Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract:
The paper offers an analysis of the symbolic importance of material culture. Our starting premise is that
clothing is a cultural document of a given time and space, as it participates in the formation of individual
and collective identities. Bearing this in mind, we’ll study the female traditional costume of the Azores with
a view to improving knowledge on the archipelago’s culture and to creating new visual objects that not only
embody the cultural legacy of the islands but also capitalise on environmental resources and endogenous
elements. In order to accomplish our purpose, we’ll analyse the islands’ historic background from the point
of view of culture, economy and politics, and reflect on the role played by culture in preventing the risk of a
de-characterised global world, as well as a force that ensures resistance, empowerment and sustainability.
Finally, we’ll seek to enhance the future life of the traditional costume by using it as an inspiration for the
creation of jewels. It is our aim to demonstrate the power of contemporary jewellery. Contemporary design
can both preserve the community’s identity and transform the visual object into a message that travels
across frontiers and unites different peoples.
1. Introduction
One way of understanding the nexus between culture and identity is to highlight the autonomous
development of identities as a means of fighting patterns of thinking and acting based on uniformity.
Another approach underlines the importance of culture in preserving identity traits alongside the
preservation of the natural environment and cultural heritage. A third approach brings the focus onto the
effect of creative activities for personal well-being and for the formation of community spaces of belonging.
As we study the first two approaches, it becomes clear that there is an overlapping of culture and identity,
as they share a common ground where questions are asked about who we are, both collectively and
individually, and measures are adopted for protecting our cultural legacy. When the Heads of State of the
nine Member States of the European Community met in Copenhagen to write the “Declaration on the
European Identity”, on the 14th of December 1973, they considered crucial to emphasize the need to
“preserve the rich variety of their national cultures” and to stress the fact that from “the diversity of
cultures within the framework of common European civilization” ensues a key element in giving European
identity “its originality and its own dynamism”. As Hawkes would later say, culture participates actively in
strengthening a set of values and priorities at the heart of identity: democracy, inclusion, creativity,
imagination, freedom, justice, peace, health, vitality are some of the elements that help define who we are
and the society we live in, being, therefore, the broad terrain where these two concepts meet (Hawkes,
2001, p.7).1
1
em: https://www.cvce.eu/content/publication/1999/1/1/02798dc9-9c69-4b7d-b2c9-
f03a8db7da32/publishable_en.pdf
identity studies, being a common thematic priority and unifying element in studies that would otherwise be
compromised by an almost unlimited set of diverse interests.
Power is, thus, at the heart of culture and of identity. It is crucial to understand the mechanisms of power
production and distribution, be it material, social or symbolic, so that patterns of domination/dependence,
oppression/agency are known and made clear what is validated or reprehended, who is heard and who is
ignored, so that all identities are treated equally and benefit from the same rights and opportunities.
In the last years of the 20th century, contributions from anthropology (Holland et al., 1998), feminism
(Butler, 1990), cultural studies (Hall, 1996) and literature (Moya, 2002) offered a new perspective, following
the very influential paper of Davies and Harré which has paved the way for a shift from focusing on the
‘social role’ to selves ‘positioning’ themselves through language as the best way to study identity and
power relations. The authors argued that self-positioning often emerges from speech acts and symbolic
representations. Discourse acts and representations are an important tool of empowerment, resistance,
will and agency. Cultural processes dealing with creative action in several systems of representation
promote imagination, improvisation, and innovation, breaking down deterministic patterns and
dependence schemes.
Authorship brings satisfaction. Voicing one’s opinion grants empowerment. Identity formed in the context
of symbolic and creative action strengthens collective ties, promotes a feeling of belonging and agency in
change-making, generating in return a feeling of self-accomplishment. In a similar manner, Moran (2011)
highlights that identity is shaped by the joint forces of the self and the others. The claim of association is
always present as a powerful force. Performances allow individuals to stage different forms of acting in life,
which broadens their potential for choosing who they want to be and who they want to become. It is
worthy to recall that through cultural performance the individual is placed at the centre of both cultural
activity and social and political action.
As we’ve mentioned, regional culture displays meaning from different kinds of representations. The
paintings by Domingos Rebelo, Tomaz Borba Vieira e Urbano strike important chords at the heart of
Azorean identity: emigration due to poverty, inefficient political legislation to overcome economic
constraints, unequal distribution of power. In a similar manner, traditional costumes speak about the
archipelago’s identity. As they are constantly subject to change, all these identity symbols allow current
times to engage in a fruitful dialogue with the past and renew former meanings, adjusting them to
contemporary taste and vocabulary. It happened with the paintings, as with clothing. Such will be the main
concern of the next two sections.
The proposed reconstruction chooses white, blue and bright pink as the main colors – colors, according to
the author, «preferred by our people» and which, coincidentally, are also found in the hydrangeas that line
the regional roads in the first weeks of summer. Enthusiastically, the author updates the description
provided for the first illustration, with a second image and description. This time she adds new details: skirt
with a light “pink meringue” hem, embroidered in capuchins with the same blue, pink apron with hem in
the same way, white underskirts, embroidered by hand, white lace stockings, made by hand, toe overshoes
pointed galoshes and black polishing strip. (Gomes, 1955, p. 129). Note the sophisticat*ed choice of the
shade of light “pink meringue”, unequivocally the result of a refined taste that impregnates the
reconstitution of the past according to the preference of the elite and represents the desire for cultural
affirmation of the archipelago both nationally and internationally.
We know from Arruda Furtado that in 1884 women almost always wore, over their shirts, a strong skirt
made of rough serge or woven patchwork blankets, like bed blankets (Gomes, 1955, p. 123). Lace,
underskirts and embroideries were excluded from a poor and destitute daily life, although they appeared
during festive seasons.
Bearing in mind the particular case of São Miguel, it is important to underline the sharp contrast between
the cape and hood, which survived until the first decades of the 20th century, both as an outerwear and as
a concealment factor. An article published in Revista Michaelense in 1919 asserted that the first
appearance of this costume had served the purpose of expressing the shame that Portuguese women felt
for the Spanish administration in Portugal. Made of strong and thick cloth, dark blue or black, it consisted of
the “Capote”, a round cape that covered the woman up to her feet, and the “Capelo”, a wide head covering
resting on the shoulders and supported by a whalebone bow and hemp lining, which ensured its shape and
consistency. With sober colors and heavy fabric, it contrasts with the attire associated with festive rurality,
the latter partially redone with the intention of communicating a colorful and beautiful image in tune with
the colors of the landscape. The first covered almost entirely the female figure, from head to toe. The
second, adapted from testimonies and memories, is shorter and lighter, the skirt is higher, the colors more
cheerful, chosen to correspond to the taste of the people and to the framework of the natural landscape.
Figure 1: Female attire: on the left, “Capote e Capelo” [traditional Azorean Cape and Hood] (São Miguel, Azores). Source:
http://www.icpd.pt/arquivo/ver.php?id=1646 ICPD/Coleção Fotográfica Digital: PT/ICPD/CFD.01604.
On the right, Folk costume. Source: http://artesanato.azores.gov.pt/artesanato/tecelagem/
We can conclude that, thanks to the efforts of a wealthy elite committed to the affirmation of regional
identity, the Azorean insular costume, similarly to other national and foreign regions, ended up being
formed between monochrome and polychrome, that is, between the explosion of joy and the sense of
interiority (Teixeira, 2009, p.376). Another conclusion points to the fact that it constitutes an instrument of
power: not only the interest in its recovery and preservation emerges within the São Miguel elite, but also
aims to affirm the beauty of the region as well as the competence of the artisans. It was hoped that its
knowledge would bring recognition to this region in natural and heritage terms.
A final aspect to point out is the pedagogical dimension that the same elite considered essential to this
entire process. The vision that Maria Luísa Costa Gomes has of the people is that they are “uneducated”,
permeable to cinema images, and, therefore, “entontecido pelo fulgor de cetins baratos e vistosos, que
chegam da América” [dazed by the glow of cheap and showy satins that arrive from America] (Gomes,
1955, p. 114). It needs to “be guided”; failure to do so is a “serious fault” (idem, ibidem). Mirroring a power
network dominated by the higher socioeconomic classes, the regional costume is thus an identity
instrument that, in the name of the people, displays an unpopular taste and cultural agenda.
Figure 2: Watercolour studies, on the left, of São Miguel’s costume, for jewellery creation. Right: vector drawing.
The necklace consists of eight pieces, culminating in the ninth, which is the representation of the Island of
São Miguel – located below the heart; assumed as the green island and which has six basalt volcanic stones
that represent the six municipalities of São Miguel: Lagoa, Nordeste, Ponta Delgada, Povoação, Ribeira
Grande and Vila Franca do Campo. The jewel appears in the sense of reusing existing endogenous
resources, namely basalt – a stone already incorporated by other Azorean artists such as the jeweler Paulo
do Vale. The colors will be obtained using the ancestral technique of enamel. All the pieces are represented
with the same symbol, the Heart, in an oval piece, almost as if it were volcanic pebbles, in the sense that it
is inspired in the shirt embroidery. Assuming thus a heterogeneity regarding the individuality of each Island
and a homogeneity in the whole as a geographical area, Azores. The square pieces that intersperse the 8
hearts represent the Cross of Solomon, with the representation of two intertwined triangles, which
symbolizes the transformation and the divine protection, which appears in the aprons as a pattern, just as it
2
V. https://www.almanaqueacoriano.com/index.php/artigos/1074-cores-das-ilhas
also appeared in times gone by, in the cradles of young children and on agricultural implements in order to
protect the blessed. This jewel is designed to be realized and executed together with artisans from São
Miguel, given the fact that the region's resources are identitary and unique in their execution, and because
it intends to be a sustainable jewel, since it uses Earth materials, with a view to enhance female power.
Figure 3: Detailed design of the jewel, on the right, for the Traje de São Miguel, with the inspiration elements. Own source. Left:
Female costume of the folkloric group Cantares e balhados da Relva, with a simulation of the jewel. Photo by Vitor Melo.
6. Final considerations
We started by establishing the relationship between culture and identity as a way of basing the creation of
a jewel that represented the Azorean regional identity and repositioned it in the contemporary era,
emphasizing both the interest of its identity legacy and the new position of the region at the national level.
We established as a theoretical basis the idea that culture carries meanings and participates in the creation
of places of belonging and well-being, in the same way that identity represents individual and collective
evolution, not being a static concept, but a dynamic one. We then verified how the Azorean and
Portuguese culture and identity are similar, and we refer to the economic and political asymmetries that
resulted in profound difficulties for the archipelago, having caused emigration flows since the 19th century.
The analysis of the Azorean regional costume allowed us to understand the stories it tells, to relate it to the
characteristics of the landscape and to the desire of a literate elite to make known the beauty and talent of
regional handicrafts beyond the insular borders. It is worth noting how poverty and regional periphery
stand out from regional clothing, quite simple and sober, in its most genuine version, worn by the lower
classes. In this sense, it is the intervention of the elite that makes both economic and political progress, as
well as advancing the costume for greater visual expressiveness and external affirmation.
Finally, we proposed a jewel that could give visibility to the region, following a dynamic identity sense. In
fact, if, in the past, the Azores struggled with a situation of periphery from the political, economic, and
cultural point of view, nowadays, an agricultural industry and tourism, the political autonomy and the
cultural strength of the region put it in a different situation. The proposed jewel not only reflects this
change but is also expected to collaborate to strengthen identity bonds, at an internal level, and to
accentuate archipelagic knowledge at a national and international level.
Culture and identity are no longer fixed in the past, but use different techniques to enhance creation,
innovate and associate tradition and our cultural heritage with what we want to be and do in the future. If,
in the mid-19th century, the focus on regional costume served to affirm the region through the creation of
folk groups and make it known to the world, in the 21st century, adding a collection of jewelry to this
costume could contribute to the region to recognize the lively character of its past, a source of inspiration
for a new centrality in which culture is valued as a creative, sustainable and identity-renewing language.
Acknowledgments
References
Barker, C., 2004. Identity. The SAGE Dictionary of Culture Studies (p.93-95). [Online] Disponível em:
https://fib.unair.ac.id/jdownloads/Materi%20Kuliah/Sastra%20Inggris/Arum%20Budiastuti/ebooksclub.org__the_sag
e_dictionary_of_cultural_studies.pdf [Acesso em 25 de abril de 2022].
Butler, J., 1990. Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity. London: Routledge.
Davies, Bronwyn, Harré, Rom, 1990. “Positioning: The Discursive Production of Selves”, in: Journal for the Theory of
Social Behaviour. 20: I.
Dias, M. Fátima Sequeira, 2008. Os Açores na História de Portugal. Lisboa: Livros Horizonte.
Freitas Jr, Miguell Archanjo, Perucelli, Tatiane, 2019. “Cultura e identidade. Compreendendo o processo de
construção/desconstrução da identidade cultural”, in: Cadernos de estudos culturais, Campo Grande, MS, vol. 2, pp.
11-133.
Gomes, M.L, 1955. “Trajos regionais micaelenses”, in: Insulana, Vol. XI, 1º semestre. Ponta Delgada: Instituto Cultural
de Ponta Delgada, pp. 113-131.
Gomes, M.L, 1956. “Trajos regionais dos Açores”, in: Insulana, Vol. XII, 1º semestre. Ponta Delgada: Instituto Cultural
de Ponta Delgada, pp. 225-227.
Hall, Stuart, Du Gay, Paul (ed.), 1996. Questions of Cultural Identity, London, Thousand Oaks, New Delhi: Sage
Publications.
Hall, Stuart, 2006. A identidade cultural na pós-modernidade (trad. de Tomaz Tadeu da Silva e Guacira Lopes Louro),
Rio de Janeiro: DP&A.
Hartley, John, 2002. Communication, Cultural and Media Studies. The Key Concepts. London and New York: Routledge.
Hawkes, Jon, 2001. The Fourth Pillar of Sustainability – culture’s essential role in public planning. Melbourne: Common
Ground and The Cultural Development Network.
Holland, D. Lachiotte, W. Jr., Skinner, D., Cain, C., 1998. Identity and Agency in Cultural Worlds. Cambridge, MA:
Harvard University Press.
Lourenço, Eduardo, 1988. O labirinto da saudade. Psicanálise mítica do destino português. Lisboa: Dom Quixote.
Mattoso, J., 1998. A Identidade Nacional, Lisboa: Gradiva.
Moran, A., 2011. “Indigenous Identities: from colonialism to post-colonialism”, in: A. Elliot (Ed.) Handbook of Identity
Studies (pp. 347-363), London: Taylor & Francis.
Moya, P., 2002. Learning from Experience: Minority Identities, Multicultural Struggles, Berkeley: University of
California Press.
Teixeira, M.B., 2009. O Traje Regional Português e o Folclore. Volume VII [Online] Disponível em:
https://www.om.acm.gov.pt/documents/58428/182327/1_PI_Cap7.pdf/803cd114-b7e8-448a-8dea-aeacb67866fe
[Acesso em 29 de abril de 2022].
Urrieta, L., Noblit, G. W., 2018. Cultural Constructions of Identity – Meta-Ethnography and Theory, New York: Oxford
University Press.