Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Narrative Review
From: 1Li Ka Shing Knowledge Background: Pulsed radiofrequency (PRF) treatment uses low energy, short pulsations to
Institute, St. Michael’s Hospital,
modulate tissue characteristics. PRF treatment has been effective as an interventional pain
Unity Health Toronto, Toronto,
ON, Canada; 2Dept. of Physical management technique to treat a variety of chronic neuropathic pain (neuralgia) disorders,
Medicine and Rehabilitation, but a comprehensive review of its biological mechanism has not been updated in a decade.
University of Toronto, Toronto
Rehabilitation Institute, Toronto,
ON, Canada; 3Dept. of
Objectives: In this literature review, we performed a literature search in PubMed to identify
Anesthesiology, Toronto Western publications describing the mechanisms of action of pulsed radiofrequency for pain indications.
Hospital, University of Toronto,
Toronto, ON, Canada; 4Bloor Pain
Specialists, Toronto, ON,
Study Design: Narrative literature review.
Canada; 5Anesthesiology,
University of Wisconsin School of Methods: A systematic search was performed through PubMed from database inception to
Medicine and Public Health,
December 31, 2019, to identify all articles addressing the cellular or molecular mechanisms of
Madison, WI, USA; 6Dept. of
Anesthesiology, McMaster action of PRF on neuropathic pain. The search terms “pulsed radiofrequency” and “pulsed
University Health, Hamilton, ON, radiofrequency mechanisms” were used. Cellular and molecular mechanisms of PRF interventions
Canada, Spine Pain Program,
were subdivided into 3 broad categories: nociceptive signalling, immune activity, and synaptic
Bloor Pain Specialists, Toronto,
ON, Canada, Cleveland Clinic function. A total of 20 publications were identified for inclusion in this updated review.
Canada, Toronto, ON, Canada
Address Correspondence:
Results: It was found that pulsed radiofrequency impacts many different biological pathways
Ognjen Visnjevac, MD involved in the modulation of chronic neuropathic pain (neuralgia). With regards to nociceptive
Cleveland Clinic Canada signalling, PRF treatment modulates ion channels (Na/K ATPase, HCN, P2X3), CGRP,
181 Bay Street, Suite 3000
Toronto, ON, Canada, M5J 2T3
neurotransmitters (aspartate, citrulline, M-ENK, glutamate), postsynaptic receptors (AMPA-R,
E-mail: ovisnjevac@yahoo.com
GABA-B), and synaptic function (KCC2). PRF treatment also modulates immune activity,
including microglial markers (CD3, CD56, Iba1), inflammatory cytokines (IL-6, IL-17, IRF8,
Disclaimer: There was no IFN-γ, TNFα), and intracellular proteins implicated in immune mediated neuropathic pain
external funding in the
preparation of this manuscript. (BDNF, β-catenin, JNK, p38, ERK1/2).
Conflict of interest: Each author Limitations: This review is primarily limited by the diverse data sets that needed to be collated and
certifies that he or she, or a
member of his or her immediate
correlated, as no study was comprehensive in addressing all markers, cytokines, pathways,
family, has no commercial neurotransmitters, ion channels, proteins, genes, and gene expression changes, along with their
association (i.e., consultancies, clinical outcomes concurrently. As such, the interplay of these individual pathways and mechanisms
stock ownership, equity interest,
patent/licensing arrangements,
and their isolated effects on efficacy of PRF cannot be concluded. Rather, the large majority of
etc.) that might pose a conflict of findings can be seen as associations instead of definitive causal relationships to clinical outcomes.
interest in connection with the
submitted manuscript. Conclusions: Herein describes a clinically relevant collated update describing the cellular
Manuscript received: 07-16-2020 and molecular mechanisms of action of PRF for pain management.
Revised manuscript received:
07-27-2021 Key words: Biomarkers, chronic pain, cytokines, ganglia, hyperalgesia, immunomodulation,
Accepted for publication:
08-04-2021 neuralgia, neurotransmitter, nociceptors, pulsed radiofrequency treatment, receptors, spinal
www.painphysicianjournal.com
Pain Physician: December 2021 24:525-532
526 www.painphysicianjournal.com
Pulsed Radiofrequency Mechanisms of Action
synaptic end, glutamate levels were attenuated follow- compared to control. Upregulation of these inhibitory
ing PRF treatment in diabetic neuropathic pain rodent pathways by PRF treatment reversed mechanical allo-
models. Compared to sham treated rats, PRF treatment dynia in this model (23).
decreased heat hyperalgesia, mechanical hyperalgesia, In addition, PRF induces upregulation of met-
and cold allodynia (19). Attenuation of aspartate and enkephalin (M-ENK) concentrations in a SNI-model
citrulline (nitric oxide release marker) is also seen, (24). M-ENK is an endogenous opioid neurotransmitter
leading to relief of mechanical allodynia in complete that serves as an agonist for opioid receptors. Activa-
Freund’s adjuvant (CFA) inflammation induced rodents tion of these receptors by M-ENK reduces nociceptive
following PRF (20). Both glutamate and aspartate are stimulation at both pre- and post-synaptic neurons (25).
excitatory amino acids (EAA) and their inhibition by PRF M-ENK levels increased significantly following PRF
leads to decreased nerve cell polarization. treatment in SNI-models and their mechanical thresh-
In addition to attenuation of nociceptive signal old increased, as well (24).
propagation, enhancing inhibition pathways is another Together, the above evidence suggests PRF modu-
mechanism of action for PRF. Gamma-aminobutyric lates both excitatory and inhibitory neurotransmitter
acid B receptor 1 (GABA(B)-R1) and 5-hydroxytrypta- activity to decrease nociceptive signalling in neuro-
mine receptor 3a (5-HT3r) are G-protein coupled recep- pathic pain models.
tors and ligand-gated channels, respectively. GABA is
an inhibitory neurotransmitter. Binding of GABA to its Ion Channels
transmembrane receptor on the postsynaptic neu-ron Ion channels play a critical role in all signal propa-
hyperpolarizes the cell via calcium influx (21). In a gation within the CNS and peripheral nervous system
similar manner, binding of serotonin to 5-HT3r induces (PNS). The Na/K ATPase channel is widely distributed
hyperpolarization, and thus inhibits nociceptive signal across many cell types and plays an important role for
propagation (22). Both of these inhibitory receptors are action potential propagation in nociceptive signalling (26).
implicated in PRF’s mechanism of action. RT-qPCR of RT-qPCR of the dorsal root ganglion (DRG) and spi-nal
spared nerve injury (SNI) rat models treated with PRF cord in SNI rat models revealed downregulation of Na/K
revealed an upregulation of GABA(B)-R1 and 5-HT3r channels (23). This results in prolonged hyperac-
www.painphysicianjournal.com 527
Pain Physician: December 2021 24:525-532
528 www.painphysicianjournal.com
Pulsed Radiofrequency Mechanisms of Action
though there is no current evidence of PRF modulating growth factor 2 (IGF-2) has also been correlated with
IFN-α and IFN-β, it does appear to affect IRF8 activity. neuropathic pain. IGF-2 is an imprinted gene respon-
PRF on the DRG in SNI-rats attenuated IFR8 levels and sible for cellular proliferation, growth, and survival. In
improved mechanical allodynia, which is a commonly neurons, it has been reported to trigger inflammatory
reported outcome of IRF8 hyperactivity (38-40). pathways via ERK1/2 pathways (43). SNI-models had
Tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNFα) is a cytokine el-evated levels of IGF-2 compared to control.
widely distributed across the CNS and PNS. TNFα is Treatment of PRF reversed aberrant IGF-2 expression
up-regulated states of increased inflammation, including to relieve neuropathic pain. Interestingly, PRF has also
sepsis and nervous injury, and is responsible for trig- shown to inhibit ERK1/2 activation following SNI in this
gering caspases, which leads to apoptosis of neuronal pathway, resulting in greater reduction in allodynia in
cells resulting in increased neuropathic pain (41). Levels treatment groups compared to controls (43).
of TNFα is significantly upregulated in both DRG and
sciatic nerve of CCI models. Treatment of these models Intracellular Proteins
with PRF not only alleviated mechanical allodynia and Beta catenin (β-catenin) is an intracellular protein
thermal hyperalgesia, but also decreased TNFα levels in that plays a key role in the canonical/non-canonical
both DRG and sciatic nerve (42,43). Evidence suggests WNT signalling pathway, which leads to the down-
that part of PRF’s mechanism of action is by downregu- stream transcription of inflammatory cytokines IL-18,
lating key inflammatory cytokines including TNFα. TNFα, and glutamate receptors in the spinal cord (44).
Aside from inflammatory cytokines, insulin-like In CCI models, β-catenin levels were elevated, identi-
www.painphysicianjournal.com 529
Pain Physician: December 2021 24:525-532
fying a correlation with neuropathic pain. β-catenin nique used for treating chronic neuropathic pain. There
levels decreased significantly following PRF treatment are several studies that evaluated and proved the
to the DRG and sciatic nerve compared to sham (45). efficacy of PRF in treating different pain conditions. The
PRF also modulates c-Jun N-terminal kinases exact mechanism of action is still unclear.
(JNK) to reduce neuroinflammation in the DRG. Similar Herein, we provided a comprehensive literature re-
to β-catenin, JNKs trigger gene expression to regulate view evaluating the cellular and molecular mechanisms
neuronal plasticity and inflammation. Translocation of underlying PRF mechanisms of action for modulating
activated JNKs into the nucleus leads to transcription of and reducing chronic neuropathic pain. PRF modulates
TNFα and IL-1B (46). PRF appears to inhibit JNK in many different pathways involved in nociceptive sig-
CFA-induced hyperalgesia models, correlating with im- naling, immune activity, and synaptic function, which,
provements in mechanical hyperalgesia (47). individually and in concert, are thought to pathologi-cally
The mitogen activated kinase (MAPK) pathway is result in chronic neuropathic pain.
another well-studied pathway that is implicated in This review is primarily limited by the diverse data
neuropathic pain and modulated by PRF. P-p38 is the sets that needed to be collated and correlated, as no
phosphorylated form of p38, which is a type of MAPK. study was comprehensive in addressing all markers,
This kinase’s aberrant activity results in hypersensitivity cytokines, pathways, neurotransmitters, ion channels,
after nerve injury by evoking P2X4R and brain-derived proteins, genes, and gene expression changes, along
neurotrophic factors (BDNF) activity from microglia (4). with their clinical outcomes concurrently. As such, the
Following PRF treatment in the DRG of CCI-induced interplay of these individual pathways and mechanisms
rodents, microglial activity and p-p38 levels decreased and their isolated effects on efficacy of PRF cannot be
in the spinal cord (40). concluded. Rather, the large majority of findings can be
Furthermore, BDNF and its upstream activator seen as associations instead of definitive causal rela-
phosphoinositide-3 kinase (PI3K) was also found to be tionships to clinical outcomes. Furthermore, limitations
modulated by PRF. BDNF has roles in inducing neural of individual studies also carry through to this review.
hypersensitivity, in addition to nerve growth and Moreover, not all PRF is the same. With different pa-
inflammation-induced pain. BDNF binding to TrkB re- rameters (frequency, pulse width, temperature, time,
ceptors triggers downstream increases in intracellular cannula and active tip size) variably utilized from study
chloride, suppression of GABA-A inhibition, and thus to study, it is possible that some of the tissue effects
depolarization with subsequent allodynia (5). PRF to the and mechanisms of action varied with changes in pa-
DRG inhibited SNI-induced BDNF upregulation and rameter, not only based on parameters as a whole, but
partially reversed allodynia in rodents (48). for different sets of parameters in different tissue types
(i.e., sympathetic ganglia, peripheral nerves, DRG) and
Synaptic Function different species (i.e., humans versus rodents). The
As previously discussed, GABA plays an inhibitory multitude of potential parameters and their effects on
role in nociceptive signalling and PRF acts to directly different nerve tissue types remains to be studied to
enhance this inhibition, but PRF may also enhance further subclassify the mechanism of action for various
nociceptive inhibition by altering epigenetic profiles of sets of PRF parameters. Lastly, the majority of studies
nerve cells. In CFA rodents, it was found that his-tone were performed in rodents which, while use-ful in the
subunits H3/H4 are hypoacetylated, resulting in identification and evaluation of cellular and molecular
decreased expression of K-Cl-Cotransporter-2 (KCC2) mechanisms, may or may not be translatable to human
(49). KCC2 maintains intracellular chloride gradients, neuropathic pain pathophysiology and the human
which is essential for GABA-ergic and glycinergic trans- response to PRF therapy. Further investigation is
missions (5). PRF in the DRG appears to restore warranted to fully elucidate the direct mechanisms of
histone acetylation of H3/H4 and increase expression of action of PRF for treatment of neuropathic pain in
KCC2 to enhance GABA-mediated nociceptive humans.
inhibition, resulting in attenuation of sensitized pain
behaviour in these rodents (49).
Conclusion
While clinical outcomes and indications for PRF
Discussion have been described previously, this review describes
PRF is an interventional pain management tech- cellular and molecular mechanisms of action of PRF as
530 www.painphysicianjournal.com
Pulsed Radiofrequency Mechanisms of Action
an update to the known literature. PRF continues to be pain with a growing body of cellular and molecular data
an increasingly popular interventional pain manage- describing its mechanisms of action.
ment technique used for treating chronic neuropathic
References
1. Schopflocher D, Taenzer P, and Physician 2014; 17:477-486. radiofrequency treatment attenuates
Jovey R. The prevalence of chronic pain 11. Eyigor C, Eyigor S, Korkmaz OK, Uyar increases in spinal excitatory amino
in Canada. Pain Res Manag 2011; M. Intra-articular corticosteroid injections acid release in rats with adjuvant-
16:445-450. versus pulsed radiofrequency in painful induced mechanical allodynia.
2. Institute of Medicine (US) Committee on shoulder: A prospective, randomized, single- Neuroreport 2013; 24:431-436.
Advancing Pain Research, C., and Education. , blinded study. Clin J Pain 2010; 26:386-392. 21. Wu C and Sun D. GABA receptors in
Summary, in Relieving Pain in America: A 12. Teixeira A and Sluijter ME. Intradiscal brain development, function, and injury. Metab
Blueprint for Transforming Prevention, Care, high-voltage, long-duration pulsed Brain Dis 2015; 30:367-379.
Education, and Research. 2011: Washington (DC). radiofrequency for discogenic pain: 22. Nasirinezhad F, Hosseini M, Karami Z,
p. 1-17. A preliminary report. Pain Med Yousefifard M, and Janzadeh A. Spinal 5-HT3
3. Scholz J, Finnerup NB, Attal N, et 2006; 7:424-428. receptor mediates nociceptive effect on central
al. Classification Committee of the 13. Chua NH, Vissers KC, and Sluijter neuropathic pain; possible therapeutic role for
Neuropathic Pain Special Interest, The ME. Pulsed radiofrequency treatment in tropisetron. J Spinal Cord Med 2016; 39:212-
IASP classification of chronic pain for interventional pain management: 219.
ICD-11: chronic neuropathic pain. Pain Mechanisms and potential indications-a 23. Vallejo R, Tilley DM, Williams J, Labak S,
2019; 160:53-59. review. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 2011; Aliaga L, and Benyamin RM. Pulsed
4. Ji RR, Nackley A, Huh Y, Terrando 153:763-771. radiofrequency modulates pain
N, MaixnerW. Neuroinflammation and 14. Cedeno DL, Vallejo A, Kelley CA, Tilley regulatory gene expression along
central sensitization in chronic and DM, and Kumar N. Comparisons of lesion the nociceptive pathway. Pain
widespread pain. Anesthesiology 2018; volumes and shapes produced by a Physician 2013; 16:E601-613.
29:343-366. radiofrequency system with a cooled, a 24. Wu B, Ni J, Zhang C, Fu P, Yue J, and
5. Basbaum AI, Bautista DM, Scherrer protruding, or a monopolar probe. Pain Yang L. Changes in spinal cord met-
G, Julius D, Cellular and molecular Physician 2017; 20:E915-E922. enkephalin levels and mechanical threshold
mechanisms of pain. Cell 2009; 139:267- 15. Visnjevac O, Ma F, and Abd-Elsayed values of pain after pulsed radio frequency in a
284. A. A literature review of dorsal root entry spared nerve injury rat model. Neurol Res
6. Cavalli E, Mammana S, Nicoletti F, zone complex (DREZC) lesions: 2012; 34:408-414.
Bramanti P, Mazzon E. The neuropathic pain: Integration of translational data for 25. Henry MS, Gendron L, Tremblay
An overview of the current treatment and future an evolution to more accurate ME, and Drolet G. Enkephalins:
therapeutic approaches. Int J Immunopathol nomenclature. Journal of Pain Endogenous analgesics with an
Pharmacol 2019; 33:2058738419838383. Research 2021; 14:1. emerging role in stress resilience. Neural
7. Mekhail N, Visnjevac O, Azer G, 16. Chang MC. Efficacy of pulsed Plast 2017; 2017:1546125.
Mehanny DS, Agrawal P, Foorsov V. radiofrequency stimulation in patients 26. Tsantoulas C and McMahon SB.
Spinal cord stimulation 50 years later: with peripheral neuropathic pain: A Opening paths to novel analgesics: the role of
clinical outcomes of spinal cord narrative review. Pain Physician 2018; potassium channels in chronic pain. Trends
stimulation based on randomized 21:E225-E234. Neurosci 2014; 37:146-158.
clinical trials-A systematic review. Reg 17. Chater TE and Goda Y. The role of 27. Ramirez D, Zuniga R, Concha G,
Anesth Pain Med 2018; 43:391-406. AMPA receptors in postsynaptic and Zuniga L. HCN Channels: New
8. Ke M, Yinghui F, Yi J, et al. Efficacy of mechanisms of synaptic plasticity. Front therapeutic targets for pain treatment.
pulsed radiofrequency in the treatment of Cell Neurosci 2014; 8:401. Molecules 2018; 23(9).
thoracic postherpetic neuralgia from the 18. Cho JH and Lee DG. Translocation of 28. Liu Y, Feng Y, and Zhang T. Pulsed
angulus costae: A randomized, double- AMPA receptors in the dorsal horn of the radiofrequency treatment enhances
blinded, controlled trial. Pain Physician spinal cord corresponding to long-term dorsal root ganglion expression of
2013; 16:15-25. depression following pulsed radiofrequency hyperpolarization-activated cyclic
9. Ding Y, Hong T, Li H, Yao P, Zhao stimulation at the dorsal root ganglion. Pain nucleotide-gated channels in a rat
G. Efficacy of CT guided pulsed Med, 2019. model of neuropathic pain. J Mol
radiofrequency treatment for trigeminal 19. Huang YH, Hou SY, Cheng JK, Wu CH, Neurosci 2015; 57:97-105.
postherpetic neuralgia. Front Neurosci and Lin CR. Pulsed radiofrequency attenuates 29. Fu M, Meng L, Ren H, and Luo F. Pulsed
2019; 13:708. diabetic neuropathic pain and suppresses radiofrequency inhibits expression
10. Vigneri S, Sindaco G, Gallo G, et al. formalin-evoked spinal glutamate release in of P2X3 receptors and alleviates
Effectiveness of pulsed radiofrequency with rats. Int J Med Sci 2016; 13:984-991. neuropathic pain induced by chronic
multifunctional epidural electrode in chronic 20. Yang CH, Chen KH, Huang HW, constriction injury in rats. Chin Med
lumbosacral radicular pain with neuropathic Sheen-Chen SM, and Lin CR. Pulsed J (Engl) 2019; 132:1706-1712.
features. Pain 30. Cho HK, Kang JH, Kim SY, et al. Changes in
neuroglial activity in multiple spinal
www.painphysicianjournal.com 531
Pain Physician: December 2021 24:525-532
segments after caudal epidural pulsed Behav Immun 2018; 70:157-165. pulsed radiofrequency modulation through
radiofrequency in a rat model of 37. Tsuda M, Masuda T, Kitano J, down-regulation of insulin-like growth factor
lumbar disc herniation. Pain Physician Shimoyama H, Tozaki-Saitoh H, Inoue K. 2 in a neuropathic pain model. Int J Mol Sci
2016; 19:E1197-E1209. IFN-gamma receptor signaling mediates 2015; 16:27156-27170.
31. Ren H, Jin H, Jia Z, Ji N, and Luo F. spinal microglia activation driving 44. Zhang YK, Huang ZJ, Liu S, Liu YP,
Pulsed radiofrequency applied to the sciatic neuropathic pain. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA Song AA, Song XJ. WNT signaling
nerve improves neuropathic pain by down- 2009; 106:8032-8037. underlies the pathogenesis of
regulating the expression of calcitonin gene- 38. Tsuda M. Microglia in the spinal neuropathic pain in rodents. J Clin Invest
related peptide in the dorsal root ganglion. cord and neuropathic pain. J Diabetes 2013; 123:2268-2286.
Int J Med Sci 2018; 15:153-160. Investig 2016; 7:17-26. 45. Jiang R, Li P, Yao YX, et al. Pulsed
32. Park HW, Ahn SH, Son JY, et al. Pulsed 39. Fang X, Xu X, Lin X, Liu R. radiofrequency to the dorsal root ganglion or
radiofrequency application reduced mechanical Downregulated spinal IRF8 and BDNF the sciatic nerve reduces neuropathic pain
hypersensitivity and microglial expression in in NAC are involved in neuropathic behavior, decreases peripheral pro-
neuropathic pain model. Pain Med 2012; pain-induced depression relief via inflammatory cytokines and spinal beta-
13:1227-1234. pulsed radiofrequency on dorsal catenin in chronic constriction injury rats.
33. Luo, H, Liu HZ, Zhang WW, et al. root ganglion in rat SNI model. Reg Anesth Pain Med 2019.
Interleukin-17 regulates neuron- Brain Res Bull 2019; 146:192-200. 46. GaoYJ and Ji RR. Activation of JNK
glial communications, synaptic 40. Liu R, Xu X, Xu Y, Fang X, Lin X. pathway in persistent pain. Neurosci Lett
transmission, and neuropathic pain Pulsed radiofrequency on dorsal root 2008; 437:180-183.
after chemotherapy. Cell Rep 2019; ganglion relieved neuropathic pain 47. Chen KH, Yang CH, Juang SE, et al.
29:2384-2397 e2385. associated with downregulation of the Pulsed radiofrequency reduced complete
34. Ramzy EA, Khalil KI, Nour EM, spinal interferon regulatory Factor 8, Freund’s adjuvant-induced mechanical
Hamed MF, Taha MA. Evaluation of the microglia, p38MAPK expression in a CCI hyperalgesia via the spinal c-Jun N-terminal
effect of duration on the efficacy of rat model. Pain Physician 2018; kinase pathway. Cell Mol Neurobiol 2014;
pulsed radiofrequency in an animal 21:E307-E322. 34:195-203.
model of neuropathic pain. Pain 41. Sekiguchi M, Sekiguchi Y, Konno S, 48. Xu X, Fu S, Shi X, Liu R. Microglial BDNF,
Physician 2018; 21:191-198. Kobayashi H, Homma Y, Kikuchi S. PI3K, and p-ERK in the spinal cord are suppressed
35. Zhou YQ, Liu Z, Liu ZH, et al. Comparison of neuropathic pain and by pulsed radiofrequency on dorsal root ganglion to
Interleukin-6: An emerging regulator of neuronal apoptosis following nerve root ease SNI-induced neuropathic pain in rats. Pain
pathological pain. J Neuroinflammation or spinal nerve compression. Eur Spine J Res Manag 2019; 2019:5948686.
2016; 13:141. 2009; 18:1978-1985. 49. Liu CK, Liao WT, Chu YC, et al.
36. Das B, Conroy M, Moore D, Lysaght J, 42. Lee JB, Byun JH, Choi IS, Kim Y, Lee Pulsed radiofrequency attenuates complete
McCrory C. Human dorsal root ganglion pulsed JS. The effect of pulsed radiofrequency applied freund’s adjuvant-induced epigenetic
radiofrequency treatment modulates to the peripheral nerve in chronic constriction suppression of potassium chloride
cerebrospinal fluid lymphocytes and injury rat model. Ann Rehabil Med 2015; cotransporter 2 expression. Pain Med 2017;
neuroinflammatory markers in chronic radicular 39:667-675. 18:807-813.
pain. Brain 43. Yeh CC, Sun HL, Huang CJ. Long-
term anti-allodynic effect of immediate
532 www.painphysicianjournal.com