Professional Documents
Culture Documents
No crime was
Crimes against the fundamental committed by the
laws of the State: detained;
b. That the detained
OFFENDERS: Public
is not violently
officers who are acting
insane; or
under their official function
c. That he has no
provided that it is illegal
ailment which
except as to the last crime
requires
under Art. 133 – refers to
compulsory
any person. A private
confinement in a
person can also be liable
hospital
under title II of this code
if he conspires with a DETENTION – A person placed
public officer. What is in a confinement or there is
required is that the principal restraint on her person.
offender must be a public
ARREST WITHOUT WARRANT
officer, thus if the private
is the most usual form of arbitrary
individual conspires or
detention.
becomes an accessory or
accomplice in the Who can commit the crime of
commission of the crime, arbitrary detention?
he becomes liable for the
Public officers or
same.
employees
COUNTERPART: Title IX
How is arbitrary detention
Crimes against Personal
committed?
Liberty and Security which
is committed by a private When a public officer or
person. employee detains a person
without legal grounds.
Arbitrary detention and When is there “detention”?
expulsion
There is detention when a
person is placed in a
Art. 124. Arbitrary detention
confinement or there is
ELEMENTS: restraint in his person.
1. The offender is a public When is detention “without legal
officer or employee; grounds”?
2. He detains another person;
1. When no crime is
3. The detention is without
committed by the detained
legal grounds, meaning:
person;
2. When the detained is not
violently insane; or
3. When the detained has Yes, when without malice
no ailment that would one would arrest another.
require compulsory
confinement in a hospital. Does the law fix any minimum
period of detention?
When is arrest lawful?
No, in the case of US v
Arrest is lawful when there Braganza a councilor and a
is warrant properly issued barrio lieutenant were
by the court, served by the convicted of arbitrary
public officer or employee detention , even if the
against a person who offended party was
committed a crime. detained for less than an
hour.
WARRANTLESS ARREST
IS AN EXCEPTION. It is
lawful under the Art. 125. Delay in the delivery
circumstances of an in of detained persons to the
flagrante delicto, hot proper judicial authorities.
pursuit, or escaping ELEMENTS:
prisoner.
1. The offender is a public
officer or employee;
Compare illegal detention from 2. The he detains a person for
unlawful arrest. some legal grounds;
Illegal detention is 3. That he fails to deliver such
committed by a private person to the proper
person or a public officer judicial authorities within:
in his private capacity a. 12 hours for light
and deny the offended penalties;
party of his liberty while b. 18 hours for
unlawful arrest is correctional
committed by anyone and penalties;
the offended party was c. 36 hours for
accused of a crime he did afflictive or capital
not commit, deliver him penalties.
to the proper authority
and file the necessary
charges to incriminate
him.