You are on page 1of 5

Nurse Researcher Question development

Setting a research question,


aim and objective
Cite this article as: Doody O, Bailey ME (2016) Setting a research question, aim and objective.
Nurse Researcher. 23, 4, 19-23.

Date of submission: November 4 2014. Date of acceptance: May 27 2015.

Correspondence
owen.doody@ul.ie Abstract
Owen Doody PhD, MSc, BSc Aim To describe the development of a research into research. This necessitates engaging with the
is a lecturer at the Department
of Nursing and Midwifery,
question, aim and objective. relevant published literature and knowledgeable people.
University of Limerick, Limerick,
Republic of Ireland Background The first steps of any study are Conclusion This paper identifies the issues to be
Maria E Bailey MSc, BSc,
developing the research question, aim and objective. considered when developing a research question, aim
RNT, RGN is a lecturer at the Subsequent steps develop from these and they and objective. Understanding these considerations will
Department of Nursing and govern the researchers’ choice of population, enable researchers to effectively present their research
Midwifery, University of Limerick,
Republic of Ireland
setting, data to be collected and time period for the question, aim and objective.
study. Clear, succinctly posed research questions,
Peer review aims and objectives are essential if studies are to Implications for practice To conduct successful
This article has been subject
to double-blind review and
be successful. studies, researchers should develop clear research
has been checked using questions, aims and objectives.
antiplagiarism software Discussion Researchers developing their research
Author guidelines
questions, aims and objectives generally experience Keywords research question, research aim, research
journals.rcni.com/r/ difficulties. They are often overwhelmed trying to objective, study development, nursing research,
nr-author-guidelines convert what they see as a relevant issue from practice novice researchers

Introduction researchers work through the different steps of the


DEFINING THE research question is a particularly design cycle, reviewing the literature, integrating
significant step in research as it narrows the theory and developing a conceptual framework
research aim and objective down to specific areas (Hennink et al 2011).
the study will address (Creswell 2014, Johnson and Novice researchers are often overwhelmed and
Christensen 2014). Research questions are vital as bewildered when trying to convert what they see
they guide the choice of methodology, methods, as relevant issues from practice into a study. This
sample, sample size, data collection instrument and difficulty arises as they progress their work and they
data analysis techniques (Lipowski 2008). feel they know what they need to answer.
Selecting and constructing a good research Only by consulting a supervisor and/or other
question is one of any study’s most difficult aspects knowledgeable people about the research and
(Blaikie 2007, 2009, Aslam and Emmanuel 2010). critical evaluation of the relevant published
Despite this, there is little direction on creating literature can researchers develop research
good research questions (Lipowski 2008). They questions, aims and objectives. Developing a
do not appear spontaneously and the ability to research question is an interactive and inductive
pose good questions is a skill that can be refined endeavour that takes place over time.
and developed with direction and collaboration A clear research question is vital and sets the
from colleagues and supervisors (Thabane et al scene for development of a clear research aim and
2009). Importantly, research questions are not objective that are inextricably linked (Martindale
static: they change, adapt or are refined when and Taylor 2014).

© RCNi / NURSE RESEARCHER March 2016 | Volume 23 | Number 4 19


Downloaded from RCNi.com by ${individualUser.displayName} on Jun 20, 2016. For personal use only. No other uses without permission.
Copyright © 2016 RCNi Ltd. All rights reserved.
Nurse Researcher

Table 1 Types of quantitative research question and setting the limits by revealing the boundaries
of the study and highlighting the type of data to be
Type Question collected (White 2009).

Descriptive ■■ Seeks to quantify responses to one or more variables Quantitative research questions These tend to
■■ Often begins with ‘What is…?’ or ‘What are…?’ be precise and can be categorised as ‘descriptive’,
‘comparative’ or ‘relationship’ (Table 1). Words such
Comparative ■■ Seeks to compare two or more groups for some outcome variable as ‘do’, ‘does’, ‘is’ or ‘are’ should be avoided as they
■■ Often uses words such as ‘compare’ invite ‘yes’/‘no’ responses.
■■ When it involves two groups it can be written as: ‘What is Appropriate questions should highlight the
the difference in (dependent variable) between (group 1) and population, dependent variables and design
(group 2)?’ (historical, descriptive, correlational, experimental,
■■ Can be extended to three or more groups by replacing the word causal-comparative, quasi‑experimental), and
‘between’ with ‘among’ the link between the research question and the
■■ Can be causal in nature, such as the effect of X on Y design (Onwuegbuzie and Leech 2006, Kloda
■■ Such causal questions are implicitly comparative in nature when and Bartlett 2013). In comparative/relationship
a comparison is made between a group where X is involved and research questions, independent variables
a group where X is not involved should also be highlighted.
Qualitative research questions are flexible,
Relationship ■■ Is concerned with trends between or among two or more variables adaptable and non-directional (Creswell 2013).
■■ Often uses words such as ‘relate’, ‘relationship’, ‘association’ They seek to determine or discover a process,
and ‘trend’ or define experiences. They are normally used to
■■ Relationship questions involving two variables usually can be try to understand particular educational, familial
written using: ‘What is the relationship between (independent or social processes or experiences that happen in
variable) and (dependent variable) among (population)?’ a specific location and/or context (Marshall and
■■ Can be extended to three or more variables by replacing the word Rossman 2011). They usually describe and address
‘between’ with ‘among’ ‘what’ and ‘how’ questions, avoiding words such as
‘affect’, ‘influence’, ‘compare’ and ‘relate’.
(Onwuegbuzie and Leech 2006)

Qualitative research questions These can represent


Researchers should: broad or central areas of research or specific areas
■■ Develop a research problem that matches your or sub-categories (Creswell 2013). Sub-questions
interests, background, training and publications. can address important concerns and difficulties to
■■ Base research on current evidence. be resolved or describe the context. Like quantitative
■■ The research question should logically present questions, qualitative questions link to research
each step in a progression from what is known to design, including historical/narrative, case study,
important issues that are not. ethnography, phenomenology, grounded theory and
■■ Do not try to be ‘research trendy’. Do not follow autoethnography.
a trend or issue with little evidence from the Generally, these questions are non-directional
literature or little idea of how it will add to the and use words that state that the study will:
knowledge base. ‘discover’ (grounded theory), ‘explain’ or ‘seek to
■■ Avoid topics. Look at clearly defined research understand’ (ethnography), ‘explore a process’
problems instead. (case study) or ‘describe the experiences’
■■ Stay focused. You will find many things of (phenomenology).
interest along the path, but you should ask Researchers can often find developing qualitative
yourself: ‘Is this related to what I want to uncover questions difficult (Agee 2009). To help researchers
or just a point of interest?’ think about the different types and purposes of their
studies, constructs for question types are presented
Research questions in Table 2. Comparative questions are often
Research questions can be developed from overlooked in qualitative research. Onwuegbuzie and
theoretical knowledge, previous research or Leech (2007) described four measures that compare:
experience, or a practical need at work (Parahoo 1. Participants pairwise (pairwise sampling
2014). They have numerous roles, such as designs).
identifying the importance of the research, 2. Two or more subgroups (subgroup sampling
providing a framework, direction and cohesion, designs).

20 March 2016 | Volume 23 | Number 4 © RCNi / NURSE RESEARCHER


Downloaded from RCNi.com by ${individualUser.displayName} on Jun 20, 2016. For personal use only. No other uses without permission.
Copyright © 2016 RCNi Ltd. All rights reserved.
Question development

3. Two or more members of the same subgroup, The authors suggest that once the research topic
wherein one or more members represents a has been identified, the researcher should begin
sub-sample of the full sample (nested sampling framing the research question by listing all the
designs). questions that could be researched. This may be a
4. Two or more subgroups that are extracted from large or small list with questions interconnected or
different levels of a study (multilevel sampling very different. Forming the right questions should
designs). be seen as an iterative process that occurs through
continually engaging in reading and refining ones
Mixed-methods studies Researchers conducting ideas at all stages (Maxwell 2013).
these studies can choose to develop separate Hulley et al’s (2007) criteria for quantitative
quantitative questions and qualitative questions research are:
or develop a mixed methods question depending ■■ Feasible.
on the study (Creswell 2009). Separate quantitative ■■ Interesting.
and qualitative questions are appropriate when the ■■ Novel .
approaches, not the mixed methods or integrative ■■ Ethical.
component of the study, are the focus (Tashakkori ■■ Relevant.
and Teddlie 2010). This identifies the significance These criteria are collectively known as FINER.
of the qualitative and quantitative phases of the Cooke et al’s (2012) characteristics of qualitative
study and their collective power (Creswell and Plano research are:
Clarke 2011). ■■ Sample
The development of a mixed methods question ■■ Phenomena of interest
should reflect the procedures or the content and ■■ Design
not include separate quantitative and qualitative ■■ Evaluation
questions (Creswell 2009, Tashakkori and Teddlie ■■ Research type
2010). This suggests that there is some integration These characteristics are collectively known as
or linking between the study’s quantitative and SPIDER. Researchers informed by these criteria
qualitative phases (Tashakkoria and Teddlie 2010, and characteristics are likely to identify important
Creswell and Plano Clark 2011). aspects of research questions and develop successful
Overall, good research questions are the basis of research projects (Farrugia et al 2010). However,
good research as they enable researchers to identify while researchers can refer to these criteria in
what they want to know and to work from knowing
less towards knowing more (Payne and Payne 2004). Table 2 Types of qualitative research question
Identifying what you want to know more about is
essential. Researchers can be vague at the beginning Type What it does
of a study about what they want to know and
unclear questions can lead to an unfocused project Contextual Describes the form or nature of what exists
(White 2009). Researchers should aim to write clear,
articulated questions that enable them to find the Explanatory Examines the reasons for or associations between what exists
answers in a focused, clear way.
Evaluative Appraises the effectiveness of what exists
Criteria One difficulty in writing good research
questions is that there are potentially an unlimited Generative Provides new ideas, aiding the development of theories, strategies
number of them. Without a clear, focused research or actions
question, it is difficult to know how or what to
research (Grove et al 2013). While researchers may Ideological Advances the ideology of a position
appreciate that if they do not know what questions
they are asking, there is little hope of finding any Exploratory Investigates a phenomenon where little is understood
answers, this may only add stress to an already
tense situation. Explanatory Explains a phenomenon
Common problems encountered when developing
a research question include: deciding which area to Descriptive Tries to describe a phenomenon
research from a range of issues that are of interest;
knowing which area to focus on with no precise Emancipatory Engages in social action related to a phenomenon
topic; and knowing the area and topic but finding it (Ritchie et al 2014, Marshall and Rossman 2011)
problematic to clearly communicate the question.

© RCNi / NURSE RESEARCHER March 2016 | Volume 23 | Number 4 21


Downloaded from RCNi.com by ${individualUser.displayName} on Jun 20, 2016. For personal use only. No other uses without permission.
Copyright © 2016 RCNi Ltd. All rights reserved.
Nurse Researcher

identifying important general aspects of a research long‑term aim is and describe the overall purpose
question, a more specific format should be (what should be accomplished) in general terms.
considered when developing specific research This ultimately enables the reader to judge
questions (Farrugia et al 2010). whether the researcher has achieved that purpose
Richardson et al’s (1995) format for quantitative (Tully 2014). In this context, the Newman et al
research is: (2003) framework can be used to identify nine types
■■ Population, patient, problem. of aim. These are to:
■■ Intervention. ■■ Predict.
■■ Comparison. ■■ Add to the knowledge base.
■■ Outcome. ■■ Have a personal, social, institutional,
This format is known as PICO. and/or organisational impact.
Kahn et al’s (2003) format for qualitative ■■ Measure change.
research is: ■■ Understand complex phenomena.
■■ Population, problem. ■■ Test new ideas.
■■ Exposure. ■■ Generate new ideas.
■■ Outcome or theme. ■■ Inform constituencies.
This format is known as PEO. ■■ Examine the past.
These methods have been used in evidence-based
practice to frame and answer clinical questions Objectives Determining the research’s aim leads
(Huang et al 2006), develop strategies for searching naturally to determining its objectives. Research
literature (Schardt et al 2007), and frame research objectives are more specific than the aim and relate
questions (Aslam and Emmanuel 2010). Once a directly to the research question (Grove et al 2014,
research question has been identified, the research Parahoo 2014). They may be divided into ‘primary’
aim and objectives are developed. Developing a (bound to be achieved) and ‘secondary’ (incidental)
research question can be difficult, as can stating the objectives (Newell and Burnard 2011), and should
research aim and objectives (Blaikie 2009). be: closely related to the research question, cover
all aspects of the problem, specific, ordered in a
Aims The researcher must be cognisant that logical sequence, achievable, take into consideration
the research’s question, aim and objectives are the available resources, including time, and
inextricably linked. To determine the study’s mutually exclusive of each other. They should also
aim, the researcher must decide what its overall, be stated using action verbs that can be evaluated,

References
Agee J (2009) Developing qualitative research Creswell JW (2009) Research Design: Doran GT (1981) There’s a SMART way to Huang X, Lin J, Demner-Fushman D
questions: a reflective process. International Qualitative, Quantitative and Mixed write management’s goals and objectives. (2006) Evaluation of PICO as a knowledge
Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education. Methods Approaches. Third edition. Sage, Management Review. 70, 11, 35-36. representation for clinical questions. AMIA
22, 4, 431-447. Thousand Oaks CA. Annual Symposium Proceedings. 359-363.
Farrugia P, Petrisor BA, Farrokhyar F et al
Aslam S, Emmanuel P (2010) Formulating Creswell JW (2013) Qualitative Inquiry (2010) Research questions, hypotheses and Hulley SB, Cummings SR, Browner WS et al
a researchable question: a critical step for and Research Design: Choosing Among objectives. Canadian Journal of Surgery. (2007) Designing Clinical Research.
facilitating good clinical research. Indian Five Approaches. Third edition. Sage, 53, 4, 278-281. Third edition. Lippincott Williams and Wilkins,
Journal of Sexually Transmitted Diseases and Thousand Oaks CA. Philadelphia PA.
Grove SK, Burns N, Gray JR (2013) The Practice
AIDS. 31, 1, 47-50.
Creswell JW (2014) Educational Research: of Nursing Research: Appraisal, Synthesis, Johnson RB, Christensen LB (2014) Educational
Blaikie N (2007) Approaches to Social Enquiry. Planning, Conducting, and Evaluating and Generation of Evidence. Seventh edition. Research: Quantitative, Qualitative, And
Second edition. Polity Press, Cambridge. Quantitative and Qualitative Research. Elsevier Saunders, St Louis MO. Mixed Approaches. Fifth edition. Sage,
Fifth edition. Pearson Education, Upper Saddle Thousand Oaks CA.
Blaikie N (2009) Designing Social Research. Grove SK, Gray JR, Burns N (2014)
River NJ.
Second edition. Polity Press, Cambridge. Understanding Nursing Research: Building Kahn KS, Kunz R, Kleijnen J et al (2003)
Creswell JW, Plano Clark VL (2011) Designing An Evidence-Based Practice. Sixth edition. Systematic Reviews To Support Evidence-Based
Cooke A, Smith D, Booth A (2012) Beyond
and Conducting Mixed Methods Research. Elsevier Saunders, St Louis MO. Medicine: How to Review and Apply Findings
PICO: the SPIDER tool for qualitative evidence
Second edition. Sage, Thousand Oaks CA. of Healthcare Research. Royal Society of
synthesis. Qualitative Health Research. Hennink M, Hutter I, Bailey A (2011)
Medicine Press, London.
22, 10, 1435-1443. Qualitative Research Methods. Sage,
Thousand Oaks CA.

22 March 2016 | Volume 23 | Number 4 © RCNi / NURSE RESEARCHER


Downloaded from RCNi.com by ${individualUser.displayName} on Jun 20, 2016. For personal use only. No other uses without permission.
Copyright © 2016 RCNi Ltd. All rights reserved.
Question development

such as ‘to describe’, ‘to identify’, ‘to measure’ ■■ Realistic: do you have the resources to make
or ‘to compare’. the objective happen?
Johnson and Christensen (2014) offer five typical ■■ Time specific: state when you will achieve
research objectives: ‘exploration’, ‘description’, the objective.
‘explanation’, ‘prediction’ and ‘influence’. Qualitative These criteria are collectively known as SMART.
and quantitative research studies can be linked It should be acknowledged that there is some
to one or more of these five research objectives debate as to whether research aims and objectives
(Onwuegbuzie and Leech 2006): are required for all studies, and whether either or
■■ ‘Exploration’ involves using mainly inductive both are necessary. This is evident in published
methods to discover a concept, construct, studies where only the research aim or the
phenomenon or situation and advance objectives are identified. This may be because
understanding, hypotheses or generalisations. only one was set or only one was identified in the
■■ ‘Description’ involves identifying and describing published work.
the antecedents, nature and aetiology of
a phenomenon. Conclusion
■■ ‘Explanation’ involves developing theory for the Developing a good research question, aim and
purpose of explaining the relationships among objective is a vital aspect of research. This can be
concepts or phenomena and determining reasons challenging. It is essential that you take the time to
for the existence of events. do this systematically as the eventual success of the
■■ ‘Prediction’ refers to using pre-existing knowledge study relies on asking a suitable and clear question.
or theory to predict what will occur at a later The question must be grounded in research,
point in time. coherent, clear and ask precisely what you want
■■ ‘Influence’ relates to manipulation of the setting to find out. Knowing this will help you plan the
or variable to produce an anticipated outcome. project and identify the methodology, sample, data
Doran’s (1981) criteria can be applied when setting collection and data analysis necessary.
Online archive
research objectives. These are: Developing the research question, aim and
■■ Specific: be exact about what you are going objective is an interactive and inductive process For related information, visit
our online archive and search
to accomplish. that takes place over time, through consultations using the keywords
■■ Measurable: quantify the objectives. with a supervisor, knowledgeable people, published
■■ Appropriate: align with the needs of the literature, and use of the appropriate criteria (FINER Conflict of interest
target audience. and SPIDER) and format (PICO and PEO). None declared

Kloda LA, Bartlett JC (2013) Formulating Newell R, Burnard P (2011) Research for Parahoo K (2014) Nursing Research: Principles, Tashakkori A, Teddlie C (2010) Sage Handbook
answerable questions: question negotiation Evidence-Based Practice In Healthcare. First Process and Issues. Palgrave MacMillan, of Mixed Methods In Social and Behavioral
in evidence-based practice. Journal of the edition. John Wiley and Sons, Oxford. Basingstoke. Research. Second edition. Sage, Thousand
Canadian Health Libraries Association. Oaks CA.
Newman I, Ridenour CS, Newman C et al Payne G, Payne J (2004) Key Concepts in Social
34, 2, 55-60.
(2003) A typology of research purposes Research. Sage, Thousand Oaks CA. Thabane L, Thomas T, Ye C et al (2009) Posing
Lipowski EE (2008) Developing great research and its relationship to mixed methods. the research question: not so simple. Canadian
Richardson WS, Wilson MC, Nishikawa J et al
questions. American Journal of Health-System In Tashakkori A, Teddlie C (Eds) Journal of Anaesthesia. 56, 1, 71-79.
(1995) The well-built clinical question: a key to
Pharmacy. 65, 17, 1667-1670. Handbook Of Mixed Methods In Social and
evidence based-decisions. ACP Journal Club. Tully MP (2014) Research: articulating
Behavioral Research. First edition. Sage,
Marshall C, Rossman GB (2011) Designing 123, 3, A12-A13. questions, generating hypotheses, and choosing
Thousand Oaks CA.
Qualitative Research. Fifth edition. study designs. Canadian Journal of Hospital
Ritchie J, Lewis J, McNaughton Nicholls C et al
Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks CA. Onwuegbuzie AJ, Leech NL (2006) Linking Pharmacy. 67, 1, 31-34.
(2014) Qualitative Research Practice: A Guide
research questions to mixed methods data
Martindale S, Taylor R (2014) Alternative for Social Science Students and Researchers. White P (2009) Developing Research Questions:
analysis procedures. Qualitative Report.
and complementary research approaches. Second edition. Sage, Thousand Oaks CA. A Guide for Social Scientists. Palgrave MacMillan,
11, 3, 474-498.
In Taylor R (Ed) The Essentials of Nursing and Basingstoke.
Schardt C, Adams MB, Owens T et al (2007)
Healthcare Research. Sage, Thousand Oaks CA. Onwuegbuzie AJ, Leech NL (2007) Sampling
Utilization of the PICO framework to improve
designs in qualitative research: making the
Maxwell JA (2013) Qualitative Research Design: searching PubMed for clinical questions. BMC
sampling process more public. Qualitative
An Interactive Approach. Third edition. Sage, Medical Informatics and Decision Making. 7, 16.
Report. 12, 2, 238-254.
Thousand Oaks CA.

© RCNi / NURSE RESEARCHER March 2016 | Volume 23 | Number 4 23


Downloaded from RCNi.com by ${individualUser.displayName} on Jun 20, 2016. For personal use only. No other uses without permission.
Copyright © 2016 RCNi Ltd. All rights reserved.

You might also like