Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Names of Sub-Units
Direct and Indirect Tax , Constitutional Validity of taxes, Administration of Tax Laws, Sources of
Income Tax Law in India, Basic Principles of Charging Income Tax Section- 4, Assessment Year
Section 2 (9), Previous Year Section 3,Assesses Section 2(7), Person Section 2(31), Income Section 2(24),
Heads of Income Section 14, Gross Total Income Section 80B(5), Rounding off of total Income - Section
288A, Rounding off of tax- Section 288B, Capital Receipt and Revenue Receipts- The distinction and
implication, Basis of Charge and Scope of total Income, Diversion and Application of Income.
Overview
This unit describes the direct and indirect tax, the constitutional validity of taxes and administration
of tax laws. Also, this unit explains the sources of income tax law in India and basic principles of
charging income tax section-4. Further, this unit discusses the assessment year section 2(9) with
the previous year’s section 3. This unit elaborates on person section 2(31), income section 2(24) and
Heads of Income Section 14. It also describes gross total in income section 80B (5), rounding off of total
income- section 288A and rounding off of tax- section 288B. In the end, this unit explains capital receipt
and revenue receipts - the distinction and implication, basis of charge and scope of total income and
diversion and application of income.
JGI JAIN
DEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
Direct Tax Laws
Learning Objectives
Learning Outcomes
https://www.bankbazaar.com/tax/direct-tax.html
https://keydifferences.com/difference-between-capital-receipt-and-revenue-receipt.html
1.1 INTRODUCTION
The 16th Amendment, passed by Congress on July 2, 1909 and ratified on February 3, 1913, is widely
credited with establishing the individual income tax. Its history, on the other hand, goes back even
further.
Governments in almost every country around the world levy compulsory levies on individuals or entities,
which is known as taxation. Taxation is primarily used to raise revenue for government expenditures,
but it can also be used for other purposes.
India’s tax system is divided into direct and indirect taxes. While direct taxes are levied on taxable
income earned by individuals and corporations, assesses are responsible for depositing taxes.
2
UNIT 01: Basic Concepts of Income Tax and Residential Status of Various Persons JGI JAIN
DEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
Following are some of the most significant direct taxes imposed in India:
Income tax: Income tax is imposed on individuals who fall into various tax brackets based on their
earnings or revenue and they are required to file an income tax return each year, after which they
must either pay the tax or be eligible for a tax refund.
Estate Tax: Estate tax also known as inheritance tax is a tax levied on a person’s estate or the total
value of money and property left behind after they die.
Wealth Tax: A wealth tax is a tax levied on the value of a person’s assets.
Estate and wealth taxes, on the other hand, have been repealed.
Direct taxes do have some benefits for a country’s social and economic development. Let’s discuss these
benefits.
It reduces inflation: When there is monetary inflation, the government frequently raises the tax
rate, which reduces demand for goods and services, causing inflation to condense as a result of
lower demand.
It enables social and economic balance: The government has well-defined tax slabs and exemptions
in place based on each individual’s earnings and overall economic situation to balance out income
inequalities.
There are several of drawbacks to direct taxes. However, the lengthy procedures of filing tax returns are
a taxing task in and of themselves.
Indirect Tax
Indirect tax is a government tax levied on goods and services rather than an individual’s income, profit
or revenue and it can be shifted from one taxpayer to another. Previously, paying an indirect tax meant
paying more than the actual cost of a product or service. In addition, taxpayers were subjected to a slew
of indirect taxes.
The Goods and Services Tax (GST) is one of India’s existing indirect taxes. Many indirect tax laws have
been absorbed into it.
The Goods and Services Tax or GST, was implemented on July 1st, 2017 to replace the country’s various
indirect taxes. Due to this the other taxes that used to be levied previously no longer exist. It has done
away with the tax’s cascading effect.
Service tax, state excise duty, countervailing duty, additional excise duty and special additional customs
duties are all included in the GST at the state level.
3
JGI JAIN
DEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
Direct Tax Laws
Verification of a tax return or claim for credit, rebate or refund; investigation, assessment, determination,
litigation or collection of a person’s tax liability; investigation or prosecution of a tax-related crime; or
enforcement of a tax statute are all examples of tax administration.
Responsibilities
Inland tax regulations are written, revised and interpreted.
National tax administrations and local tax administrations plan, direct, supervise and evaluate the
levy and collection of national tax.
Directing, supervising and evaluating all levels of tax administration’s anti-corruption efforts
Auditing major cases of tax evasion, as well as supervising and evaluating audit performance at all
levels of the tax administration
Tax administration, as well as tax information, planning and evaluation
Encouragement of tax-related education and public awareness campaigns
4
UNIT 01: Basic Concepts of Income Tax and Residential Status of Various Persons JGI JAIN
DEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
This is due to the fact that it was due in March. Similarly, if your company paid you in advance for April
and May in the month of March, it will be taxed again in March. As a result, salary income will be taxed
on a due or received basis, whichever comes first.
In layman’s terms, this category contains the rental income from the homes.
The following is a list of the income that is taxed under this heading:
Profits made during the assessment year by the assesses
Profits from an organisation’s revenue
Profits from the selling of a specific license
Cash received as a result of an individual’s export under a government program
Profit, income or bonus earned as a result of a business collaboration
Benefits gained as a result of working for a company
5
JGI JAIN
DEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
Direct Tax Laws
Real estate, equities, mutual funds, bonds, gold and other capital assets are examples of capital assets.
As a result, anytime you sell a capital asset and profit. This is considered your income and it will be taxed
under the Capital Gains heading. Rental income is taxed as “Income from House Property,” but if the
property is sold and profit is made, then it will be taxed as “capital gain.”
Applicable exemptions and deductions should be taken into account when calculating income under
different headings. If there is any provision for clubbing, this should be taken into account. Yearly losses
should be carried forward and losses from previous years should be deducted. Gross Total Income refers
to the income after such adjustments. Then you should claim a deduction under Chapter VIA. The total
taxable income is the amount on which tax is calculated at the prescribed rate. TDS and Advance Tax
paid will be deducted from the tax computed. If applicable, interest will be charged under sections 234A,
234B and 234C. The total tax will be rounded up to the nearest ten rupees multiple.
If your tax liability exceeds your prepaid taxes, you’ll have to pay the difference in self-assessment tax. If
the amount of prepaid taxes is greater than the actual tax liability, a refund should be requested.
In India, the government keeps track of its finances for a year, from April 1 to March 31. As a result, it is
referred to as the financial year. The Internal Revenue Service has similarly chosen the same year for
its assessment method.
The Assessment year is the fiscal year of the Government of India during which a person’s income from
the previous year is assessed for taxation. Every individual who is subject to taxation under this Act is
6
UNIT 01: Basic Concepts of Income Tax and Residential Status of Various Persons JGI JAIN
DEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
required to file a return of income by the specified deadlines. Officials and officers from the Internal
Revenue Service process these returns. Assessment is the term for this type of processing. This is where
the assesse’s income is scrutinised and validated.
An assessment order is issued when the tax is calculated and compared to the amount paid. The
assessment year is the year in which the entire procedure is completed.
If the prior year is regarded to be 2020-21, the previous year will begin on April 1, 2020 and end on March
31, 2021. And the previous/financial year’s evaluation year will be 2021-22, i.e., from April 1, 2021, to
March 31, 2022.
In the same way, if the assessment year was 2020-21, the previous/financial year would have been
2019-20.
7
JGI JAIN
DEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
Direct Tax Laws
interest to deduct tax at source and deposit the cash collected in the government treasury. Assesses-
in-default occurs when a person fails to deduct tax at the source or deducts tax but does not deposit
it in the treasury.
Note: A company that meets the requirements of section 184. A business does not meet the
requirements of Section 184.
Association of Persons or Body of Individuals: Co-operative societies, MARKFED, NAFED and other
organisations are examples of such organisations. When individuals come together to carry on a
joint venture but do not meet the legal definition of partnership, they are assessed as an association
of persons. An association of people is more than just a group of people who get paid together. To
achieve a common goal, such as earning money, there must be a common purpose and common
action. Firms, companies, associations and individuals can all be members of an AOP.
Non-individuals cannot be members of a body of individuals (BOI). A body of individuals can only be
made up of natural human beings. Whether a group is AOP or BOI is a question of fact that must be
decided on a case-by-case basis.
Local authorities: It includes municipalities, panchayats, cantonment boards and port trusts,
among others.
Person of Artificial Judgment: Artificial Juridical Persons are a type of public corporation created
by a special act of the legislature and a body with its legal personality.
Every artificial juridical person: not falling within any of the preceding sub-clauses.
Association of Persons or Body of Individuals or a Local authority or Artificial Juridical Persons:
shall be deemed to be a person whether or not, such persons are formed or established or incorporated
with the object of deriving profits or gains or income.
8
UNIT 01: Basic Concepts of Income Tax and Residential Status of Various Persons JGI JAIN
DEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
It is never stated that “Income” only refers to monetary gain. It includes the value of Perquisites and
Benefits.
The term “income” refers to both the amount received and the amount saved by using the property
himself. Anything that can be converted into money can be considered a source of income accrual.
“Income comprises”:
Profits and Gains: For example, a businessman’s profits are taxable as “Income.”
Dividend: A “dividend” declared/paid by a company to its shareholders, for example, is taxable as
“income” in the hands of the shareholders.
Voluntary contributions received by a Trust: Voluntary contributions received by a Trust are
included in its income. This rule applies in the following situations.
A trust established entirely or partially for charitable or religious purposes receives such a
contribution; or
A scientific research association receives such a contribution; or
Any fund or institution established for charitable purposes receives such a contribution; or
Any university, other educational institution or hospital can receive such a contribution.
According to the above-mentioned Section 14 for the computation of Income Tax in India, the five
primary heads of income are:
1. Income from Salary: This heading essentially involves any remuneration received by an individual
in exchange for services rendered under a contract of employment. Basic pay, advance salaries,
pensions, commissions, gratuities, perquisites and a yearly bonus are all included in a salary. The
crucial thing to remember is that salary is taxable on a due or received basis, depending on which
comes first. Allow me to illustrate this with an example. If you get paid in April 2020 for the month
of March 2020, it will still be taxable in the prior fiscal year 2019-20.
This is because it was due in March. Similarly, if your company paid you in advance for April and
May in the month of March, will be taxed again in March. As a result, salary income will be taxed on
a due or received basis, whichever comes first.
2. Income from House Property: Sections 22 to 27 of the Income Tax Act of 1961 deal with the income
tax computation of a person’s total standard income from his or her home or land.
In layman’s terms, this category contains the rental income from the homes.
9
JGI JAINDEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
Direct Tax Laws
3. Income from Profits and Gains of Business or Profession: The income produced through the profits
of a business or profession will be attributed to the income tax computation of total income. The
difference between the revenue collected and the expenses will be charged.
The following is a list of the income that is taxed under this heading:
Profits made during the assessment year by the assesses
Profits from an organisation’s revenue
Profits from the selling of a specific license
Cash received as a result of an individual’s export under a government program
Profit, income or bonus earned as a result of a business collaboration
Benefits gained as a result of working for a company
4. Income from Capital Gains: Profits or gains obtained by an assessee from the sale or transfer of a
capital assets kept as an investment are referred to as capital gains.
Real estate, equities, mutual funds, bonds, gold and other capital assets are examples of capital
assets. As a result, anytime you sell a capital asset and profit. This is considered your income and
it will be taxed under the Capital Gains heading. Rental income is taxed as “Income from House
Property,” but if the property is sold and profit is made, then it will be taxed as “capital gain”.
5. Income from Other Sources: This category includes interest from bank deposits, lottery prizes, card
games, gambling and other sports awards. These earnings are taxable and are ascribed under
Section 56(2) of the Income Tax Act.
10
UNIT 01: Basic Concepts of Income Tax and Residential Status of Various Persons JGI JAIN
DEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
It is the amount that must be disclosed when filing an income tax return. Deductions under Chapter VI
A must be subtracted from GTI to arrive at the taxable or total income.
Gross Total Income does not include when computing gross total income, one must add all of their
earnings together without deducting any tax-saving investments made under Sections 80C to 80U of
the Income Tax Act of 1961.
If the total figure’s last digit is less than 5, the total should be reduced to the next lower number which is
a multiple of ` 10. This rounding off income should only be done on the total income, not on the income
under each of the various headings. This means that if your total income is ` 12,98,465.50, you should
round it up to ` 12,98,470.
1.16 CAPITAL RECEIPT AND A REVENUE RECEIPT- THE DISTINCTION AND IMPLICATION
During the business, two types of receipts are generated. The money brought into the business from
non-operating sources such as proceeds from the sale of long-term assets, capital brought in by the
proprietor, sum received as a loan or from debenture holders and so on is referred to as capital receipts.
The non-recurring income received by the company is referred to as capital receipts. Rather than being
part of the operating activities, they are part of the financing and investing activities. Capital receipts
either reduce or increase an asset or liability. The following sources can be used to generate receipts:
Shares issued
Debt instruments such as debentures issued
A bank or financial institution provides a loan
11
JGI JAIN
DEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
Direct Tax Laws
Revenue Receipts are receipts that are generated as a result of the company’s core operations. These
receipts are a regular part of business operations, which is why they appear so frequently. However, the
benefit can only be enjoyed during the current accounting year because the effect is temporary. All of
the operations that bring cash into the business are included in the income received from day-to-day
business activities, such as:
Revenue generated from inventory sales
Services provided
Creditors or suppliers have given you a discount
Interest has been received
Dividend remuneration is a type of remuneration that is received in the form of a dividend
Rent received
Capital receipts differ from revenue receipts in that the former has no impact on the financial year’s
profit or loss, whereas the latter is offset against the period’s revenue expenses.
12
UNIT 01: Basic Concepts of Income Tax and Residential Status of Various Persons JGI JAIN
DEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
of each person is determined by his Residential Status under the provisions of the Income Tax Act of
1961.
The assessee’s total income is taxed. The total income of each person is determined by his Residential
Status under the provisions of the Income Tax Act of 1961.
Section 56(1) states that income of any kind that is not excluded from total income under this Act is
chargeable to income tax under the heading “Income from Other Sources” if it is not chargeable to
income tax under any of the first four heads listed in Section 14.
Scope
1. Subject to the provisions of this Act, the total income of any previous year of a person who is a
resident includes all income from whatever source derived which—
a. Is received or is deemed to be received in India in such year by or on behalf of such person; or
b. Accrues or arises or is deemed to accrue or arise to him in India during such year; or
c. Accrues or arises to him outside India during such year:
Provided that, in the case of a person not ordinarily resident in India within the meaning of sub-
section (6) * of section 6, the income which accrues or arises to him outside India shall not be so
included unless it is derived from a business controlled in or a profession set up in India.
2. Subject to the provisions of this Act, the total income of any previous year of a person who is a non-
resident includes all income from whatever source derived which—
a. Is received or is deemed to be received in India in such year by or on behalf of such person; or
b. Accrues or arises or is deemed to accrue or arise to him in India during such year.
The process of diverting income before it is earned by the assessee is known as diversion of income.
Because the income is diverted to someone else before being earned by the assessee, it is excluded from
the assessee’s total income. There is an overriding title of any other person on such income in the event
of income diversion.
For example, if XYZ is a partnership firm and their deed specifies that 20% of any profits they are likely
to earn will be distributed to X’s mother, as well as the wives of Y and Z. This is a classic case of income
diversion. The rationale is that the deed mentioning the above-mentioned provision has an overriding
right to the money and is a requirement for the firm to continue. As a result, it isn’t taxable.
13
JGI JAINDEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
Direct Tax Laws
It is a diversion of income if a third party becomes entitled to receive a sum of money due to the assesses
obligation, but it is not a diversion but rather an application of income if an obligation to pay to a
third party arises after the income is received. Many people try to divert their income to avoid paying
taxes. For instance, diverting income to the wife and children. Such tax avoidance is not tolerated by the
courts. In some cases, taxes are combined (sections 60-65). Transferring income without transferring
assets, income derived from revocable asset transfers, spouse income and minor income can all be
grouped together.
Taxation is primarily used to raise revenue for government expenditures, but it can also be used for
other purposes.
Direct and indirect taxes are important for the welfare of the Economy.
Article 265 to article 289 of the Constitution refers to taxation provisions.
No tax shall be levied or collected unless authorised by law and the right to levy taxes must be
exercised by the legislature.
A tax administration’s job is to collect all owed taxes in a fair and efficient manner, with minimal
costs to both taxpayers and the tax administration.
The basis of a charge of an income tells us how much of a person’s income is subject to taxation.
1.20 GLOSSARY
Case Objective
This case aims to show the computation of rental income in the case of income tax.
This case will help us in finding out how is rental income added to the owner’s income tax return?
Adi rented out his Mumbai apartment for 35,000 rupees per month. He has to file tax returns for the
year. Adi needs to find out how much he owes the Income Tax Department.
Let us know the other expenses linked with the house during the year.
In November, Adi paid 25,000/- rupees in property taxes and spent 8,000/- rupees on repairs and 30,000/-
rupees on the payment of electricity bills. Adi also paid an interest of 2,20,000/- rupees on the money
14
UNIT 01: Basic Concepts of Income Tax and Residential Status of Various Persons JGI JAIN
DEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
which he had borrowed for building the house. Since He has rented the property the entire interest on
the home loan can be claimed as a deduction.
He must determine the Gross Annual Value (GAV) of the property. It is important for calculating the
income earned from house property.
For rented property, the annual rent collected must be higher than or equal to the reasonable rent of the
property as founded by the municipality.
The municipality in the case of Adi has calculated the reasonable rent of ` 32,000/-
Therefore, GAV= ` 4,20,000/-
Deduct the property tax payment for finding the net annual value.
As per the Income Tax Act Section 24, the Act allows Adi to claim a standard deduction of 30 per cent on
the net annual value. Adi home loan interest is also fully deductible.
Note:
Expenses on repairs and electricity are not allowed to be deducted.
If Adi was getting rental income from more than one house property; he would have to calculate for each one
of them individually in the same manner as above.
Source: https://cleartax.in/house-property/case-study-aditya-the-landlord
Questions
1. Summarise the Income Tax Act.
(Hint: Salary, business or profession, house property, capital gains and other sources are all covered
by the Income Tax Act of 1961.)
2. What is rental Income?
(Hint: the amount received in lieu of renting out or letting out the property)
https://www.indiacode.nic.in/handle/123456789/2435?sam_handle=123456789/1362
https://indiankanoon.org/doc/789969/
Discuss with your professor how income tax is computed in Western countries?
16
Basic concept of Income Tax
Unit – 01
CA. Prashant Bharadwaj
Assessment Year and Previous Year
• The period of 12 months commencing on the 1st day of April
every year is known as the Assessment Year as defined u/s
2(9). An Assessment Year is a financial year which immediately
succeeds the relevant Previous Year. For instance Assessment
Year 2022-23 the relevant Previous Year is 2021-22.
• The Financial Year in which the income is earned is referred to
as the Previous Year. Section 3 read with section 2 (34) defines
previous year to mean the financial year immediately preceding
the Assessment Year.
Person – Sec 2(31)
Person includes:
• An Individual
• A Hindu Undivided Family
• A Company
• A Firm
• An Association of Persons or a Body of individuals, whether incorporated
or not.
• A Local Authority; and
• Every artificial juridical person, not falling within any of the preceding sub-
clauses.
Assessee – Sec 2(7)
Assessee means a person by whom any tax or any other sum of
money is payable under this Act and it includes :
• Every person in respect of whom any proceeding has been initiated
under the Act for the assessment of his income, loss or refund or the
income, loss or refund of any other person in respect of which he is
assessable.
• A person who is deemed to be an assessee under any provisions of
the Act.
• A person who is deemed to be an assessee in default under any
provisions of the Act.
Income – Sec 2(24)
• Profits and gains of business or profession.
• Dividend
• Voluntary contributions received by Charitable or Religious Trust or
Institutions or Association or University or Hospitals or Electoral Trusts.
• Value of any perquisite or profit in lieu of Salary taxable u/s 17 and Special
Allowance or Benefit specifically granted personal expenses or performance
of duties.
• Export incentives.
• Any interest, salary, bonus, commission or remuneration earned by a partner
of a firm from such firm.
• Any capital gains chargeable u/s 45.
• Winnings from lotteries, crossword puzzles, races including horse races, card
games and other games from gambling or betting of any form or nature.
Income – Sec 2(24)
• Any sum received by assessee from his employee towards welfare fund contributions, such as
Provident fund or superannuation fund.
• Any sum received under keyman insurance policy including sum allocated by way of bonus on such
policy.
• Any sum of money or moveable or immovable property received as gifts as stipulated in sec 56(2).
• Any consideration received for issue of shares exceeding the fair market value of shares referred u/s
56(2)(viib).
• Any sum of money received as an advance or otherwise in the course of negotiations for a transfer of
a capital asset, if such sum is forfeited and the negotiations do not result in transfer of such capital
asset.
• Assistance by way of subsidy/grant/cash incentive/duty drawback by whatever name called by Central
Government or State Government or any authority given to the assessee. (Note: Subsidy or grant
which is taken for determination of Actual Cost of Asset under section 43 (1) shall not be treated as
income. Similarly, subsidy or grant by Central Government, for the purpose of corpus of a trust or
Institution established by Central Government or State Government, shall not be treated as Income).
• Any sum of money or property received by any person, referred in clause (x) of sub-section (2) of
section 56, including gift to a non-resident / foreign company (on or after 5th July 2019).
• Conversion of stock-in-trade into a capital asset.
• Compensation on termination of employment or modification of terms of employment.
Heads of income
1. Income from salaries
2. Income from house property
3. Profits and gains of business or profession
4. Capital gains
5. Income from other sources
Note – Taxable income under the above 5 heads is called gross
total income after considering clubbing of income and set off of
losses, if any.
Rounding off
• Section 288A – Total income shall be rounded off to nearest Rs
10.
• Section 288B – The final Tax Liability shall be rounded off to
nearest Rs. 10.
UNIT
Names of Sub-Units
Overview
This unit begins by explaining meaning of residential status, its types. Further, it discuses types of
income and its tax lability, meaning of incidence lawand its scope, determine the residential status of
each person.
Learning Objectives
Learning Outcomes
https://www.indiafilings.com/learn/residential-status-income-tax/#:~:text=Residential%20
status%20refers%20to%20a,years%20preceding%20the%20financial%20year.
https://incometaxmanagement.com/Pages/Tax-Ready-Reckoner/Residential-Status/Meaning-of-
Residential-Status.html
2.1 INTRODUCTION
Residential status refers to a person’s status in relation to how long they have lived in India over the
previous five years. A taxpayer’s income tax liability is determined by his or her residence status
during the financial year and the four years prior to the financial year. In addition, when filing income
tax returns, the taxpayer must declare the appropriate residency status. The Income Tax Act divides
taxpayers into three categories based on their residence status:
1. Resident but not ordinarily resident
2. Resident
3. Non-resident
Each of the above categories of taxpayers has a different taxability. Let us look at how a taxpayer
becomes a resident, an RNOR, or an NR before we get into taxability.
a. Resident: If a taxpayer meets one of the following two criteria, he is considered an Indian resident
1. Stay in India for a year is 182 days or more, or
2. Stay in India for the immediately 4 preceding years is 365 days or more and 60 days or more in
the relevant financial year.
2
UNIT 02: Residential Status of Various Persons JGI JAIN
DEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
If a citizen or person of Indian origin leaves India for employment during a fiscal year, then he will
only be considered a resident of India if he stays in India for 182 days or more. These individuals are
permitted to stay in India for a period of time that is greater than 60 days but less than 182 days.
These individuals are permitted to stay in India for a period of time that is greater than 60 days but
less than 182 days. For those whose total income (other than foreign sources) exceeds ` 15 lakh, the
period is reduced to 120 days or more beginning in the financial year 2020-21.
An individual who is a citizen of India and is not liable to tax in any other country will be deemed
to be a resident of India beginning in FY 2020-21. Only if his total income (other than from foreign
sources) exceeds ` 15 lakh and he has no tax liability in other countries or territories due to his
domicile or residence, or any other similar criteria, is he considered to be a resident.
b. Resident but Not Ordinarily Resident: If a person meets the residency requirements, the next step
is to determine whether he or she is a Resident and Ordinarily Resident (ROR) or a Resident but Not
Ordinarily Resident (RNOR). If he meets both of the following criteria, he will be a ROR:
1. Has been a resident of India in at least 2 out of 10 years immediately previous years and
2. Has stayed in India for at least 730 days in 7 immediately preceding years
Therefore, if any individual fails to satisfy even one of the above conditions, he would be an RNOR.
From FY 2020-21, a citizen of India or a person of Indian origin who leaves India for employment
outside India during the year will be considered a resident and ordinarily resident if he spends at
least 182 days in India. This condition, however, will only apply if his total income (excluding foreign
sources) exceeds ` 15 lakh. A citizen of India who is deemed to be a resident in India will also be a
resident and ordinarily resident in India (as of FY 2020-21).
c. Non-Resident: An individual satisfying neither of the conditions stated in (a) or (b) above would be
an NR for the year.
Taxability
A resident will be taxed in India on his global income, which includes both income earned in India and
income earned outside India.
NR and RNOR: In India, their tax liability is limited to the income they earn there. They do not have to
pay any taxes in India on their foreign earnings. Also, keep in mind that in the event of double taxation
of income, where the same income is taxed both in India and abroad, one can use the Double Taxation
Avoidance Agreement (DTAA) that India would have entered into with the other country to avoid paying
taxes twice.
3
JGI JAIN
DEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
Direct Tax Laws
3. A person’s residential status should be determined each year, as it is possible that his or her
residential status will change in the following year.
4. If an assessee is resident in India for any source of income in the previous year relevant to the
assessment year, he is deemed to be resident in India for all other sources of income in the previous
year relevant to the assessment year.
5. For any given year, a person may have been a resident of more than one country.
6. There is a distinction between residential status and citizenship. In the previous year, a person could
have been an Indian national/citizen but not an Indian resident or vice versa.
The determination of residential status is critical because a resident who is an ordinary resident must
pay tax on all of his worldwide income, even if he is eligible for DTAA benefits, whereas a non-resident
or resident who is not an ordinary resident (RNOR) must pay tax only on income derived from India,
received or earned in India.
For income tax purposes, understand about your residency status in India. It differs between an
individual and a corporation.
1. Individual: An individual’s residential status is determined by the number of days spent in India.
2. Company: In any other case, residential status is determined by the place of incorporation (in the
case of a company) and the place of control and management.
The purpose of determining a person’s residential status is to determine the tax liability on the total
income earned by that person in a fiscal year.
If a HUF’s control and management of its affairs was entirely outside India during the previous year, it
is said to be non-resident in India.
In other words, if no part of the control and management of its affairs is located in India, it will be
considered non-resident in India.
The decisions made regarding the HUF’s affairs are referred to as control and management. Control
and management are located at the location where the HUF’s business decisions are made.
4
UNIT 02: Residential Status of Various Persons JGI JAIN
DEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
Once the HUF has established residency in India, it must be determined whether it is:
Resident in India and ordinarily resident there; or
Resident in India, but not ordinarily resident.
If the HUF’s karta meets both of the following conditions, the HUF is said to be resident and ordinarily
resident in India.
a. He (Karta) must have lived in the United States for at least two of the ten years immediately preceding
the relevant previous year; and
b. He must have spent at least 730 days in India in the seven years preceding the relevant previous
year.
If the HUF’s manager (Karta) does not meet anyone, or both, of the conditions listed in clauses (a) and
(b) above during the relevant previous year, the HUF is said to be resident but not ordinarily resident in
India.
The residential status of HUF’s ‘Karta’ for the relevant previous year has no bearing on whether HUF is a
Resident or not. However, Karta’s status in the preceding years is relevant in determining whether HUF
is ordinarily resident in India or not.
Except for individuals and HUF, everyone else is either a resident or a non-resident. They are not to be
divided into two categories: ordinarily resident and not ordinarily resident.
A person’s residential status must be determined in order for their income to be taxed. The Income Tax
Act originated this phrase, which has nothing to do with a person’s country or citizenship. Each year, the
assessee’s residence status is determined using the ‘prior year.’ In one year, a person may be a resident
and, in the following, a non-resident. The residential status of the assessment year is immaterial.
The state in which a company is registered determines its residential status. Section 6(3) lays out the
following requirements in this regard.[Section 6(3)] Resident A company is said to be resident in India
in any previous year if:
a. it is an Indian company; OR
b. its place of effective management is in India at any time during that year. A location where critical
management and commercial decisions necessary for an entity’s overall functioning are made is
referred to as a “place of effective management.”
[Sec. 6(3)(ii)] Foreign Company having turnover more than `50 crores in the previous year
For foreign company, the phrase ‘place of effective management’ (POEM) is used to determine the
domicile of a corporation created in another country. Almost all of India’s tax treaties recognise the
concept of ‘place of effective management’ for determining a company’s residence as a tie-breaker rule
for avoiding double taxation. Each case’s POEM will be assessed based on the facts and circumstances.
5
JGI JAIN
DEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
Direct Tax Laws
Furthermore, an entity may have several management locations, but only one effective management
location at any given moment. POEM must be determined on a year-to-year basis since “residential
status” must be determined each year. The process of determining POEM would be primarily based on
whether or not the company is actively engaged in business outside of India.
The Central Board of Direct Tax (CBDT) issued a set of guiding principles in the form of a circular dated
24-01-2017 [Circular No. 06 of 2017] to provide a comprehensive and clear understanding of the concept
of POEM for a company.
The CBDT’s ‘Place of Effective Management’ guidelines, issued via Circular No. 6/2017, dated 24-01-2017,
do not apply to a foreign company with a turnover or gross receipts of Rs. 50 crores or less in a fiscal
year.
[Sec. 6(3)(iii)] Foreign Company having turnover less than `50 crores in the previous year.
A company whose turnover is less than 50 cr. Rupees in the previous year is always treated as non-
resident in India -Circular No. 8/2017, dated February 23, 2017. In other words, a foreign company (whose
annual turnover/gross receipts is Rs. 50 crore or less) cannot be resident in India from the assessment
year 2017-18 onwards.
When a firm, AOP, or other entity is said to be resident in India in any previous year unless the control
and management of its affairs is located entirely outside of India during that year.
The control and management of a firm is in the hands of the partners, so if the partners regularly meet
in India to discuss the firm’s affairs, the firm is said to be resident in India.
Non-resident entities are those whose control and management of their affairs took place entirely
outside of India during the preceding year.
To put it another way, if you’re a Non-Resident, you shouldn’t have any control or management in India.
A juridical person is a non-human legal entity that is not a single natural person but rather an
organisation recognised by law as a legal person, such as a corporation, government agency or non-
governmental organisation (NGO), university. A juridical person, also known as an artificial person,
juridical entity, juridic person, juristic person, or legal person, has certain duties and rights that are
outlined in relevant laws.
6
UNIT 02: Residential Status of Various Persons JGI JAIN
DEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
We cannot calculate an assessee’s total income unless we know where he lived in India the previous year.
The assessee can be one of the following, depending on their residence status:
A person who lives in India; or
Non-Resident in India
Individuals and HUFs, on the other hand, cannot simply be called Indian residents. If a person lives in
India, then he will be one of the following:
If you are a resident and ordinarily resident in India; or
If you are non- resident and ordinarily resident in India
Other categories of people must be either Indian residents or non-Indian residents. In their case, there
is no distinction between ordinarily resident and not ordinarily resident.
(a) any income which is received or (b) any income which accrues (c) any income which accrues or
is deemed to be received in India in or arises or is deemed to accrue arises outside India during the
the relevant previous year by or on or arise in India during the relevant previous year.
behalf of such person; relevant previous year;
B. In the case of a Resident but not Ordinarily Resident in India (In the case of individuals and HUF
only) [Section 5(1) and its proviso]:
7
JGI JAIN
DEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
Direct Tax Laws
The following incomes from whatever source derived form part of Total Income in the case of
resident but not ordinarily resident in India:
(a) any income which is received (b) any income which accrues (c) any income which accrues or arises
or is deemed to be received in or arises or is deemed to to him outside India during the relevant
India in the relevant previous accrue or arise to him during previous year if it is derived from a
year by or on behalf of such the relevant previous year; business controlled in or a profession
person; set up in India.
(a) any income which is received or is deemed to be (b) any income which accrues or arises or is
received in India during the relevant previous year by deemed to accrue or arise to him in India during
or on behalf of such person; the relevant previous year.
In all three cases above, income described in items (a) and (b) must be included in total income of all
three categories of assessees in the same way. The income described in item (c), i.e., income earned or
arising outside of India, is as follows:
i. If the assessee is not a resident of India, it is not included in the total income.
ii. Only if it is derived from a business controlled in India or a profession set up in India is it included in
the total income of a resident but not ordinarily resident in India.
If an assessee has various incomes both inside and outside India, the tax incidence is likely to be higher
in the case of a resident and ordinarily resident in India, a little lower in the case of a resident but not
ordinarily resident in India, and the lowest in the case of a non-resident in India.
The provisions regarding incidence of tax above may be summarised in the following table:
8
UNIT 02: Residential Status of Various Persons JGI JAIN
DEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
The term “receipts” refers to the first receipt: The term “receipt of income” refers to the first time the
money is placed in the recipient’s possession. Any remittance or transmission of an amount received as
income to another location does not constitute receipt within the meaning of this clause at that location.
This principle is important in determining the year of receipt, as well as determining the taxation
incidence where the income is solely dependent on receipt.
Non-residents, for example, do not have their foreign income assessed unless it is actually received in
India. In their case, unless the money is received as income from an outside source when it arrives in
India, it will not be considered an income receipt. If a non-resident received moneys as income or exempt
income outside of India (in a previous year or during the previous year) and transferred the funds into
India during the accounting year, the moneys will not be considered income in the eyes of the law.
Even if actual receipt is not made, the following incomes are deemed to bereceived in India in the
previous year:
1. Contribution by the employer to the recognised provident fund of more than 12% of the employee’s
salary.
2. Interest is credited to the employee’s RPF at a rate of more than 9.5 percent per year.
3. The contribution made by the Central Government or any other employer to an employee’s account
under a notified contributory pension scheme referred to in Section 80CCD in the previous year.
4. The Tax Officer adds the amount to the employee’s account if the employee has an old provident
fund that was not recognised previously but is now recognised. If the old funds had been recognised
earlier, they would have been taxed sooner. As a result, it is now taxable as income deemed to be
received.
The person is also deemed to have received tax deducted at source. The company’s dividend is considered
received in the year in which it is declared, distributed or paid. The previous year’s income is also
considered when calculating the interim dividend.
9
JGI JAIN
DEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
Direct Tax Laws
Within the ambit of tax liability, Indian Income Tax Laws cover residents, non-residents and residential
but non-ordinary residents’ taxpayers. The Act also imposes a tax liability on foreign companies’ and
non-resident Indians’ income to the extent that it is sourced within India.
It is important to note that Sections 9 and 5 of the Act are inter-twined, hence a thorough understanding
of Section 5 is required first.
Residential status
According to the Income Tax Act of 1961, a taxpayer’s residence status can be one of the following:
A. Resident: To be a resident of India, the taxpayer must meet one of the following two requirements:
a. Has spent at least 182 days in India in the previous year
OR
b. Have spent at least 365 days in India in the previous four years
And
In the relevant financial year, spends at least 60 days in India.
B. Resident but not Ordinarily Resident: If a person meets both of the following criteria, he falls into
this category:
a. He has spent at least two of the previous ten years as a “Resident of India.”
AND
b. Has spent at least 730 days in India in the previous seven years.
C. Non-Resident of India: Indians who are not citizens of the United States (NRI)
If the taxpayer does not meet any of the above conditions of Resident or Resident Non-Ordinarily
Resident, he is said to have the residential status of an NRI.
10
UNIT 02: Residential Status of Various Persons JGI JAIN
DEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
The Income Tax Act’s Section 9 is a deeming provision. In a few circumstances, it specifies a certain
income that is deemed or supposed to accrue or arise in India. Non-residents’ income cannot be taxed in
India unless it falls within the four corners of the Income Tax Act, Section 5 read with Section 9.
Certain incomes are deemed to have arisen in India for tax purposes under Section 9(1). Even if it accrues
or arises outside of India, certain income is said to have been incurred in India.
Foreign companies and NRIs’ business income is taxed in India to the extent that it accrues or arises:
through a business connection in India
through any asset located within India
through any source of income within India
Section 9(2) of the Income Tax Act defines deemed income as income incurred or arising in India for
taxation purposes
Any profit made by non-residents from such a connection is said to have been made within India and is
taxable under the Income Tax Act of 1961.
a. Income from assets or property located in India: Any income earned from any property located
in India, whether movable, immovable, tangible, or intangible, is considered incurred within India
for tax purposes.Mr. X, for example, resides in Beijing. He receives a royalty for a book that was
published in India. Such royalties are taxable in India because they are deemed to have accrued in
India, regardless of whether they are received in or outside of India.
Income arising from the transfer of capital assets located in India is said to have incurred in India if
the asset is located in India, regardless of the transferor’s or transferee’s residential status.
b. Salary earned for services performed in India: Any income earned as a salary for services
performed in India, regardless of whether the salary is paid within or outside the country.
c. Salary earned for services rendered outside India: Any Indian citizen’s salary paid by the Indian
government for services rendered outside India is considered to have been incurred in India.
d. Interest Income: In India, any interest received from the following is taxable in the hands of the
recipient:
Except when the interest is paid in connection with money borrowed for use in a business or
profession outside India, by the Government, or
by Indian residents.
By NRIs, as long as the interest is related to the money borrowed for use in a business or
profession carried on in India.
11
JGI JAINDEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
Direct Tax Laws
e. Royalty income: Any royalty paid by any of the following is taxable in India in the hands of the
recipient of such income:
Unless the royalty is paid in connection with the right or information used in a business or
profession located outside India, it is paid by the government, or
by an Indian resident.
By NRIs, as long as the royalty is in connection with a right or information that is used in a
business or profession conducted in India.
f. Fee Paid for technical service: Fees paid for rendering technical services are taxable in the hands of
the recipient of such income in India if paid by one of the following:
by the government
Unless the service is provided in connection with a business or profession that is based outside
of India.
By NRIs, provided that the service is used in connection with a business or profession conducted
in India.
g. Distribution of Profits: If the entire business operations are not confined within India and are
conducted globally, only that portion of the total operation that is attributable to the operations
conducted in India is deemed to be accrued in India and taxable within India under Section 9(1)(I).
For example, in any business operation, different countries are responsible for manufacturing and
selling. Manufacturing, for example, takes place in India, and the goods produced are exported.
Profit attributable to selling operations is deemed not to accrue in India in this case.
In the event that the income from operations carried out in India cannot be determined, Rule 10 of
the Income Tax Rules, 1962, takes precedence. As per the following rule:
Assessing Officers determine a percentage of total turnover that has accrued or arisen in India
after considering the facts and circumstances.
OR
Any amount that has the same proportion of total profit as the total receipts of the business.
OR
Any other method that the Assessing Officer deems appropriate.
12
UNIT 02: Residential Status of Various Persons JGI JAIN
DEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
A HUF is said to be resident in India in any previous year unless the control and management of its
affairs is located entirely outside of India during that year.
When a firm, AOP, or other entity is said to be resident in India in any previous year unless the
control and management of its affairs is located entirely outside of India during that year.
Non-resident entities are those whose control and management of their affairs took place entirely
outside of India during the preceding year.
A local authority is an organisation that is formally in charge of all public services and facilities in
each area.
2.12 GLOSSARY
Domicile: It refers to a place where a person resides with an intention of living their permanently
Ambit: The range or area of something
Intertwined: It means connected together and difficult to separate
Possession: When a person is owing or controlling something
Case Objective
The objective of this case study is to determine whether the income generated in India considered to
be taxable or not?
Ramesh was born in India in 1976 and moved to the U.K. for further studies after doing graduation from
India. He completed his studies in the U.K. and started doing a job. After some years he came to India
but stayed only for 3 months in India. He used to do this every year. Along with job he started a business
with a company in India. In the first year of his business where he supplied goods to a company which
is situated in India he made a profit of ` 3 lakhs. He was taxed by the Income tax authorities in India but
he argued and refused to pay the tax.
Question
1. Discuss whether he should be taxable? Why?
(Hint: Any profit made by non-residents from such a connection is said to have been made within
India and is taxable under the Income Tax Act of 1961. Refer Section 2.10.)
13
JGI JAINDEEMED-TO-BE UNIVERSIT Y
Direct Tax Laws
https://incometaxmanagement.com/Pages/Tax-Ready-Reckoner/Residential-Status/Meaning-of-
Residential-Status.html
https://taxguru.in/income-tax/residential-status-individuals-income-tax-act-1961.html
Compare and contrast the tax systems in India and the UK.
14
Residential Status of various
Persons
Unit – 02
CA. Prashant Bharadwaj
Residential Status of Individuals – Sec 6(1)
An individual is said to be resident in India in any previous year if
he fulfills any one of the following two basic conditions:
• He is in India, in the previous year for a total period of 182 days
or more.
OR
• He is in India for a total period of 60 days or more during the
previous year AND 365 days or more during 4 years preceding
the previous year.
Note: The day on which he enters India, as well as the day on
which he leaves India, shall be considered as stay in India.
Resident and Ordinarily Resident – Sec 6(6)
In addition to fulfilling the above basic conditions, any individual if he
fulfills both of the following conditions he will be treated as ordinarily
resident in India, in the previous year:
• He has been resident in India in at least 2 out of 10 previous years
immediately preceding the relevant previous year;
AND
• He has been in India for a period of 730 days or more during 7 years
immediately preceding the relevant previous year.
Note: An individual who satisfies one or more basic conditions as per
section 6(1), but does not satisfy the two additional conditions laid down
in section 6(6) [as above], is treated as resident but not ordinarily
resident in India.
Residential Status of HUF – Sec 6(2)
• A Hindu Undivided Family is said to be resident in India if the control and
management of its business affairs is situated wholly or partly in India.
• A Hindu Undivided Family is non-resident in India if the Control and
management of its business affairs is situated wholly outside India.
• If the control and management of the business affairs of the Hindu Undivided
Family is situated wholly or partly in India and if the manager (Karta) satisfies
the conditions of section 6(6), then the Hindu Undivided Family is considered
as “Ordinarily Resident”.
• If the control and management of the business affairs of the Hindu Undivided
Family is situated wholly or partly in India and if the manager (Karta) fails to
satisfy any of the conditions of section 6(6), then the Hindu Undivided Family
is considered as “Not Ordinarily Resident”.
Residential Status of Companies – Sec 6(3)
The following types of companies are considered resident in India:
• Indian company.
• Any other company whose turnover/gross receipts in the previous
year is more than Rs. 50 Crore and the place of effective
management is situated wholly in India.
In any other case the company shall be considered non-resident.
Note: Place of effective management means a place where key
management decision and commercial decision that are necessary for
the conduct of the business entity as a whole are, in substance made.
Residential Status of Firm or AOP – Sec 6(4)
A Firm, Association Of Persons and every other person is
considered as resident if the control and management is situated
wholly or partly in India. If the control and management is
situated wholly outside India, such firm, Association Of Persons
or any other person is considered as non-resident.
Scope of Total Income – Sec 5
PARTICULARS RESIDENT & RESIDENT & NON-
ORDINARILY NOT- RESIDENT.
RESIDENT. ORDINARILY
RESIDENT.