Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Areo
Features, History
https://areomagazine.com/2021/02/24/apocalypse-no-why-i-no-longer-believe-in-the-end-of-the-world/ 1/27
24/02/2021 Apocalypse No: Why I No Longer Believe in the End of the World - Areo
Some time in my mid-forties, I came to realise that every few years I required a
new apocalypse as the expiry date ran out on the previous one. It was as if there
were an apocalypse-shaped slot in my mind that had to be periodically lled with
new content. This struck me as a mental health issue. Was I really looking for new
Armageddons, so that I could feel under threat all the time? Was this a
dependency? Was I addicted to apocalypses?
Rather than searching for a new cataclysm, I decided to take a step back and ask:
why am I drawn to the apocalypse narrative in the rst place? And is it just me?
Western culture seems obsessed with apocalypses: from those preached by tele-
evangelists, to the ravings of terrorists and cults and the fantasy scenarios
depicted in blockbuster movies.
https://areomagazine.com/2021/02/24/apocalypse-no-why-i-no-longer-believe-in-the-end-of-the-world/ 2/27
24/02/2021 Apocalypse No: Why I No Longer Believe in the End of the World - Areo
As John Gray writes in Black Mass: Apocalyptic Religion and the Death of Utopia,
“The political violence of the modern West can only be understood as an
eschatological phenomenon.” We have lived within the apocalyptic mindset for
two thousand years and it has shaped the evolution of our culture, arts,
philosophy and even psychology in ways we’re probably still not fully aware of.
Most faiths view time and cosmology as cyclical, with eras or epochs that move
from birth through maturity, decay and destruction to cosmic rebirth, after which
the cycle repeats for all eternity. Such beliefs are most often associated with
Buddhism and Hinduism (The Wheel of Time) but they also exist in the faiths of
the Mayans, Aztecs and ancient Egyptians, as well as among the Hopi, Q’ero and
many other First Nations and aboriginal peoples. Cyclic rebirth is also a tenet of
Taoism and some Chinese folk religions, in uenced the thirteen-century Nordic
belief in Ragnarök and is an element of Jainism. There are several exceptions—
such as the eternal afterlife creed of the Zoroastrians and the apocalyptic beliefs
of the thirteenth-century Japanese Nichiren Buddhists—but otherwise, before the
spread of Christianity, the idea of a linear end time barely existed. Instead, most
of the world conceived of time as cyclical.
https://areomagazine.com/2021/02/24/apocalypse-no-why-i-no-longer-believe-in-the-end-of-the-world/ 3/27
24/02/2021 Apocalypse No: Why I No Longer Believe in the End of the World - Areo
Even early Judaism was not apocalyptic at all. According to New Testament
scholar, Bart D. Ehrman, “There is no place of eternal punishment in any passage
of the entire Old Testament. In fact—and this comes as a surprise to many people
—nowhere in the Hebrew Bible is there any discussion at all of heaven and hell as
places or rewards and punishments for those who have died.”
Ehrman claims that, before the New Testament, the idea of the apocalypse—the
cataclysmic moment at which every soul is sent to everlasting heaven or hell—
simply does not exist and there is no eternal life of torment for the dead. The
dead simply remain in Sheol, the grave or pit: eternal nothingness is their only
punishment. The heaven that was promised by late Judaism and early
Christianity, Ehrman claims, was very much in this world: “Jesus believed eternal
life was lived in the body here on earth.”
Ehrman argues that, when the apocalypse and resurrection narrative appears in
late Hebrew texts, such as Ezekiel and Isaiah—“Your dead shall live, their corpses
shall rise”—this is about the “afterlife of the nation.” For the Israelite prophets,
“the ‘resurrection’ was not something to happen at the end of human history
when individual bodies returned for eternal reward or punishment. It was instead
a metaphor for the nation being given new life.”
This political dream arose amid intense geopolitical con ict, as the Jews struggled
for control of Jerusalem for more than eight hundred years, while they were
subjected to Assyrian (722–539 BCE) Persian (529–244 BCE) and Hellenistic rule
(334–323 BCE) and nally subjugated by the Roman military.
In response, over the two centuries before Christ, many of the colonised Israelites
began to believe that a messiah would come to destroy the colonisers.
https://areomagazine.com/2021/02/24/apocalypse-no-why-i-no-longer-believe-in-the-end-of-the-world/ 4/27
24/02/2021 Apocalypse No: Why I No Longer Believe in the End of the World - Areo
ur ideas about a peaceful messiah and his end time prophecies are all
O wrong, claims anthropologist Marvin Harris: “What people fail to
realise about these vengeful prophesies is that they were made in
conjunction with actual wars of liberation waged under the leadership of real-life
military messiahs … From the gospels alone you would never know that Jesus
spent most of his life in the central theatre of one of history’s ercest guerrilla
uprisings.”
Christ was not a preacher of peace, Harris and Ehrman claim, but just one in a
line of “Jewish military messiahs.” As Ehrman says, “The cult of the vengeful
messiah was rooted in the practical struggle against Roman colonialism.”
Citing Josephus (37–100 CE), a Jewish defector to the Romans, Harris argues that
Jesus was one of ve such rebel leaders—each declared King of the Jews—who
lived between 40 BCE and 73 CE. The Jews, he claims “consistently believed the
messiah would be the great and powerful ruler who delivered Israel from its
oppressors” and rebuilt a “great Jewish empire.”
According to Harris, the defeat caused such shame and confusion that all memory
of it was suppressed. From reading the Bible, he says, “you could never guess that
in 68 A.D. the Jews went on to stage a full-scale revolution that required the
attention of six Roman Legions under the command of two future Roman
Emperors before it was brought under control [in 73 CE]. According to Josephus,
1.1 million Jewish non-combatants died during the siege and military takeover
https://areomagazine.com/2021/02/24/apocalypse-no-why-i-no-longer-believe-in-the-end-of-the-world/ 6/27
24/02/2021 Apocalypse No: Why I No Longer Believe in the End of the World - Areo
and 97,000 Jews were enslaved. Jerusalem was burned to the ground and the
survivors dispersed. The long awaited Jewish and Christian goal of establishing a
Holy Jewish Empire was over. Defeat was total.
“The Siege and Destruction of Jerusalem by the Romans Under the Command of Titus, A.D. 70” by David Roberts
(1850)
But surely the New Testament, with its blood-soaked vision of the apocalypse,
was written before the cataclysm of 70 CE?
Apparently not. Ehrman states, “It is now widely acknowledged that the earliest
gospel was Mark, written around 70 CE; the last was probably John written
around 90–95 CE.” Fearful for their lives, the authors—highly educated Greek-
speaking Christians living under persecution in other parts of the Roman empire,
two generations after Christ’s death—deliberately revised the Christ myth. Harris
claims,
https://areomagazine.com/2021/02/24/apocalypse-no-why-i-no-longer-believe-in-the-end-of-the-world/ 7/27
24/02/2021 Apocalypse No: Why I No Longer Believe in the End of the World - Areo
The decisive break with the Jewish messianic tradition probably came about
only after the fall of Jerusalem, when the original politico-military
components in Jesus’ teachings were purged by Jewish Christians living in
Rome and other Roman cities of the empire, as an adaptive response to the
Roman victory … it quickly became a practical necessity for Christians to
deny that their cult had arisen out of the Jewish belief in a messiah who was
going to topple the Roman Empire.
By why should paci sts cling to the idea of a world-ending universal apocalypse?
https://areomagazine.com/2021/02/24/apocalypse-no-why-i-no-longer-believe-in-the-end-of-the-world/ 9/27
24/02/2021 Apocalypse No: Why I No Longer Believe in the End of the World - Areo
This revenge fantasy of a traumatised people became a faith that spread like fear
throughout the western world over the next thousand years, retraumatising
generation after generation, while the connection to the original historical
trauma event was lost.
https://areomagazine.com/2021/02/24/apocalypse-no-why-i-no-longer-believe-in-the-end-of-the-world/ 10/27
24/02/2021 Apocalypse No: Why I No Longer Believe in the End of the World - Areo
As the Roman Empire began to fall in the fourth century, this too was interpreted
by Christians as the beginning of their long awaited end time. In the seventh
century, the apocalypse narrative was adopted wholesale by Islam, where it was
embellished with a complex eschatology of signs of the end times and with even
greater post-mortem punishments and pleasures following the Day of Judgement.
Over the next millennium, many sects and prophets predicted the date of the end
of the world, which was supposed to occur in the years 786, 793, 800, 970, 992,
1000, 1033, 1184, 1260, 1284, 1290, 1306, 1335, 1367, 1370, 1378, 1420 and 1496.
There were a further thirty- ve failed occurrences of the last day before the year
1700. Seventy-three last days came and went in the twentieth century and twenty
have already passed in the twenty- rst.
Believers tend to read the apocalypse in terms of the political struggles of their
own eras. As the apocalypse has failed to transpire, again and again, the narrative
https://areomagazine.com/2021/02/24/apocalypse-no-why-i-no-longer-believe-in-the-end-of-the-world/ 11/27
24/02/2021 Apocalypse No: Why I No Longer Believe in the End of the World - Areo
has had to adapt to survive, mutating through di erent religious factions, cults,
death cults and political movements, retraumatising adherents as it moves
through time.
y the middle ages, the second coming was already a thousand years
B too late, so Christians began to distort their own narrative: they no
longer had to wait for the apocalypse and nal judgement, but could
bring it about by their own actions. This justi ed the systemic violence of the
crusades, the Spanish Inquisition and, later, the Reformation.
In 1213, Pope Innocent III used apocalyptic theology to rally Europe to a fth
crusade to capture Jerusalem and the Holy Land from the Ayyubid Empire. The
rise of Islam, he claimed, was a sign of the reign of the Antichrist, whose defeat
would usher in the second coming.
https://areomagazine.com/2021/02/24/apocalypse-no-why-i-no-longer-believe-in-the-end-of-the-world/ 12/27
24/02/2021 Apocalypse No: Why I No Longer Believe in the End of the World - Areo
“The New Jerusalem, from the Apocalypse of John,” Martin de Los and Johan de Sadeler (1559).
The founding beliefs of America’s Puritan settlers were deeply apocalyptic and
America therefore became the new epicentre of the apocalyptic narrative. From
the founding fathers to present day leaders, Americans have talked of American
exceptionalism, America as a beacon of hope and of America’s manifest destiny.
humanity to its prelapsarian state, in which the ideals of equality and liberty
would once again reign in “perpetual peace.” This is what M. H. Abrams calls
“apocalypse by revolution,” a “secular means of renovating the world.”
The English Puritans also saw the 1793 French Reign of Terror as a sign of the end
times. According to Abrams, there was “a chorus of prophets who invested the
political events in France with the explosive power of the great Western myth of
apocalypse, and so expanded a local phenomenon into the perfervid expectation
that man everywhere was at the threshold of an earthly paradise restored.”
The belief in creating a new Jerusalem on virgin soil is not unique to religious
groups: it also permeates the language of nineteenth-century American utopian
socialism, which inspired many communitarian experiments, such as the Owenite
colony at New Harmony, the Fourierist utopians, the Brook Farm
Transcendentalist Unitarians and the Onedia community. Ironically, many of the
groups that attempted to create new secular utopias adopted the narratives of a
heaven on earth and a dying world and thus western radical secularism
embedded itself ever deeper within the apocalypse myth.
https://areomagazine.com/2021/02/24/apocalypse-no-why-i-no-longer-believe-in-the-end-of-the-world/ 14/27
24/02/2021 Apocalypse No: Why I No Longer Believe in the End of the World - Areo
It was through these pioneering Christian socialists and the merging of Christian
progressivism with the foundations of the American progressive era that the
apocalypse narrative survived the twentieth-century collapse of faith in
Christianity.
The apocalypse narrative mutated once again to survive in this new environment.
We could call the new form, which is still alive and well today, secular
apocalypticism.
https://areomagazine.com/2021/02/24/apocalypse-no-why-i-no-longer-believe-in-the-end-of-the-world/ 15/27
24/02/2021 Apocalypse No: Why I No Longer Believe in the End of the World - Areo
[Anabaptist leader] “Jacob van Campen with a mitre on his head on the scaffold at Amsterdam in 1535” by Jan
Luyken, 1692.
Marx imbibed the idea that history has an end point and purpose from Hegel;
Hegel absorbed it from radical Protestantism. In Marx’s writings, the apocalypse
narrative morphs into a belief in the inevitability of the stages of history and the
teleological project of progress. Heaven on earth will arise following a fated
destruction. Looking back, Marx is “a formidable prophet whose writings
prophesied an apocalypse and redemption,” an example of what John Gray
describes when he writes, “Where the west is distinctive is in using force and
terror to alter history and perfect humanity … in the twentieth century
[apocalyptic beliefs] were embodied in secular regimes that aimed to remake
humanity by force.”
https://areomagazine.com/2021/02/24/apocalypse-no-why-i-no-longer-believe-in-the-end-of-the-world/ 16/27
24/02/2021 Apocalypse No: Why I No Longer Believe in the End of the World - Areo
https://areomagazine.com/2021/02/24/apocalypse-no-why-i-no-longer-believe-in-the-end-of-the-world/ 17/27
24/02/2021 Apocalypse No: Why I No Longer Believe in the End of the World - Areo
Nazism was also inspired by the apocalyptic Christian idea of the purifying
cataclysm that would usher in the thousand-year reign. Even the name the Third
Reich drew directly from the Christian millenarian narrative of the teleological
three ages of history.
At the height of the Cold War in the 1970s and 80s, CND (the Campaign for
Nuclear Disarmament) also put forward the nuclear war apocalypse thesis with a
repent or the apocalypse will be nigh narrative. CND has been in decline since the
end of the Cold War, but Christian CND (CCND) has turned out to be the most
enduring element of the movement.
The most radical ecologists also follow a version of the Christian model of a
violent civilisational collapse caused by man’s sins. Today’s eco-protest movement,
Extinction Rebellion, with its claims that “our earth is dying” and that “billions of
children will die” and its staged environmental die-ins, has often been described
as cult-like, millenarian and “death-obsessed.” Their claims that “we are in the
sixth mass extinction event,” their banners reading Are We the Last Generation?
and their public displays of penitence all directly reference the early Christ cult—
although most supporters of Extinction Rebellion would not accept that lineage.
As we’ve seen, wherever there is historical trauma, the apocalypse narrative
adapts to suit the new terrain.
https://areomagazine.com/2021/02/24/apocalypse-no-why-i-no-longer-believe-in-the-end-of-the-world/ 18/27
24/02/2021 Apocalypse No: Why I No Longer Believe in the End of the World - Areo
Many of the radical ecologists’ future plans for a post-scarcity world present
images of heaven, featuring bright sunlight, clean air, pure architectural forms at
one with nature, and animals and children frolicking over verdant pastures.
Luxury eco-communism merges all these strands of apocalyptic narrative into a
vision of a perfectly planned, sustainable, egalitarian society brought about
following the supposedly inevitable prophesied cataclysmic collapse of industrial
capitalism.
Eco activist Greta Thunberg’s hosts at the World Economic Forum openly situate
her in an apocalyptic context and a 2020 portrait of Thunberg even depicts her
surrounded by eschatological references. The wild animals in the picture
reference the apocalypse of Isaiah (9:6–7; 65:20): “The wolf shall live with the
lamb, the leopard shall lie down with the kid, the calf and the lion … and a little
child shall lead them.”
https://areomagazine.com/2021/02/24/apocalypse-no-why-i-no-longer-believe-in-the-end-of-the-world/ 19/27
24/02/2021 Apocalypse No: Why I No Longer Believe in the End of the World - Areo
https://areomagazine.com/2021/02/24/apocalypse-no-why-i-no-longer-believe-in-the-end-of-the-world/ 20/27
24/02/2021 Apocalypse No: Why I No Longer Believe in the End of the World - Areo
Again and again throughout western history, we see exactly the same narrative
model. If someone is telling you that their plan for a society of perfect peace has
to come about to avert the destruction of the world, that is the apocalypse
narrative.
And this is accompanied by the same dark ip side that has come to us all the way
from the rst Christians: a subconscious yearning for the end of all things, for a
bloody revenge against the world as it is.
I no longer buy into the apocalypse narrative. But the question is: can we live
without this narrative, given that it underlies nearly all our belief systems? How
can we get rid of this dubious and dangerous belief, in a world that insists on
framing every event as a signal that we must do penance because the end is nigh?
If you enjoy our articles, be a part of our growth and help us produce more writing
for you:
https://areomagazine.com/2021/02/24/apocalypse-no-why-i-no-longer-believe-in-the-end-of-the-world/ 21/27