You are on page 1of 25

Group 4

Messy Urbanism:
Understanding Other Cities
of Asia
Case Study
Little Manila, Hongkong
location
Little Manila, Hongkong
affirmed the employer’s status

cheaper
“modern” type easy to communicate
with

emergence
Philippines Migrant Workers

1970 1973
Hong Kong shifted from an industry-based to a Policies for allowing foreign national workers to work as
service-oriented economy. domestic helpers.
interactions
border

locals foreign
workers
Perceive as holiday destination
“eyesore”

places for leisure and pleasure


activities - do not have a place
“invading” “taking over” of their own

“nuisance” “too
noisy,” “dirty”
activities language

adaptation
“sensuous geographies” brings the focus to the
everyday practices of migrant workers.

emotional
blanket
Loneliness and Homesickness
results
“Messy Geography”
SPECTER -
CENTRAL

Foreign
“metaphorize the dominant order” Workers

Ackbar Abbas’s semiotic analysis of Central suggests


that the urban cityscape upholds the symbolic borders focauldian -
of political and economic power. (Ackbar Abbas) panoptic
gaze
LE PERRUQUE - THE WIG
The ability to slip between formal structures and rules and to recognize the limits of what it can get aways with

Tactics cause by Absence of Power

Times, Opportunities, Power

Liminal Spaces

Trompe l’oeil - tricks


The temporal and transient nature that characterize little manila
also symbolize, to a large extent, the plight of the philippino
population in Hong Kong - both share the liminal space of being an HOST//GUEST//
exception to the norm. PARASITES
POPULATION I
N
HONG KONG
C
IDENTIFIABLE L
U WORKER
D PHILIPINO
E
D
-
CLASSIFIABLE DESCRIABLE O ACTIVITIES
PARASITE
U
T
LOCALS
PROBLEM FOR WORKER
in messy urbanism.

They do not belong and are not regarded as part of the host country.

THREATEN THE SYSTEM


POACHERS IS THERE A
BURDEN FOR SOCIETY GOOD
PARASITES
RISK AND JEOPARDY GUEST ARE FOREIGN ?
PARASITE
YES.

“STEAL OUR RICE BOWL”


FORMING
DIVERSITY
Conclusion
Adaptation of environment is the consequences towards
the organization and perspective of power in little manila
and it is heavily linked with the perception of law use in a In little Manila migrant
space to see the activities as legalize structures. workers do not vandalize
The parasite interrupts the system, but new system form, the face of Hong Kong,
and the host becomes the parasite and so on and so forth
they are what
until the chain becomes a complex system of relationships
that is the society. makes Hong Kong.
They ignore that eradication brings with it the message
and the documented the system of which they themselves
as parasites are part.

You might also like