12/8/2021 Why big American businesses fail in China | The World from PRX

DONATE

Economics

Why big American businesses fail

in China
GlobalPost
September 23, 2013 · 4:30 AM UTC
By
Benjamin Carlson

Mattel stormed China with a six-story Barbie concept building in central Shanghai, in 2009. It left in
2011. What went wrong?
Credit: STR
     

HONG KONG — If Tolstoy had written a history of foreign

corporations in China, it might have started something like this:
https://www.pri.org/stories/2013-09-23/why-big-american-businesses-fail-china 1/8
12/8/2021 Why big American businesses fail in China | The World from PRX

“Companies that succeed in China do so for similar reasons; every

company that fails, fails in its own way.”

Since China opened up to foreign investment in the late 1970s, some of America’s
most powerful corporations have gone confidently into the People’s Republic, only
to stagger out a few years later, battered, confused, and defeated.

It’s not because the businesses were incompetent. Many of the biggest failures
belong to the Fortune 500: Mattel, eBay, Google, Home Depot. All of these have
thrived in markets around the world, but not in China.

Why?

Some suffered from a lack of flexibility, or a failure to localize. Others fell because of
bad timing, or a superior local competitor. While the causes are as varied as the
industries themselves, a pattern can be discerned among the biggest failures in
China: an inability to grasp just how different — and cutthroat — the Chinese market
can be. 

“It’s a lack of understanding of the legal and cultural environment that leads to most
failures,” says Shawn Mahoney, managing director of the EP China consulting group.
“The only difference between a success and failure in my experience is that people
who are successful are more willing to talk and learn about how things work on the
ground.”

Here, we look at how four of the biggest US companies lost their way in China.

Home Depot: China’s not the land of DIY

America’s suburbs are full of tinkerers and home-improvement hobbyists, and

Home Depot exists to serve them. With aisles upon aisles of power tools, building
materials, and hardware supplies, its big-box stores are a testimony to US
homeowners’ do-it-yourself ethic. 

On the surface, it seems like things might be similar in China. The country has a
growing middle class, millions of new homeowners, and a culture of everyday
ingenuity and thrift.
https://www.pri.org/stories/2013-09-23/why-big-american-businesses-fail-china 2/8
 g
12/8/2021
y Why big American businesses fail in China | The World from PRX

Wouldn’t Home Depot do perfectly there?

That’s what the company thought when it bought into China in 2006. The Atlanta-
based firm acquired a local firm, stocked its 12 stores with tools and materials, and
waited for the money to roll in.

It never did.

After six years of struggle, Home Depot shut its seven remaining stores and fired 850
workers in China.

There are several factors behind the failure. First was simply timing: Home Depot
came late to China, after its competitors already had a foothold. By the time it
arrived China’s growth was slowing down.

Second was the nature of China’s housing market. Many people buy homes for
investment and speculation, not to improve.

Third was the store format. As Best Buy and other American retailers have found,
Chinese consumers don’t like big, boxy warehouses far away from a city center.

Finally, and most fatally, Home Depot tried to bring American notions of DIY to a
market where labor was so cheap that most people simply hired a handyman.

“Home Depot, Barbie, Best Buy — they came and tried to sell the American vision,
thinking people wanted to buy that,” says Mahoney. “That’s not what Chinese want
to buy.”

The company admitted as much when it left China. As the company spokeswoman
said at the time, “China is a do-it-for-me market, not a do-it-yourself market, so we
have to adjust.”

Mattel: Nobody wants $100 Barbie jeans

The irony of Barbie’s failure in China is that Barbie, the doll, was actually fairly
l Th bl th t B bi th b d
https://www.pri.org/stories/2013-09-23/why-big-american-businesses-fail-china t 3/8
12/8/2021 Why big American businesses fail in China | The World from PRX
popular. The problem was that Barbie, the brand, was not.

Mattel’s foray began in 2009, when it opened the world’s largest “House of Barbie” in
a prime Shanghai location. The toymaker spent $30 million making the six-story
shop a temple to all things Barbie. It included a restaurant, a hair and nail salon, a
cocktail bar, and a spa.

Mattel even launched a localized doll, Ling, to appeal to Chinese consumers.

So what went wrong?

Partly, it was a failure of planning. The store was too big, too expensive, and too
confusing in its mixture of adult pleasures (Barbie martinis, bust-firming treatments)

and children’s toys.

More fundamentally, Mattel seems to have misread the market. Instead of focusing
on children’s dolls, Mattel assumed that Chinese consumers would want a whole
range of pricey Barbie-themed clothing, foods, and goods.

But, as author and business consultant Helen Wang points out, “Since Barbie is not
a cultural icon in China as she is in America, Chinese consumers couldn’t care less
about Barbie-branded products.”

By the time Mattel realized its mistake, the store was bleeding money. In 2011, the
House of Barbie closed.

If there’s a lesson, it’s this: Before you go in big in China, do your homework.
Companies need to be flexible, adaptable, and responsive to Chinese tastes. That
means experimenting before dropping $30 million on a mega-store.

eBay: Don’t neglect “guanxi”

Spend any time in China, and you quickly learn the power of "guanxi," or social
connections. Guanxi drives business deals and government contracts. It’s the
invisible glue that ties people together. It’s the sense of connection and mutual
obligation that Chinese society prizes in personal relationships. 

Thi lik t i i l d t il f
https://www.pri.org/stories/2013-09-23/why-big-american-businesses-fail-china f l ti It’ t 4/8
12/8/2021 Why big American businesses fail in China | The World from PRX
This may seem like a trivial detail for a powerful corporation. It’s not.

Take the case of eBay.

In 2004, the San Jose online auctioning giant decided to enter the Chinese market.
EBay bought a local company, Eachnet, switched it to the eBay platform, and
expected to sweep China in short order. After all, they had dominated other
countries’ markets. Why not China's?

Two years later, they shut down their portal, abandoning the Chinese auction
market. A local competitor, Taobao, went on to take over 95 percent of the local
market share.

The problem was that eBay had no mechanism for simulating guanxi. According to a
study conducted by researchers in the United States and Hong Kong, this was a
crucial error. While Taobao allowed buyers and sellers to chat over instant-
messaging, giving them a chance to establish a personal connection, eBay did not.

“Those buyers really want to get to know the sellers,” Paul A. Pavlou, a professor at
Temple University’s Fox School of Business, told Pacific Standard.

In China, business is not just business. It’s social.

Today, eBay says it has learned from its experience. The company has refocused
away from the domestic market, toward helping Chinese sellers market directly to
consumers abroad.

“It’s frustrating that people say we failed in China,” says Daniel Feiler, a spokesman
for eBay. “From our perspective, we now have a very successful, large, and
continuing-to-grow export business.”

Google: Running afoul of the government

Google’s Chinese defeat is one of the most dramatic, and the most complex.

The context is well known. In 2010 Google announced that it had been hacked, and
would no longer be censoring at the government’s behest. It moved its servers to
H K It k t h di df
https://www.pri.org/stories/2013-09-23/why-big-american-businesses-fail-china 30 tt 3 t i 2013 5/8
12/8/2021 Why big American businesses fail in China | The World from PRX
Hong Kong. Its market share dipped from 30 percent to 3 percent in 2013.

What happened? While poor decisions in Mountain View certainly played a part,
politics was what killed Google. From the very beginning of its China venture,
Google was hamstrung. Launched in 2006, Google.cn was a bare-bones search
engine, with no Gmail, blog software, or YouTube; the company refused to keep its
servers in China, for fear of having to turn over user data.

In 2008, Beijing demanded that Google more thoroughly censor its auto-fill search
suggestions. In 2009, Google detected a breach of its servers that the company
traced to China. The attackers not only stole corporate secrets, but also rifled
through the personal accounts of dissidents and activists related to China and Tibet.

By 2010, Google’s chiefs had had enough. They decided that they would no longer
comply with Beijing’s demands.

The lesson from Google’s China fiasco is hard, but important. In the end, foreign
companies who want to thrive in China have to abide by the rules of a repressive,
autocratic government. That means either compromising with policies you may find
unsavory — as Google did, at first — or getting out.

“China is a tough, large market with fierce competitors,” Kaifu Lee, Google’s former
China head, recently wrote. “To have a chance in China, the American company
must empower the local team to be responsive, autonomous, localized, and ready
for combat.”

Want a seat at the table?

Every morning, the editorial team at public radio’s international news show The World
meets to plan what they'll cover that day. Want to see what's on deck?

Sign up for our daily newsletter TOP OF THE WORLD and get the big stories we’re
tracking delivered to your inbox every weekday morning.

Your name

Your email
https://www.pri.org/stories/2013-09-23/why-big-american-businesses-fail-china 6/8
12/8/2021 Why big American businesses fail in China | The World from PRX

SUBSCRIB E

Categories: Business, Economics and Jobs, Economics, Politics, Development & Education and Go East.

Tagged: China.

Latest Content

Tens of thousands of Hong Kongers have applied for special new UK visas

Taliban takes over three more Afghan provincial capitals

China sentences Canadian to 11 years in case tied to Huawei executive

6.2 million Burmese could go hungry by October. It’s the worst situation in ‘living memory,’ UN
official says
https://www.pri.org/stories/2013-09-23/why-big-american-businesses-fail-china 7/8
12/8/2021 Why big American businesses fail in China | The World from PRX

Jordanian musicians worry that their national orchestra could be shuttered

Our coronavirus coverage has never been behind a paywall.

No paywalls, ever.

Donate

Sign up for The Top of The World

The World's daily email newsletter

Your Name

Your Email

Subscribe

The World is a public radio program that crosses borders and time zones to bring home the stories that matter.
Produced by

Major funding provided by

About | Donate | Meet the Team | Contact | Privacy policy | Terms of use

©2021 The World from PRX.

PRX is a 501(c)(3) organization recognized by the IRS: #263347402.

https://www.pri.org/stories/2013-09-23/why-big-american-businesses-fail-china 8/8