Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
This paper understands Hall's "cultural identity theory" through the cultural phenomenon in the ethnic dense.
Through the study of the connotation, definition, characteristics and construction mode of "cultural identity
theory", the author understands and digests this theory further, and through the reflection of this theory, the
author put it into the actual teaching, combined with cross-cultural teaching, hoping to understand the definition
of cross-cultural identity.
that the subject can exercise in this position, are the emphasized that culture itself is "continuous",
important objects of Hall's research. Second, Hall which is due to the inheritance of culture itself. So,
views identity as a reflection of cultural issues. The Hall argues that this position on cultural identity
structure and practice of culture are the basis and can distinguish between different cultural identities
key for individuals to think about identity by seeing shared cultures as stable, continuous
problems, and it is impossible to understand and boundaries. In a cultural group, according to the
explain identity problems without in-depth study of meaning of shared culture to understand the world,
culture, nor can people better analyse the power to communicate and to exchange with the world,
relationship. In general, Hall's cultural identity these are a means of expressing "cultural identity."
regarded "decentration" as a research center, the Then through the repeated use, cultural identity is
same as the cultural embodiment of the later ethnic defined, accepted and then recognized, then such a
denies of Gilroy.[1] Hall believes that cultural "collective" cultural identity can be built
identity reflects the original ethnic culture, ethnic successfully. Therefore, some people also think that
culture and linguistic and religious culture. Western cultural identity is used to refer to the collective
scholars mainly tend to define cultural identity self-awareness reflected in a particular group. It can
through several cultures, which is not also be considered a national or social enrichment
comprehensive, in order to build a cultural of values and world views. This cultural identity is
community between religion and people's linked to the past and is the embodiment of
imagination, rather than objectively distinguishing everyone's past. This cultural identity also
cultural identity. Then the two dimensions of race expresses the mapping of a culture's personal
and nationality are considered by Hall to be the two traditions and values. [2]
most important aspects of cultural identity. In
At the same time, Hall believes, people also
"Cultural Identity and the Ethnic Dispersion", Hall
need to know that the source of cultural identity in
analyses two positions on the concept of cultural
the first position is only a reflection of the past.
identity. In fact, Hall also constructs a third position
Cultural identity is not fixed and forever unchanged
based on and beyond the two positions — an
in the past in a certain nature, but according to
integrated and conversational cultural identity.
different living environment, historical and cultural
influences, it changes. Hall believes that this
2. THE POINT OF IDENTITY AND homologous past gives the west an excuse to
DIFFERENCE IN CULTURAL construct a single historical counterpart to a single
IDENTITY identity. The west overemphasized cultural identity
which is fixed by the historical and cultural, but
Hall points out that the first position of cultural
consciously ignored the continuity of cultural
identity is to define cultural identity from the
identity, while at the same time to build a more
perspective of identity and to share the culture,
"advanced" and more "civilized" cultural identity
which embodies the collective identity of the same
for themselves. Under the influence of the great
true self, which is hidden in other superficial or
culture of post colonialization and globalization, the
false egos. Then people who share a history or
scholars have to focus on what kind of culture they
ancestor will share this self at the same time. It can
will become rather than always use what culture
also be said that the cultural identity reflects
they come from to know the own cultural identity.
common historical traces and shares cultural
Only in this way can people change the inherent
experiences that provide people, as the same race,
way of thinking about the cultural identity of
with a stable and continuous definition in an
essentialism. That is to say, the continuity of
environment of different historical changes. In this
culture itself allows us to have a common historical
position, Hall emphasizes the "identity" and
culture, but also it will turn with the change of
"continuity" of cultural identity. Because, first of
historical culture. Although historical culture gives
all, Hall believes that cultural identity is due to the
different cultural patterns and trends to different
common enjoyment of "one" culture, and culture
races, this trend is not always fixed and is
itself has "identity" because culture has a common
changeable. People should determine what kind of
source, and share a historical ancestor, with the
cultural pattern it is, what kind of new cultural
same historical traces and cultural experience. In
trends people will embody, and use it to build a
this way, the same nation enjoys a common overall
new cultural identity. Rediscovering the cultural
characteristic, which is the true self mentioned by
identity can be used to counter the essentialist
Hall, but also the most true and essential
cultural identity of the west. This idea of
embodiment of a nation's experience. Second, Hall
178
Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 588
reconstructed identity can help people achieve a third position of cultural identity definition. This
conscious victory in the post-colonial struggle. It position is a combination of two positions. Hall has
can also help people re-write cultural identities that emphasized that cultural identity is specific and is a
are different from those in western discourse. sign of similarities and differences. In other words,
Through this kind of re-writing, people can reuse Hall believes that cultural identity is formed under
the way the west tries to hide to build cultural the public image of these two characteristics. First
identity and locate people to reposition and build of all, the similarity of cultural identity is
power. Hall believes that this kind of construction characteristic of history. Similarities in cultural
is crucial to rediscovering the cultural identity of identity also originate from a common culture and
the African-American community in the post- shared history. Sharing a culture with a group of
colonial movement. people also produces a common and similar cultural
identity — a similar reality that can be used as part
Hall's second position is to acknowledge that
of the rebuilding of cultural identity. In this way,
there are some important differences beyond shared
different groups can enjoy the same position and
common ground, and that they come together to
power relationship in culture under the same
make up who they are today. As mentioned above,
historical role. At the same time, this remodelled
cultural identity is the result of a combination of the
identity of the same culture can be used to resist the
past built by history and the present of change first.
rule of western colonial powers. This is Hall's
In the second position, cultural identity is both the
theory, which explores the neglected similarities of
past and the change of future. Cultural identity is
cultural identity from a historical perspective, so
not only the embodiment of the existence of
that it can expose the colonial purposes of the west,
history, but also constantly changing, which cannot
thus resisting the cultural identity of nationalism
be fixed in a certain essential past. Only from the
and racism, and reconstructing new cultural
perspective of the future and changing views of
identities and new power relations. What makes
cultural identity can people make identity and get
more sense in cultural identity is its differences.
rid of the inherent positioning, in order to make the
According to Hall, the difference refers to the
identity of the positioning become richer and have a
difference between "other" and the difference of
broader future. So, the second position places more
"continuing". These two differences are the space
emphasis on the differences contained in cultural
for political and power to survive, and only a
identity. In this position, Hall emphasizes more on
correct understanding of these two differences can
the construction of cultural identity, which is
view the true purpose of western unity and its
different from the western cultural identity
exclusive. The importance of cultural identity is not
positioning and is also different from the western
only the political power of the position in Hall's
discourse system level differences. Postcolonial
view, but also the embodiment of cultural identity
scholars have used these differences to criticize the
under the leadership of the west. Cultural identity is
western view of cultural identity and the false and
formed in the communication of similarity and
colonial nature of this view of identity. This kind of
difference and is a complex. This exchange shows
western not only refers to the region also the
that cultural identity is a common combination of
subject of western construction thought, and they
instability, homology similarity and difference.
build a superior cultural identity in the spirit of self-
Therefore, Hall believes that cultural identity
interest, distinguishing themselves from those
belongs to a changing category. This shows that a
politically and economically superior to other
similar but different cultural identity is not an
regions or countries, reflecting the self-superior
identity that can reflect the essence, nor can it be
distinction between others. Only by recognizing the
used as a reasonable standard for hierarchical
differences in cultural identity can people break the
groups.[3]
so-called cultural superiority of the colonists and
the colonists, and recognize the implicit irregularity
of western centralism, then realize that cultural 3. THE OVERALL CHARACTER OF
identity in the past is only the result of the self- CULTURAL IDENTITY
construction of the west through misinterpretation.
To understand Hall's theory of cultural identity
In order to realize the broken and hidden parts of
deeply, people must correctly grasp the
western cultural identity, these can be reconstructed
characteristics of cultural identity. First of all,
by cultural identity to explore the differences.
cultural identity is a specific collective identity,
Hall not only defines cultural identity from both which brings people a sense of belonging, but also
common and different aspects, but also studies the the embodiment of the essence of cultural identity.
179
Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 588
Hall believes that cultural identity is who people western colonialism. This imagination constructs
are, and here "people" refers to a group of people of the imagination of the common collective through
a particular race, ethnic group that has the same symbolism to produce practical effects, which is a
language or religious culture. It is this sense of kind of framework that is considered to be
community that has fixed the identity. But this constructed, especially the concept of nation-state.
classification only seems to be reasonable in Hall questioned the concept of nation and group, an
quantity, thus hiding deception. The west uses this imagination embodied in the current world's pattern
collectivization to distinguish cultural identity from and cultural identity. Cultural identity is a sense of
binary opposition. Such as: mainstream and non- community, and all members have such a
mainstream, civilization and non-civilization, consciousness in mind. In this way, people imagine
advanced and backward and so on. All of these hide and build a community, building a sense of
the irrationality. The rationality of collective nature belonging and security. Being able to analyse
that Hall emphasizes is not his purpose, and it has common historical experiences and groups living in
the instability of this distinction, but rather the the same region creates a different identity from
collectivist that Hall criticizes has another purpose. others through imagination, and strengthens self-
The collective in cultural identity is a part of the awareness to exclude other qualities, which is the
cultural structure, which is passed down from process of the power to construct opposite
generation to generation in the form of a collective. relationship. Hall believes that constructing an
Such experiences and traces can influence people imaginary identity is defined by one specific
now across the limits of time and space, that's the cultural story after another. Western colonialism
collective, the group people know. Then the ruled colonial areas by building a story that helped
specific cultural and historical experience and the colonized people. The superiority of cultural
traces have had the same effect on them — people identity is also accomplished by constructing one
have a specific production way of life, and it has a cultural story after another. Hall tried to emphasize
solid effect on the collective identity. In this way, this and try to break this essentialism. Only by
people establish unique norms of behaviour, power making the public clear about cultural identity and
relations, identity, and so on in the collective. making them create identity through narrative
However, the differences existing in this collective building, people can see who they are.
concept should not be excluded, and the implied
Finally, cultural identity is dynamic. Hall once
meaning in a single cultural identity is conducive to
used this to criticize the cultural identity of western
the construction of the western ruling class's view
centralism, although Hall did not specify that
of cultural identity. In this way, people can break
cultural identity is dynamic in the article. Hall
the stable point of view in the collective view, so as
believes that cultural identity is changing, and as
to establish a new and correct view of cultural
mentioned above, cultural identity belongs to both
identity. The new view of cultural identity can be
the past and the future. This change is due to the
used to counter postcolonialism and form a new
historical culture or the change of time and space,
sense of resistance. In Hall's view, the behaviour of
and the result is the change of the definition of
blacks in the ethnic diaspora to embody black
cultural identity. Therefore, it is not enough to
culture in their various cultural forms is a good
describe cultural identity by stability and continuity
resistance to western centrism. This kind of
alone, but also to add the factors of time and space
collective identity constructed by the west is not
to make it a three-dimensional structure. Then any
stable, but also full of contradictions, which means
one of the four factors has changed, cultural
that cultural identity in different social and cultural
identity will change, so history has become a
structures will certainly change.
direction to drive cultural identity, and cannot
Second, Hall questions the cultural identity maintain the stability of cultural identity. Similarly,
defined by western colonialism, because it is a it is not comprehensive to define cultural identity
sense of identity and belonging formed through by the same time and space factor, for example,
imagination. The traditional cultural identity view different peoples in the same geographical area of
holds that sharing the same kind of history and the same country will also have different cultures,
experience with the same group should have the so that racial differences in groups lead to
same cultural identity, thus forming the cultural differences cannot be ignored. In this way, dynamic
identity and collective concept. Hall attributes this cultural identity and the western construction of a
recognition to the result of imagination, which is complete and stable definition of cultural identity is
the product of the essential culture constructed by the complete opposite. So, the slavery, black
180
Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 588
identity, and so on that the west has built can only to materialize the effects of imagination. Although
represent the past. This means that groups that tradition is belonging to history, tradition is only a
share the same historical culture are not able to part of history — it comes from history and is
express their common identity in their entireties, changed by history. In fact, tradition is more of a
which is simply a political tool in the west. Then, in product of society, which constructs people's
the meaning of cultural identity flow, identity cultural identity in a way that is like history. Hall
cannot be distinguished by superiority, stresses that cultural identity is constructed from
backwardness and so on. historical narrative, and he questions the
authenticity of history. Then the cultural identity
4. METHODS OF CULTURAL with common historical experience should also be
IDENTITY CONSTRUCTION questioned. On the other way, history can also be
used to highlight the hidden parts of history in an
At the end of the 20th century, the study of the attempt to reconsecrate cultural identity. If people
construction of cultural identity appeared in the really want to find the source of cultural identity,
field of sociology. In the early days, people talked they should actually look for historical means. That
about the construction of cultural identity through is, how cultural identity is described and
the difference of the social construction of constructed in history. [4]
boundaries, that is, through the following three
Most cultural scholars agree that identity is
ways: first, the source of culture and history;
constructed by words. In this view, Hall agrees,
second, the subordination of social rules; third, the
arguing that discourse can be both a way to dissolve
use of cultural boundaries in a narrow sense. In
the essential cultural identity and a way to rebuild
fact, either way is to tell people to distinguish
the cultural identity. Then, the cultural identity
themselves from him and me — disguised
constructed by different discourse systems is also
recognition of a relatively stable collective identity.
different, and this kind of cultural identity is not the
In "The Problem of Cultural Identity", Hall mainly
embodiment of the essence of identity but the
tends to the dynamic of cultural identity, that is,
relationship of identity position. So, what he
cultural identity has been in the construction state,
reminds people is that the right to speak behind the
not completed, so people can understand that
construction of cultural identity is its political
cultural identity is created, not discovered. This
purpose. In Hall's view, discourse requires people
identity is false, imagined, constructed, and people
to use a specific expression and a specific
should break it. But Hall did not explicitly suggest
knowledge system to disseminate certain
the way cultural identity is constructed in any
information within a certain range, and to think in
article, in which he suggested that the same identity
this framework and to product again and again.
constructed by history is one of the reasons for the
Discourse focuses on the subject of the speaker and
formation of cultural identity. Because the common
the subject of what rules to speak on. This rule
culture, tradition will let a group form a common
controls how people communicate in a particular
identity, so the imagined common identity is
society and culture. Then, at a particular stage of
formed. History is a narrative form that people
history, the class with the right to speak can
understand and remember, and it provides an
manipulate reality through discourse, so that some
explanation of the origin or beginning of events.
kind of distorted truth is produced. So Hall used
This is consistent with Hall's critical cultural
these rules of discourse to remind people that the
identity, which is essential and consistent, and they
cultural identity of race is not a universal
all agree that history is a narrative form, a more
embodiment of nature, but rather a way that
self-interested way of narrative. Each country's way
western class constructed and defined by discourse
of recording history is subjective in its own way,
according to its own wishes. So, the hidden parts of
and this self-interest makes it easier to emphasize
the truth that are obscured by the western classes
the continuation of cultural identity and the
really should be restored. Hall systematically
specificity of history and culture. The west uses a
criticized the construction of cultural identity by the
particular history to link specific person identities,
western class. He pointed out that the west is first
such as: the history of the west is civilized; the East
and foremost a social or social development degree,
is backward. In the process of constructing cultural
and the west is also the product of the construction
identity, history not only produces imaginary effect
of historical discourse. Second, the west also
in human mind, but also produces substantial
contains the relationship of intellectual power.
results in the composition of cultural identity. Hall
People would consider non-western regions to be
points out that history, like tradition, has the ability
181
Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 588
182
Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 588
the essentialism to limit the cultural identity and In foreign language teaching, College English
constructs a new dynamic cultural identity view. teachers should consciously compare Chinese
This is a new identity that is more diverse and culture with western culture, especially introduce
inclusive. This is reflected in his break with the old Chinese culture. It can make college students fully
ethnic diaspora model to build a mixed new ethnic understand the excellent Chinese culture and
diaspora model. stimulate students' sense of national pride. College
English teachers should guide students to learn to
6. THE COMBINATION OF express Chinese culture in English and carry
CULTURAL IDENTITY THEORY forward the essence of international exchanges of
AND CROSS-CULTURAL traditional Chinese culture. At the same time,
TEACHING college English teaching should help students learn
more about the world cultural heritage. Human
In cross-cultural learning, learning a language is acceptance of indigenous culture is often in an
much simpler to use; but to learn a language well, unconscious state. Because of the lack of conscious
you must understand the culture it represents. guidance and stimulation, people hardly reflect on
Culture is the most important in college English the culture on which they depend. Even if people
teaching, and understanding foreign culture is also occasionally have similar thoughts, they are
the key to the consciousness of local culture. So, bewildered by the cultural phenomenon of
this identity has also been a difficult point for confusion and disorder and do not know how to
teaching. Cultural identity theory is the theory that deal with it. The purpose of cultural teaching is to
people re-identify with their own identity. While strengthen the understanding of university students'
studying this theory, the author also hopes to make knowledge of their native culture, to prevent
use of it in college English teaching, so that students from being locked into the ideology of
students can better learn English culture and national centrism, to help them rationally
language. In college English teaching, most understand their value orientation and mode of
students can write sentences with correct grammar. action, and then to help them develop open and
But these "non-native" English sentences are flexible thinking patterns. Having a cultural
sometimes unable to communicate effectively due awareness requires going through a difficult
to a lack of cultural identity. Cultural identity is the process. Understanding your culture is a
sense of cultural belonging and cultural group that prerequisite. Then understand that a multicultural
an individual feels from himself. It is based on the environment can position itself in a multi-level
culture to which the language is used. Cultural cultural world. People need to adapt consciously
identity involves social values, religious beliefs, the existence of cultural diversity, constantly
customs, language and art etc. Increasingly frequent communicating with different cultures, and then
international cooperation brings countries and creating a set of social order and code to promote
countries closer together and provides an harmonious development and coexistence.
opportunity for different cultures to communicate
and interact closely. In this process, people can not 7. CONCLUSION
only in-depth understand of their knowledge, of
their local culture and foreign culture, but also face Although Hall did not propose the theory of
a crisis of cultural identity, so school education cultural identity system in any article, in his nearly
should strengthen students' cultural awareness and 30 years of literature people can find his continuous
will, establish cross-cultural exchange awareness, and rich process of this theory. Therefore, this
improve their own cultural identity to protect the paper has also carried out a rough study on the
survival and development of local culture rights. understanding of the theory of ethnic diaspora and
Because cultural identity is based on the cognitive Hall's theory of cultural identity. Hall's research on
nature of human ascension, it has a decisive the problem of cultural identity is instructive, as it
influence on human language and value orientation. can be seen from the solution of the real problems
It is also defined by the consensus and recognition of British society, and it also provides a theoretical
of human culture. On this basis, cultural identity basis for the study of China's construction of
often provides pragmatic principles to guide cultural identity in a foreign country. Hall's study of
specific cross-cultural communication behaviour cultural identity is actually a study of different
relationships. [6] ethnic groups, a wake-up call to their self-
consciousness, and he hopes that his research will
enable each ethnic group to clearly understand the
183
Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 588
AUTHORS' CONTRIBUTIONS
Bo Yang wrote the manuscript, Dan Zhao
contributed to revising and Lu Liu contributed to
editing.
REFERENCES
[1] Gilroy, P. The Black Atlantic: Modernity and
Double Consciousness [M]. Verso, 1993.
[2] Hall, S. Critcher, C.& Jefferson, T.et al.
Policing the Crisis: Mugging, the State and
Law and Order [M]. New York: Macmillan
Press Ltd, 1982.
[3] Hall, S. et al. Culture, Media, Language:
Working Papers in Cultural Studies (1972-
1979) [M]. London: Hutchinson, 1980.
[4] Hall, S. The Empire Strikes Back [M].
London: Routledge, 2004.
[5] Hall, S. The Fateful Triangle: Race, Ethnicity,
Nation [M]. London: Harvard University
Press, 2017.
[6] Barker, C. Cultural Studies: Theory and
Practice [M]. London: Sage, 2003.
184