You are on page 1of 6

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/281629326

DETERMINATION OF RADON CONCENTRATION IN WATER USING RAD7 AND


RAD H 2 O ACCESSORIES

Conference Paper · November 2014


DOI: 10.1063/1.4915231

CITATIONS READS

10 1,536

3 authors:

Muhammad fadhirul izwan abdul malik NOR AIN RABAIEE


Universiti Sains Malaysia International Islamic University Malaysia
13 PUBLICATIONS 82 CITATIONS 6 PUBLICATIONS 22 CITATIONS

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Mohamad Suhaimi Jaafar


Universiti Sains Malaysia
229 PUBLICATIONS 2,033 CITATIONS

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Alpha particles and blood components View project

Nanoparticles View project

All content following this page was uploaded by NOR AIN RABAIEE on 10 September 2015.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


DETERMINATION OF RADON CONCENTRATION IN
WATER USING RAD7 AND RAD H2O ACCESSORIES
M.F.I. Abdul Malika,*, N.A. Rabaieeb, and M.S. Jaafarb
a
Science and Engineering Research Centre (SERC), Universiti Sains Malaysia, Seri Ampangan Nibong Tebal
14300 Penang, Malaysia
b
School of Physics, Universiti Sains Malaysia,
11800 Penang, Malaysia

Abstract. In the last decade, the radon issue has become one of the major problems of radiation protection. Radon exposure
occurs when using water for showering, washing dishes, cooking and drinking water. RAD7 and Rad H20 accessories were used
in order to measure radon concentration in water sample. In this study, four types of water were concerns which are reverse
osmosis (drinking water), mineral water, tap water and well water. Reverse osmosis (drinking water) and mineral water were
bought from the nearest supermarket while tap water and well water were taken from selected areas of Pulau Pinang and Kedah.
Total 20 samples were taken with 5 samples for each type of water. The measured radon concentration ranged from 2.9±2.9 to
79.5±17 pCi/L, 2.9±2.9 to 67.8±16 pCi/L, 15.97±7 to 144.25±24 pCi/L and 374.89±37 to 6409.03±130 pCi/L in reverse osmosis
(drinking water), mineral water, tap water and well water. Well water has the highest radon compared to others. It was due to
their geological element such as granite. Results for all types of water are presented and compared with maximum contamination
limit (MCL) recommended by United State Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) which is 300pCi/L. Reverse osmosis
water, mineral water and tap water were fall below MCL. However, well water was exceeded maximum level that was
recommended. Thus, these findings were suggested that an action should be taken to reduce radon concentration level in well
water as well as reduce a health risk towards the public.

Keywords: Radon, Water, Radiation, Environment.


PACS: 23.60. +e

Introduction that released to air from water [8]. It has been


determined that inhalation of radon dissolved in and
There are three naturally occurring isotopes of radon; released from water for human consumption accounts
Radon-222, Radon-219 and Radon-220 [1]. In this for 89 % of radon related cancers (USNRC) [9]. The
study, term radon refers specifically to Radon-222, ground and surface waters generally have different
which is a decay product of U-238 and the half life of radon concentration because radon in groundwater
3.824 days and emitting alpha (∝) particle. It is also has its origin in the radioactive decay of radium and
soluble in water and organic solvents , the only gas reflect not only in chemical form but also in
that has radioactive isotopes under normal condition, structural properties of rock in the aquifer [10,11].
occurs naturally, whose density is 7.5 times higher Several different methods of measuring
than air and responsible for a large percentage of radon in water have been developed and used such as
natural radiation exposure; considered a health gamma spectrometry and liquid scintillation counting
hazard due to its radioactivity reported as major (LSC) techniques which is method based on solid
causes of lung cancer [2,3,4]. It also caused cancer state nuclear track detector and charcoal canister
death by drinking the water [5]. By the late of 1970s, (SSNTD). Tayyeb in his study said SSNTD
a program to reduce public exposure to waterborne technique is simple and cheap as compared to the
radon was initiated because they discovered that other methods [12]. However, this method lacks of
cases in which groundwater concentration was sensitivity to detect radon at the lower levels as it is
exceeded 1 million pCi/L [6]. Over exposure to the now considered important [6]. In comparison with
radon gas and consequent decay product may lead to other detector, RAD H20 offers a method as accurate
lung cancer [7]. as LSC that was recommended by EPA with
In 2004, WHO recommended the Reference additional advantages. RAD H20 is faster to the first
Dose Level (RDL) of the committed effective dose reading, portable, less labour intensive and less
equal to 0.1 mSv from 1 year consumption of expensive.
drinking water. However, the risk is smaller for radon
Material and method laboratory drying unit during the initial purging
process to save the small drying tubes for the actual
Four types of domestic water were taken measurement in water. They are a source of radon-
into account which is drinking water, mineral water, free (or relatively radon free) air or inert gas to purge
tap water and well water. This sample was chosen the system.
because there is the common domestic water used for RAD7 calculates the sample water
drinking in Malaysia. Mineral water and drinking concentration by multiplying the air loop
water with different branding were bought from the concentration by a fixed conversion coefficient that
nearest supermarket. Tap water’s samples were taken depends on the sample size. This conversion
from different area around Penang and Kedah, coefficient was derived from the volume of the air
Malaysia. The sample is taken from Sungai Dua, loop, the volume of the sample and the equilibrium
Universiti Sains Malaysia (USM), Bukit Gambir, radon distribution coefficient at room temperature.
Baling and Kampung Mengkuang. Another five Conversion coefficient is 25 for 40mL sample
samples of well water was collected from Masjid volume and 4 for 250mL sample volume. There is no
Batu Uban, Bukit Mertajam, Kampung Charok correction for the temperature of the water sample.
Kapas, Kampung Bukit Hitam (1) and Kampung Theoretically, the correction would slightly improve
Bukit Hitam (2). Total 20 samples of water from four the analytical accuracy for the larger sample volume
types of common drinking water was concerned in (25mL), but it would make little or no difference in
this studied. 250 ml of water sample was used in each the smaller sample volume. The results of the sample
study. A larger sample size was chosen because it were corrected from the time of the sample was
will improve sensitivity and precision at low radon drawn to the time it was counted. Decay correction
concentrations. can be used for samples counted up to 10 days after
The water samples should not contacting sampling, though analytical precision will decline as
with air during collecting the sample and also not the sample gets weaker and weaker.
been through a charcoal filter or been sitting for days
in a hot water tank. For collecting tap water, water  
was allowed to flow about 10 minutes to ensure an  () =  (/132.4hours)
accurate radon content of water can be collected from
the underground water supplies. Then, the bottles Where; T is the decay time in hours.
were closed rapidly and tight to avoid radon leakage.
The samples that had taken were analysed in the Based on decay correction factor’s table, decay
Medical Physics Laboratory, School of Physics, times of less than 3 hours require very small
Universiti Sains Malaysia (USM), Penang, Malaysia. correction. The decay factor can be neglected for the
Decay correction was applied to give a more accurate samples counted quickly. Thus, the actual radon
calculation of radon if the sample was analysed more concentration for each sample was calculated as
than three hours after sampling. This is due to the fact below:
that sampling and measurement of radon present  R
complications due to its volatility and relatively short   r =    
half-life.
The RAD7 (manufactures by Durridge The background of RAD7 is low enough and can
Company) with Rad H20 accessory was used to be ignored it. So, there is no need to have this
measure radon in water over the concentration range background measured. Numerous experiments were
from of less than 10pCi/L to greater than 400 000 available to measure the background. The results
pCi/L. The Rad H20 requires the desiccant be used at were negligible, especially, after the device has been
all times to dry the air stream before it enters the purged from radon for 15 minutes. The intrinsic
RAD7. The good desiccant is in blue colour. If the background of RAD7 is less than 1 count per hour.
desiccant was changed to pink colour, it needs to heat Corresponding to 40ml water sample concentration
in the oven for 2 hours with 2000C – 2250C before of less than 740Bq/m3 (even lower for the 250ml
proceeding to the next measurement. For water sample), the background was less than 1Bq/m3 after
sample analysis, the small drying tubes is necessary the air has been subtracted by loop and desiccant.
to avoid using the large drying tube as its much larger The background was ignored during the measurement
volume would cause improper dilution of the radon. of radon in water. Nonetheless, the RAD7 was
Humidity reading for RAD7 has to remain below purged for 30 minutes to remove the old radon from
10% and must be free of radon and dry before start the machine and purged again for 15 minutes
the measurement. It is convenient to use the larger between the measurement and the remains.
Result and discussion.
TABLE 1 Radon concentration in pCi/L for different Table 1 represents five different brands of
sample of drinking water (reverse osmosis) drinking water (reverse osmosis) and their radon
Temperature Radon concentration that was measured using RAD7. This
Sample Source (0C) RH concentration
(pCi/L) brand was named by A, B, C, D and E. There are
A Bukit 28.15 4.50 5.81 ± 4.41 three different sources of this water before its bottle.
Jelutong, Shah Sample A and B taken from Bukit Jelutong Shah
Alam Alam. While, sample C and D taken from Taman
B Bukit 27.85 12.75 30.00 ± 11.00
Jelutong, Shah Perindustrian Shah Alam and sample E from Jalan
Alam Air Kuning Taiping. Temperature during
C Taman 27.10 10.25 2.90 ± 2.90 measurement of drinking water’s sample between
Perindustrian, 240C to 280C and relative humidity is from 4 to 12.
Shah Alam
D Taman 27.10 12.25 4.83 ± 3.90 As can be seen from table 1, brand E has the highest
Perindustrian, radon concentration with 79.5 ± 17 pCi/L. Brand B
Shah Alam has the second highest concentration, 30 ± 11 pCi/L
E Jalan Air 24.30 13.25 79.50 ± 17.00 followed by 5.81 ± 4.41 for brand A. The lowest
Kuning,
Taiping radon concentration in drinking water is brand C and
D, where 2.9 ± 2.9 and 4.83 ± 3.9 pCi/L for each of
them.
TABLE 2 Radon concentration in pCi/L for different Table 2 summarizes the radon concentration
sample of mineral water for different samples of mineral water. Temperature
Sample Source Temperature RH Radon
(0C) Concentration
during measurement is 240C to 280C and relative
(pCi/L) humidity is between 7 to 13. Each sample had
F Mukim Sabai, 28.23 9.50 3.84 ± 3.40 different source and temperature between 24 0C-280C.
Pahang There are four different sources of this mineral water.
G Mukim Ulu 28.30 9.25 2.90 ± 2.90 Sample F was taken from Mukim Sabai Pahang and
Sg Johor
H Jalan Air 27.40 13.00 15.45 ± 7.00 sample G from Mukim Ulu Sungai Johor. Jalan Air
Kuning, Kuning Perak is the source for sample H and I. The
Taiping last sample is sample J that was taken from Mukim
I Jalan Air 24.83 7.50 67.8 ± 16.00 Batang Kali, Hulu Selangor. Sample I have the
Kuning,
Taiping highest radon concentration with 67.8 ± 16 pCi/L.
J Mukim 25.28 10.00 58.15 ± 15.00 Next is sample J with 58.15 ± 15 pCi/L and 15.45 ± 7
Batang Kali, pCi/L of radon concentration of sample H. It was
Hulu Selangor then followed by sample F 3.84 ± 3.4 pCi/L and the
lowest radon concentration is brand G 2.90 ± 2.9
pCi/L
TABLE 3 Radon concentration of tap water from different Table 3 presented radon concentration for
places sample of tap water from different places. The
Sample Temperature RH Radon Concentration temperature during the measurement of radon
(oC) (pCi/L)
concentration of the tap water’s sample is between
Sungai dua 26.1 12.00 43.63 ± 13.00 24.60C and 310C. Relative humidity between 4 to 12.
USM 27.10 7.50 109 ± 20.00
Bukit 24.60 4.25 144.25 ± 24.00 Bukit Gambir have the highest radon concentration
Gambir with 144.25 ± 24 pCi/L. Followed by USM with 109
Baling 31.30 5.00 33.13 ± 9.00 ± 20 pCi/L and Sungai Dua 43.63 ± 13 pCi/L. Baling,
Kampong 31.00 6.75 15.97 ± 7.00 Kedah has only 33.13 ± 9 pCi/L of water
Mengkuang
concentration and the lowest radon concentration is
TABLE 4 Radon concentration of well water from from Kampung Mengkuang with 15.97 ± 7 pCi/L.
different places Table 4 provides the radon concentration in
Sample Temperature RH Radon the well water’s sample. The temperature during
(0C) concentration measurement between 260C to 300C while relative
(pCi/L) humidity between 4 to 12. So, Kampung Bukit Hitam
Masjid BatuUban 26.10 12.00 4692.5 ± 150.00
Bukit Mertajam 26.80 9.00 374.89 ± 37.00 (1) have the highest concentration with 6409.03 ±
Kampung Charok Kapas 31.00 7.50 2780.58 ± 130.00 130 pCi/L. Masjid Batu Uban have 4692.5 ± 150
Kmpg Bukit Hitam (1) 30.78 4.50 6409.03 ± 130.00 pCi/L.
Kmpg Bukit Hitam (2) 30.70 5.00 4110.46 ± 110.00
Next is Kampung Bukit Hitam (2) with 4110.46 ± surface water was decrease very fast because of
110 pCi/L and Kampung Charok Kapas 2780.58 ± escape radon from water into atmosphere before
130 pCi/L. The lowest radon concentration in the reaching water supplier or home. Thus, tap water is
well water’s sample is Bukit Mertajam with only safe to use for domestic purpose.
374.89 ± 37 pCi/L. In the current study of well water, all the samples
In Malaysia, there is no regulation about radon in were exceeded of MCL recommended by USEPA
water. But, other radionuclide like Ra-226 and Sr-90 and not safe for domestic purpose. The reason of this
together with gross alpha and gross beta in water is not clear but it may relate with source of well water
were included in the Malaysia Water Quality that gets their water from underground. Radon is the
Standard [13]. Some believe that radon in drinking decay product of Ra-226. Trace amount of uranium
water may affect the sensitive cells in the stomach as and radium are present in rocks and soil. [15] in their
well as other organs once they observed into the study said the radon gas can move freely through the
bloodstream [14]. Currently, the radon concentration pores of soil and rocks. When these pores are filled
in drinking water is not regulated but USEPA has with water, radon is dissolved into the water and
proposed a MCL for drinking water is 300pCi/L or transported with it. Therefore, radon concentration is
11.1Bq/L. usually high in ground water compared to surface
Result of this study indicates that most of water is water as supported by [16].
safe to use for various purpose because most of The land of Kampung Bukit Hitam (1) that was
sample presented the values of radon concentration placed at Baling is built of varies geological elements
below MCL. Only well water exceeded the maximum such as granite and limestone. A strong relationship
level that was recommended by USEPA. Five between radon concentration and granite has been
different brands of reverse osmosis water was reported in literature [10]. Thus, high radon
measured and obtained at table 1. The results of this concentration in Baling might be due to more granite
study show that Brand E has the highest radon that was containing in this land. Bukit Mertajam’s
concentration compared to others. Meanwhile, brand well was found to have lowest radon concentration. It
I shown the highest radon concentration for mineral reduce more than half compared to the Kampung
water as presented on table 2. These results may be Bukit Hitam (1)’s well water which is the highest
explained by different source of water for reverse radon concentration for well water. This
osmosis and mineral water. Each source has different inconsistency may be due to Bukit Mertajam’s well is
geological element and compound. This findings a deep well and the rest is shallow well. [9] made a
support the idea of [2] that radon concentration study and found the radon level in shallow wells is
varying from region to another depended on variation relatively higher compared with deep well. In the
of the structure of the source of drinking water. shallow well, a stream of carbon dioxide moving
The possible reason of reduction radon upwards and draws radon from the pores. These
concentration for other brands might due to radon gases migrating together are dissolved in the shallow
decay process during the water treatment procedure groundwater thus increasing its radon concentration.
including the procedures of mixing, As the literature indicated, radon concentration in
flocculation/coagulation, sedimentation and filtration sample can also be affected due to time of sampling,
process before it bottled [8]. Thus, a longer time sampling technique, humidity and temperature during
consuming from the time it was collected and measurement [4,5].
supplied to public may reduce radon concentration in Humidity during measurement is another factor
this water. Thus, it is possible reason for high radon that contributes to radon concentration. This was
concentration for brand E and I because they might supported by [8] that humidity is the greatest impact.
be having a short time between the dates of bottled Humidity suppose below 10% for entire 30 minutes
and measurement compared to other brand. Even of measurement. However, during measurement, the
though this two is the highest, there are still low humidity increases exceed than 10% in most of
compared to MCL that was recommended by measurement. High humidity reduces the efficiency
USEPA. of collection of Po-218 atoms. So, less reading can be
Based on table 2, the tap water at Bukit Gambir is obtained by the detector. RAD7 detector has unusual
the highest compared to USM, Sungai Dua, Baling ability to tell difference between new radon daughter
and Kampung Mengkuang. These entire samples are and old radon daughter left from previous test as
below MCL recommended by USEPA. It seems shown in table 3. The inconsistency of background
possible because most of tap water comes from a also may affect the result. This is known as
surface water source such as river, lake or reservoir. background radiation. The higher radon
It is due to no underground water contribution to this concentration and longer the previous sample is held
surface water [5]. Plus, radon concentration on in the cell, more daughter activity is leaves behind.
In order to remove the background, detector is [3] HAMMOOD, H. A. & AL-KHALIFA, I. J. M. Radon
Concentration Measurement in Water of Dhi - Qar
purge and the background activity that left in the
Governorate (in Iraq) Using Emanometer. Journal of Basrah
detector is flush from the chamber. Researches (Sciences) ‫ ب صرة‬ ‫ب حاث‬ ‫ ي اث (مج ل ت‬ ‫ ع ل‬),
37, 22-29 (2011).
Conclusion [4] HUSSEIN, Z. A., JAAFAR, M. S. & ISMAIL, A. H.
Measurement of indoor radon concentration levels and its
Risks inside Hospitals in Iraqi Kurdistan Region: Case Study
This paper was to measure concentration of radon in Autumn Season. Online Journal of Physical and
in water. Environmental pollution has been a great Environmental Science Research, 2, 1-6 (2013).
[5] ZAINI HAMZAH, AHMAD SAAT & MOHAMMED
threat to humanity since the beginning of life on
KASSIM, Determination of Radon Activity Concentration in
earth. So it is natural for the public to be sensitive Hot Spring and Surface Water Using Gamma Spectrometry
and active against all the pollutants causing threats to Technique. The Malaysian Journal of Analytical Sciences, Vol
our lives. USEPA recommended that the radon 15, 288-294 (2011).
[6] DURRIDGE COMPANY. Rad7 RAD H20 Owner's Manual
concentration in drinking water should not exceed
(2009)
300pCi/L. In this study, three types of sample which [7] MEHRA, R., BADHAN, K. & SONKAWADE, R. Radon
are reverse osmosis water, mineral water and tap Activity Measurements in Drinking Water and in Indoors of
water have a level concentration of radon below Dwellings, Using RAD7. Tenth Radiation Physics &
Protection Conference, Nasr City-Cairo, Egypt. 35, (2010).
MCL that was recommended by USEPA. However,
[8] TODOROVIC, N., NIKOLOV, J., FORKAPIC, S., BIKIT, I.,
the well water’s sample has exceeded the MRDJA, D., KRMAR, M. & VESKOVIC, M. Public
recommended level. It is likely that well water is exposure to radon in drinking water in SERBIA. Applied
significantly higher risk of radon concentration as Radiation and Isotopes, 70, 543-549 (2012).
[9] ALEISSA, K. A., ALGHAMDI, A. S., ALMASOUD, F. I. &
estimated by USEPA. These present study suggests
ISLAM, M. S. Measurement of radon levels in groundwater
that concentration of radon for every water source supplies of Riyadh with liquid scintillation counter and the
should be measure before distribute to public. As a associated radiation dose. Radiat Prot Dosimetry, 154, 95-103
conclusion, radon concentration in reverse osmosis (2013).
[10]HAN, Y. L., TOM KUO, M. C., FAN, K. C., CHIANG, C. J.
water, mineral water and tap water is low and safe to
& LEE, Y. P. Radon distribution in groundwater of Taiwan.
drink. Hydrogeology Journal, 14, 173-179 (2006).
[11] BAYKARA, O. & DOGˇRU, M. Measurements of radon and
Acknowledgments uranium concentration in water and soil samples from East
Anatolian Active Fault Systems (Turkey). Radiation
Measurements, 41, 362-367 (2006).
This work is supported by the research university [12] TAYYEB, Z., KINSARA, A. & FARID, S. A study on the
grant (308/AIFIZIK/415403) from Universiti Sains radon concentrations in water in Jeddah (Saudi Arabia) and
the associated health effects. Journal of Environmental
Malaysia. And also we would like to acknowledge
Radioactivity, 38, 97-104 (1998).
Nabil Saleh Hadi Al-Aawr and Nisar Ahmad for [13] HAMZAH, Z., SAAT, A. & KASSIM, M. Determination of
willing to assist in getting this project on the right radon activity concentration in water using gamma
track and useful discussions. spectrometry and liquid scintillation counter techniques.
Sustainable Energy & Environment (ISESEE), 3rd
International Symposium & Exhibition in, IEEE, 191-193
(2011).
References [14] ONER, F., YALIM, H., AKKURT, A. & ORBAY, M. The
measurements of radon concentrations in drinking water and
the Yeşilırmak River water in the area of Amasya in Turkey.
[1] HOPKE, P. K., BORAK, T., DOULL, J., CLEAVER, J., ECKERMAN, Radiation protection dosimetry, 133, 223-226 (2009).
K., GUNDERSEN, L., HARLEY, N., HESS, C., KINNER, N. & [15] NASIR., T. & SHAH., M. Measurement of Annual Effective
KOPECKY, Health risks due to radon in drinking water. Doses of Radon from Drinking Water and Dwellings by CR-
Environmental Science & Technology, 34, 921-926 (2000). 39 Track Detectors in Kulachi City of Pakistan. Journal of
[2] ISMAIL., A. H. & HAJI, S. O. Analysis of Radon Basic & Applied Sciences, 8, 528-536 (2012).
Concentration in Drinking Water in Erbil Governorate (Iraqi [16] PRASAD, Y., PRASAD, G., CHOUBEY, V. & RAMOLA,
Kurdistan) and its Health Effects. Tirkit Journal of Pure R. Geohydrological control on radon availability in
Science, Vol. 13 (2008). groundwater. Radiation Measurements, 44, 122-126 (2009)

View publication stats

You might also like