One of the functions of the OSHA office of construction and
Engineering headquartered in Washington, D.c., is to provide
technical assistance to State government agencies. Accordingly, on
January 3, 1990, a team of engineers from the Office’ of
Construction and Engineering met with CalosHA staff in California
to begin this work. The assistance provided by OSHA was limited to
determining the cause of the accident. Evaluation of compliance
with safety regulations and enforcement actions relating to the
accident were the sole responsibility of calosHA.
1.2 OSHA Investigation
The OSHA investigation included a detailed inspection of the
collapsed structure, a review of eyewitness accounts of the
collapse, laboratory tests to determine the mechanical properties
of the structure and computer analyses of the crane structure. The
work was carried out in cooperation with Cal0SHA. Eyewitness
interviews obtained by CalOSHA immediately following the accident
were provided to the OSHA investigating team. Inspection of the
collapsed structure and collection of relevant data were done
jointly. Both groups planned the laboratory testing program. The
laboratory tests were conducted by a private firm under contract to
alOSHA. “Throughout the course of the investigation, both groups
worked together sharing information and jointly developing
perspectives on the various aspects of the accident and the cause.
13 Organization of the Report
This report is organized in nine Chapters and Appendices:
chapter 2 describes the procedures followed by OSHA in conducting
the investigation.
Chapter 3 describes the tover crane structure, the brakes and the
climbing operation used to raise the crane.
Chapter 4 provides background information on the crane prior to the
collapse and activities underway at the time of the collapse.
Eyewitness accounts of the collapse are reviewed. Detailed
observations of the collapsed structure and performance of the
components of the structure are also presented.
Chapter 5 describes the results of the laboratory tests conducted
to determine the material properties and evaluate the behavior of
the structural components of the tower including the slewing
brakes.Chapter 6 presents the results of analytical studies conducted to
evaluate the response of the tower and climbing section to a
variety of loading conditions. Forces and stresses in the
structural members and the forces on the rollers of the climbing
section were determined. Failure mechanisms and associated loading
conditions were also determined.
Chapter 7 presents the results of the investigation. The
information obtained in the investigation is used to identify the
cause of the failure.
Chapter 8 presents the conclusions reached in the OSHA
investigation.
Chapter 9 lists the references cited in the text.
‘The Appendixes include a description of the climbing procedure and
the calculations of the limit states for the structural components.‘TOWER SECTION No. 16
CLIMBING SECTION
#293 Fr.
1 THRU 15
TIE-IN To
BUILDING
TOWER SECTION NO.
TOWER _CRAN} (GURATI OR_TO COLLAPSE
FIGURE 1.1.2