You are on page 1of 8

Rapid Plasma Reagin Card Test for Syphilis

and Other Treponematoses


JOSEPH PORTNOY, Ph.D., JOHN H. BREWER, Ph.D., and AD HARRIS

some of the characteristics desired for the


INpatient'sMay
strated
1961 Dr. John H. Brewer demon¬
a test for syphilis that mixed the
with VDRL antigen contain¬
serum
"card" test, such as stable antigen suspension,
rapid performance, and high sensitivity level.
ing carbon particles that had been dried on During this cooperative study, the desirable
plastic-coated white cardboard cards. This attributes of both procedures, together with a
test had the advantage of using disposable com¬ slide for the rapid collection and separation
ponents and of being performed without lab¬ of plasma from finger-stick blood, were incor-
oratory apparatus except that used for the porated into the testing procedure herein desig¬
separation of serum. At Dr. Brewer's request nated as the rapid plasma reagin (RPR) card
the Public Health Service Venereal Disease test.
Eesearch Laboratory entered into a cooperative This report describes the technique for the
agreement with him to evaluate this procedure. RPR card test and presents the preliminary
Although this test had many attributes of a evaluation of this test compared with the VDRL
screening test for syphilis that could be rapidly slide test in selected patient categories.
performed under field conditions, there was an
apparent need for a rapid, simple means of Materials and Methods
collecting and separating blood without cen¬ Equipment Glassware
trifugation, if an ideal field-testing procedure and
was to be developed. Early testing indicated 1. Brewer plasma collection slide (A).
that VDRL antigen when dried on the cards 2. Brewer diagnostic card (B).
or in ampules did not possess the desired 3. Capillary tubes capable of measuring 0.03
stability. ml. (C).
The rapid plasma reagin test for syphilis 4. Rubber bulbs for use with capillary tubes.
with unheated plasma (i,#) or serum {3) had
Reagents
Mr. Harris is director and Dr. Portnoy is assist¬ 1. Antigen: VDRL slide flocculation test
ant director, Venereal Disease Research Laboratory, antigen (If).
Communicable Disease Center, Public Health Serv¬ 2. Saline solution: 1 percent buffered saline
ice, Atlanta, Ga. Dr. Brewer is director of biological solution (VDRL flocculation test buffered
research, Biological Research Laboratories, Hynson, saline).
Westcott & Dunning, Inc., Baltimore, Md. 3. Phosphate (0.02 M); Merthiolate, 0.2 per¬
The antigen suspension and testing materials, in¬ cent solution (Z?) : Dissolve 1.42 gm. Na2HP04,
cluding the Brewer plasma collection slide, used in 1.36 gm. KH2P04, and 1 gm. Merthiolate in
the serologic evaluations were supplied by Hynson, distilled water to a final volume of 500 ml.
Westcott & Dunning, Inc. The pH of this solution should be 6.9. Store in

Vol. 77, No. 8, August 1962 645


dark at room temperature. May be used for a ity are selected by trial testing and are main¬
period of 3 months. tained for daily use.
4. Choline chloride solution (40 percent) : Antigen suspension is tested with controls of
(a) Dissolve 40 gm. choline chloride in known reactivity prior to performing tests with
distilled water to a final volume of 100 ml. unknown specimens, and only those suspensions
(b) Filter and store at room tempera¬ that have given the designated reactions are
ture. May be used for 1 year. Refilter if visi¬ used in testing unknowns.
ble particles form.
5. EDTA (0.25 M) : Dissolve 9.3 gm. ethyl¬ Plasma Collection
ene dinitrilo tetra-acetic acid, disodium salt in The plasma collection kit contains only three
approximately 90 ml. of distilled water. Ad¬ items: a sterile lancet, a Brewer plasma collec¬
just pH to 7.0 with NaOH and add distilled tion slide, and a toothpick, which serves as a
water to 100 ml. stirring device. The kit is enclosed in a metal
6. Charcoal suspension (0.25 percent) : Sus- plastic-sealed package. The Brewer plasma
pend 25 mg. charcoal (E) in 10 ml. distilled collection slide measures 2 inches by 5 inches
water. and is made from plastic-coated board (fig. 1).
7. Resuspending solution: This solution is It has a 1-inch keyhole-shaped depression in
freshly prepared each time antigen suspensions the center and a perforated line 1 inch from the
are made. To prepare 10 ml. of resuspending
solution, combine the following:
Milliliter
EDTA (0.25 M)_ 0. 5
Choline chloride (40 percent)_ 2.5
Phosphate (0.02 M), Merthiolate (0.2 percent) 5. 0
Distilled water_ 1. 0
Charcoal suspension (0.25 percent)_ 1.0
Preparation of Antigen Suspension
1.Prepare antigen emulsion as for the
VDRL flocculation tests (5, 6).
2. Centrifuge measured aliquots of the anti¬
gen emulsion at room temperature for 15 min¬
utes at 2,000 g.
3. Decant the supernatant fluid by inverting
the tube, taking care not to disturb the sediment.
While holding the tube in an inverted position,
wipe the wall of the tube with cotton gauze
without disturbing the sediment.
4. Resuspend the sediment with a volume of
resuspending solution equal to that of the cen¬
trifuged antigen suspension. Blow the solu¬
tion directly onto the sediment. Agitate the
centrifuge tubes by hand to aid in resuspension.
5. If more than one centrifuge tube is used,
combine all resuspended aliquots. This is the
completed antigen suspension.
Preparation and Use of Controls
Controls are prepared by diluting reactive
plasma in nonreactive plasma or by diluting
reactive serum in nonreactive serum. Dilu¬
tions that produce the desired degree of reactiv¬
646 Public Health Reports
Figure 2

top. The top section can be bent down to form a pronounced clumping of the blood cells and
a support which will allow the plasma to drain the coincident separation of the plasma are
down into the narrow part of the "keyhole." noted.
The depressed area of the slide is coated with 5. Place slide on table with the perforated
an anticoagulant and a lectin, which are stable line coinciding with the edge of the table and
at room temperature. The lectin is of a type the short end of the slide extending over the
which will cause both red and white blood cells edge. Fold down tab against table edge.
to agglutinate, leaving the plasma free to flow 6. Place slide on flat surface to allow plasma
down into the collection slot. to drain into the collection slot. This usually
The directions for use of the Brewer plasma takes 1 or 2 minutes.
collection slide are as follows: Plasma may then be removed for testing in
1. Tear off end of package containing plasma the unheated state with the capillary tube.
collection kit and remove collection slide. Note : lf considerable delay is encountered in test¬
Write patient's name or laboratory number at ing the plasma and drying is anticipated, it is advisable
bottom of slide with a ballpoint pen or glass to place the collection slide in a humidifying device.
marking pencil. Cleanse area to be punc- Serum Collection
tured.finger, toe, or ear.with antiseptic solu¬
tion. Use sterile lancet to obtain blood. Blood is collected in clean, dry tubes not con¬
2. Allow three drops of blood to fail freely taining anticoagulant and is allowed to clot.
on the circular portion of the depressed area Serum is separated in the usual manner and
of the slide, carefully avoiding entry of blood is tested in the unheated state.
into narrow plasma collection slot.
3. Holding the toothpick in an almost hori- Performance of Test
zontal position, spread the blood over the entire 1. Using capillary tube, remove 0.03 ml. of
circular area, stirring gently for approximately unheated plasma from the Brewer plasma col¬
20-30 seconds. Avoid contact with the inked lection slide or 0.03 ml. of unheated serum and
border which surrounds the depressed area of place on one test area of the Brewer diagnostic
the slide. card (fig. 2).
4. Pick up slide and, using a tilting motion, 2. Add one drop (approximately 1/70 ml.)
cause the blood to rotate within the circle until of antigen suspension, using needle and plastic

Vol. 77, No. 8, August 1962 647


dispensing bottle, to each plasma or serum. the mixture so that it fills the entire test
Hold dispenser in vertical position. surface.
3. Using a separate clean toothpick for each 4. Shake by tilting test card to and fro for a
plasma or serum, mix antigen suspension with maximum of 4 minutes, allowing time for the
test specimen gently but completely, spreading mixture to flow into the apex so that the par-

Note : In total lines, figures in parentheses are percentages.


Table 2. Comparison of RPR card (plasma) and VDRL slide tests on 1,802 patients without
syphilis diagnosis
RPR card test VDRL slide test
Clinical category
Test result Number Reactive Weakly
reactive
Nonreactive
patients
Contact to infectious syphilis:
Untreated_ f Reactive_ 27 16 7
\Nonreactive 218 0 216
Treated_ f Reactive_ 3 0 2
INonreactive 14 0 12
Cluster,1 untreated_ |\Nonreactive.
Reactive_
63
11 2
0
8
61
No history of syphilis. f Reactive_ 54 31 14
\Nonreactive 394 6 379
Premarital_ fReactive_ 6 2 4
\f Nonreactive
Reactive_
306
16
0
2
305
14
Gonorrhea, untreated. INonreactive 690 0 687
Totals_ f Reactive_ 117 ( 6.5) 53 (8.0) 15 (0.8) 49 ( 2. 7)
\ Nonreactive 1, 685 (93. 5) 6 (0.8) 19 (1.1) 1,660 (92. 1)
Grand total_ 1,802 (100.0) 59 (8.8) 34 (1. 9) 1,709 (94.8)
1
Contacts, associates, and suspects related to persons with infectious syphilis.
Note: In total lines, figures in parentheses are percentages.
648 Public Health Reports
ticles will be in close proximity and then to partment. Eesults of these tests, divided into
spread out as the particles flow away from diagnostic categories, are shown in tables 1
the apex. and 2.
5. Eead macroscopically and report as "reac¬ The EPE card and VDEL slide tests were
tive" specimens showing characteristic dump¬ also performed at the Venereal Disease Ee¬
ing ; report as "nonreactive" specimens showing search Laboratory in Chamblee, Ga., on serums
no clumping at the end of the 4-minute shaking from venipuncture blood stored in a serum bank
period. that is maintained for comparative evaluation
Note : Clumping is characterized by the appearance of new or modified testing procedures. The
of a front of agglutinated particles which move out 248 serums used for this comparison were from
from the apex of the teardrop test area. As the par¬ several diagnostic categories, including three
ticles reach the outer limit of the teardrop they tend of the treponematoses.syphilis, yaws, and
to deposit at the periphery. When this clumping is
observed in less than 4 minutes it is not necessary to pinta.and were from presumed nonsyphilitic
continue the shaking. However, the full 4-minute donors with or without other diseases. Eesults
shaking period must be used for specimens not con¬ of this serum testing are shown in tables 3
sidered reactive. and 4.
Discussion
Evaluation The EPE card test is designed for use as a
The EPE card test was performed on plasma field test or an office procedure. It does not
from approximately 2,400 randomly selected require any of the usual laboratory equipment.
patients of the Fulton County (Ga.) Health Centrifuges, water baths, rotating machines,
Department venereal disease clinic and the microscopes, or other expensive apparatus usu¬
social hygiene clinic of the Houston (Tex.) ally associated with serologic testing are elimi¬
City Health Department who were routinely nated. All materials employed are inexpensive
subjected to venipuncture for VDEL slide test¬ and disposable. All supplies and apparatus for
ing. Technologists from the Venereal Disease performing 100 tests can be included in a kit
Eesearch Laboratory obtained the finger-stick which occupies less than 1 square foot of desk
blood and performed the EPE card test on these space. This includes the material for.drawing
patients. Eesults of the VDEL slide test and the blood and separating the plasma. Indi¬
diagnoses were later obtained from clinic rec¬ vidual tests, including collection of blood and
ords for comparative purposes. The VDEL separation of plasma, can be run in 7 or 8
tests discussed in this section of the report were minutes.
performed by the Georgia Department of Pub¬ In principle, the EPE card test makes use of
lic Health and the Houston City Health De¬ the EPE test antigen suspension (2) to which

Table 3. Comparison of results of RPR card and VDRL slide tests for treponematoses on serum
bank specimens
RPR card test VDRL slide test
Clinical category
Test result Number Reactive Weakly Non¬
patients reactive reactive

Primary and secondary syphilis, untreated fReactive_ 18 16 0


\Nonreactive__ 7 0 7
Syphilis, treated J_._ (Reactive_ 19 13 1
\Nonreactive__ 21 0 21
Yaws, treated_ f Reactive_ 29 29 0
\Nonreactive__ 0 0 0
Pinta, treated_ fReactive_ 37 33 1
INonreactive. 5 3 1
1
Primary, secondary, latent, and late.
Vol. 77, No. 8, August 1962 649
Table 4. Comparison of results of RPR card and VDRL slide tests on serum bank specimens from
presumed nonsyphilitic patients
RPR card test VDRL slide test
Clinical category
Test result Number Reactive Weakly Non¬
patients reactive reactive

Presumed normal_ f Reactive_ 0 0 0


\f Reactive_
Nonreactive 20
0
0
0
20
0
Diseases other than syphilis. \f Nonreactive 20 0 20
Reactive_ 27 20 0
Biologic false positive reactors \(Reactive_
Nonreactive 18 2 16
0 0 0
Leprosy_ INonreactive 27 3 22

has been added small amount of specially


a arouser of suspicion of syphilis is suggested
prepared charcoal, to act as a visualization from table 2, which presents a comparison of
agent. The particle size of the charcoal is such the EPE card test and the VDEL slide test
that the nonreactive specimens appear to have on 1,802 patients without definite diagnoses of
an even light-gray color. When flocculation syphilis. In 245 untreated patients named as
occurs, there is a conglutination that is readily known contacts to infectious syphilis, 27, or
visible without the aid of a microscope. The approximately 11 percent, were reactive in the
test is performed on plastic-coated cards which, card test; approximately 7 percent were reac¬
if allowed to dry properly, may be filed for tive and 2 percent were weakly reactive in the
future reference. VDEL test. The group of patients identified
The effectiveness of the EPE card test in as "cluster, untreated" represents persons asked
providing serologic support for the diagnosis to report to the clinics through the use of the
of syphilis is apparent from the results given cluster procedure (7), a technique for increas¬
in table 1, which also demonstrates the gener¬ ing the detection of syphilis by blood-testing
ally good agreement between results of the card contacts, associates, and suspects related to per¬
test and the VDEL slide test. In untreated sons with known infectious syphilis. In this
syphilis the card test had essentially the same category approximately twice the number of
capacity to detect antibody (reagin) as the reactors was obtained with the EPE card test
VDEL slide test, and a high level of agreement as with the VDEL slide test. This disparity
between the two tests was apparent. On the in number of reactors was likewise seen in the
basis that a reactive EPE card test accompa- premarital and untreated gonorrhea categories.
nied by a reactive or weakly reactive VDEL Although the percentage of reactive results in
slide test constituted agreement, as did non¬ the EPE card test was low, approximately 2
reactive results with both tests, 7 out of 83 cases percent in each of these categories, the VDEL
of untreated syphilis, or approximately 8 per¬ test gave 1 percent or less reactors. It was only
cent, gave disagreeing results. By contrast, in in the category "no history of syphilis," which
the treated syphilis group, approximately 15 included patients with genitourinary com¬
percent of 517 cases showed disagreement. plaints or conditions, chancroid, or diagnoses
There was little difference in the reactivity level of biologic false positive, that the number of
of the two tests; 71.0 percent of the patients reactors in the two tests was essentially the
with a clinical diagnosis of syphilis were reac¬ same.
tive in the EPE card test and 72.7 percent in Since the EPE card test was significantly
the VDEL slide test (64.2 percent reactive, 8.5 more reactive than the VDEL slide test in pa¬
percent weakly reactive). tients without a diagnosis of syphilis, it might
The potential value of the EPE card test as be inferred that the card test was more non¬
a screening procedure and as an additional specific than the VDEL test. However, since
650 Public Health Reports
patients attending the clinics are venereal dis- This evaluation of the RPR card test is lim-
ease prone, the possibility exists that syphilis, ited and preliminary, but results appear to
past or present, was being detected by the card justify an early report of technique and method-
test. In the absence of other data, such as ology so that more extensive testing and evalu-
results of treponemal tests, in these cases it is ation may be accomplished by other investi-
difficult to arrive at a better understanding of gators. A broader field evaluation of the RPR
the reactivity pattern. If the card test were card test now being conducted by the Venereal
more nonspecific than the VDRL slide test, it Disease Branch, Communicable Disease Center,
might be expected that this would also be noted will be the subject of a later report.
with serums of presumed nonsyphilitic patients.
However, table 4 shows that the RPR card Summary and Conclusion
test was more specific than the VDRL test. It
is possible, of course, that qualitative differences The RPR card test for syphilis and other
between plasma and serum may be responsible treponematoses has the elements required for an
for this peculiar behavior. It should be real- ideal field test.
ized that the reactions are compatible with the The chief characteristics of the test which
concept that the RPR card test may be used as make for rapidity and ease of performance are
a screening procedure and suspicion arouser. (a) application of a device for obtaining
Although the RPR card test was conceived plasma from finger-stick blood in a rapid and
for use as a field or office procedure employing simple manner; (b) a stable antigen suspension
plasma, it was of interest to examine the be- containing charcoal; and (c) use of a plastic-
havior of serum in an identical test. The re- coated card surface to perform the test.
sults presented in tables 3 and 4 clearly indicate Results obtained with the RPR card test have
that the RPR card test had a satisfactory re- been compared with clinical diagnoses and with
activity level with unheated serum. results of the VDRL slide test. Preliminary
Similar findings were obtained with the RPR findings contained in this report indicate that
card test and the VDRL slide test in syphilis, the RPR card test has adequate sensitivity and
yaws, and pinta (table 3). In the presumed specificity.
nonsyphilitic group the RPR card test was
apparently more specific than the VDRL slide REFERENCES
test (table 4). Its behavior in leprosy was of
particular interest since all 27 patients were (1) Portnoy, J., Garson, W., and Smith, C. A.: Rapid
plasma reagin test for syphilis. Pub. Health
nonreactive, whereas 5 of these patients showed Rep. 72: 761-766, September 1957.
some reactivity in the VDRL test. (2) Portnoy, J., and Garson, W.: New and improved
The results obtained in this study point to the antigen suspension for rapid reagin tests for
potential usefulness of the RPR card test in syphilis. Pub. Health Rep. 75: 985-988, Novem-
syphilis and other treponematoses. The results ber 1960.
obtained with leprosy patients suggest that it (3) Portnoy, J., Bossak, H. N., Falcone, V. H., and
Harris, A.: Rapid reagin test with unheated
might be more specific than the VIDRL slide serum and new improved antigen suspension.
test in detecting treponematoses in areas where Pub. Health Rep. 76: 933-935, October 1961.
leprosy is endemic. (4) Harris, A., Rosenberg, A. A., and Del Vecchio,
There has been an urgent need for a more B. R.: The VDRL slide flocculation test for
efficient field-testing procedure for the trepone- syphilis. II. A supplementary report. J. Ven.
Dis. Inform. 29: 72-75 (1948).
matoses. The RPR card test performed with (5) Harris, A., Rosenberg, A. A., and Riedel, L. M.: A
plasma obtained with the Brewer plasma col- microflocculation test for syphilis using cardio-
lection slide has the necessary components for lipin antigen. Preliminary report. J. Ven. Dis.
an effective field test: (a) a rapid, simple Inform. 27: 169-174 (1946).
method for obtaining plasma from finger-stick (6) U.S. Public Health Service: Serologic tests for
syphilis, 1959 manual. PHS Publication No.
blood, requiring no centrifuge; (b) a stable 411. U.S. Government Printing Office, Washing-
antigen suspension; (c) rapid performance; ton, D.C.
and (d) adequate sensitivity and specificity. (7) Brown, W. J.: Cluster testing-a new develop-

Vol. 77, No. 8, August 1962 651


ment in syphilis case finding. Am. J. Pub. Hynson, Westcott & Dunning, Inc., Baltimore,
Health 51: 1043-1048, July 1961. Md.
(a) Capillary tubes, Hynson, Westcott & Dunning,
EQUIPMENT REFERENCES Inc., Baltimore, Md.
(D) Merthiolate, Eli Lilly and Co., Indianapolis, Ind.
(A) Brewer plasma collection slide (patent applied (E) Specially prepared charcoal, small-particle size,
for), Becton-Dickinson & Co., Rutherford, N.J. Hynson, Westcott & Dunning, Inc., Baltimore,
(B) Brewer diagnostic card (patent applied for), Md.

Communications at Scientific Meetings


The National Association of Science Writers has * Every effort should be made to obtain texts or
published "A Handbook for Press Arrangements abstracts of programed talks well in advance.
at Scientific Meetings." * At least one society helps solve three problems:
Although its emphasis is on relations with repre- (a) informing the public and press; (b) informing
sentatives of daily newspapers and wire services, the its members; and (c) defraying pressroom expense
text offers advice on the general arrangements of by assembling the annual meeting's abstracts be-
meetings and other channels of communication. forehand in a printed volume for distribution to the
The following quotations speak for themselves: press and sale to members and others.
* The vitality of science in a democracy depends * Don't try to censor stories. Don't demand that
in large measure upon public appreciation of science. all stories written be cleared with the source. ...
. . . Science flourishes as the public understands Give reporters full and accurate facts in the first
its concepts, contributions, methods, needs, and place, and make sources and advisers available for
challenges. those who want to check facts.
* The layman is the ultimate audience for consump- * Do not attempt to hide or sequester controversial
tion of information about research. reports. Make them available but you are within
* Obviously, the science writer cannot report a your rights, if you wish, to express your view on
meeting if he is not aware it is being held. And if the soundness or validity of any research project
there are concurrent sessions, he can listen to only or report.
one speaker at a time. This handbook provides practical suggestions for
* Newsmen need and welcome assistance in per- the conduct and management of scientific meetings
forming their work, but do not expect to be and and the improvement of science communications.
should not be coddled. Among the authors are Alton Blakeslee, Associ-
* A pressroom is not and should not be a barroom. ated Press; Arthur J. Snider, Chicago Daily News;
* It can be most helpful if, as a matter of course, and Eugene H. Kone, American Institute of Physics.
all members and speakers list their local addresses The National Association of Science Writers has
when registering. . . One press officer writes that
. nearly 500 members engaged primarily in reporting
"A paging or message system to find scientists and news of science and medicine through newspapers,
bring them to the pressroom can be the most im- magazines, radio, television, and the issuances of
portant service that the individual in charge of a universities, industries, and scientific and medical
pressroom can perform. Plans for this must be organizations.
made in advance." Copies of the pamphlet are available from the
* The pressroom should be large enough to accom- National Association of Science Writers, 5 Longview
modate the anticipated number of reporters and Road, Port Washington, N.Y., for $1.00 or, in
photographers. quantities of a hundred or more, 50 cents.

652 Public Health Reports

You might also like