
 MEDIUM HEAD & MEDIUM DISCHARGE - FINAL MODELS
40 KBL-KOS-325+* KDS-325+ + (KBL)
KDI 325++(KBL) V GUARD-VCN-TR120
35 KS-316+ KSMB 324
KSMB 328 KBL-KOS-318+**
30 KBL JOS-326” KBL JOS-330“”
KDS-318+ + (KBL) KDI 318++(KBL)
25
Head , m

20
15
10
5
0
0 5 10 15 20
Discharge, LPS
Conclusion:-
1)For medium head & discharge, Need to developed 4 pumps.
2) First model should have performance of VCN TR120 (V-Guard) & will replace KDS/KDI/KOS/JOS 325 (KBL) .
3)Trim down of first model will replace KSMB 328 (KBL) & KSMB 324 (KBL).
4) Need to developed pump having performance of VCTAN 030085 (V-Guard) with increased discharge which will
replace JOS 326 (KBL), JOS 330 (KBL), KDS/KDI/KOS 318 (KBL) & KS 316 (KBL).
5) Need to22-Jul-20
developed pump having Thisperformance
is a proprietary of CFG-50/3D
document (CRI) Brothers
of Kirloskar with increased
Limited shutoff head which
12 will
replace KDS/KOS 314 (KBL) & KDS 312 (KBL).
 LOW HEAD & HIGH DISCHARGE MODELS

22-Jul-20 This is a proprietary document of Kirloskar Brothers Limited 13

 LOW HEAD & HIGH DISCHARGE ALL COMPETITOR MODELS
18
F4-50/200B PEDROLLO
F4-50/200A PEDROLLO
16 F4-65/160A PEDROLLO
F4-65/200A PEDROLLO
14 F4-80/160C PEDROLLO
F4-80/160B PEDROLLO
F4-100/160B-N PEDROLLO
12 NM4 65/16S/A (CALPEDA)
NM4 65/20B/C (CALPEDA)
NM4 80/16A/C (CALPEDA)
10 NM4 80/20C/B (CALPEDA)
Head , m

CFG-51/3D (CRI)
CFG-52/3D (CRI)
8

0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55
Discharge, LPS
22-Jul-20 This is a proprietary document of Kirloskar Brothers Limited 14
 LOW HEAD & HIGH DISCHARGE ALL COMPETITOR BEST MODELS
18
F4-50/200A PEDROLLO

16 F4-100/160B-N PEDROLLO
NM4 65/20B/C (CALPEDA)
NM4 80/16A/C (CALPEDA)
14
CFG-52/3D (CRI)
CFG-50/3D (CRI)
12
LBL-51C(LUBI)
Head , m

LBL-51D(LUBI)
10
LBL-51EV(LUBI)
ACS 2280 (TEXMO-TARO)
8

0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55
Discharge, LPS
22-Jul-20 This is a proprietary document of Kirloskar Brothers Limited 15
 LOW HEAD & HIGH DISCHARGE - FINAL MODELS
18
16 F4-100/160B-N PEDROLLO

14 LBL-51C(LUBI)

12 LBL-51D(LUBI)

10
Head , m

8
6
4
2
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55
Discharge, LPS
Conclusion:-
1) For low head & high discharge, Need to develop/improve 2 models.
2) Need to developed pump having performance of LBL 51C (Lubi) with increased flow like LBL 51D (Lubi) .
3) Need to developed pump having performance of F4-100/160B-N (Pedrollo)..
22-Jul-20 This is a proprietary document of Kirloskar Brothers Limited 16