1/2/23, 6:20 PM Portrayal of Women in Ramayana-A Different Perspective

 (https://plus.google.com/116197632981133219340)
 (https://www.facebook.com/eSamskriti)
 (https://twitter.com/eSamskritiindia)
 (https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCHnWwG92M-iTHCYh1nY7QPQ)
eBook (/ebook.aspx)
Subscribe

Search Site Index 

HOME (HTTPS://WWW.ESAMSKRITI.COM) } C U LT U R E ( H T T P S : / / WWW . E S A M S K R I T I . C O M / S / C U LT U R E . A S P X ) }

I N D I A N C U LT U R E ( H T T P S : / / WWW . E S A M S K R I T I . C O M / A R T I C L E / I N D I A N - C U LT U R E . A S P X ) }
P O R T R AYA L O F W O M E N I N R A M AYA N A - A D I F F E R E N T P E R S P E C T I V E

Portrayal of Women in Ramayana-A Different

Perspective
By Lakshmi Sarma  July 21 2021  lakshmi.s2976@gmail.com (mailto:lakshmi.s2976@gmail.com)  8097 views

AA  Print Page  01 of 01

Choose : Article  Sub-sections  Author 

Snapshot

. Women are invariably portrayed, now days, in the Ramayana using contemporary and probably colonial mind sets. The author
uses examples from Valimiki’s Ramayana to state that women were free to express their views and accorded an important
status.

There are innumerable versions of the Ramayana and myriad interpretations of these versions across India
and other countries. Many of these popular versions, both in text form and depictions on stage and
television, have created strong impressions of most of the principal characters of the epic among people.
Even some of the minor characters and their stories evoke vivid imagery in our minds and we tend to paint
rather stereotypical sketches of their personalities that we have over time come to believe and accept as
definitive.

In the light of these numerous versions, a study of the original composition by Sage Valmiki gives
refreshingly different perspectives about many aspects of the story and the characters. What is striking is
that these characters – major and minor ones –Receive
are far from the often one-dimensional depictions that they
Site Updates

https://www.esamskriti.com/e/Culture/Indian-Culture/Portrayal-of-Women-in-Ramayana~A-Different-Perspective-1.aspx 1/12
1/2/23, 6:20 PM Portrayal of Women in Ramayana-A Different Perspective

are subjected to and are able to hold their own ground, giving momentum and direction to the turn of
events constituting Shri Rama’s epic journey.

The description of some of the well-known events by Sage Valmiki is not only surprising in the way these
are presented but also clearly bring out the finer nuances of the characters and their interpersonal dynamics
along with the attendant socio-political framework.

Ramayana is not generally talked about in the context of women’s empowerment and many instances in
the epic are typically viewed through the prism of patriarchy. However, Valmiki presents a rather contrarian
picture and a few instances described in Ayodhyakaanda and Aranyakaanda provide illuminating
perspectives about the status and influence of women.

Let us take two such interesting instances that present entirely different perspectives compared to what is
ordinarily assumed or understood.

Firstly, despite being selfish and unjust in nature, Kaikeyi’s wishes were upheld by both Emperor Dasharatha
and Rama, who very strongly emphasised the need to fulfill the promises made to her, irrespective of the
consequences. After all these boons were granted to her by Dasharatha as a reward for the help she
rendered to him during war.

But what is even more remarkable is another episode in this context with reference to Sita.

When Rama is exiled and is about to leave Ayodhya with Sita, the royal preceptor, Sage Vasishtha angrily
chastises Queen Kaikeyi saying that she had exceeded all limits of decency and her behaviour did not
conform to the standards (of righteousness) and says the following:

न गन्तव्यं वनं देव्या सीतया शीलवर्जिते।

अनुष्ठास्यतिरामस्यसीताप्रकृ तमासनम्।।2.37.23।।

“O woman dead to (all) decorum! Princess Sita shall not proceed to the forest.

Remaining here she will occupy the throne which was offered to Rama.” (Source: Srimad
(https://www.valmiki.iitk.ac.in/sloka?field_kanda_tid=2&language=dv&field_sarga_value=37) Valmiki
Ramayana, Gita Press, Gorakhpur publication)

Sage Vasishtha goes on to further add:

आत्मा हि दारास्सर्वेषां दारसङ् ग्रहवर्तिनाम्।

आत्मेयमिति रामस्य पालयिष्यति मेदिनीम्।।2.37.24।।

“A wife is the very self to all householders. As the (other) self of Rama, she will rule over the globe.” (Source:
Srimad (https://www.valmiki.iitk.ac.in/sloka?field_kanda_tid=2&language=dv&field_sarga_value=37)
Valmiki Ramayana, Gita Press, Gorakhpur publication)

Coming from Sage Vasishtha, these were strong statements and made with considerable authority. Both
royalty and society were therefore, open to the idea of Sita occupying the throne, should she have wished
to do so. Moreover, this also meant Sita would have had the training to be crowned the ruler, as this was an
important prerequisite even for the male heirs to the throne.

Receive Site Updates

https://www.esamskriti.com/e/Culture/Indian-Culture/Portrayal-of-Women-in-Ramayana~A-Different-Perspective-1.aspx 2/12
1/2/23, 6:20 PM Portrayal of Women in Ramayana-A Different Perspective

Cover image of Valmiki Ramayan, Gita Press Gorakpur.

Surely Sita chooses to follow Rama into the forest. Sage Valmiki beautifully summarises her influence over
all the subsequent events of the Ramayana through the thoughts of Hanuman described in the
Sundarakanda, when he perceives Sita for the very first time.

Hanuman says to himself that it was indeed for this Sita that fourteen thousand demons of Janasthana
along with their commanders, Khara, Trishira and Dushana, were killed by Rama and so was the demon
Viraadha. For her sake Kabandha was killed and subsequently, Vaali too was killed by Rama. It was because
of her that Sugriva attained the throne of Kishkindha and the ruler ship of all the Vaanaras. And she alone
was the cause of his own leap across the ocean and arrival at Lanka. (Source: Summarised reproduction of
Slokas 7-12 of the Sixteenth Chapter of Sundarakanda of Srimad (https://www.valmiki.iitk.ac.in/sloka?
field_kanda_tid=2&language=dv&field_sarga_value=37) Valmiki Ramayana, Gita Press, Gorakhpur
publication)

The ultimate destruction and killing of Ravana and his forces at the hands of Rama was brought about by
Sita.

In Aranyakanda, Valmiki highlights another interesting aspect – that of women, especially those belonging
to royal lineages- of being well-versed in the Shaastras including statecraft and governance.

The instance connected with Surpanakha is very interesting and provides food for thought.

Surpanakha, is usually portrayed in popular media as a rakshasa-woman of terrible appearance, who

complains to Ravana about how she was badly treated by Rama and Lakshmana and instigates him to
abduct Sita to avenge her humiliation by the two princes.

While she does instigate Ravana to kidnap Sita, what is very interesting in Valmiki Ramayana is the manner
in which she convinces him to do so. It is not merely an emotional appeal by a sister made to her brother.
The arguments she presents reflect a deep knowledge of statecraft and administration. What is even more
noteworthy is that she chides Ravana about his ‘inaction’ in response to the threat posed by Rama, in front
of all his ministers and counsellors very boldly and without mincing words!

An entire chapter of the Aranyakanda (Ch. 33) is dedicated to her speech to Ravana, which centers upon the
duties and responsibilities of a monarch and the nuances of managing law and order and the security of his
territories.

Speaking about the responsibilities of a ruler, she says that a monarch who does not personally attend to
his affairs gets ruined without doubt, along with his kingdom as well as those affairs. Narrating the plight of
an inept ruler, she says that just as elephants keep away
Receive from a muddy river, people will keep distance from
Site Updates

https://www.esamskriti.com/e/Culture/Indian-Culture/Portrayal-of-Women-in-Ramayana~A-Different-Perspective-1.aspx 3/12
1/2/23, 6:20 PM Portrayal of Women in Ramayana-A Different Perspective

a king who does not employ spies, does not give audience to his people and is not independent. She
further adds that those rulers of men who do not reclaim a territory, which is no longer under their control,
do not shine through prosperity any more than mountains submerged in an ocean. (Source:Summarised
reproduction of Slokas 4-6 of the Thirty-third Chapter of Aranyakanda [Srimad
(https://www.valmiki.iitk.ac.in/sloka?field_kanda_tid=2&language=dv&field_sarga_value=37) Valmiki
Ramayana, Gita Press, Gorakhpur publication & Sloka & Translation | Valmiki Ramayanam (iitk.ac.in)
(https://www.valmiki.iitk.ac.in/sloka?field_kanda_tid=2&language=dv&field_sarga_value=37))

This line of reasoning cannot be from one who does not understand governance or who does not have prior
experience in debating and discussing such topics.

Surpanakha also nonchalantly questions Ravana’s ability to continue as king saying:

त्वन्तु बालस्वभावश्च बुद्धिहीनश्च राक्षस।

ज्ञातव्यन्तुनजानीषेकथंराजाभविष्यसि।।3.33.8।।

“You are undoubtedly childish of disposition and devoid of intelligence and do not know what ought to be
known, O demon! How (then) will you continue to be a king?” (Source:Srimad
(https://www.valmiki.iitk.ac.in/sloka?field_kanda_tid=2&language=dv&field_sarga_value=37) Valmiki
Ramayana, Gita Press, Gorakhpur publication)

Driving home her point she then enumerates what a ruler should guard against and how he must act. She
calls a king dislodged from his kingdom worthless, even if he is capable, like a piece of cloth that is worn
and discarded and similar to garlands that are used and crushed.

About the qualities of a respected ruler, she says that the king who is vigilant, knows everything (about
himself and his enemy), whose senses are fully controlled, who recognises the services of others and is
pious by disposition continues on his throne for long. She adds that the king, who remains prudent and
whose frown and favour are manifest in the form of punishment and reward, is honoured by the people.
(Source: Summarised reproduction of Slokas 19-21 of the Thirty-third Chapter of Aranyakanda [Srimad
(https://www.valmiki.iitk.ac.in/sloka?field_kanda_tid=2&language=dv&field_sarga_value=37) Valmiki
Ramayana, Gita Press, Gorakhpur publication & Sloka & Translation | Valmiki Ramayanam (iitk.ac.in)
(https://www.valmiki.iitk.ac.in/sloka?field_kanda_tid=2&language=dv&field_sarga_value=37))

Surpanakha finally admonishes Ravana severely saying that he was utterly deprived of all these virtues and
warned him that he would lose his sovereignty and perish soon if he continued to ignore the realities of the
situation they were faced with. For his part, Ravana does reflect upon her words quietly before questioning
her further about the events preceding her arrival at his court.

It is quite a fascinating account given that even in a society (such as that of the rakshasas), where ‘might
was right’, Surpanakha could express herself frankly and publicly and hold her own in front of Ravana, her
all-powerful brother and king. That Sage Valmiki chose to present even a character like Surpanakha, who
has a relatively fleeting albeit impactful presence in the epic, with so much depth speaks volumes about
why Ramayana resonates across the subcontinent and around the world, among all sections of society.

Even as later versions of the Ramayana may have inadvertently incorporated the impact of socio-political
influences of their times (i.e., when they were composed) as regards the status of women in the story, the
societies depicted by Sage Valmiki in his Ramayana – be it those of humans, vanaras or even rakshasas –
had strong women influencing the course of events, having their say and also providing useful counsel to
the menfolk.
Receive Site Updates

https://www.esamskriti.com/e/Culture/Indian-Culture/Portrayal-of-Women-in-Ramayana~A-Different-Perspective-1.aspx 4/12
1/2/23, 6:20 PM Portrayal of Women in Ramayana-A Different Perspective

Far from a one-dimensional perspective, he has presented the epic in a way that demands a more layered
understanding of the events and the characters. Trying to compartmentalize the characters and their roles
into pre-defined narratives and opinions can be very misleading, while taking away from the essence of the
itihaasa.

To read all articles by author (https://www.esamskriti.com/author/Lakshmi-Sarma-.aspx)

Also read

1. Five Elemental Women (https://www.esamskriti.com/e/Culture/Indian-Culture/Five-Elemental-Women-

1.aspx)

2. Queen Abakka who defeated the Portuguese at sea (https://www.esamskriti.com/e/History/Great-

Indian-Leaders/RANI-ABBAKKA-is-the-forgotten-Warrior-Queen-of-Ullal,-Karnataka-1.aspx)

3. Why Ahilyabai Holkar is a great woman (https://www.esamskriti.com/e/History/Great-Indian-

Leaders/Why-Ahilyabai-Holkar-was-a-GREAT-WOMAN---1.aspx)

4. Three Generation of Indian Women Violinists (https://www.esamskriti.com/e/Culture/Music/Three-

generations-of-Indian-Women-Violinist-~-Dr-N-Rajam----1.aspx)

 Tagged : Indian Women (/tags/Indian-Women.aspx) Women Ramayana (/tags/Women-Ramayana.aspx)

Ramayana (/tags/Ramayana.aspx) Valmiki (/tags/Valmiki.aspx) Ravana (/tags/Ravana.aspx)

Vasistha (/tags/Vasistha.aspx) Surpanakha (/tags/Surpanakha.aspx) Qualities of a Ruler (/tags/Qualities-of-a-Ruler.aspx)

Latest from eSamskriti

Yashovati, the First Queen of Kashmir

(/e/History/Indian-History/Yashovati,-the-First-Queen-of-Kashmir-1.aspx)

Of Demons and Exorcism in Sanatana Dharma

(/e/Spirituality/Philosophy/Of-Demons-and-Exorcism-in-Sanatana-Dharma-----------1.aspx)

Raja Raja Chola SAMADHI Deserves to be BETTER

(/e/History/Great-Indian-Leaders/Raja-Raja-Chola-SAMADHI-Deserves-to-be-BETTER--1.aspx)

Translating Knowledge to Knowhow

(/e/Spirituality/Education/Translating-Knowledge-to-Knowhow--1.aspx)

Who ruled Maharashtra before Shivaji Maharaj Part 1

(/e/History/Indian-History/Who-ruled-Maharashtra-before-Shivaji-Maharaj-Part-1--1.aspx)

SCUBA DIVING Andaman Islands

(/a/Andaman-And-Nicobar/SCUBA-DIVING-Andaman-Islands.aspx)

GARBA MAHOTSAV, United Way of Baroda

(/a/Gujarat/GARBA-MAHOTSAV,-United-Way-of-Baroda.aspx)

City Palace Udaipur Diwali

(/a/Rajasthan/City-Palace-Udaipur-Diwali.aspx)

Receive Site Updates

https://www.esamskriti.com/e/Culture/Indian-Culture/Portrayal-of-Women-in-Ramayana~A-Different-Perspective-1.aspx 5/12