Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Vol. 6, No 3, 2018.
Abstract: This research purposes at identifying the directors on the draft IFRS presentation,
level of segmental information disclosure in the the negative effects of aggregation levels
annual financial reports of the banks operating in
identifies in the financial reports.
Iraq for the period 2016, through the use of
indicators prepared in accordance with the However, for some bank’ differences
requirements of IFRS 8. The significance of the in aggregation levels between financial
research stems from the reputation of objective statement items are difficult to understand
information provided by the segmental financial
and analyze by the users. Therefore, the
reports that contribute to the addition of a new type
of accounting information on the performance of
overall financial information at the
the bank's segments to meet the needs of the corporation level as a whole does not fully
financial reports users. However, in accordance meet the needs of users, as this information
with the research findings, this research presented a makes it difficult for users to understand
set of recommendations, the most important is the and analyze the corporation's activities and
necessity of the banks operating in Iraq to comply financial performance independently due
with all the requirements of the segmental to the expansion and diversification of
information disclosure that are in line with the multiple activities practiced by banks and
requirements of IFRS 8. geographic regions. Which requires the
Keywords: information, banks attention to the segmental information of
corporations that have more activity, which
Introduction
requires these banks to provide
Corporate (bank) extensive financial information for each segment of business
reporting alone is insufficient to assist to be useful in evaluating the results of the
users in accessing accurate and objective corporation's business, and banks can
corporate performance evaluations because provide detailed information including
of the limited capacity of their numbers to complete financial statements for each
segment works.
capture disparities in the performance of
the corporation's segments. Thus, the high Given the importance of the
levels of aggregation affect the value of information provided by the segmental
information in overall financial reports. In reports, the research deals with the
exploration of the practices of banks
this direction, some professional
operating in Iraq concerning the segmental
accounting boards and organizations have
information disclosure in published
identified the negative effects of high financial reports through the use of a
levels of aggregation in financial reports, model in assessing the level of segmental
including the US and international information disclosure in published
accounting standards board (IASB). While, financial reports.
at the July 2010 meeting of the board of
41
www.japmnt.com
(JPMNT) Journal of Process Management – New Technologies, International
Vol. 6, No 3, 2018.
The importance of the research lies in information about the results of the
the significance of the information departments they manage instead of the
provided by the segmental financial reports need for a single income statement for the
whether it is information about business whole corporation. Provides a statement of
segments or geographical segments, as it the corporation's income as aggregate
consists of information content that helps summary information for all operations of
to evaluate the performance of banks in a the corporation does not contain sufficient
way that affects the rationalization of the details allow the manager to discover
decisions of users of accounting opportunities and problems that may exist
information. in the corporation (bank), for instance, a
product may be more profitable while
However, the research aimed to assess
others are unprofitable. Some sales offices
the reality of the segmental information
may be more efficient than others, or some
disclosure in the banks operating in Iraq
factories do not use the energy or resources
based on the accounting standards issued
available to them efficiently.
by the professional accounting committees
and boards, especially the IFRS 8. Increasingly, more and more
information sought as a result of the need
The Concept of Segmental Information for this type of information. Many
Disclosure financial analysts and investors have called
for the disclosure of segmental
Accounting disclosure means the information. In response to requests from
inclusion of financial reports on all financial analysts and investors, many
information necessary and necessary to professional organizations have issued
provide users of these reports a clear and accounting standards that require
correct image of the accounting unit. segmental information disclosure.
According to Abubakr et al., (2017: 353) However, the FASB issued standard No.
as a result of the development and 14 of 1976, corporate segment financial
expansion of economic activity besides the reporting, which was replaced by standard
emergence of large-scale projects on the No. 131 of 1997, the disclosure of
geographical level and the various corporate segments and associated
activities carried out by these projects. information.
While, accounting disclosure in its
traditional form is not meet the needs of Consequently, the International
users, as the financial reports prepared by Accounting Standards Board (IASC)
the corporations contain a summary of issued IASC14, which amended in 1997,
achievements at the macro level. The and was replaced by IFRS 8 in November
managers of these corporations can 2006. The segment information is
manage the corporation efficiently and disclosed by dividing the corporation into a
effectively, they need information about number of the segments. As, (Mantiziou,
the corporation at the level of the segment 2014: 17) mentioned the operating
does not need the need at this point, but the segment also intended for the independent
external users of the information unit within the corporation that achieves a
corporation need information on segments specific profit and has separate accounting
that are one such corporation and to make records within the corporation, under
decisions. which the performance and efficiency of
the unit assessed.
In this context, Garrison & Norin,
(2013: 602) argued that some managers
can work efficiently. Thus, they need
42
www.japmnt.com
(JPMNT) Journal of Process Management – New Technologies, International
Vol. 6, No 3, 2018.
As can realize from the above disclosure means disclosing the material
definition, any part of the corporation to information of the main sectors that
which the conditions set out in the comprise the corporation to judge the
definition can consider as an operating corporation's position and market value
segment. Accordingly, Aljaarat, (2017: and assess its ability to generate cash flows
in the future. In the same regard, Nobes &
435) believed that corporations could
Parker, (2010: 428) identify the segmental
classify their activities by operating
information disclosure as the division of
segments in several ways, including the corporation's overall reporting
dividing the corporation according to the information into detailed information for
nature of the activities so-called activity each section of the corporation to provide
segments or geographical segments or by more detailed information on the
combining the segments of activity and the performance of the corporation
geographical segments. The activity and components. Thus, it believes that the
the geographical segments can express as concepts of segmental information
follows: disclosure as one of the forms of expansion
of accounting disclosure does not replace
First, activity segment is a branch of the disclosure of the total information and
the corporation that provides a specific is complementary to it, to help users of
product, service, or set of products or financial reports to make rational
services. However, is subject to risk and economic decisions.
has different returns than other segments. The primary objective is to disclose
Second, the geographical segment is a segmental information in corporations in
branch of the corporation were providing providing information on their core sectors
products and services in a particular related to the dissemination of information
economic environment, while it is subject about the types of business activities and
to risk and has different returns from other the economic conditions in which the
branches of the Corporation operating in corporation operates. And the opinion of
other economic environments. the US accounting standard FASB No.131
disclosure about segment of an enterprise
From the above, it is possible to and related information and IFRS No.8
present many different views on the operation segments the objectives of the
definition of the segmental information disclosure of segment information are to
disclosure. While, (Epstein & Mirza, 2002: assist users of financial reports on: (FASB,
780) defined that it is the disclosure of standards No 131,1997: 5) and (IASB,
information on operations in various standards No 8 , 2006: 4):
industries, foreign sales, export sales and
key customers of the corporation. a) Gain a better understanding of the
corporation's diverse activities.
Nevertheless, there are those who b) Better estimate the corporation's
believe that the segmental information returns, risk and estimate future
disclosure is the division of the corporation
cash flows.
into segments, whether business or
c) To arrive at a better opinion based
geographical segments and the
presentation of the financial statements on more information on the overall
fragmented with the corporation's total performance of the corporation
information (Roberts, 2002: 420). with a variety of activities.
However, (Nikolai & Bazley, 2009: 263)
believe that segmental information
43
www.japmnt.com
(JPMNT) Journal of Process Management – New Technologies, International
Vol. 6, No 3, 2018.
45
www.japmnt.com
(JPMNT) Journal of Process Management – New Technologies, International
Vol. 6, No 3, 2018.
47
www.japmnt.com
(JPMNT) Journal of Process Management – New Technologies, International
Vol. 6, No 3, 2018.
Part One, General Information Second, Analysis the Results of the Level
of Segmental Information Disclosure of
This section comprises two items,
the Surveyed Banks
which intend to disclose the factors used in
identifying or diagnosing the segments, To reach this research results, the
also comprising the basis of the indicators prepared for the financial reports
corporation and the manner in which the prepared at the end of 2016. However, to
management has adopted based on reach the measurement of the level of
differences in products, services, segmental information disclosure of these
geographic regions and regulatory banks, weight was assumed (0) for each
environments or a combination. Thus, item of disclosure that is not available,
these collected to form a more significant while (1) for each item of disclosure for
segment. Moreover, public information which segmental information is available.
also includes the types of products and Based on the above, the level of disclosure
services that the segment derives. for the sample of the research can provide
as follows:
Part Two, Information on Profit or Loss or
1. The Level of Segmental Information
Assets and Liabilities of the Segment
Disclosure
This section contains 13 items To obtain the measurement of the
designed to collect information about the level of segmental information disclosure
required disclosures about profit or loss for each bank for the year of study, the
containing the specific revenues and ratio was calculated by dividing the
expenses involved in the reported profit or number of items in which sectoral
loss, assets and liabilities segments, and information is available on the total (22)
the measurement basis adopted.
items which represent the overall items of
disclosure as reveals in the Table below
Part Three, the Matches (1):
48
www.japmnt.com
(JPMNT) Journal of Process Management – New Technologies, International
Vol. 6, No 3, 2018.
Table 1: Segmental Information Disclosure ratio for banks research Sample for 2016
49
www.japmnt.com
(JPMNT) Journal of Process Management – New Technologies, International
Vol. 6, No 3, 2018.
As summarized in a table (1) that the Baghdad, which reached the level 59.1%
level of segmental information disclosure of total segmental information disclosure.
for banks ranges between 4.5% at the However, as reveals in a table below (2)
lowest level and 59.1% the maximum the distribution of the percentage of
level, so, the accounting level for the segmental information disclosure to banks
disclosure in banks reached 20.23%. according to different categories as
While, the highest level of information follows:
disclosure establishes at the bank of
Table 2: Percentage of disclosure of sectoral information for banks Sample study for 2016
1-10 6 30
11-20 5 25
21-30 5 25
31-40 2 10
41 and above 2 10
Total 20 100%
As indicated in the Table (2) there are disclosure between banks, besides low the
six banks or 30% of the sample size of the overall disclosure levels for all banks.
research whose segmental information
checked for less than 10% in the survey 2. Distribution of Disclosure Ratios
period 2016. While, two banks, or 10% of According to the Segmental
the sample, examined their segmental Information Disclosure
information by more than 41% in the same
As showed in a table below (3), that
period indicated.
analyzed the overall level of segmental
The researcher notes that 18 banks, or information disclosure indicators to the
about 90% of the sample size, have component items to provide a more
disclosed their segmental information by detailed image of the disclosure levels. To
less than 40%. However, this percentage achieve the desired objective, while the
also ranges from 10% to 30%. These percentage of segmental disclosure for
results demonstrate significant differences each item calculate the number of banks
in the percentage of segmental information that disclosed the item divided by the total
number of sample banks (20).
50
www.japmnt.com
(JPMNT) Journal of Process Management – New Technologies, International
Vol. 6, No 3, 2018.
Table 3: The level of segmental information disclosure in accordance with the terms of the disclosure
indicators
51
www.japmnt.com
(JPMNT) Journal of Process Management – New Technologies, International
Vol. 6, No 3, 2018.
Third, Matches:
Through showing the results as segmental information for the item reached
revealed in the table (3) the percentage of 50% of the items namely with any items of
segmental information disclosure for each disclosure indicator disclosed by 100%.
indicator varies independently during the The lowest level of segmental information
research period. While, there are items that disclosure item was constituting a 05% for
have not disclosed permanently, like the items as; Interest income as well as
revenues from transactions with the interest expense. Also, the bank's share of
operating segments of the same profit or loss of associates and joint
corporation. However, income and expense ventures. Besides the amount of
items of relative importance by paragraph investment in associates and joint ventures
97 of IAS 1 financial statements. in the equity method.
Consequently, income tax expense, When we look at the same table (3),
non-monetary items except depreciation we can realize that the highest level of
and amortization. So, the basis adopted segmental information disclosure of the
measurement as well as revenue from item concerned was the item of revenue
senior customers (if 10% of the bank’s from external clients for each product or
revenues exceed) that items have not service. In the second part or item four
disclosed. As a result, reveals that none of (disclosure at the corporation level) by
the disclosure items disclose at 100%. 85% for the period indicated.
Subsequently, the minimum level of
disclosure that has observed for in the
52
www.japmnt.com
(JPMNT) Journal of Process Management – New Technologies, International
Vol. 6, No 3, 2018.
The table above displays that the rate expense, corporation's share of profit or
of segmental information disclosure for loss of associates and joint ventures, the
2016 for the sample banks is 20.23%, amount of investment in associates and
ranging between (4.5%) in the minimum equity-sharing projects. The highest level
and (59.1%) in the maximum, which is of segmental information disclosure for the
relatively low, and the statistical results item concerned was the item of revenue
revealed that 18 banks, or nearly 90% of from external clients for each product or
the sample size, reported their segmental service. In the second part or paragraph
information by less than 40%. However, four (disclosure at the corporation level) by
from these results, there are significant 85% for the for the period indicated.
differences in the ratio of segmental
information disclosure among banks and Recommendations:
the low level of disclosure for all banks. Based on the above results, the
So, based on the preceding, the primary researcher recommends the following:
hypothesis rejected regard, the banks
operating in Iraq disclose the segment Recommending the supervisory
information in the financial statements by authorities of the banks, including the Iraqi
the requirements of IFRS 8. central bank and the accounting disclosure
department in the Iraqi stock exchange, to
Conclusions oblige banks in Iraq to prepare segmental
financial reports by the requirements of
The results of the research indicated IFRS 8 and to issue severe consequences
that most of the sample banks did not against banks that did not require this.
disclose the segmental information. While
these results showed that the general The reports of external auditors should
disclosure of segmental information in include in the review of the financial
2016 was 20.23% Which ranges from statements of banks as to their commitment
(4.5%) in the minimum and (59.1%) in the to disclose segment information in the
maximum). However, the statistical results financial reports published in accordance
also showed that 18 banks, or about 90% with IFRS 8, to ensure the reliability of
of the sample size, had disclosed their their reports in the information provided by
segmental information by less than 40%. the financial reports.
The results also indicate that there are The researcher also recommends that
items that have not disclosed. These items establish training courses for specialists in
include income from transactions with the banks, especially those working in the field
same operating segments, income and of accounting segment financial reporting
expense items of relative importance by mechanisms and the necessary accounting
paragraph 97 of IAS 1, (Excluding information that must disclose in
depreciation and amortization), approved accordance with the requirements of IFRS
measurement basis, revenue from senior 8 to be able to present this vital
customers (if 10% of the bank’s revenues information accurately. The board of
exceed). accounting and auditing standards in Iraq
should issue a special accounting rule
The results of applying the provisions relating to the preparation of segmental
of the segmental information disclosure financial reports specifying the detailed
indicator showed that the minimum level requirements for the preparation of these
of disclosure, that disclosed the segmental reports in accordance with the
information for the item reached 50% for requirements of IFRS 8.
the items: interest income, interest
53
www.japmnt.com
(JPMNT) Journal of Process Management – New Technologies, International
Vol. 6, No 3, 2018.
54
www.japmnt.com
(JPMNT) Journal of Process Management – New Technologies, International
Vol. 6, No 3, 2018.
55
www.japmnt.com