802.

1AC-Rev
MAC Service Definition
Editor’s report
John Messenger, May 2016

v01
Ballotting

• PAR granted June 2013

• Initial draft 0.1 June 2013
• Draft 0.2 February 2014 (Task group ballot)
• Draft 1.0 June 2014
• Draft 2.0 April 2015
• Draft 2.1 June 2015
• Draft 2.2 August 2015
• Draft 3.0 September 2015
• Draft 3.1 April 2016

• 802.1AC-Rev Draft 3.1 issued April 2016

• Sponsor recirculation ballot
• Comment resolution to be performed at the May interim meeting

2
Sponsor ballot results

Initial 1st recirc

D3.0 D3.1
Voters 96 96
Responders 74 77% 76 79%
Approve 69 97% 70 95%
Disapprove 2 3% 3 5%
Abstain 3 4% 3 3%

• Ballot
• got enough responses (79% > 75%)
• passed (95% > 75%)

3
Commenting statistics

• D3.1: 4 Comments
• 2 TR
• 0 T
• 2 ER
• 0 E
• 0 G

• D3.0 remaining unsatisfied MBS Comments from Kivinen, Tero:

• 1 TR (we accepted one of his alternative resolutions)
• 1 ER (accepted)
• He has not responded to the recirculation ballot

4
Main ballot comment items

• Address size (64-bit/48-bit).

• Typo in a figure title

• Editorial issue on lettered list numbering

• LLC Encapsulation Ethertype

5
Plan

• Perform comment resolution at this meeting.

• Try to obtain the missing Ethertype from the RAC ASAP

• Prepare a new draft for sponsor recirculation ballot before the July
plenary

• Comment resolution at the July plenary meeting

6
Thank You

JMessenger@advaoptical.com