Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Daniela Drago, Markus Yap & Ozgur Ekmekci (2016): Increasing the odds
of effective drug development: Elevating regulatory affairs professionals to strategic partners,
Clinical Research and Regulatory Affairs, DOI: 10.3109/10601333.2016.1152661
Article views: 4
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Regulatory strategy;
important that regulatory affairs play an active and strategic role in this sector; and proposes a new regulatory education;
educational perspective to facilitate the recognition and acceptance of regulatory affairs competencies
professionals as strategic partners.
CONTACT Daniela Drago drago@gwu.edu George Washington University, 2100 Pennsylvania Avenue, Suite 362, 20037 Washington, DC, USA
reduction of costs (7). This change is visible in many Although the estimation of the cost of drug develop-
organizations, including the pharmaceutical and biotech ment is not yet grounded in a uniformly accepted
industries (8,9). Companies operating in a high-regulated standard, the reported development cost for the average
environment must face additional challenges. drug may reach up to USD 2.6 billion (the figure is based
Mainly in response to new technologies, increasing on information provided by 10 pharmaceutical compa-
regulations, and improved understanding and expect- nies stating an investment of $1.4 billion in R&D
ations of patients’ needs, the regulatory landscape has development plus $1.2 billion investment in ‘time
evolved dramatically (10). From a technology perspec- cost’) (15).
tive, recent years have seen a remarkable drive towards At a time when R&D costs continue to increase, and
personalized medicine, advancements in genomic map- business models continue to change, the ability to
ping, and novel mAb therapies for oncology, which obtain first-cycle product approvals is probably one of
initiated a number of changes. the most significant indicators of the performance of a
pharmaceutical company. In 2010, a white paper pub-
Box 1. 23andMe and Personalized Genetic Testing (PGT)
lished by Parexel Consulting estimated that getting a
services.
new drug through the approval process at first attempt
After 13 years of multiple international teams’ collaborations, in 2003 the
Human Genome Project to sequence the entire human genome was
in the US is worth, on average, almost USD400 million in
completed, opening the pathway for Personalized Medicine, defined as sales (16). Additionally, the increased attention to
customized diagnostics and therapy based on an individual’s unique effective risk management at a governance level would
Downloaded by [Gazi University] at 09:17 30 March 2016
Given this overall context, it is puzzling that leaders of governance structure. As a result, the role of a number
regulatory functions in many organizations do not report of functions (such as Finance, Human Resources (HR),
directly to the CEO. An analysis of the organizational and Information Technology (IT)) has shifted dramatic-
structure of large and mid-size pharmaceutical compa- ally. Although leadership has traditionally viewed these
nies located in the US, conducted in 2012 by KPMG, departments as merely operational areas, the mentioned
revealed that less than 25% regulatory affairs functions departments have transformed into functions with ever
report to a C-level executive (19). Since, for similar increasing influence to become key strategic partners
compliance and ethics functions from both private and (25–27). Professionals in these functions have become
public companies, in addition to non-profits, this percent- valued members of the executive management team
age does not fall below 40% (19,20), it is fair to suggest and active participants in the decision-making process.
that regulatory affairs functions do not receive adequate Inclusion of HR and IT in strategic planning has also
representation in board rooms, as strategic partners. improved employees’ and the leadership teams’ percep-
tions of such functions. In the early 1990s, Schuler (28)
had already emphasized the opportunity for the HR
Importance for regulatory affairs professionals
function to transition from an ‘employee advocate’ to a
to play an active and strategic role in the
‘member of the management team’. To be successful in
biopharmaceutical industry
this shift, he recommended to HR professionals to be
When ties to the C-suite are weak, a function risks being concerned with the bottom line, profits, and organiza-
Downloaded by [Gazi University] at 09:17 30 March 2016
In organizations where the regulatory affairs function better balance executive’s perceptions from ‘overly
is involved only in a passive manner—for example by cautious’ gatekeepers to going to market enablers.
asking this function to fix a problem after the fact, rather In the last several years, there have been positive
than help preventing it from happening—professionals developments regarding the perceived role of regulatory
working in this function may become alienated. Failing affairs professionals. For example, in a report of the
to consider the regulatory implications of a specific Regulatory Affairs Professional Society (RAPS) in 2010,
course of action can be disastrous for an organization. the organization published data on self-perception of
Making mid-course corrections when trying to get regulatory professionals, in which respondents rated the
products on the market not only wastes valuable time, ‘perceived value and importance of regulatory profes-
but also it may lead to significant economic costs. There sionals by senior and executive management in their
are many where the lack of regulatory professionals’ organization’ (p. 1) (36). Results indicate that the image
imprint may have resulted into a substantial impact on of the profession improved over the years. On average,
the business outcome of regulated products. The regulatory professionals working in industry reported
majority does not catch the media’s attention, or even that they believed senior and executive management in
surface to the public’s knowledge, or can be substan- their organization perceived them as ‘valuable’ (using a
tiated by publicly available information. They are less 5-point scale from ‘highly valuable’ to ‘not at all
apparent than 23andMe or Theranos and tend to be valuable’). In spite of what seem to be promising
intertwined with proprietary knowledge that is not recent developments, overcoming a negative image
Downloaded by [Gazi University] at 09:17 30 March 2016
that promotes and fortifies the profession’s strategic evolving demands placed on today’s workforce.
role. Additionally, it puts the regulatory field on the same
So, what types of competencies should today’s type of trajectory as other healthcare disciplines (40–42).
regulatory affairs professionals focus on developing as This vision inspires a blueprint to ensure that the
they strive to be recognized as strategic partners? The regulatory function is seen as a consistent strategic
trends may vary, although not substantially, by geog- member of the drug development team. The trend is
raphy, product categories (e.g. medical devices vs that members of these teams, similarly to healthcare
pharmaceuticals), and by company (due to different teams, focus on a culture of competency-based educa-
companies’ cultures and priorities). Nevertheless, we tion with both discipline-specific and, beyond that,
have seen some clear signals about how regulatory shared, team-based, inter-professional competencies.
affairs jobs are evolving and can identify some of the key There is a strong call for the educational regulatory
skills that companies seek now. community to put the strategy domain at the forefront
The luxury of educating new regulatory affairs of the core curriculum for regulatory educational
professionals only internally—by way of on-the-job programs. With this article, we hope to stimulate
exposure training—is no longer a sustainable model discussion about the status and future direction of
for many companies, which is why alternative avenues, regulatory education and how it will contribute to
including elevating the role of academic institutions in advancing drug development globally. Such dialogue
formally educating the next generation of regulatory will hopefully lead to action that strengthens regulatory
Downloaded by [Gazi University] at 09:17 30 March 2016
professionals, has been explored (39). To help prepare education. We believe this is key to equip the next
regulatory affairs professionals for the new challenges generations of regulatory professionals not only with
facing them, some academic institutions have begun to core competencies to succeed in their respective fields,
incorporate new competencies into their curricula and but also to allow them to lead change and play a key
to offer innovative Regulatory Affairs/Science programs. role in the delivery of safe, high quality, effective, and
For that matter, as we glance at the future of the accessible medicinal products.
profession, strategy has been identified as one of the five
key competency domains that should drive the way
regulatory affairs professionals receive their formal Disclosure statement
education (39). The ability to function effectively as M. Yap is a staff member at the FDA. The views and
part of inter-professional teams; apply lessons learned opinions expressed in this paper are those of the authors
from the past towards solving future problems; partici- and do not represent FDA’s views or policies. The
pate in the formulation of approaches to support authors have no other relevant affiliations or financial
strategic enterprise-level objectives; and walk the fine involvement with any organization or entity with a
line between ensuring compliance and promoting financial interest in or financial conflict with the subject
innovational thinking constitute the principle elements matter or materials discussed in the manuscript apart
of a comprehensive educational foundation on which from those disclosed.
regulatory affairs professionals can build careers that
involve valuable strategic contributions.
While the changes in regulatory landscape may seem References
daunting, they provide an opportunity for the commu- 1. Page M. The regulatory affairs function as a global
nity of regulatory educators, academics, and practi- development strategic partner. Regulatory Rapporteur
tioners. Indeed, the growing belief that regulatory 2014;11:4–6.
2. Li NL. NDA submission strategy for new chemical entity
strategy is vital to increase the odds of drug develop-
(NCE) products in Asia Pacific Countries to reduce drug
ment sets forth a new vision wherein regulatory educa- lag. Boston, Massachusetts: DIA 2013 49th Annual
tion plays a decisive role. We believe in the need for a Meeting, 2013.
transformation in regulatory education, beyond the 3. Keramidas S. Perspectives on the regulatory profession
traditional on-the-job training, and invite our colleagues and its critical role in the global health product sector. The
to join us in creatively envisioning it. Clearly defining Monitor 2013;August:13–16.
4. Ukwu HN. Global regulatory affairs—role in the bio-
how regulatory professionals are academically prepared,
pharmaceutical industry. Global regulatory systems: a
their competencies, and their scope of practice is a strategic primer for biopharmaceutical product develop-
pivotal step. ment and registration. CenterWatch; 2011. p 31.
Competency-based regulatory education, which must 5. Berry D, Saias P, Williams B. Unlocking hidden value
include a strategy domain, helps the regulatory field to within regulatory affairs. Delaware: KPMG Healthcare &
chart its educational expectations in response to the Life Sciences; 2014.
6 D. DRAGO ET AL.
12. Medical Device Innovation Consortium (MDIC). MDIC function: Transformation or demise? Executive
patient-centered benefit-risk project report: a framework 1990;4:49–60.
for incorporating information on patient preferences 29. Regulatory Affairs Professional Society (RAPS). Rockville,
regarding benefit and risk into regulatory assessments of Maryland: Regulatory professionals: valued strategic part-
new medical technology. St. Louis Park, MN: MDIC; 2015. ners. Available online at: http://www.prweb.com/releases/
13. Claiborne AB, Olson S, editors. Strengthening a workforce 2010/StrategicPartners/prweb4705764.htm, accessed 9
for innovative regulatory science in therapeutics develop- December 2015.
ment: workshop summary. Washington, D.C.: National 30. Yarbrough C. Why regulatory intelligence is more import-
Academies Press; 2012. ant than ever. Erie, PA: Pharmaceutical online; 2013.
14. Dolgin E. Big pharma moves from ‘‘blockbusters’’ to ‘‘niche
Available online at: http://www.pharmaceuticalonline.-
busters’’. Nat Med 2010;16:837.
com/doc/why-regulatory-intelligence-is-more-important-
15. DiMasi JA, Grabowski HG, Hansen RW. Cost to develop
than-ever-0001, accessed 9 December 2015.
and win marketing approval for a new drug is $2.6 billion.
31. 23andMe. 23andMe takes first step toward FDA clearance.
Boston MA: Tufts University; 2014. Available online at:
23andMe Press Release. 2012. Available online at: https://
http://csdd. tufts. edu/news/complete_story/pr_tufts_
www.23andme.com/about/press/fda_application/,
csdd_2014_cost_study, accessed 9 December 2015
accessed 9 December 2015.
16. Parexel Consulting. Drug innovation, approval, market
32. 23andMe wants FDA approval. Bonnie Rochman: Time
access, and the ‘‘new normal’’. Emerging FDA review
Magazine; 2012. Available online at: http://healthland.ti-
outcome trends for new drugs. Waltham, MA: White
me.com/2012/08/02/23andme-wants-fda-approval-for-
Paper; 2010.
personal-dna-testing-what-can-it-reveal/, accessed 9
17. Genentech, Inc. Herceptin development timeline.
Available online at: http://www.gene.com/media/product- December 2015.
information/herceptin-development-timeline, accessed 9 33. 23andMe founder Anne Wojcicki’s $99 DNA Revolution.
December 2015. Fast Company; 2013. Available online at: http://www.fast-
18. Cohen R. HerceptinÕ : Breaking New Ground. Cancer company.com/3018598/for-99-this-ceo-can-tell-you-what-
biotherapy and radiopharmaceuticals. 1999;14:1–4. might-kill-you-inside-23andme-founder-anne-wojcickis-
19. KPMG LLP. Cutting edge information. Delaware: KPMG; dna-r, accessed 9 December 2015.
2012. 34. FDA warning letter 23andMe. Available online at: http://
20. Jaeger J. More compliance departments reporting directly www.fda.gov/ICECI/EnforcementActions/WarningLetters/
to the CEO. Delaware, USA: Wilmington Compliance Week 2013/ucm376296.htm, accessed 9 December 2015.
Inc; 2013. Available online at: http://www.compliance- 35. Park A. Genetic testing company 23andMe returns to
week.com/news/news-article/more-compliance-depart- market. New York: Time Oct; 2015. Available online at:
ments-reporting-directly-to-the-ceo#.VQroNfnF_DU, http://time.com/4080583/23andme-dna-genetic-testing/,
accessed 9 December 2015. accessed 9 December 2015.
21. Parloff R. This CEO is out for blood. New York: Fortune; 36. Regulatory Affairs Professional Society (RAPS). Rockville,
2014. Available online at: http://fortune.com/2014/06/12/ Maryland: Regulatory professionals: valued strategic part-
theranos-blood-holmes/, accessed 9 December 2015. ners; 2010. Available online at: http://www.prweb.com/
22. Carreyrou J. Hot startup Theranos has struggled with its releases/2010/StrategicPartners/prweb4705764.htm,
blood-test technology. The Wall Street Journal, Oct 16, 2015. accessed 9 December 2015.
23. Carreyrou J. Hot startup Theranos dials back lab tests at 37. Madhavan G, Oakley B, Kun LG, et al. Career development
FDA’s behest. The Wall Street Journal; 2015. Available in bioengineering and biotechnology. New York, NY:
online at: http://www.wsj.com/articles/hot-startup- Springer; 2008.
CLINICAL RESEARCH AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS 7