Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.elsevier.com/locate/apcata
Abstract
As a part of a study for the preparation of nano-sized g-Al2O3 powder with controlled porosity and pore size distribution, a precipitation/
digestion route was exploited to generate a boehmite precursor having a narrow size distribution of spherical nano-sized particles: size 3.5 nm with
surface area 261 m2/g, average pore diameter of 4.86 nm, and pore volume 0.377 cm3/g. In this route, aqueous solution of aluminum nitrate and
sodium carbonate were added simultaneously drop by drop to a well-stirred 200 ml volume of deionized water (taken in a round-bottom flask) at
70 8C to precipitate boehmite precursor in the pH range of 7.5–8.5 after digestion at the same temperature for 3 h. The boehmite precursor thus
obtained is further washed with deionized water first to avoid ‘Na’ contamination and then by ethanol/acetone. The digested precipitate was finally
air dried at room temperature. The calcinations of as-dried boehmite precursor at 550 8C/5 h in air produced porous nano-sized g-Al2O3 powder
particles having spherical shape with size of 4.5 nm. These powder particles showed BET surface surface area 220 m2/g with average pore
diameter of 7.0 nm and pore volume 0.487 cm3/g. However, room temperature precipitation/digestion produces non-crystalline boehmite that
gave poorly crystallized g-Al2O3 powder particles with lower surface area 133.90 m2/g; these had higher average pore diameter of 26.67 nm with
pore volume of 1.02 cm3/g. In methanol conversion to DME reaction, g-Al2O3 catalyst made from precipitation/digestion at 70 8C gave a similar
yield of DME when compared with the yield for g-Al2O3 prepared from commercial Catapal-B boehmite sample.
# 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
base like NaOH or NH4OH or thermal decomposition of urea in burettes) drop by drop to precipitate Al cations in the form of
aqueous medium. Many preparation parameters, like pH, nature hydroxides. The temperature was maintained 70 8C during
of salts and bases and their addition sequence, have to be precipitation/digestion experiment. The pH after precipitation
judiciously controlled to obtain boehmite/g-Al2O3 powders with was found to be in the range of 7.5–8.5. The precipitates were
enhanced and reproducible properties, such case explains the further digested at 70 8C for 3 h. The digested precipitates were
persistence of intense research in the area of chemical processing filtered and re-dispersed again in hot 2 l of deionized water,
of inorganic materials in general and of boehmite/g-Al2O3 in filtered and finally washed with ethanol first followed by acetone
particular [10,12,13]. It is reported [14] that, at pH 8, to avoid contamination of ‘Na’ ions; and air dried at room
gelatinous alumina monohydrate AlO(OH) or boehmite is temperature. The as-dried precipitates were calcined in a
formed, which decomposes to g-Al2O3 after calcinations at 400– programmable furnace at 550 8C/5 h in air with heating rate
500 8C in air whereas pH above 9.0 favors formation of beta of 2 8C/min to produce nano-sized g-Al2O3 powders. To
alumina trihydrate {Al(OH)3} or bayerite. Chuah et al. [14] compare the effect of temperature on physical/chemical
studied the effects of digestion on textural properties of the characteristics of as-prepared boehmite/g-Al2O3 powders and
boehmite precursor and g-Al2O3 powders obtained by its their effect in methanol to DME conversion, we carried out
calcination in air at various temperatures. They conducted precipitation/digestion experiments at RT keeping similar
precipitation reactions at room temperature using 0.75 M precipitation/digestion conditions.
solution of ammonia as precipitant and 0.5 M solution of
aluminum nitrate; fractions of these precipitates were digested 2.2. Characterization
further at 100 8C for different time durations. During precipita-
tion, it is necessary to keep pH 6.0 by controlled addition of Thermo-gravimetric analysis of the samples was conducted
ammonium hydroxide and or nitric acid solution. To solve such in TGA/DTA (TA Instrument: DMA, SDT 2960) in flowing
problems, sodium carbonate was used as precipitant and co- nitrogen atmosphere at a heating rate of 10 8C/min up to
precipitation/digestion simultaneously was carried out at 70 8C 1200 8C using an alumina as the reference material. This
for 3 h. The in situ generated OH ions produced by hydrolysis of showed the various decomposition reactions occurring in as-
sodium carbonate in aqueous medium were used for the dried precursor as a function of temperature and we could
precipitation process. A temperature of 70 8C and a pH of 7.5–8.5 decide the calcination temperature of the as-dried precursor.
was maintained to enhance kinetics of precipitation/digestion To identify phases and their crystallinity in as-dried and
reaction. Therefore, the main objective of the present work is to calcined materials, we carried out powder X-ray diffraction
use a simple precipitation/digestion method to produce boehmite (XRD) studies was carried out with a Rigaku diffractometer
precursor with controlled chemistry and geometry using cheaper using Cu Ka radiation. The BET surface areas and pore volumes
starting chemicals like aluminum nitrate and sodium carbonate at were estimated from nitrogen adsorption and desorption
pH 7.5–8.5 and to generate g-Al2O3 powders possessing high isotherm data obtained at 196 8C on a constant-volume
surface area with controlled porosity, pore size distribution and adsorption apparatus (Micromeritics, ASAP-2400). The pore
crystallinity by its calcinations in air. Another aspect of present volumes were determined at a relative pressure (P/Po) of 0.99.
work is to characterize both boehmite precursor and g-Al2O3 The as-prepared samples were degassed at 150 8C for 3 h before
powders employing various physico-chemical characterization measurements. The pore size distributions in as-prepared
techniques. Thus we can further test the performance of g-Al2O3 samples were verified by a BJH (Barett–Joyner–Halenda) model
in dehydration reactions of methanol to DME and compare the from the adsorption branch of the nitrogen isotherms [15]. The
results with those for a standard g-Al2O3 catalyst derived from microstructures of both as-prepared and calcined samples were
commercial Catapal-B boehmite sample. All these results related studied by transmission electron mocroscope (TEM) images
to synthesis, characterization and methanol to DME conversion obtained on a JEOL JEM 2100F (Field Emission Electron
reaction are presented in this paper. Microscope) instrument operated at 200 kV. The PL spectra were
recorded on a Perkin-Elmer LS50B spectrometer using 325 nm
2. Experimental excitation wavelength from a pulsed Xenon lamp. The
temperature desorption of ammonia (NH3-TPD) experiment
2.1. Syntheses was performed to determine the surface acidity of various
samples. A 0.1 g sample was initially flushed with He at 500 8C
Aluminum nitrate {Al(NO3)39H2O, 99.5%} (Aldrich), for 5 h and then cooled down to 100 8C and further saturated with
sodium carbonate {Na2CO3, 98%} (Junsei) and deionized water NH3. After NH3 exposure, the sample was purged with He until
were used as starting chemicals. Initially, aluminum nitrate equilibrium, and then heated from 100 to 700 8C at a heating rate
(0.041 M) solution is made by dissolving 15.614 g in 400 ml of of 10 8C/min. A BEL-CAT instrument was employed to monitor
deionized water. Similarly (0.075 M) solution of sodium the amount of ammonia in the effluent.
carbonate is prepared by dissolving 7.95 g in 400 ml of
deionized water. Two hundred milliliters of deionized water is 2.3. Catalyst testing in methanol to DME conversion
taken in a 2 l capacity round-bottom flask and stirred well using
magnetic stirrer. Then sodium carbonate and aluminum nitrate The g-Al2O3 catalysts made by the precipitation/digestion
solutions are added to 200 ml of deionized water (from separate method were tested for their activity in methanol dehydration
H.S. Potdar et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 321 (2007) 109–116 111
reactions to dimethyl ether (DME). Their performance was were observed in TGA curve, at 90 and 300 8C respectively, and
compared with that of a standard g-Al2O3 catalyst prepared a very small weight loss above 500 8C is also shown. The first
from Catapal-B (SASOL) boehmite under similar operating endothermic weight loss at 90 8C is related to removal of
reaction conditions. All catalysts were pretreated separately, physically adsorbed water/ethanol/acetone, while the second
keeping a He flow of 50 ml/min at 500 8C for 1 h, and then the weight loss at above 300 8C is ascribed to dehydroxylation
activity was measured with 0.5 g catalyst in a fixed bed reactor process and nitrate decomposition. The broad exothermic peak
at the reaction conditions given below: T = 250 and 270 8C, at 500 8C with a very minor loss in weight in TGA curve may be
P = 101.30 kPa, WHSV = 1.0 h1. The reaction products were attributed to crystallization of transition alumina and or decom-
analyzed using a FID detector equipped with 30 m GS-Q position of residual organics and further continuation of dehy-
capillary column. droxylation process. A total weight loss of 28.63% is seen
during the three-step decomposition process. If bayerite phase
3. Results and discussion only would have formed by reaction (2), then in that case a total
theoretical weight loss of 34.62% would have been expected
A transparent gel like precursor containing Al cations is due to following decomposition reaction (4):
precipitated at pH 7.5–8.5 when sodium carbonate and Al
2AlðOHÞ3 ! Al2 O3 þ 3H2 O (4)
nitrate salt solutions are added drop by drop to 200 ml
deionized water. The mixture was stirred and maintained at a However, the total weight loss of 28.63% is shown in the
temperature of 70 8C. The following chemical reaction experimentally observed TGA curve. If we presume that the
occurred: single phase boehmite is precipitated by reaction (3), then the
total weight loss of 15% would have been expected by follow-
Na2 CO3 þ 2HOH ! 2NaOH þ H2 O þ CO2 (1)
ing reaction (5) leading to the formation of g-Al2O3 powder:
AlðNO3 Þ3 þ 3NaOH ! AlðOHÞ3 # þ 3NaNO3 (2) AlOOH ! Al2 O3 þ H2 O (5)
AlðOHÞ3 ! AlOOH # þ H2 O (3) The results in our thermal analysis study indicate that the as-
dried precursor may have composition AlOOH corresponding
The hydrolysis of sodium carbonate in aqueous medium gen- to the boehmite precursor as the total loss of 28.63% shown in
erates OH1 ions by reaction (1). The precipitate obtained by TGA is higher than theoretically calculated for reaction (5) i.e.
reaction (2) is digested at a temperature 70 8C, which helped 15%. This additional loss of 13.63% in TGA curve may be
to homogenize it due to the slow ripening process. The pre- related to adsorption of water and or alcohol/acetone/nitrate
cipitate is further processed by washing with deionized water species in boehmite precursor. As we do not know the exact
first, followed by washing with alcohol and acetone to avoid the ratio of adsorbed water/acetone + ethanol and the concentration
contamination of sodium ions. The digestion step is found to be of our associated nitrate species, it is not possible for us to
essential to convert it to crystalline boehmite precursor by calculate the corrected molecular weight of boehmite precursor
reaction (3). EDAX analysis of as-dried precursor showed with adsorbed species and to match experimentally observed
the presence of Al and oxygen elements, no signal correspond- weight loss of 28.63% with that theoretically calculated from
ing to sodium element was detected, indicating its absence in the corrected molecular weight of precursor [16]. To support
the material. To confirm further the formation of boehmite by our argument, that the as-dried precursor that is formed by
reaction (3), we performed a systematic characterization of the reaction (3) is boehmite and crystallization of g-Al2O3 take
as-dried precursor. The thermal behavior of as-dried precursor place above 500 8C, as is seen by DTA/TGA studies, XRD and
was studied by DTA/TGA and experimental curves for the same IR studies were under taken on as-dried precursor and powder
are depicted in Fig. 1. Two major endothermic weight losses obtained by its calcination at 550 8C. Fig. 2A(a–c) depicts XRD
patterns of as-dried precursor formed by precipitation/digestion
at RT and 70 8C and of commercial Catapal-B boehmite
sample. Fig. 2A(a) shows the as-dried precursor to be non-
crystalline in nature, as a broad hump is seen in XRD pattern,
whereas Fig. 2A(b, c) showed all reflections matching with
boehmite [JCPDS 21-1307] phase. The boehmite prepared at
70 8C appears to be more crystalline than that prepared at RT. It
seems that precipitation/digestion at 70 8C for 3 h helps to
generate crystalline boehmite due to a fast ripening process. It
is very clear from Fig. 2A(b, c) that the boemite precursor
particles show nano-size nature as is seen from line broadening
due to the presence of small crystallite sizes. The crystallite
sizes were calculated the using Scherrer equation:
kl
D¼ ;
Fig. 1. DTA/TGA curves of as-dried boehmite. b cos u
112 H.S. Potdar et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 321 (2007) 109–116
Table 1
Surface area, average pore diameter, and pore volume of boehmite and g-Al2O3 powder
Item Surface area Average pore Pore volume
(m2 g1) diameter (nm) (cm3 g1)
Boehmite (70 8C precipitated precursor) 261 4.86 0.377
g-Alumina (made from 70 8C precipitated precursor) 220 7.02 0.485
Boehmite (RT precipitated precursor) 178 20.39 1.021
g-Alumina (made from RT precipitated precursor) 134 26.67 1.026
Boehmite (Ref. [14]) 294 3.90 0.200
g-Alumina (Ref. [14]) 258 5.14 0.270
Boehmite:Catapal-B 274 4.78 0.396
g-Alumina from Catapal-B 198 6.94 0.435
70 8C and the in situ generation of OH ions shown by reaction of OH ions help to obtain nano-sized boehmite precursor with
(1). Thus, the condition required for fast nucleation of Al(OH)3 comparable textural properties when compared to with those
and controlled growth is achieved by maintaining a slight reported by Chuah et al. [14]. The pH of 7.5–8.5 in the present
alkaline pH of 7.5–8.5 and in situ generation of OH ions is investigation helps the boehmite particles to acquire a positive
achieved by using Na2CO3 as precipitant. Chuah et al. [14] charge and may help to maintain them in an un-agglomerated
maintained a slightly acidic pH 6.0 during precipitation at state, because the reported isoelectric point of boehmite
room temperature and used 0.75 M solution of ammonia as particles is 9.7 [20]. As the particles of boehmite carry positive
precipitant; digestion was subsequently carried out at 100 8C/ charge, there is some possibility that NO31 species may get
48 h. Thus, a better control of pH and in situ generation adsorbed on the surface of it, which is reflected in the IR
Fig. 4. N2 adsorption and desorption isotherms of (A) as-dried boehmite and Fig. 5. BJH pore size distribution of (A) as-dried boehmite and (B) g-Al2O3
(B) g-Al2O3 powder. (a) Precipitated precursor at RT, (b) precipitated precursor powder. (a) Precipitated precursor at RT, (b) precipitated precursor at 70 8C, and
at 70 8C, and (c) Captapal-B. (c) Captapal-B.
114 H.S. Potdar et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 321 (2007) 109–116
spectrum of as-dried precipitate where the presence of nitrate that a total pore volume of, 0.487 cm3/g, which is much
species is confirmed. The nature of N2 adsorption and higher than that reported by Chuah et al. [14], is obtained for
desorption isotherm remains type IV, as is seen from samples digested at 70 8C for only 3 h in the present study. They
Fig. 4A(a–c) and Fig. 4B(a–c) for as-dried boehmite precursor could obtain similar values of pore volume but longer durations
and calcined g-Al2O3 powders with changes in hysteresis, of digestion time of 96 h or more are required. The lower pore
indicating thereby changes in pore structure in these materials volume 0.435 cm3/g is maintained in commercial g-Al2O3.
[21]. The BJH pore size distribution curves are reproduced in Fig. 6(a, b) shows the SEM micrographs for as-dried boehmite
Fig. 5A(a–c) and Fig. 5B(a–c), respectively. The pore size and g-Al2O3 powders. The boehmite and g-Al2O3 indicated
distribution is wide and pore size lies between 2 and 100 nm for strong agglomeration of particles with varied sizes. The
as-dried boehmite precursor if precipitation/digestion is carried boehmite and g-Al2O3 powder, showed similar morphological
out at RT. Most of the pores lie in the macro porous range. On features. Therefore, to get more information of morphological
the other hand, a broad pore size distribution in the range of 2– features of as-dried boehmite and calcined g-Al2O3 powders,
100 nm is maintained in the sample that is made by we undertook TEM studies. Fig. 7(a, b) represents typical TEM
precipitation/digestion at 70 8C for 3 h. The Catapal-B images of as-dried boehmite precursor and calcined g-Al2O3
boehmite sample shows a narrow pore size distribution in
the 2–100 nm range. The RT precipitated/digested sample after
calcinations in air gave a pore size distribution in the range of
10–100 nm {Fig. 5B(a)}. However, the pore size becomes
narrower, as is seen in Fig. 5B(b), and the pore size lies in the
range of 2–50 nm, i.e. in mesoporous range, in the case of
samples precipitated/digested at 70 8C after calcinations in air.
The commercial sample, however, gave a narrow pore size
distribution in the range of 2–20 nm. The important finding is
Fig. 6. SEM photographs of (a) as-dried boehmite and (b) g-Al2O3 powder. Fig. 7. TEM images of (a) as-dried boehmite and (b) g-Al2O3 powder.
H.S. Potdar et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 321 (2007) 109–116 115
Fig. 8. PL spectrum of g-Al2O3 powder. Fig. 9. NH3-TPD profiles of g-alumina obtained from (a) Catapal-B, (b) RT,
and (c) 70 8C.
powders. Fig. 7a reveals that the boehmite particles are precipitated/digested at RT (0.8698 mmol/g). The g-alumina
spherical in nature, having a narrow size distribution with size powder derived from the commercial boehmite (Catapal-B)
of 3.0–3.5 nm. These particles are aggregated to form pores of sample also gave the lower value of the desorbed ammonia
varying sizes. This observation is consistent with BJH pore size (1.14 mmol/g).
distribution curve {Fig. 5A(b)} where wide pore size The TPD spectra (Fig. 9) of the g-alumina powder contain
distribution is evident. Fig. 7b shows the TEM of g-Al2O3 two main intense peaks in the temperature range of 300–
powders obtained by calcinations of as-dried boehmite 600 8C. These peaks can be assigned to the NH3 desorbed from
precursor. The results indicate the presence of spherical the acidic sites with medium to high strengths [23]. The
particles of 4–4.5 nm size. Some particles aligned to form intensity of these two peaks is found to be higher in the sample
rods whereas most of them remain with spherical shape, precipitated/digested at 70 8C than that of the samples
thereby producing pores of narrow size distribution which is precipitated/digested at RT and commercial Catapal-B,
consistent with a BJH pore size distribution curve {Fig. 5B(b)}. respectively. From these results, it can be concluded that the
Further characterization of g-Al2O3 powders was carried out by g-alumina powder possesses strong surface acidic sites as
measuring the PL spectrum that is shown in Fig. 8. The compared to the g-alumina powder obtained from the RT
spectrum indicated two peaks: a strong one centered at 415– precipitated/digested and the commercial Catapal-B boehmite
420 nm and a weak one centered at 650 nm. The emission at sample. The precipitation/digestion at 70 8C not only helped to
415–420 nm is ascribed to singly ionized oxygen vacancies improve surface area of the boehmite/g-Al2O3 powder
[22]. The origin of the peak at 650 nm is not clear at present. It (Table 1) but also helped to enhance the surface acidity of
may be associated with defects other than oxygen vacancies the resulting g-Al2O3 powders (Table 2). This is an interesting
generated during decomposition of the boehmite precursor. finding or important result of the present investigation. Thus,
the g-Al2O3 obtained through precipitation/digestion route
3.1. NH3-TPD gave more Lewis acidity and acid density resulting in a higher
performance as a catalyst.
Fig. 9 shows the NH3-TPD spectra of the g-alumina powder
and the data obtained for the same are summarized in the 3.2. Catalyst performance
Table 2. It is evident from the Table 2 that the amount of
ammonia desorbed from the sample precipitated/digested at The catalyst activity tests was conducted at two different
70 8C is more (1.6701 mmol/g) than that of the sample temperatures of 250 and 270 8C under similar reaction
conditions for three g-Al2O3 catalysts, two prepared from
precipitation/digestion experiments at RT and 70 8C, and one
Table 2 commercially available Catapal-B sample; results are depicted
NH3-TPD data on g-alumina obtained from precipitated precursor at RT, 70 8C
and Catapal-B
in Fig. 10. The catalyst made from 70 8C precipitation/
digestion boehmite precursor shows much higher conversion of
Region I Region II Total amount of methanol to DME compared to the conversion for the one made
(mmol/g) (mmol/g) acid sites (mmol/g)
from room temperature precipitation/digestion material. The
RT 0.4112 0.4586 0.8698 performance of g-Al2O3 catalyst (70 8C precipitation/diges-
70 8C 0.9814 0.6887 1.6701
tion) is comparable with that of commercially Catapal-B
Catapal-B 0.6527 0.4918 1.1445
(SASOL Company) calcined sample. However, it is found that
116 H.S. Potdar et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 321 (2007) 109–116
Acknowledgements