Professional Documents
Culture Documents
No Investment Criteria Best Case Worst Case Best Case Target Conclusion
1 Payback Period 3.15 3.38 2.95 < 4 Years Accepted
2 Profitability Index 1.48 1.34 1.61 >1 Accepted
3 IRR 25% 22% 29% > 12% Accepted
4 NPV $ 18,304,125 $ 13,107,874 $ 23,500,376 Positive Accepted
5 Cummulative Cash Flow $ 46,998,250 $ 39,525,850 $ 54,470,650
Conclusion:
- When the price is changed by +/- 5%, the NPV will increase/decrease by $5.2 mio and the cumulative cash flow will incre
- When the sales volume is changed by +/- 5%, the NPV will increase/decrease by $3.1 mio and the cumulative cash flow w
This case is more sensitive to price
VOLUME SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS
Y1 Y2 Y3 Y4
Base Case 74,000 95,000 125,000 105,000
Worst Case 70,300 90,250 118,750 99,750
Best Case 77,700 99,750 131,250 110,250
Target Conclusion
< 4 Years Accepted
>1 Accepted
> 12% Accepted
Positive Accepted
PRICE SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS
5%
Base Case Worst Case Best Case
Price $ 480 $ 456 $ 504
BASE CASE
1. Projected Income Statement
Year
1 2
Price $ 480 $ 480
Volume 74,000 95,000
Sales $ 35,520,000 $ 45,600,000
Side Effect $ (6,925,000) $ (6,225,000)
Sales - Adjusted $ 28,595,000 $ 39,375,000
Year
0 1 2
Operating Cash Flow $ 9,387,578 $ 15,243,778
Change in NWC $ (5,719,000) $ (2,156,000)
Recovery of NWC
Capital Spending $ (38,500,000)
Projected Cash Flow $ (38,500,000) $ 3,668,578 $ 13,087,778
5. IRR 25%
6. NPV $ 18,304,125
WORST CASE
1. Projected Income Statement
Year
3 4 5
$ 480 $ 480 $ 480 Price
125,000 105,000 80,000 Volume
$ 60,000,000 $ 50,400,000 $ 38,400,000 Sales
Side Effect
$ 60,000,000 $ 50,400,000 $ 38,400,000 Sales - Adjusted
Year
3 4 5
$ 22,880,528 $ 18,371,778 $ 13,098,318 Operating Cash Flow
$ (4,125,000) $ 1,920,000 $ 2,400,000 Change in NWC
$ 7,680,000 Recovery of NWC
$ 6,516,273 Capital Spending
$ 18,755,528 $ 20,291,778 $ 29,694,590 Projected Cash Flow
4. Profitability Index
5. IRR
6. NPV
- - - - -
Year
1 2 3 4 5
$ 456 $ 456 $ 456 $ 456 $ 456
74,000 95,000 125,000 105,000 80,000
$ 33,744,000 $ 43,320,000 $ 57,000,000 $ 47,880,000 $ 36,480,000
$ (6,925,000) $ (6,225,000) $ - $ - $ -
$ 26,819,000 $ 37,095,000 $ 57,000,000 $ 47,880,000 $ 36,480,000
Year
0 1 2 3 4 5
$ 8,233,178 $ 13,761,778 $ 20,930,528 $ 16,733,778 $ 11,850,318
$ (5,363,800) $ (2,055,200) $ (3,981,000) $ 1,824,000 $ 2,280,000
$ 7,296,000
$ (38,500,000) $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 6,516,273
$ (38,500,000) $ 2,869,378 $ 11,706,578 $ 16,949,528 $ 18,557,778 $ 27,942,590
1.34
22%
$ 13,107,874
BEST CASE
1. Projected Income Statement
- -
Year
1 2
Price $ 504 $ 504
Volume 74,000 95,000
Sales $ 37,296,000 $ 47,880,000
Side Effect $ (6,925,000) $ (6,225,000)
Sales - Adjusted $ 30,371,000 $ 41,655,000
Year
0 1 2
Operating Cash Flow $ 10,541,978 $ 16,725,778
Change in NWC $ (6,074,200) $ (2,256,800)
Recovery of NWC
Capital Spending $ (38,500,000) $ - $ -
Projected Cash Flow $ (38,500,000) $ 4,467,778 $ 14,468,978
5. IRR 29%
6. NPV $ 23,500,376
- - -
Year
3 4 5
$ 504 $ 504 $ 504
125,000 105,000 80,000
$ 63,000,000 $ 52,920,000 $ 40,320,000
$ - $ - $ -
$ 63,000,000 $ 52,920,000 $ 40,320,000
Year
3 4 5
$ 24,830,528 $ 20,009,778 $ 14,346,318
$ (4,269,000) $ 2,016,000 $ 2,520,000
$ 8,064,000
$ - $ - $ 6,516,273
$ 20,561,528 $ 22,025,778 $ 31,446,590
Y1 Y2 Y3
Base Case 74,000 95,000 125,000
Worst Case 70,300 90,250 118,750
Best Case 77,700 99,750 131,250
BASE CASE
1. Projected Income Statement
Year
1 2
Price $ 480 $ 480
Volume 74,000 95,000
Sales $ 35,520,000 $ 45,600,000
Side Effect $ (6,925,000) $ (6,225,000)
Sales - Adjusted $ 28,595,000 $ 39,375,000
Year
0 1 2
Operating Cash Flow $ 9,387,578 $ 15,243,778
Change in NWC $ (5,719,000) $ (2,156,000)
Recovery of NWC
Capital Spending $ (38,500,000)
Projected Cash Flow $ (38,500,000) $ 3,668,578 $ 13,087,778
5. IRR 25%
6. NPV $ 18,304,125
5%
Y4 Y5
105,000 80,000
99,750 76,000
110,250 84,000
WORST CASE
1. Projected Income Statement
Year
3 4 5
$ 480 $ 480 $ 480 Price
125,000 105,000 80,000 Volume
$ 60,000,000 $ 50,400,000 $ 38,400,000 Sales
Side Effect
$ 60,000,000 $ 50,400,000 $ 38,400,000 Sales - Adjusted
Year
3 4 5
$ 22,880,528 $ 18,371,778 $ 13,098,318 Operating Cash Flow
$ (4,125,000) $ 1,920,000 $ 2,400,000 Change in NWC
$ 7,680,000 Recovery of NWC
$ 6,516,273 Capital Spending
$ 18,755,528 $ 20,291,778 $ 29,694,590 Projected Cash Flow
4. Profitability Index
5. IRR
6. NPV
- - - - -
Year
1 2 3 4 5
$ 480 $ 480 $ 480 $ 480 $ 480
70,300 90,250 118,750 99,750 76,000
$ 33,744,000 $ 43,320,000 $ 57,000,000 $ 47,880,000 $ 36,480,000
$ (6,925,000) $ (6,225,000) $ - $ - $ -
$ 26,819,000 $ 37,095,000 $ 57,000,000 $ 47,880,000 $ 36,480,000
Year
0 1 2 3 4 5
$ 8,678,103 $ 14,332,965 $ 21,682,090 $ 17,365,090 $ 12,331,318
$ (5,363,800) $ (2,055,200) $ (3,981,000) $ 1,824,000 $ 2,280,000
$ 7,296,000
$ (38,500,000) $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 6,516,273
$ (38,500,000) $ 3,314,303 $ 12,277,765 $ 17,701,090 $ 19,189,090 $ 28,423,590
1.39
23%
$ 15,169,566
BEST CASE
1. Projected Income Statement
- -
Year
1 2
Price $ 480 $ 480
Volume 77,700 99,750
Sales $ 37,296,000 $ 47,880,000
Side Effect $ (6,925,000) $ (6,225,000)
Sales - Adjusted $ 30,371,000 $ 41,655,000
Year
0 1 2
Operating Cash Flow $ 10,097,053 $ 16,154,590
Change in NWC $ (6,074,200) $ (2,256,800)
Recovery of NWC
Capital Spending $ (38,500,000) $ - $ -
Projected Cash Flow $ (38,500,000) $ 4,022,853 $ 13,897,790
5. IRR 28%
6. NPV $ 21,438,684
- - -
Year
3 4 5
$ 480 $ 480 $ 480
131,250 110,250 84,000
$ 63,000,000 $ 52,920,000 $ 40,320,000
$ - $ - $ -
$ 63,000,000 $ 52,920,000 $ 40,320,000
Year
3 4 5
$ 24,078,965 $ 19,378,465 $ 13,865,318
$ (4,269,000) $ 2,016,000 $ 2,520,000
$ 8,064,000
$ - $ - $ 6,516,273
$ 19,809,965 $ 21,394,465 $ 30,965,590
Base Case
Price $ 480
ACCOUNTING BREAK-EVEN
1. Projected Income Statement
Year
1 2
Price $ 480 $ 480
Volume 53,734 64,673
Sales $ 25,792,515 $ 31,043,227
Side Effect $ (6,925,000) $ (6,225,000)
Sales - Adjusted $ 18,867,515 $ 24,818,227
Year
0 1 2
Operating Cash Flow $ 5,501,650 $ 9,428,650
Change in NWC
Recovery of NWC
Capital Spending $ (38,500,000)
Projected Cash Flow $ (38,500,000) $ 5,501,650 $ 9,428,650
5. IRR -9%
6. NPV $ (16,271,645)
CASH BREAK-EVEN
1. Projected Income Statement
Year
3 4 5
$ 480 $ 480 $ 480 Price
40,792 34,267 29,621 Volume
$ 19,580,176 $ 16,447,973 $ 14,217,844 Sales
Side Effect
$ 19,580,176 $ 16,447,973 $ 14,217,844 Sales - Adjusted
Year
3 4 5
$ 6,733,650 $ 4,808,650 $ 3,438,050 Operating Cash Flow
Change in NWC
Recovery of NWC
Capital Spending
$ 6,733,650 $ 4,808,650 $ 3,438,050 Projected Cash Flow
4. Profitability Index
5. IRR
6. NPV
Year
1 2 3 4 5
$ 480 $ 480 $ 480 $ 480 $ 480
25,043 15,502 5,675 9,189 11,691
$ 12,020,458 $ 7,440,870 $ 2,724,103 $ 4,410,674 $ 5,611,513
$ (6,925,000) $ (6,225,000) $ - $ - $ -
$ 5,095,458 $ 1,215,870 $ 2,724,103 $ 4,410,674 $ 5,611,513
Year
0 1 2 3 4 5
$ - $ - $ - $ - $ -
$ (38,500,000)
$ (38,500,000) $ - $ - $ - $ - $ -
Err:523
$ (38,500,000)
FINANCIAL BREAK-EVEN
1. Projected Income Statement
Year
1 2
Price $ 480 $ 480
Volume 80,742 71,201
Sales $ 38,755,956 $ 34,176,368
Side Effect $ (6,925,000) $ (6,225,000)
Sales - Adjusted $ 31,830,956 $ 27,951,368
Year
0 1 2
Operating Cash Flow $ 10,680,275 $ 10,680,275
Change in NWC
Recovery of NWC
Capital Spending $ (38,500,000)
Projected Cash Flow $ (38,500,000) $ 10,680,275 $ 10,680,275
5. IRR 12%
6. NPV $ (0)
Year
3 4 5
$ 480 $ 480 $ 480
61,374 64,888 67,390
$ 29,459,602 $ 31,146,173 $ 32,347,011
$ - $ - $ -
$ 29,459,602 $ 31,146,173 $ 32,347,011
Year
3 4 5
$ 10,680,275 $ 10,680,275 $ 10,680,275
PRELIMINARY CALCULATION
1. Projected Sales
In 5 Years
ario - No Project
Volume Price Variable Cost Fixed Cost
80,000 $ 310 $ 125 $ 1,800,000
60,000 $ 310 $ 125 $ 1,800,000
ario - Project
Volume Price Variable Cost Fixed Cost
65,000 $ 275 $ 125 $ 1,800,000
45,000 $ 275 $ 125 $ 1,800,000