16/01/23, 01:33 The Fabelmans: A Review and Analysis - The Commentator

(HTTPS://YUCOMMENTATOR.ORG/)

Search 

 (HTTPS://WWW.FACEBOOK.COM/YUCOMMENTATOR)
 (HTTPS://TWITTER.COM/YU_COMMENTATOR)

The Fabelmans: A Review and Analysis

By: Yoni Mayer (https://yucommentator.org/author-posts/?author_id=WW9uaSBNYXllcg==) | Opinions
(https://yucommentator.org/category/opinions/)  |  December 25, 2022

 Share
(https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https://yucommentator.org/2022/12/the-fabelmans-a-review-and-analysis/)

 Tweet
(https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?
text=The%20Fabelmans%3A%20A%20Review%20and%20Analysis&url=https%3A%2F%2Fyucommentator.org%2F2022%2F12%2Fthe-
fabelmans-a-review-and-analysis%2F&)

 Share

 Share
(http://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?
mini=true&title=The%20Fabelmans%3A%20A%20Review%20and%20Analysis&url=https://yucommentator.org/2022/12/the-fabelmans-a-
review-and-
analysis/&summary=For+over+50+years%2C+Steven+Spielberg+has+been+the+artist+who+has+captured+the+minds+and+imaginations+...)

Like 11 Share

For over 50 years, Steven Spielberg has been the artist who has captured the minds and imaginations of moviegoers
everywhere. In his new movie, Spielberg explores the roots of his movie-making magic through a fictional family, “the
Fablemans,” heavily inspired by, if not directly mirroring, his own. The movie depicts the beginning of his interest in film and
his first steps as a young filmmaker (directing his sisters as his first actresses.) The film then traces his progression into an
amateur high school filmmaker, creating films for his boy scouts troop and his high school and taking his films from a
pastime to a passion. Over the course of the film, the audience sees him develop cinema tricks and direct actors for the first
time and impress his family and friends with his craft. We witness the growth of his own understanding of the power of
cinema and the importance it has on his life and the lives of those around him. If there’s any artist who has earned the right
to create art that tells the story of how they fell in love with their craft, it’s Steven Spielberg, and he has done that with his
new movie, “The Fabelmans.”

“The Fabelmans” revolves around a character based on Spielberg: a young moviemaking enthusiast, Sammy Fabelman. In
direct parallels to Spielberg's life, Sammy is the son of a computer engineer father and a concert pianist mother. This
tension between the artists and scientists is evident at the beginning of the movie as Sammy’s parents take him to the
movies; his father explains movies scientifically as pictures that the brain processes together, and his mother describes
movies as “dreams that you never forget.” 

https://yucommentator.org/2022/12/the-fabelmans-a-review-and-analysis/ 1/6
16/01/23, 01:33 The Fabelmans: A Review and Analysis - The Commentator

“The Fabelmans” explores the themes of family, passions and the interrelationship and coexistence of the two. In a pivotal
scene in the movie, I noticed this theme explored perfectly in the triad of protagonists, Sammy and his parents. 

This three-minute sequence reveals Spielberg’s fluency in the language of cinema. There is no dialogue between the
characters, rather, the camera tells a story with its movements and the details it chooses to highlight. The scene is a
microcosm and demonstration of the full control Spielberg possesses over his movies. If I had the time, an entire book could
be written analyzing every scene and its implications for the movie, but for this piece, I chose to focus on a particularly
moving scene in the movie. 

Sammy is in the midst of uncovering a compromising truth about his family through the footage that he took over a family
camping trip. Sammy’s father, Burt, is seated on the couch in the living room looking over computer plans and listening
inattentively to his wife, Mitzi, playing the piano, the hauntingly beautiful melody of Bach’s Concerto BWV 974 in D minor
emanating from the keys. 

This scene is anchored in the relationship between family and passions; Sammy is grounded in the world of film and
struggles the most with the balance between his interests and the people he loves. Cinema consumes him and is the lens
through which he views the world. For this reason, he discovers the family secret not on the camping trip itself, but when
looking at the footage. Additionally, throughout the course of this revelation, the camera revolves around Sammy signifying
both the reality-upending effects of this truth being revealed, but more implicitly, symbolizing that cinema is constantly on his
mind. He is locked into the world of the camera; art surrounds him on all sides. The majority of this scene focuses on
Sammy analyzing the film from the trip and only lends a few frames at the end to his reaction to the truth. His priority was
analyzing the film; the harsh truth of the family is secondary. 

Throughout the scene, the camera cuts between Sammy, Mitzi and Burt as a further demonstration of the tension between
family members and the lens through which we the audience view that family: the camera. Mitzi’s relationship with her art is
more consuming than Sammy’s; she focuses on the fun and whimsical in life, even at the expense of her family. She plays
the piano somberly, focusing on the keys alone, even though her husband sits on a couch directly across from her. The
camera raises above her head signaling to the audience that for Mitzi, passions separate oneself from the world. They raise
us out of this reality and become an all-encompassing experience. The camera moves away from her to demonstrate that
her music, her form of artistic expression, removes her from those around her. 

Sammy’s father has the healthiest understanding of the balance between passion and family. He is seated on the living
room couch, the same room as Mitzi and the piano, and is introduced in the scene with a wide shot; he is involved in this
scene, but the focus is not directly on him. He flips through his computer engineering papers, which are his personal
preoccupation, but, due to the wide shot, he is not the main focus of this scene, at least not yet. As the scene progresses,
cutting between Mitzi, Sammy and Burt, the camera slowly zooms in on Burt, gradually transitioning into a close-up and
indicating that we should take note of the father as he takes up more of the screen. As the camera zooms in, we notice Burt
paying closer attention to Mitzi’s piano playing. Eventually, he puts down his papers and focuses all his attention on the
music. He is devoted to his wife and places his own passion aside so that he can give respect to hers. He realizes that
family takes precedence over personal interests. Similarly, he initially discounts Sammy’s filmmaking as a hobby and wishes
he would go into something more practical like engineering, but by the end of the movie, he understands that filmmaking is
Sammy’s ultimate passion and acquiesces.

In this brief, three-minute sequence, Spielberg proves yet again why he is the master filmmaker whose movies stand the
test of time — he uses the medium of movies to their fullest degree. There’s a mantra in filmmaking: “Show, don’t tell.” The
audience should be able to ascertain the message and intent of the filmmaker through the images on the screen, not
necessarily through dialogue. Famously, Steven Soderbergh, an acclaimed American director, noted
(https://extension765.com/blogs/soderblog/raiders) how Spielberg’s “Raiders of the Lost Ark” conveyed its story just as
well without audio and in black-and-white. He remarked, “I operate under the theory a movie should work with the sound off,
and under that theory, staging becomes paramount ... how the shots are built and laid out, what the rules of movement are,
what the cutting patterns are.” In other words, the character blocking, cinematography, camera movement and expressions
of the characters would succeed in conveying a message just as well as dialogue. 

With “The Fabelmans,” Spielberg didn’t make a whimsically creative and imaginative movie like he was known for in his
early days. There were no killer sharks, dinosaurs or extraterrestrials. However, the theme of family, a theme that often
appeared in those movies, was explored in full force in this movie. Spielberg analyzed his own life and the core memories

https://yucommentator.org/2022/12/the-fabelmans-a-review-and-analysis/ 2/6
16/01/23, 01:33 The Fabelmans: A Review and Analysis - The Commentator

which shaped him into one of the most influential filmmakers of all time. He demonstrated mastery of his craft: his ability to
connect with an audience, visually explore a story through the full use of cinema as a medium and bring life to the
seemingly mundane story of a boy's high school experience. “The Fabelmans” is a brilliant movie and the backstory of one
of the most beloved and celebrated directors. I highly recommend a trip to the theater
(https://yucommentator.org/2021/10/journey-to-the-center-of-the-mind-the-magic-of-the-theater/).

For more stories like this, join us on WhatsApp. (https://chat.whatsapp.com/Ci2iLlFmmJaAZHWmA9JfZT)

_________

Photo Caption: Camera

Photo Credit: Flickr

 Share
(https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https://yucommentator.org/2022/12/the-fabelmans-a-review-and-analysis/)

 Tweet
(https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?
text=The%20Fabelmans%3A%20A%20Review%20and%20Analysis&url=https%3A%2F%2Fyucommentator.org%2F2022%2F12%2Fthe-fabelmans-a-review-and-
analysis%2F&)

 Share

 Share
(http://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?
mini=true&title=The%20Fabelmans%3A%20A%20Review%20and%20Analysis&url=https://yucommentator.org/2022/12/the-fabelmans-a-review-and-
analysis/&summary=For+over+50+years%2C+Steven+Spielberg+has+been+the+artist+who+has+captured+the+minds+and+imaginations+...)

Like 11 Share

0 comments Sort by Newest

Add a comment...

Facebook Comments Plugin

TRENDING POSTS

(https://yucommentator.org?p=15275)

WILF CAMPUS STUDENT COUNCILS LAUNCH BIKKUR CHOLIM BRIGADE TO DELIVER RELIEF BAGS TO ILL STUDENTS
(HTTPS://YUCOMMENTATOR.ORG?P=15275)
By: Andy Katz (https://yucommentator.org/author-posts/?author_id=QW5keSBLYXR6) | News (https://yucommentator.org/category/news/) January 6, 2023

(https://yucommentator.org?p=15272)

STUDENTS CAUGHT CHEATING USING AI ON FINAL; ACADEMIC INTEGRITY POLICY UPDATED (HTTPS://YUCOMMENTATOR.ORG?P=15272)
By: Jonathan Levin (https://yucommentator.org/author-posts/?author_id=Sm9uYXRoYW4gTGV2aW4=) | News (https://yucommentator.org/category/news/) January 5, 2023

https://yucommentator.org/2022/12/the-fabelmans-a-review-and-analysis/ 3/6
16/01/23, 01:33 The Fabelmans: A Review and Analysis - The Commentator

(https://yucommentator.org?p=15269)

RABBI ARI ROCKOFF APPOINTED AS DAVID MITZNER COMMUNITY DEAN FOR VALUES AND LEADERSHIP (HTTPS://YUCOMMENTATOR.ORG?P=15269)
By: Hannah Pollak (https://yucommentator.org/author-posts/?author_id=SGFubmFoIFBvbGxhaw==) | News (https://yucommentator.org/category/news/) January 2, 2023

SOCIAL FEED

https://yucommentator.org/2022/12/the-fabelmans-a-review-and-analysis/ 4/6
16/01/23, 01:34 The Fabelmans: A Review and Analysis - The Commentator

Tweets from @yu_commentator Follow on Twitter

YU Commentator @yu_commentator · Dec 29, 2022

“YU was privileged to welcome Panzarelli in 2018 and she has consistently been a student favorite ever since,” writes @ariel_kahan in Features.

yucommentator.org
From Venezuela to Furst Hall: A Panzarelli Story - The Commentator
Everybody knows that some classes in YU are absolutely impossible to register for because they fill up so quickly. While
there are a few classes in this category, any class with Prof. Alexandra...

YU Commentator @yu_commentator · Dec 20, 2022

YU to Hold American Dream Mall Takeover
—
Dov Pfeiffer reports

yucommentator.org
YU To Hold American Dream Takeover For Second Straight Year - The Commentator
Yeshiva University will host a takeover of the American Dream Mall for undergraduate students and faculty members on
Dec. 20th as part of Chanukah celebrations.  The takeover, organized and funded by...

YU Commentator @yu_commentator · Dec 15, 2022

BREAKING NEWS The Appellate Division of the New York State Supreme Court upheld a June order directing @YUNews to recognize the
YU Pride Alliance today.
__
Jonathan Levin reports

yucommentator.org
YU Loses in New York Appellate Court - The Commentator
The Appellate Division of the New York State Supreme Court upheld a June order directing Yeshiva University to
recognize the YU Pride Alliance Thursday.  The court ruled that YU does not meet the...

1 3

YU Commentator @yu_commentator · Dec 9, 2022

“Several thousand Jews still reside in Iran today. In light of the current situation in Iran, below is an article published in 1997 which highlights
Iranian students at YU,” writes Akiva Herzfeld in Features.

yucommentator.org
From the Commie Archives (November 11, 1997; Volume 62, Issue 5) — Rabbis and Ayatollahs: Students...
Editor’s Note: For the past two months, protests have raged across Iran following the arrest and eventual death of 22-
year-old Mahsa Amini, who was punished for incorrectly wearing her hijab. The...

YU Commentator @yu_commentator · Dec 9, 2022

The Stern College Drama Society (SCDS) will perform “The Mousetrap” at the Schottenstein Theatre on Wilf Campus next week.
__
Hannah Mamet reports

yucommentator.org
Stern College Dramatics Society to Perform 'The Mousetrap' this December - The Commentator
This article was originally published on Dec. 6. The Stern College Drama Society (SCDS) will perform “The Mousetrap” at
the Schottenstein Theatre on Wilf Campus next week. The play will be directed...

View more on Twitter

https://yucommentator.org/2022/12/the-fabelmans-a-review-and-analysis/ 5/6
16/01/23, 01:34 The Fabelmans: A Review and Analysis - The Commentator

©YU COMMENTATOR

https://yucommentator.org/2022/12/the-fabelmans-a-review-and-analysis/ 6/6