You are on page 1of 10

Vol. 90 No.

4 October 2000

ORAL SURGERY
ORAL MEDICINE
ORAL PATHOLOGY

REVIEW ARTICLE

A review of perioperative corticosteroid use in


dentoalveolar surgery
Roger E. Alexander, DDS,a and Roger R. Throndson, DDS,b Dallas and Galveston, Tex
BAYLOR COLLEGE OF DENTISTRY, TEXAS A&M UNIVERSITY SYSTEM HEALTH SCIENCE CENTER, AND
UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS MEDICAL BRANCH

Objectives. Dental surgeons are often advised to use corticosteroids during and after third molar removal and other
dentoalveolar surgery to reduce postsurgical edema, but recommendations for use are rarely accompanied by definitive guid-
ance regarding the type of steroid, dosage, or duration of administration. Many regimens in use appear to be based on anec-
dotal information from articles in the 1960s and 1970s and might be subtherapeutic. Few regimens have been updated with
data from more recent studies, and well-designed comparison studies are lacking.
Study design. In this article, the literature from the past 30 years is reviewed, meaningful findings are highlighted, and avail-
able data are used as a basis for formulating interim clinical recommendations for corticosteroid use pending the emergence
of more evidence-based data. A meta-analysis of data was not performed.
Results. Recent data suggest that perioperative corticosteroid regimens should be administered in higher doses and for longer
durations than recommended in the past and should be started before surgery for optimum benefit.
Conclusions. Based on the literature review, interim recommendations for the use of corticosteroids are proposed, including
dosages and regimens that appear rational for oral, intramuscular, or intravenous corticosteroid administration before and after
extractions and other dentoalveolar surgery. These largely empiric recommendations might require adjustment when evidence-
based data become available in future studies. There is a great need for well-designed clinical research to further evaluate
protocols for corticosteroid use. (Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod 2000;90:406-15)

Many dentists routinely or episodically use cortico- cally sound philosophy regarding the use of cortico-
steroids for patients after dentoalveolar surgery, based steroids to control postsurgical sequelae in dentistry.
on generalized, nonspecific recommendations in many Our objective is to review the available contemporary
textbooks, articles, and educational forums, although literature and use that information to formulate some
the exact incidence of usage is unstudied. Rarely are interim suggestions for the rational use of cortico-
specifics mentioned regarding the type, dosage, and steroids during and after dentoalveolar surgery until
duration of administration, and the guidance does not further studies can clarify these issues and provide
appear to be founded on evidence-based studies. additional evidence-based guidelines on dose form,
Despite dozens of published articles, relatively little dosages, and duration of administration.
reliable data are available for formulating a scientifi-
SEARCH STRATEGY AND SELECTION
CRITERIA
aProfessor, Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery and
Conventional electronic databases were searched for
Pharmacology, Baylor College of Dentistry, Texas A&M University
System Health Science Center, Dallas, Tex. articles published in the last 30 years on the topic of
bAssistant Professor, Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery Division, drug use for limiting postsurgical edema. Studies
Department of Surgery, University of Texas Medical Branch, published before 1970 were not included unless they
Galveston, Tex. had some specific contribution because drugs and
Received for publication Dec 28, 1999; returned for revision Mar 24,
surgical procedures and equipment have changed over
2000 and May 4, 2000; accepted for publication Jun 20, 2000.
Copyright © 2000 by Mosby, Inc. time, and older studies might no longer be relevant to
1079-2104/2000/$12.00 + 0 7/12/109778 current practices. The identified articles were not
doi:10.1067/moe.2000.109778 subjected to any type of definitive data analyses; there-

406
ORAL SURGERY ORAL MEDICINE ORAL PATHOLOGY Alexander and Throndson 407
Volume 90, Number 4

fore, this article should be considered a comprehensive have been validated for accuracy, reproducibility, or
literature review, not a meta-analysis. statistical reliability. Because many different method-
ologies are used, data from one study cannot be easily
THE PHYSIOLOGY OF OROFACIAL compared with data from other studies. Intraoral
POSTSURGICAL EDEMA swelling is even more difficult to measure.
Surprisingly, some dentists consider edema a compli- Surgical experience and difficulty are recognized as
cation rather than a normal physiologic reaction to significant factors in the incidence and severity of post-
insult and injury. When body tissues are injured, operative complications (including edema) after
regardless of the cause, the normal physiologic dentoalveolar surgery.3,13-16 Inexperienced doctors will
response is inflammation, leading to edema. Edema, in generally encounter more postoperative edema than
varying amounts, will occur after every surgical inter- highly experienced surgeons, all other variables being
vention and should be expected. The only questions equal, even when procedures are of short duration and
concern how much edema will occur and where it will tissues are handled gently.
occur. The reader is referred to Hupp’s discussion in a The precise duration of the edema response to oral
leading contemporary oral surgery textbook1 or to the surgery has not been well documented and is probably
article by Patten et al2 for further information on the variable from patient to patient and procedure to proce-
pathophysiology of wound healing and inflammation. dure. Laskin16 states that edema maximizes in 24 to 48
Prostaglandins also might play a minor role in edema hours, but Peterson17 says it usually maximizes in 48 to
formation but do not appear to be the sole factor 72 hours and is usually resolved after the first postop-
involved.3 Studies are currently underway to clarify erative week. Any postoperative swelling that
their precise role in the process. continues to expand after 3 days is thought to be addi-
Edema occurs as osmotic pressures rise, capillary tional swelling resulting from infection and is not post-
permeability is altered, transudation of fluid occurs operative edema.17 A 2-day to 3-day time frame is most
through vessels into the area of damage, and the local frequently cited and is consistent with published
lymphatic system becomes obstructed by fibrin and studies. Excessive activity on the part of the patient
fibrinogen clots derived from plasma and adjacent might theoretically increase the amount of edema, but
injured tissues. Fluid then accumulates in the intersti- we are unaware of any reliable data that compare the
tial spaces. In most cases, greater degrees of tissue edema responses of resting versus physically active
injury lead to greater amounts of edema.1,3 Hupp3 also patients after maxillofacial surgery.
notes that edema is variable from area to area and will
accumulate more freely in areas of loose connective CORTICOSTEROID USE TO CONTROL
tissues, whereas tissues that are tightly bound down to EDEMA
underlying structures tend to have less swelling. Corticosteroids are well-known adjuncts to surgery
Postsurgical facial edema is difficult to quantify accu- for suppressing tissue mediators of inflammation,
rately because it involves 3 dimensions of measurement thereby reducing transudation of fluids and lessening
with an irregular, convex surface and can manifest itself edema.3,13 Some reduction of postoperative pain
internally as well as externally. To the subjective generally accompanies a reduction of edema, and corti-
observer, lean patients appear to have more swelling costeroids have some inhibitory effects on
develop than patients who are “portly,” “plump,” prostaglandins. But steroids alone do not have a clini-
“stout,” or obese.4 Messer and Keller4 also state that cally significant analgesic effect.4,8,10 In fact, the use of
redheaded, blonde, and fair-skinned patients swell more steroids might increase the patient’s reaction to pain by
than dark-complexioned patients. Over the years, suppressing β-endorphin levels.18 Many patients also
numerous researchers have tried various measurement experience a mild euphoric, or mood altering, effect
techniques in an effort to objectively measure edema from steroids that theoretically might help them cope
and make comparisons between patient populations. with postoperative sequelae,19,20 but this effect is
Most are indirect assessments of the altered contours of poorly studied in postsurgical dental patients and might
the skin surface. Measurement tools mentioned in the be highly variable. Long-term use of steroids can delay
literature have included visual analog scales, trismus healing and increase susceptibility to infection, but
recordings (which are not generally reliably related to these effects are not clinically significant with the
edema), standardized stereo radiographic or photo- typical short-term usage protocols in oral surgery.21
graphic measurements, computerized tomography,
modified face bow devices, ultrasonography, facial Anti-inflammatory effects
plethysmographs, or various other ways of taking direct Generally speaking, to gain the desired anti-inflamma-
facial measurements.5-12 Few of these methodologies tory effects, corticosteroids must be administered in
408 Alexander and Throndson ORAL SURGERY ORAL MEDICINE ORAL PATHOLOGY
October 2000

doses exceeding the normal physiologic amounts All these forms have nearly pure glucocorticoid
released by the body.20 Although most administered effects and virtually no mineralocorticoid effects.19
corticosteroids are eliminated from the blood in less than Dexamethasone and methylprednisolone reportedly
24 hours, some late anti-inflammatory effects have been also have the least adverse effects on leukocyte chemo-
alleged to linger for up to 3 days.21 The mechanisms of taxis.13 The longer-acting forms will generally have a
actions of corticosteroids are not completely understood, more depressing effect on the adrenal glands. Dosages
but recent research has further enhanced our under- of methylprednisolone of ≤40 mg will reportedly not
standing. Research has shown that steroids with a ketone produce any adverse systemic effects.27
at the C11 position are metabolized by the liver into an
active 11-hydroxyl form that is necessary for most of the Contraindications
glucocorticoid effects of the drugs.22 Steroids have been Corticosteroids are said to be absolutely contraindi-
shown to reduce levels of lymphokines, prostaglandins, cated for use in patients with active or incompletely
serotonin, bradykinins, cortisol, migratory inhibiting treated tuberculosis, active viral or fungal infections
factor, and β-endorphins.18,22-24 Steroids are also (especially ocular herpes), active acne vulgaris,
involved in the synthesis of immunoreactive and regula- primary glaucoma, or patients with a history of acute
tory proteins, including vasocortin, angiotensin- psychoses or psychotic tendencies.1,25,28 However,
converting enzyme (which degrades bradykinin) and the recommendations are primarily based on long-
lipocortin.23-24 Some authors state that steroids stabilize term chronic steroid use rather than single-dose or
cellular membranes and have a suppressive effect on short-term use.21,22 Nevertheless, it is prudent to
lymphocytes, monocytes, and eosinophils.1,20,22 An in- minimize use in these patients until more data emerge
depth review of the pharmacotherapeutics of cortico- on the risks of short-term usage. Because some
steroids is beyond the scope of this article, and the thera- formulations of steroids contain methylparaben or
peutic effects of corticosteroids are summarized sulfites, allergic reactions are possible in susceptible
elsewhere.1,19,21,22 patients.22 There have been at least 30 documented
The body’s natural glucocorticosteroid is hydrocorti- allergic reactions and numerous side effects reported
sone, also called cortisol. The normal daily output by in the literature.25
the adrenal glands is reported to be between 15 mg and Preoperative medical consultation might be prudent
30 mg, but up to 300 mg can be supplied in times of for patients with diverticulitis, peptic ulcers, Cushing’s
crisis.20,21,25 Steroids also have numerous other desir- syndrome, renal insufficiency, uncontrolled hyperten-
able effects and side effects with which clinicians sion, uncontrolled diabetes mellitus, pregnancy, lacta-
should be familiar before using the drugs. tion, acute or chronic infections, or myasthenia
gravis.1,20,25,28 The adverse effects on hypertension
Common forms and glaucoma are related to mineralocorticoid activity
The most commonly used forms of corticosteroids and are not a problem with the newer derivatives, such
in dentoalveolar surgery include dexamethasone as methylprednisolone and dexamethasone.19
(oral), dexamethasone sodium phosphate (intra-
venous or intramuscular Decadron Phosphate, Systemic side effects
Decadrol, Dexone, Hexadrol Phosphate, and others), Steroids should not be used casually. As in any other
and dexamethasone acetate (intramuscular Decadron- aspect of the healing arts, the risks need to be weighed
LA and others); methylprednisolone (oral Medrol, against the anticipated benefits of use. Since the early
Meprolone), methylprednisolone acetate (Depo- 1970s, several authors have expressed concern over
Medrol and others); and methylprednisolone sodium the theoretical dangers of adrenal suppression, infec-
succinate (intravenous or intramuscular Solu-Medrol tion, and interference with the immune system when
and others).3,13,25 Dexamethasone has a longer dura- steroids are used to control edema. At least 3 authors
tion of action than methylprednisolone and is consid- have suggested that the side effects should contraindi-
ered more potent.11 Authors have also recommended cate the use of steroids after minor procedures, but
the use of betamethasone sodium phosphate these views are not well supported in the litera-
(Celestone Phosphate), 11,26 but this form has no ture.16,21,29 The data have disproved any significant
apparent advantage over dexamethasone. A combina- risks when corticosteroids are used as a single dose or
tion form of betamethasone exists, where short- are confined to protocols of less than 3 to 5
acting (sodium phosphate) and long-acting (acetate) days.20,21,25 Most systemic effects, such as changes in
forms are used together, but we have not located any levels of sodium, potassium, or plasma cortisol, are
studies that substantiate any additional surgical minor, transient, and do not exceed the normal ranges
benefit from that combination. of variation.30 Sisk and Bonnington31 noted that
ORAL SURGERY ORAL MEDICINE ORAL PATHOLOGY Alexander and Throndson 409
Volume 90, Number 4

Table I. Comparisons between various corticosteroids


Corticosteroid Equivalent dose 1 Equivalent dose 2 (dose 1 × 4) Biologic half-life Available forms
Cortisone 25 mg 100 mg 8-12 h V, M, O
Hydrocortisone
(Cortisol) 20 mg 80 mg 8-12 h V, M, O
Methylprednisolone 4 mg 16 mg 18-36 h V, M, O
Dexamethasone 0.75 mg 3 mg 36-54 h V, M, O, L
Betamethasone 0.6-0.75 mg 2.4-3.0 mg 36-54 h O, L
V, Intravenous; M, intramuscular; O, oral; L, liquid form.

Table II. Brands, dose forms available


Corticosteroid Form Dosage available Brand names
Methylprednisolone O 2, 4, 8, 16, 24, 32 mg Medrol
Methylprednisolone acetate M 20, 40, 80 mg Depo-Medrol, depMedalone,
Depoject, Depopred, M-Prednisol,
Duralone, Medralone
Methylprednisolone sodium succinate V, M 40, 125, 500 mg, 1 g, 2 g Solu-Medrol, A-Methapred
Dexamethasone O, L 0.25, 0.5, 0.75, 1, 1.5, 2, 4, 6 mg Decadron, Dexameth, Dexone, Hexadrol
Dexamethasone acetate M 8 mg/mL Decadron-LA, Dalalone LA, Decaject-LA,
Solurex LA, Dexasone LA, Dexone LA,
Cortastat LA
Dexamethasone sodium phosphate (V),* M 4, 10, 20, 24 mg/mL Decadron Phosphate, Dalalone, Decaject,
Dexasone, Dexon, Hexadrol Phosphate,
Solurex, Cortastat
Betamethasone O, L 0.6 mg Celestone
Betamethasone sodium phosphate V, M 4 mg Celestone, Cel-U-Jec
V, Intravenous; M, intramuscular; O, oral L, liquid.
*One form for IV use; other forms are IM only.

single-dose therapy does not really increase suscepti- LITERATURE REVIEW FINDINGS
bility to infection but can delay the diagnosis of infec- In a 1969 study by Hooley and Francis,26 patients
tion by masking some signs and symptoms. All who received prophylactic oral betamethasone imme-
hormone levels return to normal by the seventh post- diately before surgery experienced much less edema,
operative day in the typical protocols.8,28 The use of 50% less pain, and used 50% less pain medication after
oral forms might cause gastrointestinal upset, and surgery than the control group. In a 1975 article,
steroids are best taken with food.25 Finally, cortico- Messer and Keller4 subjectively noted a “significant”
steroids can cause depression or psychoses in certain decrease in clinical swelling, pain, and trismus in 500
patients, but this effect is fairly unpredictable. patients by using 4 mg of intramuscular dexametha-
sone immediately after surgery. Huffman32 reported a
Equivalency statistically significant decrease in early edema in
The various steroid preparations are not equal in patients who were given 125 mg of intravenous
potency or duration of effect. One hundred milligrams of methylprednisolone immediately before surgery, but
cortisone is equivalent to 80 mg of hydrocortisone they noted no difference after 1 week. Hargreaves and
(cortisol, the body’s natural product), 16 mg of methyl- Costello24 noted a 62% decrease in immunoreactive
prednisolone, and 3 mg of dexamethasone or betametha- bradykinin release 3 hours after surgery by using 125
sone.21 Hydrocortisone use is limited by its short biologic mg of methylprednisolone.
half-life of 8 to 12 hours. Methylprednisolone has an Several authors have noted limited responses to
intermediate half-life of 18 to 36 hours, whereas dexam- single doses of steroids. Gersema and Baker20 provide
ethasone and betamethasone have longer half-lives of 36 a good review of reported cases. Skjelbred and
to 54 hours.19 The acetate forms have low solubility that Lokken11 studied postoperative swelling after the use
acts as a sustained-release depot for 1 to 2 weeks (peak of 9 mg of intramuscular betamethasone immediately
effect, 4-8 days), giving these forms some clinical advan- before surgery. Their data reflect a 55% reduction of
tage when a longer effect is needed (Tables I and II). swelling on the third postoperative day and a 69%
410 Alexander and Throndson ORAL SURGERY ORAL MEDICINE ORAL PATHOLOGY
October 2000

Table III. Recommended interim protocols for the use of prophylactic corticosteroids after third molar extractions
and other minor oral procedures in adult patients
Protocol Drug(s) used Evening before surgery
Intramuscular (IM) Methylprednisolone acetate (MPA), 40 mg/mL AM case: (optional) (2) 8-mg tablets,
Methylprednisolone 8-mg tablets (optional) (2 total) methylprednisolone, at bedtime
Possible alternate drug: dexamethasone acetate PM case: Give nothing
(DMA), 8 mg (unstudied protocol) Alternate drug: Give (2) 4-mg tablets, dexamethasone
at bedtime
Intravascular (IV) Methylprednisolone sodium succinate AM case: give nothing
(MPSS), 125 mg/mL PM case: give nothing
Methylprednisolone tablets, 8 mg (Rx 8 total)
Alternate regimen: dexamethasone sodium phosphate
(DSP), 8-12 mg IV/IM
Dexamethasone tablets, 4 mg (Rx 8 total)
Oral Dexamethasone tablets, 4 mg (Rx 10-12 total) AM case: (2) 4-mg tablets, dexamethasone, at bedtime
PM: nothing (see day of surgery, PM case)

reduction on the sixth postoperative day in 23 of 24 significant effect when using 4 mg of intramuscular
patients in the steroid group. Pedersen33 noted a 50% dexamethasone immediately before and 1 day after
decrease in swelling on the second postoperative day surgery. These results underscore the need for higher,
with the use of 4 mg of intramuscular dexamethasone, longer dosages to gain significant benefits from the anti-
but noted no significant differences on the seventh day inflammatory aspects of the corticosteroids.10,13,19,20,25
after surgery. Her patients also used fewer analgesics.
By using a single preoperative dose of 20 mg of Dosage and duration of use
methylprednisolone, Milles and Desjardins10 noted a The dosage and duration of action of the glucocorti-
42% decrease in swelling on the first day after surgery, costeroids have clinically significant effects on the
34% less on the second day, but only 19% less on the overall amount of swelling after surgery. As with any
third day after surgery. Schaberg et al9 also noted as other medications, steroids must be used properly to
much as a 62% decrease in edema 24 hours after derive the maximum anticipated benefit. These criti-
orthognathic surgery by using 1 mg/kg of intravenous cally important effects are rarely addressed in refer-
methylprednisolone, but they noted no significant ences advocating postoperative steroid use and include
differences after the second postoperative day. Neupert the following:
et al12 noted no benefit after administration of 4 mg of • All steroids must be administered before the inflic-
intravenous dexamethasone immediately before tion of tissue damage (several hours before, in oral
surgery, although this is now recognized as a subthera- usage), not during or after surgery.3,21,23 Oral forms
peutic dose.10,19,20 Beirne and Hollander8 noted must be given at least 2 to 4 hours in advance of the
decreased edema the first day after surgery by using a procedure to allow for adequate tissue levels.21,23,24
single intravenous dose of 125 mg of methylprednisolone Peak levels for bradykinin release occur within 3
immediately before surgery, but they noted a rebound hours after tissue trauma.24 Few data exist on the
increase in edema on the second and third postoperative subject of optimal lead times for preoperative intra-
days. Numerous authors emphasize the need for a longer muscular administration.
duration of dosing to extend the benefits of the drug • A higher steroid dose will yield more satisfactory
throughout the period of edema formation. According to results.10,19,20 Gersema and Baker20 state the steroid
Matheny,34 tapering of oral doses is not necessary unless dosage should exceed the maximum daily output,
high doses for more than 3 to 5 days are used. equivalent to 300 mg of cortisol, for maximum effect.
Bystedt and Nordenram29 noted no statistically signif- Gersema and Baker20 and Beirn and Hollander8
icant differences in swelling from a placebo group after recommend the administration of a high-loading dose
the use of 12 mg of oral methylprednisolone before of 125 mg of methylprednisolone parenterally (a
surgery and 4 mg twice a day for 2 days after surgery. dosage that is equivalent to 23 mg of dexametha-
Again, this was most likely because of the subthera- sone). This dose has yielded the best results and has
peutic doses used in the study. Edilby et al30 noted no not created any clinically significant problems for
ORAL SURGERY ORAL MEDICINE ORAL PATHOLOGY Alexander and Throndson 411
Volume 90, Number 4

Day of surgery First day after surgery Second day after surgery
AM case: MPA, 40 mg IM immediately before surgery after local Nothing Nothing
anesthesia administration (or DMA, 8 mg, unstudied protocol)
PM case: (2) 8-mg tablets, methylprednisolone in AM, 3-4 h
before appointment, then MPA, 40 mg IM immediately
before surgery after local anethesia adminstration
AM case: MPSS, 125 mg IV or DSP, tablet, 8-12 mg IV at MPSS case: (1) 8-mg tablet (1) 8-mg tablet
start of case methylprednisolone, every 6 h (4 total) methylprednisolone
PM case: MPSS, 125 mg IV before start of case or 8-12 mg DSP Alternate: dexamethasone (4) 4-mg every 6 h (4 total)
IV at start of case tablets in AM Alternate: nothing
If MPSS used: (2) 8-mg tablets, methylprednisolone, at bedtime
If DSP used: nothing at bedtime
AM case: (4) 4-mg tablets, dexamethasone, 3-4 hours prior to (4) 4-mg tablets, Nothing
appointment start dexamethasone in AM
PM case: (4) 4-mg tablets in AM, 3-4 hours prior
to appointment start
Both: (2) 4-mg tablets, dexamethasone at bedtime

patients without contraindications. Messer and Timing


Keller4 recorded no side effects when up to 12 mg of If unexpected intraoperative difficulty is encountered
dexamethasone or equivalent were administered. in removing a tooth, the question is raised of whether it
• Rebound swelling can occur if the duration of use is is useful to inject corticosteroids at that point in the
inadequate; therefore, it is important to maintain case? Studies suggest that if an intravenous form is
levels of short-duration steroid formulations for used, some limited benefits are derived, even if the
more than 1 day.9,10,12,13,19,25 Peterson13 and Milles steroid is begun after surgery.4,25 The steroid should be
and Desjardins10 state there is a need to continue administered as soon as the need is realized during
corticosteroid therapy for a minimum of 3 days surgery. There is a chance for some benefit, and there
because swelling in patients treated with steroids is no significant risk unless the patient has one of the
does not appear to peak until the third day after specified contraindications. The benefits of using an
surgery. This has not been well studied, however. intramuscular form during surgery are less likely to
With most forms, single-use steroid effects wear off occur because of the delay in tissue uptake.
after the first day, and rebound edema occurs. Milles In a typical practice setting, administering cortico-
and Desjardins10 recommend a sustained release steroids 3 hours before surgery is usually not convenient.
form of steroid, such as Depo-Medrol (methylpred- As a matter of convenience, many surgeons use the intra-
nisolone acetate) in a higher single dose of 40 mg. A venous form of the drugs in conjunction with intravenous
study by Huffman32 did not show any statistically sedation or the intramuscular form with local anesthesia.
significant clinical differences between the use of 40 An additional benefit is that the parenteral regimen
mg and 125 mg doses of methylprednisolone. The removes any potential compromises caused by patient
alternative is to place the patient on a multiple-day noncompliance. The protocol suggested by Milles and
dosage regimen of an oral corticosteroid after Dejardins10 seems appropriate, in which the patient is
surgery. Tapering of doses is not mandatory in short- started on an oral dose the night before surgery, then is
term dosing.21,34 Follow-up dosage requirements given an intramuscular dose immediately before surgery.
have not been adequately studied. Despite less-than-optimal timing, Messer and Keller4 gave
• Use of usual dosages of corticosteroids over 3 to 4 the intramuscular steroid immediately after surgery and
days has no significant adverse effects on healing reported good results. Nevertheless, several studies have
and they do not suppress adrenal function to a signif- shown that giving intramuscular or intravenous steroids
icant degree.20,21,25,28 Cortisol levels return to before the procedure yields more significant results than
normal value in 5 to 7 days.8,28 Many authors refer starting the steroids after the procedure has finished or not
to administering a high dose, followed by an abrupt using steroids at all.4,8,10,32 If oral corticosteroid therapy is
discontinuance or rapidly tapering doses as “pulsed started at least 3 to 4 hours before the surgery and is
therapy.”19,28 However, this is generally associated continued for at least 2 days after surgery, it can be nearly
with therapeutic, not prophylactic, use. as effective as parenterally administered forms.10,13,19,23,25
412 Alexander and Throndson ORAL SURGERY ORAL MEDICINE ORAL PATHOLOGY
October 2000

We are unaware of any published data related to the to be of slight advantage only in the most difficult
timing of the appointment (AM or PM) relative to a cases. Therefore, we believe that the use of antibiotics
preoperative dose the night before, or whether a should be based on the amount of surgical trauma
supplemental dose should be administered the morning inflicted, not solely because of corticosteroid use.
of surgery when the patient has an afternoon appoint-
ment. Logic would seem to support such use. INTERIM RECOMMENDATIONS FOR
DENTAL SURGERY USE
Effects of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs Although many authors anecdotally advocate the
Recent studies have suggested that the anti-edema use of corticosteroids to limit postoperative edema,
benefits of corticosteroids for patients after surgery few authors have made definitive recommendations.
might be further enhanced by the use of nonsteroidal Consequently, protocols have evolved by word of
anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), such as ibuprofen mouth, and many regimens in common use might be
and flurbiprofen.5,6 This is countered by other subtherapeutic and of limited benefit. Based on the
authors.7,23,31 They note that the anti-inflammatory data reported in various studies, we believe newer
effects of NSAIDs take several days to evolve, and information suggests a need to change some of the
prostaglandins play only a minor role in edema.5,35 protocols that are based on studies from the 1960s
Schultze-Mosgau et al6 reported the combination of and 1970s. As noted previously, higher doses of
double-dosed oral methylprednisolone and ibuprofen steroids are indicated, and the studies showing
reduced swelling by 58% (by visual analog scale; 56% rebound swelling on the second and third days afer
by using ultrasonography) over patients who used surgery suggest a need for longer courses of prophy-
placebos.6 Their conclusions were contradicted by lactic steroids in most cases. By using this guidance,
Hargreaves,23 who noted a lack of evidence that the 2 we recommend the following interim regimens for
drugs were potentiated and expressed concern that the prophylactic corticosteroid administration, until
combination of drugs could potentially increase future studies can provide additional data (Table III).
gastrointestinal side effects. It is unknown whether
such a gastrointestinal effect is a significant risk with Intramuscular
short-term use, however. Sisk and Bonnington31 note A 1-time depot intramuscular form, such as 40 mg
no significant effect of flurbiprofen on edema at 72 methylprednisolone acetate (Depo-Medrol and others,
hours when it is used with 125 mg of methylpred- 40 mg/mL) is advantageous, as recommended by
nisolone, although it did provide improved analgesia. Milles and Desjardins10 and Montgomery et al.19 The
Ücok7 showed that the NSAID tenoxicam, which was drug can be injected before surgery into the deltoid,
not administered along with a steroid, was no more gluteus, masseter, or medial pterygoid muscle on one
effective than placebo in modifying swelling during the or both sides, immediately after administration of seda-
first 2 days after surgery. Troullos et al5 showed that tion or local anesthesia. If injected intraorally before
NSAIDs alone have only a minor anti-edema effect. local anesthesia administration, it is quite uncomfort-
Several studies have noted an increase in swelling able. As an alternative, 8 to 12 mg of dexamethasone
after dental surgery with the use of aspirin. Skjelbred acetate (Decadron-LA and others) can be administered
and Lokken 11 noted a 50% increase in swelling instead of Depo-Medrol. Depo-Medrol or Decadron-
(versus the use of acetaminophen). A news item in the LA should never be injected intravenously; they are
California Dental Association Journal cites a study intended for intramuscular use only.
from the Academy of General Dentistry that showed a Montgomery et al19 note that administration of a
55% increase in swelling after aspirin use.36 high dose of steroid intramuscularly into the masseter
muscle has not been shown to improve anti-inflamma-
Routine concurrent antibiotic use tory actions over injections at distant sites, but there is
Evidence is lacking for the routine concurrent use a convenience factor for the surgeon to use an intraoral
of prophylactic antibiotics for prevention of infection site. One article also suggests the steroid can be
along with the use of corticosteroids. It is beyond the injected into buccal vestibule tissues,1 although we do
scope of this article to discuss the rationales of not know of any clinicians who do so.
prophylactic antibiotic use. Capuzzi et al,37 among In keeping with the recommendations to administer
others, show that the use of routine antibiotic prophy- oral doses at least 3 to 4 hours before surgery, a preop-
laxis is not justified, whether corticosteroids are used erative dose of two 8-mg methylprednisolone tablets or
or not, and does not significantly reduce the postop- two 4-mg dexamethasone tablets can be considered at
erative sequelae.37 A study by MacGregor and Addy38 bedtime the night before surgery (for AM cases), or
showed that the use of systemic penicillin was shown early the morning of surgery (for PM cases), to achieve
ORAL SURGERY ORAL MEDICINE ORAL PATHOLOGY Alexander and Throndson 413
Volume 90, Number 4

optimal benefit. This is then followed with the intra- Oral


muscular dose at the start of surgery, although the If oral administration is planned, the regimen should
optimal lead time for the intramuscular dosing is not generally begin the night before surgery or the morning
well established. of surgery (for an afternoon surgery) because studies
The use of 8 to 12 mg of the dexamethasone acetate have shown that at least 2 to 4 hours is needed for orally
form (Decadron-LA and others), a long-acting, reposi- administered steroids to become effective.21,23 Dexa-
tory form, might have therapeutic advantages, but we are methasone is our favored oral form, with two 4-mg
unaware of any clinical studies that have evaluated the tablets at bedtime the evening before surgery, a three to
efficacy and safety of that particular drug form in four 4-mg tablet loading dose preoperatively on the day
dentistry. It seems logical that this would be a viable of surgery, and a single follow-up dose of three to four
alternative drug form, and it is interesting that its use has 4-mg tablets on the morning of the first and second days
not been studied. Clinical studies are therefore needed. after surgery. Again, this empiric regimen is based on
the review of the literature and lacks statistical
Intravenous verification. The recommendation should be considered
Methylprednisolone sodium succinate, 125 mg (Solu- for use only until more research data emerge.
Medrol and others), or 12 mg of dexamethasone sodium
phosphate (Decadron and others) are favored by many DISCUSSION
for intravenous administration. A popular protocol is 125 Corticosteroid use should not be routinely used after
mg of methylprednisolone sodium succinate intra- every dentoalveolar surgery, even for mildly difficult
venously immediately before surgery. Oral preoperative cases. Rather, it should be reserved for selected cases
doses have not been proven necessary when the loading where a significant amount of surgical trauma is antic-
dose is administered intravenously. Although Gersema ipated before surgery or serendipitously encountered
and Baker20 do not believe follow-up dosing is necessary, during surgery. Examples of this include deeply
we believe if the drug is used for a morning case, then the impacted teeth; large teeth with weakened coronal
injection ideally should be followed by two 8-mg tablets structure or widely divergent roots, which are
of oral methylprednisolone (Medrol) the evening after embedded in dense bone; multiple extraction cases
surgery because of the shorter biologic half-life of the with extensive alveolar remodeling (such as alveo-
drug. Then, one to two 4-mg tablets of methylpred- plasty or tori removal); vestibuloplasties; block resec-
nisolone is given 4 times daily during the first and second tions; and other similarly extensive surgical proce-
days after surgery. Although this dosage protocol has not dures. Data on the benefits of use, if any, in
been statistically verified, it is consistent with clinical orthognathic and cosmetic surgery are still emerging.
recommendations of others.13,16 Follow-up doses of Anecdotally, many surgeons often anticipate greater-
dexamethasone and betamethasone are not required than-usual swelling in patients with lighter complex-
because of their longer half-lives. Tapering of dosages is ions and lighter natural hair color because these
not necessary because of the short regimen durations.34 patients seem to be more reactive, as noted by Messer
If either of the longer-acting dexamethasone or and Keller.4 We have noted similar clinical observa-
betamethasone forms is used by the surgeon, we recom- tions in our practices, but we are unaware of any scien-
mend a minimum preoperative loading dose of 8 to 12 tific data that compare postsurgical edema in patients
mg (4 mg/mL) because some studies have shown little to of differing complexions, so little objective verification
no edema reduction with only 4 mg.12,13 This dose exists for this clinical impression. Some authors have
should ideally be followed by four 4-mg tablets of oral also stated that women appear to experience more post-
dexamethasone on the morning of the first day after operative edema than men, but this, too, is unproven.
surgery. Because the elimination half-life of these drugs
is 36 to 54 hours, theoretically it should not be necessary Research needs
to continue the follow-up dosing beyond the morning of There are still no precise, evidence-based answers to
the first postoperative day. Administration of steroids as many questions concerning steroid use, despite the many
a single large dose each day minimizes the side effects articles written since the 1960s. Most articles compare
and causes less adrenal suppression.21 This recom- the use of a single steroid with a placebo group, but few
mended dosage level is 8 mg of dexamethasone per day, articles have compared various steroids or steroid regi-
which is slightly higher than the recommendations of 4 mens to discern which is the most effective form and
to 6 mg per day from other authors.21,30,33 Again, this what the minimal dose is that provides maximum benefit
aspect has not been studied in controlled clinical with minimum risks. Well-designed prospective clinical
research and should be considered an interim recom- studies are needed to help answer several key questions:
mendation, pending more evidence from future studies. • Do darker-complexioned and darker-haired patients
414 Alexander and Throndson ORAL SURGERY ORAL MEDICINE ORAL PATHOLOGY
October 2000

truly experience less swelling than lighter featured tions in combination with corticosteroids to increase
patients? edema reduction is not well supported in the literature.
• Do obese patients have more clinical swelling than The use of antibiotics for patients receiving short-term,
lean patients? prophylactic corticosteroids should only be considered
• Do women routinely experience more postsurgical in cases where the high risk of postoperative infection
edema than men? clearly outweighs the risks of use or for patients who are
• Do patients who rest quietly after surgery experience immunocompromised.
less edema than physically active patients?
We thank Tommy W. Gage, BS, DDS, PhD; Robert G.
• Is it necessary to continue oral dosages to the third Triplett, DDS, PhD; and Sterling R. Schow, DMD for their
postoperative day, or could the regimen be continued reviews of the manuscript and insightful comments.
for only 1 day after surgery?
• How long before surgery should intramuscular corti-
REFERENCES
costeroid forms be administered for optimal effect?
1. Hupp JR. Wound repair. In: Peterson LJ, Ellis E, Hupp JR,
• Is an oral preoperative dose the night before surgery Tucker MR, editors. Contemporary oral and maxillofacial
significantly beneficial? Surgery. 3rd ed. St Louis: Mosby; 1998. p. 58-60.
• Which dosages of oral steroids are the most optimal 2. Patten JR, Patten J, Hutchins MO. Adjunct use of dexametha-
sone in postoperative dental pain control. Compend Contin Educ
for the follow-up regimens? Dent 1992;13:580-9.
• Is an intravenous-plus-oral dexamethasone regimen 3. Hupp JR. Principles of surgery. In: Peterson LJ, Ellis E, Hupp
clinically superior to a single-dosed methylpred- JR, Tucker MR, editors. Contemporary oral and maxillofacial
surgery. 3rd ed. St Louis: Mosby; 1998. p. 56.
nisolone acetate regimen, or vice versa? 4. Messer EJ, Keller JJ. The use of intraoral dexamethasone after
• Is the longer acting, acetate form of dexamethasone extraction of mandibular third molars. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral
clinically equal or superior to its methylprednisolone Pathol 1975;40:594-8.
5. Troullos ES, Hargreaves KM, Butler DP, Dionne RA. Comparison
counterpart? of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, ibuprofen, and flur-
• What is the optimal dosage in an oral dexamethasone biprofen with methylprednisolone and placebo for acute pain,
regimen? swelling, and trismus. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 1990;48:945-52.
6. Schultze-Mosgau S, Schmelzeisen R, Frölich JC, Schmele H.
• Does the available combination form of short-acting Use of ibuprofen and methylprednisolone for the prevention of
and long-acting betamethasone offer any clinical pain and swelling and removal of impacted third molars. J Oral
advantages? Maxillofac Surg 1995;53:2-7.
7. Ücok C. Stereophotogrammetric assessment of the effect of
• Which one of the many recommended techniques tenoxicam on facial swelling subsequent to third molar surgery.
from past studies for quantifying edema is the most Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg 1997;26:380-2.
accurate? 8. Beirne OR, Hollander B. The effect of methylprednisolone on
pain, trismus, and swelling after removal of third molars. Oral
We must have a standardized and verified means of Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol 1986;61:134-8.
comparing future data. None of these issues have been 9. Schaberg SJ, Stuller CB, Edwards SM. Effect of methylpred-
well explored, in our judgment. nisolone on swelling after orthognathic surgery. J Oral
Maxillofac Surg 1984;42:356-61.
10. Milles M, Desjardins PJ. Reduction of postoperative facial
CONCLUSIONS swelling by low-dose methylprednisolone. J Oral Maxillofac
The use of corticosteroids to reduce edema after Surg 1993;51:987-91.
11. Skjelbred P, Lokken P. Post-operative pain and inflammatory
dentoalveolar surgery is widely recommended and prac- reaction reduced by injection of a corticosteroid. A controlled
ticed, but should not be done routinely. Rather, the tech- trial in bilateral oral surgery. Eur J Clin Pharmacol
nique should be used for select cases where significant 1982;21:391-6.
12. Neupert EA 3d, Lee JW, Philput CB, Gordon JR. Evaluation of
surgical trauma is inflicted or the patient is judged to be dexamethasone for reduction of postsurgical sequelae of third
at risk for excessive edema. In routine cases, surgical molar removal. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 1992;50:1177-82.
skills and attention to operative details should be 13. Peterson LJ. Principles of management of impacted teeth.
Principles of oral and maxillofacial surgery. Vol 1. Philadelphia:
adequate to keep postoperative edema at acceptably low JB Lippincott; 1992. p. 117.
levels. When steroids are used, they should be started 14. Sisk AL, Hammer WB, Shelton DW, Joy ED. Complications
before the surgical procedure, should be given at higher following removal of impacted third molars: the role of the expe-
rience of the surgeon. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 1986;44:855-9.
dosages and should either be used in a long-acting form 15. MacGregor AJ. Reduction in morbidity in the surgery of the
or be used as a supplemental follow-up to extend steroid third molar removal. Dent Update 1990;17:411-4.
coverage for at least 2 days after surgery. Such usage 16. Laskin DM. Oral and maxillofacial surgery. Vol 2. St Louis:
Mosby; 1985. p. 39.
should not interfere with healing and will not signifi- 17. Peterson LJ. Postoperative patient management. In: Peterson LJ,
cantly impair adrenal function. Recommended regimens Ellis E, Hupp JR, Tucker MR, editors. Contemporary oral and
are summarized in Table III, but should be considered maxillofacial surgery. 3rd ed. St Louis: Mosby; 1998. p. 251.
18. Hargreaves KM, Shmidt EA, Mueller GP, Dionne RA.
empiric and interim until data emerge from future Dexamethasone alters plasma levels of beta-endorphin and post-
controlled studies. The benefit of using NSAID medica- operative pain. Clin Pharmacol Ther 1987;42:601-7.
ORAL SURGERY ORAL MEDICINE ORAL PATHOLOGY Alexander and Throndson 415
Volume 90, Number 4

19. Montgomery MT, Hogg JP, Roberts DL, Redding SW. The use of tory response. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol 1985;60:137-
glucocorticosteroids to lessen the inflammatory sequelae following 45.
third molar surgery. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 1990;48:179-87. 32. Huffman GG. Use of methylprednisolone sodium succinate to
20. Gersema L, Baker K. Use of corticosteroids in oral surgery. J reduce postoperative edema after removal of impacted third
Oral Maxillofac Surg 1992;50:270-7. molars. J Oral Surg 1977;35:198-9.
21. Bahn SL. Glucocorticosteroids in dentistry. J Am Dent Assoc 33. Pedersen A. Decadronphosphate in the relief of complaints
1982;105:476-81. after third molar surgery. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg
22. Nadel DM. The use of systemic steroids in otolaryngology. Ear 1985;14:235-40.
Nose Throat J 1996;75:502-16. 34. Matheny JL. Adrenocorticosteroids: systemic and topical
23. Hargreaves KM. Use of ibuprofen and methylprednisolone for therapy. In: Holroyd SV, Wynn RL, Requa-Clark B, editors.
the prevention of pain and swelling after removal of impacted Clinical pharmacology in dental practice. 4th ed. St Louis:
third molars. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 1995;53:7-8. Mosby; 1988. p. 238-45.
24. Hargreaves KM, Costello A. Glucocorticoids suppress levels of 35. Bennett DR, editor. Drug evaluations annual 1995. Chicago:
immunoreactive bradykinin in inflamed tissue as evaluated by American Medical Association; 1995. p. 1885.
microdialysis probes. Clin Pharmacol Ther 1990;48:168-78. 36. Post-surgical aspirin may not be so swell (news item). Calif
25. Koerner KR. Steroids in third molar surgery: a review. Gen Dent Dent Assoc J 1990;18:11.
1987;35:459-63. 37. Capuzzi P, Montebugnoli L, Vaccaro MA. Extraction of
26. Hooley JR, Francis FH. Betamethasone in traumatic oral impacted third molars: a longitudinal prospective study on
surgery. J Oral Surg 1969;27:398-403. factors that affect postoperative recovery. Oral Surg Oral Med
27. Hebel SK. Drug facts and comparisons. St Louis: Facts and Oral Pathol 1994;77:341-3.
Comparisons; 1999. p. 122, 126a. 38. MacGregor AJ, Addy A. Value of penicillin in the prevention of
28. Butler RCD, Vorono AA, Finstuen K. Dosage effects of pulsed pain, swelling and trismus following the removal of ectopic
steroid therapy on serum cortisol levels in oral and maxillofacial mandibular third molars. Int J Oral Surg 1980;9:166-72.
surgery patients. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 1993;51:750-3.
29. Bystedt H, Nordenram Ä. Effect of methylprednisolone on
complications after removal of impacted mandibular third Reprint requests:
molars. Swed Dent J 1985;9:65-9. Roger E. Alexander, DDS
30. Edilby GI, Canniff JP, Harris M. A double-blind placebo- Professor
controlled trial of the effects of dexamethasone on postoperative Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery and Pharmacology
swelling [abstract]. J Dent Res 1982;61:556. Baylor College of Dentistry
31. Sisk AL, Bonnington GJ. Evaluation of methylprednisolone PO Box 660677
and flurbiprofen for inhibition of the postoperative inflamma- Dallas, TX 75266-0677

BOUND VOLUMES AVAILABLE TO SUBSCRIBERS


Bound volumes of Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine, Oral Pathology, Oral Radiology, and Endodontics
are available to subscribers (only) from the Publisher, at a cost of $92.00 for domestic, $112.35 for
Canadian, and $105.00 for international, for Vol 87 (January-June) and Vol 88 (July-December).
Shipping charges are included. Each bound volume contains a subject and author index, and all
advertising is removed. Copies are shipped within 60 days after publication of the last issue in the
volume. The binding is durable buckram with the journal name, volume number, and year stamped
in gold on the spine. Payment must accompany all orders. Contact Mosby, Subscription Customer
Service, 6277 Sea Harbor Dr, Orlando, FL 32887; phone 800-654-2452 or 407-345-4000.
Subscriptions must be in force to qualify. Bound volumes are not available in place of a regular
journal subscription.

You might also like