Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Adaptation Theories
“Re-Evaluating Fidelity: Film Adaptation Meaning of Literature in Film Review
in the Language Arts Classroom” of
Rachel Malchow
Is Film considered as literature?
THE DISPLACED SETTING
- Movies are considered literature
The film retains the original language and
because they can be analyzed and
flow of the film but makes changes in the
interpreted in the same way as
setting. This, according to her, is commonly
traditional written literature.
FILM AND LITERATURE
Film Review - For Example: Aristotle's definition of
man
- Film review is a popular way for - Aristotle said that Man is a
critics to assess a film’s overall rational animal.
quality and determine whether or - In the sentence above,
not they think the film is worth Rationality = is considered to
recommending. be the essence of man
Writing a Film Review (5 Elements) - A dead man is no longer a
a. Introduction man. It no longer possesses
b. Plot Summary any reason/ rationality (a
c. Description soul)
d. Analysis
e. Conclusion/Evaluation Medium Essentialism
Tips in making Film Reviews
1. Watch the film at least once. ● A philosophical theory stating that
2. Express your opinions and support each artform has its own distinctive
your criticism. medium, and that the essence of
3. Consider your audience. such an artform is dependent on its
4. Know the Actors' portfolios. particular medium.
5. Call out directors, cinematographers, ● The theory relies on the presumption
and special effects. that every artform has a unique
6. No spoilers! medium.
7. Study the professionals. ● Medium essentialism is the idea that
8. Reread, rewrite and edit. the way a message is
9. Find your voice communicated affects its meaning
1. Dream Medium Essentialism
5.1 Essentialization ● A film's medium is to be found in its
creator's or director's intention or
Essentialism ‘dream’.
2. Editing medium essentialism
- From the word: Essence ● A film's medium (and therefore
- The intrinsic nature or indispensable essence) lies in its editing.
quality of something, especially 3. Reality medium essentialism
something abstract, determines its ● American philosopher Stanley Cavell
character. proposes that a film's essence is
- The basic nature of a thing; the defined by its medium, and that that
quality or qualities that make a thing medium lies partly within a film's
what it is. portrayal of an illusion of reality.
● "Not by literally presenting us with a
In Aristotelian Philosophy:
world, but by permitting us to view it
- Essentialism is something which unseen […] we are displaced from
remains constant throughout the our natural habitation within it,
entire process of change. placed at a distance from it."
● A film's medium lies in its projection
of reality
FILM AND LITERATURE
Criticisms - Netflix’s datasets have just as much
influence on a film or TV show as human
- Most critics of the idea reject the premise creativity.
that every artform has a distinctive medium
which necessarily determines its essence. - The political drama House of Cards was
Netflix’s most-streamed show prior to
- A film critic, V.F. Perkins in the 1970s Stranger Things, and the first original show
proposed that no one aspect of the film which achieved significant success.
medium (photographic production,
specifically) is superior to its counterparts - Algorithms had identified that a large
(such as artistic intention or soundtrack). segment of their viewership watched Fight
Club and The Social Network from
Noël Carroll in 'Theorising the Moving beginning to end. It also a core segment
Image,'published in (1996) loved political dramas. These data points
provided the foundation for House of Cards
“Medium essentialism is an inaccurate way and strongly predicted its commercial
to evaluate a work - as it requires the success.
distillation of a film to one medium, when a
film is constituted by not one, but several How the Science of Essentialism
mediums. These mediums may include Influences the Human Element of
editing, lighting, narrative, photography, Creativity
color, and artistic intention.”
- As movies and TV shows are forged from
The Psychology of Essentialism and larger and larger data sets, the human
How It Impacts Innovation and Creativity element of creativity has become displaced.
in Film As viewers, do we want to feel as if the
show was made by a fellow human? Would
● Focus Groups we be less likely to enjoy a film made
○ They are Also called test through artificial intelligence with little
audiences human ingenuity involved?
○ The studio calls together a
group of random strangers - Essentialism, this is the idea that we see
from the target everyday objects as having a hidden ‘soul’,
demographics, screens the which transcends its physical qualities
film and monitors their
reactions. If the test audience - With the philosophy of essentialism, Only
isn't happy, the studio asks the real painting has the essence. And this
them what would have made essence shapes our perception of the
the film better and painting, and how we value it.
implements that.
- We gravitate toward the meaningful.
Big Data and Artificially Intelligent
Algorithms - What forms the essence of something in
our mind? A major contributor is the origin
story of the object; what we believe about
how it came into the world.
FILM AND LITERATURE
The Role Essentialism Plays in the Film - The belief about the creative essence of
Industry the film impacts how it’s enjoyed.
- The origin story of the film - how it came to - As an American journalist, Andrew
be, and what its hidden essence is, shapes Leonard stated that,
how we perceive it.
“A reliance on Big Data might funnel
- Using the example of the movie Fargo by craftsmanship in particular directions. What
the Cohen Brothers in 1996 happens when directors approach the
editing room armed with the knowledge that
- The film tells the story of a grizzly set of a certain subset of subscribers is opposed
murders stemming from a staged to jump cuts or get off on gruesome torture
kidnapping gone wrong. The film opens with scenes? Is that all we’ll be offered?”
the following lines:
5.2 Author vs. Auteur
This is a true story. The events depicted in
this film took place in Minnesota in 1987. At Auteur - “author”
the request of the survivors, the names
have been changed. Out of respect for the - auteur - a director who exerts a
dead, the rest has been told exactly as it high level of control across all
occurred. aspects of a film.
- “An auteur is a filmmaker whose
individual style and complete
control over all elements of
production give a film its personal
and unique stamp
- The Coen Brothers later admitted that the
film wasn’t actually based on murders that
Auteur Theory
took place in Minnesota. The actual
inspiration for the story has been the subject
- director is the author and primary
of much speculation, and the Cohen
creative force behind a movie
Brothers have never revealed what, if any,
- Origin - French publication in 1954
historical events the film is based on.
of Cahiers du Cinema (notes on
cinema)
- There’s no arguing with the film’s success.
- American critic Andrew Sarris was
It took home the Grammy for Best Original
the one who referred to Francois
Screenplay and in 1997, was considered by
Truffaut's manifesto as "Auteur
the American Film Institute as one of the
Theory."
100 greatest films ever made.
- The theory arose from the ideas of
- When asked about this, Joel Cohen had Andrè Bazin and Alexandre
the following to say, “If an audience believes Astruc
that something is based on a real event, it
gives you permission to do things they Rules of Auteur Theory
might otherwise not accept."
a. Basic Competency
FILM AND LITERATURE
- "A great director has to at least be Author- The originator or creator of a work,
a good director." especially of a literary composition.