renn2018 Ynpaanovwe picxanv: Hoabie npuruans | Harvard Business Review - Pocors! Harvard Business Review POCCUA er Le ‘@or0: Giovanni Cala / Unsplash Ynpasneuve puckamu: HoBble NPAHyMNbI 23 mona 2012 | Crap p 2007 rony reviepanbibim aupextopoM BP, Toun KeviBopA Top»kecTBEHHO TOKNLALICH, ¥To aahMeToA mpeskye acero BoMIpocaMa SesonacHocTH. Ot BBEMI KORBIe IpaBWTa. Cornacho HM, HaNPKMep, HlepeHHocMTh ¢ MecTa Ha MECTO YaLIKy ¢ Kope MOXHO ObiNO, TOMBKO HaKDEIB ee KDBIMIKOM. A elle CoTPYAHUKAM peKOMeHNORANOCE He BECTA CMC-MlepenMcky, ypaBnss aBToMo6ueM, IIpoUINO TPH ToRa, KB wIOHE 20) Ha rnagax Xeiipopa 8 MekcukaHCKoM amine B20pRanact 6ypopas nnaTtbopMa Deepwater Horizon, To Tpuperto x ofHO# Ha CaMDIX CTDALIELIX B KCTOPMM PYKOTRODHBIX SKOMOTHMeCKUX KaTacTpop. AMEpKaHCKaRL ChegcTBeHHan KOMUCCKS puna K BLIBORY, “To NPHSKHOM TparemMn Cran OMMMGKK B yTIPABTEHAN, HapariusoBapuine «croco6HOCTb OTBETCTBEHHEX HL] BMEBIATD PACK, HayIeExKallyiM O6pasoM OleHMBATD Hx, coobuiarh o HX 4 Hx YorpaHATe™, ropa WgJEA KOPOTKO CucTema ynpaaneHns prckamn, ocHOBaHHan Ha CoSmiOneHnH npasin, xopowa, eon pers nAeT 06 yKopeHeHMM Kopnoparipiiix \eHHocTel w KoHTpone #@ nepcowanom. Ho ofa He ropes gine npeporBpalyenie yrpos, KoTOpble MoryT NoMeUlaT> KOMNAHKK pealliaoBbiBarb ee hitpsiIhbr-russia.rulmanagementkorporatvnyy-opytlat13°47uIm_source=newsieter&utm._medium=emailéutm_campaig Jotoy_fond hor fo... 115reno Ynpasnavwe picxanu: Hoabie npukuans | Harvard Business Review Pocows CIPaIeH MG, IIOKE HERE ENDNBIN NUCIIEAET BRM Yast LM MULSDIA TERNOIIUN MIN AIIM SH@4H 1 EHTBNBIK TlonwTMeckux waMeHeHii, TOTORHTECR K ONaCHOCTSIM TaKOro Poga HYDKHO, CepbeaHo OBcyKHAA HX. Baxvo yaurbisaTe MaculTa6 npeanonaraeMbix yrpos w CKOpocTb MaMeHeHAMA Mx xapakTepa, XOTA CTPYKTYDL! oTBeNaloulne 2a Aliana puCKOR M NOMCK KONTPMeP, YK@XAOM KOMMAHAK CBO, BCIO STY paBOTY HYPKHO yenaolBaTb © KopnopaTHBHbIMM riooyeaypama crpaTerMYecKoro NiaHHpoBaHAR, Alepkarts nog KoHTponeM cepbeaHble BHeUIHMe PACK, HenofBNacTHBle KOMNAHIRM, MOXKHO © NOMOUBIO TaKiX MNCTpyMeHTOR, Kak aHanita clieHapwes pagBHTUn COSBITHA M BepOsTHbIX RelICTAHA KOHKypeHTOR, BbiGop cocoa saencnr orToro, Kak 6biCTpo MOryT MarepvannsoBaTsCA NoTeHUMANIUMbIe OMACHOCTH H HeM OH bIaBaHbI ~ HaMeHeHMAMM reononHTHNecKoro, sKOHOMMNeCKOTO, NMDEAHOTO KepAKTEpA WH >ke AeACTAARMA Koneypenroe. eTopus Xetpopna poice4npaer obutyio npo6nemy. Ha ynpaprieHHe pAcKaMM, CKONBKO 6bi 06 9TOM HA TOBOPMIIM M GKOMIBKO Obl HeHer B OTO HM BKMAy(BIBATIM, Waiule BETO CMOTPAT C OHOM TOUKK sperHA: coorneTeTBus Tpe6onaHisM, YTO6H HX BEITOTHSITE, HaNo ChopMyMMpORATh TOSOMSLe MPABM H sacTaBHT Tepconan cnenosaTe Wm, KoweuHo, MHOrKe Mpanima BIOTHe pasyMHLI H NeHeTBUTeNbHO MpenOTEpantaroT HeKOTOpBie TOTeHIMAMbHO CephesHbie OTACHOCTH. HO HUKAKMMM TIDABKNAMM He CHMSMT BePORTHOCTE KaTaCT- pops spore Tov, To mponaoumna c Deepwater Horizon, He yMeHBUIATS ee nlocnencTBHi. Benb npasana Ke mpenoraparun GaxKpoTCTBa MHOrHx OUHaHCOBLX OpTANMsaLIMi BO BDeMs KDeMKTHOTO xpusiica 2007-2008 ToRoB. Bool crarse mn mpenmaraem HoByio KnaCcHpKalwio PUCKOB, Ova NOSBONAeT MORATE, KAKHE H2 HX MOKHO RepXaTb TON KONTPOTIEM c MOMOLISIO TIPABWN, a NVI KAKIEX EYRE HeHbte Mepbl, Mbi PaCcKagBIBaeM 0 TOM, KaKHe TPYAHOCT: COMpAIKeHD! ¢ TIPOBE/LeHHEM OTKDBITBLK, KOHCTPYXTHBHBIX OGCYDKNEHII PHCKOB, ConyrerByioux peamuaann™ KopnopaTMBHOA Crparerim, 4 [OKasbIsaeM, “TO TAKOTO Pola AVCKYCCHH ODE! MMeTb He Mpocto TeopeTHYECKyiG, HOH MpAKTHECKYlO SHASMMOCTD, TO ECT HX BEIBOHB! HONDKHD! MIpAMO orpaxkarboa Ha rpotlenlypax Bhipasorxk H BorIOMleHMA ctpaTernk. HB saKMOYEHMe MBI TOrOBOPMM 0 TOM, Kak BBIABILATS HeMpenBMgeHHble PACKM, KoTOpble BOSHHKAIOT HesaBUCMMO OT CTPAterA K pa6orhi opraknsalyen, M Kak FOTOBHTbGH K HVAM. Ynpasnenne puckaMu: npabuna un qManor? Tlepaniit war Ha nyt k cosmaHiio HaeXHoK CACTeMB! YaIpABNIeHHs PUCKAMK — OKMMAHHe Toro, 470 opranusauns crankmpaeTestc paskbiMH To cHoei Tppone yrposaMy. B xOMe MCCMeNOBAHUGL MEI BEITBHNM TPH x KaTeTOpHM. K KAKO 681 HM OTHOCHTACE Ta KIM MHAR OMaCHOCT, OHA MOKET OKASATECA POKOROM AMA cTpatervar KoMmaHun 1 Rake Ania ambHeiulero cyujecTBOBaKHA 6usHeca Kareropun 1: npeaorspaTamble puckH. IMcIOTCE B BYZY OrLaCHOCTH, BOSHMKAIOUIMe B CaMoit opranvsaLtiy AX MooKHO KOHTpOMMpoBATs, HeO6XONHMO YoTpaHsith UNH Hs6eraTb. Pes, B YACTHOCTH, MAeT o MocnencTAMAX HempaBOMOWHBIX, HesaKONHBIX, HeOTHUHBIX, OLIMGOUHBIX NlelicT BMH PATOBEIX COTPYANMKOR M PYKOROAMUTENTEM, a ‘Taloke c60en 8 CTaHApTHEIX pabounx Mporteccax. YTo KacaeTCs AeheKTOR M OUIMGOK, 13-38 KOTODLIX 6uaHEC cepbesito He MocTpanae? 1 Us6aSKTHCA OT KOTOPEIX ONHOCTHIO CHUIIKOM ZOPOTO, TO TYT, KOHEYHO, KOMTIAHUS ROMKHa Mpenycmorpers «rome omtycKa», Ho B 1lemtOM TlOnOSHELe PUCK CrleAYeT YOTPAHATS, TOCKOMEKY OTE HexenlarenbHBl CTpaTerMYecKM, He ONULIKOM WleMeTHNLHDI TOProBLU areHT HK COTPYREMK, NaOUIKiA BIATKY MUHOBEUKY, MOTYT OGecrIeHMTD dupMe HEKY20 CHLOMHEYTHYIO BRITON, HO B Ie7OM x RevICTEHA ONPMBAIOT penyTanmo KOMMaHMy, 470 O6a3aTeNbHo OTpas/TOR Ha ee CTOKMOCTH, PHCKOB oTOM KaTeropum ny'ure BOOBUTe He MONYCKAr®, a Ail STOFO HY>KKO KECTKO KOLTPONMpoBAT> PAbOUHte MPOLECCh!, YKOPeHAT KENTATENUE HOpMel TloseneHns M NOSMBaTECA rpaMOTHBIX peuteHHt. MocKonbKy 0 COBMOReHKA NpABKN yRe HaTACAHO HeMano, Mbi He 6yNeM sylecb BuaBATbOR B MonpOGHoCTH, OTChITaeM saMeTepeconAHHsIX “MTaTeTeH K BPESKE «Bblabnenke npeorapatnMbix pACKOB H Bhipa6orka KoHTPMep» /ntps:thbrrussia,ruimanagementkorporativnyy-opyiatt3142utm_source=newslettorButm_medium: ansrenn2018 Ynpasnovwe picxanv: Hoabie npuruans | Harvard Business Review Pocows! BbIAB/IEHME MPEAOTBPATMMbIX PACKOB VM BbIPABOTKA KOHTPMEP Komnaxnn He B CocTosHi npesBuaeTb 8ce CUTYALINY, 8 KOTOPbIX y COTPYAKMKOB BO3H/KaeT KoHebnnk witTepecos. MosToMy B Ka4eCTBe NepBOl NAHni OSopoHbI BNlonHe rogsiToA YeTKO copmynvpopanible Yenw v YeHHocTH KOMNaHH Muceua. Heo6xofMo BHATHO MW OfHOsHa4HO onpegenuTb Muccuio oprakuazaunn. Ja Konnextnga sto cTakeT caoero poga [lonapHoi aBeszoi, No KoTOpol OHM 6yayT opveHTvpoBaTbca 8 6ypHoM Mope 6uzHeca. Hanpimep, Nepean pasa sHaMexnToro Kpego Johnson & Johnson, goxymela, onpepensiouero @unocouio Kopnopaliny, TakoBa: «Hawa OCHOBHAaA OTRETCTREHHOCTS — Nepen BpavaMn M MeAMUMHCKAMM CecTpaMu, Nepep NaleHTamy, Nepes OTYAMH ” MaTepAMn, Nepep BCeMN, KTO NoNbayeTeR Hae NDOAYKWKer M yenyramu». V kaxabii 8 KOMnaHnl NoHMMaeT, bH MHTepecd! B Nobo cuTyaln CTOST Hanepgo mecTe, Miuccnio opranvigauvin Ao/xHbI sHaTb M pagnensirb BCe COTPYAHHKA LenHoctn. Komnatinay HeoSxogVMO abicTpoMTb ACHYIO CHCTeMy YeHHOCTed, 4TO6bI COTPYAHNKM pykoBOACTRORANNCb MMM, B2anMonericTAYA Cc KnMeHTaMY, NocTABLIMKaMN, konneramy, akuvoHepamy, npeficrasuTensMn cooSwecTe, Ito rapahTupyer, UTO He 6yayT Hapylwexb! cTaHgaprb! KOMNaHIM M HATO He NocTashT Nopyrpogy ee penyraunio MaKTHBDI Tpanypt. Kopnopatienas kynstypa onpenenser, vero genaTb Henbsa. Braropapa YeTkO O¥epYEHHBIM TpakWUaM MOKHO TUIaTeNbHO KOHTponMpoRaT AevIcTANE. TonbKo nopymaltTe: AeBaTb ua Jlecaty 2anorenel u jeRATb 2 NepEbIx AecATH MonpaBok K KoHCTMTYLAM CLA 1787 ropa (onbiUe WaBeCTHDIX Kak «BUNA 0 Npawax») csopmyniMpoBaHel 8 dope oTpuyatins. KomnatiaM HykHbI CBOs\bI KOpNopaTHBHbIx npaBMn, B KOTOPLIX OSBACHANOCD 6b), Kak BECTH CeGA B Chae KONDpNNKTa MHTepeCOB, HapyLUeHHA altTHTpeCTOBCKOTO 2akoHopaTenbcTRa, pagrnalueHvia KOMMepYeckOlt Talib, chy»KeGHOl MAdopMaLinn, BATOUMMMECTRA, AMICKPAMMHALIMK, CeKcyanbHbIx JOMOTATeNBCTE. KoHeuHo, ckonbko Hi dopMynvpyii MiCCuIO, CKOALKO Hi ONpEpENsI YeHHOCTH 1 HA ovepunBali rpAHMUbI, 970 eye He FapaHTHpyeT, 4TO COTPYAHMKH BCerga 6yayT BECTH cebs AOCTOMHO. UTO6ei MOAN NPABUNbHO ZelicTBOBANH BNIO6bIx cuTYALNAX, TOT-MeHEAKEPEI AOMKHBI MlOQaBaT> MM NMED H oKagbIBATB, TO y HVX CroBa He PacxogATca c AenaM. KOMnaHAM HY)KHbI Hag@KHbIe CHCTeMbI BHYTPeHHero KOHTponA. Heo6xoqMMmo NpepycmoTperb, HanpuMep, pagneneHne NonHOMOUVit KoTHagMT Npoyecc MHopMupoBAHiA pYKOBOJICTBA O HapyllleHMAX, Torgla CTaHeT MeHbille He TONbKO NPOCTYNKoa, HOM HCKyWeHIMA wx coBepulaTb, CHNbHbIM HeaaB/ICMMbIM OTAEN BHYTPeHHero KOHTPONA, KOTOPbIMA 6b MOCTOSHHO cnepMN 2a TeM, Kak COTPYAHMKK CoBNioAAlOT NpaaHna M VHCTPYKUWN, TOKE yaepxuean 6bi niofel oT HapyweHnii HW eblaBNAN 661 yoke NpovcweAWE. Kareropus 2: pucki ctparermn, Hexoropsie pucxn mpenmpusitua 6epyt Ha ces NospoRoMbHo — pan MaKcuMAnbHOd MpKOLITH, KOTOpy!O MOXHO TOMy'HTD, peanuays Gusxec-crpatermo. BaHX, HanpMMep, pucxyer, nitpsithbr-russia.rulmanagementkorporatvnyy-opytlat13°47uIm_source=newslater&ulm_medium=emalléutm_campagn=zolotoy fond hbr_ro... 3/15renn20e Ynpasnovwe picranv: Hoabie npuruans | Harvard Business Review - Pocors! MpeYLELASIIO SEY ATDL, KUMLUGIAA-UPURSBUNATEIA— KIG/\DLSAA ENDL ws ACEC YUAN A PasbravU LWA PUCKK STOW KaTeTOpHM cyleCTREHHO OTM#AlOTeA OT MpEMOTHPATUMEIX, MOCKOTBKY UX HeMb3sl HasBaTb sn CTpaTerus Halleneva Ha TonyveHe 6onbIilon MpHSEINH, TO OFA MsHavANBHO TompasyMenaeT BEICOKHH DUCK, M SHAT, Pan MOTEHIMANbHOM MPVOLINE Hao THATEMbHO OTCNEKHBATS STOT xmowesowt daxTop ee RocTIoexus. BP 6ypupiiian B MexcHKaHCKOM sa7iBe CKBAKUHY TMYSMEOM S HecKOMEKO KumOMeTpOB, Ove PHCKOBANA, Hazlench Xopouto sapaboraTh Ha HedpTH H Tase, KOTOPEIe PAccUMTEIBATTA NOSEITD, PMOKM CTpaTerui HeBOsMOKHO KOHTPONMPOBATD M TpemOTBpAUaTh, TONbKo cobmonaR Mpaswiia, BsToM cnyyae HY kHa CCTM YIIPABTIOHHA PHICKAMM, KOTOPAR 6b CHIDKATIA BEPOATHOCT MX , a CCT coGpitas pasBMBaloTCs M10 HeraTHBHOMY CLleHapmto, To MoMOrana 6b1 KOMNAHK HANpaBnaTb Mx B HYKHOC Hao6opor, o1 TosponMT MfITH Ha SonbuIMi PUCK, CyNsILKit Bone BBICOKMe MPUOBITY, EM Y KOHKypeHTOR, He OSnagarouHx cTonb >ke sibbexTHMBHOM cHcTeMoM HeXenaTENBHEIMH TIO CYTE. pycuo, Takas cHoTeMa He HloMeWwaeT KOMIIaHMAM 6paTbCa 9a CaMble abalT:OpHbie Hala: Kareropus 3: sHewnne pickm. MiFor7ia KOMIaMIa lomanaeT 8 SoHY pucKa H3-3a cObLITHMIE, NpoucKONAUIMX BHe ce Tels, KoTOpbIe OT Hee He 3aBMCAT H Ha KOTOPhle OFA HUKAK He MOXeT BOIReMCTBOBATS, STO NpMpOMIHIE 1 TOnATHHeCKHe KaTaCTpobel, YSMHHELe MAKPOOKOHOMMMECKHe COBATH. YIPABTATS BIeUNMAMM PUCKAMA HyPKHo OcO6bIM O6paaoM. MocKONBKY NpEMOTBPATATe REISBIBAIOUIME HX COBLITHA KOMMTAHKH He B CHMAX, BAXKKO Tpke ACETO BLISBIATS HX MPUSHAKH (saN1HUM HKCTIOM OBbINHO CTaHOBKTCA MOHATHO, 4TO OHM He MOTTA He CHY4MTbCA) K TIBITATECA CMATUATS HX mTOCTeN(CTBHA. TIpolleslypbl YNPABNEHMA PACKAMM KOMMAHMM JO‘DKHB COoTBeTCTBOBATH MepewCHeHHbIM TpeM KaTeropvaM. Co6MOfaTb MpaBya BAXHO, ECM peu UNeT o pUcKAX MpenoTapaTaMEix, HO AMIS BHEMIBUK K YO iX CTPATernH STO ASCOMOTHO He MpUMeHKMO, a 3HAuAT, B TomOSHBIX Cny ax HYKHE! APYTHE TOAXOME!, Mpenionaraioulne B TOM YKCTe OTKPEITOe K TOApOSHOE oécyxxnenne pucka [panna 970 merko Tomko Ha crioBax, Kak oKasan o6uMpHLie uccnenOBaHMs MOBeneHMA oTmenbHEIxX moneit u Wembix oprarusattuit, Halla ICHXMKa yoTpoeHa TAKUM O6pasoM, 470 MI TpeMMOWTAeM saKpsisaTs Taga Ha BepOATHBIe OMACHOCTH H He MOMM sapattee Ux O6Cy>xTATE. Touemy Tax TpyAlo o6cy»knaTe pcKH B pesynbrare MHoro4MoneHHEIX MooresjoBaHMy yueHble CENA BBIBOG, YTO MoNM MepeoljeHMBAloT CBOIO crloco6HocTh OkaabiBaTb BNMAKMe Ha COOBITHA, KoTOpBIe Ha CaMOM [JesIe BO MHOTOM oripeflenmoTos creseHMeM O6cToaTesICTE, Mbi GIMLIKOM yBepeHbi B TOYHOCTH HALMX IIpOrHOSOB M OL{eHOK pcKa M, MSIFKO TOBOPA, He coBceM ajleKBaTHo mpesieTaBiaem ceGe Mx ReposTHBIe TOCHeNCTBY: Kpome Toro, Mp1 TlonBepxxeHel TaK HaaHBaeMoMy addexty skopenia WM QUKCALIKH Ha KOBECTHOM, TO ECTS eMaeM BLIBOMB!, OTTATKUBAACH OT CHEBUTHEIX, MeKELIMX Ha MOREPXHOCTH AKTOB, XOTH MSBECTHO, UTO MpaMonuHeyio SxcTpanonuponarh co6siTus HACTOAU{ero KNM HeNaBHero Mpoumnoro Ha HeoMpereneHHOe 6ynyniee — Becia oraco, Sra Hallra ocoGeHHoCTS Hepenko ycyryOnAeToR CTpeMmeHHeM BO BCeM MCKATE HonTBepxsleHie Halted MpaBOTH!, 13-38 WETO Mbi HeBOMbEO BOCTIPHHUMAeM TOMBKO KHGOPMALTIAO, HOKPennmOUIy!O HaMy TOAKY speHies (KaK paso, 06 yortexay), u OTCeKAeM Be, 4TO eH poTHBOPeHHT (KAK TIpaBwsio, pes upeT o Heyqa4ax). Ecru co6nirits pasByBaioTon He Tak, KaK MBI RYMAN, MBi HepenKo HaCTaMaaeM Ha OnH@KAL BhOpaHHOM, XOTH i REMYLEM B TYNMK Kypce, ¥, He Kerlas OTKasaTECH OT CBOeTO PelllenMsA, HepasyMHO TeTIneMon 3a Hero, TATA ce HOBDIe 1 HOBIE PecypcEl, TO ec TloMpocTy BNOpactisam NeHLTK Ha BeTep. HexoTOpHIe OCObeHHOCTH EKTHBHOM IICMNOMOTHH TOKE OTPLATENHO CKaSLIBAWTOR Ha Haulieit cocobHOCTH OGcyKNaTS oMACHOCTA it Heymann, CKaxeM, B CHTYAlIHH HeonpenerieHHOCTH: KONMEKTHBE! HArIANHO REMOHCTPMDYOT beHoMeH rpyntiogoro MaieHis. Kor Eom Kakve-To peuteniis 7k RevicTEust OnOSpmoTes GONbIIKMHCTROM, To OCTANBHEIe UTeHsI Tpyrimtsl O6BIHO ocTaBnsioT CBO BoapaXenHs (NYCTh H OveHb TeHHBIe) TPH cebe H NOAUMHMOTER. [pynToBoe MEMUITeRHE Wane MposBIaeTCs B KOMTeKTHMBe C ABTODUTADHHIM, HIM CAMOYBePEHHEIM, HIM CTPeMsIMMer MOBO! teKoyt wa6erare KOHGMKTOR 1 Ha KOPHIO Mpecexar mo6yio yrposy ero BnactH pyxoBoguTeNeM. Boe STH HowxonlorMeckie ocoGeHHOCTH — OTHEMbHDX MOReH K WeMbUX KONTCKTABOB — OSLACHALT, NOWeMY CTO MHOTHe KOMTAHKi£ He SaMCHAIOT HEABEBIX YIDO3 WIM HEBeDHO Mx MCTOIKOBEIBA:OT. BMeCTO TOTO HTOGEL hitpsuthbrrussia elmanagementkorporativnyy-opyvat13147utm_ sour jotoy fond_hbr ro... 445renn2018 Ynpaanovwe picxanv: Hoabie npuruans | Harvard Business Review - Pocors! «TlOgeTHMATE COMOMKY», OHK CAMM ToBEprawT ce6sl ROAECKHAM PUCKAM. Oni HauMHaloT CHMLIKOM sleTKOMBICNEHHO OTHOCHTECR K METIKMM, BPONe 6bi, C6ORM M HenOCTaTKAM nojoStibie HepBbie «SBOHKM» BOCTPMHMMAIOT He KaK OMrHanbt HaNBATAIOUIeHICR ONACHOCTA, a KAK TOKIO ‘Tpenory. To ect To, Yo ONKHO 6biNTO Gb MX HACTOPOXVT, CTAHOBKTCH NDABBINHBIM, @ SHaYHT, — HOpMoy. Yorpanvirs nogobitble richxonornueckvie NOBYIUKH 4 MPASBAHLE] paMoTHo BBICTpoeHtHbie MPOLERYPEL «KoHTponuponarh pucks coBceM He merko», — ronopur [pKeHTpH JT, RenyuN cetwanKeT Mo cucTeMaM Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL) nonpasmenentaa NASA. B mpoexritix rpynmax JPL pa6oraioT my'unne BEIMYCKHAKH IyMLInx yHWBepCNTeTOR: MHOTHE 13 HUX BOOBIIe He SHAIOT, LTO TaKoe — Heymaa, c HMM TaKorO He cnYWATOCE Hi BO BpeMa ywe6si, HH Ha paéore. Korga JI saanics embio yKopeHHTh B JPL HoByO KYTBTYpy npobumaKraKH PMCKOB, OKasamIOc®, YTO CaMoe TDYAHOe — STO HAyYUTH MPoeKTHEIe FpYIIMEI AYMaTS O TOTEHUMANEHO YsaSBUMEK MecTax Ux TanaHTIMBLIX peuleHMi w sapanee OScyxMaTh STO. B Tako cATYALAM pacnMcbiBatb, YTO MOXKHO JeMIaTb, a Yero HeNbss, SeccMBICNeHHO. BooSue MpaBuria wane Boero MPUBOAAT K o6parHomy sdibexTy. Thom HAYMHAIOT MBICITS ke Tuma, ~ roBopit [propa Kuxapes, crieuManucr no pucky JP Morgan, — B AeBATH cny asx Ks eCATH OHM Mpuaxator, 470 HenopaGoranx. Torma Mbi canMMcH a PecTpyKTyDUpyeM cHemxM» Tnapuaa onlacHocr> nepenoja crlelivanvctos Mo pucky B NospasmenenuiR cRAsAHA.C TEM, ¥TO OHA ACCHMMIIMPYOTCR, CTAHOBATCH «CBOKMMt? [VLA PYKOBOCTBA M M3 KPATHKOB CHesIOK NPEBpaLalores BMX MEYIMATOPOR. 3a To, ¥TO6BI sTOTO He NpeMcxoAMN, FOMKeH OTBEYATS AMpeKTOp Mo pUCKAM U TeHAMpeKTOP, oT KOTOporo & KOHEYHOM CYeTe AaBVICHT, Kak B KOMIAHKM OTHOCATCA K PHCKAM, ‘TPM KATEFOPUM PUCKOB PUcky, KoTOpBIM TIPOTHBOCTOAT KOMITAHKM, MOXKHO pag/leMMTb Ha TPH KaTeropKy, M MpesOTBPallla WX HYKHO Mo-pasHomy. TIpeorapatuMble PUCK, ACTOHRUKOM KOTOPEIX OKaSbIBAeTOR CaMa OpraHAsatlve, MOKHO orcnexuBats # KoHTPoNMpoBarb, BBO;A Crporne HpaBwa, NpoNaraHjMpys KOpropatMBHb\e YeHHCCTH MA peanusys craHslapritble Mepb BHYTPeHHero KOHTponA. “ro KacaeTCH PHCKOB BHEUHMX 4 CYpaternYeCKAX, TO B@KHO, YTOGEI YIDABMIEHUB OTKPEITO O6CVAUANH VX A BMECTE C TOYHHEHHBIMM KCKAMIM SKOHOMHHEIE cTloco6sl CHIOKeHKA BePONTHOCTH HeKeTIaTeMbHOTO PasBUTHS COOMTHM MH6O CMSTYEHKE Hx TocTeRCTEMi Kareropan2 Kareropun 1 Pron enparerin Kareropen 3 Tipegoraparuunse pcan ° cue on son cenraeeeen Brewnme prea a psn Wem ncnoaneece aceon oMnrars rocrepstormHexenarersnor pau Cote Vadoxans uw npegorapaune aeosouncke cofccsceest eozosen HexeraTentnoe pas0KTVe Sroroumeoor so ers CaKaTeSePEATCETS lonacwerapaeven corn weupram neersneTae pwn xorrpons onpuroe opeacive pea, Tepe Nery ROME Canora ropropsrvanankymirype, Sobrante THM erroe oonyruposanve west coMrann CFE ce ‘agar ornenaynpannwts pecan Koopnsaponar eypiponae wt kcpperapona ce-eM /ntps:thbrrussia,ruimanagementkorporativnyy-opyiatt3142utm_source=newslettorButm_medium: ronranen ners ani CTBETPINECURENEH oworats canis nordeam moxapreoanione ‘poston nanteoai on beeanenpoedea, owas ailutm_campaig ues no6o-Hore PEK HTpEC 76 Jotoy_fond_ brorenn2018 Ynpaanovwe picxanv: Hoabie npuruans | Harvard Business Review - Pocors! ‘riowesne ornena ynpannein prexawn x SHRM enorasior rynny peapa6owutos erpaves eiorayorxacnesaavcinve cpanel senanvenue —unnpuleryior = pon" wESaRCMM ederayor coe wesovcintos kaSnenarer Onachocte AeneHuA pucKos no yHKKMAM onyctam, pyxosoncrao noowpaer axtusHoe obcyxxmeHMe pucxoB, Ho Terleph BOSHMKACT OMlaCHOCTD yronMTD B RDYTyi KOTHMTABHO-NcHxOMOrMNeCKy:O MOBYLIKy. Morse pyicxw CTpaTerMK (# HeKOTOpEIe BHELIHHe) Brome mpenckasyeMni « NadKe XOPOUIO M3BECTHDI, H KOMMAHKM MOGAT AemMTb HX Ha KATerOpHM To PYHKUMAAM monpasneneniit, Baki par>kMPYIOT PUCKM KaK «KPeAWTHBU, UHanconsle. Tips TaxKoM nenteHvit HeBOSMOXHO HameKHO KOHTPONMPOBATH PHCKH OTBETCTBEHHOCTS PAsMEITA, HeoGxonuMas KEdopManina cBoGomHO He NMpKynMpyeT. He Tony'aeTeR 1 ObcyxMeHHA BIaMMOsaSHCHMOCTIE PasHBIx pyicKos. [put rpaMoTHO OpraHHSOBaHHOMt MUCKYCCMM ee YYACTHMKM He TONDKO BBICKASBIBaOT MPOTHBOMONOKHbIe MHOHKH, HO M MULYT TOUKM CoMpHKockoReHKs, HenompasuMniis yuleps GusHeCy MOET HaHeCTH Yepena MenkHX COBLITHA, HeTpeACKAsyeMbiM O6pasoM YouIMBALOULAX APYT Apyra. Yro6e ACH BUTeTb PUCKH, YrPOxaLoUIHE Beer KOMTIAHHM, PYKOBOMTEMAM crenyeT NPMHMMAT® PelleHAA TapartnentbHo c HaHMDOBAHMeM cTpater nH — oTo ONMH MS TEX MHTErPAlYORHBIX MPOL|ECCOB, 470 yoke OTHAKEHBB Gombulanoree xopoino yrnpaBiineMblx KOMNaHHit Cxaxen, Infosys, wnnuiicxnis roctasniK 10 Ans smeKTPOHHO KOMMepIIA H TeTeKOMMYHUKAM/OHHBIX Kommanvsi, aHannanpya 1 OScykRaR PUCK, TlOMaraeTes Ha CHCTeMy cOamancuposaHkEIx MoKasaTereit — MHOTPYMEHT ONeHKM CTPATET Hn H HArNANHOTO OTPAKEHVE TOTO, Kak y KOMMAHMAH OCTORT flema, «PasMBILINAR Hay TeM, PHCKH KaKOTO TaTla HaM HYKHO YHUTbIBATS, Mbi NOCTENeHHO O6Hapy>XMNH Te, KOTOPEIe MOTYT HoMeuiaTh Ham Ho6HTEcE Hertev, onIpeneTIeHHbIx Walle KopMopaTMBHOA cHCTeMOIL ToKasaTeneyts, — roBOpHT MAL Panraviarx, satje-npesijlerT mo ympapnenimo packamy, Cosflanaz CROW cMoTeMY cBarlaHcMponaHHBix nokasarertey, Infosys 8 Ka¥eoTBe OCHOBHOM saya BLUReNMATIa BIAMMOCOTHOWEHHA C KIMEHTAMM H BEI6paTA Hokasareni AVIA OWeHKH Mporpecca 8 oTokt OGNIactM, HarlpAMeD KONI“YeCTBO MHOCTPAHABAX KNMEHTOS, cyMMa 3akasoB KOTOPAX 9a Foy MPeBbiulaeT $50 MiIH, a TAIOKE exer OMHOE YBENIAYEHHE, B IDOLEHTAX, YOXOROB OF KpYTHEIX KMMEHTOB. Tpoatannanpozan 9TH lem 4 cooTBeToTByIOUIKe TtoKasaTesn, pyKoBORCTEO Infosys ocosHamtO, TO TaKaR crpaterua Hecer HoBbie yrposbi — OHM CaASAHBI ¢ BePOATHBIM HeBbINTONHCHMeM KIMCHTAMM CBORX dunanconeix obssarenbors. Kora Infosys umera jlerl0 Co MHOXECTBOM MerIKHX 3aKas4MKoB, KeBBITTIaTA onra KeM-HMGyib As HAX He NoRBepramia orlacHocTH KoMmaHMo. Ho rotepa $50 itt Hantecmia 6b eit cepbesitbilt yalap. Infosys Havana orcneKnBarb Kpenutocriecobiicet KaxHOre KPYFIHOTO SaKAsuHKa — 3 cTano rnapitbim ToKasaTenem Toro, 6yfleT uN He Byer onmmaveHt aakas, CNH sHatenwe MoKasaTens pocmo, B Infosys mpwHmMann Mepsi, 470681 KMMeHT Moracnm safOMKEHHOCTS, UNM TpesoRAMn MlOsTAMHEIX BRITITAT. BOT pyro mpumep: Volkswagen do Brazil, fowepHee MpennpusaTHe HeMerxoro KonLlepa B Bpasunuy. B ero oTAeMe Ympannenvis puckanu nom axanuse u o6cyKNeHUH BepOATHEIX Yrpos OTTANKMBALOTR OT CTPATerHeCKOTO Tinazia KoriaHun, [Ins KaKROM 13 BHECeHHEIX B TAH 1eMM BEITBMISIOT 3Ce TO, 1TO MOXeT TIOMeMlIaTD ee ROcTIOKeEIO. SaTem jis KaKy{oro pMcKa cocTaBAAloT KapTy. B Heh Nepeyvenmior MpakTAveckHe MocmesIcTBAH KORKPETHOTO PHCKa IMIS MPOMSBORCTBA, YKasHIBAIOT CTeMleH eT BeposTHocTH, OCHOBHBIe TOKasaTeMM H Mes Tperynpexnenns onacoctn, KpoMe Toro, B KapTe yKasbiBaioT OTBeTCTBEHHOTO 3a PUCK (oM. BpeaKy «Kapra piickas), Morom onyfent cocTaBnisier saxmoueHne o peaymbrarax jist AbICuIeTo pyKoBORCTRA (eM. Bpeaky «Kapra orvera 06 ynpapnieHin pucxamm). KOMIAHMsIM EYOKHO H€ TOMBKO IIOCTORHHO BLLTBNIATH PHCKK H ntpsuthbecussia.ulmanagementhorporativayy-opylat13142utm_source=newslaterButm_mediumeemalsutn._campaignezololay fond hor 0... 845renn2018 Ynpasnovwe picxanv: Hoabie npuruans | Harvard Business Review Pocows! paspa6arsipars MpopusiaKTHYeckMe Mepbi, HO M CosmaBATS ocoBbIe eHaslaopHBIe» CTPyKTypEL.B Infosys ec JelTPANMSOBAKHEIA OTAeN, KOTOPEU SAHMMACTCA CELIKMM PUCKAMM CTDATErHH M CoCTABNAeT cooTheTeTnyiouHi Mian peRCTAMs, m Crlel{anKaMpoRAHitble rpynisa ea MeCTaX», KOTOPEIe BMECTE c 6ULSHEC- Toppasnenenusmn paspabarsisato? MeToA(sl peanMsal{u sToro «ljeHTpanHsoRAHHOrO» TiIaHa, CHEAT 32 TEM, Kax oH BLINOMESeTCS, H HOMOraloT GusHec-Tonpas/leNleHMAM OTREYATL Ha BOSHUKAHOUIKe YrPOIbI K TOTOBUTECH K HOBLIM PUCKAM. B UckMOUNTeNbHLIX cMyasx — HamIpMMep, ecmm MeHemxep Mo paGoTe ¢ KTMeHTAMM XOWeT TpefocTasir» HeKoeit KOMMAHHM, IMaTeECTIOCOSHOCTL KOTOPOHt BLISMIBACT COMHEHUS, KPERUT Ha 6OMBILOM cpox ~ no npoce6e stux rpynm nogxmouaeToR eHTpANMs0BaerHEI OTHE KAPTA PUCKA Cee nomontsio B VW do Brasil oulenmBaioT puicKM cBoes cTpaTerMn. TIpexKne Bcero MeHEADKEDH! ONVCHIBAIOT OnacHOCTH, KOTOPEIe MOY? TIOMELIGT KOMMIAHICH BLITONEMTE KaKRYIO Ke ee CTpaTerHveckHx sana. [ns KaX(j0TO BLIMIBMIeHHOTO PUCKa COCTABNALOT Xapry: 8 Hell MepeuHonMOT MpaKTHECKMe MOCHeNCTEH HexeTaTenbHDIX cobuITHi ANIA pa6oTt dupes. O6pasey TaKoi Kaprsi MpUBeMIOH HIOKe. Syrece OTIMCaHE: TiocnencTBns c60n B MoCTaSKax, 13-32 KoToporo VW do Brasil Moxer He HocTH™b CBOek cTpaTeryuecKoit yeNM, a MMelHO — oTnaquTb 6ecmepeSoittioe cHabxeHHe. Eo) Topavmwgo- Cok onero ss Exemveevonpono- 0. Mayan, Srononenc — snocraneax ramon fsconeionn re perp me secre wenove coomen meonore Sonpocaw owsna” — cuaSnet nacrovon ve a (oe tte acre yenmanne aaa oe E tsraenon nora, sromy af anynox HKOHTpO socasaron0 Henna aera (aks omypenam sauce Spax Ss eneree Henonieie o6opynosarne Mporasoner nopren focranateron sewsie gereneh insane re nance. read ‘Mepeino npepor- pene poe: pepsin eapyaconwn rocranucon Mepainonpenorape somo pater ewracteamoe Topo no crave ‘nor seven ecnocranuyneon. KAPTA OTUETA OB YNPAB/IEHM PACKAMA Pucku cpoesi crparerux VW do Brasil cymmupyer Ha Kapre oT4era 06 ynpanyiensin pucKaMy, crpyKTYpa KoTopoit oripejenseres crpatermveckumn tienAMn (bparMeHT npuBered HIKE), PykoBonMTeNH Cpasy KE BULAT, KaKHe MS BBIABIIHHbIX [VIF KAKO CTpaTerM4eckok: sajla4H PHCKOB ONactHbi M Tpebylor BHUMAHHA ui ocobEIx KOHTpMep. K IpHMepy, B VW BBIABWTM, “To BBITONHAT sanayy «Onpangbiar oKnAanus Totpe6utenelis Moryt momeurark 1] dakropon. Yernipe omackhi, Ho chTyaliua yIyUIKTack Ho cpaRHeHmio c mpensiqyutun KBapranom. Kpome Toro, kapra MoKasbiBaeT, Kak O6cTOSIT yjeMla c ynpaBMeHvem pucKaMa BO BCer KOMIaHHAH, eee Csemeere Cocca oY hitpsiMhbr-russia rulmanagementkorporativnyy-opytlat13142ulm_sourcs Jotoy_fond_ hor fo... 9/15reno Ynpasnonwe picxanu: Hoabie npuruans | Harvard Business Review ~ Pocows! ‘Yeenmurs ceoio Aono pink ‘Onpasaare oxnnanun norpeGureneh Ynysunre penyrauio xoMnsin ‘Coapare annepexy opranusauno B paGore nap wiHoBaunnman Ha nepsoe wecTo craswTb wHTepecki novpeGuiTeneh Boicrpansare siipexrasnste npouenypet sanyeKa HOsHHOK osticnre rextonornveckyio séibextasHocrs PaspaGorare sonnorirs ag/pexruhyo erparerwio yenieni oBeeMoB npowaBoRCTES Onnaaurs 6ecnepesotinoe cnabenne +I+tt-lt-1 Cosqare npuenexarenoioli, whvosauyontil accopruNesT Kax nokaaeipaior ori npuMepei, pasMep i samauH OTAeNA To ypaBrettmio pucKaMH He SaBMCAT OT BeTMMEB opraniaatinit. B Hydro One, a sto Kpymiiag KOMTIaHv, OH OTHOCHTENbHO HEBEMAK; TEM He MeHee OF BBIRBNET yrposbi jis 6Histieca, MNbopMUpyeT o HUX BCI >UpMY, a TakKKE KOHCYMbTHpyeT PYKOBONCTHO Mio BoTIpocaM acripe/levieHiAn Peoypoos ¢ yYeTOM PHCKOB. Hi HaoBopo", B CpABHMTeNbHO HEGOMbLIKX KOMMAHAX Wi noypasjenensnx spoye JPL 4 JP Morgan Private Bank mHorga Nowra y Kaxkyoro npoekta eorb eBoit Ha6moRaTeNbHBit CORET HIM CRON cTlelIMANHCTH!, KOTOPhle BLIABMISIOT YSIBAMEIe MecTa 6USHEC-peUleHHit. A, cxaxkeM, Infosys, HatlenenHom Ha poct KpyTHOM KOMMAHMH ¢ MaCLITA6HEIM MpoHaBONCTBOM H CTpaTerKerh, HeOGxORUMD! H CHTIBHaN HeHTpaNnsoBaHHaN cny>K6a, H CeMMaNMCTH Mo PUCKAM, DaboTaIOUIHTe B Tompasnlenenunx, KOTOpLie OleHMBALOT C TOUKM SpeHUs PHCKOB Hx KOMMeDYeCkie DelileNns « O6MeHMBAIOTCR werbopmannest c uerrTpanvsosanHod rpynnoi Kontpont Hexontponmpyemoro K senivM puckam (rpeTbs KaTeropy), Kak MpaBumio, He TIpUMexHMBI Mepsl KOHTPONA 3a MpenoTBpaTHMEIMH, PuCKAMI 1 PHOKAMM CTpaTerHM, OHH O6LIHO HUKAK He SaBMCAT OT CaMOMt KOMMIAEKM; BCe, TO OHA MOXET, — 970 MX BbIABIIAT, OLCHMBAT® OTEHUMA/IbEbIe NOCHEACTEMA M yMars, ¥TO HeNIaT, eon COBEITHAE ByAyT pasBMBaTboH No HexKenaTenbHOMy CeHapmio, OlacHoCTH BHeUIHero XapakTepa MHOTHa ONBMI{HEI, NOSTOMY K HMM TIpAMeHAME Te 9Ke Mepbl, YTO MK PUCKAM CTpATer HH, CKadKEM, BO BPeMs MUPOBOTO SKOHOMMYECKOTO xpiovca, KacTyTIMBUIero BeneR 8a dpunaHcoBhim, Infosys cronKHynac c HOBO MpobyeMol, KoTOpaR MeWaTia efi BRIOTIUATS ONY 13 HAMeYeHHBIX 3444, @ MMEHHO — CosslaT MeXIyHapONHbi KOMIEKTHE [st ToSansHoro PBIHKAa, Pet Umer o pocTe MpoTeKIIMOHMSMA. Sra nonuTuKa nonpasyMenana XecTKHe OrpaHWeHMAA Ha MIpeROcTaBNeHMe pabownx BMS TPaxnaKaM 13 HeKOTODDIx CTPaH — "NeHOS OprannsaljAn oKOHOMMYeCKOTO COTPYAEMUCCTBA K pasBHTHA, B KOTODEIX y Infosys bun Kpynutble KoLMeHLTEI, XOTA TEOPeTMHECKY: HPOTEKYMOKMCTCKOE FAKOHORATELCTRO OTHOCHTCA K PHCKAM sHeumtero xapaxtepa, B Infosys K HeMy OTHecHMob KaK K PMoKy Grpaterna, [iA Hero CocTaBMNA KapTy PACKa, kyfla BRUCANM HOBBIA TokasaTertb: KONMYeCTBO COTPYANAKOB ¢ RBOMHBIM rpaxAAHCTBOM KH ¢ paspewlenMem pa6oTaTs sa mpenenamn Hawn u ux fons B mpoueHrax. EonM 6bi 43-24 TeKYWECTH KaMpoR 970 KONMMECTBO cTano yMenbutarses, rnoéanbias eTparerns Infosys Morma 661 OKasaThCs TIOn yrposok Mosromy B KoMMaHvs orany McKaTs HOBHIe MeTORM HaliMa M MpeqoTBpalileHvs Texy¥eorT KampoR, KOTOPAIe CMsrs0nn 6bi LOCKE CTEM TIpOveXYMOHMIMa, Ho Ho GONbuUleH YACTH IA BHELINMX YFpOa HYKHDI HHbIC ANANATEMECKMe HOAXOABL, HOCKONBKY 11460 BepoATHOCTS OMLacHOrO pasBHTHA COBbITHI: O¥CHD Masta, NAGO MX ‘TpyAHO MpenBUyeTb, Koryla BbICTpaMBawor crpareriMo. Mbl BEIABHIK HeCKOMBKO UCTOHUKOS BHLIHMX PICKOB, /ntps:ithbrrussiaruimanagementkorporativnyy-opyiatt3142utm_sourco=newslettorButm_medium: Jotoy_fond_ hore. 10115renn2018 Ynpasnovwe picxanv: Hoabie npuruans | Harvard Business Review Pocows! Tpnponnuie w skoHoMnveckne KaTacTpodl, NocneACTa:A KOTOPUIX NpoREAAIOTEA cpaay. CaMM NO Cebe OHM ApencKaayeMbl ADYTOe AeNO, “TO OBbINHG HeBOSMOKHO TOUHO HaaBaTb BpeMs CobbiTHA (onHaXKAbI B KanaopHAn HasepHnka nponaoVineT ClnbHoe aeMNeTPACeHNe, HO HE MBBECTHO TONHO, KONG iM & KAKOM KOHKPETHO MECTE) Curanss, rosopauyve 0 npAGMIDKeHAH NoROGHUIK KaTacTpod, oTHOGHTeNbHO c/aGbi. B KaYecTae NpuMepa NpHBeHeM Takite npupogHIe KaTaKmWaMbI, Kak WaBepxXeHNe synkaHa B VicnakaAn 8 2010 roxy, Ha-aa KOTODOTO NpMUITOC sakpbiTb BOsAYLUMOe MpoCTPAHCTaO Esponbi, Ani NageHHe CTOMMOCTH aKTHBOB M3-2a SKOHOMMMECKOTO KOHEMCA, Ecnn nogoShbie co6bITHAR NpOMCXOAAT, vx Nlocre”CTMA TAXeNbI M BAKE! CPasy, — AOCTATO4HO scnOMHMTS semmerproeHine W uyHamn 2011 roga 8 Anowmn FeononmTnveckie H NpHpoaHble HaMeHeHHA, NOCREACTANA KOTOPHIX OUIVUIaIOTEA AONFOe BPEMA. Pes ABET O nonuTHeckix nepTypéaynnx (Ceppeskeix noMMTAYECKHx PedonMax, TOCYMADCTSeHHLK NepeBOpOTAX, PeBOMOUKAK W sofia), mnoGanbHOM NoTeNTeHHK, HCTOUICHMM BaXxHEMWHX NPRORHEIX pecypcoB Bpore MpecHO BOA AlelicTana KonkypeTos co cpenvecpounbia BosnelicTavem. B oTy KaTeropitio pACKOB NONaNaIOT NOAPHIBHIE TexHonorun (HanpHMep, MHTepHET, cMapTOHEA LUTDMX-KOR) H HEOKAAHHbIe CTpATerMYeCkHe XOMI ATPOKOB OTPACA (a NacTHocTu, Amazon aaHanach posHA4Holl Toproaneh KHHTaMA, a Apple ~ nponaBORCTBOM MOBIATLHIX Tene”>oHOR 1 6orTOBO sneKTpoHnki)). BHELIHME puck KaxkqOrO THNa TpeBy:oT Ocoboro aHanMTHYecKorO NoAKoAA, Crpecc-recro! no6ouHoro pucka. ON rloMoraior KOMNaliMAM Ol|ekWTb Nocmes{CTBMs CepbesHbix MsMeHen Ait (pews upeT 06 onHoM unm mByx TepemeHtnix hakTopax), KoTOpBie SyAYT HeMeNMIEHHDIMH H CHTBHEIMH, XOTS ‘TOUHO CKasaTb, KOTAa MPOMSOHAYT BLISBABLINE HX COBEITAS, HEROSMOXKHO. OUHAHCOBEIE bUpMEI TpAMeHSOT crpece-Tecr#s, 1706ti cnporHospoBATS, Kak, HaNpHMep, TIOBBIMLIEHMe B TDM Dasa eH Ha HOE, pesKne Komle6aHMs KYPCOB BamMOT UNM MPOLeHTHLIX CTABOK, ReDONT KpyMHOTO MACTHTYNMOHANLHOTO MrpOKA HT. cyBepeHoro rocymapersa OTpasATCA Ha TOSsMUKOHHO! Topropne H MEBeCTHAMAX. Ho TIpy BCeX CBOUX TmOCaX cTpece-Tectuponakite oveHb saBMCuT OT MpennonoxeHMit (a OHM MOTYT OasaThOA HEOSBEKTHBHBIMIA) 0 xonuuectse baxropos, KoTophie Nperepnat waMeneHvA, CKaxeM, B 2007-2008 romax MHOTMe GaHKK MCxonMNM ig cHeHapys, KOTODBIA CHMTANH XYAUIAM: YeHbI Ha KMTbe B CLA craGummanpyirToR M KONTO HepsKatoR Ha ontor ormerxe, Mano KoMy Mputuinio B ronoBy mposepyts, To 6yster, ect eH MOvIAYT BANS, Oto — MPMMep ‘TOTO, KaK MONM B OBOHX OlleHKaX OTTANKMAOTER OT HOCreNHAX M CAaMBIX NOOTYMHBIX NaHHbIx. BoMbIUNKAHeTBO KoMmaHisi orlupariocs Ha AaHHble 0 CTOKMOGTH KMNIbs B CIIIA 3a NocnesHve rojib, a eH! HECKOTIBKO REcATMMIETHH CyLIeCTBEHKO He CHIDKANMOb. B UTore porHoshl OKasw/IMcb USMMUIKE ONTAMMCTHUKEIMA CyenapHoe nnaxmposatine. SroT meron TpensasHateH nA axanvsa Gonee unit Metee oTHanexHoro Gynytero. Meron paspa6orarm 8 1960-x 8 Shell Oil. Ox nosBonser cosjaBarb npasgonoqoGuyio Kaprniy «cocToRHK Mupae tet Yepes TATb-jlecATS, CreuManMeTh avaMMsMpyioT MpMpontble ABNEHAA, NOMATICGECKHe, SKOHOMMYECKHE, TEXHOMOLMYECKHE, COMANIbHbIE, HOPMATABHO-l1paBoBble axTOpbi M BbIEMPAWT HECKO/IKO (o6m1uHo verbipe), BoseACTBMe KOTOpHIX Ha 6USHEC Byer OCoBeHHO OMlyTAMBIM. Koe-Tye MpocsIT CBOKX KOHCYMBTAHTOR BRIABIISITE BAKHEMUIHe TEHeHIINH, KOTOPEe PAdBUBAIOTEN Bie Ux EUSHECA 4 OTPACTH KoTophie Hao O6ssaTeMBHO YURTHIBATS B TAKMX cleHapmax. [na KaxKNOTO BBEpaHHOTO paKTopa PACCUUTHBAIOT MaKCHMAnBHBle M MMAVIMATBHBIe OKMMAeMBIe SHATEHUS, TAKHE, KAKUMH OHI Mpenttonoxutensuo 6yAyT vepes MnTE-RecnTS ner. KoméutHanias Kpaluux skatiennit YeTbpex OaKTopoR RaeT 16 ceHapwes. [IpumepHo nonopitHa BLITNAAUT Hey6eAUTENbHO, H HX axe He PACCMATpHBaIOT. AHANKSMPYOT TORBKO, ¥To Gyner c KOpMopaTuEHos cTpareruel: mp ocTABUINxcR CLeHapuaX, EonM CTAHOBUTCR OFeBMEHO, ‘To cTparerua paccunTana Ha Goree wii Melee ONTHMMCTHECKMit MPOrHOS, €e MOTYT CKOppeXTMPOBATS C yueToM HeccuMucTHYecKoro CeHApHs N60 IPORYMATS, KAK KANO SYACT Ce MaMeHHTb HPA TIepBbIX TIpMsiaKax HeGnaronpnaTHoro pasBuTHA CoBBITHN, ‘Avanua AelicTBuit KOHKypeHTOB. Or: TloMoTaeT OlfeHuTS CTeTeHS OMACHOCT: ATA KOMTIAHHiE HOBLIX TexHOMOT HE WI HaMexeHUs CTpaTerHit KOHKypeHTOR, TpeM-YeTLIpeM rpyniman Mopyyaior MogroToBUTE MpaBnoTonOGHEIe crpatervan ana Gnixxamurero 6yayutero Wri TInAHE ReVICTBWIL Y>Ke CYMICCTBYIOMINX WIM MOTEHUKANbEBX KOHKYPeHTOB, KOTOpEIe Te MOTH Obi PearlusoBaTb B Cregy:oUIKe ron-ABa, PaccMaTpMBaeMbIit MepMon B STOM cny'iae Kopoue, 4ieM rIpy alarinse cyeHtapves, SareM rpyiitbl BCTPEUAIOTCR M O6CY>KNAIOT, KAK KOHKYPEHTL Morn 6b MonopBath ctpatermio KoMrialiay. Takasi Mpottenypa ToMoraet pykononiwrensm npeonomers HeBOMbHYIO HeOSDeKTHBHOCTS, KoTOpaR sacTABNAeT MX A HOPHPOBAt ‘pakTHl, MpoTHBOPELALIME MX MpencTasnenva o cMme WM cra6ocTH KOHKypenTos. MpeRoTBpathT COONTHA, BEIABMEHHBLe B PesynbTaTe npsiihberussia.ulmanagementkorporatvnyy-opyla13142utm_source=newsetterButm_medium=emaléutm_campaign=zolotey_fond_hbr_p.. 11/15renn2018 Ynpaanovwe picxanv: Hoabie npuruans | Harvard Business Review Pocows! aHayinga BepOATHEIX HeACTAMM KOHKYPeHTOB, KOMIAHKM He BCATSX, Ho MOKHO MPHHATS Mepbl, YTOOBL OMArsytt 4x nocnencrans, CK@KEM, ABMAKOMIAKMM SallMuljaloros OT PesKoro HOBBILICKM eH Ha TOITABO C HOMOUIbIO dunaHcoBbx HepuBaTmpos. Eure BapMaHy — AHBECTApOBaTb, He HOKAKAAC NOBEIMEHMH YEH. Hanpamep, nponsnoycrBentiag KOMIaHMs, 3aB0f1bI KOTOPOH HAxXOMATCH B CeltCMOOTIACHOH 3oHe, MOXeT, YBenM4HB CBOM pacxoj[bl Ha CTpoMTeNbeTBO, OGesorIAcHTh caMble BAXHbIe O6DEKTHI OT PASPyUIATENBUBK TONSEMEELX TONYKOB. Kommanvam, HoRSepxkeHHDIM pasHLiM, HO CKONEBIM OTfaCHOCTAM, CCT cMBICN evieTBOBATD coobuA. Tax, suibopmannonnait yeHTp YEuBepcwTera CesepHolt Kaponmen MoxeT mocTpanaTe oT yparatia, a yHupepowTera, pacnonoxexroro B Kanudopxmx wa paatome Cax-Axmpeac, — oT semnerpsceniin, BepoaTHocTs ‘Toro, 470 OTH NpMpoALIBIe KaTACTPOdbI MPOHSONIRYT OAOBPEMeHHO, AOBONDHO MayTa, NOSTOMY 06a yiiupepontera saluTat ce6s, ecnm 6ynyT CneRNT» sa HcTeMAMM mpyr ADYra B BevepHve M HOUHbIE Yack. Tpyanoctu ynpasnenua Tlepkarb non KOHTpOTIeM puckH HIIK peariMsoBbIBATS CTpaTerMio — coBceM He OfIHO M To xe. 3ajlaya YMpapnenvs pAckamn — NpeoTsparHTs HeraTuBHoe PasBuTHe COBITHIA: TYT B eHTpe BAMMAHAA He HOBBIE BOSMOXHOCTH U4 YorlexH, 2 ONacHOCTH # MoTepy. HB STOM cMBicne caMa Kjjem yIpaBmeHe pucKaMit RMaMeTpamHO MpoTMBOMIONIOKHa KOPMOpaTMBHOK Ky/TYpe, KOTOpyiO MYLIe BCeTO OMMMCSIBAeT MoayHT: «Bye Foros! Bcerpia roToa!> 4 KOTOpyio BOsYECKA IIPMBETCTAYIOT pyKOBORUTENH, Tipy atom oft o6si4HtO uriHOpMpytOT ByAYilIe’; uM He XONETCA TpATHT> peMs K TelibrH celt4ac, YTOGEL wa6exkath npoGrtem, KoTopbie To nM 6yZYT, TO NM Her, a eon K OYAYT, To pas6upaTbcA ¢ HMMM TIpHNeTCA Y>KE ABYCMM HauanbHnkaM. Boree Toro, mpeslorppariientve otenttivanbibix yrpos Yatite Bcero TlompasyMenaeT paccpeyoToveHve pecypcon u AUuBepoHKaLIA MABECTANIN, a KKsHEcHOCOBHaA crpaterns, Hao6opor, BBICOKyIO KOHLeHTPaL Mio Pecypoos, PyKOBORMTENAM KadKETCR, YTO STO KAK-TO HeNpABMNIbHO — BRICTPAABath cTleyambHbie MpOLeRyPEl H BLITBMIATS YAIBUMBIE MecTa CTpATer His, PAapAbOTAHHEIK ¢ UX IKE YACTHEM. Viento ostomy 8 6onbuIMHCTBe KOMMaHMit OTBeUATS 9a CTPATErMMECKHe 1 BHELINMe PUCKH FORE! oTembaie Cryxx6t2, CKOTEKO 5 Hix GyReT COTPYRHVKOS, SaBMCUT OT BeNMMMHL! KOMMAHUH M XapaKTepa ce GusHeca, Ho MOMNMHATECH STH OTREMEI ROMKHE HanpAMyWO TON-MeHeMKMeHTY. CoBCTBEHHO, 970, mOKanyi, B@KHeMllan Mx Safava — MOATEpXUBAT TECH CRABB C BBICLIMM pyKOBOICTBOM. Cnoco6Hocr KOMIIaHiM BhIeD>KaTs LITOPM Bo MHOTOM cripenenseTcr TEM, HaCKONbKO CepbesHo PYKOBORCTBO orHocutes K S10 pasore Torja, Kora Ha HeGe BOBCIO CBETHT CONHe M Ha FopHsOHTe HK ObNIaKa. Tem 6aHkiA, pasOpHBUIMECS Bo RPEMsT bUHAKCOBOTO KpHaHica, OTIMMANMCh OT YIEMEBLIAX? B epBEIX PUCKAMM JaHUMANHCh ones) ocHOBHas sajavia KOTOpEIX — crequTh 3a CoOmomeHHeM TpebORAHKit HOPMATABHEIX NOKYMEHTOB, MPOBORMTD 1OpunHVECKyIo SKCTEPTHSY YIPeHATENBELIX 4 APYHX HOXYMEHTOB KOMNAHMIt — KRMEETOR 6akKa, OTenexsBaIOT ux «UMCTOTY» H TAL ¥ COTPYABUKOB, KORTPOTMAPYIOUIHX PUCKH, He Gti Mpaworo FocTyTa K BBIOILIEMY PyKOBONOTRY ¥ CORETAM MHDEKTODOS, a OT HX MPeNyMpEXAeNKit o cmuMIKoM GonbutoMe Home COMHMTENBHBX KPeRMTOR M HeMOCTATOSHOM MuBepCHOuKalIA SAHKOBCKMX MopTdeneh nompocty ormaxusanuce, Yro 2Ke KacaeToR Griaroniony4Ho nepexMsilnx duHakcoBbin xpuaxte Goldman Sachs 4 JP Morgan Chase, To y Hix 6buIM cHbHBIe OTWerIBI TIO PMCKaM. MX PYKOBONCTEO XOpOILIO TOKAMAMIO, HTO GaHKHt MOABepxXeltbl MHOTONMCNHISIM O1aCHOCTAM, 1 IPALMMaNo CooTReTCTBYIOWAE Mepbl, Bappxt Sy6poy, Rupextop to piican JP Morgan Chase, okasani HaM: «Xora sto Mos erlapxvs, Ha CaMOM zleMIe y Hac B KOMITaHAY, puckaMK BefaeT HaLi rexeparbubil, Ipxemn [laliMor B ynpabnenun puckaMn METYHAUKE He HOMOracT — cama 9Ta aaqja'ia MpOTMBOpeNAT MHOTMM TloMxONOrWaeCKH, OSbACHMMEIM OcObCHHOCTAM M CKNOHHOCTAM OTHENIDEBIX MOMeM Ht HevIbLx opraxaanylt, KecrKum cobmoneHHem npaBMii M SaKOHOAATeIHBIX HOPM, OKOHOMMYECKMH M LOPUAUYCCKMMHL SKCHePTHSAMA MOXHO OTBeCTH MMLIb HeKOTOpbIe Yrposl. UTOGbI Ha/|@KHO /lep>KAT MOY KOHTPOTIEM PHCKH H HaXORAT crlocobsl CMSIrHeHUs 1x Tocme[CTBAi, HYYKHO CHCTeMATAYECKK OTCHEKKBATS DACKM pasHbIx KaTeropMis, paspa6oras Wns KaxsoH cooTRETCTAYIOUIMe Mpovlenypbl. TombKo 6rlaroRaps TpaMorHo BBICTPOeHHBIM MIpoeccaM MOXHO HeiiTpanvgonaTs ecTecTBeHHBle [IA Mo60ro YenoReKa KOTHUTHBHBIe UCKAXKEHMM, BCAMY KOTOPEX rmnannantii TeMnuwrain RUTETh MIEN TAYUM WaIINe UM ¥ATATIAGE Bi) UTAAK AH REIT a He TALIM waKnR aH npsithbe.russia rulmanagementkorporatvnyy-opyla13142utm_source=newsletter&utm_medium=email&utm_campagn=zololay fond orp... 12/15ren2018 Ynpasnovwe picranv: Hoabie nputuans | Harvard Business Review - Pocowst ects A MoXeT CYaTb. 06 apropax Po6ept Kannax (Robert S. Kaplan) — rowers npopeccop PappapacKom uskortsi 6usHeca, Anert Maiixe (Anette 6usuieca, ikes) — noon Kabenpe 6yxrantepcxoro yuera m ynpasmenss 8 PapeapacKoit uiKone Kommenrapi (0) ApesosngHeii sun Hoasiev Flonynapaeie” KonnaicrHbih Kowrexcr Bomamre, 4To6b! ocTasnATs KOMMeHTapHi. BOmTH [Baeaure Email AMREPCTBO / ENO MISHA ‘oro: KIM KULISH/CONTRIGUTOR/GETTY IMAGES Cynep6occ u3 Marvel 18 won6pa 2018 | CuqHH OuaKensurresin hitpsthbr-russia.rulmanagementikorporatvnyy-opytlat13147uIm_source=newsleter&ulm_medium=emalléutm_campagn=zolotoy fond Abr... 13/15renn2018 Ynpaanovwe picxanv: Hoabie npuruans | Harvard Business Review - Pocors! Crou Jit ne moun, orga xYROKHMKA Hanpacho TpaTH/IM BpeMs., BhiIAlOU\NitcH aBTOP M M3qaTeHI KOMMKCOR, yMepuinii B Hoxi6pe 2018 roaa B BospacTe 95 ster, CHHTaN, 470, eCHIM MOM CHAT 6es eN1a, OHM B O60! MoMeHT MOrYT OF CKYKH YiiTH K KOHKypeHTy. KpoMe Toro, oH BCeryja JM4HO Sa60THNICA 0'TOM, ¥TO6bI ero COTPYALNKKAM He MpMxORMNOCS cUNTare KAKA eH”. TlH Boerfa oSecNeunBaN CBOAM NoAYAHEHHSIM MOCTOSEHY!O SAHATOCTS, MHOTVIa MOKe B yulep6 6usHeCy. Muorua nspecTHa ucTopia 0 TOM, KaK onHaxnel Croxt Jlse pasqan HaMHoro Gonbule sanaHuii, 4M ObiI0 HYDKHO KOMMaHisH, H He CKagarl 06 310M CBOeMY HaYambHNxy, uanatemo Maprnety TyaMany, JlAumHvMn KOMAKCAMH OF 3a6um OnKH HS uIKaboB B CTyAKM, HTOOb! BoctIONbsOBATbOA MMM, Korma IpHgeT spems, Korma Tyaman yannen ator uikad, of Bemten Tl yBortuT Bolo ero KoMaltqy. Tor BEINONHHAN yKagatiMe Ha¥ambHHAKa, XOTA M YyBOTBOBAN, To 970 6bu1o OMIM6KOHL. BhocnencTBNK JIM HacTaMBan Ha TOM, 4TO, aBar AONONHATENbHble SaztaHAE, OH MHBeCTApoBan B CBOMX COTBYAHHKCB. si mayan Guorpadimo x Kapbepy Crowe Jin aia Moci Kunri «CyrrepGoccnn. Kax a yoke miccan paribure B cTaTbe HBR, cynep6oce — sro He mpocTo xopouinit HatanbHMK, KOTOpEIH yMero oprakuayeT pabounit mpouecc um mepesbinomtiser max no foxofiam. Cynep6occsi HaXONAT TaalTMMBbIx COTPYAUMKOS, O6YHAIOT HX o6ecresmpator NocTORHHBIX MpTOK HOBBIx KafpoR. Tax, Hanpumep, Axor CrioapT Aleman nonynapHbinn KOMMKoB B mepemtave Daily Show, a lited)-nopap 4 pectoparop Orme Yorepe roMorasia Kapbepe HOBBIX thlebos, CynepSoccsi, yMelouie HaxonitTs, BOCHUTEIBATS M PasBABaTb TaNaHTE!, KAK CYMeprepon M3 KOMMKCOB, okashisalor KonloccanbHoe BIIKAHMe Ha TO, 470 NPOMCXONMT B KOMIAHAW. He mapate coTpyAHMKaM cKy4aTb — 970 Bcero Mull ORME Ws YpoKOR, KOTOpLIi # yeBoun Gnaronaps Cros Jiu. Bropoit ne Metiee nakitbilt ypox — He cTaHoBHTbcA eHsOpOM. JI MpeNMO“MTAN, ¥TOGE YHACTHMKH: ETO KOMANABL CamoctonTenbHo NpKHMMarA Boe KpeaTHpHbie pelllelia. OH BCHOMHHaml, Kak ONHAKAIb! EMY AOBETOCE pa6oTaTb Hall KOMMKCOM, B PAHaNe KOTOPOro 6bUIO MCILONbIOBAHO CHOBO «r1OFO-CTHKy (pogo stick — NOny/IApHAA ATPYLUIKA B BAsIe KPBOKKOBO! XOKYsIM — NPHM. pea). PejlakTOp KOMMAKCAa PeULW, WTO HeropocKMM MMTATEMISM He TOHDABUTCH CHIOBO «T1OTO-CTHK» M BEMleN 3AMCHATH CTO Ha , JH cormacunes, XoTs S70 HCHOpTHTO LIyTKy. B KOHIIe KOHIIOB, KOMHKC H BOBCe He BEILIEN B cBeT, a JI npusiancs: «Takas WeHsypa a7in Mess ~ 970 NowTm GeccTHIACTBO», Hanuman xynoxHuKa, aiire eMy BOSMOOKHOCTS em1aTb CBO! PaSoTy, OGBACHAT OH. «ECTH HeMIOBeK 3aHMMAeTCH TBOPYECKHM TPYHOM, ¥, T10 ero MHeHis0, ¥TO-To FOMRHO ObITb cReNaHO Tak, a He MHaYe, TOSBONBTe eMy cenaTb 9TO», — MpusBiBant JI%. CroH MIM noaKpennn cBox copa JleNoM HECKOMbKO ser CIYCTS, KOT/a KOMUKC «Xavik», ppakuiMsa KOMIAHKK Marvel, ner 8 ocHopy rlonynspHoro Tenecepwana, OH 6:1n TlopaxxeH TeM, Kak TROpYECKas KOMAHAA ‘Tpaxchopmuposana «Xanka» Ans HoBoro hopmara, u 6m pay ocTaTBCE B CTOpoHEe. [losqHee On BCTIOMMHAN: «fl o'er MHoroe Hon mpo Tenesnmenve 13 Walltmx pasroRopos c KewoM [bKOHCOHOM 0 TOM, KAK NyWlle anantmponars «HenepoaTHoro Xanka» x opMary TerleBusHoHHOTo cepwama, Vortex sT0To toy, cosmaHHOro Tron, pyKononcTsom Kexa, AOKasnIBaeT, HaCKOMbKO BaXXHO AOBEPATE TROPYECKMe MPOEKTH Mo-HACTOMIeMy ‘TaaHTIVBBIM 1 KPeATHBHBIM MONAMs. JI C YROBONBCTBMEM OTCTPARMNICA K HOBEPUTICH CAMbIM MOMIORHIM: "ream KOMAHy{b1, KOTOPLIX Gore KOHCepBaTHBHbIe PYKOBORMTEN COUTH Gbl CRUIIKOM «3emTeHbIMI, ‘Thetis ypox, KoTopHiM Mepertsi oT Crowa JI, ~ XBanhTe CBOMX COTPYAHMKOB, Kora OHM sTorO sacnyKHBAIOT. S70 SBYtHT TaK MpocTo, Ho Tax peAKo cnywaeToR B KHNL, OAK Ha MpHeMox, KOTOpEIM JInt TOMbsoBaTICH, TO6t1 ToxBann7» Konner, — cTpaHMta c bamunuAMn aBTopos. SToT Daanen OLIN YHUKANBEBIM, AO JIM XyMORENKY KOTOPLIC PUCOBANK XOMUKCH, OCTABATIICL aHOHMMELIMe, Ha STOH CTpAHMe BA MOT MpoHeCTE, HanpMep, TaKoe: «CileHapyii Harucax co Crpactsio CraHioM JI, Hapzconaxo c Popnocrswo Jbkexom Kep6x. Benmxonienso packpaurexo [bxo CaaHorrom. Texct Hartcax Ckpaity4iM [lepom Aprit Cumexay, Kpome Toro, Tn perynapHo nica 0 csoux coTPYALMKaX B exeMecs'HOM SionmeTexe The Bullpen Bulletin, Takwe orsbisb1 wiorja Mera Kapbepsi. HarpaMep, xyOKHMK [>KeK Kep6i B cepestsHle cRoero KaphepHioro NyTH Tony4yAn OF Croita JI nposbuie «Kopon KOMMKCoB», “ MHOrMe HasbiBalot ero Tak M no Celt Nettb. Takoit Map 6sin He ‘TonbKo MlomeseH aBTopaM KOMMKCOB. OH TlosBOMIAT MOMIORBIM YUTaTersM cTaTb MpeMAHHEIMK akaraMy Toro Wl Metoro xynOXGIKa, Braromaps STOMY MHOTHe XYMOXHMKK cTaNM accoluMpowaTées c Marvel, a uuTaTeMK TOwyRCTRORAMTH Ocobyio CRASE ¢ MOSUMEIM 6peHTOM, TaK JIM MPONBHTaM CBO TaNaHTMMBBIX COTYAHUKOR 1 ToBEILIaT ypoBeHs MpodecchoHannama B Mupe KOMMKCOS (9To GEO elle OHO! ero CTDACTEHO) npsithberussia.culmanagementkorporatvnyy-opyla113142utm_source=newsletterButm_medium=emaléutm_campaign=zolotey fond orp... 14/15renn2018 Ynpasnovwe picxanv: Hoabie npuruans | Harvard Business Review Pocows! Hexorent, mpumep Crawa JI HamominaeT HaM 0 TOM, TO MEI ROTDsa8 MeUTaTe o GonbuleM. STO onTHMaTBEBIE crtoco6 MOTMBHPOBATD CBOUX MYHLIIX COTPYAHMKOB, «Mbi TITaeMOR MepeOCMBIOMMTD XKAHD KOMUKCOS Ht cRenars ero RoctodtHna yBaxenvny, — ckazar onHaxzbl Ji, OH ¥YBCTBORAN, YTO KOMVKCBI — MecTO A715 B@OKHDIX COMMANDHBIX BBICKASDIBAHMM, YTO OHM MOTT ObITb MPOHMLATENBHBIMME H OCTPOYMHBIMH OF BEPH, 4TO HacTynMTe AeH, Kora Mooi oSpasoBantibih Bspocnbih ¥eNOBeK He 6yqeT CTeCHATBOH MATH M10 ynuLe c KOMUKCaMH B PYKaX, 1 BOCMM CHNaMH MDGIMKaN OTOT HeHb, OH CHM TAN, YTO KOMMKGEI OMDKHE] H3YYATHCA B yitupeponterax: «Eon mon usy4aior Kullo, TeneBMjeltHe, oMepy, arte, KOHIepTEL CKYABITYPY, KUBOTMCE, A RpYPKe 2kaHipbi MeKycoTBa, OHM MOryT H3y4aTb M KOMHKCbL, TOTOMY YTO KOMMKCHI TorKe tbopMHpyIOT o6pas MBIMITERUST Monet. JM YTREPKAAM, YTO HET HUKAKUX MIPHUMH, To KOTOPHIM KOMUKCE He AOMKHB! CUATATHCH MeKyccTBOM. H STOT MOAXON MPMBNEK K COsaHMIO KOMMKCOB MHOTX TaNaHTNWBEIX XyORKHMKOB. Ua, Ji we Ohi wReanbHDIM, KaK « TOGO RPyro# YemloBeK, Ho B KOHEHHOM CHETE, OH HSMEHHAT Por KOMMKCOR, cnemas ux ucKyccTBOM, npuBHtec Gonbute npotbeccnoranHaMa 8 CBOlO OTPaciib m cilocoScrBoBAN KapbepHOMy pocty AecATKO CBOHX COTpyAHKKOB. Mho6oH pykoponnTeNtb oxapakTepHsonall 6bi Takoe HacHesMe CrIOBOM coymteps 06 abtope. Cuann OuskenbuiTeiin (Sydney Finkelstein) — mpodeccop mewemxwenra B 6arec-uiKoTe Taka Japruytoxoro xonnempka, asTop KuHrH «Superbosses: How Exceptional Leaders Master the Flow of Talento. -ntpsuithbrrussia.rumanagementkoxporatvnyy-opyvat13142utm,_source=newsltter&utm_medium: Jotoy_fond_ hore. 18/15