You are on page 1of 6

2021 IEEE 17th International Conference on Automation Science and Engineering (CASE)

August 23-27, 2021. Lyon, France

2021 17th IEEE International Conference on Automation Science and Engineering (CASE)

An adaptive evolutionary framework for the decision-making models


of digital twin machining system*
Shimin Liu, Member, IEEE, Hui Shen, Jie Li, Yuqian Lu, Member, IEEE, and Jinsong Bao Member,
2021 IEEE 17th International Conference on Automation Science and Engineering (CASE) | 978-1-6654-1873-7/21/$31.00 ©2021 IEEE | DOI: 10.1109/CASE49439.2021.9551595

IEEE

Abstract—Digital twin technology is the core promoter of However, under the mode of multi-variety and small batch
intelligent autonomous machining systems, which has been production or when the digital twin system needs to be
gradually explored and applied in the machining field. The established on a large scale, the following phenomena will
digital twin system can observe, analyze, and control the lead to remodeling:
machining process in real-time by creating high fidelity virtual
entity of the physical entity. However, the current digital twin (1) There are new kinds of parts or different quality
system is usually customized for specific scenarios, which lacks requirements;
sufficient robustness. Remodeling may lead to poor modeling (2) A new machining system different from the past needs
effects and low modeling efficiency due to insufficient data. This
to build its digital twin systems.
paper explores an adaptive evolution mechanism of the digital
twin decision-making model through incremental learning and These situations lead to the system mismatch in the direct
transfer learning. Besides, the specific implementation method is hard transplantation. The imbalance between the virtual
concluded. system and the physical system will occur, resulting in the
I. INTRODUCTION performance degradation of the system. However, the
construction of a data-driven digital twin system is complex,
As a new high fidelity replica method, digital twin and the following problems will appear when reconstructing
constructs the product process model adaptively and analyzes the model in line with the working conditions.
the twin data based on the machining process to predict and
optimize the machining process [1]. Digital twin machining is (1) The production process is affected by the suspension
based on cutting modeling theory and digital manufacturing of adjustment;
technology to predict and optimize the machining process [2]. (2) Remodeling can lead to waste of resources;
In machining, advanced data monitoring and machining
technology are used to monitor and extract features of (3) It is challenging to build the system because of the lack
machine tools, workpieces and tools in real-time. Combined of data.
with theoretical knowledge and machining experience, the Therefore, to solve the above problems, it is urgent to
machining state is identified and monitored by artificial automatically improve the generalization performance of
intelligence technology [3]. Based on data analysis, reasoning digital twins to adapt to various working conditions
and decision-making, real-time optimization of cutting automatically. The essence of a digital twin system is a
parameters and equipment status adjustment can achieve the data-driven intelligent manufacturing system. This paper
ideal workpiece quality and machining efficiency. Therefore, proposes a digital twin adaptive evolutionary framework,
the digital twin has been gradually applied to the machining which endows different decision-making models with
process to control the machining process [4]. evolutionary characteristics. With the integration of the
However, the disadvantage of the digital twin lies in its incremental learning method, the system can adaptively
high cost, and most of the decision-making modules of the improve its machining quality requirements with product
current system are based on the data analysis model [5]. development. The idea of transfer learning is integrated to
Therefore, it is generally only used in a specific scenario [6]. realize the self-adaptation of the decision-making model in
machining. Through the above methods, the robustness of the
decision-making module of the digital twin system is
*This work is financially supported in part by National Key Research and
Development Plan of China (Grant 2019YFB1706300), in part by the
improved, and the time of system remodeling is reduced.
Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities and Graduate Therefore, the remainder of this paper is as follows: In
Student Innovation Fund of Donghua University (Grant No.
CUSF-DH-D-2020056). (Corresponding author: Jinsong Bao.)
Section Ⅱ, the related work on the digital twin, incremental
Shimin Liu, Hui Shen, Jie Li and Jinsong Bao are with the College of learning, and transfer learning is summarized, and the
Mechanical Engineering, Donghua University, Shanghai 201620, PR China research gaps are highlighted; In section Ⅲ, the
(e-mail: 1182021@mail.dhu.edu.cn; sh15721584547@163.com; decision-making model of the digital twin machining system
jie.li@dhu.edu.cn; bao@ dhu.edu.cn). and its related theoretical framework are analyzed; In Section
Yuqian Lu, is with Department of Mechanical Engineering, The Ⅳ, various scenarios in the machining process are analyzed,
University of Auckland, Auckland 1010, New Zealand (e-mail:
yuqian.lu@auckland.ac.nz).

978-0-7381-2503-9/21/$31.00 ©2021 IEEE 771

Authorized licensed use limited to: AIT Austrian Institute of Technology. Downloaded on February 16,2022 at 11:41:51 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
and corresponding evolutionary methods are proposed. Ye and Dai [26] applied transfer learning to time series data
Finally, the methods in this paper are summarized. prediction and solved it. They proposed a deep anti transfer
learning network for intelligent fault diagnosis of the machine,
II. RELATED WORK realizes the recognition of new faults with high precision,
With the development of artificial intelligence, big data, Zhou et al. [27] proposed a multi-level deep convolution
cyber-physical systems and other technologies, the digital transfer learning method to solve the problem of machine fault
twin has been highly concerned by the academic community diagnosis under different working conditions; Cao et al. [28]
and carried out in-depth research. In this section, we will proposed feature transfer method to solve the problem of
review the related research and highlight the research gap. machine fault diagnosis under variable conditions.
From the above literature review, it can be found that:
A. Digital twin related applications 1) The existing research launched a deep exploration of the
Grievers [1] put forward the digital twin concept in the modeling, analysis and prediction of the machining process.
course of product lifecycle management in 2003. Since then, These studies are mainly limited in their specific scenarios.
relevant scholars have researched it one after another. They Whether these methods can be directly transplanted to other
summarized the concept, reference model and development
scenarios is a scientific question. If transplanted directly, it
direction of digital twin [8][9][10][11]. Tao [12] pointed out
that the digital twin has great potential to change the may lead to wrong decision results. Therefore, the robustness
manufacturing industry. Tao et al. [13][14] put forward the of the digital twin needs to be studied to improve its
digital twin workshop concept, which applies digital twin to generalization performance.
product design, manufacturing and service. Zhu et al. [15] 2) At present, there are few kinds of research on the
proposed the digital twin management control framework and generalization of digital twin systems. The decision accuracy
applied it in assembly. Leng et al. [16]proposed a workshop of the digital twin system mainly depends on its data-based
framework for glass production lines to realize rapid decision model. Incremental learning and transfer learning
automatic manufacturing. Zhou et al. [17] proposed a digital can be integrated into the digital twin system to improve the
twin manufacturing cell, which supports autonomous
adaptability of the system to more scenarios.
manufacturing through intelligent perception, simulation,
understanding, prediction, optimization and control strategies. Both of them play a significant role in improving the
Liu et al. [18] proposed a digital twin modeling method for the robustness of the system and are further addressed in the
machining process based on biological mimicry, changing following sections.
with the machining process. Sun et al. [19] proposed a method III. DECISION MODEL OF THE DIGITAL TWIN SYSTEM
of assembly and adjustment coupling based on the digital twin
to realize high-precision product assembly. Tong et al. [20]
A. Digital twin machining system and demand analysis
proposed a real-time monitoring method based on Intelligent
Machine Tool (IMT) digital twin, which is used to visualize The digital twin system based on data support can build a
and analyze processing trajectory, machining status, and new knowledge base to improve itself through continuous data
energy consumption. Kong et al. [21] proposed a data accumulation; it includes decision-making, implementation
construction method, which can adaptively design the data and improvement. The digital twin machining unit can
construction framework according to the system's data understand, optimize and ultimately control the machining
requirements. process. As shown in Figure 1, the system includes four
spaces, and the cooperation and integration between them
B. Incremental learning and transfer learning make the digital twin machining system have a solid cognitive
and learning ability. Specifically, it includes the physical
In the aspect of incremental learning, many scholars have space of the container of physical manufacturing resources,
carried out applied research. Wang et al. [22] developed a the virtual space as the container of virtual manufacturing
novel transfer and incremental soft-sensor scheme for batch resources such as virtual manufacturing equipment, the data
manufacturing processes with the support of multiple layer for storing historical data. The decision level is used to
historical process modes, termed mode-cloud here. Wang et analyze twin data to control the whole machining process.
al. [23] designed a spatial correlation-based incremental The new generation of machining systems needs
learning technique for spatiotemporal modeling to improve generalization and robustness. The depth ability lies in the
accuracy and efficiency. Du et al. [24] proposed an online high decision accuracy of the system. On the other hand, the
cognitive, joint angle error compensation method based on adaptive generalization ability of the system is also vital. It
incremental learning to reduce joint angle error. can be seen from the above that most of the decision-making
Many scholars apply the transfer learning method to the models in digital twin machining systems are mainly data
production and manufacturing process. Wang et al. [25] analysis models. Therefore, the adaptive characteristics of
obtain the milling force prediction model after transfer based digital twin systems limited to data-driven can be divided into
two parts.
on a small number of target field data set finetune. Compared
with the small sample data, the modeling accuracy is higher;

772

Authorized licensed use limited to: AIT Austrian Institute of Technology. Downloaded on February 16,2022 at 11:41:51 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
1) The amount of data in the training set cannot ultimately model can exist. At this time, the construction of the model
include the data of the whole process, so no matter how to will be more time-consuming and laborious.
modify the model, the system still cannot improve the
adaptive ability of the decision-making model itself; B. Decision-making model in the whole life cycle of product
2) The change in the distribution of a training sample set manufacturing
can influence the model accuracy. This corresponds to the To overcome the above challenges, it is necessary to
accuracy problem of the decision-making model when the analyze the application of digital twin systems in the whole
elements such as tools, machine tools and parts change in life cycle of products and analyze the decision-making module
machining. of the machining process and the factors influencing the
machining model. From the development of a digital process
Machine
Data layer monitoring system to detect the life cycle of the parts, the
tool Physical space
Rules library whole process is shown in Figure 2.
Tool Fixture
Learning model
It can be seen from the above that the decision-making
Twin machine
Cognitive model model of digital twin machining system mainly exists in the
Virtual space
tool
design stage, machining stage and machining quality
Twin tool Twin fixture
inspection stage. Most of these models are based on the
Case library
amount of data. The corresponding forecasting,
Decision layer
decision-making, and control systems are formulated by
Processing status Decision making and
analyzing and mining historical data.
recognition module control
Cutting Cutting force Tool life
Tool status
temperature optimization optimization C. Classification of decision-making models in the digital
Parameter NC code
Cutting path Surface quality adjustment modification
Data support twin system
Cutting force Surface quality
...
monitoring optimization
The classification of the digital twin decision-making
system can be classified according to the way of its
Figure 1. The digital twin machining system construction. For example, the typical decision-making mode
can be divided into the expert system and learning system, and
However, most of the high-end manufacturing industries
the learning system can be divided into generative and
are multi-variety and small-batch manufacturing modes.
discriminant according to the method of learning. Therefore,
There are often different machining objects, different
according to the decision-making model structure, this paper
machining requirements and different machining
divides it into three categories: tree, line, graph, or network, as
technologies. When the tool, workpiece, and machine tool in
shown in Figure 3.
the system are changed, the problem of inapplicability of the
Design Machining Inspection
DM Process Process monitoring Quality online
optimization inspection

Process Control Online collection


Real machining Machining
planning command and prediction of
Cutting process quality
optimization based Virtual machining information
Feature on Simulation
recognition
Real-time Data Construction of
Requirement decision-making acquisition quality knowledge
analysis Real-time
simulation Parameter Information graph
Parameter
adjustment, error collection,
Path planning optimization
Machining compensation extraction and
error processing Quality knowledge
calculation Optimization graph analysis
Selection of Simulation result
production Abnormal decision
resources processing State analysis,
Result analysis alarm anomaly Digital twin Product quality
detection data inspection result
...

Digital twin
Figure 2. Intelligent machining process based on digital twin
As shown in Figure 3a, the tree structure mainly includes feasibility of the decision-making analysis method is a
decision trees and expert system models. This kind of model graphical method of intuitive use of probability analysis. This
mainly classifies the classified tagged data according to the branch of decision-making is graphically like the branch of a
specified requirements. They are mainly based on the tree.
probability of occurrence of various situations. To judge the

773

Authorized licensed use limited to: AIT Austrian Institute of Technology. Downloaded on February 16,2022 at 11:41:51 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
As shown in Figure 3b, this type is the generic model of incremental model and transfer model are integrated into the
probability graph model construction, mainly composed of system to improve its adaptive evolution.
various elements and various entities. Through the modeling
and analysis of various relationships, the network model A. Adaptive construction and evolution framework of digital
relationship is constructed. twin decision-making model.
As shown in Figure 3c, this type is mainly based on data to The adaptive evolution characteristics of the ideal system
build a transitive analysis network. The typical is the deep are as follows: 1) the established system can continuously
neural network. It is mainly composed of the analysis units in supplement the knowledge in its domain according to the
series. experience accumulation of machining tasks so as to improve
the accuracy of its model; 2) the established system can
complete similar work according to its domain skills. The
function of the decision-making model in the manufacturing
system is mainly divided into three parts: health monitoring,
condition monitoring and quality prediction. These algorithms
contain a large number of their own models, which need to be
timely analyzed according to the specific situation of the
scene. Therefore, the depth and breadth of the system need to
be improved.
a) Tree structure b) Network structure
The adaptive evolutionary framework of digital twin
c) linear structure decision-making models is shown in Figure 4. The framework
has the following characteristics:
Figure 3. The structure of the digital twin decision-making model
1) The system collects data at the time of running, and then
IV. ADAPTIVE EVOLUTIONARY METHOD FOR THE DIGITAL it is used to improve the decision-making model.
TWIN DECISION-MAKING MODEL 2) When the system cannot provide an effective
From the above analysis, it can be seen that the core decision-making model, according to the corresponding task
driving force of the digital twin system lies in its conditions, the decision-making model meeting the machining
decision-making model. Most of these decision-making task is reconstructed.
models are based on a data analysis model, so the
generalization performance of the digital twin system depends
on its decision-making model. In this section, the ideas of the
Machining process

Process-1 Process-2 Process-3 Process-1


T
D
Blank Data acquisition Data acquisition Product

Machine Model
Quality model
Tool Machine tool fault reconstruction
Tool health construction
New task

breakage prediction tool health diagnosis


warning prediction model
Residual life Quality Quality T
Tool remaining life prediction
prediction of analysis
prediction
machine tool

Decision model layer

New data

Original data

New model

Figure 4. The adaptive evolutionary framework of digital twin decision-making models


suitable for people. It is mainly applicable to the cloud sharing
B. Model self-evolution under data increment platform or the increase of data volume during machining.
The idea of data increment is to form the field machining
data of each product application into experience data and As shown in Figure 5, the system cannot identify the new
input it into the training set continuously so as to improve the categories that the training sample set cannot represent
performance of the system. This kind of scene is mainly because the actual industrial process is in constant change.

774

Authorized licensed use limited to: AIT Austrian Institute of Technology. Downloaded on February 16,2022 at 11:41:51 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
The traditional decision-making model lacks the target task, choose the appropriate reconstruction method.
corresponding recognition mechanism, so it can only classify The main method of reconstruction is transfer learning. The
the new class samples to the known class, which leads to the general idea of the transfer model can be divided into three
wrong classification results. When a new category problem categories: inductive transfer learning, transductive transfer
occurs, the incremental learning method first uses the expert learning and unsupervised transfer learning, as shown in Table
knowledge to identify its real category; then, it uses the II.
marked samples to update the classification model offline, and
then continues to put the updated model into online use. Due TABLE I. ANALYSIS OF MODEL FAILURE UNDER DIRECT REUSE
to the production requirements, many actual industrial
processes (primarily process industrial processes) usually Event Decision-making Reasons for not reusing
need to maintain continuous operation for an extended period. model
Because offline labeling of samples and offline updating of Replace Tool wear monitoring The range of cutting force,
models take a long time, incremental learning is not suitable different types of Tool life prediction vibration, heat and machine
for fundamental industrial processes with high real-time and tools Tool breakage warning tool electrical signal is
long continuity. In other words, if we can identify new different
samples online, it is of great significance to the process Replace Machine tool fault The composition of the data
diagnosis of the actual industrial process. different types of diagnosis signal is different
Sample space
Category 1 Category 2 Category 3 Category n machine tools Remaining life
prediction of machine
tool
Training data
Develop new Machining strategy The composition of
types of products recommendation manufacturing features is
Process data
New category 1 New category 2 New category 3 New category n
Incremental data different
Changes in Changes in quality mix The target domain tasks are
Model evolution
machining requirements different
technology Different Different target domains
combinations of
quality characteristics

Figure 5. Incremental evolution method of the digital twin model


Source domain
C. Construction method of the decision-making model due to
Source domain
model change
As shown in Table I, when the basic elements of the
model building, such as replacing new tools or machine tools, Model
transfer
appear, the previous model cannot be used directly, or the
accuracy drops significantly. The usual way is to retrain the Target domain
model, and the data model itself is more dependent on the
breadth of the data itself. Recollecting data to build the model Target domain

will waste many resources. Therefore, this paper proposes


using the transfer method to build the decision-making model Figure 6. Transfer method of the digital twin decision-making model
of the digital twin system, as shown in Figure 6.
Given the above situation, the system first captures the
dynamic characteristics in machining. After analyzing the

TABLE II. DIFFERENT SETTINGS OF MODEL TRANSFER METHODS FOR DIFFERENT APPLICATION SCENARIOS
Decision-making model Inductive Transfer Learning Transductive Transfer Learning Unsupervised Transfer Learning
Tool breakage warning √
Tool health prediction √
Machine tool health prediction √ √
Tool remaining life prediction √ √
Residual life prediction of machine tool √ √
Quality prediction √ √
Quality analysis √ √
Machine tool fault diagnosis model √

775

Authorized licensed use limited to: AIT Austrian Institute of Technology. Downloaded on February 16,2022 at 11:41:51 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
[13] F. Tao and M. Zhang, Digital Twin Shop-Floor: A New Shop-Floor
Paradigm Towards Smart Manufacturing. IEEE Access, vol. 5, pp.
V. CONCLUSION
20418-20427, 2017.
The digital twin application in machining and [14] F. Tao, et al., Digital twin-driven product design, manufacturing and
manufacturing is an effective means to break through the service with big data. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Tech., vol. 94(9-12), pp.
3563-3576. 2018.
bottleneck of product machining quality and accuracy. Given [15] Zhuang, C., J. Liu and H. Xiong, Digital twin-based smart production
the lack of functional generalization characteristics of the management and control framework for the complex product assembly
current digital twin model, this paper analyzes the shop-floor. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Tech., vol. 96, pp. 1149-1163. 2018.
[16] J. Leng, et al., Digital twin-driven rapid reconfiguration of the
decision-making model categories of the digital twin system. automated manufacturing system via an open architecture model.
Combined with the current development direction of Robot. Comput. Integr. Manuf., vol. 63, pp. 101895, 2020.
intelligent manufacturing, the interconnection mechanism of [17] G. Zhou, et al., Knowledge-driven digital twin manufacturing cell
towards intelligent manufacturing. Int. J. Prod. Res., vol. 58, no. 4, pp.
the digital twin workshop is proposed, and the adaptive 1034-1051, 2020.
evolution framework of the digital twin system is given. The [18] S. Liu, J. Bao, Y. Lu, J. Li, S. Lu, and X. Sun, “Digital twin modeling
main contributions of this paper are as follows. method based on biomimicry for machining aerospace components,” J.
Manuf. Syst., vol. 58, pp. 180-195, 2021.
(1) This paper analyzes the nodes that need to build a
[19] Sun, X., et al., A digital twin-driven approach for the
decision-making model during the digital twin machining assembly-commissioning of high precision products. Robot. Comput.
process. Integr. Manuf., vol. 61, pp. 101839, 2020.
(2) This paper proposes a digital twin adaptive evolution [20] Tong, X., et al., Real-time machining data application and service
based on IMT digital twin. J. Intell. Manuf., vol. 31, pp. 1113-1132,
framework to improve the generalization and robustness of 2020.
the system. [21] Kong, T., et al., Data Construction Method for the Applications of
The future research directions include in-depth application Workshop Digital Twin System. J. Manuf. Syst., 2020.
[22] J. Wang; C. Zhao, Mode-cloud data analytics based transfer learning
in each decision-making model. Besides, the construction of a for soft sensor of manufacturing industry with incremental learning
digital twin robustness evaluation system can also promote the ability. Control. Eng. Pract., vol. 98, pp. 104392, 2020.
application of a digital twin system. [23] B. Wang, H. Li, H. Yang, Spatial Correlation Based Incremental
Learning for Spatiotemporal Modeling of Battery Thermal Process.
IEEE T. Ind. Electron., 2019.
REFERENCES [24] Du, Guanglong; Liang, Yinhao; Gao, Boyu; Al Otaibi, Sattam; Li, Di
[1] J. Cheng, H. Zhang, F. Tao, and C. F. Juang, “DT-II: Digital twin (2020). A cognitive joint angle compensation system based on
enhanced Industrial Internet reference framework towards smart self-feedback fuzzy neural network with incremental learning. IEEE
manufacturing,” Robotics and Computer-Integrated Manufacturing, Transactions on Industrial Informatics, (), 1–1.
vol. 62, Apr. 2020. [25] J. Wang, et al. "Milling force prediction model based on transfer
[2] S. Liu, S. Lu, J. Li, X. Sun, Y. Lu, and J. Bao, “Machining learning and neural network." Journal of Intelligent Manufacturing
process-oriented monitoring method based on digital twin via 5(2020).
augmented reality,” International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing [26] Ye, R. and Q. Dai, A novel transfer learning framework for time series
Technology, vol. 113, no. 11–12, pp. 3491–3508, Apr. 2021. forecasting. Knowl-based. Syst, 2018. 156: p. 74-99.
[3] S. Zhang, C. Kang, Z. Liu, J. Wu, and C. Ma, “A Product Quality [27] J. Zhou, et al., A multistage deep transfer learning method for
Monitor Model with the Digital Twin Model and the Stacked Auto machinery fault diagnostics across diverse working conditions and
Encoder,” IEEE Access, vol. 8, pp. 113826–113836, 2020. devices. IEEE Access, Vol. 8, pp. 80879-80898, 2020.
[4] L. Zhao, Y. Fang, P. Lou, J. Yan, and A. Xiao, “Cutting Parameter [28] N. Cao, et al. Bearing state recognition method based on transfer
Optimization for Reducing Carbon Emissions Using Digital Twin,” learning under different working conditions. Sensors, vol. 20, 2020.
International Journal of Precision Engineering and Manufacturing, [29] S. Liu, Y. Lu, J. Li, D. Song, X. Sun, and J. Bao, “Multi-scale evolution
vol. 22, no. 5, pp. 933–949, May 2021. mechanism and knowledge construction of a digital twin mimic
[5] J. Liu et al., “Dynamic design method of digital twin process model model,” Robotics and Computer-Integrated Manufacturing, vol. 71,
driven by knowledge-evolution machining features,” International Oct. 2021, doi: 10.1016/j.rcim.2021.102123.
Journal of Production Research, 2021.
[6] C. Qin, J. Tao, H. Shi, D. Xiao, B. Li, and C. Liu, “A novel
Chebyshev-wavelet-based approach for accurate and fast prediction of
milling stability,” Precision Engineering, vol. 62, pp. 244–255, Mar.
2020.
[7] M. Grieves, “Digital twin: manufacturing excellence through virtual
factory replication,” White Pap., vol. 1, pp. 1–7, 2014.
[8] F. Tao, H. Zhang, A. Liu, and A. Y. C. Nee, “Digital twin in industry:
State-of-the-art,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Informatics, vol. 15, no. 4, pp.
2405–2415, 2018.
[9] Kyh. Lim, P. Zheng, and C. H. Chen . "A state-of-the-art survey of
Digital Twin: techniques, engineering product lifecycle management
and business innovation perspectives." J. Intell. Manuf., vol. 31, 2020.
[10] Y. Lu, et al. "Digital Twin-driven smart manufacturing: Connotation,
reference model, applications and research issues." Robot. Comput.
Integr. Manuf., vol. 61, 2020.
[11] Q. Qi, et al. "Enabling technologies and tools for digital twin." J.
Manuf. Syst., vol. 58, pp. 3-21, 2021.
[12] F. Tao and Q. Qi, “Make more digital twins.” Nature, p. 490-491, 2019.

776

Authorized licensed use limited to: AIT Austrian Institute of Technology. Downloaded on February 16,2022 at 11:41:51 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.

You might also like