Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Impacto Dos Carboidratos No Reganh de Peso
Impacto Dos Carboidratos No Reganh de Peso
CURRENT
OPINION Impact of carbohydrates on weight regain
Anja Bosy-Westphal a,b and Manfred J. Müller b
Purpose of review
Research on obesity treatment has shifted its focus from weight loss to weight-loss maintenance strategies.
The conventional approach of a low-fat diet is challenged by insights from glycemic effects of
carbohydrates on body weight regulation.
Recent findings
Metabolic and endocrine adaptations to weight loss that contribute to weight regain involve reduced
energy expenditure, increased insulin sensitivity, and enhanced orexigenic signals. This review summarizes
the impact of carbohydrates on energetic efficiency, partitioning of weight regain as fat and lean mass,
and appetite control. Both the amount and frequency of postprandial glycemia add to body weight
regulation after weight loss and strengthen the concept of glycemic index and glycemic load. In addition,
dietary fiber and slowly or poorly absorbable functional sugars modify gastrointestinal peptides involved in
appetite and metabolic regulation and exert prebiotic effects.
Summary
Current evidence suggests that a low-glycemic load diet with a preference for low-glycemic index foods
and integration of slowly digestible, poorly absorbable carbohydrates may improve weight-loss
maintenance. Future studies should investigate the health benefits of low glycemic functional sweeteners
(e.g., isomaltulose and tagatose).
Keywords
carbohydrates, glycemic index, glycemic load, weight loss, weight regain
concept for prevention of weight regain is a low-fat [4 ,5 ,6,7]. We provide a comparative evaluation
diet that may be beneficial for weight management of these studies and discuss the drawbacks of
because of a low energy density with a high satiety
value that prevents passive overconsumption. A a
Institute of Nutritional Medicine, University Hohenheim, Stuttgart and
low-fat diet can theoretically be high in protein that b
Institute of Human Nutrition and Food Science, Christian-Albrechts
facilitates weight maintenance by its satiating and University of Kiel, Kiel, Germany
thermogenic effects [2]. A low-fat diet is, however, Correspondence to Professor Anja Bosy-Westphal, Institut für Ernäh-
usually high in carbohydrate and, therefore, also in rungsmedizin, Universität Hohenheim, Fruhwirthstr. 12, 70593 Stuttgart,
glycemic load (especially if carbohydrates with a Germany. Tel: +49 (0)711/459 24690; fax: +49 (0)711/459 24699;
high glycemic index are chosen) and may thus e-mail: Anja.Bosy-Westphal@uni-hohenheim.de
facilitate a positive energy balance. First results have Curr Opin Clin Nutr Metab Care 2015, 18:389–394
shown that a low-glycemic index and/or glycemic DOI:10.1097/MCO.0000000000000193
1363-1950 Copyright ß 2015 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved. www.co-clinicalnutrition.com
The effect of carbohydrates on appetite control of insulin, C-peptide, glucagon, and GIP, and
during weight-loss maintenance is only partly increased GLP-1 that resulted in an increased insu-
&&
explained by the concept of glycemic index and/or lin-to-glucagon ratio compared with sucrose [27 ].
glycemic load. First, it seems contradictory that a These mechanisms argue in favor of slowly or poorly
primary mechanism by which starches are thought absorbable functional sugars such as isomaltulose
to regulate satiety and food intake is through their (produced by enzymatic rearrangement of the gly-
blood glucose-raising effect whereas previous reviews cosidic bond between glucose and fructose from an
have claimed that consumption of high-glycemic a-1.2 linkage of sucrose to an a-1.6-glycosidic bond)
index foods increases hunger and decreases satiety and tagatose (an L-epimer of D-fructose with an
levels in short-term human intervention studies (for a inversion at C4) that are low-glycemic index, have
review, see [18]). In line with the latter finding, a prebiotic effects on gut microbiota, and offer a great
lower energy intake is observed with a low-glycemic potential for improved metabolic and body weight
index vs. high-glycemic index diet [19,20]. This could regulation and therefore deserve greater attention
be explained by a prevention of excessive postpran- and further research.
dial insulin secretion that leads to a transient appe-
tite-stimulating hypoglycemia. Alternatively, fiber-
related effects independent of glycemic index could Carbohydrates may affect the dynamics of
affect appetite control. Fermentable carbohydrates weight regain but are unlikely to prevent
such as inulin, oligofructose (fructans), as well as regain per se
indigestible carbohydrates (dietary fiber and resistant It is often claimed that maintaining a large weight
starch) have been shown to affect appetite-regulating loss requires substantial behavioral efforts to over-
&
hormones in humans [21 ]. A whole grain barley come the metabolic and endocrine adaptation to
kernel product, rich in intrinsic indigestible carbo- weight loss that causes a drive to weight regain.
hydrates increased the release of glucagon-like pep- However, although the weight regain-promoting
tide 1 (GLP-1) and reduced subsequent energy intake actions of the discussed mechanisms seem obvious,
&
[21 ]. Moreover, the end products of bacterial fer- they remain largely speculative, as human evidence
mentation, short-chain fatty acids, have been shown demonstrating causal relations between these fac-
to regulate expression of gut hormones implicated in tors and weight regain is scarce or lacking [28]. The
satiety [22]. main cause of relapse to a positive energy balance
On the contrary, detrimental effects on appetite and weight regain is likely to be the lack of
regulation have been found for high intakes of adaptation of energy intake to a lower energy
the low-glycemic index sugar fructose: diminished requirement. After weight loss, reduction in
suppression of acyl ghrelin in response to fructose energy requirement is due to a decrease in resting
was observed in insulin-sensitive obese compared energy expenditure, thermic effect of food and
with lean adolescents whereas insulin-resistant energy expenditure for a certain physical activity
obese study participants also had an impaired ghre- that is partly due to a decrease in body weight, a
lin suppression to glucose ingestion [23]. Increased decline in activity levels and change in body com-
fructose consumption may thus promote hunger position, and, to a lesser extent, increased meta-
and overeating. These drawbacks of fructose com- bolic efficiency [7]. Although the chronic positive
pared with glucose are, however, highly controver- energy balance that led to overweight and obesity is
sial and dose dependent with some results showing mainly because of behavioral rather than metabolic
no difference between high-fructose corn syrup and factors, this does not justify blaming relapse into
sucrose on basal and postprandial levels of energy- old habits as a major driver for weight regain. The
regulating hormones (insulin, leptin, and ghrelin) failure to adapt energy intake to a suddenly lower
at normal human consumption levels [24]. level of energy requirement is a consistent bio-
In addition to the similar effects on energy- logical phenomenon that not only applies to
regulating hormones, short-term overfeeding with obesity relapse during weight-loss maintenance
fructose or glucose both contribute to insulin resist- but also contributes to weight gain after pregnancy,
ance and fatty liver [25]. Recent results in mice have increased waist circumference after detraining in
shown that a slower absorption of simple carbo- competitive athletes, spontaneous positive energy
hydrates and reduced postprandial insulin and balance during physically inactive metabolic ward
glucose-dependent insulinotropic peptide (GIP) conditions, and increase in BMI after spinal cord
&
levels can prevent liver fat accumulation [26 ]. Also injury and smoking cessation. Even the increase in
in patients with type 2 diabetes, ingestion of slowly energy requirement during rapid growth (e.g.,
absorbed isomaltulose attenuates postprandial catch-up growth after a low birth weight and
hyperglycemia, decreased plasma concentrations growth during puberty) may convey a higher risk
1363-1950 Copyright ß 2015 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved. www.co-clinicalnutrition.com 391
*
35 16
iAUC (mmol/l/14h)
tAUC (mmol/l/7h)
30 14
8 25 12
20 10
8
15
6
10 4
7 5 2
0 0
LGI HGI LGI HGI
Interstitial glucose (mmol/I)
Incremental AUC
4
3 LGI
Total AUC HGI
2
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
0
.0
.0
.0
.0
.0
.0
.0
.0
.0
.0
.0
.0
.0
.0
(h)
0.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
FIGURE 1. Glycemic responses over 24 h for the low-glycemic index (LGI, dark grey symbols) and high-glycemic index
(HGI, light grey symbols) diet groups. Incremental areas under the glucose–response curve during daytime (iAUC-CGMday,
08.00–22.00 h) and total areas under the glucose–response curve during nighttime (tAUC-CGMnight 0–07.00 h) are shown
as an insert. Adapted with permission from [21 ]. &
for the development of obesity. With respect to the peroxisome proliferator activated receptor c, or liver
impact of carbohydrates, there is evidence that X receptor). Both the amount and frequency of
these vulnerable phases benefit from a low-glyce- postprandial glycemia, therefore, add to body
mic index/low-glycemic load diet, for example, weight regulation after weight loss and strengthen
during pregnancy [20,29] and puberty [30]. In the concept of glycemic index and glycemic load.
addition, a lower energy density of food (that can
be achieved by a lower fat and sugar content) also Methods and design of carbohydrate:
ameliorates or even prevents a high spontaneous weight regain studies
energy intake at a low energy requirement under Studies investigating the effect of diet composition
metabolic ward conditions. on energy balance during weight-loss/maintenance
In addition to glycemic index and energy sometimes use body weight as an outcome variable
density, the frequency of high-glycemic index [3] whereas others also investigated fat and fat-free
& &&
carbohydrate intake may be relevant to weight gain mass [4 ,5 ]. Despite methodological difficulties of
and energy partitioning as fat. A hypercaloric diet body composition measurement during unstable
especially with a high sugar content increased liver conditions of weight changes [32], information of
fat and abdominal fat only with high meal fre- changes in fat mass are indispensable for interpret-
quency but not with increasing meal size [31] ation of changes in energy balance. A high-glycemic
suggesting that a continuous flow of nutrients to load diet could theoretically lead to a lower weight
hepatocytes (rather than cycles of fasting and feed- regain that is not due to a less positive energy
ing) stimulates de-novo lipogenesis (e.g., through balance but a higher regain in fat mass with a high
induction of carbohydrate-responsive transcription energetic equivalent. In addition, the composition
factors such as carbohydrate-responsive element- and therefore the amount of weight regain within a
binding protein or insulin-mediated induction certain time period is not independent from the
of sterol regulatory element-binding protein 1c, composition and amount of weight loss [32]. These
1363-1950 Copyright ß 2015 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved. www.co-clinicalnutrition.com 393
20. McGowan CA, Walsh JM, Byrne J, et al. The influence of a low glycemic index 27. Ang M, Linn T. Comparison of the effects of slowly and rapidly absorbed
dietary intervention on maternal dietary intake, glycemic index and gestational && carbohydrates on postprandial glucose metabolism in type 2 diabetes mellitus
weight gain during pregnancy: a randomized controlled trial. Nutr J 2013; patients: a randomized trial. Am J Clin Nutr 2014; 100:1059–1068.
12:140. This randomized, double-blind, crossover study in patients with type 2 diabetes
21. Johansson EV, Nilsson AC, Östman EM, Björck IME. Effects of indigestible has shown that slowly absorbed isomaltulose attenuates postprandial hypergly-
& carbohydrates in barley on glucose metabolism, appetite and voluntary food cemia by reducing oral glucose appearance, enhancing GLP-1 secretion, inhibit-
intake over 16 h in healthy adults. Nutr J 2013; 12:46. ing endogenous glucose production, and increasing splanchnic glucose uptake
In this randomized crossover human trial, consumption of a high-fiber evening compared with ingestion of rapidly absorbed sucrose. The article provides
meal resulted in improved glucose regulation and GLP-1 release as well as important evidence for functional properties of lowly absorbed sugars for the
less food intake the following day and a greater excretion of breath H2 regulation of glucose homeostasis.
(marker for colonic fermentation), indicating a role of fermentation in the host 28. Ochner CN, Barrios DM, Lee CD, Pi-Sunyer FX. Biological mechanisms that
metabolism. promote weight regain following weight loss in obese humans. Physiol Behav
22. Kaji I, Karaki SI, Tanaka R, Kuwahara A. Density distribution of free fatty acid 2013; 120:106–113.
receptor 2 (FFA2)-expressing and GLP-1-producing enteroendocrine L cells 29. Knudsen VK, Heitmann BL, Halldorsson TI, et al. Maternal dietary glycaemic
in human and rat lower intestine, and increased cell numbers after ingestion of load during pregnancy and gestational weight gain, birth weight and post-
fructo-oligosaccharide. J Mol Histol 2011; 42:27–38. partum weight retention: a study within the Danish National Birth Cohort. Br J
23. Van Name M, Giannini C, Santoro N, et al. Blunted suppression of acyl-ghrelin Nutr 2013; 109:1471–1478.
in response to fructose ingestion in obese adolescents: the role of insulin 30. Murakami K, McCaffrey TA, Gallagher AM, et al. Dietary glycemic index and
resistance. Obesity (Silver Spring) 2015. [Epub ahead of print] glycemic load in relation to changes in body composition measures during
24. Yu Z, Lowndes J, Rippe J. High-fructose corn syrup and sucrose have adolescence: Northern Ireland Young Hearts Study. Int J Obes (Lond) 2014;
equivalent effects on energy-regulating hormones at normal human consump- 38:252–258.
tion levels. Nutr Res 2013; 33:1043–1052. 31. Koopman KE, Caan MW, Nederveen AJ, et al. Hypercaloric diets with
25. Lecoultre V, Egli L, Carrel G, et al. Effects of fructose and glucose overfeeding increased meal frequency, but not meal size, increase intrahepatic triglycer-
on hepatic insulin sensitivity and intrahepatic lipids in healthy humans. Obesity ides: a randomized controlled trial. Hepatology 2014; 60:545–553.
(Silver Spring) 2013; 21:782–785. 32. Bosy-Westphal A, Müller MJ. Measuring the impact of weight cycling on body
26. Keyhani-Nejad F, Irmler M, Isken F, et al. Nutritional strategy to prevent fatty composition: a methodological challenge. Curr Opin Clin Nutr Metab Care
& liver and insulin resistance independent of obesity by reducing glucose- 2014; 17:396–400.
dependent insulinotropic polypeptide responses in mice. Diabetologia 33. Alssema M, Boers HM, Ceriello A, et al. Diet and glycaemia: the markers and
2015; 58:374–383. their meaning. A report of the Unilever Nutrition Workshop. Br J Nutr 2014.
This animal study shows that the site of glucose absorption and the GIP [Epub ahead of print]
response determine liver fat accumulation and insulin resistance. Future studies 34. Calanna S, Piro S, Di Pino A, et al. Beta and alpha cell function in metabolically
need to further investigate the health benefits of isomaltulose vs. sucrose healthy but obese subjects: relationship with entero-insular axis. Obesity
in humans. (Silver Spring) 2013; 21:320–325.