Professional Documents
Culture Documents
[Type here]
pg. 1
[Type here]
Definitions
• Appropriate Government (Section 2 (a)): The term "appropriate
Government" refers to the government that has jurisdiction over an industrial
dispute.
Central Govt. as
appropriate Govt.
If an industrial dispute is related to any industry under the Central
Government, a railway company, certain specified industries, or certain
government-owned corporations
State Govt. as
appropriate Govt.
pg. 2
[Type here]
Case study
Cox & Kings (Agents) Ltd. v. Their Workmen
- It was explained that for an award to be made, there must be an existing
or anticipated industrial dispute, and the Labour Court or Tribunal must
adjudicate the dispute based on relevant evidence and their own judgment.
- The definition of "award" also includes interim awards, but these
should not be confused with interim relief granted by the Tribunal under
Section 10(4).
- If an industrial dispute is withdrawn by order of the adjudication
authority, there is no award because there has been no determination of the
dispute on merit.
- However, if the parties settle the dispute through a private agreement
and ask the Tribunal to make an award based on the agreement, that award
will be binding on the parties as long as there was no fraud or coercion
involved.
pg. 3
[Type here]
- If a party fails to appear before the Tribunal, the Tribunal may proceed ex-
parte, but it cannot make an award unless it has considered the evidence
and exercised its judgment.
• Board (section 2(c): Means a Board of Conciliation constituted under this Act
Conciliation
- Conciliation means the process of resolving an industrial dispute by
mediation between the parties involved, with the assistance of a third
party known as a conciliator appointed by the appropriate government.
- The aim of conciliation is to reach a settlement that is acceptable to both
parties and avoid a strike or lockout.
- If the conciliation process fails, the dispute may be referred to a labour
court or an industrial tribunal for adjudication.
pg. 4
[Type here]
Activities
included
- activities carried out with or without investment of capital
- activities with a motive to make a profit
- activities related to sales and promotion
Activities
excluded
- Agricultural operations (unless carried out in combination with another
industry)
- Hospitals or dispensaries, educational or research institutions, charitable
organizations, khadi or village industries
- Government activities related to defence research, atomic energy, or space.
- Domestic services and co-operative societies/clubs with less than 10
employees.
Example:
In the case of Gujarat Forest Producers, Gatherers and Fore Workers Union vs.
State of Gujarat, it was determined that the Forest and Environment Department of
the State Government is not an industry under the Act. Whether any unit,
establishment, or undertaking of the Department is considered an industry or not
depends on the nature of the work being done.
Industrial Dispute:
Under section 2 (k) (as it is)
pg. 5
[Type here]
Simplified definition
"Industrial dispute" refers to a conflict related to employment or labour conditions
between employers and employees or among employees themselves. It can include
disagreements over employment/non-employment status, terms of employment, or
labour conditions.
The above definition can be analysed and discussed under the following heads:
(a) Existence of a dispute or difference
(b) Parties to the dispute
(c) Subject matter of dispute
(d) Dispute in an “Industry”
pg. 6
[Type here]
Case study
pg. 7
[Type here]
workers due to the closure of the mill. The court found that since the
industry was closed, no industrial dispute could exist. This decision
affirmed that the existence of an industry is a condition precedent to an
industrial dispute, and without it, no such dispute can arise.
If the worker presents himself for work during normal working hours on any day and
is not given employment within two hours of his presentation, he is considered laid-
off for that day.
If the worker is asked to present himself during the second half of the shift and is
given employment, he is considered laid-off only for one-half of that day.
pg. 8
[Type here]
However, if the worker is not given any employment even after presenting himself,
he is not considered laid-off for the second half of the shift for the day and is entitled
to full basic wages and dearness allowance for that part of the day.
Both lay-off and lock-out are temporary and result in the contract of employment
being suspended but not terminated.
• Public utility services (Section 2 (n): refers to services or industries that are
essential for the public, including:
o railway and air transport services,
o major ports or docks,
o sections of industrial establishments related to safety, postal,
telegraph or telephone services, power, light, and water supply
industries, public sanitation systems, and
pg. 9
[Type here]
o any industry specified in the First Schedule of the Act that the
government declares as a public utility service for a specified period.
- voluntary retirement, or
Does not include - retirement at the age of superannuation, or
- termination due to the non-renewal of a contract, or
- termination due to continued ill-health
The interpretation of the term "retrenchment" in earlier cases suggested that it only
applied when there was a surplus of workers in an existing industry. This view
was challenged by the introduction of new sections 25FF and 25FFF which
provided compensation for workmen in case of transfer or closure of an
undertaking. This expanded the scope of the term "retrenchment" under the Act
to include termination of service due to transfer or closure of an undertaking.
• Settlement
o This section envisages two categories of settlements
(i) a settlement arrived at in the course of conciliation proceedings,
and (ii) a written agreement between employer arrived at otherwise in
the course of conciliation proceedings.
- Conciliation proceedings are a form of dispute resolution
between two parties with the participation of an impartial third
party.
o For the second category, it must be signed by the parties in the
prescribed manner and must be sent to an officer authorized by the
appropriate government and conciliation officer in a prescribed manner.
o Settlements must be in writing and cannot be changed by oral
agreement.
o If the settlement is accepted by the majority of workers, it is presumed
to be fair and just.
o However, a memorandum of settlement signed by union officials
without proper authorization does not count as a settlement.
• Strike
pg. 10
[Type here]
(5) Work-to-rule:
• It involves employees doing only what is strictly required by the rules and
procedures of their job.
• It is not considered a strike because work is not stopped.
pg. 11
[Type here]
Legality of strike
• The legality of a strike is determined by the legal provisions of the Industrial
Disputes Act, and the reason for the strike is not relevant in determining its
legality.
• The Act has sections that deal with strikes and impose restrictions on their
commencement and prohibit their continuance.
• Village Industries (section 2 (rb)): As assigned under the Khadi and Village
Industries Commission Act, 1956, which is:
o "village industries" refers to any industry in a rural area that produces
goods or services with or without the use of power, and the fixed
capital investment per artisan or worker does not exceed one lakh
rupees (or a different amount specified by the Central Government).
o It includes non-manufacturing units established to promote, maintain,
assist, service, or manage any village industry.
o The investment limit is higher (one lakh and fifty thousand rupees) for
industries located in hilly areas.
Includes Excludes
Allowances Bonuses
Facilities (medical, home, etc.) Contributions to pension or provident funds
Food concessions Gratuity payable on termination of service
Travelling concessions
Commissions on sales or business
• Workman (Section 2(s): The term "Workman" refers to any person (including
an apprentice), employed in any industry to do any kind of manual, unskilled,
skilled, technical, operational, clerical, or supervisory work for compensation,
regardless of whether the terms of employment are expressly stated or
implied.
It includes:
pg. 12
[Type here]
It excludes:
o Subject to the Army Act, 1950, or the Air Force Act, 1950 or the Navy Act,
1957
o Employed in the police service or as an officer or other employee of a prison
o Employed mainly in a managerial or administrative capacity
o Employed in a supervisory capacity drawing more than Rs. 10,000 per month
as wages
Some of the expressions used in the definition of “workman” have been the subject
of judicial interpretation and hence they have been discussed below:
pg. 13
[Type here]
Works
Committee
National Conciliation
Tribunal Officers
AUTHORITIES
Labour Boards of
Tribunals Conciliation
Industrial Court of
Tribunals Inquiry
Works Committee
Formation of Works Committee for Industrial Establishments:
pg. 14
[Type here]
• When required?
o If an industrial establishment employs 100 or more workers, or have
been employed on any day in the preceding 12 months, the
appropriate government can require the employer to form a Works
Committee.
• Number of representatives:
o with an equal number of representatives from the employer and
workers, as per Section 3.
o Worker representatives are chosen from among the workers and their
trade union, if any registered under the Indian Trade Unions Act, 1926.
Conciliation Officers:
• Number of Conciliation officer: The government can appoint Conciliation
Officers, as many as it deems necessary, to mediate and settle industrial
disputes.
• Appointment area and duration of appointment: Conciliation Officer can
be appointed for a particular area or specific industries in that area, either
permanently or for a limited period of time.
• Primary goal: to create a peaceful environment within the establishment
where workers and employers can resolve their disputes through the
mediation of the officers.
Boards of Conciliation
• A Board of Conciliation shall have a chairman and 2 or 4 other members.
• The chairman of the board of conciliation shall be independent, while the
other members shall be appointed in equal numbers to represent the parties
involved in the dispute.
o Each party will recommend their representative, but if a party fails to do
so within the prescribed time, the appropriate government will appoint
someone to represent them.
• A Board can still function even if the chairman or some members are absent
or there are vacancies.
o But if the appropriate Government informs the Board that the chairman
or a member is no longer available, the Board cannot act until a new
chairman or member is appointed.
Courts of Inquiry
• The appropriate Government can constitute a Court of Inquiry into any matter
connected with an industrial dispute.
• The Court may have one or more independent persons (as required), with one
appointed as Chairman (where court consists of more than one member).
pg. 15
[Type here]
• A Board can still function even if the chairman or some members are absent
or there are vacancies.
o But if the appropriate Government informs the Board that the chairman
or a member is no longer available, the Board cannot act until a new
chairman or member is appointed.
Labour Courts
• Number of courts: The appropriate Government can establish one or more
Labour Courts for the adjudication of industrial disputes related to matters
specified in the Second Schedule.
• Member: only one
• Qualification of officer: The presiding officer of a Labour Court must fulfill
certain qualifications, including:
a) he is, or has been, a Judge of a High Court; or
b) he has been a District Judge or an Additional D Judge for a period of not less
than 3 years; or
c) he has held any judicial office in India for not less than 7 years; or
d) he has been the presiding officer of a Labour Court constituted under any
Provincial Act or State Act for not less than 5 years.
e) Has been a Deputy Chief Labour Commissioner (Central) or Joint
Commissioner of the State Labour Department including-
- have a degree in law
- Should have at least 7 years of experience in the labour department (
including 3 years of experience as a Conciliation Officer)
- Should resign from the service of the Central or State Government, as
applicable, before being appointed as the presiding officer.
f) he is an officer of Indian Legal Service in Grade III with 3 years' experience in
the grade
Tribunals
• Number of courts: The appropriate Government can establish one or more
Industrial Tribunals for the adjudication of industrial disputes related to
matters specified in the Second or third Schedule of the act.
pg. 16
[Type here]
(d) he is an officer of Indian Legal Service in Grade III with 3 years' experience in
the grade
(e) The government can also appoint two assessors to advise the Tribunal.
National Tribunals
• Formation: Section 7-B of the Act authorizes the Central Government to
establish one or more National Tribunals for resolving industrial disputes that
involve national importance or affect industrial establishments in multiple
states.
• Member:
o Only one person (presiding officer) with the qualities:
- must have been a Judge of a High Court
- must be an independent person
- should not be above the age of 65 years.
• The Central Government may also appoint two assessors to provide guidance
to the National Tribunal during its proceedings.
pg. 17
[Type here]
Notice of Change
Employers cannot change the conditions of service for workers in certain matters:
• without giving them notice of the proposed change in the prescribed manner,
and waiting for 21 days after giving such notice.
• However, no notice is required if the change is made due to settlement or
award or if the workers are covered under certain rules or regulations notified
by the appropriate Government.
pg. 18
[Type here]
Arbitration
Arbitration is a procedure in which a dispute is submitted, by agreement of the
parties, to one or more arbitrators who make a binding decision on the dispute.
(1) When an industrial dispute is not referred to Conciliation Board, Labour Court,
and Court of Inquiry, Industrial Tribunal or National Tribunal for adjudication, the
employer and the workmen through a written agreement forward the matter for
arbitration specifying the names of the arbitrator.
o If an arbitration agreement specifies an even number of arbitrators
(equally divided in opinion), an umpire will be appointed to resolve a
deadlock. The umpire's decision will prevail and be considered the
arbitration award.
(2) The arbitration agreement should be made in prescribed form and should be
signed by the parties.
(3) Within one month from the receipt of the arbitration agreement which should be
forwarded to Appropriate Government and the Conciliation officer, a copy of the
same has to be published in the official Gazette.
pg. 19
[Type here]
• All conciliation officers, members, and presiding officers are considered public
servants.
• The relevant body has the power to determine the costs of proceedings,
including who pays and how much. Any costs owed can be recovered by the
government as if they were an arrear of land revenue.
Section 12 of the Industrial Disputes Act outlines the duties of conciliation officers in
resolving industrial disputes.
Duties of Board
• The Board must submit its report within 2 months of the date on which the
dispute was referred to it.
• However, the appropriate Government may extend the time by up to 2
months, and the parties may agree to further extensions in writing.
Duties of courts
A court shall inquire into the matter referred to it and report thereon to the
appropriate Government within a period of 6 months from the commencement of its
inquiry.
pg. 20
[Type here]
Subsection:
• If an award is rejected or modified by the appropriate government or the
Central Government, and the modified award is presented to the legislative
body, the award becomes enforceable after 15 days from the date of its
presentation.
• If no order is made by the government to reject or modify the award, then the
award becomes enforceable after a period of 90 days from its publication.
Subsection (2):
A settlement is binding for the agreed period or 6 months (if no such period is agreed
upon), from the date of signing. It continues to be binding for 2 months after written
notice to terminate is given.
Subsection (3):
An award remains valid for 1 year from the date it becomes enforceable, but the
government can reduce or extend the period up to a maximum of 3 years.
Subsection (4):
The government may refer an award to a labour court or tribunal to decide if a
change in circumstances warrants a shorter period of operation. The decision of the
court or tribunal is final.
Subsection (6):
The award will still be valid even after its initial period has ended. However, if any
party wants to terminate the award, they must give notice to the other parties. The
award will then no longer be valid after 2 months from the date of the notice.
pg. 21
[Type here]
Subsection (2):
A conciliation process ends in three possible ways:
(a) if a settlement is reached and signed by the parties involved,
(b) if no settlement is reached and a report is submitted to the appropriate authority
or published, or
(c) if the dispute is referred to a court or tribunal while the conciliation process is
ongoing.
Subsection (3):
Proceedings before an arbitrator, Labour Court, Tribunal or National Tribunal are
considered to have started on the date of the dispute reference, and they end when
the award becomes enforceable
Subsection (1):
Employees working in public utility services cannot go on strike without fulfilling the
following conditions:
• Giving notice of strike to the employer within 6 weeks before striking.
• Not going on strike within 14 days of giving the notice.
• Not going on strike before the specified strike date mentioned in the notice.
• Not going on strike during conciliation proceedings and 7 days after the
conclusion of such proceedings.
Subsection (2):
Employers of public utility services cannot lock out their employees without fulfilling
the following conditions:
• Giving notice of lock-out to the employees within 6 weeks before locking them
out.
• Not locking out employees within 14 days of giving the notice.
• Not locking out employees before the specified lock-out date mentioned in the
notice.
• Not locking out employees during conciliation proceedings and 7 days after
the conclusion of such proceedings.
Subsection (3):
• If there is already a strike or lock-out in a public utility service, the notice of a
new strike or lock-out is not necessary.
pg. 22
[Type here]
Subsection (6):
• If an employer receives notices from employees or gives notices to them as
referred to in sub-sections (1) or (2), he must report it to the appropriate
government within 5 days.
• The government may also require the employer to report the number of such
notices received or given.
pg. 23
[Type here]
pg. 24
[Type here]
pg. 25
[Type here]
The order of the appropriate government will be final and binding on all parties and
will remain in force for 1 year.
The appropriate government or specified authority may review the order or refer
the matter to a tribunal for adjudication.
• the Tribunal must pass an award within 30 days from the date of such
reference.
pg. 26
[Type here]
is deemed illegal, and the workmen are entitled to all benefits under any law as if
they had not been laid-off/ retrenched/ closing down an undertaking
PENALTIES
Penalty for illegal strikes and lock-outs
• For supporting an illegal strike: If any workman starts or supports an illegal
strike, they may face imprisonment of up to 1 month or a fine of up to Rs. 50
or both.
• For supporting an illegal lock-out: If any employer starts or supports an
illegal lock-out, they may face imprisonment of up to 1 month, or a fine of up
to Rs.1000, or both.
pg. 27
[Type here]
• Any person who commits this offence may face imprisonment for up to 6
months, or a fine of up to Rs.1000, or both.
pg. 28
[Type here]
Sub-section (2)
• During any industrial dispute proceedings, an employer can change the
working conditions of a worker not related to the dispute, or punish them for
misconduct not related to the dispute, if it is in accordance with the standing
orders or contract terms.
o However, the worker cannot be dismissed or discharged without being
paid one month's wages and the approval of the relevant authority.
Sub-section (3)
• During an industrial dispute proceeding, no employer can take any action
against a "protected workman" who is a member of the executive or office
bearer of a registered trade union connected with the establishment.
• The employer cannot alter the conditions of service or punish the protected
workman without the express permission in writing of the authority before
which the proceeding is pending.
• The term "protected workman" means a workman recognized as such in
accordance with rules made for this purpose.
Sub-section (4)
pg. 29
[Type here]
The term "Labour Court" includes any court constituted under any law relating to
investigation and settlement of industrial disputes in force in any state.
Sub-section (2)
• In cases where a worker is entitled to receive money or a benefit from their
employer, and there is a dispute over the amount or calculation of such
money or benefit, a Labour Court specified by the appropriate government
may decide the matter.
• The decision should be made within a period not exceeding three months,
o although the presiding officer of the court may extend this period if they
consider it necessary or expedient for reasons recorded in writing.
Protection of persons
• If a person refuses to take part in or continue participating in an illegal strike
or lockout under this Act, they cannot be expelled from their trade union or
society, fined, penalized, or deprived of any right or benefit they are entitled
to.
Representation in conciliation-
In conciliation proceedings or court proceedings under this Act, no party to a dispute
can have a legal practitioner represent them.
pg. 30
[Type here]
pg. 31
[Type here]
pg. 32
[Type here]
pg. 33
[Type here]
pg. 34
[Type here]
pg. 35