Professional Documents
Culture Documents
I declare that this senior project entitled “Effect of liquidity management on financial
performance of the commercial banks in Mogadishu-Somalia” is the result of my own
research except as cited in the references. The project has not been accepted for any
degree and is not concurrently submitted in candidature of any other degree.
Signature: ............................................................................................
Date: ______/______/________
SUPERVISOR APPROVAL
I hereby declare that I have read this senior project entitled “Effect of liquidity
management on financial performance of the commercial banks in Mogadishu-
Somalia” and in my opinion, this senior project is sufficient in terms of scope and
quality for the award of Bachelor Degree of Banking and finance and I accepted for
the submission to the examining panel.
Signature: ___________________________
Date: _____/______/________
APPROVAL SHEET
_____________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________
Date: __________/_________/________________
DEDICATION
This work is dedicated my lovely parents that I appreciate their endless love, care,
moral and spiritual guidance and who taught me control, patience, and self-
righteousness. May ALLAH reward and keep them prosperous and wellbeing, may
the almighty bless them abundantly.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I would like to take the opportunity to acknowledge the support and help of all who
have assisted me in the research. Without their contribution and advice, I would have
never been able to progress with the work in the thesis.
Firstly, the first and greatest thank belongs to ALLAH (SWT) the LORD of the
universe. Indeed, without His Help and Will, this thesis would not have been possible.
Thirdly, I am fully indebted to my friends for their moral and spiritual support during
my period of study. Without their continued support, this may not have been
achieved. My love for them endures for a life time.
Fourthly, I would like to thank my dear lovely friend and classmate Mr. Mohamed
Abukar Gutale who helped as possible as he could.
ABSTRACT
STUDENT DECLARATION...............................................................................................i
SUPERVISOR APPROVAL...............................................................................................ii
APPROVAL SHEET.........................................................................................................iii
DEDICATION....................................................................................................................iv
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT...................................................................................................v
ABSTRACT.......................................................................................................................vi
TABLE OF CONTACTS..................................................................................................vii
LIST OF TABLES...............................................................................................................x
LISTOF FIGURES.............................................................................................................xi
CHAPTER ONE..................................................................................................................1
INTRODUCTION...............................................................................................................1
1.0 INTRODUCTION................................................................................................1
CHAPTER TWO.................................................................................................................9
LITERATURE REVIEW....................................................................................................9
2.0 Introduction..........................................................................................................9
2.3 SUMMARY.......................................................................................................18
CHAPTER THREE...........................................................................................................19
METHODOLOGY............................................................................................................19
3.0 INTRODUCTION..............................................................................................19
3.6.1 Validity........................................................................................................22
CHAPTER FOUR.............................................................................................................24
4.0 Introduction........................................................................................................24
CHAPTER FIVE...............................................................................................................32
5.0 Introduction........................................................................................................32
5.2 Conclusion..........................................................................................................32
5.3 Recommendation................................................................................................33
APPENDICES A: QUESTIONNAIRE.............................................................................39
LIST OF TABLES
INTRODUCTION
1.0 INTRODUCTION
Liquidity According to Begg, Fisher and Rudiger (1991) liquidity refers to the speed
and certainty with which an asset can be converted back into money (cash, income)
whenever the asset holder desires. Cash is the most liquid asset of all. In terms of
accounting, liquidity can be defined as the ability of current assets to meet current
liabilities (working capital). In terms of investment, it is the ability to quickly convert
an investment portfolio to cash with little or no loss in value. A liquid company is one
that stores enough liquid assets and cash together with 3 the ability to raise funds
quickly from other source to enable it meet its payment obligation and financial
commitment in a timely manner The liquidity in the commercial bank represents the
ability to pay its obligations by the contractor at the time of maturity, which includes
lending and investment commitments, withdrawals, deposits, and accrued liabilities
(Coyle, 2000).
Liquidity also means the ability to finance the increase in assets and meet liabilities
when they due fall without any unexpected losses, and so the efficient management of
liquidity in the bank help to make sure that the bank is able to meet the incurred cash,
which are usually uncertain and subject to external factors and to the behavior of other
agents. The liquidity management is a key factor in business operations. It is vital for
the survival of business; the firm should have sufficient degree of liquidity. It should
be IJSER International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 8, Issue
7, July-2017 1460 ISSN 2229-5518 IJSER © 2017 http://www.ijser.org neither
excessive nor inadequate. Excessive liquidity means bank has ideal funds. Due to
which profitability may be lower, increase speculation, and unjustified extension.
Whereas inadequate liquidity results in interruptions of business operations. A proper
balance between these two extreme situations therefore should be maintained for
efficient operation of business through skill full liquidity management. (Abiola and
Olausi 2014),
Kane and Rice, (1998). The quick ratio cuts out all but the most liquid of current
assets. Inventory is the most notable omission, because it is not as speedily
convertible to cash. The quick ratio is a reasonable marker of a business’s short term
liquidity. The quick ratio gauges a company’s ability to meet its short term obligations
with its most liquid assets. The higher the quick ratio the better the position of the
business. 1.1.2 Financial Performance Although “performance” may appear to be an
easy concept, a unique definition in the literature does not exist. Moreover, academics
often use special definitions tailored to fit the individual research purposes
(Langfield-Smith, 1997). The financial performance is often measured using
traditional accounting Key Performance Indicators such as Return On Assets,
Operating Profit margin, Earnings Before Interest and Tax, Economic Value Added or
Sales growth (Ittner&Larcker, 1997; Fraquelli&Vannoni, 2000; Crabtree &DeBusk,
2008). The advantage of these measurements is their general availability, since every
profit oriented organization produces these figures for the yearly financial reporting
(Chenhall&LangfieldSmith, 2007). However, balance sheet manipulations and
choices of accounting methods may 4 also lead to values that allow only limited
comparability of the financial strength of companies. Ratios are best used when
compared or benchmarked against another reference, such as an industry standard or
"best in class" within the industry. This type of comparison helps to establish financial
goals and identify problem areas. Vertical and horizontal analysis can also be used for
easy identification of changes within financial balances. 1.1.3 Effect of Liquidity on
Financial Performance There are several theories which have been developed to study
the effect of liquidity on financial performance. According to Chandra (2001),
normally a high liquidity is considered to be a sign of financial strength, however
according to some authors as Neto (2003), a high liquidity can be as undesirable as a
low. This would be a consequence of the fact that current assets are usually the less
profitable then the fixed assets. It means that the money invested in current assets
generates less returns then fixed assets, representing thus an opportunity cost. Besides
that, the amounts employed in current assets generate additional costs for
maintenance, reducing thus the profitability of the company. However, Arnold (2008)
points that holding cash also provides some advantages, such as (1) provides the
payment for daily expenses, such as salaries, materials and taxes. (2) Due to the fact
that future cash flows are uncertain, holding cash gives a safety margin for eventual
downturns. And finally (3) the ownership of cash guarantees the undertaken of highly
profitable investments that demands immediate payment. Thus it is an important task
for the financial manager to achieve the appropriate balance between the adequate
liquidity and a reasonable return for the company. They studied effects on working
capital management on Spanish SME’s profitability and concluded that additional
value can be created by reducing inventories and the number of day’s accounts
outstanding. Shortening the cash conversion cycle can also be a means to improve
firm’s profitability.
1.2 PROBLEM STATEMENT
Commercial banks have experienced huge financial losses due to poor liquidity
management (Vintila and Nenu, 2016). Thus poor liquidity management in the banks
poses major liquidity management which adversely affects their capital structure and
earnings. If not properly managed, liquidity management may lead to severe
consequences in the institution (Marozva, 2015). 4 Banks wholly depend on deposits
made by their clients and most of their operations are carried out through the deposits
(Vintila and Nenu, 2016). In a situation where all the depositors withdraw their cash
from the accounts, the bank is likely to face a liquidity management trap. This may
lead to borrowing funds from the central bank or other banks at a very high cost due
to high interest charges (Vintila and Nenu, 2016).
Due to this problem commercial banks have tried to ensure that they hold adequate
funds at all times so that they are able to meet the demand of their depositor’s.
However, maintaining this amount of funds in the organizations has proved extremely
expensive. This is due to the fact that the banks have to maintain large mandatory
cash reserve of 15 billion in their accounts .This may not only lead to the loss of
revenue but also high oportunity costs associated with holding large amounts of cash.
Generally, the main cause of liquidity management in these institutions is a mismatch
between the assets and the liabilities. This is measured using the maturity mismatch
gap. The larger the funding gap the higher the probability of a liquidity management
crisis. Many studies have examined the effects of liquidity management on the
performance of banks (Banks, 2005; Ruozi and Ferrari, 2012).
Maina (2011) studied this issue among oil companies in Kenya. The results showed
that liquidity management has no effect on the firm’s profitability. Moreover, Kweri
(2011) examined the same problem among manufacturing firms. There is no study
done so far on the effect of liquidity management on the performance of commercial
banks in Mogadishu-Somalia. (Gurley & Shaw,1960).
The main objective of the Study The objective of this is to determine the effect of
liquidity management on the financial performance of commercial banks in
Mogadishu-Somalia.
The findings of the study are expected to help the following parts:
Business Consultants: The findings of this study will be influential guiding business
consultants when accounting policies for the companies. The finding may act as a
guiding document on the approach those companies when making decisions on the
accounting procedures in their firms. To the researchers and scholars. The findings
may act as reference for the future researchers who may choose to carry out similar
research in the related This identification will help to carefully devise trade
policies. Further, this study will help management to know the most important
factors to be in focus minutely to make sound decisions for better management
of liquidity and profitability matters. (Manzura and Juanjuan 2009).
Liquidity management: is defined by the relative ease, cost, and speed with which
an asset can be converted in to cash. ( Li and Zou 2014)
Financial performance of banks: is a subjective measure of how well a firm can use
assets from its primary mode of business and generate revenues.
Cash management: involves the process of cash collection, monitoring of cash and
its application in investment activities.
Account receivable
management
Cash management
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.0 Introduction
This chapter seeks to present in depth details from related literatures books academic
journals and articles relating and specific focus will be on the effect of liquidity
management on the financial performance of commercial banks in Mogadishu-
Somalia.
The term liquidity is often used in multiple contexts. An asset’s liquidity can be used
to describe how quickly, easily and costly it is to convert that asset into cash (Berger
& Bouwman, 2008). Liquidity can also be used to describe a company by the amount
of cash or near cash assets a company has; the more liquid assets, the higher a
company’s liquidity. Financial ratios that measure liquidity are referred to as a
company’s liquidity ratios. One such ratio is the current ratio which determines a
company’s ability to pay short term debts as they come due (Van Ness, 2009).
Liquidity risk has many definitions but the one that can be derived from the ratio is
the probability that a company will not be able to pay its short term obligations as
they come due. This inability can lead a company to face serious financial problems.
In addition to this, liquidity risk can also be defined in terms of the counterparty to a
transaction. In this sense the term means the risk inherent in the fact that the
counterparty may not be able to pay or settle the transaction even if they are in good
financial standing, because of a lack of liquidity (Petria & Petria, 2009)
Liquidity risk for a bank is especially prevalent as it is easy for a bank to lose its
liquidity because depositors can withdraw funds when they choose. In addition to
depositors, banks face another way in which their cash reserves can be strained by
fulfilling obligations to companies. These companies have previously established loan
commitments, called credit lines, that can be borrowed from the bank when needed
(Gatev, Schuermann, & Strahan, 2007).
. Historically, runs on banks have shown certain banks predisposition to liquidity risk
and the severity of impact this risk can have on the economy. This risk is intricately
tied to the nature of banking. This is why banks, governmental entities, and private
industry have tried to understand liquidity risk and implement public policy,
regulations, and risk assessment policies to mitigate this risk. (Ogboi and Unuafe
2013).
Mishkin, (1997) Aside from managing their own liquidity, banks play another role
with regards to liquidity by creating liquidity for the market. Due to the growth of the
commercial paper, equity, and bonds markets in recent decades, the role of banks as
the sole provider of capital to large companies has diminished. This results from
companies looking for the type of financing that best suits their specific needs. Banks
still play a largely influential role in financing. They are a primary issuer of capital to
companies who seek loans to fulfill a portion of their financing needs. Many times
they act as the fall-back crutch on which companies support themselves in times of
difficult financing.
The conclusion one might draw is that effective inventory management can make a
significant contribution to company’s profit as well as increase its return on total
assets. It is thus the management of this economics of stockholding, that is
appropriately being refers to as inventory management. The reason for greater
attention to inventory management is that this figure, for many firms, is the largest
item appearing on the asset side of the balance sheet. (Yang et al, 2006)
Cash management involves the process of cash collection, monitoring of cash and its
application in investment activities. It is one of the key element for ensuring a
company’s financial stability and solvency (Hansen, 2005). It is worthy noting that
any business entity, having the objective of maximizing on the profits must always
want to acquire the necessary resources for the operation not. These resources
needed are limited by ownership of the firms and supply. Money needed for any
investment opportunities is also scarce and can only be availed because it was
withheld from consumption.(Ronald Coase’s 1937).
It is unrealistic to suppose that every business payment bill will go through the bank
account. When the firm has determined its future cash needs, it is prudent to plan their
financing so as to gain control over it. If the shortage of cash is persistent, it indicates
a state of under-capitalisation and the need for additional permanent capital; and
unless this is obtained the entity may be forced out of business (Flick, 1998).
According to the free cash flow theory of cash management (Huseyin, 1991), the
management has the responsibility of holding cash to gain control over it in making
investment decisions which can affect a business entity. Therefore, this will improve
the financial performance of the business entities. (Seppala, 2000).
Hutchison (2007) defines cash management as the process which involves the
collection and management of cash to ensure optimal cash balances by the business
entities. The management of cash focuses at ensuring adequate cash is maintained by
the business entities and any surplus is put into the correct use. Business entities have
the duty of ensuring that the entities don't overuse overdrafts as the means of finance.
Cash management entails cash forecasting. If entities know their demand for cash in
the future, it is possible for any business entity to estimate the demand for cash at any
point in time. Due to the uncertainty involved, determining the level of liquidity
entails the forecasting of short term and long term cash demands with reference to
investment by the firms, their marketing demands and production activities. Cash
forecast. Nevertheless, cash budgets are the best tools for the ongoing WC
requirements. It is therefore advisable for the financial controller to carry out the cash
forecasts on daily, weekly or monthly basis depending on how busy the entity is the
objective of the cash management is to ensure the financial health of a business entity
which will ultimately improve the profitability for the shareholders. This can be
achieved by ensuring that finance is available when needed since liquidity is the
lifeblood of any business entity. According to Miller –Orr model approach (Miller
and Orr, 1961), business entities should always maintain the optimal cash balances;
and incase of any cash crisis the business entity should reverse past investment
decisions by diverting from activities which are not key. (Yusuf, 2003).
Business entities should ensure that the cash conversion cycle is as short as possible,
it implies that the business organization need few resources to operate. when the cash
conversion cycle is longer it implies that the sales growth is high which translates to
higher profits. According to the cash conversion cycle theory the shorter the cash
conversion cycle the better the financial performance (Petria & Petria, 2009)
According to Haris (2005), in many organizations the growth in access to credit has
led to a rising level of consumer indebtedness which is having a significant impact on
business profitability. Accounts receivables management is an issue for every
institution offering credit to its customers and the challenge for organizations is to
protect profit margins by reducing write-offs, cutting the cost to collect and
maximizing the cash collected. According to Bellie et al (2000) the view of Accounts
receivables management should not be limited to customers who are unable to pay;
the key is for organizations to use early identification of accounts at risk to enable
proactive management of a customer before they become bankrupt. Management of
accounts receivables which aims at maintaining an optimal balance between each of
the accounts receivables components, that is, cash, receivables, inventory and
payables is a fundamental part of the overall corporate strategy to create value and is
an important source of competitive advantage in businesses (Deloof, 2003). In
practice, it has become one of the most important issues in organizations with many
financial executives struggling to identify the basic accounts receivables drivers and
the appropriate level of accounts receivables to hold so as to minimize risk,
effectively prepare for uncertainty and improve the overall performance of their
businesses
The term debtors are defined as ‘debt’ owned to the firm by customers arising from
sale of goods or services in the ordinary course of business” (Pike and Cheng, 2001).
The three characteristics of receivables the element of risk, economic value and
futurity explain the basis and the need for efficient management of receivables
(Jackling et al., 2004). The element of risk should be carefully analyzed. Cash sales
are totally riskless but not the credit sales, as the same has yet to be received.
Accounts receivables management entails managing the firm's inventory and
receivables in order to achieve a balance between risk and returns and thereby
contribute positively to the creation of a firm value. Excessive investment in
inventory and receivables reduces the profit, whereas too little investment increases
the risk of not being able to meet commitments as and when they become due (Harris,
2005).
For a long time, financial performance has been perceived only through its ability to
obtain profits. This has changed over time. Further, also act as a restrain in financial
performance, since it does not contribute to return on equity (Rafuse, 1996). A well
designed and implemented financial management is expected to contribute positively
to the creation of a firm‘s value (Padachi, 2006). Dilemma in financial management is
to achieve desired trade- off between liquidity, solvency and profitability (Lazaridis,
2006).The subject of financial performance has received significant attention from
scholars in the various areas of business and strategic management. It has also been
the primary concern of business practitioners in all types of organizations since
financial performance has implications to organization‘s health and ultimately its
survival.
A firm can be categorized as global performance if it can satisfy the interests of all
stakeholders: managers are interested in the welfare and to obtain profit, because their
work is appreciated accordingly; owners want to maximize their wealth by increasing
the company’s market value (this objective can only be based on profit); current and
potential shareholders perceive performance as the company’s ability to distribute
dividends for capital investment, given the risks they take; commercial partners look
for the solvency and stability of the company; credit institutions want to be sure that
the company has the necessary capacity to repay loans on time (solvency); employees
want a stable job and to obtain high material benefits; the state seeks a company to be
efficient, to pay its taxes, to help creating new jobs, A firms’ management use
financial indicators to measure, report and improve its performance. Analysis of the
determinants of corporate financial performance is essential for all the stakeholders,
but especially for investorsRisk and growth are two other important factors
influencing a firm’s financial performance. Since market value is conditioned by the
company’s results, the level of risk exposure can cause changes in its market value
(Fruhan, 1979). Economic growth is another component that helps to achieve a better
position on the financial markets, because market value also takes into consideration
expected future profits (Varaiya, Kerin & Weeks, 1987).
2.3 SUMMARY
For a long time, financial performance has been perceived only through its ability to
obtain profits. This has changed over time. Further, also act as a restrain in financial
performance, since it does not contribute to return on equity (Rafuse, 1996). A well
designed and implemented financial management is expected to contribute positively
to the creation of a firm‘s value (Padachi, 2006). Dilemma in financial management is
to achieve desired trade- off between liquidity, solvency and profitability (Lazaridis,
2006).The subject of financial performance has received significant attention from
scholars in the various areas of business and strategic management. It has also been
the primary concern of business practitioners in all types of organizations since
financial performance has implications to organization‘s health and ultimately its
survival.( Payle, 1997).
A firm can be categorized as global performance if it can satisfy the interests of all
stakeholders: managers are interested in the welfare and to obtain profit, because their
work is appreciated accordingly; owners want to maximize their wealth by increasing
the company’s market value (this objective can only be based on profit); current and
potential shareholders perceive performance as the company’s ability to distribute
dividends for capital investment, given the risks they take; commercial partners look
for the solvency and stability of the company; credit institutions want to be sure that
the company has the necessary capacity to repay loans on time (solvency); employees
want a stable job and to obtain high material benefits; the state seeks a company to be
efficient, to pay its taxes, to help creating new jobs, (Valentin, 2013). A firms’
management use financial indicators to measure, report and improve its performance.
Analysis of the determinants of corporate financial performance is essential for all the
stakeholders, but especially for investorsRisk and growth are two other important
factors influencing a firm’s financial performance. Since market value is conditioned
by the company’s results, the level of risk exposure can cause changes in its market
value (Fruhan, 2012). Economic growth is another component that helps to achieve a
better position on the financial markets, because market value also takes into
consideration expected future profits (Varaiya, Kerin & Weeks, 2015).
CHAPTER THREE
METHODOLOGY
3.0 INTRODUCTION
This chapter discusses the research methodology of the study. The first section
present research design method, the second section focuses on research population
including sample size and sampling procedure. The third section specifies research
instrument with the validity and reliability of the instrument. Fourth section will
discuss data collection. Section five presents data analysis followed by section six
which presents the ethical consideration of the study, while final section presents the
limitations of the study.
A research design is a plan or strategy used to get the expected study results (Kothari,
2004). Research design is categorized into different types depending on the nature of
the study, which includes case study design, survey design and experimental
design.This study was conducted through quantitative survey descriptive research
design.Since the study is aimed to investigate the effect of liquidity management on
financial performance. The researcher has seen that survey research design would
enable him together the necessary data. The population of this study were derived
from some selected of commercial banks in Mogadishu-Somali. This study is based
on primary data and use questionnaire as a tool of data collection.
The researchers used Solvent’s formula to calculate the sample size, with maximum
N
acceptable error 5 %. n = 1+ Ne 2
51
2
n= 1+ 51 ( 0 . 05 ) =45
This study will apply non- probability sampling and the research team will use
purposive technique (judgmental) select the sample size. During the purposive
sampling the researchers consciously decides who will include the sample, the
main purpose of purposive sampling is that it designed to collect focused
information. It is preferred for this study because of its efficiency particularly it saves
time and money.
This study will be used questionnaire instrument as main tool for collection data,
which Questionnaire may be defined as well established tool within social science
research for acquiring information on participant social characteristics, present and
past behavior, standards of behavior or attitudes and their beliefs and reasons for
action with respect to the topic under investigation (Bulmer, 2004).
Before data entry into computer a series of pretest were conducted the data scanning
and scrutiny technique were employed from available questionnaires from
respondents to examine and validate the survey instrument so as to ensure content
reliability and validity.
3.6.1 Reliability
A reliability test will conduct to evaluate the logic and internal consistency of the
items by using all variables. The reliability of the research instruments concern with
the degree to which the research will give the same result. The reliability of an
instrument is the ability of the instrument to collect the same data consistently under
similar conditions.
Reliability is trustworthiness of a measuring instrument; it is the degree to which the
instrument consistently measures whatever it is meant to be. The researcher conducts
a pilot study before the final collection of data. Data collection tools are pilot tested in
order to ascertain its ability to solicit the relevant responses to support the study. The
justification for establishing the reliability of the instruments is determined by the
consistency, relevancy and clarity of the instruments. Kothari (2004) defined validity
as the degree to which an instrument measures what is supposed to measure. Gay
(1996) defined reliability as the degree of consistency that the instrument
demonstrates. Reliability consists of both true and error scores and it is necessary but
not sufficient for validity.
3.6.1 Validity
Refers to the extent to which data collection method accurately measures what it will
intend to measure or to the extent to which research findings were about what they
claimed to be about (Saunders Lawis&Thornhill, 2009). Generally,
in This study, the data will be collect from 50 respondents of the commercial
banks in Mogadishu, Somalia. The data will be collected in hand and the researcher
responsible for this collection of the data. Then the researchers will try to cooperate
with the respondents to fill the questionnaires appropriately in addition to that
researchers distributed to the target population by self-administration.
3.8 DATA ANALYSIS
Data from questionnaires will be use a computerized data analysis package known as
Statistical Package for Social Science (SPSS) version 15.0 To analyze objectives, the
researchers used descriptive statistics because it can utilize our objectives, descriptive
analysis used to measure central tendencies such as mean and measures of description
such as standard deviation to describe a group of subject (Oso & onen, 2008).
This study has many limitations which may affect researchers across on its research
procedure such limitations include: the geographical scope, the study will be limited
only in Mogadishu, the study will be limited to only a sample of 50respondents of
commercial banks’ in Mogadishu, the time of the researcher is also limited as well as
limitation of the population, the researchers look about positive side of the role of
commercial on customer satisfaction in local banks, the Potential researchers are
expected to cover large samples in the future research. In addition the study also
suffers the use of questionnaire. Because, the questionnaire have some limitations
such as Poor response rate, Incomplete or poorly completed answers, Limit and shape
nature of answers and cannot check truth of answers. And another major drawback of
Questioner is there is no way of checking misinterpretations and unintelligible replies
by the respondents.
In this study, the researcher regarded the ethical issues through the research project by
keeping the privacy, confidentiality and anonymity of respondents. To maintain
ethical issue, the researchers requested from banks’ administration a permission to
distribute questionnaire to their customers and will be used it only for academic
purpose and the research will be kept the solitude, confidentiality and secrecy of
respondents. The researchers promised that this research will be conducted in a fully
ethical manner way and all copyrights will be reserved.
CHAPTER FOUR
4.0 Introduction
This chapter presented the findings and interpretations of the study results. Analysis
of data in this study was done concurrently with data collection. After data collection
the questionnaires of respondents were sorted out accordingly; responses were
verified, coded, categorized and entered into the computer using statistical package
for Social Sciences (SPSS) version 20.0 software. For easy understanding and
following of the results, descriptive data analysis was used and the results were
presented using mean and standard deviation.
Figure 4.1.2 indicates that the majority of respondents 43(66.7%) ware in the age
between20 – 30 years old, while 11 (24.4%) ware in the age between 31 – 40, and the
minority group 4 (8.9%) were ages above 40 years.
Figure 4.1.3: Marital status of the respondents
The above figure illustrate that the most of the participants 27(60.0%) were single,
18(40.0%) were married.
Figure 4.1.5: Educational level of the respondents
The above figure illustrate that the most of the participants 36 (80.0%) were bachelor,
while 6 (13.3%) were master, and the minority of the respondent were diploma and
secondary.
Figure 4.1.6: Occupation of the respondents
Figure 4.4.6 shows that most of the respondents 29 (64.4%) were employees, and the
remaining portion were management.
4.2 Descriptive analysis of the variables
Table 4.2.1 Shows that most of the respondents agreed that inventory has good
influence to financial performance which was indicated by mean value of (M=3.17)
and standard deviation (SD=0.89).
Statement Mean SD
Statement Mean SD
Firm Ensures that expected payments are received in a timely manner 4.47 .625
Managing debt owed to the firm by customers arising from sale of goods or
4.64 .645
services
To increase the sales volume and decrease the risk of credit should
1.60 .688
minimize accounting receivable
Maintaining adequate capital of the firm, cash management should be first
4.67 .876
priority
Total Average Mean 3.85 0.71
Table 4.2.3 Shows that most of the respondents agreed that Account receivable
management has good effect on financial performance which was indicated by mean
value of (M=3.85) and standard deviation (SD=0.71).
Table 4.3.1 above shows correlation between liquidity Management and Financial
Performance. The result obtained indicated that there is significant moderate
relationship between liquidity Management and Financial Performance. The findings
indicate that there is positive relationship liquidity and Financial Performance which
was indicated by r-value (r =.361) and p-value (p = 0.015) as shows in the table.
CHAPTER FIVE
5.0 Introduction
Chapter five provides the summary of findings. This has been arrived at using the
three study objectives. In this chapter the conclusion provides the summery of
objectives, as well as the recommendations also followed the conclusion.
The study concentrated main different types of demographic factors, like gender, age,
educational level and occupation, the result obtained shows that, majority of the
respondents 80.0% were male while 20.0% were female, other hand, age of majority
of respondents 66.7% ware in the age between 20 – 30 years old, while 24.4% ware in
the age between 31 – 40, which means most participants were young and the ages
above 40 years were minority group 8.9% were.
In term of education, the most of the participants 80.0% were bachelor, while 13.3%
were master, and the minority of the respondent were diploma and secondary, so all of
participants were educated people, but in term of occupation most of the respondents
64.4% were employees, and the remaining portion were management.
The result from study is reliable since most of participants were educated, young and
employed people.
5.2 Conclusion
This section discovers the research result and findings derived from the distributed
questionnaires. The main objective of this study is “To determine the effect of
liquidity management on the financial performance of commercial banks in
Mogadishu-Somalia”. The study had three objectives, the objective one of the study,
which is “To establish the effects of inventory management on financial performance
of Commercial banks in Mogadishu-Somalia” the mean value of the questions was
3.17 which indicates Agree level so this indicates that the answer shows that there is a
very good level. The objective two of this study was “To determine the effects of
Cash management on financial performance of Commercial banks in Mogadishu-
Somalia” the mean value was 3.59 which indicates agree level so this indicates that
the answer shows that there is a very good level. The objective three of this study was
“To find out the effects of Account receivable on financial performance of
Commercial banks in Mogadishu-Somalia” the mean value was 3.85 which means
strongly agree level so this indicates that the answer shows that there is a very good
level.
Finally the study indicates the correlation between the two variables which are
liquidity management and financial performance is measured using Pearson's
correlation method with two tailed and the relationship between the two variables
were positive relationship with R-value of .361 and this information indicates that
there is moderate positive significant relationship between liquidity management and
financial performance.
5.3 Recommendation
The researcher suggested the following suggestions to the selected institution “Salam
Somali Bank Mogadishu-Somalia
The researcher found that there is a possible area for further research which enables
academic students to make further research and they are as follows:
Adebisi and Oladunjoye (2013) Private Management and Public Policy. Prentice-Hall:
Englewood Cliffs, NJ. Reinhardt FL. 1999. Bringing the environment down to
earth. Harvard Business Review July–August(114): 149–157.
Amengor, (2010). (Equity, Bonds and Bank Debt: Capital Structure and Financial
Market Equilibrium under Asymmetric Information, Journal of Political
Economy, pp. 324-351.
Begg, Fisher and Rudiger (1991) Small business and relationship banking: the impact
of participative behavior, entrepreneurship; Theory and practice, 21(4), 83 92,
EdMacmillan.
Chirwa and Montfort, (2004). Financing Change – the Financial Community, Eco-
Efficiency, and Sustainable Development. MIT Press: Cambridge, MA. Scholz
RW, Weber O,
Coase (1960). Framework for Credit Risk Management, CIB Publishing , UK.
Conford, (2000). The banks’ impact on the natural environment – on the space
between ‘what is’ and ‘what if’. Business Strategy and the Environment 9(3):
186–195.
Coyle, (2000). Financial markets and institutions, 5th ed: Pearson Education. Koch ,T.
(2010). Bank Management: The Dry Den Press.
Demirguc. k and Huzinga, (2000). Research Methodology. New Delhi: New Age
International (P) Ltd.
Flannery and Ragan (2002). Does it really pay to be green? An empirical study of
firm environmental and financial performance. Journal of Industrial Ecology
5(1): 105–116.
Gatev, Schuermann, & Strahan, (2007). Global Financial Crisis. Journal of Banking
and Finance.
Gurley & Shaw, (1960). Modern Banking. London: John Wiley & Sons.
Kane and Rice, (1998). Monitoring and Reputation: The Choice between Bank Loans
and Directly Placed Debt", Journal of Political Economy, Vol 99, pp. 689-721.
Li and Zou (2014) The relationship between default prediction and lending profits:
integrating ROC analysis and loan pricing. Journal of Banking and Finance
29: 1213–1236.
Manzura and Juanjuan (2009). Microfinance Risk Management Hand Book. New
York, Care International.
Payle, (1997). The Risk Management Process Business Strategy and Tactics, John
Wiley & Sons: London.
Petria & Petria, (2009) Making microfinance work: managing for improved
performance. Geneva, International Labor Organization, 15 – 21.
Rajan (2010). The Effect of Credit Market Competition on Lending Relationships .
The Quarterly Journal of Economics. Credit Risk Management And Financial
Performance Of Selected Commercial Banks In Kenya DOI: 10.9790/487X-
1911079298
Yang et al, (2006). Capital adequacy, Cost income ratio and the Performance of
Commercial Banks. (24(10).
UNIVERSITY OF SOMALIA
Dear respondents,
After your informed consent, I kindly request you to answer the questions sincerely
and accurately. The information will only be used for academic purposes and it will
be treated with maximum confidentiality. Thank you for your kind cooperation.
The following questions refer to the demographic profile of the respondents. Please
provide the appropriate information by placing (✔ ) in the bracket provided to
represent your answer.
( ) Male
( ) Female
( ) 20 – 30 years
( ) 31 – 40 years
( ) above 40
( ) Single
( ) Married
( ) Divorced
( ) Secondary Level
( ) Diploma Degree
( ) Bachelor Degree
( ) Master Degree
( ) PhD
( ) Management
( ) Employees
Please (✔) one cell according to the following 4-point Linker scale, with 1-Strongly
Disagree and 4- Strongly Agree that best describe your level of argument with the
following statements.
NO Statement SD D A SA
1 There is reorder level to avoid any possible inventory run
out
2 The company rarely experiences production shutdown due
to inventory run out
3 The company always fully satisfies the customer’s order
4 The company always base its order quantity to market
demand to inventory holding costs
NO Statement SD D A SA
1 The stewardship or proper use of an entity’s cash resources
2 Serves as the means to keep an organization functioning by
making the best use of cash or liquid resources of the
organization
3 Is to use to finance working capital and financial
institutions
4 Collection and monitoring of cash and its application in
investment activities
Section D: Account receivables management
NO Statement SD D A SA
1 Firm Ensures that expected payments are received in a
timely manner
2 Managing debt owed to the firm by customers arising from
sale of goods or services
3 To increase the sales volume and decrease the risk of credit
should minimize accounting receivable
4 Maintaining adequate capital of the firm, cash management
should be first priority
NO Statement SD D A SA
1 The most important tasks in transition planning and
analyzing
2 Understanding company-capital market interaction and
investment planning
3 The degree to which financial objectives being or has been
accomplished in best manner
4 Assess firm's production and productivity performance, of
the firm