You are on page 1of 10

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/331465248

SUSTAINABLE MANAGEMENT OF MUNICIPAL SOLID WASTE UNDER


CHANGING CLIMATE: A CASE STUDY OF KARACHI, PAKISTAN

Article · January 2018

CITATIONS READS

3 165

3 authors, including:

Salman Khan
Hohai University
3 PUBLICATIONS   3 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

TRMM for Runoff Modelling View project

Water Security Assessment View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Salman Khan on 07 January 2020.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


Asian J. Env. Tech. Vol 2 No 1 2018 E-ISSN 2548-6691; Khan et. al. (2018)

SUSTAINABLE MANAGEMENT OF MUNICIPAL SOLID WASTE UNDER


CHANGING CLIMATE: A CASE STUDY OF KARACHI, PAKISTAN
Salman Khan*1, Laura Cristina Macias Alvarez2, and Yan Wei3
1 College
of Hydrology & Water Resources, Hohai University, China
College of Environmental Sciences & Engineering, Hohai University, China
2
3 School of Languages, Shanghai University of International Business and Economics, China

Email: salman@hhu.edu.cn*;

ABSTRACT

Karachi, the most urbanized and industrialized city in Pakistan, plays a key role in the country’s economy.
However, this coastal city is experiencing a constant menace of environmental pollution as well as the absence
of an integrated solid waste management system. In spite of the fact that the city has a population of over 20
million producing more than 14,000 tons of municipal solid on a daily basis, an adequate solid management
system is entirely nonexistent. Consequently, posing a threat to groundwater and marine life and resulting in the
emission of greenhouse gases. The objective of this study is to highlight the current issues pertaining to the
municipal solid waste in Karachi and assess the suitability of sophisticated recycling and waste to energy
systems. In other words, this research analyzes the potential of generating energy from combustible and
putrescible solid waste in a city undergoing a critical power shortage. The results indicate the Karachi has a
potential of generating 90 Gg of methane annually through the anaerobic decomposition of biodegradable
organic waste. In addition, a well-established recycling sector can generate a revenue of over 20 million US
dollars annually while offsetting the city’s GHG emissions.

Keywords: Karachi, Municipal solid waste, GHG, climate change

INTRODUCTION contributor to global non-CO2 GHG emissions


generating 550Tg of methane gas annually [3].

Climate change and environmental degradation are Ever-growing population and urbanization are the
the two major challenges faced by current human major causes for amplified solid waste and
civilization. Nevertheless, there has been a greenhouse gas generation. Despite the fact that
plausible emphasis on the causes, mitigation and agriculture, livestock and fisheries sectors in rural
impacts of climate change in the scientific areas also contribute to climate change and their
community and it has been widely acknowledged influence is considerably increasing, cities have a
that anthropogenic emissions of greenhouse gas substantially higher carbon footprint [4].
are the leading cause of rising temperatures [1]. Additionally, it is estimated that over 6 billion people
Moreover, waste sector is among the major will reside in cities by 2050. The challenge of rapid
contributor to greenhouse emissions as a significant urbanization is particularly alarming in the emerging
amount of methane gas is generated during the economies of the Asian continent as they strive to
degradation of organic matter present in alleviate poverty and achieve food security.
wastewater and municipal solid waste (Fig 2). Furthermore, economic growth and the demand for
Studies indicate that the concentration of CH4 in the an improved livelihood are leading to an
atmosphere has risen up to 1700 PPB as opposed accelerated increase in solid waste generation in
to 700 PPB in the pre-industrial era and the human these regions [5]. The generation of solid waste is
activities are credited to have caused 60 to 70 % of inescapable as it is composed of materials
the increase in methane concentration [2]. discarded resulting from any human activity and its
Municipal solid waste alone is the fourth largest volume is greatly reliant on the lifestyle of the
people as well as their socioeconomic condition [6].
Asian J. Env. Tech. Vol 2 No 1 2018 E-ISSN 2548-6691; Khan et. al. (2018)

Pakistan, despite its negligible contribution to the Presently, solid waste management practices in
global greenhouse gas emissions, its per GDP CO2 Karachi largely focus on disposing the municipal
is substantially higher than the developed world e.g. waste in the nearby landfills. Notwithstanding,
Germany [7]. According to 2008 estimates, waste informal recycling is done by underage scavengers
sector alone was responsible for the generation of from impoverished families with the majority of
5505 million tons of CO2 equivalent greenhouse these waste pickers being refugees and settlers
gas emissions in the country. Moreover, the country from Afghanistan[15]. Municipal solid waste is
is highly susceptible to the adverse impacts of commonly incinerated to reduce its volume and to
climate change due to its geographical location and obtain valuable recyclable materials such as
arid to semi-arid climate. Studies indicate that the metals. These recyclable items are a potential
rise in global temperatures is altering rainfall source of livelihood for the impoverished
patterns over the country and consequently communities in the urban area [16]. Insufficient
exacerbating the frequency and intensity of extreme resources and the lack of skilled manpower are
events [8]. In addition, the mismanagement of solid among the biggest hurdles in the path of a
waste in the country has led to environmental as sustainable development. In addition, the
well as social and economic issues. These issues unavailability and inadequacy of reliable data
are further worsened by rapid urbanization, poor pertaining to municipal solid waste is another
infrastructure, lack of an effective recycling system enormous challenge in the field of solid waste
and insufficiency of funds [9]. GHG emissions are management in the country [6].
proportionally linked with the waste generated by a
This study provides an insight into the current solid
city and reducing the amount of waste is vital to
waste management practices in Karachi and offers
mitigate the environmental impacts [10].
a more comprehensive approach in handling over
Karachi, with over 20 million inhabitants, is the 14,000 tons of solid waste produced by the city
largest industrial hub as well as the financial dwellers every day. The aim of this study is to
epicenter of Pakistan. Despite its vital significance estimate and segregate different constituents of the
and contribution to the country’s economy, it ranks municipal waste as well as to foresee the potential
among the worst cities of the world in terms of of organized recycling and waste to energy
sustainability [11]. Likewise, the urban population in generation. Moreover, Integrated and sustainable
the city has increased by 1500% in the past 60 solid waste management will not only assist in
years [12]. Being located in the coastal region, the combating climate change but also provide an
city is susceptible to the impacts of sea level rise alternative power generation resource in a country
and storm surges. Furthermore, squatter undergoing a severe energy shortage. In brief, this
settlements in the city are under a constant threat of research proposes a sustainable solid waste
fluvial, storm water flooding and torrents. management approach in the coastal city of Karachi
by incorporating state-of-the-art recycling and
Pakistan Environmental Protection Agency
introducing waste to energy system (incineration,
estimates that the city produced 0.613 kg per capita
thermal treatment etc.) for the city.
per day of solid waste in 2004, moreover, a
significant upswing in the solid waste generation is MATERIALS AND METHODS
anticipated by 2025. Solid waste from a typical
Study Area
urban community in Karachi consist of kitchen
refuse, construction waste, garden litter and dirt and Karachi, located on the coast of Arabian Sea, is the
grit from street sweeping [13]. Nevertheless, merely industrial, financial, commercial and cultural
a half of the municipal solid waste is collected by epicenter of Pakistan. It covers a total area of 3,640
the municipal corporation and disposed in the square kilometer with 22,594,000 (2015 estimates)
landfills located within 30 kilometers of the city inhabitants of diverse ethnic, religious and socio-
center. The remaining half is dumped in the streets, economic backgrounds. The population of Karachi
clogs the sewerage system in the monsoon season is predicted to rise up to 27,550,000 in the next 3
and may ultimately pollute the coastal water year. Approximately 30% of the industrial output as
endangering numerous marine species [14]. well as 95% of the country’s foreign
Asian J. Env. Tech. Vol 2 No 1 2018 E-ISSN 2548-6691; Khan et. al. (2018)

trade is done through the ports of Karachi [17]. The the landfills. The per capita municipal waste is
city lies between latitude 24 degree 15 N to 24 estimated to be 0.613 kilogram per day which is
degree 45N and longitude 66 degree 37E to 67 significantly lower than the developed nations.
degree 37 and an average elevation of 51m above However, the existing municipal solid waste
the mean sea level with the highest peak of 528m in management has been deemed inadequate and
the north. It has a subtropical climate with warm inefficient. The current solid waste management is
summers, mild winters and very brief autumn and being carried out in the following steps:
spring seasons. Karachi receives an annual
average rainfall of 256 mm with average high and  Source Segregation: Recyclable materials,
low temperatures of 31.7 and 20.3 degrees Celsius particularly metals are separated by the
respectively. homeowners or waste pickers and later sold at
the junk shops for revenue. The separation of
Karachi, with a coastline of 135 km along the metals, discarded paper, and plastic bottles
Arabian Sea, has the busiest ports in the region result in significant reduction of the total waste
(Fig. 1). The coastline is composed of a complex volume.
array of creeks and the Indus river delta having  Collection/Dumping: Refuse or garbage
diverse marine flora and fauna. However, its coastal produced by city residents is generally collected
ecosystem is under a constant threat of door-to-door by waste pickers. These waste
environmental pollution due to unregulated waste pickers charge up to Rs 2000 (19 USD) per
disposal and occasional oil spills. The city household per month in affluent areas and as
generates more than 14,000 tons of domestic solid low as 75 Rs (0.71 USD) per month in low
waste on a daily basis with a 60% collection and income areas [19]. The collected municipal
disposal rate. The city is governed by a mayor or waste is, subsequently, either disposed into
locally known as Nazim and for administrative large containers designated by the town
purpose, the city is divided into 6 districts and 18 municipal administration or unauthorized
town municipal administrations (TMAs). One of the dumping spots or sometimes in the drains and
major responsibilities of these TMAs is to collect natural streams. This results in the blockage of
solid waste from secondary collection sites and sewage system and the waste gets transported
transport it to the nearest landfill. The city has 10 to the ocean with the storm water during the
waste disposal sites including two officially rainy season [14]. Recyclable materials such as
designated landfills [18]. plastic bottles, metallic items and paper
products are collected by scavengers. These
Current Status of MSW in Karachi
scavengers belong to impoverished families and
Solid waste management in Karachi consists mainly consist of war refugees from
of generation, informal source and secondary reuse Afghanistan. A large number of migrant children
and recycling, disposal, collection and transport to from poor backgrounds

Figure 2. Study Area Figure 1. Municipal Waste and GHG Emissions


Asian J. Env. Tech. Vol 2 No 1 2018 E-ISSN 2548-6691; Khan et. al. (2018)

 are among the scavengers handpicking the Integrated Solid Waste Management for Karachi
recyclable materials in an unhygienic
Integrated solid waste management can be
environment and are oftentimes exposed to
defined as a comprehensive system that includes
several health hazards. Moreover, open burning
waste avoidance, reduction, reuse, recycling and
of solid waste is commonly carried to recover
composting with minimal landfill disposal that can
valuable materials such as metals. CO2
be implemented in an environment-friendly manner
released during the burning of fossil carbon
[21]. One of the major targets of United Nations
present in the solid waste is a significant source
Sustainable Development Goals is to significantly
of the total GHG contribution of waste sector
reduce the per capita environmental impacts of
[20].
cities by improving municipal waste management
 Transport to Landfills: There are two officially
practices [22]. Waste prevention is regarded as the
authorized landfills namely Jam Chakaro and
primary and most effective way to reduce the
Gond Pass in Karachi located in a 30 kilometer
amount of solid waste as well as combating climate
radius of the city. However, municipal solid
change. The current study aspires to achieve a
waste is commonly disposed at 8 other
sustainable management of solid waste with zero
locations in additions to the landfills. Sanitary
landfill disposal. Therefore, municipal solid waste is
landfills are non-existent in the city [18]. The
divided into two three broad categories based on
transport and disposal of waste are generally
the final treatment.
carried out in open trucks operated by the town
municipal administration.
Table 1 Current MSWM in Karachi

ZERO LANDFILL MSWM

[CATE
[CATE GORY
GORY NAME]
NAME]

[CATE
GORY
NAME]

Figure 3. Integrated SWM with Zero Landfill Figure 4. Sustainable SWM Treatment
Asian J. Env. Tech. Vol 2 No 1 2018 E-ISSN 2548-6691; Khan et. al. (2018)

Waste Recycling carbon fraction (DOC) in the solid waste. Methane


generation potential (L) can be computed as follows
Waste reuse and recycling is kept at the top of the
[3]:
sustainable management hierarchy. Fortunately,
the recycling industry is well established in
developing countries like Pakistan, where the
(1)
segregation and separation of reusable materials is
carried out at both source and disposal levels.
Nonetheless, there is a severe lack of reliable data
and researches regarding the amount of items (2)
recycled in the country [16]. Other major issues
concerning recycling in developing countries are the
disregard towards the reuse of low-value (3)
recyclables and the lack of a formal sector as well
as the well-being of waste-pickers [23]. The findings
of the present study are tabulated (Table 2) in the Where DDOC is the fraction of decomposable
Results and Discussion section. landfill waste, DOCf is the decomposable fraction of
Composting DOC, W is the total landfilled waste, T is the
temperature in the anaerobic zone (commonly
United Nations Sustainable Development Goal 12 taken as 35 degree Celsius) and F is the
envisions to reduce per capita global food waste at percentage of CH4 in biogas (50% recommended
both retail and consumer levels, and decrease food by IPCC guidelines).
losses during production and supply processes by
50% by 2030. The biodegradable fraction of the Thermal Treatment
municipal solid waste is decomposed into biogas by Incineration of combustible waste is a highly
anaerobic bacteria in the absence of oxygen. exothermic process and will result in a significant
Biogas mainly consists of methane, carbon dioxide amount of energy in the form of heat. However, the
with trace amounts of hydrogen sulfide and other amount of energy produced is dependent on the
gases [24]. High humidity and temperatures of calorific values of constituents incinerated and
Karachi provide an ideal environment for the requires excess oxygen. The energy generated can
establishment anaerobic composting in the city. be employed to run steam turbines to generate
Nonetheless, it must be noted that anaerobic electrical energy that can be added to the city’s grid
digesters produce inferior quality of compost in system. The study calculates the amount of energy
terms of nutrients and volume reduction [25]. produced based on the materials with high calorific
The study employs First order decay model to values such as textile, paper and plastic.
estimate the quantity of biogas produced at the Subsequently, the electrical energy is estimated by
from the anaerobic degradation of putrescible waste assuming a 30% system efficiency. Results are
[26]. Biogas, mainly consisting of CH4 and CO2, is presented in Table 3. The amount of CO2 released
released during the biodegradation of organic during the combustion process in calculated by the
following equation [27].

(4)

Where: IW = amount of municipal waste incinerated (Gg), CCW = fraction of carbon content in the waste (taken
as 0.4), FCF = fraction of fossil carbon (default 0.4), EF = Incineration efficiency (taken as 0.95)
Asian J. Env. Tech. Vol 2 No 1 2018 E-ISSN 2548-6691; Khan et. al. (2018)

RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS Materials like paper, metals, glass, plastic and
bones are utilized in numerous recycling industries.
The study indicates that Karachi produces 14,712
The recovery of these materials present in the
tons of municipal solid waste on a daily basis. Out
municipal solid waste is estimated to generate a
of the total solid waste generated daily the fractions
revenue of up to 202,448,503 USD every year for
of food, paper, plastic and polyethylene, leather and
the city of 24 million inhabitants.
rubber, glass, rags, metal, bones and wood waste
are 3237 tons, 2157 tons, 1205 tons, 1021 tons, The study also indicates that there’s a large
814 tons, 2014 tons, 325 tons, 374 tons and 536 potential of waste to energy production in the city. It
tons respectively. Approximately 50% of the waste was estimated that the combustible waste, if
generated is collected and transported to landfills properly managed and collected, can produce up to
with the remaining half left and dumped in the 96,747 GJ of thermal energy on a daily basis. This
streets and vacant plots. energy can be utilized to operate steam turbines
and generate electricity. The detailed results of WtE
It is worth mentioning that the energy and revenue
through incineration are listed in Table 3.
generations are estimated based on the data
available in the existing literature. For instance, no The study also considers the recovery of methane
data was available related to the moisture content from decomposition of biodegradable waste via
present in the combustible waste, hence, the anaerobic composting. Food and garden waste of
energy generation potential was estimated using the city has a methane generation potential of 90.97
the maximum calorific values of the constituents. Gg annually (Table 4). The process also yields
Based on the actual calorific value of the waste, organic fertilizer as a byproduct which can be used
alternative WtE technologies such as Circulating as a soil conditioner for agricultural production.
Fluid Bed combustion may also be considered [28]. Methane generated in this process can either be
Furthermore, the recycling of food waste (leftover used for domestic cooking or to generate electricity
bread etc.) by dairy and livestock industries is not for a city suffering from a severe energy shortage. A
considered in this study and finally, the price of yearly revenue of 18,572,522 USD can be
electricity was assumed to be 4.77cents per KWh in generated by using methane recovered from
the calculation of energy revenue. anaerobic digestion for electricity production.
Economic Benefits
It was observed that around 33% of the total
municipal waste generated is of recyclable nature.
Asian J. Env. Tech. Vol 2 No 1 2018 E-ISSN 2548-6691; Khan et. al. (2018)

Table 2. Waste to Energy (Incineration)

Environmental Benefits Table 4. Carbon Dioxide Emissions


The study predicts that an integrated management
of municipal waste will result in numerous positive
impacts on the city’s as well as the global
environment. The recovery of methane from
landfills and biodegradation of food and garden
waste will bring about a considerable reduction in
the city’s total greenhouse emissions. In addition,
the use of methane for electricity generation will
decrease the CO2 released from the combustion of Socio-economic Benefits
fossil fuels. Despite the release of greenhouse
gases in burning methane (Table 5), it is anticipated The implementation of an integrated solid waste
that the integrated system will leave a far less management system is expected to have a
severe impact on global climate. considerable positive impact on the socio-economic
condition of the city’s population. The establishment
Table 3. Methane Recovery from Anaerobic of waste to energy and formal recycle industries will
Composting create new jobs for the city residents and will have
a holistic positive influence on the city’s economy.
Sustainability in the solid waste management is
expected to improve the livelihood as well as the
general health and well-being of the 24,000,000
people living in Karachi.
CONCLUSION
In this study, an attempt is made to propose a
comprehensive approach by integrating different
waste management practices into the municipal
solid waste of Karachi for a sustainable future of the
city. It is revealed that each resident produces
approximately 0.613 of solid waste per day making
the total amount of municipal solid waste to be
14,712 tons. Moreover, this study outlines the
potential of generating energy from the incineration,
and anaerobic degradation of solid waste.
Asian J. Env. Tech. Vol 2 No 1 2018 E-ISSN 2548-6691; Khan et. al. (2018)

It is estimated that up to 96,747 GJ of thermal Sustainable Energy Reviews 16(7): 5423-


energy can be produced from the incineration of 5429.
combustible waste. Additionally, approximately [6] Hafeez MS. 2013. Comparison of Solid
90.95 Gg of methane can be produced from the Waste Management between Oslo (Norway)
anaerobic biodegradation of food and other and Lahore (Pakistan), in International
putrescible waste in the city. The recycling industry Environment and Development Studies.
Norwegian University of Life Sciences.
can be enhanced and upgraded to generate a
[7] Novak P. 2015. Sustainable energy system
revenue of 20 million USD annually. Furthermore,
with zero emissions of GHG for cities and
the compost produced during the anaerobic countries. Energy and Buildings 98: p. 27-33.
process can assist in improving the water holding [8] Ahmed N. 2009. Sustainable community
capacity of Karachi’s sandy soils while offsetting the waste collection in Karachi, Pakistan.
energy requirements for synthetic chemical Engineering Sustainability 162(ES3).
fertilizers. In a nutshell, it is anticipated that the [9] Korai MS, Mahar RB, and Uqaili MA. 2017.
capture of methane gas and recovery and reuse of The feasibility of municipal solid waste for
recyclable materials from the municipal solid waste energy generation and its existing
will significantly reduce Karachi’s total GHG management practices in Pakistan.
emissions. Renewable and Sustainable Energy
Reviews 72: 338-353.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT [10] Lee T and van de Meene S. 2013.
Comparative studies of urban climate co-
The author expresses sincere thanks to Exceed benefits in Asian cities: an analysis of
Swindon who support author to participate relationships between CO2 emissions and
International conference "Advanced Technology in environmental indicators. Journal of Cleaner
waste water and waste management for extractive Production 58: 15-24.
Industries" October 23-26th 2017 in Bali, Indonesia. [11] Phillis YA, Kouikoglou VS, and Verdugo C.
2017. Urban sustainability assessment and
REFERENCES ranking of cities. Computers. Environment
and Urban Systems 64: 254-265.
[1] Samo SR, Mukwana KC, and Sohu AA.
[12] Ali SMH et al. 2015. A study to incorporate
2016. Potential of Solid Waste and
renewable energy technologies into the
Agricultural Biomass as Energy Source and
power portfolio of Karachi, Pakistan.
Effect on Environment in Pakistan, in
Handbook of Climate Change Mitigation and Renewable and Sustainable Energy
Adaptation, W.-Y. Chen, T. Suzuki, and M. Reviews 47: 14-22.
Lackner, Editors. Springer: Switzerland. p. [13] Vij D. 2012. Urbanization and solid waste
3313. management in India: Present practices and
[2] Soomro SA et al. 2012. Municipal Solid future challenges. in International
Conference on Emerging Economies –
Waste Management: Options for Its
Prospects and Challenges. Elsevier Ltd.
Treatment and Energy Recovery, in Energy,
[14] Sabir W et al. 2016. A Study of Solid Waste
Environment and Sustainable Development,
Management in Karachi City. Journal of
M.A. Uqaili and K. Harijan, Editors. Springer:
India. Education & Social Sciences 4(2): 151-163.
[3] Zuberi MJS and Ali SF. 2015.Greenhouse [15] Shahid M et al. 2014. Environmental Impact
effect reduction by recovering energy from of Municipal Solid Waste in Karachi City.
waste landfills in Pakistan. Renewable and World Applied Sciences Journal 29(12):
Sustainable Energy Reviews 44: 117-131. 1516-1526.
[16] Wilson DC et al. 2009. Building recycling
[4] Onyanta A. 2016. Cities, municipal solid
rates through the informal sector. Waste
waste management, and climate change:
Manag 29(2): 629-635.
Perspectives from the South. Geography
[17] Anwar F. 2012. Karachi City Climate
Compass 10(12): 499-513.
[5] Ali G et al. 2012. Green waste to biogas: Change Adaptation Strategy. Shehri-
Renewable energy possibilities for Citizens for a Better Environment.
Thailand's green markets. Renewable and [18] Abbasi H, Lu X, and Zhao G. 2015. An
Overview of Karachi Solid Waste Disposal
Asian J. Env. Tech. Vol 2 No 1 2018 E-ISSN 2548-6691; Khan et. al. (2018)

Sites and Environs. Journal of Scientific Pakistan: Potential, development and


Research and Reports 6(4): 294-303. prospects. Renewable and Sustainable
[19] ESCAPE U. 2012. Baseline Study for Solid Energy Reviews 59: 264-275.
Waste Management - Karachi, E.S.C.f.A.a.t. [25] Iqbal MK et al. 2012. Comparative Study of
Pacific, Editor. UN HABITAT. Different Techniques of Composting and
[20] Suvi Monni et al. 2006 Global climate their Stability Evaluation in Municipal Solid
change mitigation scenarios for solid waste Waste. J.Chem.Soc.Pak. 34(2).
management. Finland: VTT PUBLICATIONS. [26] Pipatti R et al. 2006. Solid Waste Dsiposal,
[21] Samo SR, Mukwana KC, and Sohu AA. in IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse
2017. Potential of Solid Waste and Gas Inventories.
Agricultural Biomass as Energy Source and [27] Xiao Y et al. 2007. The composition, trend
Effect on Environment in Pakistan p. 953- and impact of urban solid waste in Beijing.
1006. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment
[22] United Nations (UN). 2016. Transforming 135(1-3): 21-30.
Our World: The 2030 Agenda for [28] Huang Q, Chi Y, and Themelis NJ. 2013. A
Sustainable Development, U. Nations, Editor. Rapidly Emerging WTE Technology:
[23] Zhen-shan L et al. 2009. Municipal solid Circulating Fluid Bed Combustion. in
waste management in Beijing City. Waste Proceedings of International Thermal
Management 29(9): 2596-2599. Treatment Technologies. San Antonio. TX.
[24] Raheem A, Hassan MY, and Shakoor R.
2016. Bioenergy from anaerobic digestion in

View publication stats

You might also like