Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
This study was a randomised clinical trial on 60 candidates undergoing lumbar disc herniation surgery. Anxiety rate and
vital signs were measured before and after the intervention. There was a statistically significant difference between the
two groups in terms of the preoperative anxiety, systolic and diastolic blood pressure, pulse and respiratory rate
(P ¼ 0.0001). Neurosurgery perioperative nurses can make use of multimedia in preoperative nursing visit based on the
needs of patients.
Keywords
Preoperative anxiety/Lumbar disc herniation/Vital signs/Nursing visit/Multimedia
Provenance and Peer review: Unsolicited contribution; Peer reviewed; Accepted for publication 20 June 2017.
2005, Mavridou et al 2013, Ali et al 2014). Preoperative materials in different formats and from different
anxiety begins when the patient receives notification perspectives for patients (Wiljer & Catton 2003).
that surgery is required, it is increased during the
hospitalization, and reaches its peak prior to anesthesia To sum up, as preoperative anxiety can lead to
(Nourian et al 2014). complications, it is essential to reduce preoperative
anxiety and educate patients. This study was conducted
High preoperative anxiety could slow down the to determine the effectiveness of a multimedia-based
postoperative recovery process (Kraskian 2010, Duthey nursing visit on preoperative anxiety and vital signs in
2013). A high level of anxiety preoperatively is followed patients undergoing spinal disc herniation surgery.
by high incidence of postoperative pain (Laufenberg-
Feldmann et al 2016), reduced ability to resist infection, Methods
increased use of analgesics after surgery, delayed
wound healing (Britteon et al 2017), negative effects on This study was a randomised clinical trial (RCT) with two
patient's mood and prolonged hospitalization (Rasouli et groups. The RCT is an experimental study in which
al 2016). participants are randomly assigned to treatment groups
(intervention and control groups); it aims to determine
Since nurses spend more time with patients in the whether a clinical intervention is effective under optimal
clinical environment than other members of the medical circumstances (James et al 2015). The study was
team, and also have more interaction with patients, they approved by the Student Research Committee and
play a crucial role in relieving anxiety (Zakerimoghadam Research Council of Kurdistan University of Medical
et al 2010). Several studies have shown that giving Sciences No 1395.132 and has been registered at
information and education leads to the increased Iranian Registry of Clinical Trial
(IRCT2016051627927N1).
understanding of clinical interventions by patients and
thus reduces anxiety (Jlala et al 2010, Parveen et al
Subjects included patients who were candidates for non-
2016). A nursing visit includes assessing a patient's
emergency lumbar disc herniation surgery. The inclusion
condition, charting the observations, performing
criteria were:
evaluation tasks, listening to the patient and responding
to concerns or requests, and providing care that is
• voluntary participation in the study
accompanied with patient education (Sadati et al 2013,
• elective surgery
Fortacín et al 2015). Studies have found that holding an • surgery under general or spinal anesthesia
education class for patients before spinal surgery • lack of history of diseases such as hypertension, vas-
enhances satisfaction and improves control of pain in cular diseases, thyroid diseases, rheumatoid arthritis,
these patients (Papanastassiou et al 2011). Also, an lumbar trauma, fever, lack of history of mental dis-
educational program with the use of a compact disc (CD) eases or taking antidepressants
which contains video and images about the process of • no previous experience of surgery, and
pre and postoperative care before the spinal surgery can • 18 to 65 years of age.
reduce the state of anxiety, as the experience of
unpleasant feelings when confronted with specific The exclusion criteria included:
situations, demands or a particular object or event can
improve self-care (Cho & Chun 2015). • patients taking medications affecting anxiety such as
alprazolam, oxazepam, chlordiazepoxide and diaze-
Multimedia education can be defined as using basic pam (24 hours before the intervention until re-
types of media material like text, video, sound, graphics measurement of anxiety and vital signs) and
and animation and incorporating this approach into a • patients withdrawal from continuing to participate in
learning environment (Raymond 2016). Multimedia the study.
education provides a relatively cost-effective, time-
saving, user-friendly and easy to reach strategies in The research environment was the neurosurgery ward of
patient and caregiver education (Lam et al 2016). Today, Besat Hospital in Sanandaj, Iran.
multimedia sources of information like videos, audio,
and pictures are combined in preoperative education Based on the sample size formula as well as previous
strategies (Raymond 2016). Using multimedia assists studies (Sadati et al 2013, Valiee et al 2012), the
educators in overcoming linguistic, physical and cultural sample size for each group was calculated as n=30 for
barriers and in addressing different learning needs. It each group. Seventy seven patients were assessed for
also provides unique experiences in presenting eligibility and 17 excluded for not meeting the inclusion
Zarei et al. 9
criteria or for declining to participate. None of subjects thermometers (Infrared Ear Thermometer, CuraplexV
R)
left the study after randomization (Figure 1). was used to measure body temperature. All
measurements were performed by one person.
Measuring tools Before the data collections, investigator triangulation
Data collection tools in this study included a three-part was used to confirm the reliability of measurement of
data recording: vital signs and preoperative anxiety by the researcher.
Thus, after the measurement by one of the researchers,
• form containing demographic data a follow-up measurement was done by a nurse using the
• form including clinical data and same protocol to be sure of the correct method of
• the Spielberger State Anxiety Inventory (1983). measurements. To determine the validity of the
instrument to measure blood pressure an analog
The Spielberger State Anxiety inventory included 20 manometer (ALPK2 model: No 300-VS; Tanaka Sangyo
likert items. The minimum earned point (20) means the Co Ltd) was used for all the research units after being
absence of anxiety and the maximum point (80) calibrated. Anxiety and vital signs were measured at
means the highest rate of anxiety. The validity and 7.00pm one day before the surgery; these readings were
reliability of this questionnaire has been examined the 'before the intervention' score or baseline. Anxiety
in Iran (Mahram 1993). The validity of the test has been and vital signs were measured before the transfer to the
confirmed through concurrent validity (Kraskian 2010). operating room as 'after the intervention' score.
Excluded (n=17)
♦ Not meeting inclusion criteria (n=10)
♦ Declined to participate (n=5)
♦ Other reasons (n=2)
Randomized (n=60)
Allocation
Allocated to intervention (n=30) Allocated to intervention (n=30)
♦ Received allocated intervention (n=30) ♦ Received allocated intervention (n=30)
♦ Did not receive allocated intervention (give ♦ Did not receive allocated intervention (give
reasons) (n=0) reasons) (n=0)
Follow-Up
Lost to follow-up (give reasons) (n=0) Lost to follow-up (give reasons) (n=0)
Discontinued intervention (give reasons) (n=0) Discontinued intervention (give reasons) (n=0)
Analysis
Analysed (n=30) Analysed (n=30)
♦ Excluded from analysis (give reasons) (n=0) ♦ Excluded from analysis (give reasons) (n=0)
BOX 1. Multimedia based nursing visit steps taken in the intervention group
interview. After explaining the purpose of the study and played on a tablet of the neurosurgeon doctors talk-
obtaining their written consent, the patients were ing about lumbar disc herniation surgery, as well as
randomly allocated to either the intervention or control the three video clips of several patients who had
group by tossing a coin; the side of the coin (ie heads - undergone surgery and had recovered. Finally, a pam-
control, tails - intervention) determined the assignment phlet about lumbar disc herniation surgery was
of each subject. The tossing a coin is the most common shown.
and basic method of simple randomization. This • In the second step, some information regarding trans-
randomization method is easy and simple to implement fer to the operating theatre, its physical environment
in clinical research (Suresh 2011). and waiting room, instruments and equipment avail-
able in the operating theatre, and explanations about
The anxiety and vital signs (systolic and diastolic blood the surgical and anesthesia team were provided.
pressure, pulse rate, respiratory rate, and body Information regarding what was expected of the
temperature) of the two groups were measured and patient before and during general or spinal anesthe-
recorded. All patients were admitted to the ward at sia and how to participate, measures taken in the
5.00pm one day before surgery. The levels of cortisol recovery and how the patient is transferred were pre-
increase in evening (Gonzalez et al 2017) and there is a sented; at the same time, ten pictures taken from the
greater level of cortisol in patients with elevated anxiety surgery room and the instruments used there were
(Yilmaz et al 2012). Thus, to control for the confounding displayed via the tablet.
effect of this change and to have enough time for • In the third phase, pamphlets and photographs were
intervention and to measure variables at the same time used to educate patients about postoperative care,
for all subjects, variables were measured at 7.00pm one both in the ward and at home, such as how to
day before the surgery. Afterwards the control group change dressing and bandages and how to walk.
received the routine care and the intervention group • In the fourth step, any questions and uncertainties of
received multimedia-based nursing visit (Box 1). the patients in various fields relating to disease and
surgery process that were not referred to by the
The multimedia-based nursing visit in the intervention researcher in nursing visit, were answered.
group included a 30-to-50 minute visit at the patient's
bedside by the researcher in four steps. Patients in the control group received only the
routine preoperative information given by the ward
• The first step included providing information about nurses (removal of hair from the wound site by
herniated intervertebral disc, the causes of the dis- electric clippers (National Collaborating Centre for
eases, critical preoperative care, removal of accesso- Women's and Children's Health 2008), eating nothing by
ries and denture on the operation day before mouth before surgery (Brown and Heuberger 2014), and
transferring to the operating room, different ways of specific information regarding postoperative
treatment including surgery. Then a video clip was complications such as bleeding, pain and drains at
Zarei et al. 11
Intervention Control
the incision site, time of dressing change and time to to the participants that they could leave the study
walk after surgery. whenever they wanted to.
Results
Statistical methods
The information obtained from the 60 patients was
The demographic characteristics of the two groups were
analysed. Statistical tests showed that there was no
compared using statistical chi-square test, and the
significant relationship between the intervention (n=30)
independent t-test was used for the age. The
and control groups (n=30) in terms of demographic
Kolmogorov-Smirnov test was used to determine the
variables; the two groups were homogeneous in this
normal distribution of variables and to decide whether to
respect (Table 1).
use a parametric or nonparametric test. To compare the
rate of anxiety and vital signs in the two groups at The results showed that before the intervention, the
different times Mann-Whitney test was used (Corder and mean anxiety in patients in the intervention group was
Foreman 2011). 50.93 10.41 and in the control group it was 48.06
10.95 (p ¼ 0.4). After the intervention, the mean
anxiety for the intervention group and control group was
Ethical considerations 37.83 7.20 and 53 10.29 respectively (p ¼ 0.0001)
This study is the result of a master’s degree dissertation which indicated a significant statistical difference after
funded by the Council of Kurdistan University of Medical intervention in the intervention group. Moreover, there
Sciences. The study was approved by the Ethics was a significant difference in the anxiety rate before
Committee of Kurdistan University of Medical Sciences and after intervention in the control group (p ¼ 0.0001).
IR.MUK.REC.1395.132. Ethical considerations in the
research included getting permission from the subjects, There was a significant difference in the systolic and
explaining the objectives and nature of the research, diastolic blood pressure rate in the intervention group
getting written consent and inviting them to participate before and after intervention (p ¼ 0.0001). Moreover,
in the research, and ensuring them that obtained there was a significant difference in the systolic and
information would remain confidential. It was explained diastolic blood pressure rate before and after intervention
12 Journal of Perioperative Practice 28(1 & 2)
Table 2 Comparison of preoperative anxiety and vital signs intra and between groups
Group
Variable Intervention Control p
in the control group (p ¼ 0.0001). There was not a al 2015). A preoperative visit by an anesthesiologist, a
statistically significant difference in the systolic (p ¼ 0.1) recovery nurse or a theatre nurse can reduce
and diastolic blood pressure (p ¼ 0.14) rate before the preoperative anxiety in patients (Sadati et al 2013). In
intervention between the two groups. But there was a the present study, a multimedia-based nursing visit
statistically significant difference in the systolic reduced preoperative anxiety. This reduction in anxiety
(p ¼ 0.0001) and diastolic blood pressure (p ¼ 0.0001) could result from the nurse interacting directly with the
rate after the intervention between the two groups. patient, giving information, creating a secure
environment, providing an opportunity to express
There was a significant difference between the pulse uncertainties, and responding to the patient.
rate (p ¼ 0.0001) and respiratory rate (p ¼ 0.002)
before and after intervention in the intervention group. According to the obtained results, the rate of anxiety
Also, there was significant difference between pulse rate before and after intervention was significantly different
(p ¼ 0.001) and respiratory rate (p ¼ 0.003) before and in the control group, but the rate of anxiety had
after intervention in the control group. Body temperature increased on the operation day. An increase in anxiety in
before and after intervention in the intervention group the patients of the control group has been reported in
(p ¼ 0.62) and control group (p ¼ 0.055) did not show a other studies (Fortacín et al 2015, Mousavi et al 2011,
significant difference (Table 2) (Figure 2). Valiee et al 2012, Sadati et al 2013). In the present
study the increase could be due to different reasons
such as the lack of receiving adequate education and
Discussion awareness on the process of surgery and anesthesia as
The results of this study showed that anxiety of patients well as patients having various questions and
before lumbar disc herniation surgery was reduced after uncertainties about postoperative steps and expected
the multimedia-based nursing visit. The results of surgery complications.
previous studies have shown that a nursing visit reduces
preoperative anxiety and postoperative complications According to the existing difference in anxiety scores
(Fortacín et al 2015, Sadati et al 2013). In another after intervention, in both intervention and control
research study, preoperative anxiety reduced after a groups, and the increase of anxiety rate in the control
photographic display with music (Gómez-Urquiza et al group, it can be said that in the present study, the
2016), a nursing visit (Sadati et al 2013) and a multimedia-based nursing visit to patients before lumbar
preoperative visit and face to face education (Fortacín et disc herniation surgery has led to a reduction of
Zarei et al. 13
Figure 2 Changes of variables before and after intervention in intervention and control groups
preoperative anxiety. A multimedia-based nursing visit anxiety in the intervention group, it can ultimately lead to
provides the opportunity for the patients to raise any the reduction of vital signs such as blood pressure in
questions and disturbing subjects that the researcher this group of patients by reducing the stimulation of the
has not properly referred to during the nursing visit. On sympathetic system. However, since there was no
the other hand, through face to face contact with intervention in the control group and the rate of
patients, nurses can also ensure patients' preoperative anxiety had increased, it could increase
understanding and perceive the reflection of their systolic blood pressure in patients by stimulating the
preoperative education. sympathetic system.
Blood pressure
Respiratory rate
In the present study, as in other studies (Valiee et al
2012, Gómez-Urquiza et al 2016), after the intervention Considering the respiratory rate, the results showed that
the rate of systolic and diastolic blood pressure after intervention the respiratory rate significantly
significantly decreased in the intervention group and decreased from16.73 1.33 to 15.46 1.56 in the
increased in the control group. The effect of anxiety on intervention group, while it significantly increased in the
the sympathetic nervous system and the ensuing control group from 16.33 1.97 to 17.40 1.83. In
changes in vital signs can be referred to as the reasons another study, the patients' respiratory rate had
for systolic decrease in the intervention group and its decreased significantly in the intervention group after
increase in the control group. Following the emergence intervention (Gómez-Urquiza et al 2016).
of anxiety, the rate of blood catecholamine and
consequently the body's need for oxygen will increase, The increase of respiratory rate after intervention in the
and this will affect and increase the rate of the cardiac control group can be due to the effect of preoperative
output and blood pressure (McRee et al 2003). anxiety on the increase of adrenocorticoids and
epinephrine and consequently, the increase in
Anxiety stimulates the sympathetic system response and respiratory rate (McRee et al 2003). The reduction of
thus causes tachycardia, hypertension, and anxiety in the intervention group due to the nursing visit
vasoconstriction (Barker et al 2006). In the present is one of the reasons for the reduction of respiratory rate
study, the intervention led to reduction of preoperative in patients.
14 Journal of Perioperative Practice 28(1 & 2)
Gonzalez RE, Lamy O, Stoll D et al 2017 High evening cortisol level treatment of surgical site infection London, National
is associated with low Tbs and increased prevalent vertebral Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence
fractures: Osteolaus study Journal Of Clinical Endocrinology Nourian M, Jalaledinee A, Saatchi K et al 2014 Effects of
and Metabolism doi: 10.1210/jc.2016-3804 stroke massage using sesame oil on hospitalization anxiety
Hong J, Reed C, Novick D, Happich M 2013 Costs associated in school-age girls Modern Care Journal 10 210–18
with treatment of chronic low back pain: An analysis of the Padmanabhan R, Hildreth AJ, Laws D 2005 A prospective,
UK general practice research database Spine 38 75–82 randomised, controlled study examining binaural beat
Hoy D, Bain C, Williams G et al 2012 A systematic review of the audio and preoperative anxiety in patients undergoing
global prevalence of low back pain Arthritis and general anaesthesia for day case surgery Anaesthesia 60
Rheumatology 64 2028–37 874–77
Hoy D, March L, Brooks P et al 2010 Measuring the global Papanastassiou I, Anderson R, Barber N et al 2011 Effects of
burden of low back pain Best Practice and Research preoperative education on spinal surgery patients SAS
Clinical Rheumatology 24 155–65 Journal 5 120–24
James S, Rao SV, Granger CB 2015 Registry-based randomized Parveen A, Ellahi R, Sultana S, Tahir M 2016 Effect of
clinical trials: A new clinical trial paradigm Nature Reviews preoperative education on level of anxiety in patients
Cardiology 12 312-16 undergoing cataract surgery Journal of Islamabad Medical
Jlala H, French J, Foxall G et al 2010 Effect of preoperative and Dental College 5 192–94
multimedia information on perioperative anxiety in patients Rasouli MR, Menendez ME, Sayadipour A 2016 Direct cost and
undergoing procedures under regional anaesthesia British complications associated with total joint arthroplasty in
Journal of Anaesthesia 104 369–74 patients with preoperative anxiety and depression Journal
Kraskian A 2010 State-trait anxiety inventory Roshd Moshaver of Arthroplasty 31 533–36
Madreseh 22 58–59 Raymond YK 2016 An evidence-based guideline for
Lam M, Choi M, Lam HR et al 2016 Use of multimedia in preoperative nursing education to alleviate postoperative
pain among patients undergoing video-assisted thoracic
patient and caregiver education for cancer pain
surgery Degree of Master of Nursing, University of Hong
management: a literature review Annals of Palliative
Kong
Medicine 6 66–72
Sadati L, Pazouki A, Mehdizadeh A et al 2013 Effect of
Laufenberg-Feldmann R, Kappis B, Schuster M, Ferner M 2016
preoperative nursing visit on preoperative anxiety and
Relevance of preoperative anxiety for postoperative
postoperative complications in candidates for laparoscopic
outcome in urological surgery patients: A prospective
cholecystectomy: a randomized clinical trial Scandinavian
observational study Schmerz 30 166–73
Journal of Caring Sciences 27 994–98
Ma VY, Chan L, Carruthers KJ 2014 Incidence, prevalence,
Spielberger CD, Gorsuch RL, Lushene R, Vagg PR, Jacobs GA
costs and impact on disability of common conditions 1983 Manual for the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory Palo Alto
requiring rehabilitation in the United States: Stroke, spinal CA Consulting Psychologists Press
cord injury, traumatic brain injury, multiple sclerosis, Suresh KP 2011 An overview of randomization techniques: An
osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis, limb loss and back pain unbiased assessment of outcome in clinical research
Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 95 Journal of Human Reproductive Sciences 4 8–11
986–95 Tan TC, Black PM 2002 Sir Victor Horsley (1857–1916):
Mahram B 1993 Manual of Spielberger state-trait anxiety Pioneer of neurological surgery Neurosurgery 50 607–12
inventory Master of Science dissertation Ferdowsi Valiee S, Bassampour SS, Nasrabadi AN et al 2012 Effect of
University of Mashhad acupressure on preoperative anxiety: a clinical trial Journal
Mavridou P, Dimitriou V, Manataki A et al 2013 Patient's of PeriAnesthesia Nursing 27 259–66
anxiety and fear of anesthesia: Effect of gender, age, Wiljer D, Catton P 2003 Multimedia formats for patient
education and previous experience of anesthesia. A survey education and health communication: Does user
of 400 patients Journal of Anesthesia 27 104–08 preference matter? Journal of Medical Internet Research 5
Mcree LD, Noble S, Pasvogel A 2003 Using massage and e19
music therapy to improve postoperative outcomes AORN Yilmaz M, Sezer H, Gürler H, Bekar M 2012 Predictors of
Journal 78 433–47 preoperative anxiety in surgical inpatients Journal of
Mousavi SJ, Akbari ME, Mehdian H et al 2011 Low back pain in Clinical Nursing 21 956–64
Iran: a growing need to adapt and implement evidence- Zakerimoghadam M, Aliasgharpoor M, Mehran A, Mohammadi
based practice in developing countries Spine 36 E638–46 S 2010 Effect of patient education about pain control on
National Collaborating Centre for Women's and Children's patients' anxiety prior to abdominal surgery Hayat 15
Health 2008 Surgical site infection: Prevention and 13–22